1550 lines
88 KiB
Plaintext
1550 lines
88 KiB
Plaintext
The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger
|
||
Electronic Edition
|
||
|
||
January 1994
|
||
Vol. XII, No. 1
|
||
ISSN 1073-6859
|
||
|
||
Published by the Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers in the
|
||
interest of continued, improved, and expanded rail service for the present
|
||
and potential railroad and rail transit passengers of southeastern
|
||
Pennsylvania, southern New Jersey, and nearby areas.
|
||
|
||
The Electronic Edition is published as a service to the network community
|
||
by DVARP. We hope you consider joining DVARP or your local rail passenger
|
||
organization.
|
||
Back issues are available from LISTSERV@cunyvm.cuny.edu (send a message
|
||
including the text "GET DVARP 9401 RAILNEWS" (substitute desired year
|
||
and month for 9401) Thanks to archivist Geert K. Marien
|
||
or by FTP from hipp.etsu.edu, directory pub/railroad/dvarp Thanks to
|
||
archivist Robert Wier.
|
||
|
||
Please send comments and suggestions to <mmitchell@asrr.arsusda.gov>
|
||
or to the address below.
|
||
|
||
For more information about DVARP and good rail service, please contact us:
|
||
P.O. Box 7505,
|
||
Philadelphia, PA 19101
|
||
215-222-3373
|
||
|
||
Schedule change alert: SEPTA trains will run on a weekday schedule
|
||
Presidents' Day.
|
||
New R5 Paoli schedules in effect this month.
|
||
Watch for seasonal schedule changes on SEPTA City Transit and NJ Transit
|
||
bus lines.
|
||
Time to Renew Your DVARP Membership! use the coupon on ##TT
|
||
|
||
New! Expanded Contents! Searchable Flags!
|
||
To quickly go to an article, use the "Find" function of your word
|
||
processor to find the ## heading. On the Railroad Lines articles
|
||
are headed with the route number (e.g. ##R1) or with the SEPTA division
|
||
initials (e.g. ##CTD). We hope you find this useful.
|
||
|
||
##A. NJ Transportation Commissioner Downs Named Amtrak President
|
||
##B. Editorial: People of the Year
|
||
##C. RailWorks¨ Ridership Statistics: Coming Back
|
||
##D. Yerusalim Reacts to DVRP Story
|
||
##E. On the Railroad Lines...
|
||
##F. Streetcars Versus Buses
|
||
##G. SEPTA Ridership Update
|
||
##H. SEPTA Takes Bids For Computerized Info System
|
||
##I. 30th St.: Transportation or Mall?
|
||
##J. Wow, Look! Raves for a trolley fleet
|
||
##K. An Ocean City Connection for the Atlantic City Rail Line
|
||
##L. NJT Plans to Keep Building Ridership
|
||
##M. Cape May Shuttle Train is Coming!
|
||
##N. NJ Sets Transportation Conference
|
||
##O. Big Three Automakers will get Half-Billion Handout
|
||
##P. You Can Fool Some of the People Some of the Time: Padding of
|
||
Passenger Train Schedules
|
||
##Q. ISSN?
|
||
##R. Well Said! Gordon Linton Speaks About His Goals
|
||
##S. NC Shows the Way
|
||
##T. What is "Commuter Rail"?
|
||
##U. What is "Regional Rail"?
|
||
##V. Gore Proposes End to Railroad Retirement Board
|
||
##W. Clinton Seeks Equal Tax on Parking
|
||
##X. Quebec Moves Forward for Commuters
|
||
##Y. Pollution Standards Too Loose?
|
||
##Z. NARP Discusses Amtrak Finances, Future
|
||
##AA. Hearings on Sunset Wreck Yield More Confusion
|
||
##BB. Texas TGV Fails to Meet Financial Target
|
||
##CC. Eurorail Views
|
||
##DD. New European Travel, Pass Options
|
||
##EE. ICE/X2000 Feedback
|
||
##FF. Computer Corner-BBS Systems in the Delaware Valley
|
||
##GG. Have Too Many Assets Been Removed?
|
||
##HH. Membership Renewal
|
||
##II. DVARP Considers New By-Laws: We Need Your Opinion!
|
||
##JJ. Volunteer Opportunity: Highway Safety Liaison
|
||
##KK. NARP Regional Meetings
|
||
##LL. Shop Tour for Trolley Coalition
|
||
##MM. SEPTA Board Meeting Schedule
|
||
##NN. DVARP Meeting Schedule
|
||
##OO. Conrail Double-Stack Progress
|
||
##PP. Dates of Interest
|
||
##QQ. Up and Down the Corridor
|
||
##RR. Voice Mail is Pulse Friendly
|
||
##SS. DVARP Phone & Voice-mail Directory
|
||
##TT. DVARP Membership/Renewal Coupon
|
||
##UU. Upcoming DVARP Meetings:
|
||
|
||
DVARP President: Chuck Bode Newsletter Editor: Matthew Mitchell
|
||
for other officers and committee chairs, see page 19 Production Manager:
|
||
Tom Borawski
|
||
entire contents copyright (C) 1994 DVARP, except photos (C) 1994 credited
|
||
photographers
|
||
Opinions expressed in The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger are not
|
||
necessarily
|
||
those of DVARP or its members. We welcome your comments: call 215-222-3373
|
||
|
||
##A NJ Transportation Commissioner Downs Named Amtrak President by
|
||
Matthew Mitchell
|
||
The Board of Directors of the National Railroad Passenger Corporation
|
||
(Amtrak) announced the retirement of its Chairman and President, W. Graham
|
||
Claytor, Jr., effective December 6, 1993. Claytor, 81, has served as
|
||
President and Chairman of Amtrak since July, 1982. The Board also
|
||
announced the appointment of Thomas M. Downs as President and Chairman,
|
||
effective December 7, 1993.
|
||
Downs, who is 50, will leave his positions as Commissioner of the New
|
||
Jersey Department of Transportation, and Chairman of the New Jersey Transit
|
||
Corporation, which he has held since March, 1990. His previous positions
|
||
included President, Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority in New York
|
||
City, 1988-1990; City Administrator, Washington, D.C., 1983-1988; Director
|
||
of the D.C. Department of Transportation, 1981-1983; Executive Director of
|
||
the Urban Mass Transportation Administration, U.S. Department of
|
||
Transportation, 1980-1981; and White House Fellow to the Secretary of
|
||
Transportation, 1977-1978. He also served as the District of Columbia's
|
||
representative to the Union Station Redevelopment Corporation which planned
|
||
and guided the restoration and development of the landmark station.
|
||
In choosing Downs, the Amtrak Board went to an outsider instead of
|
||
promoting from within, a decision which was closely watched inside Amtrak.
|
||
Outgoing President Claytor, who came up through the railroad industry
|
||
ranks, was keenly interested in the choice of his successor. It was
|
||
reported that Claytor threatened to withdraw his resignation last year if
|
||
he was unsatisfied with the Board's choice.
|
||
Downs will face both immediate and long-term challenges as he takes the
|
||
helm. Facing a reduction in Federal operating grants and hit by costly
|
||
floods and wrecks in 1993, Amtrak made minor cuts in service in October,
|
||
and continues to defer needed maintenance. The quality and reliability of
|
||
Amtrak services remain unsatisfactory as a result.
|
||
The good news though, is that Amtrak is looking forward to putting new
|
||
'Genesis' locomotives, Viewliner sleepers and dining cars, and Superliners
|
||
into service in the coming years; and efforts to extend Northeast Corridor
|
||
electrification to Boston and obtain new high-speed trains are well
|
||
underway. Amtrak's commuter and real estate subsidiaries are successful,
|
||
and it is increasing its revenue from carrying mail. The states are
|
||
clamoring for more trains, and many of them are willing to back their
|
||
requests up with money. [see NARP Directors Meeting story on page 16 for
|
||
more about Amtrak's problems and opportunities]
|
||
|
||
##B From the Editor's Seat:
|
||
People of the Year
|
||
The biggest story of 1993 was the conclusion of the RailWorks(R)
|
||
megaproject. While the people who did the construction work and got the
|
||
job done on time and under budget have gotten well-deserved credit for
|
||
their efforts, DVARP pointed to the loss of RRD ridership as cause for
|
||
concern. Finally, this threat to the long-term health of the railroad has
|
||
been recognized by SEPTA management, and work is underway to stem the flow
|
||
of passengers to the private auto. Richard DiLullo, SEPTA's head of
|
||
marketing, is in charge of this effort. In a move we applauded in these
|
||
pages, he's meeting the challenge head-on, with the "SEPTA, Better than
|
||
Driving" campaign.
|
||
New Jersey Transit is giving serious thought to passenger rail service for
|
||
Burlington and Gloucester Counties. James Schwartzwalder, Area Planning
|
||
Manager for NJ Transit has set an excellent example for his peers in the
|
||
transit planning business by going out to the community both to sell NJ
|
||
Transit's ideas and more importantly to hear the public response to them.
|
||
That kind of attitude is essential in winning public support for any
|
||
project.
|
||
Kim Heinle is recognized here as an example of new thinking within SEPTA.
|
||
Heinle has filled a variety of roles in the Authority, and in each of them
|
||
been willing to reject the tired excuses offered by other management
|
||
personnel--'we need more money,' 'it won't work in Philadelphia,' 'what if
|
||
it doesn't work?' He has also been willing to look outside the usual
|
||
places for support--Heinle's vision created the widely acclaimed
|
||
Trolleyfest '93.
|
||
Not all of our persons of the year represented good news though. Political
|
||
interference with the business of public transportation was popular sport
|
||
in Harrisburg, so State Senator Vince Fumo (D-South Phila.) is recognized
|
||
on behalf of his colleagues. Fumo's efforts to wring money for
|
||
Philadelphia interests out of the Delaware River Port Authority are likely
|
||
to lead to a fare increase for PATCO riders, while the State Legislature's
|
||
short-sighted efforts to protect a foreign company with ties to Pittsburgh
|
||
caused the SEPTA Board to waste four months and a quarter-million dollars.
|
||
It could have cost taxpayers millions more had the contractors not extended
|
||
the validity of their bids.
|
||
The team of Gayle Belford and Alan Wickersham are abject proof of the adage
|
||
that the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. An existing schedule
|
||
spreadsheet, a growing public information service, and a few hours of
|
||
formatting work yielded a first-of-its kind information resource at
|
||
virtually no cost to SEPTA. While their project of getting SEPTA train
|
||
schedules on the internet is not going to have a big impact right away, it
|
||
is an excellent demonstration of how public agencies can and should be
|
||
seeking out and using unusual resources: an example of "Reinventing
|
||
Government."--MDM
|
||
|
||
##C RailWorks(R) Ridership Statistics: Coming Back
|
||
Official reports released by SEPTA last month show passengers returning to
|
||
the Reading-side commuter rail lines now that construction-related service
|
||
outages are over. The good news, while expected, is reassuring. Ridership
|
||
changes so far have been close to DVARP predictions.
|
||
Ridership losses during phase II of the megaproject were less than during
|
||
phase I, since many the people who switched to their cars or stopped going
|
||
to Center City during phase I stayed off the rails last winter and were not
|
||
counted as lost this year. The net number of SEPTA riders decreased only
|
||
slightly this year.
|
||
The biggest variable in determining how much RailWorks will cost SEPTA will
|
||
be how long it takes for the lost ridership to return to SEPTA. After the
|
||
1983 strike, that took three years. Perhaps because of the aggressive
|
||
"Better Than Driving" marketing campaign, rider recovery proceeded well in
|
||
the fall. The pace is better than DVARP anticipated, but it remains to be
|
||
seen if the positive trend can be maintained through 1994; if so, the
|
||
RailWorks drain on SEPTA finances will be reduced.
