820 lines
37 KiB
Plaintext
820 lines
37 KiB
Plaintext
|
||
Via NY Transfer News Collective * All the News that Doesn't Fit
|
||
|
||
LOVE AND RAGE
|
||
Electronic Edition
|
||
|
||
FEBRUARY/MARCH 1993
|
||
Part 4
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
A FEW WORDS ABOUT POLITICS
|
||
|
||
Love and Rage is a bi-monthly anarchist newspaper intended to
|
||
foster revolutionary anti-authoritarian activism in North America
|
||
and build a more effective anarchist movement. We will provide
|
||
coverage of social struggles, world events, anarchist actions and
|
||
cultures of resistance. We will support the struggles of oppressed
|
||
peoples around the world for control over their own lives. Anarchy
|
||
offers the broadest possible critique of domination, making
|
||
possible a framework for unity in all struggles for liberation. We
|
||
seek to understand the systems we live under for ourselves, and
|
||
reject any pre-packaged ideology. Anarchism is a living body of
|
||
theory and practice connected directly to the lived experiences of
|
||
oppressed people fighting for their own liberation. We anticipate
|
||
the radical and on-going revision of our ideas as a necessary part
|
||
of any revolutionary process.
|
||
|
||
A set of working papers, encompassing the current debate about our
|
||
Political Statement is available from
|
||
|
||
Jodi, c/o AA
|
||
PO Box 10007
|
||
Columbus, OH 43201
|
||
|
||
For more information about these and other internal debates,
|
||
subscribe to our Discussion Bulletin. [See page 9.]
|
||
|
||
-30-
|
||
|
||
CHANGES AT LOVE AND RAGE
|
||
|
||
by Ms. Tommy Lawless & Dema Crassy
|
||
|
||
THE LOVE & RAGE ANNUAL CONFERENCE in Atlanta, November 26-29, was
|
||
a veritable hotbed of actions, parties, workshops, forums, and
|
||
caucuses. NOT! It was a seventy-two hour sweaty meeting marathon.
|
||
But many changes were agreed upon: changes in the paper and
|
||
changes in the direction of the Network. As the new
|
||
co-facilitators for Love and Rage, we're here to tell you a little
|
||
bit about those changes.
|
||
|
||
CHANGES IN THE PAPER
|
||
|
||
Like any radical project, Love & Rage has had some financial
|
||
difficulties. Because we couldn't gauge when or how much money we
|
||
would have, it was hard to come up with an accurate production
|
||
schedule. Naturally, that hampered coming out monthly: seven
|
||
issues the first year, ten issues the second year, seven issues
|
||
the third year. In an attempt to keep on an accurate schedule this
|
||
year, the paper will be coming out every two months, and will be
|
||
twenty pages long, rather than sixteen.
|
||
|
||
You've probably already noticed that the cover page has changed to
|
||
magazine format. This gives an extra page for text and potentially
|
||
allows the newspaper to be carried by more distributors (because
|
||
of the way it sits on a magazine rack).
|
||
|
||
The Production Group (PG) will be more aggressive about soliciting
|
||
articles from a wider range of people. We'll be in contact with
|
||
the supporting groups, the new Regional Contacts, (more on those
|
||
later in the article), and anybody we know, to get a better
|
||
representation of the type of work that goes on in the Network.
|
||
Also, a zany new box will go into the paper each issue, begging
|
||
you to please, please, please send us info, articles, photos, and
|
||
graphics.
|
||
|
||
The On Gogol Boulevard (OGB) page, which was produced by Neither
|
||
East Nor West (NENW), will no longer appear in the paper. Instead
|
||
of OGB, we'll be running an International Page, which will seek to
|
||
cover news from our contacts all over the globe, including
|
||
continued coverage from the East. Members of NENW plan to continue
|
||
contributing to the paper and working in the PG. [Anarchy: A
|
||
Journal of Desire Armed will carry the OGB feature. See page 14
|
||
for their address.]
|
||
|
||
At the conference, Anarchist Youth Federation (AYF) members
|
||
outside of New York complained about their lack of representation
|
||
on the (New York produced) AYF page in the paper. Therefore, the
|
||
AYF feature has been temporarily suspended. There is an open
|
||
invitation to the Federation to take up production of the page
|
||
again, as soon as they come up with a process they're happy with.
|
||
|
||
Although the New York-Anarchist Black Cross (ABC) group, which has
|
||
been producing the ABC page in the paper, will be taking a six
|
||
month vacation, the page will continue. This issue's ABC page was
|
||
produced by the NY group, but, for the next two issues, the page
|
||
will be produced by the PG. ABC chapters in other cities have
|
||
agreed to contribute to this feature.
|
||
|
||
News coverage will broaden to include more world events and
|
||
anarchist analyses of them.
