639 lines
38 KiB
Plaintext
639 lines
38 KiB
Plaintext
"The release of atom power has changed everything except our way of
|
|
thinking...the solution to this problem lies in the heart of mankind.
|
|
If only I had known, I should have become a watchmaker." A. Einstein
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
BBB III TTT SSS BBB Y Y TTT EEE SSS ONLINE EDITION:
|
|
B B I T S B B Y Y T E S =THE ELECTRONIC
|
|
BBB I T SSS AND BBB YYY T EEE SSS =NEWSLETTER FOR
|
|
B B I T S B B Y T E S =HIGH-TECH
|
|
BBB III T SSS BBB Y T EEE SSS =DUMPSTER DIVERS
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Volume 1, Number 13 (October 26, 1993)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
SPECIAL ISSUE: THE DARK SIDE OF TECHNOLOGY =
|
|
Editorial: The End is Near -|- The Judgement of Thamus =
|
|
Civilization is Like a Jetliner -|- The Cult of Information =
|
|
The Disenchantment of the World -|- The Rhythms of Life =
|
|
Growing Up With Technology -|- We All Live in Bhopal =
|
|
Viruses as Weapons of War -|- Gifts to Posterity =
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Civilization Is Like a Jetliner (T. Fulano)
|
|
|
|
Civilization is like a jetliner, noisy, burning up enormous amounts
|
|
of fuel. Every imaginable and unimaginable crime and pollution had to
|
|
be committed in order to make it go. Whole species were rendered
|
|
extinct, whole populations dispersed. Its shadow on the waters
|
|
resembles an oil slick. Birds are sucked into its jets and vaporized.
|
|
Every part, as Gus Grissom once nervously remarked about space
|
|
capsules before he was burned up in one, has been made by the lowest
|
|
bidder. . . . Civilization is like a jetliner, an idiot savant in the
|
|
cockpit, manipulating computerized controls built by sullen wage
|
|
workers, and dependent for his directions on sleepy technicians high
|
|
on amphetamines with their minds wandering to sports and sex. . . .
|
|
|
|
Civilization is like a 747, filled beyond capacity with coerced
|
|
volunteers -- some in love with the velocity, most wavering at the
|
|
abyss of terror and nausea, yet still seduced by advertising and
|
|
propaganda. . . .
|
|
|
|
Jetliners fall, civilizations fall, this civilization will fall. The
|
|
gauges will be read wrong on some snowy day (perhaps they will fail).
|
|
The wings, supposedly defrosted, will be too frozen to beat against
|
|
the wind and the bird will sink like a millstone, first gratuitously
|
|
skimming a bridge (because civilization is also like a bridge, from
|
|
Paradise to Nowhere), a bridge laden, say, with commuters on their way
|
|
to or from work, which is to say, to or from an airport, packed in
|
|
their cars (wingless jetliners) like additional votive offerings to a
|
|
ravenous Medusa.
|
|
|
|
Then it will dive into the icy waters of a river, the Potomac
|
|
perhaps, or the River Jordan, or Lethe. And we will be inside, each
|
|
one of us at our specially assigned porthole, going down for the last
|
|
time, like dolls' heads encased in Plexiglas. (SOURCE: T. Fulano,
|
|
"Civilization is Like a Jetliner," Fifth Estate, Fall 1983, p. 1,
|
|
reprinted in Questioning Technology (QT) [see B&B Bookshelf])
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
EDITORIAL:
|
|
|
|
It's time to bite the hands of the dogs that feed (and clothe and
|
|
shelter) me, and to indulge my deepest fears about the technology I
|
|
love to go on about. These are scary times we're living in. The
|
|
Chinese are recruiting unemployed Russian physicists to speed up their
|
|
ballistic and nuclear weapons programs. (Wall Street Journal,
|
|
10/14/93, p. A12), Russian nuclear weapons and materials are being
|
|
sold on the black market to the highest bidder, and "Peacekeeping
|
|
forces" are fighting bloody skirmishes around the world. Closer to
|
|
home people are being killed in their homes and cars and on the
|
|
streets in rising numbers, often for no apparent reason. Terrorist
|
|
cells are hatching plots to bring the great Satan (that's us, and the
|
|
reputation is not entirely undeserved) to its knees. Children kill
|
|
their parents, men kill their girlfriends and grandparents. Striking a
|
|
blow for women's lib, women are striking back, killing their
|
|
boyfriends and castrating their husbands. There are fears that
|
|
unpopular court verdicts will spark rioting in the streets. Let's not
|
|
even discuss what tends to happen around millenniums, the next of
|
|
which is less than 7 years away. The natives are restless, and with
|
|
good reason: things are going to hell in a handbasket by most any
|
|
objective measurement. Lester Thurow's Worldwatch Institute issues a
|
|
yearly State of the World report, available at your library or better
|
|
bookstores, that gathers socio-economic, environmental, political, and
|
|
industrial and other data and statistics in an attempt to put the big
|
|
picture into perspective. It ain't pretty. You may disagree with
|
|
Thurow's analysis, but the facts and figures speak for themselves, and
|
|
are there in black and white for you to draw your own conclusions. We
|
|
are doomed, I tell you, utterly and irrevocably doomed. Head for the
|
|
hills I tell you! The end is near!