|
||
% returned
|
||
Period Mar 92 Aug 92 Oct 92 Mar 93 July 93
|
||
Sept 93 Nov 93 % lost Sept Nov
|
||
R2, R3, R5 118,996 69,901 95,974 107,326 68,925
|
||
105,758 108,743 42% 74% 80%
|
||
Norr., Fox Ch. 40,016 0 28,179 30,509 0 30,571
|
||
33,906 100% 76% 85%
|
||
Chestnut Hill 49,009 40,962 44,751 43,382 39,295
|
||
47,304 48,037 20% 82% 90%
|
||
Total* 256,729 198,187 217,006 230,073 193,041
|
||
230,437 238,185 25% 59% 71%
|
||
*total includes R7 Trenton riders and "transit shift"
|
||
As SEPTA Revenue Development Director John McGee notes in his report, it is
|
||
not easy to isolate the effects of RailWorks from other trends in RRD
|
||
ridership. Because an overall decrease in ridership has taken place over
|
||
the past several years, marketing efforts were applied to the whole system
|
||
rather than specifically to the RailWorks lines. So far, this looks like a
|
||
smart decision.s--MDM
|
||
|
||
##D Yerusalim Reacts to DVRP Story
|
||
In the November DVRP, we reported on the appearance of Pennsylvania
|
||
Secretary of Transportation Howard Yerusalim before a Federal hearing. The
|
||
editing for publication of a quote from Yerusalim inadvertently changed the
|
||
meaning intended. The full quote with the missing words underscored is,
|
||
"Transit is an issue for people who can't afford an automobile, or are too
|
||
old or too young to drive."
|
||
The November story caused a number of readers to write to Yerusalim and/or
|
||
other state officials to express their dismay at the implied disdain for
|
||
public transit users, and in turn, Yerusalim has requested space in the
|
||
DVRP to clarify his statement and put it into a more complete context.
|
||
DVARP voted to grant that request, to be as fair as possible to the
|
||
Secretary The full text of his letter is published in the print edition of
|
||
this newsletter.
|
||
DVARP has struggled for years to inform elected officials and the general
|
||
public that public transit benefits everyone, not just those who are unable
|
||
to drive. When people use public transit instead of driving, the community
|
||
as a whole gains cleaner air, safer and less-crowded streets, conservation
|
||
of energy, land, and other resources, and a reduction in the need for
|
||
taxpayer subsidies of automobile transportation. Imbalanced, highway-
|
||
dependent transportation policies of the past have had a profound effect on
|
||
development patterns and taken some of the vitality out of Pennsylvania
|
||
communities, while reducing the opportunities that senior citizens and
|
||
others who do not drive have to contribute to society. This newsletter has
|
||
been reporting for several months about how other states have taken action
|
||
to put the transportation system back into balance; PennDOT continues to
|
||
lag behind its peers in this respect, and it is Yerusalim who can and
|
||
should turn it around.
|
||
To operate a public transportation system solely for those who have no
|
||
other means of getting around is economically and politically unsound. To
|
||
maximize the financial and environmental return on the public investment,
|
||
public transit services have to be able to attract people out of their
|
||
heavily-subsidized automobiles. Rail transit does this best, which is why
|
||
DVARP believes that good rail transit is essential to the quality of life
|
||
in the Delaware Valley. While we regret any inconvenience to the
|
||
Secretary, we hope this matter leads to awareness that public transit is an
|
||
issue for everyone in our region, even those of us who own and use cars.s--
|
||
MDM
|
||
|
||
##E On the Railroad Lines...
|
||
Holiday Schedules
|
||
Contrary to notes in the published timetables, SEPTA Regional Rail routes
|
||
will run on a weekday schedule Presidents' Day: February 21. 200-series
|
||
buses will operate.
|
||
|
||
SEPTA Submits Station Grants
|
||
Five RRD stations: one in each county, are to be restored if SEPTA gets
|
||
"transportation enhancement" grants authorized under ISTEA. The stations
|
||
selected are: Allen Lane, Haverford, Radnor, Strafford, and Doylestown.
|
||
|
||
A 'Zoo' in Winter Cold
|
||
Freezing temperatures caused an after cooler to fail, bringing down
|
||
Amtrak's Zoo and Penn (30th St. Station) interlockings for two hours
|
||
December 27. Thirteen SEPTA and fifteen Amtrak trains were delayed.
|
||
|
||
##R1
|
||
Saturday Snarl
|
||
Service to Jenkintown and north was delayed more than a half hour mid-day
|
||
December 11.
|
||
Watch your Head!
|
||
Use caution on windy days at Elkins Park. Slates have been falling from
|
||
the roof.
|
||
##R2
|
||
No Parking!
|
||
Amtrak's Merchants Limited struck an abandoned car left on the tracks in
|
||
Chester December 1.
|
||
##R3
|
||
Construction Phase I Done
|
||
Limited weekend train service was restored to Elwyn last month. Trains
|
||
will run on single track on two hour headways to accommodate continuing
|
||
construction work.
|
||
|
||
More Delays
|
||
The Elwyn line experienced 15 minute delays on the 2nd of December due to
|
||
"equipment problems."
|
||
The West Trenton Line was hit with up to 45 minute delays in the morning
|
||
rush, December 27th due to downed wires at Philmont Station.
|
||
##R5
|
||
Slow Trains in North Wales
|
||
In response to a recent grade crossing accident that caused the death of a
|
||
North Wales child (see November DVRP), SEPTA has agreed to reduce the speed
|
||
limit for trains approaching the North Wales Station to 35 mph. The speed
|
||
limit was originally 55 mph, and was temporarily lowered to 45 pending an
|
||
investigation. SEPTA acknowledges that the reduced speeds will have little
|
||
real effect on crossing safety.
|
||
The speed was permanently lowered by SEPTA in exchange for North Wales
|
||
Borough's participation in an anti-trespassing campaign. Railroad AGM
|
||
James Palmer told KYW that the campaign will have a strong enforcement
|
||
provision. The Borough and SEPTA also are reviewing the crossing
|
||
protection equipment and may possibly close one of the four crossings.
|
||
|
||
Minor Schedule Change
|
||
Look for a new R5 Paoli schedule this month. One outbound Sunday train,
|
||
reportedly #2593, is to run 10 minutes later.
|
||
|
||
Bucks County Woman Found Dead in Lansdale Train Yard
|
||
An 18 year old Chalfont woman was found dead in the Lansdale freight yard,
|
||
a murder victim. According to the Reporter the victim took the 11:13 train
|
||
from Fern Rock November 8th and arrived in Lansdale about 11:43 pm. The
|
||
paper states that she called home at 12:25 am and asked her father for a
|
||
ride.
|
||
The father, noting that his daughter sounded "distracted," arrived at the
|
||
station 20 minutes later to pick her up. "I waited around and looked for
|
||
her. Then I went home thinking we'd get another call from her in a half
|
||
hour or an hour," he told the Reporter. Her body was found December 2nd.
|
||
DVARP members who may have been in the vicinity of the freight yard on the
|
||
night of November 8th or in the area of the yard between November 8th and
|
||
December 2nd are urged to call Lansdale Police at 368-1800 to report any
|
||
unusual observations. Those who may have been on the train (Mon., Nov 8th,
|
||
train 596, 10:55 out of Market East) are especially asked to call.
|
||
Murder Sparks Cleanup Finger Pointing
|
||
According to the Reporter, Borough officials may cite SEPTA for "poor
|
||
conditions" at the Lansdale Yard. Says SEPTA spokesman Jim Whitaker:
|
||
"Conrail uses the area. It's their freight area. I think they are
|
||
responsible for maintaining it." Conrail spokeswoman Andrea Just replied:
|
||
"we think it is SEPTA's responsibility."
|
||
Lansdale Cleanup Gets OK
|
||
DVARP has learned that efforts to clean up PCB contamination at the
|
||
Lansdale train station are locked into efforts to clean up the entire
|
||
Borough of Lansdale. A state legislator's aide told DVARP that the entire
|
||
borough is a Superfund site. A train station redevelopment effort was
|
||
scuttled because of the presence of the chemicals.
|
||
DVARP has also learned that an effort is underway to transfer the $5
|
||
million Federal grant earmarked for the proposed Gwynedd Valley
|
||
Transportation Center to the repair and restoration of the station at
|
||
Lansdale. DVARP has in the past opposed the ill-conceived Gwynedd Valley
|
||
project in public hearing testimony.
|
||
##R6
|
||
'Conshohocken Creek'
|
||
The R6 Norristown line was flooded out again in December. DVARP has learned
|
||
from a SEPTA engineer that the authority is involved in a lawsuit with a
|
||
Conshohocken property owner who filled in a nearby creek bed. The water
|
||
which would normally flow into the creek bed is collecting on the right of
|
||
way as the photo shows.
|
||
Inbound R6 Norristown train fords the flooded area near Conshohocken.
|
||
Photo: Tom Borawski
|
||
|
||
DVARP Acts to Protect Cynwyd
|
||
In a letter to SEPTA's Carol Lavoritano, who is responsible for SEPTA
|
||
capital planning, DVARP VP for Transportation Tom Borawski formally
|
||
alerted the authority of Amtrak's plans to deactivate the 52nd Street
|
||
Jumpover (the outbound connection to the R6 Cynwyd line) and urged SEPTA to
|
||
begin the job of finding an new connection so Cynwyd train service remains
|
||
uninterrupted.
|
||
##R7
|
||
Up All Night!
|
||
SEPTA offered all-night service on the Trenton line to New Year's revelers
|
||
coming back from Times Square.
|
||
|
||
End the 'Trenton Dash'
|
||
The NJ Transit ticket machine at 30th Street Station is now in service.
|
||
Riders can purchase through tickets from Philadelphia to New Jersey points
|
||
and New York City from the machine, which accepts credit cards for
|
||
purchases over $10.00. More details next month.
|
||
|
||
AEM-7 Wheels a Steal
|
||
The board recently voted on a contract for 40 AEM-7 wheels for a total
|
||
price of $112,000. That's $2800 each, road hazard not included.
|
||
|
||
New Seats for SEPTA's Engineers
|
||
SEPTA recently awarded a contract for 450 engineer's seats at $760 each for
|
||
the Silverliner fleet.
|
||
|
||
##100 ##STD
|
||
Bizarre Accident
|
||
A man was killed by a Route 100 train as he was attempting to board at the
|
||
Conshohocken Road station. The accident occurred at 9:20 am December 22nd.
|
||
According to The Times Herald, the man rushed up to the station platform
|
||
after the train began to depart. The operator, seeing the man, stopped the
|
||
train and started to back up. Lower Merion Police Lt. Michael Tansey said
|
||
the man slipped off the platform and was pinned between the right rear
|
||
train wheel and the third rail cover board.
|
||
It was then discovered that the victim was allegedly fleeing the scene of
|
||
a burglary he had just committed. The Times Herald reported that the
|
||
victim was found with personal papers and cash stolen from a house in Upper
|
||
Merion Township. The burglar had broken into the house and taken boxes
|
||
containing the papers and cash. Police believe that he was attempting to
|
||
flee the scene of the crime when the accident occurred.
|
||
|
||
SEPTA Staff Notes
|
||
SEPTA's Cecil W. Bond Jr. has been elected chairman of APTA's Minority
|
||
Affairs Committee.