|
||
|
||
The Spanish section of the paper will carry more articles from
|
||
Spanish- speaking communities, some of which will be translated
|
||
for the English section. Groups in Mexico have already committed
|
||
to send in a lot of material and are working towards autonomously
|
||
producing a Spanish edition of Love & Rage, and perhaps the
|
||
Spanish section.
|
||
|
||
Last year's Political Statement has been suspended. We acknowledge
|
||
in the paper that we are currently debating the future of the
|
||
Political Statement. This debate includes questions of whether or
|
||
not to have a statement, the content and scope of our statement,
|
||
what kind of statement (if any) should go into the paper. We are
|
||
making available a set of working papers, which include all
|
||
previous years' statements, all new proposed statements, and all
|
||
dialogue around this published in the Disco Bull on an ongoing
|
||
basis. For a copy of these working papers, write to the Info-Share
|
||
Coordinator. Send a small donation if you can. [See page 8]
|
||
|
||
CHANGES IN THE NETWORK
|
||
|
||
We, Dema Crassy and Ms. Tommy Lawless, have been elected as
|
||
co-facilitators for the Network this year. We bid a fond farewell
|
||
to Matt Black, who did a superb job these last eighteen months.
|
||
Although a similar arrangement for two facilitators was attempted
|
||
in 1991, the second person didn't work out. So this is the first
|
||
year with two people doing the facilitator job, and this is the
|
||
first year with WIMMIN in the job.
|
||
|
||
Out of the conference came a general commitment to decentralize
|
||
the Network. This, in part, means creating regional structures
|
||
that would both strengthen local groups and provide a means for
|
||
sharing resources. There was a sentiment that the regional
|
||
structures should grow naturally and be self-defined. For this and
|
||
other reasons, no concrete proposal was adopted at the conference
|
||
as to how this decentralization process would occur. Proposals and
|
||
processes will be discussed and developed in the Disco Bull over
|
||
the next year. Nine coordinators were elected to help us
|
||
communicate better as a Network and to help share the burden of
|
||
work. Four of those nine elected are located outside of the NYC
|
||
area. The positions include: International Communications, Network
|
||
Communications, Interorganizational Communications, Fund-Raising,
|
||
Finance, Disco Bull [Discussion Bulletin two people], Info-Share,
|
||
and Regions. Also, an informal group of people volunteered to be
|
||
temporary Regional Organizing Contacts for their areas. [See
|
||
sidebar.]
|
||
|
||
We need more. How 'bout you?
|
||
|
||
The Coordinating Group (CG) of (now) eleven members, including one
|
||
political prisoner Ojore N. Lutalo was elected. The CG is
|
||
continuing this year for immediate decision-making, but with the
|
||
goal of the Network Council (NC) becoming the main decision-making
|
||
body for the following year. The NC, made up of two delegates from
|
||
each supporting group, will meet in Washington DC this April 23 -
|
||
24. If you belong to a supporting group, send us the names of two
|
||
voting delegates who will attend. (Everyone with a genuine
|
||
interest in the project is welcome to come.)
|
||
|
||
An Urgent Response Network (URN) phone/fax/e-mail tree is in the
|
||
process of being established in order to mobilize people in the
|
||
Network quickly in emergency situations. If you're interested in
|
||
being a part of the URN, contact the Network Communications
|
||
Coordinator. The CG is empowered to decide when the URN will be
|
||
activated. If you wish to activate the URN, call any CG member
|
||
with the information.
|
||
|
||
The Disco Bull, our internal discussion bulletin which comes out
|
||
every six to eight weeks, has been an effective means of
|
||
communication for the Network and will continue this year. In
|
||
addition, a Network Bulletin will be dashing out hot and timely
|
||
newsflashes every two weeks! (Several issues are out already.) The
|
||
Network Bulletin really speeds up communications and saves on
|
||
phone bills. Individuals and groups who send in a monthly pledge
|
||
receive both bulletins, periodic mailings, and a year's
|
||
subscription to the paper.
|
||
|
||
Unfortunately, all this paper and postage costs money. The Disco
|
||
Bull costs about $600 an issue to produce and mail out. People who
|
||
don't pledge, but want to receive these bulletins and other
|
||
periodic mailings, will be required to pay a sliding scale
|
||
communications fee of $20 - $50 per year.
|
||
|
||
The Network adopted quite a few strategy and action projects for
|
||
this year. The Wimmin's Health Tour will happen this year. [See
|
||
page 4.] We will endorse and have an open anarchist contingent to
|
||
the Queer March on Washington in April. [See page 3.] A proposal
|
||
to produce a Direct Action Manual was supported and endorsed [See
|
||
page 9.] A working group is contacting ABC groups, with the goal
|
||
of forming an ABC Network. An Info-Share project is underway to
|
||
act as a clearinghouse and to compile information for possible
|
||
publication and internal education. Send any info you'd like to
|
||
share to Jodi, the project coordinator.
|
||
|
||
In addition to the above projects, suggested topics of ongoing
|
||
discussion for the Disco Bull this year include: queer issues and
|
||
politics, strategies for anti-fascist organizing, political
|
||
statement ideas and controversies, and debating the structure of
|
||
the Network.
