199 lines
11 KiB
Plaintext
199 lines
11 KiB
Plaintext
|
|
DO THE NAG HAMMADI WRITING AND DEAD SEA SCROLLS
|
|
CONFIRM MORMONISM
|
|
or
|
|
IS EINAR ERICKSON CONFUSED ?
|
|
|
|
In recent years, Mormon lecturer, Einar C. Erickson, has given
|
|
numerous talks to Mormon church groups concerning the Dead Sea
|
|
Scrolls, Nag Hammadi writings, Mandean Ginza and related Middle East
|
|
finds. These lectures have been taped and widely distributed for use
|
|
in converting the uninformed to Mormonism. Mr Erickson states that the
|
|
writings discovered in the vicinity of Nag Hammadi, Egypt, are one of
|
|
the greatest confirmations of the "truthfulness" of the Mormon church
|
|
that anyone would find anywhere.
|
|
|
|
On one of his tapes, Mr. Erickson boldly declares that: "These
|
|
documents and others leave without doubt evidence positive even on the
|
|
best rules of evidence that an attorney might be able to assemble,
|
|
that this gospel [i.e. the Mormon gospel] is true. You get no credit
|
|
for faith anymore." Mr. Erickson attempts to convince his listeners
|
|
that the writers of the Nag Hammadi were the true Christians, (based
|
|
upon his allegation of their similarity to Mormonism) and that all
|
|
others had slipped off into apostasy.
|
|
|
|
However; the Nag Hammadi writings are of "Gnostic" origin which
|
|
were written during the first to fourth century A.D. The Gnostic
|
|
heretics did cherish both the Old and New testament Scripture, but
|
|
re-interpreted them in terms of a mythological Gnostic Redeemer.
|
|
Gnosticism gave rise to the writings of a number of totally spurious
|
|
apocalyptic books, false gospels and epistles that incorporated their
|
|
own mysticism.
|
|
|
|
Gnosticism was a movement that vigorously contended with Orthodox
|
|
Christianity for supremacy. Writings by the early Church Fathers show
|
|
how widespread and influential Gnosticism was; and it was combatted as
|
|
a lethal threat to the proclamation of the Gospel. The bishops pointed
|
|
out the great gulf between Biblical Christianity and Gnosticism, even
|
|
though the Gnostics made use of Biblical text. It is obvious that
|
|
Paul, the Apostle, knew of the false ideas of Gnosticism, and spoke
|
|
out against such doctrines several times in the Scriptures.
|
|
|
|
The Gnostics believed in the supreme being as an undescribable
|
|
God. He is invisible, incomprehensible, and dwells unbegotten in
|
|
eternal peace. Some names used to describe God and to stress His
|
|
transcendence were "Father of All", "The Unapproachable God", "The
|
|
Unknowable". Such a God could not possibly have direct contact with
|
|
the material world; therefore, He does so through intermediates, each
|
|
one answerable to the other. Each intermediate in descending order is
|
|
less divine and more earthy as the chain nears the material world.
|
|
|
|
Mr. Erickson spellbinds his listeners when he tells them that the
|
|
Nag Hammadi writings confirm the Mormon doctrine of the Heavenly
|
|
Mother! What he fails to tell them is that this Mother God of the Nag
|
|
Hammadi is the "Holy Spirit." Certainly this is in direct conflict
|
|
with the Mormon concept of a Mother God, because in Mormon doctrine,
|
|
the Holy Spirit is a male. The supreme being has a female counterpart
|
|
which emanates from Him. She is known as "Mother of All" or "The Holy
|
|
Spirit."
|
|
|
|
Other emanations that come forth from the Supreme Being in pairs
|
|
are called AEONS; the lowest Aeon being "Sophia Akhamoth", she was so
|
|
full of passion to understand or know God that she fell and was placed
|
|
outside the Pleroma, God's heavenly dwelling. Because of her desire,
|
|
she becomes fertile with a formless monster. This monster (Yaldabaoth,
|
|
Samael or SATAN) is the Demiurge or inferior god who created this
|
|
material world and brought forth man upon it.