|
||
|
||
##LRD Patchwork Track
|
||
A welding truck seems to be in service nearly full time attempting to
|
||
manufacture rail an inch at a time in the streets--replacing worn out track
|
||
and fixing broken rails. When that attempt completely fails, a track crew
|
||
installs about 15 feet of rail. Patching can only hang on so long. Public
|
||
support is necessary to get funds for new track--letters to Harrisburg and
|
||
Washington from DVARP members can help. SEPTA is also working to increase
|
||
the flexibility of subway-surface operations by adding additional track
|
||
connections.
|
||
SEPTA is still working on the design for new LRVs. Suggestions can be sent
|
||
to Kim Scott Heinle, SEPTA's Chief Officer-Light Rail, who is also working
|
||
on a new image for the routes. First change is a new name: Route 15
|
||
becomes Girard Avenue Light Rail Line and Route 56 becomes Erie-Torresdale
|
||
Light Rail Line. Second change is a transit first strategy. Route 23 is
|
||
expected to need a "quite aggressive" transit first strategy. 'Transit
|
||
First' has been stated City policy since the Goode Administration, but
|
||
little has actually been done to actually enhance the speed of streetcars
|
||
and buses by reducing interference from cars and trucks.
|
||
|
||
Detour Ends
|
||
Routes 11 and 36 returned to their normal routing December 23.
|
||
|
||
Holiday Spirit Department
|
||
SEPTA LRVs 9047 and 9048 were decorated inside in a Christmas motif. They
|
||
operated as a train on Route 10 on at least one day. A SEPTA bus was also
|
||
observed in Center City with a Santa attached to the front. DVARP commends
|
||
SEPTA for these initiatives to make public transportation more friendly.
|
||
|
||
##CTD
|
||
Protesters Capture Bus
|
||
Seven protesters briefly captured a SEPTA Route 38 bus in a protest
|
||
designed to dramatize SEPTA's lack of progress in making its vehicles
|
||
wheelchair-accessible according to a story in the Inquirer. The protesters
|
||
were representatives of three groups, Disabled in Action, Consumer
|
||
Connection and ADAPT. The bus was held up for about an hour on Market
|
||
Street east of City Hall; the protesters were taken away by police.
|
||
|
||
##F Streetcars Versus Buses
|
||
For several years buses that resemble turn of the century streetcars have
|
||
been promoted by several builders. Typically these buses are used on
|
||
downtown circulator routes, tourist oriented service, and special services
|
||
such as RRTA's Christmas light tours. After going into service, reports
|
||
typically indicated increased ridership and that passengers liked the "fun"
|
||
sort of vehicle. Always unanswered was the question: How do these replicas
|
||
compare to a real streetcar?
|
||
Tuscon has unwittingly answered the question. The Arizona city has operated
|
||
the bus replicas for some time, but recently volunteers uncovered a mile of
|
||
trolley track, obtained two streetcars, and began limited service over
|
||
about half the route of the replica bus. A few sentences from the New
|
||
Electric Railway Journal sum up the results. First a description: "A ride
|
||
on the historic line costs one dollar while the SunTran shuttle bus fare is
|
||
25 cents. The trolley line is only one mile in length while the bus route
|
||
is about two miles and connects more activity centers including downtown
|
||
Tuscon and the convention center. Further discouraging riders, the
|
||
streetcar only runs three days a week while the bus runs six days." Not
|
||
quite a level playing field, but the best test to date.
|
||
And the winner?: "During May, the first full month of operation, three
|
||
times as many riders paid four times as much to ride half as far in the
|
||
newly restored rail line...."--CB
|
||
(Members interested in streetcars may find the New Electric Railway Journal
|
||
of interest. $25.00 for four issues a year. 717 Second St, Washington, DC
|
||
2002.)
|
||
|
||
##G SEPTA Ridership Update
|
||
In the first quarter of fiscal year 1994 the only ridership bright spots
|
||
were city subway and trolley routes. A big decline in city bus ridership
|
||
led to an overall drop in patronage for the three-month period of over two
|
||
million. (courtesy John McGee)
|
||
First quarter 1993 1992 change
|
||
Subway-Elevated 12,458M 12,378M +1.8
|
||
Surface (bus) 24,644M 26,663M -7.6
|
||
Light Rail 2,407M 2,325M +3.5
|
||
City Transit Total 39,509M 41,366M -4.5
|
||
Red Arrow 2,923M 3,140M -6.9
|
||
Frontier 509M 533M -4.5
|
||
Sub. Transit Total 3,432M 3,673M -6.6
|
||
Railroad Total 4,276M 4,268M +0.2
|
||
SEPTA TOTAL 47,217M 49,307M -4.2
|
||
|
||
##H SEPTA Takes Bids For Computerized Info System
|
||
SEPTA recently accepted bids for a "Computer Based Voice Response System"
|
||
which will enhance the delivery of transit information to the riding
|
||
public.
|
||
According to the Request For Proposal, the system will have the capability
|
||
of providing Railroad Division, Subway-Elevated Division and Suburban
|
||
Division (high speed) schedule information based on "station to station,
|
||
time of day and day of week requirements" of the caller. Maryland's MARC
|
||
has had this kind of 'talking timetable' in service for some time now.
|
||
For Suburban and City bus, trolley and trackless trolley routes the system
|
||
will provide "frequency of service schedule and general route information
|
||
based on route, time of day and day of week specification" by the caller.
|
||
The system will also give information on fares, and sales outlet addresses.
|
||
For the Railroad Division, Subway-Elevated Division and Suburban Transit
|
||
rail lines the system will provide a station locator index which has the
|
||
caller use the touch-tone keypad to spell the station name.
|
||
The system will retain the voice-mail "Dial-a-Schedule" function and will
|
||
also retain the customer's option to speak to a live SEPTA agent. Those
|
||
with pulse-type phones will automatically be transferred to an agent.--TB
|
||
|
||
##I 30th St.: Transportation or Mall?
|
||
Several months ago, SEPTA installed new schedule racks in 30th Street
|
||
Station. One was strategically located at the southwest corner just inside
|
||
the door used by pedestrians entering the station. It was stocked with
|
||
train, subway surface, and even NJ Transit bus schedules--a rare example of
|
||
interagency cooperation here. We are distressed to report that this
|
||
display has been banished to a much less visible location by another
|
||
trinket cart.
|
||
The effort to partially fund the station by commercial rent and to attract
|
||
persons there with trendy merchandise is commendable. However, the primary
|
||
purpose of a station is public transportation. We urge relocation of the
|
||
cart and restoration of the schedule display to its unobstructed former
|
||
location.--CB
|
||
|
||
##J Wow, Look!
|
||
Raves for a trolley fleet reported by San Francisco's Market Street
|
||
Railway:
|
||
San Franciscans have been doing double-takes along the city's streetcar
|
||
lines the past few weeks, as brightly colored trolleys swoosh by, looking
|
||
like they just came from the showroom floor.
|
||
...the car was really zipping along. A test ride along the J-line right-
|
||
of-way on San Jose Avenue clocked the car at nearly 50 mph. It rode
|
||
exceedingly smoothly at that speed, too, without the bobbing and weaving of
|
||
many of Muni's old PCCs.
|
||
When used with the raised boarding islands now under construction... [they]
|
||
comply with the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act. A
|
||
lightweight folding bridge stored behind the operator's seat and deployed
|
||
manually allows wheelchair users to roll from the island right through the
|
||
front doors, from which the center stanchion has been removed.
|
||
New Breda LRVs? A new generation of streetcar from the aerospace industry?
|
||
Guess again. These excerpts from the Inside Track newsletter are
|
||
describing--hard to believe, but true--SEPTA's PCCs now entering service in
|
||
San Francisco after an overhaul by Morrison-Knudsen. Hope SEPTA's new LRVs
|
||
get reviews this good when--and if --they come.!--CB
|
||
|
||
##CTD Bus Hearings on Tap
|
||
Public hearings on proposed changes to SEPTA routes 68 and 95 are to be
|
||
held January 14. Details are unavailable at this time, phone Mary Donahue
|
||
of SEPTA at 580-7333 for more information.
|
||
|
||
##CREDITS##
|
||
News compiled by Matthew Mitchell and correspondents: Chuck Bode, Howard
|
||
Bender, Tom Borawski, Bob Machler, James Morgan,
|
||
Don Nigro, John Pawson.
|
||
Additional news from BITNET, Carolina Association for Passenger Trains,
|
||
Conrail Newswire, KYW, Lansdale Reporter, Market Street Railway Co., New
|
||
electric Railway Journal, Newark Star-Ledger, Norristown Times-Herald,
|
||
Philadelphia Inquirer, Railway Age, USENET.
|
||
Special thanks to Amtrak Public Affairs, and to Mary Donahue, John McGee,
|
||
and Kim Scott Heinle of SEPTA
|
||
The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger is a charter member of the Rail Online
|
||
Newswire.
|
||
|
||
##K An Ocean City Connection for the Atlantic City Rail Line
|
||
by Don Nigro
|
||
With the exception of the two weekday roundtrip commuter runs of New Jersey
|
||
Transit's 555 bus and three weekend round trips (via Atlantic City) of the
|
||
551, the authority's connections between Ocean City and the Delaware Valley
|
||
are an ordeal for travelers. Travel between the two points requires a
|
||
transfer at Atlantic City to or from the 507 bus. The 507 is a local bus
|
||
with a one hour travel time between the two cities' bus terminals. With
|
||
the addition of a 20 minute layover in Atlantic City and a 93 minute rail
|
||
travel time between Atlantic City and Philadelphia, the total trip duration
|
||
between Ocean City and Philadelphia is 2 hours, 53 minutes. Even with no
|
||
transfer, the 551 takes 2 hours, 13 minutes. This is entirely unacceptable
|
||
to most potential customers.
|
||
Ocean City and its clogged approach highways need an efficient, attractive
|
||
alternative to the unwelcome cycle of highway congestion/highway
|
||
construction. The answer for the immediate future lies with the
|
||
underutilized capacity of the Atlantic City Rail Line. Express feeder bus
|
||
service should be established between Ocean City and the Absecon railroad
|
||
station allowing for a convenient and rapid connection with the rail line's
|
||
ten most strategic trains: the ones to and from 30th Street Station,
|
||
Philadelphia
|
||
The rail line's running time between Absecon and 30th Street is 75 minutes.
|
||
From Absecon to Lindenwold the time is 42 minutes. Both are competitive
|
||
with other modes of transportation. Better yet, they should show an
|
||
improvement with the next schedule release. Until recently, NJ Transit's
|
||
trains were required to travel 15 mph slower than Amtrak's Atlantic City
|
||
trains through towns. Now, the speed restrictions for NJ Transit have been
|
||
lifted, so there should be even faster service between Absecon and the
|
||
Delaware Valley in spring of 1994.
|
||
When combined with a 20 or 25 minute Absecon to Ocean City feeder bus, the
|
||
AC train would offer Ocean City residents a rapid and comfortable way to
|
||
travel, with net trip time under 100 minutes of over 170 minutes. Such a
|
||
feeder bus operation would remove many of the automobiles of summer
|
||
tourists from the streets of Ocean City and offer relief to the summer
|
||
pressure points of highways in many parts of Southern New Jersey, one of
|
||
the most notorious being the intersection of NJ 42 and Interstate 295. In
|
||
addition, an Absecon to Ocean City feeder bus would put many more riders on
|
||
the Atlantic City Line, trains which have a significantly underutilized
|
||
capacity.
|
||
Although there are several possible routings for an Absecon to Ocean City
|
||
feeder bus, the ideal one may be US 9 to NJ 52 via the Atlantic City
|
||
Expressway and Garden State Parkway. The 16 mile express route would
|
||
ensure a swift connection to and from the rail line, which offers a
|
||
spacious, comfortable mode of travel. Such a service would be attractive
|
||
to the automobile-owning, discretionary transit customer, a vast pool of
|
||
potential riders whose needs NJ Transit must continually attempt to meet.