|
||
|
||
The next Love and Rage Network Annual Conference will be in San
|
||
Diego this summer.
|
||
|
||
For more complete information and further discussion about these
|
||
projects, proposals, and ongoing debates, subscribe to the Disco
|
||
Bull and Network Bulletin. [See page 9.]
|
||
|
||
Thanks everybody, for stopping by.
|
||
|
||
by Rachel Rinaldo
|
||
|
||
[Not Published in the printed Feb/Mar Issue, but worth reading ]
|
||
|
||
-30-
|
||
|
||
|
||
CHANGES: ABC AND OGB PAGES
|
||
|
||
[Note: This article appeared on the ABC Page, which has been
|
||
autonomously produced by ABC - New York. ]
|
||
|
||
|
||
AS OF THIS ISSUE THERE ARE TWO MAJOR CHANGES IN TWO OF THE
|
||
AUTONOMOUS SECTIONS, THE ABC AND OGB PAGES. THIS IS THE LAST TIME
|
||
THE ABC page will be done by NY ABC, which for all intents and
|
||
purposes no longer exists.
|
||
|
||
When we were approached at the inception of the paper to write a
|
||
prisoner support section there were 5 of us who were to work on
|
||
the project. For more than a year now I have been doing it by
|
||
myself. It's impossible for me to continue. The production group
|
||
will be including prisoner news in the paper, and I trust that
|
||
they will do a good job with it. In a few months I hope to be
|
||
able to contribute to what ever they have going.
|
||
|
||
Thanks to everyone who wrote, especially the prisoners who took
|
||
the time to contribute to the ABC page and the paper. Input from
|
||
prisoners, like Larry Giddings, and their supporters made the
|
||
project more than just a sterile news sheet. Also, thanks to
|
||
everyone who responded to our requests for letters and calls on
|
||
behalf of individual prisoners.
|
||
|
||
The second change is definitely one for the worst. The On Gogol
|
||
Boulevard section, edited by Neither East Nor West is gone. The
|
||
OGB page , which carried news and networking info, focused on the
|
||
Ex- Eastern block but also printed news on US political prisoners,
|
||
Green movements in Cuba, etc. OGB has always offered itself as a
|
||
networking tool to Easterners and has run many documents and
|
||
letters on their behalf.
|
||
|
||
The decision to discontinue the OGB section was reached by
|
||
consensus at the recent Love and Rage Network conference in
|
||
Atlanta. The feeling, as I understand it, was that the focus
|
||
needed to broaden, from primarily Eastern news to more of a world
|
||
view. I agree that the paper should carry more global news. But
|
||
then why not have both? If space is an issue, why not rotate
|
||
sections?
|
||
|
||
The loss of OGB as an autonomous section of the paper is serious.
|
||
This is a big loss to the Easterners who used the page for
|
||
out-reach; they were not given any notice as to the discontinuance
|
||
of the section. It's also a loss to the prisoner support groups
|
||
who used the information , and the folks who put together the
|
||
demo, strikes, and campaigns that got coverage on the page.
|
||
|
||
- Neither East Nor West has a years-long history of prisoner
|
||
support.
|
||
|
||
- They organized demos at the Polish embassy in support of draft
|
||
resisters.
|
||
|
||
- They helped free anti-war activist & Moscow Trust Group
|
||
member Nina Kovalenko from a Soviet mental hospital.
|
||
|
||
- They campaigned for the release of Soviet prisoner Sergei
|
||
Troyanski and US prisoner Rainbow Hawk, both arrested on
|
||
fraudulent drug charges in politicized trials involving their
|
||
Rainbow affiliations/Peace activism.
|
||
|
||
- When several East German left-oppositionists, including
|
||
Wolfgang Templin, were arrested, they immediately picketed the
|
||
East German Embassy, in conjunction with protests in Europe,
|
||
culminating in their release.
|
||
|
||
Neither East Nor West is one of the few anarchist groups who have
|
||
been around for years, consistently getting results through their
|
||
actions. They had access to info no one else had, and to groups
|
||
no one else had contact with. Their contribution to the paper was
|
||
important.
|
||
|
||
The OGB folks will be contributing info to the paper in the
|
||
future, but will no longer have autonomy, or editorial control.
|
||
They can't offer their contacts the use of the page space.
|
||
|
||
The cancellation of the OGB page was a mistake I hope it returns.
|
||
|
||
-30-
|
||
|
||
Where's AYF?
|
||
|
||
If you've read Love and Rage before, you might notice that this
|
||
issue has no Anarchist Youth Federation page. AYF is currently
|
||
trying to develop a more-collective way to produce the page. As
|
||
soon as they come up with a process they're happy with, we'll
|
||
start running the page again.
