669 lines
31 KiB
Plaintext
669 lines
31 KiB
Plaintext
|
3 articles
|
|||
|
2nd is 'Sex, Class & Womens oppression
|
|||
|
3rd is 'Equality for some women'
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
*************** Why Women are Oppressed ***************
|
|||
|
from Workers Solidarity No 36
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
WE ARE NOW eight years from the year 2,000.
|
|||
|
Approximately 14,000 years ago the first
|
|||
|
agricultural communities, and with them human
|
|||
|
civilisation, were founded. Humanity is 600
|
|||
|
generations old.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
We hold the position of 'most successful species' because
|
|||
|
unlike animals we have been able to modify our
|
|||
|
environment to suit our needs. To early humans nature
|
|||
|
was a powerful and frightening force, the bringer of
|
|||
|
plagues, storms and droughts. Nowadays we control our
|
|||
|
environment to such an extent that nature is no longer a
|
|||
|
demon spirit or an instrument of the wrath of god. In
|
|||
|
much of the world nature is way down on our list of
|
|||
|
worries, it is more likely to fear us. As the capability to
|
|||
|
control the world around us has increased from the first
|
|||
|
primitive farmers to the high-technology multinationals,
|
|||
|
the way we perceive the world around us has also
|
|||
|
changed. So has the way we perceive each other.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
One thing, however, that has remained constant
|
|||
|
throughout this time is that in the majority of societies
|
|||
|
half our species (women) has been held in an inferior
|
|||
|
position to the other half (men). Why is this the case?
|
|||
|
The answer to this question should explain two things.
|
|||
|
It should explain why today with all our equal rights
|
|||
|
legislation women are still second class citizens, and
|
|||
|
secondly it should indicate the mechanisms and tactics we
|
|||
|
have to use to achieve womens' liberation. If we know
|
|||
|
what the problem is, we can find a solution.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
CIVILISATION DAWNS
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Early humans were hunter/gatherers living in nomadic
|
|||
|
communities, living from hand to mouth. The discovery of
|
|||
|
agriculture lead to huge changes in the organisation of
|
|||
|
humanity. Agriculture was the point at which
|
|||
|
civilisation began. This is because there are a number of
|
|||
|
ways in which an agricultural community is different from
|
|||
|
a hunter/gatherer clan. Communities remain in the same
|
|||
|
spot. Agriculture can support more people than
|
|||
|
hunting/gathering so communities get larger. Farming
|
|||
|
leads to the development of new technology. New skills
|
|||
|
lead to a greater division of labour. Individuals specialise
|
|||
|
in certain types of work, be it tool making, leatherwork or
|
|||
|
defence.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
However the key difference is that farmed land becomes a
|
|||
|
valuable resource. Land provides a surplus, that is land
|
|||
|
provides more food than is necessary for day to day
|
|||
|
survival. More importantly, land will provide this
|
|||
|
resource in the future, for the next generation. None of
|
|||
|
this is true of the herd of wild animals persued by the
|
|||
|
hunter-gatherer. The concept of ownership developed.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
So civilisation began when man began to acquire wealth
|
|||
|
in the form of land, food and animals. If a rich man wants
|
|||
|
to ensure that his offspring alone inherit his wealth, he
|
|||
|
must be sure that his wife is only mating with him. Thus,
|
|||
|
he has to be in a position of control over her. He needs
|
|||
|
to portray this as part of the 'natural order'. To
|
|||
|
accommodate this need society, through the use of
|
|||
|
religion, developed a rationale to justify the inferior
|
|||
|
position of woman.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
GOD"S CHOSEN RULERS
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Rulers have always been good at rationalising unfair
|
|||
|
practices, take for example the idea of the 'divine right of
|
|||
|
kings'. Popular for centuries, the church and state
|
|||
|
argued that kings and queens were appointed by God.