|
||
Through such actions, the authority will continue to see an increase in its
|
||
ridership and farebox revenue.
|
||
NJ Transit has had an impressive ridership record for 1993. This past
|
||
summer, the authority experienced a 14.6 percent increase in ridership on
|
||
its southern New Jersey bus routes. The northern part of the state
|
||
experienced an 8.1 percent increase for buses. The state has also seen
|
||
impressive ridership increases for its rail service. Thomas M. Downs,
|
||
state Transportation Commissioner, [see cover] who chairs NJ Transit's
|
||
board of directors, attributed this in part to the authority's quality of
|
||
service and its promotional efforts of the bus services to the Jersey
|
||
shore. This same dedicated effort should be applied to Ocean City. The
|
||
Long Island Rail Road offers feeder bus connections from its Freeport, Long
|
||
Beach and Babylon Stations to the local beaches. So too should NJ Transit
|
||
offer the comfort and speed of a train to Ocean City travelers.
|
||
Adding a feeder bus connection, thus reducing the travel time between Ocean
|
||
City and Philadelphia would result in a substantial increase in revenue for
|
||
the Atlantic City Rail Line. For example, each rider brought to the line
|
||
by the feeder bus who travels one-way to Philadelphia would result in an
|
||
additional $6 in revenue for the authority.
|
||
NJ Transit runs 12 weekday trains each direction (13 on weekends) between
|
||
Atlantic City and the Delaware Valley. Six originate at Amtrak's 30th
|
||
Street Station in Philadelphia and six terminate there. The other trains
|
||
use Cherry Hill or Lindenwold as an end-point. DVARP and NJ-ARP recommend
|
||
the operation of an Ocean City feeder bus connecting to the following ten
|
||
trains at Absecon Station:
|
||
Absecon 30th 30th Absecon
|
||
6:26 M-F 7:48 6:52 M-F 8:09
|
||
7:14 S-S 8:36 7:44 S-S 9:03
|
||
8:51 10:16 9:54 11:10
|
||
1:39 3:01 1:43 3:00
|
||
5:47 7:18 4:43 5:59
|
||
11:02 12:18 8:23 9:44
|
||
With one exception which might be able to be resolved with a new train
|
||
schedule, one operating bus should be able to handle all of the connections
|
||
between Ocean City and Absecon.
|
||
In fact, if this service is integrated with the two weekday roundtrip
|
||
commuter runs of New Jersey Transit's 555 bus, one of the 555 round trips
|
||
between Ocean City and Philadelphia could be eliminated provided that a
|
||
multi-modal weekly and monthly fare would be established between the 555
|
||
and the Atlantic City Rail Line. The 555 offers a 95 minute ride leaving
|
||
Ocean City at 6:00 and 7:00 am and returning from Philadelphia at 6:30 pm
|
||
and 7:05 pm With a feeder bus, the 6:00 am Ocean City bus could meet the
|
||
6:26 am train at Absecon; the first 555 bus to Ocean City could be replaced
|
||
by a feeder from the 5:59 train at Absecon. This change in service would
|
||
lead to additional financial benefits for the authority without infringing
|
||
on current riders.
|
||
The underutilized capacity of the Atlantic City Rail Line provides an
|
||
attractive immediate option for travel between Ocean City and the Delaware
|
||
Valley.
|
||
|
||
##L NJT Plans to Keep Building Ridership
|
||
New Jersey Transit systemwide ridership increased 1.7% during the last
|
||
fiscal year. Passenger Transport also reports that this fiscal year NJ
|
||
Transit budgeted for 41 new services to get people to jobs in the suburbs.
|
||
"The services will include extensions of existing bus and rail services and
|
||
a variety of new kinds of transit, including 'flex routes,' rail station
|
||
shuttles, park-and-rides, mini-buses, and circulators." Along with these
|
||
new ideas, we encourage NJ Transit to work on the basics including
|
||
elimination of the penalty fares from Pennsylvania and provision of NJ
|
||
Transit-SEPTA transfers and passes so passengers can afford to use public
|
||
transportation.
|
||
Cape May Shuttle Train is Coming!
|
||
Cape May Seashore Lines is ready to go ahead with its park and ride train
|
||
service from Tuckahoe to Cape May (see Feb 92 DVRP) as early as next month.
|
||
Stops at Rio Grand and Cape May Court House are proposed; shopkeepers in
|
||
Middletown are clamoring for a stop there too.
|
||
|
||
##N NJ Sets Transportation Conference
|
||
"TransAction '94," the New Jersey statewide intermodal transportation
|
||
conference, is to be held March 29 and 30 at the Trump Plaza in Atlantic
|
||
City. For information and registration, contact Frank Reilly, Morris
|
||
County DOT, PO Box 900, Morristown, NJ 07963, phone 201-829-8101.
|
||
|
||
##O Big Three Automakers will get Half-Billion Handout
|
||
Defense Electronics reports that the Clinton Administration "has united
|
||
Detroit's Big Three Automakers with the nation's defense agencies and
|
||
laboratories in a wide-ranging research project."
|
||
The magazine quotes Clinton, "The project will involve federal and industry
|
||
funding. The government will pick up a greater share of the high-risk
|
||
projects, ones identified by an auto industry-government team." It reports
|
||
that "a senior administration official, who requested anonymity, told a
|
||
separate White House background briefing for reporters that most of the
|
||
government's share of the project's funding will come from existing
|
||
research in the Department of Defense, Commerce Department, NASA and Energy
|
||
Department." The "anonymous official" estimated the government now spends
|
||
about $500 million on such projects which will now be re-directed to the
|
||
joint Detroit-Washington effort.--TB
|
||
|
||
##P You Can Fool Some of the People Some of the Time: Padding of
|
||
Passenger Train Schedules by Matthew Mitchell
|
||
Long Island Rail Road, SEPTA, and other commuter train operators all are
|
||
patting themselves on the back for setting new highs in on-time
|
||
performance. Conclusive proof that their service is getting better? Or an
|
||
attempt to deceive the riding public?
|
||
A key ingredient in those successes has been the deliberate addition of
|
||
unnecessary time to train schedules--a lowering of the standard rather than
|
||
an improvement of the service. While this "padding" takes several
|
||
different forms, they all are an inadequate substitute for solving the real
|
||
causes of unreliable service.
|
||
The most obvious padding went on on the LIRR a year ago. New schedules
|
||
added time to nearly all trains between Jamaica and Penn Station, for the
|
||
express purpose of improving the on-time statistics. While representatives
|
||
of the passengers fumed about the slower schedules, the politicians who
|
||
determine whether LIRR management is doing an acceptable job only saw the
|
||
inflated percentages. In the days before public operation of commuter
|
||
trains, railroad managers who had come up through the ranks would have seen
|
||
right through the subterfuge.
|
||
SEPTA also tried to lower the standard in 1987, by changing the definition
|
||
of on-time from the industry-standard scheduled time plus five minutes to
|
||
"time-and-six." DVARP called attention to the deception, and when railroad
|
||
management changed, SEPTA went back to the standard measure.
|
||
Travel time varies from day to day...
|
||
But padding still remains in RRD schedules, in the form of "recovery time"
|
||
for trains in the Center City tunnel. While it takes only three minutes
|
||
for Pennsy-side trains to make a station stop at Suburban Station and
|
||
travel on to Market East, five minutes are allowed in the schedule. The
|
||
excess time causes some trains to sit at Suburban Station to wait for the
|
||
scheduled departure time, frustrating Market East riders who want to get to
|
||
their destination. The slack schedules also impede the smooth flow of
|
||
trains through the tunnel; some must wait for platform space while the
|
||
train ahead is holding.
|
||
No schedule is perfect
|
||
In real life, trains rarely take the same time to complete their trip; bad
|
||
weather can slow a trip while light loads will result in a faster run. Add
|
||
to this the more serious delays caused by equipment or signal problems,
|
||
etc. and you'll see a distribution of travel times which looks like Figure
|
||
1. The graph makes it easy to determine what the scheduled time should be.
|
||
There will always be some compromise between minimizing the number of
|
||
trains which are early and minimizing the number which are late, which is
|
||
why a five-minute 'on-time' window is reasonable.
|
||
Move the goal closer, and fewer trains are late...
|
||
In Figure 2, the line representing scheduled time is moved to the right,
|
||
padding the schedule so that fewer trains will be late. But now many
|
||
trains are early. Anyone who has ridden between Fern Rock and Market East
|
||
or sat waiting to leave Suburban Station knows what happens next:
|
||
engineers have to slow down, so as not to be early. So the real result is
|
||
described by Figure 3. Management looks great, but in fact is failing to
|
||
make best use of the hard work and money which went into the
|
||
infrastructure. Why spend the extra dollars maintaining a railroad capable
|
||
of 60 mph speeds when 45 is all that's needed to meet the padded schedule.
|
||
...but more trains have to wait, which causes the average to be much
|
||
slower!
|
||
Unchecked, the attitude which breeds padded schedules leads to other lax
|
||
practices: failure to look at alternative solutions to a problem, having
|
||
trains make all stops instead of examining the market and having trains
|
||
meet market needs, and treating symptoms instead of root causes of a
|
||
problem. By comparison, the railroad which takes a sharp pencil to its
|
||
schedules is the railroad which uses the same sharp pencil for writing
|
||
budgets.
|
||
When people bemoan the shift in RRD management to people from outside the
|
||
railroad, they really say they miss having someone in charge who won't
|
||
accept rigged numbers. Expecting employees to do the best job they can is
|
||
unrealistic when they see management taking the easy way out.
|
||
|
||
##Q ISSN?
|
||
Sharp-eyed readers who checked the cover of this DVRP (to see if we got the
|
||
date right!) might have seen "ISSN 1073-6859." The name of the next
|
||
European high-speed train Amtrak will run on the corridor? No, its an
|
||
"International Standard Serial Number," used for library cataloging
|
||
purposes.--MDM
|
||
|
||
##R Well Said!
|
||
Railway Age published an interview with Philadelphia's Gordon Linton, new
|
||
head of the Federal Transit Administration. In the section on goals Linton
|
||
said: "At the FTA, we are engaging in a strategic planning process where
|
||
our number one goal is making transit in this country a very good choice,
|
||
not the second choice."
|
||
Asked what he would like to be remembered for, he replied: "I'd like to
|
||
wake up in the morning, turn on the television and see the same type of
|
||
excitement and attractiveness portrayed for people boarding a light rail
|
||
system, a heavy rail system, or a bus, as there is for a person getting
|
||
into their car and driving alone along a highway."
|
||
DVARP encourages members to support Linton by writing to their Senators and
|
||
Representatives, and state transportation officials, about the importance
|
||
of attractive public transportation options for everyone in the community.-
|
||
-CB
|
||
|
||
##S NC Shows the Way
|
||
The Carolina Association for Passenger Trains newsletter reprinted "Transit
|
||
Plans at Crossroads" from the Charlotte Observer. The gist of the story is
|
||
that Charlotte is well along investigating a new rail transit system for
|
||
the area. City-county planning director Martin Cramton seems to have a
|
||
vision significantly different than our state's suburban sprawl plans.
|
||
Cramton thinks a transit system will not only cut pollution but will also
|
||
make the community a better place to live. It could cut a two-car family
|
||
to one car and families could put that savings into houses. "In 10 years,
|
||
this will be a very different community than it was 15 years ago," Cramton
|
||
said. "At the turn of the century, the economic pressures, cost of housing
|
||
and transportation and demand for different types of housing will all come
|
||
together. And a successful city will be able to make that jump."