|
||
|
||
For more info:
|
||
AYF Discussion Bulletin
|
||
PO Box 365
|
||
NY, NY 10013
|
||
|
||
-30-
|
||
|
||
|
||
LETTERS TO LOVE AND RAGE, FEB/MARCH 93
|
||
|
||
|
||
L&R GIVES BAD HEADLINE
|
||
|
||
Dear Love and Rage,
|
||
|
||
As a gay man, I've been annoyed all my life by hearing people say
|
||
that such-and-such unpleasant thing sucks. This common piece of
|
||
slang contributes a steady drip of anti-gay prejudice into all our
|
||
lives, mostly by people who never think about the meaning of what
|
||
they say.
|
||
|
||
The dictionary defines suck in the slang sense as to be extremely
|
||
or disgustingly unpleasant or objectionable. "Disgustingly" makes
|
||
the connection to cocksucking. That sucks gets its emotional force
|
||
from the idea of cocksucking as dirty and disgusting. Of course,
|
||
when we say this we're not usually thinking directly about
|
||
cocksucking. Like many terms in the language, this one has lost
|
||
its direct connection with the idea that lies behind it. But if
|
||
you think about sucks as a figure of speech, what is it referring
|
||
to? There are several different slang uses of sucking or sucker
|
||
(never give a sucker an even break; he comes sucking around when
|
||
he needs a favor; that sucks). With a little thought they can be
|
||
traced to different actions. The idea of sucking as degrading,
|
||
disgusting, or unpleasant probably relates to cocksucking. The
|
||
idea is not just that the act is disgusting, but that the person
|
||
who does it is disgusting too. Someone will say of a particularly
|
||
nasty task, That job was a real cocksucker, or for short, That job
|
||
sucked.
|
||
|
||
So I was bothered to see Love and Rage, which ought to know
|
||
better, use sucks (spelling changed) in two headlines in the most
|
||
recent issue (Sept.-Oct.-Nov. 1992): Skool Suks, and on the same
|
||
page Oolskay Uksay. I'm not accusing anybody of sexism; nobody was
|
||
thinking cocksucking when they wrote the headline. Unfortunately,
|
||
nobody was thinking at all when they wrote the headline, and
|
||
that's what I'd like to change. I'm not asking us to PC each other
|
||
to death. I'd be quite happy if people were just to think about
|
||
the possible connections between the slang term and the actual act
|
||
that most of us approve of (whether or not we engage in it), and
|
||
draw whatever conclusions seem best.
|
||
|
||
Love (predominantly),
|
||
Chris Hobson
|
||
New York, NY
|
||
|
||
*
|
||
|
||
MAKING PUCKS A THREAT AGAIN
|
||
|
||
Hey,
|
||
|
||
The Profane Existence Collective challenges you hapless Love and
|
||
<R>Ragers to a game of hockey any day (street or ice) to determine
|
||
once and for all who is the coolest anarchist paper in North
|
||
America. Not that we really don't already know, heh heh.
|
||
|
||
Please get mohawks, especially Matt,
|
||
|
||
Joel
|
||
Profane Existence
|
||
Minneapolis, MN
|
||
*
|
||
|
||
RIGOROUS DEBATE
|
||
|
||
Paul,
|
||
|
||
I'm glad you wrote your letter in response to In the Belly of the
|
||
Beast. I have two things to say in response to your letter. The
|
||
first is about what you wrote, and the second is about the fact
|
||
that you wrote.
|
||
|
||
You wrote that while you don't oppose confrontational politics,
|
||
you think it is necessary to bear in mind, particularly when not
|
||
in a revolutionary moment, that the ideological component of
|
||
conflict and order function such that confrontations and actions
|
||
can be counterproductive, misunderstood, or authoritarian, even as
|
||
they are perceived as revolutionary acts by some.
|
||
|
||
I don't have your letter in front of me as I write this, so I hope
|
||
I'm not misrepresenting your statements. Are we on the same
|
||
wavelength? I hope so, because, if we are, I agree with you about
|
||
this and commend your addition of this important and necessary
|
||
dimension to the recent debate about action.
|
||
|
||
I'm glad if your letter is a sign that we can start to move beyond
|
||
the armchair anarchist vs. cult of action dichotomy and begin to
|
||
transcend the moralistic view that actions have absolute meaning
|
||
and inherent effects (e.g. this is revolutionary while that is
|
||
bourgeois, or this is heretical while that is holy) in favor of a
|
||
relativistic, social definition of actions as playing this role in
|
||
this circumstance and having this or that effect then. (If I were
|
||
a little less abstract here, we could title this Streetfighting:
|
||
Utopian and Scientific. Get it? Little Engels joke.) I would hope
|
||
we could begin to think more strategically and less prejudicially
|
||
about using action instrumentally to effectively reach the goals
|
||
we seek, even as these goals develop and change dialectically
|
||
through our experiences with action. I'm being vague, but its a
|
||
start.
