132 lines
6.7 KiB
Plaintext
132 lines
6.7 KiB
Plaintext
ILA file on CCW
|
||
NRA-ILA RESEARCH & INFORMATION FACT SHEET
|
||
No Fire -- Not Even Smoke
|
||
In VPC's Latest Whine About Right-To-Carry
|
||
|
||
Concealed Carry: The Criminal's Companion is an attempt, by a
|
||
tiny anti-gun group that calls itself the Violence Policy Center
|
||
(VPC), to derail the right-to-carry movement currently sweeping
|
||
across the United States. It seeks to discourage passage of
|
||
statewide right-to-carry laws by disparaging Florida's model carry
|
||
law, in effect since 1987.
|
||
|
||
The success of right-to-carry laws -- Florida's in particular
|
||
-- is by now well known, to legislators as well as to the general
|
||
public. According to the most recent data from the FBI Uniform
|
||
Crime Reports, those states with right-to-carry laws have
|
||
significantly lower overall violent and firearm-related violent
|
||
crime per capita rates than other states:
|
||
|
||
Violent crime rate 22% lower
|
||
Firearm violent crime rate 29% lower
|
||
Homicide rate 31% lower
|
||
Firearm homicide rate 38% lower
|
||
Handgun homicide rate 41% lower
|
||
Robbery rate 36% lower
|
||
Firearm robbery rate 38% lower
|
||
Aggravated assault rate 14% lower
|
||
Firearm aggravated assault rate 19% lower
|
||
|
||
Florida's homicide and handgun homicide rates have dropped 22%
|
||
and 29%, since adopting right-to-carry in 1987, even as national
|
||
rates rose 15% and 50%. Anti-gun groups often try to malign
|
||
Florida's right-to-carry law by noting that its total violent crime
|
||
rate has increased since the law took effect, but an examination of
|
||
violent crime data only supports right-to-carry advocates'
|
||
arguments -- since 1987, Florida's violent crime rate has risen less
|
||
(17.7%) than the U.S. as a whole (22.3%), and only 30% of Florida's
|
||
violent crimes involve firearms.
|
||
|
||
Florida's law relates only to the legality of carrying
|
||
firearms already lawfully possessed; it has nothing to do with
|
||
facilitating the acquisition or ownership of firearms by anyone.
|
||
Therefore, the VPC's primary assertion -- that Florida's carry law
|
||
"puts guns into the hands of criminals" -- is preposterous on its
|
||
face and only serves to discredit the group and cast suspicion on
|
||
the motives behind its "study."
|
||
|
||
"What is the point?" seems the logical response to the VPC's
|
||
claim that "criminals do apply for concealed carry licenses."
|
||
Criminals occasionally apply for licenses and Florida rejects their
|
||
applications, just as banks regularly reject loan applications from
|
||
persons with bad credit ratings. Through Sept. 30, 1995, Florida
|
||
has rejected the carry license applications of 702 persons with
|
||
criminal records. The VPC even underscores this fact, by including
|
||
in its "study" a long list of persons alleged to have criminal
|
||
records who, after their carry license applications were rejected,
|
||
wanted their rejections reconsidered.
|
||
|
||
As required by the law, Florida's licensing division quickly
|
||
revokes licenses mistakenly issued to disqualified individuals.
|
||
Florida has revoked 188 licenses mistakenly issued to persons with
|
||
criminal records. Therefore, the VPC's statement, that persons with
|
||
criminal records occasionally receive licenses, is but half the
|
||
story.
|
||
|
||
The overwhelming majority of license applicants and those to
|
||
whom licenses have been issued have been law-abiding citizens. From
|
||
the law's inception, through Sept. 30, 1995, of 310,892
|
||
applications received, only 1,256 -- 0.4% -- have been rejected for
|
||
reasons of criminal histories. Further, citizens to whom carry
|
||
licenses have been issued have proven themselves to be more law-
|
||
abiding than the public generally. Of 303,213 licenses issued, only
|
||
52 -- 0.017% -- have been revoked because license holders committed
|
||
firearm-related crimes, including those occurring in situations in
|
||
which a carry license would not have been required to have a gun
|
||
present. John Russi, of Florida's Division of Licensing, says of
|
||
the 52 disqualified licensees, "When you compare that to the number
|
||
of licenses that were issued, that's very small." This year, in a
|
||
official correspondence to the governor, the Commissioner of the
|
||
Florida Department of Law Enforcement, James T. Moore, provided a
|
||
broader assessment of Florida's carry law, saying "From a law
|
||
enforcement perspective, the licensing process has not resulted in
|
||
problems in the community from people arming themselves with
|
||
concealed weapons. The strict provisions of 790.06, Florida
|
||
Statutes, preclude the licensing of convicted felons, etc., thus
|
||
allowing the permitting of law abiding citizens who do not
|
||
routinely commit crimes or otherwise violate the law."
|
||
|
||
Obviously, the VPC ignores the big picture in Florida,
|
||
manufacturing superficial claims intended to put the spotlight on
|
||
whatever negative exceptions to the rule it believes it has found.
|
||
Fabrications, pretenses and other misleading claims made by various
|
||
anti-gun groups opposed to the right-to-carry apparently have
|
||
little effect on state legislators around the country. Since 1987,
|
||
legislators in 17 other states have voted to adopt right-to-carry
|
||
laws, and one state adopted right-to-carry through a judicial
|
||
ruling. In the first ten months of 1995 alone, seven states adopted
|
||
right-to-carry statutes, while three others voted to improve
|
||
existing laws.
|
||
|
||
1989 -- Oregon, Pennsylvania, W. Virginia and Georgia
|
||
(judicial ruling);
|
||
1990 -- Idaho, Mississippi;
|
||
1991 -- Montana;
|
||
1994 -- Alaska, Arizona, Tennessee and Wyoming;
|
||
1995 -- Arkansas, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Texas,
|
||
Nevada, Utah and Virginia
|
||
|
||
All told, 28 states, 45% of the U.S. population -- 115 million
|
||
Americans -- now have right-to-carry laws.
|
||
|
||
In summary, the VPC's attempt to discredit Florida's law today
|
||
echoes the fear-based campaign anti-gun activists waged in an
|
||
attempt to prevent passage of the law in 1987. At that time, right-
|
||
to-carry opponents claimed Florida would become the "GUNshine
|
||
State," plagued by vigilante justice and "Wild West" shootouts on
|
||
every corner. "[A] pistol-packing citizenry will mean itchier
|
||
trigger fingers....South Florida's climate of smoldering fear would
|
||
flash like napalm when every stranger totes a piece, and every
|
||
mental snap in traffic could lead to the crack of gunfire," one
|
||
carry opponent predicted, while another said that the police would
|
||
have to be armed with machineguns if citizens were allowed to carry
|
||
firearms for protection against criminals. As the evidence proves,
|
||
those predictions were as false in 1987 as the VPC's retrospect is
|
||
today.
|
||
11/6/95
|
||
=+=+=+=+
|
||
This information is provided as a service of the National Rifle
|
||
Association Institute for Legislative Action, Fairfax, VA.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|