|
|||
|
The status quo was natural and good, any opposition to it
|
|||
|
was evil and doomed to eternal hell. These days kings
|
|||
|
don't have much power, which is why not many people
|
|||
|
rush to describe Charles and Di as God's chosen rulers.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In much the same way, it was necessary to have women
|
|||
|
inferior to men to ensure inheritance rights. In order to
|
|||
|
keep women in this position a whole mythology of women
|
|||
|
as second class humans was developed. It was the
|
|||
|
accumulation of a surplus and the desire of a minority to
|
|||
|
monopolise it that lead to the class division of society and
|
|||
|
to the oppression of women.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Now we've established the motive and the cover story,
|
|||
|
but of what relevance is the status of women in early
|
|||
|
history to their status today. As capitalism evolved it
|
|||
|
built on the existing model of the family, adapting it to
|
|||
|
suit it's own interests. Assurance of inheritance rights
|
|||
|
isn't as necessary today, however the family provides
|
|||
|
other services which capitalism does require. Initially,
|
|||
|
when the industrial revolution first began men, women
|
|||
|
and children were drafted wholesale into the factories.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
DEATH IS NOT ALWAYS ECONOMIC
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Quickly, however, the bosses realised that this was not
|
|||
|
the most economic way to run the system. The labour
|
|||
|
force was weak and the children who were to be next
|
|||
|
generation of workers were dying in the mills and mines.
|
|||
|
The solution was was to be found in the family.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Before the rise of capitalism society was based around a
|
|||
|
system of slaves/serfs and kings or lords. The problem
|
|||
|
with slaves or serfs is that the owner must provide food,
|
|||
|
basic health care and subsistence in old age, i.e. maintain
|
|||
|
the slave at a cost for those times when he or she is not
|
|||
|
productive. A much more cost efficient way to keep a
|
|||
|
workforce is through the nuclear family. In this scenario,
|
|||
|
it is up to the family to provide itself with food, shelter,
|
|||
|
healthcare, look after the elderly and young (who will
|
|||
|
provide the next crop of workers). Within this family unit
|
|||
|
it is normally the woman who fulfils the functions of
|
|||
|
housekeeper, nurse, childminder and cook.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
There are two knock-on effects of women staying at home
|
|||
|
minding the family. Firstly they are not financially
|
|||
|
independent. They do not earn any money and are
|
|||
|
dependant on income received from their partners.
|
|||
|
Because nobody gets paid for rearing a family it's status
|
|||
|
as an occupation is at the bottom of the ladder and
|
|||
|
because women are financially dependant on their
|
|||
|
husbands it means they, in the past, have had little input
|
|||
|
into the major decisions affecting the family.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
ISOLATION
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This led to women having no input into the decisions
|
|||
|
affecting society. A woman's place was in the home. A
|
|||
|
second effect of women's position in the family is that
|
|||
|
they are often isolated from each other and from society
|
|||
|
in general. Unlike a paid worker they have little
|
|||
|
opportunity of meeting and sharing experiences with
|
|||
|
others in the same situation on a daily basis, and do
|
|||
|
something about it. They, on their own, have little
|
|||
|
power to change the conditions they find themselves in.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Today the family is a trap for women as much as it was for
|
|||
|
women at the beginning of the industrial revolution.
|
|||
|
Women are paid on average 2/3 of the wage that men are
|
|||
|
paid, so within any partnership it obviously makes more
|
|||
|
sense for the woman to undertake responsibility for the
|
|||
|
care of children. It is for this reason, common sense
|
|||
|
rather than sexism, that that the vast majority of part-
|
|||
|
time workers are women, juggling two jobs at the same
|
|||
|
time.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Having said that, why is it that women are among the
|
|||
|
lower paid in society? Is it necessary for capitalism to
|
|||
|
exploit women workers to this degree? The simple answer
|
|||
|
to that is sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. The only
|
|||
|
important difference between a male and female worker is
|
|||
|
that the female has the potential to get pregnant, that is
|
|||
|
the potential to want maternity leave and need creche
|
|||
|
facilities. In other words they are slightly more
|
|||
|
expensive to employ than men. So when women are
|
|||
|
asked (illegally!) at job interviews if they intend to
|
|||
|
marry, such discrimination has a material basis. An
|
|||
|
employer isn't interested on the good of society at large
|
|||
|
but in obtaining the cheapest most reliable workforce
|
|||
|
possible.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
DISPOSABLE WORKERS
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Historically women have been encouraged to work and
|
|||
|
have been accommodated when it suited capitalism.