|
||
|
||
I guess it's useful to note something about the context of the
|
||
argument I was making. Its understandable that you took it as an
|
||
argument against the passiveists, since just about every
|
||
pro-action argument in the anti-authoritarian movement seems to be
|
||
just that; however, my arguments came from another context. I
|
||
wrote it as an argument against a different dichotomy. It was
|
||
given as a speech at the Class War conference last year, meant to
|
||
stress that we live in a global economic system and must each
|
||
struggle solidly from our own position in that system, whether
|
||
that means from the elite capitalist core of the empire, from the
|
||
advanced industrial working class, from the elite of the
|
||
tricontinent, or from the periphery in any state. I was writing
|
||
this in argument with those who said revolution is about class or
|
||
race, who said we have to have a working-class revolution or
|
||
support national liberation struggles. In part, too, I was trying
|
||
to articulate something about the specific location of
|
||
middle-class anti-capitalists in the United States and Europe. I
|
||
guess it only matters to point out the difference made by the
|
||
context (the emphasis on confrontation you perceived as compared
|
||
with the emphasis on class I meant), because that gives me a nice
|
||
chance to warn, once more, against the dangers of transplanting
|
||
politics. (Ah, see what an opportunist I am?!)
|
||
|
||
The second thing I wanted to say in response to your letter has
|
||
nothing to do with what you wrote. I was excited about your letter
|
||
well before I read it. We are not living in a revolutionary moment
|
||
in this country. In such a (revolutionary) moment, the immediate
|
||
reality of everyday lives would force on our thinking, as
|
||
revolutionaries, a rigor and depth uncommon in more settled times.
|
||
It is one of the tasks of a revolutionary movement to create the
|
||
conditions for revolutionary moments to result in the emergence of
|
||
a better society rather than in a new and greater dominance and
|
||
oppression. One of the ways such a movement can do this is by
|
||
demanding of itself that it approach in its thinking the rigor and
|
||
depth of the revolutionary moment. To me, this is one of the main
|
||
purposes of a revolutionary paper. Without it, many are drawn to
|
||
left parties precisely because these parties try to, and sometimes
|
||
do, provide this stimulus and this intellectual community. I watch
|
||
people go to these parties with a combination of sadness, disgust,
|
||
and a small bit of understanding. Afterward, I wander around in a
|
||
state of despair that the anarchist/radical movement can't seem to
|
||
fulfill these functions well enough. I am heartened and happily
|
||
reminded by your letter that it is not necessary to belong to a
|
||
party to have constructive, rigorous debate. Thanks.
|
||
|
||
Kate Star
|
||
Chicago, IL
|
||
|
||
*
|
||
|
||
WOMEN AND CLASS WAR
|
||
|
||
Dear Love and Rage,
|
||
|
||
This is a late reply to Kate Star's article on the Class War
|
||
International Conference in a recent issue of Love and Rage (Vol.
|
||
3, #4), late because I only saw the article recently.
|
||
|
||
Although the introduction was one of the most accurate accounts of
|
||
the Class War Federation I've seen, I would like to refute nearly
|
||
everything else in the article. Here goes,
|
||
|
||
Because your political analysis does not include an understanding
|
||
of class you are doomed to go round in circles for eternity. The
|
||
reaction of the white working class to immigration is not, as you
|
||
say, central to determining the power in the hands of the right!
|
||
Racism exists only to serve capitalism, and is used by them to
|
||
divide our class, just as is sexism, homophobia, etc. You argue
|
||
that German reunification has as one of its functions to provide a
|
||
native and white workforce to the country. It could be more
|
||
realistically argued that German reunification was more along the
|
||
lines of uniting Europe economically. The state itself doesn't
|
||
give a toss on how many black people are in the country, only in
|
||
so far as this can be used to promote division within the working
|
||
class. The only color the state is interested in is the green
|
||
colour of currency.
|
||
|
||
As for your being offended by a male comrade at a conference
|
||
asking whether or not you were coming to a social that evening,
|
||
you only had to tell him to fuck off, as I would have done had I
|
||
seen it as an offence, rather than condemning the whole of Class
|
||
War as a bunch of revolting sexists. Your attitude to women
|
||
involved with Class War is particularly patronizing. Women members
|
||
of Class War are involved in the Federation at all levels: paper
|
||
group editorial, Heavy Stuff editorial, the lot.
|
||
|
||
American anarchists in particular seem not to understand the basis
|
||
of Class War. Our organisation is made up of working class people,
|
||
including many survivors of lifestylist anarchist politics. It is
|
||
a class struggle organisation whose main aims are to promote
|
||
revolutionary ideas and understanding whilst working alongside the
|
||
rest of our class (75% of the population!). You refer to the
|
||
inappropriateness of simplistic class-based organising... oh dear,
|
||
oh dear, oh dear. When I'm selling Class War in the town, and a
|
||
pensioner buys a copy, or someone on their lunch hour from work,
|
||
or kids stopping to make cheeky comments, or an upper class
|
||
hysteric takes the time to be offended, I know I'm going in the
|
||
right direction away from any lifestylist anarchist ghetto and
|
||
|
||
Towards Revolution!
