1884 lines
94 KiB
Plaintext
1884 lines
94 KiB
Plaintext
29 page printout
|
||
|
||
Reproducible Electronic Publishing can defeat censorship.
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
Contents of this file page
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH. 1
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE. 13
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
This file, its printout, or copies of either
|
||
are to be copied and given away, but NOT sold.
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom, Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
|
||
The Works of ROBERT G. INGERSOLL
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
1888
|
||
|
||
"Let determined things to destiny hold unbewailed their way."
|
||
|
||
|
||
There is a continual effort in the mind of man to find the
|
||
harmony that he knows must exist between all known facts. It is
|
||
hard for the scientist to implicitly believe anything that he
|
||
suspects to be inconsistent with a known fact. He feels that every
|
||
fact is a key to many mysteries -- that every fact is a detective,
|
||
not only, but a perpetual witness. He knows that a fact has a
|
||
countless number of sides, and that all these sides will match all
|
||
other facts, and he also suspects that to understand one fact
|
||
perfectly -- like the fact of the attraction of gravitation --
|
||
would involve a knowledge of the universe.
|
||
|
||
It requires not only candor, but courage, to accept a fact.
|
||
When a new fact is found -- it is generally denied, resisted, and
|
||
calumniated by the conservatives until denial becomes absurd, and
|
||
then they accept it with the statement that they always supposed it
|
||
was true.
|
||
|
||
The old is the ignorant enemy of the new. The old has pedigree
|
||
and respectability; it is filled with the spirit of caste; it is
|
||
associated with great events, and with great names; it is
|
||
entrenched; it has an income -- it represents property. Besides, it
|
||
has parasites, and the parasites always defend themselves,
|
||
|
||
Long ago frightened wretches who had by tyranny or piracy
|
||
amassed great fortunes, were induced in the moment of death to
|
||
compromise with God and to let their money fall from their
|
||
stiffening hands into the greedy palms of priests. In this way many
|
||
theological seminaries were endowed, and in this way prejudices,
|
||
mistakes, absurdities, known as religious truths, have been
|
||
perpetuated. In this way the dead hypocrites have propagated and
|
||
supported their kind.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
1
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
Most religions -- no matter how honestly they originated --
|
||
have been established by brute force. Kings and nobles have used
|
||
them as a means to enslave, to degrade and rob. The priest,
|
||
consciously and unconsciously, has been the betrayer of his
|
||
followers.
|
||
|
||
Near Chicago there is an ox that betrays his fellows. Cattle
|
||
-- twenty or thirty at a time -- are driven to the place of
|
||
slaughter. This ox leads the way -- the others follow. When the
|
||
place is reached, this Bishop Dupanloup turns and goes back for
|
||
other victims.
|
||
|
||
This is the worst side: There is a better.
|
||
|
||
Honest men, believing that they have found the whole truth --
|
||
the real and only faith -- filled with enthusiasm, give all for the
|
||
purpose of propagating the "divine creed." They found colleges and
|
||
universities, and in perfect, pious, ignorant sincerity, provide
|
||
that the creed, and nothing but the creed, must be taught, and that
|
||
if any professor teaches anything contrary to that, he must be
|
||
instantly dismissed -- that is to say, the children must be beaten
|
||
with the bones of the dead.
|
||
|
||
These good religious souls erect guide-boards with a provision
|
||
to the effect that the guide-boards must remain, whether the roads
|
||
are changed or not, and with the further provision that the
|
||
professors who keep and repair the guide-boards must always insist
|
||
that the roads have not been changed.
|
||
|
||
There is still another side.
|
||
|
||
Professors do not wish to lose their salaries. They love their
|
||
families and have some regard for themselves. There is a compromise
|
||
between their bread and their brain. On pay-day they believe -- at
|
||
other times they have their doubts, They settle with their own
|
||
consciences by giving old words new meanings. They take refuge in
|
||
allegory, hide behind parables, and barricade themselves with
|
||
oriental imagery. They give to the most frightful passages a
|
||
spiritual meaning -- and while they teach the old creed to their
|
||
followers, they speak a new philosophy to their equals.
|
||
|
||
There is still another side.
|
||
|
||
A vast number of clergymen and laymen are perfectly satisfied.
|
||
They have no doubts. They believe as their fathers and mothers did.
|
||
The "scheme of salvation" suits them because they are satisfied
|
||
that they are embraced within its terms. They give themselves no
|
||
trouble. They believe because they do not understand. They have no
|
||
doubts because they do not think. They regard doubt as a thorn in
|
||
the pillow of orthodox slumber. Their souls are asleep, and they
|
||
hate only those who disturb their dreams. These people keep their
|
||
creeds for future use. They intend to have them ready at the moment
|
||
of dissolution. They sustain about the same relation to daily life
|
||
that the small boats carried by steamers do to ordinary navigation
|
||
-- they are for the moment of shipwreck. Creeds, like life-
|
||
preservers, are to be used in disaster.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
2
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
We must also remember that everything in nature -- bad as well
|
||
as good -- has the instinct of self-preservation. All lies go
|
||
armed, and all mistakes carry concealed weapons. Driven to the last
|
||
corner, even non-resistance appeals to the dagger.
|
||
|
||
Vast interests -- political, social, artistic, and individual
|
||
-- are interwoven with all creeds. Thousands of millions of dollars
|
||
have been invested; many millions of people obtain their bread by
|
||
the propagation and support of certain religious doctrines, and
|
||
many millions have been educated for that purpose and for that
|
||
alone. Nothing is more natural than that they should defend
|
||
themselves -- that they should cling to a creed that gives them
|
||
roof and raiment.
|
||
|
||
Only a few years ago Christianity was a complete system. It
|
||
included and accounted for all phenomena; it was a philosophy
|
||
satisfactory to the ignorant world; it had an astronomy and geology
|
||
of its own; it answered all questions with the same readiness and
|
||
the same inaccuracy; it had within its sacred volumes the history
|
||
of the past, and the prophecies of all the future; it pretended to
|
||
know all that was, is, or ever will be necessary for the well-being
|
||
of the human race, here and hereafter,
|
||
|
||
When a religion has been founded, the founder admitted the
|
||
truth of everything that was generally believed that did not
|
||
interfere with his system. Imposture always has a definite end in
|
||
view, and for the sake of the accomplishment of that end, it will
|
||
admit the truth of anything and everything that does not endanger
|
||
its success.
|
||
|
||
The writers of all sacred books -- the inspired prophets --
|
||
had no reason for disagreeing with the common people about the
|
||
origin of things, the creation of the world, the rising and setting
|
||
of the sun, and the uses of the stars, and consequently the sacred
|
||
books of all ages have indorsed the belief general at the time. You
|
||
will find in our sacred books the astronomy, the geology, the
|
||
philosophy and the morality of the ancient barbarians. The
|
||
religionist takes these general ideas as his foundation, and upon
|
||
them builds the supernatural structure. For many centuries the
|
||
astronomy, geology, philosophy and morality of our ]Bible were
|
||
accepted. They were not questioned, for the reason that the world
|
||
was too ignorant to question.
|
||
|
||
A few centuries ago the art of printing was invented. A new
|
||
world was discovered. There was a complete revolution in commerce.
|
||
The arts were born again. The world was filled with adventure;
|
||
millions became self-reliant; old ideas were abandoned -- old
|
||
theories were put aside -- and suddenly, the old leaders of thought
|
||
were found to be ignorant, shallow and dishonest. The literature of
|
||
the classic world was discovered and translated into modern
|
||
languages. The world was circumnavigated; Copernicus discovered the
|
||
true relation sustained by our earth to the solar system, and about
|
||
the beginning of the seventeenth century many other wonderful
|
||
discoveries were made. In 1609, a Hollander found that two lenses
|
||
placed in a certain relation to each other magnified objects seen
|
||
through them. This discovery was the foundation of astronomy. In a
|
||
little while it came to the knowledge of Galileo; the result was a
|
||
telescope, with which man has read the volume of the skies.
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
3
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
|
||
On the 8th day of May, 1618, Kepler discovered the greatest of
|
||
his three laws. These were the first great blows struck for the
|
||
enfranchisement of the human mind. A few began to suspect that the
|
||
ancient Hebrews were not astronomers. From that moment the church
|
||
became the enemy of science. In every possible way the inspired
|
||
ignorance was defended -- the lash, the sword, the chain, the fagot
|
||
and the dungeon were the arguments used by the infuriated church.
|
||
|
||
To such an extent was the church prejudiced against the new
|
||
philosophy, against the new facts, that priests refused to look
|
||
through the telescope of Galileo.
|
||
|
||
At last it became evident to the intelligent world that the
|
||
inspired writings, literally translated, did not contain the truth
|
||
-- the Bible was in danger of being driven from the heavens.
|
||
|
||
The church also had its geology. The time when the earth was
|
||
created had been definitely fixed and was certainly known. This
|
||
fact had not only been stated by inspired writers, but their
|
||
statement had been indorsed by priests, by bishops, cardinals,
|
||
popes and ecumenical councils; that was settled.
|
||
|
||
But a few men had learned the art of seeing. There were some
|
||
eyes not always closed in prayer. They looked at the things about
|
||
them; they observed channels that had been worn in solid rock by
|
||
streams; they Saw the vast territories that had been deposited by
|
||
rivers; their attention was called to the slow inroads upon
|
||
continents by seas -- to the deposits by volcanoes -- to the
|
||
sedimentary rocks -- to the vast reefs that had been built by the
|
||
coral, and to the countless evidences of age, of the lapse of time
|
||
-- and finally it was demonstrated that this earth had been
|
||
pursuing its course about the sun for millions and millions of
|
||
ages.
|
||
|
||
The church disputed every step, denied every fact, resorted to
|
||
every device that cunning could suggest or ingenuity execute, but
|
||
the conflict could not be maintained. The Bible, so far as geology
|
||
was concerned, was in danger of being driven from the earth.
|
||
|
||
Beaten in the open field, the church began to equivocate, to
|
||
evade, and to give new meanings to inspired words. Finally,
|
||
falsehood having failed to harmonize the guesses of barbarians with
|
||
the discoveries of genius, the leading churchmen suggested that the
|
||
Bible was not written to teach astronomy, was not written to teach
|
||
geology, and that it was not a scientific book, but that it was
|
||
written in the language of the people, and that as to unimportant
|
||
things it contained the general beliefs of its time.
|
||
|
||
The ground was then taken that, while it was not inspired in
|
||
its science, it was inspired in its morality, in its prophecy, in
|
||
its account of the miraculous, in the scheme of salvation, and in
|
||
all that it had to say on the subject of religion.
|
||
|
||
The moment it was suggested that the Bible was not inspired in
|
||
everything within its lids, the seeds of suspicion were sown. The
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
4
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
priest became less arrogant. The church was forced to explain. The
|
||
pulpit had one language for the faithful and another for the
|
||
philosophical, i.e., it became dishonest with both.
|
||
|
||
The next question that arose was as to the origin of man.