|
|||
|
When there was either a shortage of male labour due to
|
|||
|
war as during the 1st and 2nd World Wars or an
|
|||
|
expansion of industry as in the dawn of the industrial
|
|||
|
revolution or the 1960s. When times are tough, when
|
|||
|
recession sets in, women are encouraged back into the
|
|||
|
family.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The conclusion for most socialists is that women's'
|
|||
|
liberation can only be lastingly obtained with the
|
|||
|
overthrow of capitalism. This is not to say that reforms
|
|||
|
should not be fought for at the moment, but to recognise
|
|||
|
that some of the gains may be short-term ones which can
|
|||
|
be withdrawn.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This conclusion isn't accepted by everyone concerned with
|
|||
|
womens' liberation, and certainly is rejected by large
|
|||
|
sections of the feminist movement. A good example of the
|
|||
|
alternative analysis can be seen in the following extract
|
|||
|
from the British Survey of Social Attitudes (a survey
|
|||
|
carried out regularly by an independent body).
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
WHO MINDS THE CHILDREN
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It found that the provision of childcare was one of the
|
|||
|
impediments preventing women from working. Their
|
|||
|
conclusion was that "in the absence of changes in
|
|||
|
mens' attitudes, or working hours outside the home
|
|||
|
or in their contribution within the family it seems
|
|||
|
unlikely that even a greater availability of childcare
|
|||
|
outside the home would alter domestic arrangements
|
|||
|
greatly. Without these changes, it is conceivable that
|
|||
|
many useful forms of work flexibility - that might be
|
|||
|
offered to women such as job sharing, career breaks,
|
|||
|
special sick leave or term-time working - might
|
|||
|
reinforce rather than mitigate the formidable level
|
|||
|
of occupational segregation based on gender, to
|
|||
|
women's longer-term disadvantage."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The authors of the survey note that as long as
|
|||
|
responsibility for childcare rests with the women they will
|
|||
|
remain trapped in the family. They also point out that
|
|||
|
concessions to women in the world of work often result in
|
|||
|
women being pidgeon-holed into less well paid job. This
|
|||
|
already happens in regard to part-time workers who are
|
|||
|
paid a lower hourly wage than full-time workers. They
|
|||
|
point out that men have to square up to their
|
|||
|
responsibility as fathers. The key they emphasise is a
|
|||
|
change in mens' attitudes.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
However what was not mentioned is that no matter how
|
|||
|
attitudes change, men are as powerless as individuals in
|
|||
|
regard to their working conditions as women are. With
|
|||
|
all the good will in the world they cannot change their
|
|||
|
employer/employee relationship, they cannot adjust their
|
|||
|
working hours to suit childcare just as women cannot. A
|
|||
|
more fundamental conclusion would be that society at the
|
|||
|
moment, capitalism, does not want to accommodate any of
|
|||
|
the problems of childcare preferring to leave it up to the
|
|||
|
individual to make their own arrangements as best as
|
|||
|
they can.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
CONTROL OF OUR BODIES
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It is for this reason that the issue of womens' ability to
|
|||
|
control their own fertility is key in obtaining womens'
|
|||
|
liberation. That is the fight for abortion rights, for freely
|
|||
|
available contraceptives, for 24 hour quality childcare.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Women will remain as second class citizens as long as they
|
|||
|
are relegated to an inferior position in the work force.