|
||
Julie
|
||
Tyneside Class War member
|
||
UK
|
||
|
||
*
|
||
|
||
KILLING RAPISTS?
|
||
|
||
Dear Love and Rage,
|
||
|
||
Chiquita La Pistolera wrote in the last issue (Vol. 3, #6) of
|
||
Class War's exclusion of wimmin from their call to revolution.
|
||
The only women's issue they raised, she comments, is rape, which
|
||
they call an anti-social crime and advocate killing rapists.
|
||
|
||
I'm taking a deep breath because I have a lot to say. O.K. First
|
||
off, what is rape? It is an act of terrorist violence against
|
||
women. The definition of rape which we use (forced intercourse) is
|
||
only one kind of rape, the most common in European nations.
|
||
Elsewhere, genital mutilation, forced marriage, purdah, etc. are
|
||
more common acts of terrorism.
|
||
|
||
Rape is so common that if every rapist were executed, the
|
||
Holocaust would pale in comparison. We are talking about the
|
||
system of patriarchy when we speak of rape. We are not talking
|
||
about a handful of maundering lunatics.
|
||
|
||
Killing is a patriarchal solution; it is not a revolution; it does
|
||
not value living. Passivity too (as in passive resistance) opposes
|
||
the revolutionary's basic agenda: life. Audre Lorde has written:
|
||
the master's tools will never dismantle the master's house. We
|
||
need to learn this; as anarchists and feminists we understand that
|
||
we need to overthrow the oppressive systems as well as the
|
||
individuals who enforce the systems. We know that the revolution
|
||
begins when we free ourselves from state/family/religion/language/
|
||
class/school teaching of obedience and submission and passivity.
|
||
The master's solutions to problems are part of the master's
|
||
system. Rape is part of (inherent in) patriarchy. So is killing.
|
||
|
||
I am an advocate of self-defense, absolutely. I would be hard
|
||
pressed to deny the validity of an attentat against Bush and the
|
||
Supreme Court (except the media would make them into Great
|
||
Martyrs). But I question whether a revolution fought in blood can
|
||
overcome the ideology of war which supports the oppressor.
|
||
|
||
Two other points I wanted to make: first, by excluding half the
|
||
human race, Class War dooms itself to failure; second the
|
||
assumption that class is the oppression around which the oppressed
|
||
will rally, so the-we-might-as well-forget-the-other-oppressions
|
||
ideology was already pass<73> in the 19th century. In the last couple
|
||
of issues, challenges have been thrown to the feminist movement to
|
||
cease all alliances with the fanatical right-wing (i.e.,
|
||
anti-porn). Radical men who exclude women , all people of color,
|
||
gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and organize in patriarchal ways also
|
||
have allied themselves with the right- wing. We must recognize and
|
||
fight this. Those who are against us cannot stand in solidarity
|
||
with us.
|
||
|
||
Whew...that's eeenuf for one letter.
|
||
|
||
In Solidarity,
|
||
|
||
Jackie Goldmyn
|
||
Albany, NY
|
||
|
||
*
|
||
|
||
KILLING FASCISTS?
|
||
|
||
Dear Love and Rage,
|
||
|
||
Although the two page spread on German anti-fascism in the last
|
||
issue (Vol. 3, #7) was generally good, it was marred in a couple
|
||
of places. First of all, the headline Nazis Raus Aus
|
||
Deutschland!, which translates as Nazis get out of Germany!, has
|
||
never been a German antifascist slogan. Even the chant Nazis
|
||
Raus! (Nazis get out) has been criticized by some who ask, and
|
||
where should they go? Antifascists are internationalists; they do
|
||
not want to export German fascists to cause problems elsewhere.
|
||
|
||
Second, I find the graphic The only good fascist is a dead one
|
||
very problematic. Indeed, we should fight fascism with any means
|
||
necessary. In Germany this can include antifascist street patrols
|
||
who beat the fascists off the streets.
|
||
|
||
Killing fascists is not necessary. At the present, it would be a
|
||
dangerous escalation, a bad strategy. Furthermore, we must always
|
||
take care to uphold our humanity. Using deadly force against
|
||
fascists might at some point be appropriate, but it would not be
|
||
desirable. The average fasho skin in east Germany is not a
|
||
dedicated nazi, but a working class youth who has been victimized
|
||
by the East German society and state, by their family, and now by
|
||
west German capital. This is not an excuse; but to call for their
|
||
death, with blood in our eyes, only serves to brutalize us.
|
||
|
||
Thirdly, in the article by Jan Kraker, Nazis are compared with
|
||
cancer. This type of dehumanizing the enemy is the same used
|
||
during the Third Reich against Jews and communists. We must be
|
||
very careful of these terms. If we convince ourselves that our
|
||
enemy is inhuman, on the level of a germ or a disease, what is to
|
||
prevent us from advocating the torture and barbarisms practiced by
|
||
Hitler, Stalin and Pol Pot? We must never loose sight of our
|
||
humanity.