|
|
|
|
How much is technology to blame for this dismal state of affairs? And
|
|
what can technology (and we, its creators and users) do to help solve
|
|
these problems? These are questions we desparately need to think
|
|
about, just in case it's not already too late. This time around, I'm
|
|
going to accentuate the negative. As long as this issue is, I realize
|
|
I didn't get to a some topics I would have liked to have covered, like
|
|
the dangers of electric radiation, and health problems like carpal
|
|
tunnel syndrome. For some comic relief, I've compiled a list of
|
|
horror/monster movies you may want to enjoy around the Halloween
|
|
season, and which also relate somewhat to the topic at hand.
|
|
|
|
Just for the record, on good days I think we're going to make it
|
|
through to the next millennium and onward to the stars, but those good
|
|
days are getting fewer and further between. Let me know how *you*
|
|
feel. Please see the administrivia section for important new access
|
|
information. We'll be back in about a week with latest news. See you
|
|
then, and - have a nice day.
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
The Judgment of Thamus (Neil Postman)
|
|
|
|
You will find in Plato's Phaedrus a story about Thamus, the king of a
|
|
great city of Upper Egypt. For people such as ourselves, who are
|
|
inclined (in Thoreau's phrase) to be tools of our tools, few legends
|
|
are more instructive than his. The story, as Socrates tells it to his
|
|
friend Phaedrus, unfolds in the following way: Thamus once entertained
|
|
the god Theuth, who was the inventor of many things, including number,
|
|
calculation, geometry, astronomy, and writing. Theuth exhibited his
|
|
inventions to King Thamus, claiming that they should be made widely
|
|
known and available to Egyptians. Socrates continues:
|
|
|
|
Thamus inquired into the use of each of them, and as Theuth went
|
|
through them expressed approval or disapproval, according as he
|
|
judged Theuth's claims to be well or ill founded. It would take too
|
|
long to go through all that Thamus is reported to have said for and
|
|
against each of Theuth's inventions. But when it came to writing,
|
|
Theuth declared. "Here is an accomplishment, my lord the King, which
|
|
will improve both the wisdom and the memory of the Egyptians. I have
|
|
discovered a sure receipt for memory and wisdom." To this, Thamus
|
|
replied, "Theuth, my paragon of inventors, the discoverer of an art
|
|
is not the best judge of the good or harm which will accrue to those
|
|
who practice it. So it is in this; you, who are the father of writing,
|
|
have out of fondness for your offspring attributed to it quite the
|
|
opposite of its real function. Those who acquire it will cease to
|
|
exercise their memory and become forgetful; they will rely on writing
|
|
to bring things to their remembrance by external signs instead of by
|
|
their own internal resources. What you have discovered is a receipt
|
|
for recollection, not for memory. And as for wisdom, your pupils
|
|
will have the reputation for it without the reality they will receive
|
|
a quantity of information without proper instruction, and in
|
|
consequence be thought very knowledgeable when they are for the most
|
|
part quite ignorant. And because they are filled with the conceit of
|
|
wisdom instead of real wisdom they will be a burden to society."