|
||
|
||
The Bible was being driven from the skies. The testimony of
|
||
the stars was against the sacred volume. The church had also been
|
||
forced to admit that the world was not created at the time
|
||
mentioned in the Bible -- so that the very stones of the earth rose
|
||
and united with the stars in giving testimony against the sacred
|
||
volume.
|
||
|
||
As to the creation of the world, the church resorted to the
|
||
artifice of saying that "days" in reality meant long periods of
|
||
time; so that no matter how old the earth was, the time could be
|
||
spanned by six periods -- in other words, that the years could not
|
||
be too numerous to be divided by six.
|
||
|
||
But when it came to the creation of man, this evasion, or
|
||
artifice, was impossible. The Bible gives the date of the creation
|
||
of man, because it gives the age at which the first man died, and
|
||
then it gives the generations from Adam to the flood, and from the
|
||
flood to the birth of Christ, and in many instances the actual age
|
||
of the principal ancestor is given. So that, according to this
|
||
account -- according to the inspired figures -- man has existed
|
||
upon the earth only about six thousand years. There is no room left
|
||
for any people beyond Adam.
|
||
|
||
If the Bible is true, certainly Adam was the first man;
|
||
consequently, we know, if the sacred volume be true, just how long
|
||
man has lived and labored and suffered on this earth.
|
||
|
||
The church cannot and dare not give up the account of the
|
||
creation of Adam from the dust of the earth, and of Eve from the
|
||
rib of the man. The church cannot give up the story of the Garden
|
||
of Eden -- the serpent -- the fall and the expulsion; these must be
|
||
defended because they are vital. Without these absurdities, the
|
||
system known as Christianity cannot exist. Without the fall, the
|
||
atonement is a nan sequitur. Facts bearing upon these questions
|
||
were discovered and discussed by the greatest and most thoughtful
|
||
of men. Lamarek, Humboldt, Haeckel, and above all, Darwin, not only
|
||
asserted, but demonstrated, that man is not a special creation. If
|
||
anything can be established by observation, by reason, then the
|
||
fact has been established that man is related to all life below him
|
||
-- that he has been slowly produced through countless years -- that
|
||
the story of Eden is a childish myth -- that the fall of man is an
|
||
infinite absurdity.
|
||
|
||
If anything can, be established by analogy and reason, man has
|
||
existed upon the earth for many millions of ages. We know now, if
|
||
we know anything, that people not only existed before Adam, but
|
||
that they existed in a highly civilized state; that thousands of
|
||
years before the Garden of Eden was planted men communicated to
|
||
each other their ideas by language, and that artists clothed the
|
||
marble with thoughts and passions.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
5
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
This is a demonstration that the origin of man given in the
|
||
Old Testament is untrue -- that the account was written by the
|
||
ignorance, the prejudice and the egotism of the olden time.
|
||
|
||
So, if anything outside of the senses can be known, we do know
|
||
that civilization is a growth -- that man did not commence a
|
||
perfect being, and then degenerate, but that from small beginnings
|
||
he has slowly risen to the intellectual height he now occupies.
|
||
|
||
The church, however, has not been willing to accept these
|
||
truths, because they contradict the sacred word. Some of the most
|
||
ingenious of the clergy have been endeavoring for years to show
|
||
that there is no conflict -- that the account in Genesis is in
|
||
perfect harmony with the theories of Charles Darwin, and these
|
||
clergymen in some way manage to retain their creed and to accept a
|
||
philosophy that utterly destroys it.
|
||
|
||
But in a few years the Christian world will be forced to admit
|
||
that the Bible is not inspired in its astronomy, in its geology, or
|
||
in its anthropology -- that is to say, that the inspired writers
|
||
knew nothing of the sciences, knew nothing of the origin of the
|
||
earth, nothing of the origin of man -- in other words, nothing of
|
||
any particular value to the human race.
|
||
|
||
It is, however, still insisted that the Bible is inspired in
|
||
its morality. Let us examine this question.
|
||
|
||
We must admit, if we know anything, if we feel anything, if
|
||
conscience is more than a word, if there is such a thing as right
|
||
and such a thing as wrong beneath the dome of heaven -- we must
|
||
admit that slavery is immoral. If we are honest, we must also
|
||
admit that the Old Testament upholds slavery. It will be cheerfully
|
||
admitted that Jehovah was opposed to the enslavement of one Hebrew
|
||
by another. Christians may quote the commandment "Thou shalt not
|
||
steal" as being opposed to human slavery, but after that
|
||
commandment was given, Jehovah himself told his chosen people that
|
||
they might "buy their bondmen and bondwomen of the heathen round
|
||
about, and that they should be their bondmen and their bondwomen
|
||
forever." So all that Jehovah meant by the commandment "Thou shalt
|
||
not steal" was that one Hebrew should not steal from another
|
||
Hebrew, but that all Hebrews might steal from the people of any
|
||
other race or creed.
|
||
|
||
It is perfectly apparent that the Ten Commandments were made
|
||
only for the Jews, not for the world, because the author of these
|
||
commandments commanded the people to whom they were given to
|
||
violate them nearly all as against the surrounding people.
|
||
|
||
A few years ago it did not occur to the Christian world that
|
||
slavery was wrong. It was upheld by the church. Ministers bought
|
||
and sold the very people for whom they declared that Christ had
|
||
died. Clergymen of the English church owned stock in slave-ships,
|
||
and the man who denounced slavery was regarded as the enemy of
|
||
morality, and thereupon was duly mobbed by the followers of Jesus
|
||
Christ. Churches were built with the results of labor stolen from
|
||
colored Christians. Babes were sold from mothers and a part of the
|
||
money given to send missionaries from America to heathen lands with
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
6
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
the tidings of great joy. Now every intelligent man on the earth,
|
||
every decent man, holds in abhorrence the institution of human
|
||
slavery.
|
||
|
||
So with the institution of polygamy. If anything on the earth
|
||
is immoral, that is. If there is anything calculated to destroy
|
||
home, to do away with human love, to blot out the idea of family
|
||
life, to cover the hearthstone with serpents, it is the institution
|
||
of polygamy. The Jehovah of the Old Testament was a believer in
|
||
that institution.
|
||
|
||
Can we now say that the Bible is inspired in its morality?
|
||
Consider for a moment the manner in which, under the direction of
|
||
Jehovah, wars were waged. Remember the atrocities that were
|
||
committed. Think of a war where everything was the food of the
|
||
sword. Think for a moment of a deity capable of committing the
|
||
crimes that are described and gloated over in the Old Testament.
|
||
The civilized man has outgrown the sacred cruelties and
|
||
absurdities.
|
||
|
||
There is still another side to this question.
|
||
|
||
A few centuries ago nothing was more natural than the
|
||
unnatural. Miracles were as plentiful as actual events. In those
|
||
blessed days, that which actually occurred was not regarded of
|
||
sufficient importance to be recorded. A religion without miracles
|
||
would have excited derision. A creed that did not fill the horizon
|
||
-- that did not account for everything -- that could not answer
|
||
every question, would have been regarded as worthless.
|
||
|
||
After the birth of Protestantism, it could not be admitted by
|
||
the leaders of the Reformation that the Catholic Church still had
|
||
the power of working miracles. If the Catholic Church was still in
|
||
partnership with God, what excuse could have been made for the
|
||
Reformation? The Protestants took the ground that the age of
|
||
miracles had passed. This was to justify the new faith. But
|
||
Protestants could not say that miracles had never been performed,
|
||
because that would take the foundation not only from the Catholics
|
||
but from themselves; consequently they were compelled to admit that
|
||
miracles were performed in the apostolic days, but to insist that,
|
||
in their time, man must rely upon the facts in nature. Protestants
|
||
were compelled to carry on two kinds of war; they had to contend
|
||
with those who insisted that miracles had never been performed; and
|
||
in that argument they were forced to insist upon the necessity for
|
||
miracles, on the probability that they were performed, and upon the
|
||
truthfulness of the apostles. A moment afterward, they had to
|
||
answer those who contended that miracles were performed at that
|
||
time; then they brought forward against the Catholics the same
|
||
arguments that their first opponents had brought against them.
|
||
|
||
This has made every Protestant brain "a house divided against
|
||
itself." This planted in the Reformation the irrepressible
|
||
conflict."
|
||
|
||
But we have learned more and more about what we call Nature --
|
||
about what we call facts. Slowly it dawned upon the mind that force
|
||
is indestructible -- that we cannot imagine force as existing apart
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
7
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
from matter -- that we cannot even think of matter existing apart
|
||
from force -- that we cannot by any possibility conceive of a cause
|
||
without an effect, of an effect without a cause, of an effect that
|
||
is not also a cause. We find no room between the links of cause and
|
||
effect for a miracle. We now perceive that a miracle must be
|
||
outside of Nature -- that it can have no father, no mother -- that
|
||
is to say, that it is an impossibility.
|
||
|
||
The intellectual world has abandoned the miraculous. Most
|
||
ministers are now ashamed to defend a miracle. Some try to explain
|
||
miracles, and yet, if a miracle is explained, it ceases to exist.
|
||
Few congregations could keep from smiling were the minister to
|
||
seriously assert the truth of the Old Testament miracles.
|
||
|
||
Miracles must be given up. That field must be abandoned by the
|
||
religious world. The evidence accumulates every day, in every
|
||
possible direction in which the human mind can investigate, that
|
||
the miraculous is simply the impossible.
|
||
|
||
Confidence in the eternal constancy of Nature increases day by
|
||
day. The scientist has perfect confidence in the attraction. of
|
||
gravitation -- in chemical affinities -- in the great fact of
|
||
evolution, and feels absolutely certain that the nature of things
|
||
will remain forever the same.
|
||
|
||
We have at last ascertained that miracles can be perfectly
|
||
understood; that there is nothing mysterious about them; that they
|
||
are simply transparent falsehoods.
|
||
|
||
The real miracles are the facts in nature, No one can explain
|
||
the attraction of gravitation. No one knows why soil and rain and
|
||
light become the womb of life. No one knows why grass grows, why
|
||
water runs, or why the magnetic needle points to the north, The
|
||
facts in nature are the eternal and the only mysteries. There is
|
||
nothing strange about the miracles of superstition, They are
|
||
nothing but the mistakes of ignorance and fear, or falsehoods
|
||
framed by those who wished to live on the labor of others.
|
||
|
||
In our time the champions of Christianity, for the most part,
|
||
take the exact ground occupied by the Deists. They dare not defend
|
||
in the open field the mistakes, the cruelties, the immoralities and
|
||
the absurdities of the Bible. They shun the Garden of Eden as
|
||
though the serpent was still there. They have nothing to say about
|
||
the fall of man. They are silent as to the laws upholding slavery
|
||
and polygamy. They are ashamed to defend the miraculous. They talk
|
||
about these things to Sunday schools and to the elderly members of
|
||
their congregations; but when doing battle for the faith, they
|
||
misstate the position of their opponents and then insist that there
|
||
must be a God, and that the soul is immortal.