|
||
|
||
An antifascist
|
||
|
||
*
|
||
|
||
LYIN' ABOUT ZION
|
||
|
||
Dear Anarchist Comrades,
|
||
|
||
Your editorial note to my letter on Zionism featured in the Jan.
|
||
92 issue of Love and Rage, in which you stated that the
|
||
Lubavitcher Jewish sect is not Zionist, obscures the fact that the
|
||
Lubavitchers are intimately, actively involved in bolstering the
|
||
most reactionary institutions and policies of the Zionist state.
|
||
|
||
Under the command of their fuhrer Rabbi Schneerson, these
|
||
authoritarian fanatics have not only supported Zionism's
|
||
imperialist wars of aggression, they regret that more Arab
|
||
territory hasn't been seized. They reject all so-called land for
|
||
peace deals, and consider it an abomination to even think about
|
||
granting any kind of autonomy to the Palestinians.
|
||
|
||
Although disdainful of Zionism's secular establishment, the
|
||
Lubavitchers nevertheless permeate Israeli society and politics.
|
||
They spearheaded the recent unsuccessful effort to change Israel's
|
||
Nazi-like Law of Return so as to allow only Orthodox-sponsored
|
||
conversions to Judaism. And the Lubavitchers are effective power
|
||
brokers in the Israeli Knesset, acting to force Shamir's fascistic
|
||
Likud bloc even further to the right.
|
||
|
||
In contrast, genuinely non-Zionist Orthodox Jews, like the
|
||
Satmars, are explicit and consistent in their rejection of
|
||
Zionism's statist edifice.
|
||
|
||
Funded primarily by American Jews, the Lubavitchers rake in well
|
||
over $100 million in donations yearly - hardly indicative of an
|
||
oppressed community.
|
||
|
||
The failure of Love and Rage to bring these facts to the attention
|
||
of its readers is simply one facet of its overall failure, or
|
||
refusal, to unambiguously address the problem of Zionism - an
|
||
oversight which for some reason seems to typify far too many
|
||
anarchist publications and anarchists in general.
|
||
|
||
Love and Rage has no direct anti-Zionist assertion in its
|
||
Political Statement; yet therein specifies opposition to
|
||
"anti-Jewish racism" - a curious bit of phraseology which implies
|
||
that Jews are a race (strangely enough, the position of Nazis and
|
||
right-wing Zionists alike), rather than, as most anti-racists
|
||
would agree, an amalgam of ethnic groups and individuals accepting
|
||
or acknowledging a heritage of certain religious and/or cultural
|
||
traditions. Moreover, anti-Jewish bigotry can manifest itself as a
|
||
purely religious phenomenon, in addition to its more usual
|
||
expression as misdirected anger over socio-economic inequities,
|
||
and its less common but most virulent appearance as ideological
|
||
racism.
|
||
|
||
The sickening antics of David Duke and of a relative handful of
|
||
thuggish Klansmen and neo-Nazis frequently seem to be the primary
|
||
focus of attention for much of the anarchist press and for many
|
||
anarchists personally; and granted, these racist freaks do pose a
|
||
danger, for their hatemongering can and often does have murderous
|
||
consequences. As a present threat and an even greater possible
|
||
future menace, they can not and must not be ignored. However, the
|
||
racist right, either here or abroad, is a feeble fart compared to
|
||
the dynamo of international Zionism, which is backed by wealthy
|
||
Jewish elitists and closely allied with the ruling class in the US
|
||
and in other countries.
|
||
|
||
No existing fascist movement so effectively dominates its ethnic
|
||
constituents, molds so favorable a public image, or projects its
|
||
military and political power around the world with such stealth as
|
||
does Zionism.
|
||
|
||
While many anarchists remain fixated on comparatively small
|
||
numbers of highly visible (and usually ineffectual) white racist
|
||
loudmouths, the Zionists, hiding behind religious respectability,
|
||
liberal phrases, and endless references to the historical
|
||
oppression of Jews, are committing genocide now against the
|
||
Palestinian people. Some so-called left or humanitarian Zionists
|
||
do occasionally speak out against the more obvious Israeli
|
||
brutalities and sometimes talk about autonomy schemes which would
|
||
amount to bantustans for the Palestinians. Citing these dubious
|
||
murmurs as proof of its democratic nature, militant Zionism
|
||
(including Labor as well as Likud) marches on toward its fanatical
|
||
goal of an imperial Jewish super power, from the Nile to the
|
||
Euphrates, with the shameful collusion of most of the Jewish
|
||
community world-wide.
|
||
|
||
Against these currents, the resistance of truly anti- Zionist
|
||
Jews, wherever they may be, stands out as all the more heroic and
|
||
inspiring.