|
|||
|
They are now in that position because to the bosses they
|
|||
|
are an unstable workforce, likely to want pregnancy
|
|||
|
leave, likely to come in late if a child is sick, likely to
|
|||
|
require a creche or want to work part time. It is because
|
|||
|
men in society are seen as the breadwinners that they
|
|||
|
have slightly more secure, slightly more dependable jobs.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It's a vicious circle, because men are in reality better
|
|||
|
paid, it makes more sense within the family to assign the
|
|||
|
role of main earner to the male and the role of carer to
|
|||
|
the female. The only way to permanently get out out of
|
|||
|
this circle is to change the system. In a society organised
|
|||
|
to make profits for a few, women loose out. In a society
|
|||
|
organised to satisfy needs, womens' fertility would no
|
|||
|
longer be a limiting factor.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
INTO THE MAINSTREAM
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Women can of course win gains at the moment. In
|
|||
|
Ireland women are no longer forced to stop working upon
|
|||
|
marriage (though lack of childcare can make it impossible
|
|||
|
to continue). Attitudes have changed considerably in the
|
|||
|
last thirty years. Most importantly, the position of
|
|||
|
women is now an issue. Whereas before it was only
|
|||
|
addressed by the few socialist or womens' groups, now it's
|
|||
|
taken up in the mainstream media, in chat shows and
|
|||
|
newspaper articles. However, any of our new freedoms
|
|||
|
are very much dependant on the economic conditions of
|
|||
|
the day. So, while in the booming sixties American
|
|||
|
women won limited access to abortion, now in recession
|
|||
|
those rights are being pushed back inch by inch.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
When the reality is weighed up equal education & job
|
|||
|
opportunities and equal pay are limited without free 24
|
|||
|
hour nurseries and free contraception & abortion on
|
|||
|
demand. While a small minority of women can buy control
|
|||
|
of their own fertility, for the majority family and childcare
|
|||
|
is still - as it has always been - the largest problem faced
|
|||
|
by women workers. In this argument capitalism won't
|
|||
|
concede, it must be defeated.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Aileen O'Carroll
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
********** Sex, class & Womens oppression **********
|
|||
|
from Workers Solidarity No 36
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Lavinia Kerwick showed great bravery when
|
|||
|
she spoke out about being raped, thousands
|
|||
|
took to the streets in support of "X" last
|
|||
|
February. Violence and discrimination
|
|||
|
against women are still very real. But for the
|
|||
|
first time since the early 1980s large numbers
|
|||
|
of women want to fight back. Aileen O'Carroll
|
|||
|
looks at some of the issues that have arisen.
|
|||
|
Can women of all classes share a common
|
|||
|
goal? Should women organise separately? Is
|
|||
|
there a connection between fighting sexism and
|
|||
|
fighting capitalism?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
IT WAS NOT until the French Revolution in 1798, that
|
|||
|
it began to be accepted that all men are equal. Until
|
|||
|
then the concept was dismissed as irreligious and and
|
|||
|
against the 'natural order'. Many of the morals, rules
|
|||
|
and rights that society assumes as constant are
|
|||
|
actually quite fluid. It is only in the last few decades
|
|||
|
that the idea of equality has been extended to include
|
|||
|
women.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Although women still hold a secondary status, the idea of
|
|||
|
women as second class citizens is beginning to lose ground.
|
|||
|
Changing attitudes in itself are not going to lead to womens'
|
|||
|
liberation (all men aren't in fact equal in today's society, though
|
|||
|
there is no longer strong ideological opposition to the idea of
|
|||
|
equality). However, the freeing of women from the chains of
|
|||
|
sexism empowers us to fight for womens' liberation.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
However having said all this, why is it that women aren't more
|
|||
|
active in politics, in community groups, in campaigning? What is
|
|||
|
it that is holding them back? Anarchists believe that the core
|
|||
|
problem facing women is class society. However overlying that
|
|||
|
core is a layer of sexist ideas. This ideology serves to reinforce
|
|||
|
and justify womens' inferior status. How does this operate?
|
|||
|
How does it manage to do this?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It's easy today to underestimate the effects of the conditioning
|
|||
|
that takes place. Conditioning that tells us, that in the very
|
|||
|
first place we doesn't have any right to compete on an equal
|
|||
|
basis. There is ample proof that this occurs, for example the
|
|||
|
findings of a recent survey on secondary school children
|
|||
|
indicated that girls had a much lower self-image than boys of a
|
|||
|
comparable age. Recent studies in American classrooms showed
|
|||
|
that when girls answered out of turn they were more likely to
|
|||
|
be told off, while boys were likely to be praised for showing
|
|||
|
intelligence or initiative. Given this it was not surprising that
|
|||
|
in later classes girls rarely spoke unless specifically asked a
|
|||
|
question while boys often spoke out or chatted with the teacher.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
RAPE AND 'GUILT'
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Researchers into the area of sexual harassment have found that
|
|||
|
people have difficulty in knowing what type of behaviour
|
|||
|
amounts to harassment. Women feel unsure as to what are
|
|||
|
their rights are, unsure as to how much hassle they are
|
|||
|
expected by society to put up with. In a recent interview a
|
|||
|
representative of Dublin Rape Crisis Centre indicated that in
|
|||
|
her experiences all the women she saw felt guilt in some way,
|
|||
|
right down to an old age pensioner raped in her own home.