|
||
|
||
We may admit the existence of an infinite Being; we may admit
|
||
the immortality of the soul, and yet deny the inspiration of the
|
||
Scriptures and the divine origin of the Christian religion. These
|
||
doctrines, or these dogmas, have nothing in common. The pagan world
|
||
believed in God and taught the dogma of immortality. These ideas
|
||
are far older than Christianity, and they have been almost
|
||
universal.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
8
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Christianity asserts more than this. It is based upon the
|
||
inspiration of the Bible, on the fall of man, on the atonement, on
|
||
the dogma of the Trinity, on the divinity of Jesus Christ, on his
|
||
resurrection from the dead, on his ascension into heaven.
|
||
|
||
Christianity teaches not simply the immortality of the soul --
|
||
not simply the immortality of joy -- but it teaches the immortality
|
||
of pain, the eternity of sorrow. It insists that evil, that
|
||
wickedness, that immorality and that every form of vice are and
|
||
must be perpetuated forever. It believes in immortal convicts, in
|
||
eternal imprisonment and in a world of unending pain. It has a
|
||
serpent for every breast and a curse for nearly every soul. This
|
||
doctrine is called the dearest hope of the human heart, and he who
|
||
attacks it is denounced as the most infamous of men.
|
||
|
||
Let us see what the church, within a few years, has been
|
||
compelled substantially to abandon, -- that is to say, what it is
|
||
now almost ashamed to defend.
|
||
|
||
First, the astronomy of the sacred Scriptures; second, the
|
||
geology; third, the account given of the origin of man; fourth, the
|
||
doctrine of original sin, the fall of the human race; fifth, the
|
||
mathematical contradiction known as the Trinity; sixth, the
|
||
atonement -- because it was only on the ground that man is
|
||
accountable for the sin of another, that he could be justified by
|
||
reason of the righteousness of another; seventh, that the
|
||
miraculous is either the misunderstood or the impossible; eighth,
|
||
that the Bible is not inspired in its morality, for the reason that
|
||
slavery is not moral, that polygamy is not good, that wars of
|
||
extermination are not merciful, and that nothing can be more
|
||
immoral than to punish the innocent on account of the sins of the
|
||
guilty; and ninth, the divinity of Christ.
|
||
|
||
All this must be given up by the really intelligent, by those
|
||
not afraid to think, by those who have the courage of their
|
||
convictions and the candor to express their thoughts. What then is
|
||
left?
|
||
|
||
Let me tell yon, Everything in the Bible that is true, is
|
||
left; it still remains and is still of value. It cannot be said too
|
||
often that the truth needs no inspiration; neither can it be said
|
||
too often that inspiration cannot help falsehood. Every good and
|
||
noble sentiment uttered in the Bible is still good and noble. Every
|
||
fact remains. All that is good in the Sermon on the Mount is
|
||
retained. The Lord's Prayer is not affected. The grandeur of self-
|
||
denial, the nobility of forgiveness, and the ineffable splendor of
|
||
mercy are with us still. And besides, there remains the great hope
|
||
for all the human race.
|
||
|
||
What is lost? All the mistakes, all the falsehoods, all the
|
||
absurdities, all the cruelties and all the curses contained in the
|
||
Scriptures. We have almost lost the "hope" of eternal pain -- the
|
||
"consolation" of perdition; and in time we shall lose the frightful
|
||
shadow that has fallen upon so many hearts, that has darkened so
|
||
many lives.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
9
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
The great trouble for many years has been, and still is, that
|
||
the clergy are not quite candid. They are disposed to defend the
|
||
old creed. They have been educated in the universities, of the
|
||
Sacred Mistake -- universities that Bruno would call "the widows of
|
||
true learning." They have been taught to measure with a false
|
||
standard; they have weighed with inaccurate scales. in youth, they
|
||
became convinced of the truth of the creed. This was impressed upon
|
||
them by the solemnity of professors who spoke in tones of awe. The
|
||
enthusiasm of life's morning was misdirected. They went out into
|
||
the world knowing nothing of value. They preached a creed outgrown.
|
||
Having been for so many years entirely certain of their position,
|
||
they met doubt with a spirit of irritation -- afterward with
|
||
hatred. They are hardly courageous enough to admit that they are
|
||
wrong.
|
||
|
||
Once the pulpit was the leader -- it spoke with authority. By
|
||
its side was the sword of the state, with the hilt toward its hand.
|
||
Now it is apologized for -- it carries a weight. It is now like a
|
||
living man to whom has been chained a corpse. It cannot defend the
|
||
old, and it has not accepted the new. In some strange way it
|
||
imagines that morality cannot live except in partnership with the
|
||
sanctified follies and falsehoods of the past.
|
||
|
||
The old creeds cannot be defended by argument. They are not
|
||
within the circumference of reason -- they are not embraced in any
|
||
of the facts within the experience of man. All the subterfuges have
|
||
been exposed; all the excuses have been shown to be shallow, and at
|
||
last the church must meet, and fairly meet, the objections of our
|
||
time.
|
||
|
||
Solemnity is no longer an argument. Falsehood is no longer
|
||
sacred. People are not willing to admit that mistakes are divine.
|
||
Truth is more important than belief -- far better than creeds,
|
||
vastly more useful than superstitions. The church must accept the
|
||
truths of the present, must admit the demonstrations of science, or
|
||
take its place in the mental museums with the fossils and
|
||
monstrosities of the past.
|
||
|
||
The time for personalities has passed; these questions cannot
|
||
be determined by ascertaining the character of the disputants;
|
||
epithets are no longer regarded as arguments; the curse of the
|
||
church produces laughter; theological slander is no longer a
|
||
weapon; argument must be answered with argument, and the church
|
||
must appeal to reason, and by that standard it must stand or fall.
|
||
The theories and discoveries of Darwin cannot be answered by the
|
||
resolutions of synods, or by quotations from the Old Testament.
|
||
|
||
The world has advanced. The Bible has remained the same. We
|
||
must go back to the book -- it cannot come to us -- or we must
|
||
leave it forever. In order to remain orthodox we must forget the
|
||
discoveries, the inventions, the intellectual efforts of many
|
||
centuries; we must go back until our knowledge -- or rather our
|
||
ignorance -- will harmonize with the barbaric creeds.
|
||
|
||
It is not pretended that all the creeds have not been
|
||
naturally produced. It is admitted that under the same
|
||
circumstances the same religions would again ensnare the human
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
10
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
race. It is also admitted that under the same circumstances the
|
||
same efforts would be made by the great and intellectual of every
|
||
age to break the chains of superstition.
|
||
|
||
There is no necessity of attacking people -- we should combat
|
||
error. We should hate hypocrisy, but not the hypocrite -- larceny,
|
||
but not the thief -- superstition, but not its victim. We should do
|
||
all within our power to inform, to educate, and to benefit our
|
||
fellow-men.
|
||
|
||
There is no elevating power in hatred. There is no reformation
|
||
in punishment. The soul grows greater and grander in the air of
|
||
kindness, in the sunlight of intelligence.
|
||
|
||
We must rely upon the evidence of our senses, upon the
|
||
conclusions of our reason.
|
||
|
||
For many centuries the church has insisted that man is totally
|
||
depraved, that he is naturally wicked, that all of his natural
|
||
desires are contrary to the will of God. Only a few years ago it
|
||
was solemnly asserted that our senses were originally honest, true
|
||
and faithful, but having been debauched by original sin, were now
|
||
cheats and liars; that they constantly deceived and misled the
|
||
soul; that they were traps and snares; that no man could be safe
|
||
who relied upon his senses, or upon his reason; -- he must simply
|
||
rely upon faith; in other words, that the only way for man to
|
||
really see was to put out his eyes.
|
||
|
||
There has been a rapid improvement in the intellectual world.
|
||
The improvement has been slow in the realm of religion, for the
|
||
reason that religion was hedged about, defended and barricaded by
|
||
fear, by prejudice find by law. It was considered sacred. It was
|
||
illegal to call its truth in question. Whoever disputed the priest
|
||
became a criminal; whoever demanded a reason, or an explanation,
|
||
became a blasphemer, a scoffer, a moral leper.
|
||
|
||
The church defended its mistakes by every means within its
|
||
power.
|
||
|
||
But in spite of all this there has been advancement, and there
|
||
are enough of the orthodox clergy left to make it possible for us
|
||
to measure the distance that has been traveled by sensible people.
|
||
|
||
The world is beginning to see that a minister should be a
|
||
teacher, and that "he should not endeavor to inculcate a particular
|
||
system of dogmas, but to prepare his hearers for exercising their
|
||
own judgments,"
|
||
|
||
As a last resource, the orthodox tell the thoughtful that they
|
||
are not "spiritual" -- that they are "of the earth, earthy " --
|
||
that they cannot perceive that which is spiritual. They insist that
|
||
"God is a spirit, and must be worshiped in spirit."
|
||
|
||
But let me ask, What is it to be spiritual? In order to be
|
||
really spiritual, must a man sacrifice this world for the sake of
|
||
another? Were the selfish hermits, who deserted their wives and
|
||
children for the miserable purpose of saving their own little
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
11
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
souls, spiritual? Were those who put their fellow-men in dungeons,
|
||
or burned them at the stake on account of a difference of opinion,
|
||
all spiritual people? Did John Calvin give evidence of his
|
||
spirituality by burning Servetus? Were they spiritual people who
|
||
invented and used instruments of torture -- who denied the liberty
|
||
of thought and expression -- who waged wars for the propagation of
|
||
the faith? Were they spiritual people who insisted that infinite
|
||
Love could punish his poor, ignorant children forever? Is it
|
||
necessary to believe in eternal torment to understand the meaning
|
||
of the word spiritual? Is it necessary to hate those who disagree
|
||
with you, and to calumniate those whose argument you cannot answer,
|
||
in order to be spiritual? Must you hold a demonstrated fact in
|
||
contempt; must you deny or avoid what you know to be true, in order
|
||
to substantiate the fact that you are spiritual?
|
||
|
||
What is it to be spiritual? Is the man spiritual who searches
|
||
for the truth -- who lives in accordance with his highest ideal --
|
||
who loves his wife and children -- who discharges his obligations
|
||
-- who makes a happy fireside for the ones he loves -- who succors
|
||
the oppressed -- who gives his honest opinions -- who is guided by
|
||
principle -- who is merciful and just?
|
||
|
||
Is the man spiritual who loves the beautiful -- who is
|
||
thrilled by music, and touched to tears in the presence of the
|
||
sublime, the heroic and the self-denying? Is the man spiritual who
|
||
endeavors by thought and deed to ennoble the human race?
|
||
|
||
The defenders of the orthodox faith, by this time, should know
|
||
that the foundations are insecure.