|
|
|
|
I begin my book with this legend because in Thamus' response there
|
|
are several sound principles from which we may begin to learn how to
|
|
think with wise circumspection about a technological society. In fact,
|
|
there is even one error in the judgment of Thamus, from which we may
|
|
also learn something of importance. The error is not in his claim that
|
|
writing will damage memory and create false wisdom. It is demonstrable
|
|
that writing has had such an effect. Thamus' error is in his believing
|
|
that writing will be a burden to society and nothing but a burden. For
|
|
all his wisdom, he fails to imagine what writing's benefits might be,
|
|
which, as we know, have been considerable. We may learn from this that
|
|
it is a mistake to suppose that any technological innovation has a
|
|
one-sided effect. Every technology is both a burden and a blessing;
|
|
not either-or, but this-and-that.
|
|
|
|
Nothing could be more obvious, of course, especially to those who
|
|
have given more than two minutes of thought to the matter.
|
|
Nonetheless, we are currently surrounded by throngs of zealous
|
|
Theuths, one-eyed prophets who see only what new technologies can do
|
|
and are incapable of imagining what they will undo. We might call such
|
|
people technophiles. They gaze on technology as a lover does on his
|
|
beloved, seeing it as without blemish and entertaining no apprehension
|
|
for the future. They are therefore dangerous and are to be approached
|
|
cautiously. On the other hand, some one-eyed prophets, such as I (or
|
|
so I am accused), are inclined to speak only of burdens (in the manner
|
|
of Thamus) and are silent about the opportunities that new
|
|
technologies make possible. The Technophiles must speak for
|
|
themselves, and do so all over the place. My defense is that a
|
|
dissenting voice is sometimes needed to moderate the din made by the
|
|
enthusiastic multitudes. If one is to err, it is better to err on the
|
|
side of Thamusian skepticism. But it is an error nonetheless. And I
|
|
might note that, with the exception of his judgment on writing, Thamus
|
|
does not repeat this error. You might notice on rereading the legend
|
|
that he gives arguments for and against each of Theuth's inventions.
|
|
For it is inescapable that every culture must negotiate with
|
|
technology, whether it does so intelligently or not. A bargain is
|
|
struck in which technology giveth and technology taketh away. The wise
|
|
know this well, and are rarely impressed by dramatic technological
|
|
changes, and never overjoyed. . . .
|
|
|
|
Had King Thamus been as wise as reputed, he would not have forgotten
|
|
to include in his judgment a prophecy about the powers that writing
|
|
would enlarge. There is a calculus of technological change that
|
|
requires a measure of even-handedness. . . .
|
|
|
|
[Thalmus knew] . . . that the uses made or any technology are largely
|
|
determined by the structure of the technology itself -- that is, that
|
|
its functions follow from its form. . . . we may learn from Thamus the
|
|
following: once a technology is admitted, it plays out its hand; it
|
|
does what it is designed to do. Our task is to understand what that
|
|
design is -- that is to say, when we admit a new technology to the
|
|
culture, we must do so with our eyes wide open. (Excerpted from
|
|
Chapter One of "Technopoly: The Surrender of Culture to Technology"
|
|
by Neil Postman (Alfred A. Knopf, 1992)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
The Disenchantment of the World (Morris Berman)
|
|
|
|
The story of the modern epoch, at least on the level of mind, is one
|
|
of progressive disenchantment. From the sixteenth century on, mind has
|
|
been progressively expunged from the phenomenal world. At least in
|
|
theory, the reference points for all scientific explanation are matter
|
|
and motion -- what historians of science refer to as the "mechanical
|
|
philosophy". Developments that have thrown this world view into
|
|
question -- quantum mechanics, for example, or certain types of
|
|
contemporary ecological research -- have not made any significant dent
|
|
in the dominant mode of thinking. That mode can best be described as
|
|
disenchantment, non participation, for it insists on a rigid
|
|
distinction between observer and observed. Scientific consciousness is
|
|
alienated consciousness: there is no ecstatic merger with nature, but
|
|
rather total separation from it. subject and object are always seen in
|
|
opposition to each other. I am not my experiences, and thus not really
|
|
a part of the world around me. The logical end point of this world
|
|
view is a feeling of total reification: everything is an object,
|
|
alien, not-me; and I am ultimately an object too, an alienated "thing"
|
|
in a world of other, equally meaningless things. This world is not of
|
|
my own making; the cosmos cares nothing for me, and I do not really
|
|
feel a sense of belonging to it. What I feel, in fact, is a sickness
|
|
in the soul.