|
|||
|
Indeed, this is hardly surprising given the type of reporting of
|
|||
|
trials such as the Kennedy rape trial this year.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
One in three of crimes against women arise from domestic
|
|||
|
violence. Yet these problems are given low priority. Rape Crisis
|
|||
|
Centres are constantly under threat of closure due to lack of
|
|||
|
funding. In the first four months of 1990, the Gardai received
|
|||
|
1,568 calls for help in domestic violence situations (and all the
|
|||
|
experts accept that only a small number of such crimes are ever
|
|||
|
reported). The Womens' Aid refuges, run by volunteers, have
|
|||
|
only 16% of the space that is needed.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Workers in a Dublin refuge reported that between four and
|
|||
|
seven families are turned away on average, while approximately
|
|||
|
another 60 women phone seeking advice each week. Our low
|
|||
|
status in society is reflected not only by the level of violence
|
|||
|
against us, but by the complete disregard that is shown for the
|
|||
|
problem by the government and society at large.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A CURFEW ON WOMEN
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Though most rapes are committed by somebody known by the
|
|||
|
woman (92% of Irish rape victims knew their attackers), police
|
|||
|
propaganda is still aimed at frightening women into maintaining
|
|||
|
a self-imposed curfew at night. Even though the statistics
|
|||
|
indicate she is probably in more danger at home! We are forced
|
|||
|
to leave limited lives. We don't have freedom of movement even
|
|||
|
within our own communities. We are denied control over our
|
|||
|
own bodies. Worse of all, we are told how to look and how to
|
|||
|
behave.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Women are constantly given cues that they are in some way
|
|||
|
inferior. This conditioning is a symptom of the position of
|
|||
|
women in society, not the cause but a symptom with far reaching
|
|||
|
affects. We learn what is the norm through what is seen as
|
|||
|
acceptable behaviour in the world around us. The media, be it
|
|||
|
TV, film industry or pop music occupy a very vocal and dominant
|
|||
|
position. Next time you watch MTV or go to the cinema try and
|
|||
|
count how many times you see women portrayed as individuals
|
|||
|
in their own right, rather than as appendages. You won't need
|
|||
|
more fingers to count on than you have on your own two hands.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Most womens' magazines are still concerned with beauty, fashion
|
|||
|
and home making. Articles about working women are almost
|
|||
|
exclusively aimed at professionals and executives. They don't
|
|||
|
reflect the the reality that most women experience. Company
|
|||
|
magazine (June 1991) asks "Are you scared of success? Career
|
|||
|
success can be dazzling and very exciting, yet it can go hand in
|
|||
|
hand with tremendous fear". The article argues that if we just
|
|||
|
didn't keep holding ourselves back, we could make it in the
|
|||
|
career world. The truth for most of us is that it is lack of
|
|||
|
childcare and job opportunities determines our position as low
|
|||
|
paid workers, not our lack of confidence.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
GLOBAL FORUM OF EGOISTS AND BOSSES
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Unfortunately much of the womens' movement does exactly the
|
|||
|
same thing. Dublin recently hosted the 1992 Global Forum of
|
|||
|
Women. At <20>180 a head the forum was dedicated to "visions of
|
|||
|
leadership". Those attending were all "political, artistic &
|
|||
|
scientific leaders or prominent in the international leadership of
|
|||
|
the womens' movement". The brochure advertising the
|
|||
|
conference proclaimed "the president of Nicaragua is a women".