|
||
|
||
They should have the courage to defend, or the candor to
|
||
abandon. If the Bible is an inspired book, it ought to be true. Its
|
||
defenders must admit that Jehovah knew the facts not only about the
|
||
earth, but about the stars, and that the Creator of the universe
|
||
knew all about geology and astronomy even four thousand years ago.
|
||
|
||
The champions of Christianity must show that the Bible tells
|
||
the truth about the creation of man, the Garden of Eden, the
|
||
temptation, the fall and the flood. They must take the ground that
|
||
the sacred book is historically correct; that the events related
|
||
really happened; that the miracles were actually performed; that
|
||
the laws promulgated from Sinai were and are wise and just, and
|
||
that nothing is upheld, commanded, indorsed, or in any way approved
|
||
or sustained that is not absolutely right. In other words, if they
|
||
insist that a being of infinite goodness and intelligence is the
|
||
author of the Bible, they must be ready to show that it is
|
||
absolutely perfect. They must defend its astronomy, geology,
|
||
history, miracle and morality.
|
||
|
||
If the Bible is true, man is a special creation, and if man is
|
||
a special creation, millions of facts must have conspired, millions
|
||
of ages ago, to deceive the scientific world of to-day.
|
||
|
||
If the Bible is true, slavery is right, and the world should
|
||
go back to the barbarism of the lash and chain. If the Bible is
|
||
true, polygamy is the highest form of virtue. If the Bible is true,
|
||
nature has a master, and the miraculous is independent of and
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
12
|
||
|
||
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
||
|
||
superior to cause and effect. If the Bible is true, most of the
|
||
children of men are destined to suffer eternal pain. If the Bible
|
||
is true, the science known as astronomy is a collection of mistakes
|
||
-- the telescope is a false witness, and light is a luminous liar.
|
||
If the Bible is true, the science known as geology is false and
|
||
every fossil is a petrified perjurer.
|
||
|
||
The defenders of orthodox creeds should have the courage to
|
||
candidly answer at least two questions: First, Is the Bible
|
||
inspired? Second, Is the Bible true? And when they answer these
|
||
questions, they should remember that if the Bible is true, it needs
|
||
no inspiration, and that if not true, inspiration can do it no
|
||
good.
|
||
|
||
North American Review, August, 1888.
|
||
|
||
END
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
THE Old Testament must have been written nearly two thousand
|
||
years before the invention of Printing. There were but few copies,
|
||
and these were in the keeping of those whose interest might have
|
||
prompted interpolations, and whose ignorance might have led to
|
||
mistakes.
|
||
|
||
Second. The written Hebrew was composed entirely of
|
||
consonants, without any points or marks standing for vowels, so
|
||
that anything like accuracy was impossible, Anyone can test this
|
||
for himself by writing an English sentence, leaving out the vowels.
|
||
It will take far more inspiration to read than to write a book with
|
||
consonants alone.
|
||
|
||
Third. The books composing the Old Testament were not divided
|
||
into chapters or verses, and no system of punctuation was known.
|
||
Think of this a moment and you will see how difficult it must be to
|
||
read such a book.
|
||
|
||
Fourth. There was not among the Jews any dictionary of their
|
||
language, and for this reason the accurate meaning of words could
|
||
not be preserved. Now the different meanings of words are preserved
|
||
so that by knowing the age in which a writer lived we can ascertain
|
||
with reasonable certainty his meaning.
|
||
|
||
Fifth. The Old Testament was printed for the first time in
|
||
1488. Until this date it existed only in manuscript, and was
|
||
constantly exposed to erasures and additions.
|
||
|
||
Sixth. It is now admitted by the most learned in the Hebrew
|
||
language that in our present English version of the Old Testament
|
||
there are at least one hundred thousand errors. Of course the
|
||
believers in inspiration assert that these errors are not
|
||
sufficient in number to cast the least suspicious upon any passages
|
||
upholding what are called the fundamentals."
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
13
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
Seventh. It is not certainly known who in fact wrote any of
|
||
the books of the Old Testament. For instance, it is now generally
|
||
conceded that Moses was not the author of the Pentateuch.
|
||
|
||
Eighth. Other books, not now in existence, are referred to in
|
||
the Old Testament as of equal authority, such as the books of
|
||
Jasher, Nathan, Ahijah, Iddo, Jehu, Sayings of the Seers.
|
||
|
||
Ninth. The Christians are not agreed among themselves as to
|
||
what books are inspired. The Catholics claim as inspired the books
|
||
of Maccabees, Tobit, Esdras, etc. Others doubt the inspiration of
|
||
Esther, Ecclesiastes, and the Song of Solomon.
|
||
|
||
Tenth. In the book of Esther and the Song of Solomon the name
|
||
of God is not mentioned, and no reference is made to any supreme
|
||
being, nor to any religions duty. these omissions would seem
|
||
sufficient to cast a little doubt upon these books.
|
||
|
||
Eleventh. Within the present century manuscript copies of the
|
||
Old Testament have been found throwing new light and changing in
|
||
many instances the present readings. In consequence a new version
|
||
is now being made by a theological syndicate composed of English
|
||
and American divines, and after this is published it may be that
|
||
our present Bible will fall into disrepute.
|
||
|
||
Twelfth. The fact that language is continually changing that
|
||
words are constantly dying and others being born; that the same
|
||
word has a variety of meanings during its life, shows how hard it
|
||
is to preserve the original ideas that might have been expressed in
|
||
the Scriptures, for thousands of years, without dictionaries,
|
||
without the art of printing, and without the light of
|
||
contemporaneous literature.
|
||
|
||
Thirteenth. Whatever there was of the Old Testament seems to
|
||
have been lost from the time of Moses until the days of Josiah, and
|
||
it is probable that nothing like the Bible existed in any permanent
|
||
form among the Jews until a few hundred years before Christ. It is
|
||
said that Ezra gave the Pentateuch to the Jews, but whether he
|
||
found or originated it is unknown. So it is claimed that Nehemiah
|
||
gathered up the manuscripts about the kings and prophets, while the
|
||
books of Job, Psalms, Proverbs, Ruth, Ecclesiastes, and some others
|
||
were either collected or written long after. The Jews themselves
|
||
did not agree as to what books were really inspired.
|
||
|
||
Fourteenth. In the Old Testament we find several contradictory
|
||
laws about the same thing, and contradictory accounts of the same
|
||
occurrences. In the twentieth chapter of Exodus we find the first
|
||
account of the giving of Ten Commandments. In the thirty-fourth
|
||
chapter another account is given. These two accounts could never
|
||
have been written by the same person. Read these two accounts and
|
||
you will be forced to admit that one of them cannot be true. So
|
||
there are two histories of the creation, of the flood, and of the
|
||
manner in which Saul became king.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
14
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
Fifteenth. It is now generally admitted that Genesis must have
|
||
been written by two persons, and the parts written by each can be
|
||
separated, and when separated they are found to contradict each
|
||
other in many important particulars.
|
||
|
||
Sixteenth. It is also. admitted that copyists made verbal
|
||
changes not only, but pieced out fragments; that the speeches of
|
||
Elihu in the book of Job were all interpolated, and that most of
|
||
the prophecies were made by persons whose names we have never
|
||
known.
|
||
|
||
Seventeenth. The manuscripts of the Old Testament were not
|
||
alike, and the Greek version differed from the Hebrew, and there
|
||
was no absolutely received text of the Old Testament until after
|
||
the commencement of the Christian era. Marks and points to denote
|
||
vowels were invented probably about the seventh century after
|
||
Christ. Whether these vowels were put in the proper places or not
|
||
is still an open question.
|
||
|
||
Eighteenth. The Alexandrian version, or what is known as the
|
||
Septuagint, translated by seventy learned Jews, assisted by
|
||
"miraculous power," about two hundred years before Christ, could
|
||
not have been, it is said, translated from the Hebrew text that we
|
||
now have. The differences can only be accounted for by supposing
|
||
that they had a different Hebrew text. The early Christian Churches
|
||
adopted the Septuagint, and were satisfied for a time. But so many
|
||
errors were found, and so many were scanning every word in search
|
||
of something to sustain their peculiar views, that several new
|
||
versions appeared, all different somewhat from the Hebrew
|
||
manuscripts, from the Septuagint, and from each other. All these
|
||
versions were in Greek. The first Latin Bible originated in Africa,
|
||
but no one has ever found out which Latin manuscript was the
|
||
original. Many were produced, and all differed from each other.
|
||
These Latin versions were compared with each other and with the
|
||
Hebrew, and a new Latin version was made in the fifth century, but
|
||
the old Latin versions held their own for about four hundred years,
|
||
and no one yet knows which were right. Besides these there were
|
||
Egyptian, Ethiopic, Armenian, and several others, all differing
|
||
from each other as well as from all others in the world.
|
||
|
||
It was not until the fourteenth century that the Bible was
|
||
translated into German, and not until the fifteenth that Bibles
|
||
were printed in the principal languages of Europe. Of these Bibles
|
||
there were several kinds -- Luther's, the Dort, King James's,
|
||
Genevan, French, besides the Danish and Swedish. Mort of these
|
||
differed from each other, and gave rise to infinite disputes and
|
||
crimes without number. The earliest fragment of the Bible in the
|
||
"Saxon" language known to exist was written sometime in the seventh
|
||
century. The first Bible was printed in England in 1538. In 1560
|
||
the first English Bible was printed that was divided into verses.
|
||
Under Henry VIII. the Bible was revised; again under Queen
|
||
Elizabeth, and once again under King James, This last was published
|
||
in 1611, and is the one now in general use.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
15
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
Nineteenth. No one in the world has learning enough, nor has
|
||
the time enough even if he had the learning, and could live a
|
||
thousand years, to find out what books really belong to and
|
||
constitute the Old Testament, the authors these books, when they
|
||
were written, and what they mean. And until a man has the learning
|
||
and the time to do all this he cannot certainly tell whether he
|
||
believe Bible or not.
|
||
|
||
Twentieth. If a revelation from God was actually necessary to
|
||
the happiness of man here and to his salvation hereafter, it is not
|
||
easy to see why such revelation was not given to all the nations of
|
||
the earth. Why were the millions of Asia, Egypt, and America left
|
||
to the insufficient light of nature. Why was not a written, or what
|
||
is still better, printed revelation given to Adam and Eve in the
|
||
Garden of Eden? And why were the Jews themselves without a Bible
|
||
until the days of Ezra the scribe? Why was nature not so made that
|
||
it would give light enough? Why did God make men and leave them in
|
||
darkness -- a darkness that he knew would fill the world with want
|
||
and crime, and crowd with damned souls the dungeons of hell? Were
|
||
the Jews the only people who needed a revelation? It may be said
|
||
that God had no time to waste with other nations, and gave the
|
||
Bible to the Jews that other nations through them might learn of
|
||
his existence and his will. If he wished other nations to be
|
||
informed, and revealed himself to but one, why did he not choose a
|
||
people that mingled with others? Why did he give the message to
|
||
those who had no commerce, who were obscure and unknown, and who
|
||
regarded other nations with the hatred born of bigotry and
|
||
weakness? What would we now think of a God who made his will known
|
||
to the South Sea Islanders for the benefit of the civilized world?