|
||
Unbelievable--a planner proposing to invest in the community instead of
|
||
pouring the income into automobile transportation costs. Imagine what this
|
||
revolutionary thinking could do for Philadelphia, Camden, Norristown,
|
||
Chester,... CB
|
||
|
||
##T What is "Commuter Rail"?
|
||
by John Pawson
|
||
An example of the way in which the meaning of words in common use can
|
||
change is the word "commute." The little-used original meaning is "to
|
||
exchange items of value." In the mid-nineteenth century, a railroad
|
||
looking for immediate revenue offered unlimited travel in a given area in
|
||
exchange for a yearly advance payment, an arrangement which on the Paoli
|
||
line lasted into the 1950s.
|
||
Today's usage of the verb is "to travel back and forth daily between
|
||
places, as to and from a city." A "commuter" is one who does this.
|
||
"Commutation" is the act of commuting. That's as far as the dictionary
|
||
takes us.
|
||
At the heart of the current usage is what the travel industry calls a "one-
|
||
day round-trip." Those who commute over 50 miles each way are called
|
||
"super-commuters." Some highly-paid entertainers can afford to commute
|
||
across the country and even between continents. Notice that the usage has
|
||
changed from an exchange to an agreement with a carrier (a "tariff") to a
|
||
way of life. No longer need it involve a journey to and from a workplace.
|
||
"Intercity rail" seems to have become prominent, if it wasn't actually
|
||
coined, when Amtrak was created 23 years ago. [ed. note: many European
|
||
railways use the name 'Inter-city' as a brand for their express services]
|
||
It describes a passenger train which runs between stations located in or
|
||
near city centers with few stops in less-developed areas. At that time,
|
||
the railroad companies which offered commuter service had no incentive to
|
||
protect a largely unwanted 'turf;' they were looking to pass it on to some
|
||
other entity.
|
||
"Commuter rail" was thereby defined legislatively. Use of multiple-trip
|
||
tickets by the majority of passengers was one test, even though the
|
||
definition had moved beyond the mere tariff to a way of life. The other
|
||
test was mileage, either travel distance or end-to-end train run; 75 or 100
|
||
miles was defined as the limit. There is some belief that the former
|
||
number was meant to corral the New York-Philadelphia and Chicago-Milwaukee
|
||
markets for Amtrak, while the latter would exclude Philadelphia-Harrisburg
|
||
as a commuter rail line.
|
||
Protecting Amtrak's 'turf' is becoming a moot question. Cost and funding
|
||
pressures now require that company to look towards its more renumerative
|
||
markets. Another change over the years is that people are commuting
|
||
farther. 'Back-to-back' commuter service is effective: a train caries
|
||
commuters to one city, then quickly turns and takes others from the same
|
||
home stations to another city in the opposite direction.
|
||
To resort to arbitrary definitions to separate commuter and intercity rail
|
||
services is not useful, if it ever was. The relative number of stations
|
||
between the city centers probably is the closest one can come to a litmus
|
||
test. Disputed cases should be resolved on the basis of the economics of
|
||
the carriers and their services and the needs of the market. Eventually,
|
||
the law will catch up to the economic realities.
|
||
|
||
##U What is "Regional Rail"?
|
||
by Matthew Mitchell
|
||
Knowledgeable observers find significance in SEPTA's choice of the phrase
|
||
"Regional Rail" to brand its suburban trains rather than "Commuter Rail."
|
||
To some, the choice belies ulterior motives. To detractors, regional rail
|
||
means 'transitization' of commuter rail service, a lowering of standards
|
||
for speed and comfort in an attempt to be all things to all markets. But
|
||
it could also greatly increase the use of public transit, thereby
|
||
increasing the community's return on its transit assets.
|
||
Regional rail is an operating rationale most often seen in Europe,
|
||
especially Germany. Several principal cities have both a city subway
|
||
system (referred to as the U-bahn or 'underground railway') and a suburban
|
||
train network (referred to as the S-bahn or 'regional railway'). The
|
||
electrified S-bahn lines provide frequent service to a relatively dense
|
||
network of stations. Like in post-tunnel Philadelphia, the S-bahn acts as
|
||
its own distributor; there are several downtown stations. Trains are
|
||
through-routed from one line to another in a fixed pattern designated by a
|
||
number like S1. (Sound familiar?) In looking at North American rail
|
||
systems, the one which may come closest to the 'Regional Rail' model is
|
||
actually the Washington Metro, but SEPTA's Railroad Division shares some of
|
||
the characteristics.
|
||
The 'commuter rail' operations of most other North American transit
|
||
properties are not meant to serve as many different travel markets as the
|
||
European 'regional rail' systems; they gear their service towards a single
|
||
market of middle-to-upper class downtown office workers who drive to a
|
||
station and ride an express train downtown. A significant number offer no
|
||
off-peak service, running trains only at times they can be filled up.
|
||
Better for the balance sheet, but not as good for the community.
|
||
But Philadelphia's rail network was designed in and for another era. The
|
||
SEPTA system has hundreds of stations on a dozen lines, spaced more closely
|
||
than on any other US commuter railroad. That characteristic, inherited
|
||
from the competing Pennsylvania and Reading systems, is both SEPTA's
|
||
blessing and SEPTA's curse. While more of our population can access and
|
||
use the railroad, per-line and per-station ridership is diluted.
|
||
The plan
|
||
In planning service through the new Center City tunnel, SEPTA managers who
|
||
themselves had little experience running a commuter railroad relied on a
|
||
plan drawn up by University of Pennsylvania professor Vukan Vuchic, an
|
||
expert in planning of transportation operations. Vuchic in turn was
|
||
influenced by European (and especially German) practices, and parts of the
|
||
plan he created for SEPTA belie that influence.
|
||
While Vuchic's analysis is not in error, some of the conditions he based
|
||
the plan on have not come to pass. Pairing of lines was based on
|
||
ridership, to reduce the number of cars required. But few of our off-peak
|
||
trains run with more than minimum consists. Slow crew changes and padding
|
||
of schedules have cut into the promised efficiency of through service.
|
||
Thru-tunnel ridership has always been quite small; the chief advantage of
|
||
the tunnel has been delivery of passengers closer to their final
|
||
destinations. The plan should be revisited in light of the realities, now
|
||
that the tunnel has been open a decade.
|
||
Will we take advantage of regional rail?
|
||
In all its lines and all its stations, not to mention electrification,
|
||
there is a vast investment in our region's rail network. There is a good
|
||
case to be made for getting the most return on this investment by operating
|
||
it as 'regional rail,' even though it may not be the most efficient
|
||
strictly in terms of the operating budget. But that argument can't be used
|
||
to justify inefficiencies in the present operation, and mustn't be allowed
|
||
to dictate the operating philosophy of any new services.
|
||
The regional rail system has been an undervalued asset, especially in the
|
||
City of Philadelphia. Do we downsize the network to better serve the
|
||
traditional commuter market, or do we revise the transit network to direct
|
||
more passengers to Regional Rail?s
|
||
|
||
##V Gore Proposes End to Railroad Retirement Board
|
||
A provision to transfer Railroad Retirement Board functions to other
|
||
agencies was part of the recommendations made by Vice President Al Gore's
|
||
National Performance Review The review recommends that Tier 1 benefits be
|
||
handled by the Social Security Administration, that unemployment benefits
|
||
be transferred to state systems, and that administration of health care
|
||
benefits be transferred to the Health Care Financing Administration. The
|
||
report does not specify what should be done with Tier II benefits.
|
||
Additional details on Tier II's disposition are expected shortly. (Rail
|
||
Online)
|
||
|
||
##W Clinton Seeks Equal Tax on Parking
|
||
In a move to cut air pollution, President Clinton has asked Congress to
|
||
reduce or eliminate the tax deduction employers can take on free parking
|
||
they provide to employees. Currently the tax-free parking benefit is
|
||
unlimited, while transit passes or tokens given to employees are taxed if
|
||
they exceed $60 per month.
|
||
|
||
##X Quebec Moves Forward for Commuters
|
||
The province of Quebec has purchased 80 used single-level coaches from
|
||
Ontario's GO Transit. New service on at least two, and as many as six
|
||
lines radiating from Montreal is planned, pending a financial arrangement
|
||
between the province and the municipalities to be served.
|
||
|
||
##Y Pollution Standards Too Loose?
|
||
The Inquirer reports that a recent study published in the New England
|
||
Journal of Medicine concluded that air pollution can shorten lives by up to
|
||
two years, even in areas where present 'clean air' standards are attained.
|
||
The study suggests that current air quality standards may be too weak.
|
||
|
||
##Z NARP Discusses Amtrak Finances, Future
|
||
by John Dawson, NARP Region III Director
|
||
The fall Board of Directors meeting of the National Association of Railroad
|
||
Passengers was held October 22nd and 23rd at the Merchandise Mart in
|
||
Chicago. This is the third time NARP has met in Chicago, but the city
|
||
always represents a good choice, since it enjoys a central location with
|
||
direct rail service from most parts of the country. Our hotel atop the
|
||
Apparel Center overlooked the busy suburban rail lines feeding Northwestern
|
||
and Union stations. On the day preceding the meeting, early arriving
|
||
attendees were offered tours of Metra's Western Avenue shops, Union
|
||
Station, and Amtrak's maintenance facility.
|
||
Amtrak Issues.
|
||
Despite the pleasant setting, the meeting was a somewhat discordant one.
|
||
Members were frustrated both about the inconsistent quality of Amtrak
|
||
service and the cuts proposed for November, and they took out their
|
||
frustrations on what were seen as failures by a top-heavy management. "If
|
||
only those people at headquarters could be more innovative, or do a better
|
||
job of marketing, or ensure that workers do the jobs they are paid to do."
|
||
Undoubtedly there are things that management could do better and areas in
|
||
which they could economize without affecting service, but the truth of the
|
||
matter is that Amtrak's budget is being squeezed. For years its capital
|
||
budget has not matched depreciation, let alone provided for expansion, and
|
||
its fiscal 1994 operating grant is six percent smaller than last year's.
|
||
This is not sufficient to operate the current system. Much of the capital
|
||
budget is now being eaten up by the need to convert onboard toilets to a
|
||
full retention system and to improve handicapped accessibility.
|
||
The budget squeeze has also reduced spending on maintenance and led to
|
||
layoffs at Beech Grove [maintenance facility], and this has affected
|
||
reliability. The stimulus package submitted to Congress last spring would
|
||
have addressed this last area, but it did was filibustered to death. It is
|
||
easy to look good when resources are adequate, but difficult when they are
|
||
not.
|
||
Several external factors have also contributed to Amtrak's financial
|
||
distress. Not only have airline fare wars adversely affected that
|
||
industry's earnings, they have pulled customers away from Amtrak and
|
||
reduced yield by limiting the railroad's ability to raise fares. And
|
||
further, when Congress passed the budget authorization last summer, it
|
||
exempted the airlines from paying federal fuel taxes for two years on the
|
||
grounds that a fuel tax could force some lines into bankruptcy. But
|
||
railroads were not exempted, and Amtrak is now paying $5.55 million per
|
||
year on this account. Hardly a level playing field, and it certainly does
|
||
not help the cause of energy conservation when fees are waived for the most
|
||
energy intensive mode and charged on the more efficient ones.
|
||
The midwestern floods last summer blocked the running of through trains
|
||
between Chicago and California for several weeks, and this produced a dip
|
||
in Amtrak's revenues at the peak of the travel season. Amtrak normally
|
||
sells out most of the space on Western trains during the summer and relies
|
||
on this revenue to balance the books. And the recent Sunset accident near
|
||
Mobile did not help financial matters, aside from the human tragedy it
|
||
produced.