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
So what! So is the Queen of England and Margaret Thatcher. I
|
|||
|
don't see things being much better for our 'sisters' over the
|
|||
|
water or for those in Nicaragua. The election of Mary Robinson
|
|||
|
didn't make any noticeable difference for the 'sisters' at home
|
|||
|
either.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The conclusion of the conference, the message they are sending
|
|||
|
to the low paid, the part-time workers and the unemployed is
|
|||
|
that what is needed is 40% representation of women at all
|
|||
|
levels. Overwhelmingly, the message to us was to get up on our
|
|||
|
bikes, to seize the opportunities, that the only thing stopping us
|
|||
|
was ourselves. Class didn't come into it.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A gap exists between what women are meant to be like and what
|
|||
|
we are, between what we are supposed to achieve and what it is
|
|||
|
possible for us to achieve. Failure on our part to live up to an
|
|||
|
ideal is attributed to some fault within us, rather than to the
|
|||
|
type of society we live in. It is for these reasons that women
|
|||
|
often find it more difficult to speak in public. We are often are
|
|||
|
less confident because by standing up we are reacting against a
|
|||
|
conditioning that tells us we should sit down.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
ORGANISING SEPARATELY?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Women are constantly conditioned to believe that we do not
|
|||
|
have a right to an opinion, to be politically active, to speak out.
|
|||
|
Sometimes the first step against this conditioning is to organise
|
|||
|
separately from men. Partly this is because it is felt that men
|
|||
|
being more confident and more self-assured tend to dominate
|
|||
|
discussions. Or even more simply some women feel that when
|
|||
|
men are present they are more likely to take a silent role and
|
|||
|
leave the arguing up to them.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Under these conditions women organising together is an
|
|||
|
exercise in empowerment. It's a positive response to the
|
|||
|
conditioning of society. It's role should be to make it possible for
|
|||
|
women to participate as equals with men. It should be seen as
|
|||
|
a temporary but necesary step, not as an end in itself.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
However problems arise when this is taken further and when
|
|||
|
women begin to campaign separately. This identifies men as the
|
|||
|
root of the problem, which they aren't. It also isolates men from
|
|||
|
the struggle, when it is obvious that in order to change society
|
|||
|
we must work alongside them.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Within many Unions and the British Labour Party there exist
|
|||
|
women only conferences. A problem with this is that womens'
|
|||
|
issues are often referred to these conferences as a as a way of
|
|||
|
avoiding the issues and forgetting about them. Rape is a
|
|||
|
womens' issue - refer it to the womens' conference,
|
|||
|
contraception is a womens' issue - refer it to the womens'
|
|||
|
conference, etc.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In these instances men are rarely confronted with these issues,
|
|||
|
rarely have to deal with them and are let off the hook.
|
|||
|
Therefore while we defend the right of women to meet
|
|||
|
separately we also think it vital in any organisation, in any
|
|||
|
campaign, that women present their arguments to the entire
|
|||
|
body of people and win those arguments and fight as a whole.
|
|||
|
Tactically, this is the only way to widen and then win the fight
|
|||
|
for womens' liberation.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Things are better for us today. A lot of the institutionalised
|
|||
|
oppression, such as marriage bars and property laws has been
|
|||
|
removed. Often equal pay legislation and quota systems have
|
|||
|
been put in their place. Yet while things may have changed on
|
|||
|
paper, we are still left with class society. As long as this
|
|||
|
remains, the majority of us will not have equal access to the
|
|||
|
workplace or much else. As long as we are denyed economic
|
|||
|
equality, society will continue making up morals and invent so
|
|||
|
called 'natural laws', as a way of justifying it's treatment of us.
|
|||
|
By tackling the symptom, sexism in society, we will be in a
|
|||
|
better position to tackle the root cause. By tackling capitalism
|
|||
|
we will be fighting for womens' liberation.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Aileen O'Carroll
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
************* Equality for some Women ***************
|
|||
|
from Workers Solidarity No35
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
LAST SEPTEMBER the Bank of Ireland was, according
|
|||
|
to the 'Irish Times', 'basking in an unadulterated glow
|
|||
|
of approval' from the Employment Equality Agency, the
|
|||
|
Council of Status for Women and the Joint Oireachteas
|
|||
|
Committee on Womens Rights among others. What the
|
|||
|
Bank of Ireland had so progressively managed to do was
|
|||
|
to provide one creche which will cater for up to 45
|
|||
|
children.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Bank of Ireland employs 11,600 people. However, at <20>55
|
|||
|
a week the centre is obviously aimed at helping only a very
|
|||
|
small section of the workforce. As Bertie Ahern said, it did
|
|||
|
not make sense having highly and expensively qualified
|
|||
|
women leaving the workforce because of lack of childcare
|
|||
|
facilities. However, it does make sense, to industry, to
|
|||
|
employ over 50% of the entire workforce having either low
|
|||
|
pay or no security of employment (or both).