|
||
If it was of such vast importance for man to know that there is a
|
||
God, why did not God make himself known? This fact could have been
|
||
revealed by an infinite being instantly to all, and there certainly
|
||
was no necessity of telling it alone to the Jews, and allowing
|
||
millions for thousands of years to die in utter ignorance.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-first The Chinese, Japanese, Hindus, Tartars, Africans,
|
||
Eskimo, Persians, Turks, Kurds, Arabs, Polynesians, and many other
|
||
peoples, are substantially ignorant of the Bible. All the Bible
|
||
societies of the world have produced only about one hundred and
|
||
twenty millions of Bibles, and there are about fourteen hundred
|
||
million people. There are hundreds of languages and tongues in
|
||
which no Bible has yet been printed. Why did God allow, and why
|
||
does he still allow, a vast majority of his children to remain in
|
||
ignorance of his will?
|
||
|
||
Twenty-second. If the Bible is the foundation of all
|
||
civilization, of all just ideas of right and wrong, of our duties
|
||
to God and each other, why did God not give to each nation at least
|
||
one copy to start with? He must have known that no nation could get
|
||
along successfully without a Bible, and he also knew that man could
|
||
not make one for himself. Why, then, were not the books furnished?
|
||
He must have known that the light of nature was not sufficient to
|
||
reveal the scheme of the atonement, the necessity of baptism, the
|
||
immaculate conception, transubstantiation, the arithmetic of the
|
||
Trinity, or the resurrection of the dead.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
16
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-third. It is probably safe to say that not one-third of
|
||
the inhabitants of this world ever heard of the Bible, and not one-
|
||
tenth ever read it. It is also safe to say that no two persons who
|
||
ever read it agreed as to its meaning, and it is not likely that
|
||
even one person has ever understood it. Nothing is more needed at
|
||
the present time than an inspired translator. Then we shall need an
|
||
inspired commentator, and the translation and the commentary should
|
||
be written in an inspired universal language, incapable of change,
|
||
and then the whole world should be inspired to understand this
|
||
language precisely the same. Until these things are accomplished,
|
||
all written revelations from God will fill the world with
|
||
contending sects, contradictory creeds and opinions.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-fourth. All persons who know anything of constitutions
|
||
and laws know how impossible it is to use words that will convey
|
||
the same ideas to all. The best statesmen, the profoundest lawyers,
|
||
differ as widely about the real meaning of treaties and statutes as
|
||
do theologians about the Bible. When the differences of lawyers are
|
||
left to courts, and the courts give written decisions, the lawyers
|
||
will again differ as to the real meaning of the opinions. Probably
|
||
no two lawyers in the United States understand our Constitution
|
||
alike. To allow a few men to tell what the Constitution means, and
|
||
to hang for treason all who refuse to accept the opinions of these
|
||
few men, would accomplish in politics what most churches have asked
|
||
for in religion.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-fifth. Is it very wicked to deny that the universe was
|
||
created of nothing by an infinite being who existed from all
|
||
eternity? The human mind is such that it cannot possibly conceive
|
||
of creation, neither can it conceive of an infinite being who dwelt
|
||
in infinite space an infinite length of time.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-sixth. The idea that the universe was made in six days,
|
||
and is but about six thousand years old, is too absurd for serious
|
||
refutation. Neither will it do to say that the six days were six
|
||
periods, because this does away with the Sabbath, and is in direct
|
||
violation of the text.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-seventh. Neither is it reasonable that this God made
|
||
man out of dust, and woman out of one of the ribs of the man; that
|
||
this pair were put in a garden; that they were deceived by a snake
|
||
that had the power of speech; that they were turned out of this
|
||
garden to prevent them from eating of the tree of life and becoming
|
||
immortal; that God himself made them clothes; that the sons of God
|
||
intermarried with the daughters of men; that to destroy all life
|
||
upon the earth a flood was sent that covered the highest mountains;
|
||
that Noah and his sons built an ark and saved some of all animals
|
||
as well as themselves; that the people tried to build a tower that
|
||
would reach to heaven; that God confounded their language, and in
|
||
this way frustrated their design.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-eighth. It is hard to believe that God talked to
|
||
Abraham as one man talks to another; that he gave him land that he
|
||
pointed out; that he agreed to give him land that he never did;
|
||
that he ordered him to murder his own son; that angels were in the
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
17
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
habit of walking about the earth eating veal dressed with butter
|
||
and milk, and making bargains about the destruction of cities.
|
||
|
||
Twenty-ninth. Certainly a man ought not to be eternally damned
|
||
for entertaining an honest doubt about a woman having been turned
|
||
into a pillar of salt, about cities being destroyed by storms of
|
||
fire and brimstone, and about people once having lived for nearly
|
||
a thousand years.
|
||
|
||
Thirtieth. Neither is it probable that God really wrestled
|
||
with Jacob and put his thigh out of joint, and that for that reason
|
||
the Jews refused "to eat the sinew that shrank," as recounted in
|
||
the thirty-second chapter of Genesis; that God in the likeness of
|
||
a flame inhabited a bush; that he amused himself by changing the
|
||
rod of Moses into a serpent, and making his hand leprous as snow.
|
||
|
||
Thirty-first. One can scarcely be blamed for hesitating to
|
||
believe that God met Moses at a hotel and tried to kill him; [Ex.
|
||
iv, 24.] that afterward he made this same Moses a god to Pharaoh,
|
||
and gave him his brother Aaron for a prophet; [Ex. vii, 1.] that he
|
||
turned all the ponds and pools and streams and all the rivers into
|
||
blood, [Ex. viii, 19.] and all the water in vessels of wood and
|
||
stone; that the rivers thereupon brought forth frogs; [Ex. viii, 3
|
||
that the frogs covered the whole land of Egypt; that he changed
|
||
dust into lice, so that all the men, women, children, and animals
|
||
were covered with them; [Ex. viii, 16, 17.] that he sent swarms of
|
||
flies upon the Egyptians; [Ex. viii, 21.] that he destroyed the
|
||
innocent cattle with painful diseases; that he covered man and
|
||
beast with blains and boils; [Ex. ix, 9.] that he so covered the
|
||
magicians of Egypt with boils that they could not stand before
|
||
Moses for the purpose of performing the same feat; [Ex. xii, 11.]
|
||
that he destroyed every beast and every man that was in the fields,
|
||
and every herb, and broke every tree with storm of hail and fire;
|
||
[Ex. ix, 25.] that he sent locusts that devoured every herb that
|
||
escaped the hail, and devoured every tree that grew; [Ex. x, 15.]
|
||
that he caused thick darkness over the land and put lights in the
|
||
houses of the Jews; [Ex. x, 22, 23.] that he destroyed all of the
|
||
firstborn of Egypt, from the firstborn of Pharaoh upon the throne
|
||
to the firstborn of the maidservant that sat behind the mill, [Ex.
|
||
xi, 5.] together with the firstborn of all beasts, so that there
|
||
was not a house in which the dead were not. [Ex. xii, 29.]
|
||
|
||
Thirty-second. It is very hard to believe that three millions
|
||
of people left a country and marched twenty or thirty miles all in
|
||
one day. To notify so many people would require a long time, and
|
||
then the sick, the halt, and the old would be apt to impede the
|
||
march. It seems impossible that such a vast number -- six hundred
|
||
thousand men, besides women and children -- could have been cared
|
||
for, could have been fed and clothed, and the sick nursed,
|
||
especially when we take into consideration that "they were thrust
|
||
out of Egypt, and could not tarry, neither had they prepared for
|
||
themselves any victual." [Ex. xii, 37-39.]
|
||
|
||
Thirty-third. It seems cruel to punish a man forever for
|
||
denying that God went before the Jews by day "in a pillar of a
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
18
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
cloud to lead them the way, and by night in a pillar of fire to
|
||
give them light to go by day and night," or for denying that
|
||
Pharaoh pursued the Jews with six hundred chosen chariots, and all
|
||
the chariots of Egypt, and that the six hundred thousand men of war
|
||
of the Jews were sore afraid when they saw the pursuing hosts. It
|
||
does seems strange that after all the water in a country had been
|
||
turned to blood -- after it had been overrun with frogs and
|
||
devoured with flies; after all the cattle had died with the
|
||
murrain, and the rest had been killed by the fire and hail and the
|
||
remainder had suffered with boils, and the firstborn of all that
|
||
were left had died; that after locusts had devoured every herb and
|
||
eaten up every tree of the field, and the firstborn had died, from
|
||
the firstborn of the king on the throne to the firstborn of the
|
||
captive in the dungeon; that after three millions of people had
|
||
left, carrying with them the jewels of silver and gold and the
|
||
raiment of their oppressors, the Egyptians still had enough
|
||
soldiers and chariots and horses left to pursue and destroy an army
|
||
of six hundred thousand men, if God had not interfered.
|
||
|
||
Thirty-fourth. It certainly ought to satisfy God to torment a
|
||
man for four or five thousand years for insisting that it is but a
|
||
small thing for an infinite being to vanquish an Egyptian army;
|
||
that it was rather a small business to trouble people with frogs,
|
||
flies, and vermin; that it looked almost malicious to cover people
|
||
with boils and afflict cattle with disease; that a real good God
|
||
would not torture innocent beasts on account of something the
|
||
owners had done; that it was absurd to do miracles before a king to
|
||
induce him to act in a certain way, and then harden his heart so
|
||
that he would refuse; and that to kill all the firstborn of a
|
||
nation was the act of a heartless fiend.