|
||
Amtrak's management is in a holding pattern right now as it awaits the
|
||
selection of Graham Claytor's replacement [see cover story], and this has
|
||
stifled innovative thinking at the top. Hopefully, a new CEO will begin to
|
||
address some of the fundamental problems facing the corporation.
|
||
Luncheon Speakers.
|
||
One of the highlights of attending any NARP meeting is listening to the
|
||
luncheon speakers, and this year's speakers were no exception. Gil
|
||
Carmichael, the former FRA administrator and now senior VP at Morrison
|
||
Knudsen (MK) spoke to us Friday. He believes that Amtrak is frustrated
|
||
with itself, that Claytor and his staff with 1200 pieces of rolling stock
|
||
have staved off a shutdown, but the equipment is now strained. MK believes
|
||
in a rail renaissance.
|
||
The Staggers Act led to a downsizing of the US rail network, but the
|
||
surviving core has received $40 billion worth of new investment and is now
|
||
in better shape than ever before. But it is only used at 25% of capacity.
|
||
Amtrak and the bus lines should work together to develop a true national
|
||
passenger system.
|
||
Amtrak needs to replace its fleet; and investment bankers will fund
|
||
equipment acquisition and station investments. Better rail access to
|
||
airports is needed, but the stations should be at the terminal and not at
|
||
the edge of the field. Cities should build intermodal terminals downtown,
|
||
in the role they play with airports.
|
||
Freight railroads see opportunities in passengers, not in carrying them,
|
||
but in joint ventures, such as providing corridors and real estate
|
||
development. States should use a penny of their fuel tax to support line
|
||
acquisition and rail service. He cautioned rail supporters to not let
|
||
states raise their gas tax without including the penny for rail.
|
||
The viewpoint of the Clinton Administration was presented on Saturday by
|
||
the new FRA administrator, Jolene Molitoris. She was dynamic and quite
|
||
upbeat, pointing out that this Administration is the first since 1980 to
|
||
put forward a non-zero budget for Amtrak and is also very supportive of
|
||
high-speed rail corridors. She promised that this Administration will be
|
||
proactive, instead of reactive, and will push for a true national
|
||
transportation system, one that is more than just a national highway
|
||
system.
|
||
On the financial side, she noted that budgets will be especially tight in
|
||
FY96 and FY97 as the effort to reduce the deficit takes hold, and she
|
||
clearly felt that corridor services were more important than long-distance
|
||
trains. This thought worried many of the Directors who fear that we could
|
||
end up with a collection of rail corridors and lose the national system.
|
||
NARP Priorities.
|
||
Every six months the Directors reexamine NARP's priorities and select up to
|
||
ten issues on which the organization should now focus its attention. It
|
||
was almost a unanimous decision that the highest priority should be given
|
||
to ensuring adequate funding for Amtrak, both short- and long-term. The
|
||
others, in no particular order, were:
|
||
2) A rail tunnel to connect North and South stations in Boston
|
||
3) The overall quality of rail service;
|
||
4) NARP's goals pamphlet;
|
||
5) Preservation of the national system (in response to Molitoris'
|
||
comments);
|
||
6) ISTEA station enhancements;
|
||
7) Daily long-distance trains (in response to Amtrak's proposed service
|
||
cuts);
|
||
8) Enhanced intermodal connections (very important to Pennsylvania);
|
||
9) More communications by NARP with the media (to give rail perspective).
|
||
|
||
##AA Hearings on Sunset Wreck Yield More Confusion
|
||
Federal hearings into the cause of the fatal derailment of Amtrak's Sunset
|
||
Limited determined that the accident was caused by a barge entering a non-
|
||
navigable bayou and colliding with the railroad bridge, but how the barge
|
||
and its tugboat got there remains a mystery. Members of the tug crew have
|
||
given conflicting accounts, alternately blaming fog, navigational lights,
|
||
and radar failure.
|
||
A formal report will not be out for some time, but uninformed commentators
|
||
dreamed up elaborate bridge safety devices and suggested they be applied to
|
||
every railroad bridge in the country, not knowing that they number in the
|
||
hundreds of thousands and that the cost of such schemes could reach
|
||
billions of dollars. Of course those same commentators never thought about
|
||
who would pay for yet another rail safety overkill measure, or how many
|
||
more people die because they drive instead of riding a train.
|
||
Lawyers at Work
|
||
Meanwhile, attorneys for Amtrak and for crash victims are proceeding with
|
||
multi-million dollar lawsuits against anyone and everyone involved.
|
||
Also on the legal front, Amtrak has sued the operator of a truck which
|
||
became stuck on a grade crossing near Kissimmee, Florida and was smashed by
|
||
Amtrak's Silver Meteor November 30. The trucker was hauling an oversized
|
||
load, and had failed to survey the route or obtain a state-required permit
|
||
for the move. One piece of good news is that the safety cab of the new GE
|
||
"Genesis" locomotive worked exactly as designed, protecting the crew from
|
||
harm and minimizing damage to the train.--MDM
|
||
|
||
##BB Texas TGV Fails to Meet Financial Target
|
||
High-speed rail in the Lone Star state is now much less likely to become a
|
||
reality, thanks to subsidized road and air competition and unrealistic
|
||
financial demands placed on the promoters. The Texas TGV consortium
|
||
announced last month that it could not raise the necessary $170 million in
|
||
private capital necessary to advance the project. The TGV was to have
|
||
served a triangle formed by Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio.
|
||
|
||
##CC Eurorail Views by James S. Morgan
|
||
There are a lot of changes going on in European railroading these days, and
|
||
the impact of these changes is a frequent topic for newspaper editorials
|
||
and articles. I subscribe to a German newspaper, Die Zeit [Time], and
|
||
occasionally buy Le Monde [The World] and El Pais [The Nation], French and
|
||
Spanish papers. This article will review some recent articles which raise
|
||
issues which could affect transit in the Delaware Valley.
|
||
An article in the May 21 issue of Die Zeit entitled "Uber die
|
||
Verfassungswidrigkeit unserer Autos" [On the Unconstitutionality of our
|
||
Automobiles] is a spoof on some antirailroad forces, in which a law
|
||
professor, Michael Ronellen-fitsch, claimed to have discovered a new German
|
||
constitutional right to mobility. He based his argument on an appeal to
|
||
Article 4 of the German constitution, which guarantees freedom of religion.
|
||
Missionaries require mobility. Hence, the failure of the state to build
|
||
more roads restricts the freedom to proselytize.
|
||
Wesel argues that there is no constitutional right to mobility. Instead,
|
||
he relies on Article 2 of the constitution to urge that the use of
|
||
automobiles violates the constitutional guarantee of freedom from bodily
|
||
injury [kšrperliche Unversehrtheit], the inviolability of the person.
|
||
Wesel is mocking conservatives who urge diminution of railway
|
||
appropriations in the name of privatization and the automobile. Note that
|
||
former Chancellor Helmut Schmidt is on the editorial board of the
|
||
newspaper. Wesel seeks to show tongue in cheek that the same basic right
|
||
that the Constitutional Supreme Court in Karlsruhe invoked to deny then
|
||
West German women access to abortion should now be invoked to vouchsafe the
|
||
same right on the highways. The court will not have to criminalize acts,
|
||
but simply lower speed limits!
|
||
The article concludes with a quotation from Erich Honecker, former East
|
||
German Communist Party boss, uttered during his trial for ordering the
|
||
shooting of fleeing refugees. More than 200 refugees were shot, but every
|
||
year 10,000 people die on German highways. Until unification, the use of
|
||
automobiles was restricted in East Germany. Honecker suggests that the
|
||
Department of Governmental Criminality turn its attention to those
|
||
bureaucrats in the West who, unresponsive to public needs, shaped a
|
||
transportation system which kills so many people every year. Wesel
|
||
concludes by saying that when Honecker is right (which may not be often),
|
||
he is right!
|
||
A quasi-satire on the unconstitutionality of automobile travel may not seem
|
||
quite germane to rail transportation. And, of course, the German
|
||
constitutional context is very different from our own, in part as a result
|
||
of measures designed to prevent a recurrence of Nazi atrocities. But then,
|
||
Die Zeit really does not believe that at least British railfans know what
|
||
the relevant issues are. Reiner Luyken's "Funf Uhr dreissig ab Charing
|
||
Cross" [Five thirty from Charing Cross] on in the April 23 issue criticizes
|
||
British attempts to sabotage the Eurotunnel by insisting upon the use of
|
||
diesel locomotives. Luyken pokes fun at British railfans with their
|
||
checklists of ancient diesels that rail enthusiasts should see, and at
|
||
their chauvinistic adoration of British diesels as the best and fastest in
|
||
the world. Such "fans" unwittingly serve the interests of Times readers
|
||
who drive Volvos or Mercedes Benz's and oppose the Eurotunnel because
|
||
British Rail is one of the last non-privatized state enterprises, and a
|
||
symbol of union power.
|
||
Die Zeit does not quite wholeheartedly endorse the French TGV (Train a
|
||
grande vitesse), however. Developments in France suggest that it would not
|
||
be appropriate. "Cinq syndicats de cheminots lancent un appel a la gr<67>ve
|
||
pour le 12 octobre" [Five rail unions call for a strike October 12] in the
|
||
October 8 Le Monde states that the unions believe that the quality and
|
||
safety of public service will be impaired if TGV East continues to be
|
||
financed out of the already indebted Fernch National Railway: SNCF. The
|
||
question is, then, why are local SNCF stations being closed and operations
|
||
being reorganized in favor of TGV service?
|
||
An article by Wolfgang Blum, "Streit um den Superzug" [Controversy over the
|
||
Supertrain], which appeared in the April 9 Die Zeit addresses this question
|
||
both in terms of the French TGV and the German ICE. The ICE is designed
|
||
for service at 250 kilometers per hour or faster, and uses one third more
|
||
electricity per passenger-kilometer than do conventional trains. The ICE
|
||
is energy competitive only in comparison with the automobile and airplane.
|
||
In other words, the ICE and the TGV are forms of rail transit designed to
|
||
be competitive in a privatized transportation industry where speed is king
|
||
because of the preeminence of the automobile and the airplane.
|
||
Blum simply recommends that the environmental costs of automobile and
|
||
airplane travel be taken into account. He does not mount the attack on the
|
||
speed cult which they have engendered that Wesel does. Blum suggests that
|
||
the public be informed that time spent travelling on conventional trains
|
||
can be used for reading, resting or sightseeing in ways in which the time
|
||
spent rushing about in cars, or even planes, cannot be. Some of Blum's
|
||
arguments that train travel time is time that can be better utilized might
|
||
prove valuable to area rail transit advocates. But when I read William
|
||
Vigrass's history of PATCO, I think we need more of Wesel's direct attacks
|
||
on the car cult, and some Luyken-style self-criticism for not having seen
|
||
this earlier.
|
||
|
||
##DD New European Travel, Pass Options
|
||
The passenger rail network in Europe undergoes a dramatic change this year,
|
||
with the opening of the Channel Tunnel. Less obvious are the new tourist
|
||
passes to be offered by the railways. Rail Europe, the joint marketing
|
||
agent for most European railways, has created a pass covering the most
|
||
popular countries for US visitors: France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and
|
||
Switzerland. The traditional Eurailpasses and Flexipasses are still
|
||
available: fares for travel on the Continent have increased about 12
|
||
percent, while British Rail is not increasing its pass rates: with hefty
|
||
fare increases for regular tickets in effect for the run-up to
|
||
privatization, the Britrailpass will be a bargain in 1994.