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It isn't sexism that holds us in the worse paid jobs but rather
|
|||
|
the economic reality of the capitalism system. To survive in
|
|||
|
the market place any company has to be competitive, to
|
|||
|
maximise profits. With wages accounting for 80% of the
|
|||
|
outgoings in most business, employing the cheapest labour
|
|||
|
makes good sense. In todays society, creches and child-care
|
|||
|
are a luxury that the profit motive can rarely afford. To
|
|||
|
women who accept this system, the provision of expensive
|
|||
|
inadequate child care is a victory, while the plight of ordinary
|
|||
|
women workers isn't worth mentioning.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
But there is a general feeling that we are now living in a
|
|||
|
post-feminist world. Women may not be quite equal to men,
|
|||
|
but the principle of equality has been widely accepted and
|
|||
|
liberation is only a matter of waiting. We are allowed to vote,
|
|||
|
to drink in pubs and to work outside marriage. Our right to
|
|||
|
an equal education system and an equal workplace is
|
|||
|
enshrined in law. We have a women president.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In Ireland there is now a wide acceptance that women have
|
|||
|
the right to participate in society on an equal basis with men.
|
|||
|
However, despite this change in hearts and minds, life on the
|
|||
|
ground for most women today, is quite similar to those of forty
|
|||
|
years ago. Though we may not, in general, have the same
|
|||
|
sexist morality to put up with; economically we are still
|
|||
|
second class citizens.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
For the majority of us, our right to choose the way of life we
|
|||
|
wish to lead is as limited as it has always been. Rather than
|
|||
|
being liberated, we are still tied, by virtue of our poor wage
|
|||
|
earning abilities, to the home and family. A study recently
|
|||
|
published in Fortune magazine indicated that the leading
|
|||
|
occupations for women in 1990 weren't so different from the
|
|||
|
top jobs for 1940 (see table). The average hourly earnings of
|
|||
|
woman are still 68% of those of men. In hard cash terms, men
|
|||
|
earn on average, <20>1.83 more per hour than women do.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Fortune Magazine Table
|
|||
|
1990 1940
|
|||
|
1. Secretary 1. Servant
|
|||
|
2. Cashier 2. Secretary
|
|||
|
3. Bookkeeper 3. Teacher
|
|||
|
4. Nurse 4. Clerical worker
|
|||
|
5. Nursing aide 5. Sales worker
|
|||
|
6. Teacher 6. Factory worker
|
|||
|
7. Waitress 7. Bookkeeper
|
|||
|
8. Sales Worker 8. Waitress
|
|||
|
9. Child care 9. Housekeeper
|
|||
|
10. Cook 10. Nurse
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
So, what are the problems facing women in the workforce?
|
|||
|
The answer you'll get to that question, will depend very much
|
|||
|
on who you are talking to. For the last six years, Social and
|
|||
|
Community Planing Research, a non-profit making institute,
|
|||
|
has been surveying British social attitudes to everything from
|
|||
|
should revolutionaries be allowed to have public meetings
|
|||
|
(only 48% said yes) to should the tax system be changed.
|
|||
|
Looking at the recently published 1991 survey, it becomes
|
|||
|
obvious that the key factor preventing women from working is
|
|||
|
children; i.e. lack of nursery places, lack of creches at work
|
|||
|
and "guilt at leaving the care of children to others".