|
||
|
||
Thirty-fifth. Certainly one ought to be permitted to doubt
|
||
that twelve wells of water were sufficient for three millions of
|
||
people, together with their flocks and herds [Ex. xv, 27.] and to
|
||
inquire a little into the nature of manna that cooked by baking and
|
||
seething and yet would melt in sun, [Ex. xvi, 23, 21.] and that
|
||
would swell or shrink so as to make an exact omer, no matter how
|
||
much or how little there really was. [Ex. xix, 12.] Certainly it is
|
||
not a crime to say that water cannot be manufactured by striking a
|
||
rock with a stick, and that the fate of battle cannot be decided by
|
||
lifting one hand up or letting it fall. [Ex. xvii, 11, 12.] Must we
|
||
admit that God really did come down upon Mount Sinai in the sight
|
||
of all the people; that he commanded that all who should go up into
|
||
the Mount or touch the border of it should be put to death, and
|
||
that even the beasts that came near it should be killed? [Ex. xix,
|
||
12, 13.] Is it wrong to laugh at this? Is it Sinful to say that God
|
||
never spoke from the top of a mountain covered with clouds these
|
||
words to Moses, "Go down, charge the people, lest they break
|
||
through unto the Lord to gaze, and many of them perish; and let the
|
||
priests also, which come near to Lord, sanctify themselves, lest
|
||
the Lord break forth upon them"? [Ex. xix, 21, 22.] Can it be that
|
||
an infinite intelligence takes delight in scaring savages, and that
|
||
he is happy only when somebody trembles? Is it reasonable to
|
||
suppose that God surrounded himself with thunderings and lightnings
|
||
and thick darkness to tell the priests that they should not make
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
19
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
altars of hewn stones, nor with stairs? [Ex. xix, 25, 26.] And that
|
||
this God at the same time he gave the Ten Commandments ordered the
|
||
Jews to break the most of them? According to the Bible these
|
||
infamous words came from the mouth of God while he was wrapped and
|
||
clothed in darkness and clouds upon the Mount of Sinai:
|
||
|
||
If thou buy an Hebrew servant six years he shall serve:
|
||
and in the seventh he shall go out free for nothing. If he
|
||
came in by himself he shall go out by himself; if he were
|
||
married, then his wife shall go out with him. If his master
|
||
have given him a wife, and she have borne him sons or
|
||
daughters, the wife and her children shall be her master's,
|
||
and he shall go out by himself. And if the servant shall
|
||
plainly say, I love my master, my wife, and my children; I
|
||
will not go out free: then his master shall bring him unto the
|
||
judges; he shall also bring him to the door or unto the
|
||
doorpost; and his master shall bore his ear through with an
|
||
awl; and he shall serve him forever. [Ex. xxi, 2-6.] And if a
|
||
man smite his servant, or his maid, with a rod, and he die
|
||
under his hand, he shall be surely punished. Notwithstanding,
|
||
if he continue a day or two, he shall not be punished; for he
|
||
is his money." [Ex. xxi, 20, 21.]
|
||
|
||
Do you really think that a man will be eternally damned for
|
||
endeavoring to wipe from the record of God those barbaric words?
|
||
|
||
Thirty-sixth. Is it because of total depravity that some
|
||
people refuse to believe that God went into partnership with
|
||
insects and granted letters of marque and reprisal to hornets; [Ex.
|
||
xxiii, 28.] that he wasted forty days and nights furnishing Moses
|
||
with plans and specifications for a tabernacle, an ark, a mercy
|
||
seat and two cherubs of gold, a table, four rings, some dishes and
|
||
spoons, one candlestick, three bowls, seven lamps, a pair of tongs,
|
||
some snuff dishes (for all of which God had patterns), ten curtains
|
||
with fifty loops, a roof for the tabernacle of rams' skins dyed
|
||
red, a lot of boards, an altar with horns, ash pans, basins, and
|
||
flesh hooks, and fillets of silver and pins of brass; that he told
|
||
Moses to speak unto all the wise-hearted that he had filled with
|
||
wisdom, that they might make a suit of clothes for Aaron, and that
|
||
God actually gave directions that an ephod "shall have the two
|
||
shoulder-pieces thereof joined at the two edges thereof," and gave
|
||
all the orders concerning mitres, girdles, and onyx stones, ouches,
|
||
emeralds, breastplates, chains, rings, Urim and Thummim, and the
|
||
hole in the top of the ephod like the hole of a habergeon? [Ex.
|
||
xxvii and xxviii.]
|
||
|
||
Thirty-seventh. Is there a Christian missionary who could help
|
||
laughing if in any heathen country he had seen the following
|
||
command of God carried out? "And thou shalt take the other ram; and
|
||
Aaron and his sons shall put their hands upon the head of the ram.
|
||
Then shalt thou kill the ram and take of his blood and put it upon
|
||
the tip of the right ear of Aaron, and upon the tip of the right
|
||
ear of his sons, and upon the thumb of their right hand, and upon
|
||
the great toe of their right foot. [Ex. xxix, 19, 20.] Does one
|
||
have to be born again to appreciate the beauty and solemnity of
|
||
such a performance? Is not the faith of the most zealous Christian
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
20
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
somewhat shaken while reading the recipes for cooking mutton, veal,
|
||
beef, birds, and unleavened dough, found in the cook book that God
|
||
made for Aaron and his sons?
|
||
|
||
Thirty-eighth. Is it to be wondered at that some people have
|
||
doubted the statement that God told Moses how to make some
|
||
ointment, hair oil, and perfume, and then made it a crime
|
||
punishable with death to make any like them ? Think of a God
|
||
killing a man for imitating his ointment! [Ex. xxx, 23.] Think of
|
||
a God saying that be made heaven and earth in six days and rested
|
||
on the seventh day and was refreshed! [Ex. xxxi, 17.] Think of this
|
||
God threatening to destroy the Jews, and being turned from his
|
||
purpose because Moses told him that the Egyptians might mock him!
|
||
[Ex. xxxii, 11, 12.]
|
||
|
||
Thirty-ninth. What must we think of a man impudent enough to
|
||
break in pieces tables of stone upon which God had written with his
|
||
finger? What must we think of the goodness of a man that would
|
||
issue the following order: "Thus saith the Lord God of Israel, Put
|
||
every man his sword by his side, and go in and out from gate to
|
||
gate throughout the camp, and slay every man his brother, and every
|
||
man his companion, and every man his neighbor. Consecrate
|
||
yourselves to-day to the Lord, even every man upon his son, and
|
||
upon his brother; that he may bestow upon you a blessing this day"?
|
||
[Ex. xxxii, 27-29.] Is it true that the God of the Bible demanded
|
||
human sacrifice? Did it please him for man to kill his neighbor,
|
||
for brother to murder his brother, and for the father to butcher
|
||
his son? If there is a God let him cause it to be written in the
|
||
book of his memory, opposite my name, that I refuted this slander
|
||
and denied this lie.
|
||
|
||
Fortieth. Can it be true that God was afraid to trust himself
|
||
with the Jews for fear he would consume them? Can it be that in
|
||
order to keep from devouring them he kept away and sent one of his
|
||
angels in his place? [Ex. xxxiii, 2, 3.] Can it be that this same
|
||
God talked to Moses "face to face, as a man speaketh unto his
|
||
friend," when it is declared in the same chapter, by God himself,
|
||
"Thou canst not see my face: for there shall no man see me, and
|
||
live"? [Ex. xxxiii, 11, 20.]
|
||
|
||
Forty-first. Why should a man, because he has done a bad
|
||
action, go and kill a sheep? How can man make friends with God by
|
||
cutting the throats of bullocks and goats? Why should God delight
|
||
in the shedding of blood? Why should he want his altar sprinkled
|
||
with blood, and the horns of his altar tipped with blood, and his
|
||
priests covered with blood? Why should burning flesh be a sweet
|
||
savor in the nostrils of God? Why did he compel his priests to be
|
||
butchers, cutters and stabbers? Why should the same God kill a man
|
||
for eating the fat of an ox, a sheep, or a goat?
|
||
|
||
Forty-second. Could it be a consolation to a man when dying to
|
||
think that he had always believed that God told Aaron to take two
|
||
goats and draw cuts to see which goat should be killed and which
|
||
should be a scapegoat? [Lev. xvi, 8.] And that upon the head of the
|
||
scapegoat Aaron should lay both his hands and confess over him all
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
21
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
the iniquities of the children of Israel, and all their
|
||
transgressions, and put them all on the head of the goat, and send
|
||
him away by the hand of a fit man into the wilderness; and that the
|
||
goat should bear upon him all the iniquities of the people into a
|
||
land not inhabited? [Lev. xvi, 21, 22.] How could a goat carry away
|
||
a load of iniquities and transgressions? Why should he carry them
|
||
to a land uninhabited? Were these sins contagious? About how many
|
||
sins could an average goat carry? Could a man meet such a goat now
|
||
without laughing?
|
||
|
||
Forty-third. Why should God object to a man wearing a garment
|
||
made of woolen and linen? Why should he care whether a man rounded
|
||
the corners of his beard? [Lev. xix, 19, 27.] Why should God
|
||
prevent a man from offering the sacred, bread merely because he had
|
||
a flat nose, or was lame, or had five fingers on one hand, or had
|
||
a broken foot, or was a dwarf? If he objected to such people, why
|
||
did he make them?" [Lev. xxi, 18-20.]
|
||
|
||
Forty-fourth. Why should we believe that God insisted upon the
|
||
sacrifice of human beings? Is it a sin to deny this, and to deny
|
||
the inspiration of a book that teaches it? Read the twenty-eighth
|
||
and twenty-ninth verses of the last chapter of Leviticus, a book in
|
||
which there is more folly and cruelty, more stupidity and tyranny,
|
||
than in any other book in this world except some others in the same
|
||
Bible. Read the thirty-second chapter of Exodus and you will see
|
||
how by the most infamous of crimes man becomes reconciled to this
|
||
God. You will see that he demands of fathers the blood of their
|
||
sons. Read the twelfth and thirteenth verses of the third chapter
|
||
of Numbers, "And I, behold, I have taken the Levites from among the
|
||
children of Israel," etc.
|
||
|
||
How, in the desert of Sinai, did the Jews obtain curtains of
|
||
fine linen? How did these absconding slaves make cherubs of gold?
|
||
Where did they get the skins of badgers, and how did they dye them
|
||
red? How did they make wreathed chains and spoons, basins and
|
||
tongs? Where did they get the blue cloth and their purple? Where
|
||
did they get the sockets of brass? How did they coin the shekel of
|
||
the sanctuary? How did they overlay boards with gold? Where did
|
||
they get the numberless instruments and tools necessary to
|
||
accomplish all these things? Where did they get the fine flour and
|
||
the oil? Were all these found in the desert of Sinai? Is it a sin
|
||
to ask these questions? Are all these doubts born of a malignant
|
||
and depraved heart? Why should God in this desert prohibit priests
|
||
from drinking wine, and from eating moist grapes? How could these
|
||
priests get wine?
|
||
|
||
Do not these passages show that these laws were made long
|
||
after the Jews had left the desert, and that they were not given
|
||
from Sinai? Can you imagine a God silly enough to tell a horde of
|
||
wandering savages upon a desert that they must not eat any fruit of
|
||
the trees they planted until the fourth year?
|
||
|
||
Forty-fifth. Ought a man to be despised and persecuted for
|
||
denying that God ordered the priests to make women drink dirt and
|
||
water to test their virtue? [Num. v, 12-31.] Or for denying that
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
22
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
over the tabernacle there was a cloud during the day and fire by
|
||
night, and that the cloud lifted up when God wished the Jews to
|
||
travel, And that until it was lifted they remained in their tents?
|
||
[Num. ix, 16-18.] Can it be possible that the "ark of the covenant
|
||
"traveled on its own account," and that "when the ark set forward"
|
||
the people followed, as is related in the tenth chapter of the holy
|
||
book of Numbers?