|
||
More information about rail travel in Europe will be included in next
|
||
month's DVRP. In the meantime, travelers who are considering seeing Europe
|
||
by train should visit their travel agent for more informaÐtion, or call
|
||
Rail Europe, 1-800-438-7245 for a brochure. For do-it-yourselfers, the
|
||
Thomas Cook European Timetable is available at Rand McNally in Liberty
|
||
Place.s--MDM
|
||
|
||
##EE ICE/X2000 Feedback
|
||
by Roger Pitcairn
|
||
The November 1993 Delaware Valley Rail Passenger asked if any DVARP members
|
||
had ridden both the X2000 and the ICE. I did. Specifically, I took the ICE
|
||
once (1 southbound PHL-WAS trip) and the X2000 five times (1 southbound
|
||
express Metroliner NYC-WAS trip; 1 NYC-WAS round trip; and 1 PHL-WAS round
|
||
trip).
|
||
The X2000 wins my vote. The X2000 rode more smoothly and quietly than the
|
||
ICE. Obviously, the X2000's better ride is a function of the tilt
|
||
mechanism which the ICE train lacks. On its native tracks, the ICE train
|
||
may ride smoothly; however, on my trip south, I thought the ride was
|
||
possibly even worse than regular Amtrak equipment. I walked the through
|
||
all the non-first class areas of the ICE and, in doing so, was frequently
|
||
buffeted from side to side. Furthermore, there were no overhead luggage
|
||
racks or grab rails to grasp. (Presumably, in Germany, the ICE track
|
||
conditions are such that no overhead grab rails are needed.) The ICE train
|
||
was surprisingly noisy--the train made a loud high pitched whine throughout
|
||
my trip.
|
||
In term of high tech gadgets, I would say the ICE beats the X2000. The LCD
|
||
color TVs on the seat backs were neat; however, in terms of appearance and
|
||
overall comfort, the X2000 beats the ICE. I think the X2000 designers had
|
||
much better taste than the ICE designers in choosing interior and exterior
|
||
colors. Also, I thought the ICE train's seats had an incredibly ugly shape
|
||
and were extremely uncomfortable--the portions supporting the lower back
|
||
were very hard. Amtrak should have handed out instructions explaining how
|
||
to use the ICE train's features. For most of the trip, I shared a
|
||
compartment with some people and we had lots of fun guessing what various
|
||
knobs, bars, and buttons did!
|
||
|
||
##FF Computer Corner
|
||
A free local computer bulletin board operated by the Philadelphia Area
|
||
Computer Society has a forum where some people discuss transit issues. Dial
|
||
215-842-9600 (8-N-1). Once connected type "J RAIL"' There's also a railfan
|
||
BBS which has a national forum--609-723-1393.
|
||
|
||
##G Have Too Many Assets Been Removed?
|
||
by Chuck Bode
|
||
The Pennsylvanian was nearly on time from Pittsburgh to about six blocks
|
||
from Harrisburg Station October 31 despite an early season snowfall. About
|
||
5:55 pm the train stopped opposite the parking garage slightly west of the
|
||
station. After an extended delay a vague announcement was made. At 6:46 pm
|
||
passengers were told there was a problem with another train and we would
|
||
have to go back. The train backed about four miles onto the Rockville
|
||
bridge (taking over half an hour), changed tracks, and returned to
|
||
Harrisburg--one track south, but otherwise no closer to the station. Still
|
||
a problem with another train.
|
||
The crew claimed to be making PA announcements, but the speakers did not
|
||
work in car 21225. When asked, the crew said that the PA had not worked in
|
||
that car all week. At 7:45 pm a freight train moved on a nearby track. At
|
||
about 8 pm the Pennsylvanian finally proceeded, arriving Harrisburg at 8:04
|
||
pm--2 1/4 hours late.
|
||
Like the Broadway incident reported last month, we must inquire: Why are
|
||
problems so difficult to resolve? While most of the passengers had no
|
||
information, we were fortunate to be sitting behind several railfans with
|
||
scanning radios. The "problem" seems to be that the freight train went past
|
||
a stop signal and then through a switch directly onto the track on which
|
||
the Pennsylvanian was coming--almost causing a head on collision.
|
||
Being a rather serious error, messages over the radio at first were vague
|
||
as the freight crew seemed to figure what to do. It became obvious that the
|
||
situation could not be covered up. Once this stage was reached, it would
|
||
have been logical to back up the freight allowing the Pennsylvanian to
|
||
proceed.
|
||
Afterward, formalities could have been taken care of. What seems to have
|
||
happened instead, is that the freight crew was removed from service for
|
||
drug and alcohol testing following the safety violation, leaving the
|
||
Conrail train standing in the way. It also seems that the railroad has
|
||
been reduced to a single serviceable track, which meant that all train
|
||
service across Pennsylvania came to a halt for two hours while another
|
||
freight crew was brought to the site--along with numerous supervisors and
|
||
signal crew.
|
||
Readers who have been in the Harrisburg area may wonder why it took so long
|
||
to get a crew when there is the huge Enola Yard only a couple miles away.
|
||
The answer is simple--the yard is gone, removed as part of the asset-
|
||
stripping process. The major US railroads have all sold off materials,
|
||
land, equipment and other assets in an effort to both raise immediate cash
|
||
and increase the percentage return on the remaining assets.
|
||
But as in the Broadway breakdown, we find that there are only the barest
|
||
minimal facilities, personnel, and management for the intended scheduled
|
||
operations. Any unscheduled incidents cannot be handled.
|
||
Also, like the Broadway, some far away decisions seem to be made--farther
|
||
along the train made an unscheduled 5 minute stop at Malvern to swap crews
|
||
with a westbound train--adding to the delay. Was this so urgent that it
|
||
could not have been done two minutes later during the scheduled Paoli stop?
|
||
The farthest decisions are political. Is the United States to have a
|
||
functional railroad system? If so, changes are necessary in Washington and
|
||
50 other places including the Harrisburg Capitol Building. Had the trains
|
||
collided, a large part of the blame would have had to be our elected
|
||
officials promotion of highways. How else can we explain the four track
|
||
'Broad Way' mainline dwindling to a single track?
|
||
|
||
##HH Membership Renewal
|
||
A big thank you to the 25% of the members who have paid for 1994. Other
|
||
members are urged to promptly send in their 1994 dues so that the
|
||
volunteers can complete this project before the annual hearing cycle
|
||
begins. Prompt renewal also eliminates the cost and effort of mailing
|
||
renewal notices.
|
||
DVARP is again holding the line on dues so that as many passengers as
|
||
possible can afford to be members. Members who can afford are urged to
|
||
renew at higher rates which support additional projects beyond the
|
||
newsletter. Postage rates decrease as the number of members per zip code
|
||
increases. You can help by recruiting other passengers, co-workers,
|
||
friends, & neighbors to become DVARP members. Or consider gift
|
||
memberships. Don't be bashful--make your voice heard over the highway
|
||
lobby.--CB
|
||
|
||
##II DVARP Considers New By-Laws: We Need Your Opinion!
|
||
DVARP is in the process of revising its by-laws in order to achieve tax-
|
||
exempt status. The first draft of the by-laws has been written and will be
|
||
sent to those who have attend past DVARP meetings for comments/corrections.
|
||
The next step is to have them reviewed by our attorney. The by-laws will
|
||
then be published in the newsletter for your review and comments.
|
||
Any proposed changes will be discussed at a DVARP regular meeting (and any
|
||
special meetings needed) to assure the by-laws writing process is open and
|
||
fair. After final review by an attorney, papers will be filed.
|
||
At this point we need our members to think of one topic: conflict of
|
||
interest. We are in the business of educating the public of the virtues of
|
||
a balanced transportation system. We are also in the business of providing
|
||
information to decision makers. We are but a small voice, and it is
|
||
important that it be a voice which can be trusted.
|
||
People with connections to the transit industry bring important information
|
||
and skills to our organization. But could DVARP's voice be trusted if
|
||
SEPTA, NJT or PATCO employees were elected to the Board of Directors? How
|
||
would we be viewed if officials of the Pennsylvania's highway lobby could
|
||
pack DVARP meetings or even run for a DVARP elected office ?
|
||
The draft By-Laws would create two classes of membership: Subscriber and
|
||
Non-Voting Subscriber. Subscribers will have the right to run for DVARP
|
||
elected office, vote for resolutions at DVARP meetings--in general nothing
|
||
changes from before. Non-Voting Subscribers will not have the right to run
|
||
for DVARP elected office nor to vote upon corporate matters;however, they
|
||
are invited to all meetings to voice their views, and can take part in
|
||
formulating testimony before planning and transportation authorities.
|
||
Non-Voting Subscribers, of course, will continue to receive the newsletter.
|
||
Presently, the conditions for non-voting subscriber classification are if
|
||
the member:
|
||
(1) Is a board member, officer or employee of SEPTA, NJT, Amtrak, DRPA or
|
||
any other public or private common carrier engaged in passenger transport.
|
||
(2) Is an policy making official at any of the state departments of
|
||
transportation in the DVARP coverage area.
|
||
(3) Is a board member, officer or employee of any contractor which receives
|
||
25% or more of its annual revenue from SEPTA, NJT, Amtrak, DRPA or any
|
||
other public or private common carrier engaged in passenger transport.
|
||
(4) Is a board member, officer or employee of any business that is engaged
|
||
primarily in highway reconstruction, highway construction or supplier to
|
||
the highway industry.
|
||
(5) Is a board member, officer or employee of any business that is engaged
|
||
primarily in petroleum industry.
|
||
It should be stressed that DVARP will not be sending out Pinkertons to
|
||
check on each subscriber's status, but it is important that the bylaws
|
||
state these rules (particularly for election to DVARP office) and hope that
|
||
those who fall into the category of non-voting subscriber understand the
|
||
need for our independence.--TB
|
||
|
||
##JJ Volunteer Opportunity: Highway Safety Liaison
|
||
DVARP is looking for a Highway Safety Liaison to foster communication and
|
||
cooperation with safety groups like CRASH (Citizens For Reliable And Safe
|
||
Highways). It is common knowledge among motorists that highway speeds 10-
|
||
15 mph faster than posted limits have been effectively legalized because
|
||
highway patrol agencies look the other way. In addition to their cost in
|
||
lives lost (effectively another public subsidy of highways), these speeds
|
||
extend an unfair competitive advantage over rail passenger service. If you
|
||
are concerned about highway safety and rail transit patronage, why not
|
||
volunteer to serve as our Highway Safety Liaison? Call our volunteer
|
||
hotline, 215-222-3373, message box 4.
|
||
|
||
##KK NARP Regional Meetings
|
||
The annual regional meetings of the National Association of Railroad
|
||
Passengers are coming up. These all-day events feature important guest
|
||
speakers and are an excellent opportunity to discuss issues like intercity
|
||
train service or cooperation among local transit authorities. Region II,
|
||
which includes New York and Connecticuit will meet Sat., Feb. 26 in Albany,
|
||
NY. Call ESPA at 315-963-3169 for information
|
||
Our own Region III (PA, NJ, DE) meets Sat., Apr. 16 in Wilmington. Call
|
||
Doug Andrews, 302-995-6419, for details.
|
||
|
||
##LL Shop Tour for Trolley Coalition
|
||
A unique opportunity to go behind the scenes of SEPTA's Light Rail Division
|
||
will be yours if you come to the Philadelphia Trolley Coalition tour of
|
||
Elmwood District Sunday, January 23. Elmwood is the maintenance and
|
||
storage base for SEPTA's 125-vehicle City LRV fleet.