|
|
|
|
According to the Gnostic, all matter is evil; therefore, only an
|
|
inferior being could have created it. Satan is the creator-god of this
|
|
earth and of man, and is an evil god. To the Gnostics, Satan is
|
|
Jehovah of the Old Testament! After Jehovah (Satan) creates man and
|
|
breathes life into him, he creates Eve. The demonic forces see the
|
|
beauty of Eve, and proceed to rape her. Through this act, she
|
|
conceives Cain and Abel.
|
|
|
|
Mr. Erickson often refers to the Hypostasis of the Archons of the
|
|
Nag Hammadi and being direct parallel to the Garden of Eden scene of
|
|
the Mormon Temple Ceremony. However, he fails to inform his listeners
|
|
that the Hypostasis of the Archeons tells of the demons raping Eve!
|
|
Nor does he point out that the serpent in the garden is really the
|
|
Holy Spirit coming to give Adam and Eve the "true knowledge." He
|
|
neglects to mention to his listeners that the "god" who comes into the
|
|
garden to ask Adam and Eve what they have done is not the "Heavenly
|
|
Father" but is Satan the arrogant Archon, the evil god. In this
|
|
instance, Mr. Erickson is, at best, mistaken about the facts -- a
|
|
fault which reappears throughout his lectures and tapes.
|
|
|
|
The authors of the Nag Hammadi writings taught a form of re-
|
|
incarnation, and that marriage was evil, because it is of the earth.
|
|
They believed the begetting of children was from Satan, since it
|
|
merely increases the number subjected to the evil angels. Resurrection
|
|
of the flesh is denied by these Gnostics, since earthly flesh is in
|
|
itself evil, and can have no part in the spiritual scheme of God. All
|
|
of these concepts are not confirmations of Mormon doctrine, but are
|
|
direct contradictions of it!
|
|
|
|
Mr. Erickson, looking elsewhere in the Middle East for "proof,"
|
|
tells his audiences that the writings of the Mandaeans of Iraq and
|
|
Iran are (also) a confirmation of Mormonism. His "evidence" for this
|
|
is that they speak of baptism for the dead, baptism by immersion,
|
|
priesthood and baptize in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy
|
|
Ghost. What he fails to mention to them is: according to the
|
|
Mandaeans, Jesus was a rebel and a heretic who led men astray by
|
|
betraying secret doctrine and making religion easier. The Mandaean
|
|
sacred book tells of how Jesus perverted the Scriptures, and that
|
|
Jesus told the Jews that He was the Father, the Son and the Holy
|
|
Ghost. Furthermore, the Mandaean book accuses Jesus perverting baptism
|
|
by baptizing in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost.
|
|
|
|
The Mandaeans were baptized many times throughout their lives.
|
|
They baptized infants; and if an infant died before or during this
|
|
baptism, a clay or dough image was made which they then baptized in
|
|
proxy for that infant. Proxy baptism was also done for an adult who
|
|
died before getting his last minute washings before death. In this
|
|
case, an individual that looked like the deceased was baptized in
|
|
proxy for the dead person.
|
|
|
|
The Mandaeans also had a ceremony of "eating for the dead" to give
|
|
the deceased nourishment for his travels to the heavenly spheres. The
|
|
Mormon people do not baptize infants, do not eat for the dead, nor do
|
|
they have last minute washing rituals before death as the Mandaeans
|
|
did. The Mormon proxy baptisms have less in common with the Mandaean
|
|
baptisms than they do with Catholic infant baptisms, last rites
|
|
ritual, and prayers for the dead. Clearly, the Mandaean concepts of
|
|
Jesus and baptism are in no way similar to Mormon doctrine.