|
||
|
||
Forty-sixth. Was it reasonable for God to give the Jews manna,
|
||
and nothing else, year after year? He had infinite power, and could
|
||
just as easily have given them something good, in reasonable
|
||
variety, as to have fed them on manna until they loathed the sight
|
||
of it, and longingly remembered the fish, cucumbers, melons, leeks,
|
||
onions, and garlic of Egypt. And yet when the poor people
|
||
complained of the diet and asked for a little meat, this loving and
|
||
merciful God became enraged, sent them millions of quails in his
|
||
wrath, and while they were eating, while the flesh was yet between
|
||
their teeth, before it was chewed, this amiable God smote the
|
||
people with a plague and killed all those that lusted after meat.
|
||
In a few days after, he made up his mind to kill the rest, but was
|
||
dissuaded when Moses told him that the Canaanites would laugh at
|
||
him. [Num. xiv, 15, 16.] No wonder the poor Jews wished they were
|
||
back in Egypt. No wonder they had rather be the slaves of Pharaoh
|
||
than the chosen people of God, No wonder they preferred the wrath
|
||
of Egypt to the love of heaven. In my judgment, the Jews would have
|
||
fared far better if Jehovah had let them alone, or had he even
|
||
taken the side of the Egyptians.
|
||
|
||
When the poor Jews were told by their spies that the
|
||
Canaanites were giants, they, seized with fear, said, "Let us go
|
||
back to Egypt." For this, their God doomed all except Joshua and
|
||
Caleb to a wandering death. Hear the words of this most merciful
|
||
God: "But as for you, your carcasses they shall fall in this
|
||
wilderness, and your children shall wander in the wilderness forty
|
||
years and bear your" sins "until your carcasses be wasted in the
|
||
wilderness." [Num. xiv, 32-33.] And yet this same God promised to
|
||
give unto all these people a land flowing with milk and honey.
|
||
|
||
Forty-seventh. And while the children of Israel were in the
|
||
wilderness they found a man that gathered sticks upon the Sabbath
|
||
day.
|
||
|
||
"And they that found him gathering sticks brought him unto
|
||
Moses and Aaron, and unto all the congregation.
|
||
|
||
"And they put him in ward, because it was not declared what
|
||
should be done to him.
|
||
|
||
"And the Lord said unto Moses, The man shall be surely put to
|
||
death; all the congregation shall stone him with stones without the
|
||
camp.
|
||
|
||
"And all the congregation brought him without the camp, and
|
||
stoned him with stones, and he died." [Num. xv, 32-36.] When the
|
||
last stone was thrown, and he that was a man was but a mangled,
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
23
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
bruised, and broken mass, this God turned, and, touched with pity,
|
||
said: "Speak unto the children of Israel, and bid them that they
|
||
make them fringes in the borders of their garments throughout their
|
||
generations, and that they put upon the fringe of the borders a
|
||
riband of blue." [Num. xv, 38.]
|
||
|
||
In the next chapter, this Jehovah, whose loving kindness is
|
||
over all his works, because Korah, Dathan, and Abiram objected to
|
||
being starved to death in the wilderness, made the earth open and
|
||
swallow not only them, but their wives and their little ones. Not
|
||
yet satisfied, he sent a plague and killed fourteen thousand seven
|
||
hundred more. There never was in the history of the world such a
|
||
cruel, revengeful, bloody, jealous, fickle, unreasonable, and
|
||
fiendish ruler, emperor, or king as Jehovah. No wonder the children
|
||
of Israel cried out, "Behold we die, we perish, we all perish."
|
||
|
||
Forty-eighth. I cannot believe that a dry stick budded,
|
||
blossomed, and bore almonds; that the ashes of a red heifer are a
|
||
purification for sin; [Num. xix, 2-10.] that God gave the cities
|
||
into the hands of the Jews because they solemnly agreed to murder
|
||
all the inhabitants; that God became enraged and induced snakes to
|
||
bite his chosen people; that God told Balaam to go with the
|
||
Princess of Moab, and then got angry because he did go; that an
|
||
animal ever saw an angel and conversed with a man. I cannot believe
|
||
that thrusting a spear through the body of a woman ever stayed a
|
||
plague; [Num. xxv, 8.] that any good man ever ordered his soldiers
|
||
to slay the men and keep the maidens alive for themselves; that God
|
||
commanded men not to show mercy to each other; that he induced men
|
||
to obey his commandments by promising them that he would assist
|
||
them in murdering the wives and children of their neighbors; or
|
||
that he ever commanded a man to kill his wife because she differed
|
||
with him about religion; [Deut. xiii, 6-10.] or that God was
|
||
mistaken about hares chewing the cud; [Deut. xiv, 7.] or that he
|
||
objected to the people raising horses; [Deut. xvii, 16.] or that
|
||
God wanted a camp kept clean because he walked through it at night;
|
||
[Deut. xxiii, 13, 14.] or that he commanded widows to spit in the
|
||
faces of their brothers-in-law; [Deut. xxv, 9.] or that he ever
|
||
threatened to give anybody the itch; [Deut. xxviii, 27.] or that he
|
||
ever secretly buried a man and allowed the corpse to write an
|
||
account of the funeral.
|
||
|
||
Forty-ninth. Does it necessarily follow that a man wishes to
|
||
commit some crime if he refuses to admit that the river Jordan cut
|
||
itself in two and allowed the lower end to run away? [Josh. iii,
|
||
16.] Or that seven priests could blow seven ram's horns loud enough
|
||
to throw down the walls of a city; [Josh. vi, 20.] or that God,
|
||
after Achan had confessed that he had secreted a garment and a
|
||
wedge of gold, became good natured as soon as Achan and his sons
|
||
and daughters had been stoned to death and their bodies burned?
|
||
[Josh. vii, 24, 25.] Is it not a virtue to abhor such a God?
|
||
|
||
Must we believe that God sanctioned and commanded all the
|
||
cruelties and horrors described in the Old Testament; that he waged
|
||
the most relentless and heartless wars; that he declared mercy a
|
||
crime; that to spare life was to excite his wrath; that he smiled
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
24
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
when maidens were violated, laughed when mothers were ripped open
|
||
with a sword, and shouted with joy when babes were butchered in
|
||
their mothers' arms? Read the infamous book of Joshua, and then
|
||
worship the God who inspired it if you can.
|
||
|
||
Fiftieth. Can any sane man believe that the sun stood still in
|
||
the midst of heaven and hasted not to go down about a whole day,
|
||
and that the moon stayed? [Josh. x, 13.] That these miracles were
|
||
performed in the interest of massacre and bloodshed; that the Jews
|
||
destroyed men, women, and children by the million, and practiced
|
||
every cruelty that the ingenuity of their God could suggest? Is it
|
||
possible that these things really happened? Is it possible that God
|
||
commanded them to be done? Again I ask you to read the book of
|
||
Joshua. After reading all its horrors you will feel a grim
|
||
satisfaction in the dying words of Joshua to the children of
|
||
Israel: "Know for a certainty that the Lord your God will no more
|
||
drive out any of these nations from before you; but they shall be
|
||
snares and traps unto you, and scourges in your sides, and thorns
|
||
in your eyes, until ye perish from off this good land." [Josh.
|
||
xiii, 13.]
|
||
|
||
Think of a God who boasted that he gave the Jews a land for
|
||
which they did not labor, cities which they did not build, and
|
||
allowed them to eat of olive-yards and vineyards which they did not
|
||
plant. [Josh. xxiv, 13.] Think of a God who murders some of his
|
||
children for the benefit of the rest, and then kills the rest
|
||
because they are not thankful enough. Think of a God who had the
|
||
power to stop the sun and moon, but could not defeat an army that
|
||
had iron chariots. [Judges 1, 19.]
|
||
|
||
Fifty-first. Can we blame the Hebrews for getting tired of
|
||
their God? Never was a people so murdered, starved, stoned, burned,
|
||
deceived, humiliated, robbed, and outraged. Never was there so
|
||
little liberty among men. Never did the meanest king so meddle,
|
||
eavesdrop, spy out, harass, torment, and persecute his people.
|
||
Never was ruler so jealous, unreasonable, contemptible, exacting,
|
||
and ignorant as this God of the Jews. Never was such ceremony, such
|
||
mummery, such staff about bullocks, goats, doves, red heifers,
|
||
lambs, and unleavened dough -- never was such directions about
|
||
kidneys and blood, ashes and fat, about curtains, tongs, fringes,
|
||
ribands, and, brass pins -- never such details for killing of
|
||
animals and men and the sprinkling of blood and the cutting of
|
||
clothes. Never were such unjust laws, such punishments, such damned
|
||
ignorance and infamy!
|
||
|
||
Fifty-second. Is it not wonderful that the creator of all
|
||
worlds, infinite in power and wisdom, could not hold his own
|
||
against the gods of wood and stone? Is it not strange that after he
|
||
had appeared to his chosen people, delivered them from slavery, fed
|
||
them by miracles, opened the sea for a path, led them by cloud and
|
||
fire, and overthrown their pursuers, they still preferred a calf of
|
||
their own making? Is it not beyond belief that this God, by
|
||
statutes and commandments, by punishments and penalties, by rewards
|
||
and promises, by wonders and plagues, by earthquakes and
|
||
pestilence, could not in the least civilize the Jews -- could not
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
25
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
get them beyond a point where they deserved killing? What shall we
|
||
think of a God who gave his entire time for forty years to the work
|
||
of converting three millions of people, and succeeded in getting
|
||
only two men, and not a single woman, decent enough to enter the
|
||
promised land? Was there ever in the history of man so detestable
|
||
an administration of public affairs? Is it possible that God sold
|
||
his children to the king of Mesopotamia; that he sold them to
|
||
Jabin, king of Canaan, to the Philistines, and to the children of
|
||
Ammon? Is it possible that an angel of the Lord devoured unleavened
|
||
cakes and broth with fire that came out of the end of a stick as he
|
||
sat under an oak-tree? Judges vi, 21.] Can it be true that God made
|
||
known his will by making dew fall on wool without wetting the
|
||
ground around it? [Judges vi, 37.] Do you really believe that men
|
||
who lap water like a dog make the best soldiers? [Judges vii, 5.]
|
||
Do you think that a man could hold a lamp in his left hand, a
|
||
trumpet in his right hand, blow his trumpet, shout "the sword of
|
||
the Lord and of Gideon," and break pitchers at the same time?
|
||
[Judges vii, 5.]
|
||
|
||
Fifty-third. Read the story of Jephthah and his daughter, and
|
||
then tell me what you think of a father who would sacrifice his
|
||
daughter to God, and what you think of a God who would receive such
|
||
a sacrifice. This one story should be enough to make every tender
|
||
and loving father hold this book in utter abhorrence. Is it
|
||
necessary, in order to be saved, that one must believe that an
|
||
angel of God appeared unto Manoah in the absence of her husband;
|
||
that this angel afterward went up in a flame of fire; that as a
|
||
result of this visit a child was born whose strength was in his
|
||
hair? a child that made beehives of lions, incendiaries of foxes,
|
||
and had a wife that wept seven days to get the answer to his
|
||
riddle? Will the wrath of God abide forever upon a man for doubting
|
||
the story that Samson killed a thousand men with a new jawbone? Is
|
||
there enough in the Bible to save a soul with this story left out?