|
||
Coalition members will be meeting at the Blue Bell, at the corner of
|
||
Woodland Ave. and Island Rd. (across from the depot) for a brown-bag lunch
|
||
before the tour. Call Joel Spivak, 215-755-7717 for more information.
|
||
|
||
##MM SEPTA Board Meeting Schedule
|
||
The SEPTA Board has scheduled its meetings for the fourth Thursday of each
|
||
month (except November and December) in the Board Room on the third floor
|
||
of 714 Market St. As in 1993, meetings will begin at 3:00. Jan. 27, Feb.
|
||
24, Mar. 24, Apr. 28, May 26, June 23, July 28, Aug. 25, Sep. 22, Oct. 27,
|
||
Nov. 17, Dec. 15.
|
||
|
||
##NN DVARP Meeting Schedule
|
||
DVARP will continue its practice of meeting the third Saturday afternoon
|
||
each month, with the exception of April, when the meeting will be Thursday
|
||
night to prevent a conflict with the NARP Region III Meeting. The dates
|
||
are as follows: Jan. 15, Feb. 19, Mar. 19, Apr. 14, May 21, June 18, July
|
||
16, Aug. 20, Sep. 17, Oct. 15, Nov. 19, Dec. 17. Please check the schedule
|
||
printed on the back page of the DVRP each month for possible changes. The
|
||
annual DVARP picnic and meeting will be August 20.
|
||
Meeting locations have been tentatively set for 1994, but are subject to
|
||
confirmation: Jan.-Marcus Hook, Feb.-Center City, Mar.-Collingswood, Apr.-
|
||
Center City, May-Bryn Mawr, June-Doylestown, July-Collingswood, Aug.-
|
||
picnic, Sept.-Center City, Oct.-Norristown, Nov.-Collingswood, Dec.-
|
||
Jenkintown. Again, please check the DVRP each month in case of changes.
|
||
|
||
##OO Conrail Double-Stack Progress
|
||
According to the Conrail Newswire of December 14th, state-sponsored
|
||
clearance work to allow double-stack freight trains to move across
|
||
Pennsylvania is well underway. The employee newsletter states that of the
|
||
total of roughly 140 structures where higher clearances were necessary, 25
|
||
are done.
|
||
Conrail reports that undercutting work is complete on the Trenton Line to
|
||
clear a route between Hagerstown, MD and Oak Island, NJ to accommodate
|
||
double-stack traffic moving on Conrail and the Norfolk Southern. Work is
|
||
also underway on two tunnels on the CP Rail (ex-D&H) route between
|
||
Philadelphia and New York state, Rockport Tunnel and White Haven Tunnel.
|
||
Undercutting work in western Pennsylvania will break for the winter when
|
||
the route is cleared to Conpit Junction, just west of Johnstown. Tunnel
|
||
work and undercutting in eastern Pennsylvania and New Jersey will
|
||
continue.--TB
|
||
|
||
##PP Dates of Interest
|
||
SEPTA on Site (RRD): Thursday mornings: 7:30 to 9:00 am, at Suburban
|
||
Station or Market East Station.
|
||
Center for Greater Philadelphia "Region at the Crossroads" Forum on Land
|
||
Use and Growth Management: Thurs. Jan. 13, 8:00 to 10:00 am at Pennsbury
|
||
Manor, 400 Pennsbury Memorial Rd., Morrisville, PA. Information: Ted
|
||
Hershberg, 215-898-8713.
|
||
FTA/FHWA Workshop on Transportation & Planning Regulations: Jan. 13-14 at
|
||
Sheraton Hotel, Washington
|
||
DVARP South Jersey Committee: Sat., Jan. 15, 10:15 to 11:45 at 104 Edison
|
||
Ave., Collingswood, NJ.
|
||
DVARP General Meeting: Sat., Jan. 15, 1:15 to 4:15 at Mary Campbell
|
||
Library, Post Road, Marcus Hook.
|
||
SEPTA Citizen Advisory Committee: Tues., Jan. 18, 5:45 pm at SEPTA Board
|
||
Room, 714 Market St.
|
||
SEPTA on Site (Suburban Transit): Wed., Jan. 19, 7:30 to 9:30 am and 3:30
|
||
to 5:30 pm at 69th St. Terminal, 7:30 to 9:30 am at Norristown
|
||
Transportation Center.
|
||
Philadelphia Trolley Coalition: Sun. Jan. 23, 2:00 pm at the Blue Bell,
|
||
Woodland and Island Avenue. Bring your own brown bag lunch, beverage and
|
||
dessert provided. Meeting includes tour of Elmwood depot.
|
||
SEPTA Board Meeting: Thu., Jan. 27, 5:45 pm at SEPTA Board Room, 714
|
||
Market St.
|
||
Deadline for February newsletter material: Thurs., Jan. 27, to Matthew
|
||
Mitchell or in DVARP mailbox.
|
||
Delmarva Rail Passenger Association: Thu., Feb. 3., 7:00 pm, in State
|
||
Senate Chamber, Legislative Hall, Dover. Call Doug Andrews, 302-995-6419,
|
||
for more information.
|
||
DVARP Commuter Rail Committee: Sat., Feb. 12, 12:00 at Chestnut Gourmet,
|
||
1121 Chestnut St., Phila.
|
||
DVARP General Meeting: Sat., Feb. 19, 1:00 to 4:00 at Temple University
|
||
Center City, 1616 Walnut St.
|
||
NARP Region II Meeting: Sat., Feb. 26 in Albany, NY. Call ESPA at 315-
|
||
963-3169 for information
|
||
NARP Region III Meeting: Sat., Apr. 16 in Wilmington. Call Doug Andrews,
|
||
302-995-6419, for details.
|
||
Listings based on information provided to DVARP. Contact sponsor to
|
||
confirm time & place.
|
||
Call 215-222-3373, message box 3, to add your event to this calendar.
|
||
|
||
##QQ Up and Down the Corridor
|
||
News of other Northeastern commuter rail and rail transit services
|
||
Feds Intervene in LI Dispute
|
||
A Presidential Emergency Board established under the archaic Railway Labor
|
||
Act handed down a recommended contract settlement for Long Island Rail Road
|
||
employees in a labor dispute going back to 1992. The package includes
|
||
modest wage increases and work rule changes. If the UTU and LIRR cannot
|
||
settle their differences based on this proposal, a settlement can be
|
||
imposed by Congress.
|
||
NJ-LI Tunnel Under Study
|
||
The Star-Ledger reports that the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
|
||
is planning a $5 million study to explore the feasibility of a second Long
|
||
Island to New Jersey connection, via midtown Manhattan. The study will
|
||
also look at the possibility of using such a tunnel to provide freight
|
||
access to Long Island.
|
||
Bronx, LI Opened to Longer Railcars
|
||
Conrail can now handle longer railcars, to destinations in the Bronx and
|
||
Long Island as a result of a project that reduced a curve through the Port
|
||
Morris section of the Bronx. The arc of the curve was reduced by
|
||
realigning 1,700 feet of track, some of it by as much as 25 feet laterally.
|
||
As a result of the $162,000 investment, the curve can now handle railcars
|
||
longer than 70 feet, 6 inches, including centerbeam lumber flat cars as
|
||
long as 73 feet. Previously, lumber shipments bound for points in Long
|
||
Island and the Bronx were unloaded in New Jersey or Connecticut and
|
||
trucked. Now they can move through to Conrail's Oak Point Yard in the
|
||
Bronx or to its interchange with the Long Island Rail Road at Fresh Pond,
|
||
Queens.s
|
||
##RR Voice Mail is Pulse Friendly
|
||
While persons with touch-tone phones can route calls directly to many DVARP
|
||
officers and committees, persons calling from rotary phones are not shut
|
||
out--just stay on the line and leave your message; and your call will be
|
||
forwarded manually to the right person. The recorded greeting is being
|
||
changed to remind callers of this feature.s--DN
|
||
|
||
##SS DVARP Phone & Voice-mail Directory
|
||
DVARP main number (voice mail line) 215-222-3373
|
||
1 Chuck Bode, President 215-222-3373
|
||
5 Tom Borawski, VP-Transportation 215-552-4198
|
||
6 Robert H. Machler, VP-Administration 215-222-3373
|
||
5 Sharon Shneyer, VP-Public Relations 215-386-2644
|
||
3 Matthew Mitchell, Newsletter Editor 215-885-7448
|
||
4 Betsey Clark, Volunteer Coordinator 215-222-3373
|
||
8 Treasurer 215-222-3373
|
||
2 John Pawson, Commuter RR Comm. 215-659-7736
|
||
(6 to 9 pm please)
|
||
3 Transit Committee 215-222-3373
|
||
7 Don Nigro, South Jersey Committee 609-869-0020
|
||
Dan Radack, Bicycle Coordinator 215-232-6303
|
||
Media Hotline (digital beeper) 215-552-4198
|
||
Computer e-mail (internet) 73243.1224@compuserve.com
|
||
|
||
##TT DVARP Membership/Renewal Coupon
|
||
Yes, I want to support improved passenger train service in our region!
|
||
Here are my DVARP membership dues for 1994! 1/94
|
||
Name Membership Number
|
||
Address
|
||
City, State, Zip
|
||
Please choose a membership category below, enclose check and mail to:
|
||
DVARP, PO Box 7505, Philadelphia, PA 19101
|
||
( ) Regular: $15.00 ( ) Family: $20.00 ( ) Supporting: $25.00
|
||
( ) Sustaining: $50.00 ( ) Patron: $75.00 ( ) Benefactor:
|
||
$100.00
|
||
(..) under 21 or over 65: $7.50 ( ) Newsletter Subscription
|
||
only: $7.50
|
||
|
||
##UU Upcoming DVARP Meetings:
|
||
Saturday, January 15, 1:15 to 4:15 Mary Campbell Library, Marcus Hook
|
||
R2 train leaves Suburban Station at 12:25, arrives Marcus Hook 1:02
|
||
Cross to inbound side of tracks, walk two blocks to Post Road (Route 13)
|
||
turn right, walk one block to library, on left
|
||
R2 train leaves Marcus Hook at 4:46, arrives Suburban Station 5:25
|
||
Saturday, February 19, 1:00 to 4:00 Temple University Center City
|
||
Saturday, March 19, 1:00 to 4:00 Collingswood Public Library
|
||
|
||
Agenda for the January meeting:
|
||
1:15 Introductions, agenda, minutes
|
||
1:20 Issues requiring immediate action
|
||
2:00 Other issues
|
||
Commuter Rail Committee:
|
||
Harrisburg Line
|
||
Off-peak and airport service
|
||
|
||
South Jersey Committee:
|
||
Ocean City, Cape May
|
||
Transit Committee:
|
||
New SEPTA streetcars
|
||
Administration:
|
||
By-laws
|
||
Goals for 1994
|
||
|
||
Committee Meetings:
|
||
South Jersey Committee: Sat., Jan. 15, 10:15 at 104 Edison Ave.,
|
||
Collingswood, NJ
|
||
Commuter Rail Committee: Sat., Feb. 12, 12:00 at Chestnut Gourmet, 1121
|
||
Chestnut St.
|
||
|
||
Bulk Rate
|
||
U.S. Postage
|
||
PAID
|
||
Philadelphia, PA
|
||
Permit #721
|
||
DVARP
|
||
P.O. Box 7505
|
||
Philadelphia, PA 19101-7505
|
||
Forwarding and Address Correction Requested
|
||
Return Postage Guaranteed
|
||
Happy New Year!
|
||
Time to renew your membership!
|
||
Use the coupon on page 23
|
||
First Class Mail
|
||
|