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It noted that while 51% of those surveyed would have
|
|||
|
thought a work-place nursery suitable for the care of their
|
|||
|
children, none of the sample surveyed had access to such a
|
|||
|
service. Overwhelmingly, children were cared for by a close
|
|||
|
relative.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
On the other hand, the Financial Times, in a major article
|
|||
|
on women managers cited the main problems for women going
|
|||
|
into business as confidence, training and expertise, credibility
|
|||
|
and networks. For women at these higher levels, childcare
|
|||
|
provision is not a key problem, as they can afford to hire
|
|||
|
other women to stay at home so they are freed to go out and
|
|||
|
work. So when women managers seek to overcome sexism,
|
|||
|
provision of free 24 hour childcare is not a priority. Women
|
|||
|
may not be equal to men in today's society, but undoubtedly
|
|||
|
some women are more equal than others.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It is certainly true that there are very few women managers,
|
|||
|
however this is just a symptom of the general situation of
|
|||
|
women as a whole, not a cause. The installation of women at
|
|||
|
the top of a profession won't change the basic ground rules by
|
|||
|
which society is run. Those women at the top may suffer
|
|||
|
sexism from their colleagues. They may be ostracised from the
|
|||
|
old boys network and may find it more difficult to succeed.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
However, they also have an interest in seeing the system
|
|||
|
continue. Their high incomes, standard of living and position
|
|||
|
in society is dependant on them being on the top of the pile.
|
|||
|
So while they may lobby on 'safe' issues that affect most
|
|||
|
women, such as rape and domestic violence, when it comes to
|
|||
|
issues that question the way society is run and thus threaten
|
|||
|
their position, sisterhood quickly breaks down.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
How many of the Irish women TD's, who support abortion
|
|||
|
information are willing to publicly say so? On the one hand
|
|||
|
they may be members of the womens movement while on the
|
|||
|
other protecting their seat is more important. Mary Robinson
|
|||
|
may be a women, but she didn't show much sisterhood or
|
|||
|
solidarity when she signed into law the new social welfare
|
|||
|
regulations on cohabiting couples. This provision limits
|
|||
|
couples to 80% of the benefit that two single people receive
|
|||
|
Normally the women is the partner who receives the lower
|
|||
|
income.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Women will remain as second class citizens as long as they are
|
|||
|
relegated to an inferior position in the work force. They are
|
|||
|
now in that position because to the bosses they are an
|
|||
|
unstable workforce, likely to want pregnancy leave, likely to
|
|||
|
come in late if a child is sick, likely to require a creche or
|
|||
|
want to work part time. It is because men in society are seen
|
|||
|
as the breadwinner that they have more secure, more
|
|||
|
dependable jobs.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It's a vicious circle, because men are in reality better paid, it
|
|||
|
makes more sense within the family to assign the role of main
|
|||
|
earner to the male and housework to the female. The only
|
|||
|
way to permanently get out out of the circle is to change the
|
|||
|
system. In a society run for profit women loose out, in a
|
|||
|
society run for need, womens fertility is no longer a limiting
|
|||
|
factor.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Women can of course win gains at the moment. In Ireland
|
|||
|
women are no longer forced to stop working on marriage,
|
|||
|
though lack of child care can make it impossible to continue.
|
|||
|
Attitudes have changed considerably in the last thirty years.
|
|||
|
Most importantly, the position of women is now an issue.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Where as before it was only addressed by the few socialist or
|
|||
|
womens groups, now it's taken up by the mainstream media,
|
|||
|
by chat shows and newspaper articles. However, any of our
|
|||
|
new freedoms are very much dependant on the economic
|
|||
|
conditions of the day. So, while in the affluent 1960's British
|
|||
|
women won limited access to abortion (used by thousands of
|
|||
|
Irish women), now in recession those rights are being pushed
|
|||
|
back inch by inch.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
When you come down to basics equal education and job
|
|||
|
opportunities and equal pay amount to little without free 24
|
|||
|
hour nurseries and free contraception and abortion on
|
|||
|
demand. While a small minority of women can buy control of
|
|||
|
their own fertility, for the majority, family and child care is
|
|||
|
still as it has always been the largest problem faced by women
|
|||
|
workers.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
And as a small finishing thought, under capitalism most
|
|||
|
managers are paid a hell of a lot more than most workers.
|
|||
|
That's a situation women mangers won't want to change.
|
|||
|
After all, Margaret Thatcher was the ultimate woman
|
|||
|
manager, wasn't she?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Aileen O'Carroll
|
|||
|
|