|
||
Is hell hungry for those who deny that water gashed from a "hollow
|
||
place" in a dry bone? Is it evidence of a new heart to believe that
|
||
one man turned over a house so large that over three thousand
|
||
people were on the roof? For my part, I cannot believe these
|
||
things, and if my salvation depends upon my credulity I am as good
|
||
as damned already. I cannot believe that the Philistines took back
|
||
the ark with a present of five gold mice, and that thereupon God
|
||
relented. [1 Sam. vi, 4.] I cannot believe that God killed fifty
|
||
thousand men for looking into a box. [1 Sam. vi, 19.] It seems
|
||
incredible, after all the Jews had done, after all their wars and
|
||
victories, even when Saul was king, that there was not among them
|
||
one smith who could make a sword or spear, and that they were
|
||
compelled to go to the Philistines to sharpen every plowshare,
|
||
coulter, and mattock. [1 Sam.xiii, 19, 20.] Can you believe that
|
||
God said to Saul, "Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all
|
||
that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman,
|
||
infant and suckling"? Can you believe that because Saul took the
|
||
king alive after killing every other man, woman, and child, the
|
||
ogre called Jehovah was displeased and made up his mind to hurl
|
||
Saul from the throne and give his place to another? [1 Sam. xv.] I
|
||
cannot believe that the Philistines all ran away because one of
|
||
their number was killed with a stone. I cannot justify the conduct
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
26
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
of Abigail, the wife of Nabal, who took presents to David. David
|
||
hardly did right when he said to this woman, "I have hearkened to
|
||
thy voice, and have accepted thy person." It could hardly have been
|
||
chance that made Nabal so deathly sick next morning and killed him
|
||
in ten days. All this looks wrong, especially as David married his
|
||
widow before poor Nabal was fairly cold."
|
||
|
||
Fifty-fourth. Notwithstanding all I have heard of Katie King,
|
||
I cannot believe that a witch at Endor materialized the ghost of
|
||
Samuel and caused it to appear with a cloak on. [1 Sam. xxviii.] I
|
||
cannot believe that God tempted David to take the census, and then
|
||
gave him his choice of three punishments: First, Seven years of
|
||
famine; Second, Flying three months before their enemies; Third, A
|
||
pestilence of three days; that David chose the pestilence, and that
|
||
God destroyed seventy thousand men. [2 Sam. xxiv.] Why should God
|
||
kill the people for what David did? Is it a sin to be counted? Can
|
||
anything more brutally hellish be conceived? Why should man waste
|
||
prayers upon such a God?
|
||
|
||
Fifty-fifth. Must we admit that Elijah was fed by ravens; that
|
||
they brought him bread and flesh every morning and evening? Must we
|
||
believe that this same prophet could create meal and oil, and
|
||
induce a departed soul to come back and take up its residence once
|
||
more in the body? That he could get rain by praying for it; that he
|
||
could cause fire to burn up a sacrifice and altar, together with
|
||
twelve barrels of water? [1 Kings xviii.] Can we believe that an
|
||
angel of the Lord turned cook and prepared two suppers in one night
|
||
for Elijah, and that the prophet ate enough to last him forty days
|
||
and forty nights? [1 kings xix.] Is it true that when a captain
|
||
with fifty men went after Elijah, this prophet caused fire to come
|
||
down from heaven and consume them all? Should God allow such
|
||
wretches to manage his fire? Is it true that Elijah consumed
|
||
another captain with fifty men in the same way? [2 kings i.] Is it
|
||
a fact that a river divided because the water was struck with a
|
||
cloak? Did a man actually go to heaven in a chariot of fire drawn
|
||
by horses of fire, or was he carried to Paradise by a whirlwind?
|
||
Must we believe, in order to be good and tender fathers and
|
||
mothers, that because some "little children" mocked at an old man
|
||
with a bald head, God -- the same God who said, "Suffer little
|
||
children to come unto me" -- sent two she-bears out of the wood and
|
||
tare forty-two of these babes? Think of the mothers that watched
|
||
and waited for their children. Think of the wailing when these
|
||
mangled ones were found, when they were brought back and pressed to
|
||
the breasts of weeping women. What an amiable gentleman Mr. Elisha
|
||
must have been. [2 Kings ii.]
|
||
|
||
Fifty-sixth. It is hard to believe that a prophet by lying on
|
||
a dead body could make it sneeze seven times; [2 Kings iv.] or that
|
||
being dipped seven times in the Jordan could cure the leprosy. [2
|
||
Kings v.] Would a merciful God curse children; and children's
|
||
children yet unborn, with leprosy for a father's fault? [2 Kings v.
|
||
27.] Is it possible to make iron float in water? [2 Kings vi, 6.]
|
||
Is it reasonable to say that when a corpse touched another corpse
|
||
it came to life? [2 Kings xiii, 21.] Is it a sign that a man wants
|
||
to commit a crime because he refuses to believe that a king had a
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
27
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
boil and that God caused the sun to go backward in heaven so that
|
||
the shadow on a sun-dial went back ten degrees as a sign that the
|
||
aforesaid would get well? [2 Kings xx, 1-2.] Is it true that this
|
||
globe turned backward, that its motion was reversed as a sign to a
|
||
Jewish king? If it did not, this story is false, and that part of
|
||
the Bible is not true even if it is inspired.
|
||
|
||
Fifty-seventh. How did the Bible get lost? [2 Kings xxii, 8.]
|
||
Where was the precious Pentateuch from Moses to Josiah? How was it
|
||
possible for the Jews to get along without the directions as to fat
|
||
and caul and kidney contained in Leviticus? Without that sacred
|
||
book in his possession a priest might take up ashes and carry them
|
||
out without changing his pantaloons. Such mistakes kindled the
|
||
wrath of God.
|
||
|
||
As soon as the Pentateuch was found Josiah began killing
|
||
wizards and such as had familiar spirits.
|
||
|
||
Fifty-eighth, I cannot believe that God talked to Solomon,
|
||
that he visited him in the night and asked him what he should give
|
||
him; I cannot believe that he told ban, "I will give thee riches
|
||
and wealth and honor, such as none of the kings have had before
|
||
thee, neither shall there any after thee have the like." [2 Kings
|
||
i, 7, 12.] If Jehovah said this he was mistaken. It is not true
|
||
that Solomon had fourteen hundred chariots of war in a country
|
||
without roads. It is not true that he made gold and silver at
|
||
Jerusalem as plenteous as stones. There were several kings in his
|
||
day, and thousands since, that could have thrown away the value of
|
||
Palestine without missing the amount. The Holy Land was and is a
|
||
wretched country. There are no monuments, no ruins attesting former
|
||
wealth and greatness. The Jews had no commerce, knew nothing of
|
||
other nations, had no luxuries, never produced a painter, a
|
||
sculptor, architect, scientist, or statesman until after the
|
||
destruction of Jerusalem. As long as Jehovah attended to their
|
||
affairs they had nothing but civil war, plague, pestilence, and
|
||
famine. After he abandoned, and the Christians ceased to persecute
|
||
them, they became the most prosperous of people. Since Jehovah, in
|
||
anger and disgust, cast them away they have produced painters,
|
||
sculptors, scientists, statesmen, composers, and philosophers.
|
||
|
||
Fifty-ninth. I cannot admit that Hiram, the King of Tyre,
|
||
wrote a letter to Solomon in which he admitted that the "God of
|
||
Israel made heaven and earth." [2 Chron. ii, 12.] This King was not
|
||
a Jew. It seems incredible that Solomon had eighty thousand men
|
||
hewing timber for the temple, with seventy thousand bearers of
|
||
burdens, and thirty-six hundred over-seers." [2 Chron. ii, 18.]
|
||
|
||
Sixtieth. I cannot believe that God shuts up heaven and
|
||
prevents rain, or that he sends locusts to devour a land, or
|
||
pestilence to destroy the people. [2 Chron. vii, 13.] I cannot
|
||
believe that God told Solomon that his eyes and heart should
|
||
perpetually be in the house that Solomon had built. [2 Chron. vii,
|
||
16.]
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
28
|
||
|
||
A FEW REASONS FOR DOUBTING
|
||
|
||
THE INSPIRATION OF THE BIBLE.
|
||
|
||
Sixty-first. I cannot believe that Solomon passed all the
|
||
kings of the earth in riches; that all the kings of the earth
|
||
sought his presence and brought presents of silver and gold,
|
||
raiment, harness, spices, and mules -- a rate year by year. [2
|
||
Chron. ix, 22-24.] Is it possible that Shishak, a King of Egypt,
|
||
invaded Palestine with seventy thousand horsemen and twelve hundred
|
||
chariots of war? [2 Chron. xii, 2, 3.] I cannot believe that in a
|
||
battle between Jeroboam and Abijah, the army of Abijah actually
|
||
slew in one day five hundred thousand chosen men. [2 Chron. xiv,
|
||
17.] Does anyone believe that Zerah, the Ethiopian, invaded
|
||
Palestine with a million men? [2 Chron. xiv, 9.] I cannot believe
|
||
that Jehoshaphat had a standing army of nine hundred and sixty
|
||
thousand men. [2 Chron. xvii, 14-19.] I cannot believe that God
|
||
advertised for a liar to act as his messenger. [2 Chron. xviii, 19-
|
||
22.] I cannot believe that King Amaziah did right in the sight of
|
||
the Lord, and that he broke in pieces ten thousand men by casting
|
||
them from a precipice. [2 Chron. xxv, 12.] I cannot think that God
|
||
smote a king with leprosy because he tried to burn incense. [2
|
||
Chron. xxvi, 19.] I cannot think that Pekah slew one hundred and
|
||
twenty thousand men in one day. [2 Chron. xxviii, 6.]
|
||
|
||
|
||
NOTE: This article was printed from manuscript notes found among
|
||
Colonel Ingersoll's papers, evidently written in the early 1880's.
|
||
While much of the argument and criticism will be found embodied in
|
||
his various lectures, magazine articles and contributions to the
|
||
press. it was thought to be too valuable In its present form to be
|
||
left out of a complete edition of his writings.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
**** ****
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Electronic Publishing can defeat censorship.
|
||
|
||
The Bank of Wisdom Inc. is a collection of the most thoughtful,
|
||
scholarly and factual books. These computer books are reprints of
|
||
suppressed books and will cover American and world history; the
|
||
Biographies and writings of famous persons, and especially of our
|
||
nations Founding Fathers. They will include philosophy and
|
||
religion. all these subjects, and more, will be made available to
|
||
the public in electronic form, easily copied and distributed, so
|
||
that America can again become what its Founders intended --
|
||
|
||
The Free Market-Place of Ideas.
|
||
|
||
The Bank of Wisdom is always looking for more of these old,
|
||
hidden, suppressed and forgotten books that contain needed facts
|
||
and information for today. If you have such books please contact
|
||
us, we need to give them back to America.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Bank of Wisdom
|
||
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
||
29
|
||
|