|
|
|
|
Those holding the Mandaean priesthood had to have a clean family
|
|
history for a number of generations, and meet strict physical and
|
|
mental qualifications. They had to be without the slightest physical
|
|
blemish, and be of pure Mandaean blood. A man who was circumcised,
|
|
impotent, or a eunuch could not be a priest for the body must be
|
|
sound, pure, and perfect. If a man was already a priest and he
|
|
received an injury which destroyed his manhood or robbed him of a
|
|
limb, he could no longer officiate as a priest. There are no such
|
|
restrictions within the Mormon priesthoods. The only things in common
|
|
with the Mormon priesthoods and baptism and that of the Mandaean are
|
|
the very words themselves!
|
|
|
|
Mr. Erickson makes false claims about the Dead Sea Scrolls
|
|
community, as well. He states that those at Qumran baptized at the age
|
|
of eight, just as the Mormons do. This is just simply NOT the case.
|
|
They trained young men for their celibate monastic order for about ten
|
|
years before they were baptized into their ranks. This baptism never
|
|
took place before the age of twenty. Mr. Erickson states that the
|
|
people of Qumran were essentially the first "Mormons." However, the
|
|
people at Qumran didn't even believe in marriage! Rather they adopted
|
|
in young men from other Essene groups who married only to beget
|
|
children. By contrast, in Mormonism, marriage is absolutely essential
|
|
to each member's salvation in the Celestial Kingdom of God.
|
|
|
|
Mr. Erickson claims that the Apocryphal books should be used as
|
|
scripture. However, even the Mormon's own "latter day" revelation
|
|
disagrees with him. In the introductory heading of Section 91 of the
|
|
Doctrine and Covenants, it declares specifically that the apocryphal
|
|
books are NOT to be accepted as scripture. Beyond that built-in
|
|
contradiction, lies the fact that one need only to read some of these
|
|
apocrypha for himself to quickly discover their singular lack of
|
|
inspiration.
|
|
|
|
For example, two "Gospels" portray the life of the young Jesus,
|
|
allegedly covering the "silent" years skipped over in the Bible. The
|
|
book, "The First Gospel of the Infancy of Jesus" portrays Jesus as a
|
|
spoiled despot who curses another child for bumping into him, and a
|
|
schoolmaster who was going to discipline Him for refusing to answer a
|
|
question. After these two people are killed at Jesus' command, Joseph
|
|
tells Mary, "we will not allow him to go out of the house; for every
|
|
one who displeases him is killed." In Thomas' "Gospel of the Infancy
|
|
of Jesus Christ", we see Jesus causing the withering of hands,
|
|
blindness, and again, death. This is clearly not the Jesus Christ of
|
|
the Bible!
|
|
|
|
The conclusion is inescapable -- the claims by Mr. Erickson (and
|
|
consequently other Mormons) that the Mormon doctrine is "exonerated"
|
|
by the findings in the Middle East is totally without foundation.
|
|
Mormon doctrine is not confirmed by these different religious sects,
|
|
it is contradicted by them! It is apparent that these claims are just
|
|
another chapter in the long history of false archeological boasts made
|
|
by Mormons in the past.
|
|
|
|
NOTE: A full and completely documented study of Mr. Erickson's
|
|
scholarship regarding the above topics has been written by Mrs.
|
|
Melaine Layton entitled: The Truth About the Dead Sea Scrolls and the
|
|
Nag Hammadi Writings in Reference to Mormonism. For further
|
|
information, please write to the office:
|
|
|
|
Computers For Christ - San Jose.
|
|
|
|
For more information see below:
|
|
|
|
This file has been brought to you by the ministry of the;
|
|
|
|
Southern Maryland Christian Information Service BBS, (SMCIS)
|
|
(301) 862-3160 HST
|
|
|
|
P.O. Box 463
|
|
California, MD 20619
|
|
|
|
Sysop: Buggs Bugnon
|