|
||
|
||
Zionism is one of many authoritarian, statist, and fascistic
|
||
forces on the rampage in the world today and must not be
|
||
obsessively dwelt upon to the exclusion of other dangers. At the
|
||
same time, by virtue of its symbiosis with the US Establishment (a
|
||
symbiosis as strong as ever, despite the present lovers' quarrel
|
||
between Washington and Tel Aviv), and in particular, by virtue of
|
||
its amazing propaganda machine, Zionism must be recognized, if not
|
||
as the most successful variant of fascism, then surely as the most
|
||
insidious and thus opposed accordingly.
|
||
|
||
Why do so many anarchists seem reluctant to mount that opposition
|
||
or to even acknowledge this enemy of freedom?
|
||
|
||
On behalf of the Collective
|
||
Yours for an International Intifada,
|
||
|
||
P.A. Ward
|
||
Raven's Banner Collective
|
||
Pinellas Park, FL
|
||
|
||
*
|
||
|
||
ANARCHY AND RACE
|
||
|
||
Dear Love and Rage,
|
||
|
||
Does anyone out there in the anarchist movement know of anything
|
||
connecting the concepts of anarchy and race?
|
||
|
||
I am looking for anarchist approaches to issues of racial
|
||
in/justice, anarchist theory which treats questions of race,
|
||
writings by anarchists of color, historical accounts of anarchists
|
||
of color, and related topics. I am mostly interested in what has
|
||
happened and what is happening in the US. I have been searching
|
||
anarchist bookstores, reading anarchist periodicals, and asking
|
||
people at anarchist coffeehouses and gatherings if anyone has any
|
||
ideas, but I have very few leads so far. I have a book (very
|
||
poorly written, I think) by Carolyn Ashbaugh called Lucy Parsons,
|
||
and I have been told to read up on the early years of S.N.C.C..
|
||
Otherwise people just shrug their shoulders and say ask so-
|
||
and-so. But the next so-and-so never knows anymore than the last
|
||
so- and-so.
|
||
|
||
Now I know that there are excuses, some more valid than others. I
|
||
also know that for the most part anarchists' hearts are in the
|
||
right place. However, I think that it is time to admit to
|
||
ourselves and to each other in public that the anarchist movement
|
||
in Europe, in North America, and even Latin America is
|
||
overwhelmingly white, and our future will be white unless we do
|
||
something to make it more colorful.
|
||
|
||
I think that it is lazy and irresponsible of us (especially those
|
||
of us who are white) to simply say as anarchists we are against
|
||
hierarchical relationships, and that obviously includes being
|
||
opposed to the idea that one race is superior and another
|
||
inferior, and leave it at that. Nor is it adequate to abstractly
|
||
proclaim that the struggle against ________ (choose one: state,
|
||
capital, megamachine, system, hegemony, technology, civilization,
|
||
alienation...) is a struggle for all people of any and all races.
|
||
I also don't think it suffices to print a few short articles on
|
||
the Black Panthers, the Mohawks, or on other non-white
|
||
non-anarchist radicals. I am not against such efforts, I am merely
|
||
saying that our efforts have not, as of yet, gone far enough. I
|
||
would embarrassingly add that from what I can tell Marxists,
|
||
feminists, and liberals seem to be more successful in addressing
|
||
these forms of racism within their movements than we are.
|
||
|
||
As a modest beginning towards a more honestly multi-racial and
|
||
multi-cultural anarchist movement, I would like to ask for an
|
||
inclusionary discussion of anarchy and race. I would like people
|
||
to write letters which share resources, experiences, knowledges,
|
||
ideas, proposals and anything else which seems like it will help
|
||
out. Please don't hesitate to point out something which may seem
|
||
obvious to you it may not be to me or someone else.
|
||
|
||
I would hope that the character of such a discussion would be
|
||
safe, supportive, and encouraging. Too often we viciously attack
|
||
or attempt to intimidate each other instead of offering
|
||
constructive criticism of our theories and actions. We should be
|
||
able to admit mistakes, problems, and shortcomings, and it should
|
||
be alright to ask for help.
|
||
|
||
Sincerely yours
|
||
for a diverse anarchy,
|
||
|
||
Eric
|
||
Santa Cruz, CA
|
||
|
||
-30-
|
||
|
||
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
|
||
@ _Love & Rage_ is a Revolutionary Anarchist newspaper produced
|
||
@ by the Love and Rage Network. The Love and Rage Network is a
|
||
@ continental network of groups and individuals in Canada, Mexico,
|
||
@ and the United States. Subscriptions to the newspaper cost:
|
||
@ $13 for first class (fast, envelope), $9 third class (slow, no
|
||
@ envelope), $13 international (outside of United States), free for
|
||
@ prisoners, GI's, published bimonthly.
|
||
@ Please write to us at POB 3, NY, NY 10012
|
||
@ email: lnr%nyxfer@igc.apc.org
|
||
@ or: loveandrage@igc.apc.org
|
||
@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
|
||
|
||
|