|
|
|
|
Translated into everyday life, what does this disenchantment mean? It
|
|
means that the modern landscape has become a scenario of "mass
|
|
administration and blatant violence", a state of affairs now clearly
|
|
perceived by the man in the street. The alienation and futility that
|
|
characterized the perceptions of a handful of intellectuals at the
|
|
beginning of the century have come to characterize the consciousness
|
|
of the common man at its end. Jobs are stupefying, relationships vapid
|
|
and transient, the arena of politics absurd. In the vacuum created by
|
|
the collapse of traditional values, we have hysterical evangelical
|
|
revivals, mass conversions to the Church of the Reverend Moon, and a
|
|
general retreat into the oblivion provided by drugs, television and
|
|
tranquilizers. We also have a desperate search for therapy, by now a
|
|
national obsession, as millions of Americans try to reconstruct their
|
|
lives amidst a pervasive feeling of anomie and cultural
|
|
disintegration. An age in which depression is a norm is a grim one
|
|
indeed.
|
|
|
|
Perhaps nothing is more symptomatic of this general malaise than the
|
|
inability of the industrial economies to provide meaningful work. Some
|
|
years ago, Herbert Marcuse described the blue- and white-collar
|
|
classes in America as "one-dimensional". "When technics becomes the
|
|
universal form of material production", he wrote, "it circumscribes an
|
|
entire culture; it projects a historical totality -- a 'world"' One
|
|
cannot speak of alienation as such, he went on, because there is no
|
|
longer a self to be alienated. We have all been bought off, we all
|
|
sold out to the System long ago and now identify with it completely.
|
|
"People recognize themselves in their commodities", Marcuse concluded;
|
|
they have become what they own.
|
|
|
|
But keeping free from the System is not a viable option. As
|
|
technological and bureaucratic modes of thought permeate the deepest
|
|
recesses of our minds, the preservation of psychic space has become
|
|
almost impossible. "High-potential candidates" for management
|
|
positions in American corporations customarily undergo a type of
|
|
finishing-school education that teaches them how to communicate
|
|
persuasively, facilitate social interaction, read body language, and
|
|
so on. This mental framework is then imported into the sphere of
|
|
personal and sexual relations. One thus learns, for example, how to
|
|
discard friends who may prove to be career obstacles and to acquire
|
|
new acquaintances who will assist in one's advancement. The employee's
|
|
spouse is also evaluated as an asset or liability in terms of their
|
|
diplomatic skills. And for most males in the industrial nations, the
|
|
sex act itself has literally become a project, a matter of carrying
|
|
out the proper techniques so as to achieve the prescribed goal and
|
|
thus win the desired approval. Pleasure and intimacy are seen almost
|
|
as a hindrance to the act. But once the ethos of technique and
|
|
management has permeated the spheres of sexuality and friendship,
|
|
there is literally no place left to hide. The "widespread climate of
|
|
anxiety and neurosis" in which we are immersed is thus inevitable.
|
|
|
|
The statistics that reflect this condition in America alone are so
|
|
grim as to defy comprehension. There is now a significant suicide rate
|
|
among the seven-to-ten age group, and teenage suicides tripled between
|
|
1966 and 1976 to roughly thirty per day. . . . Dr. Darold Treffert, of
|
|
Wisconsin's Mental Health Institute, observed that millions of
|
|
children and young adults are now plagued by "a gnawing emptiness or
|
|
meaninglessness expressed not as a fear of what may happen to them,
|
|
but rather as a fear that nothing will happen to them". . . .
|
|
In the early 1970s, it was reported that 25 million adults were using
|
|
Valium; by 1980, Food and Drug Administration figures indicated that
|
|
Americans were downing benzodiazepines (the class of tranquilizers
|
|
which includes Valium) at a rate of 5 billion pills a year. . . .
|
|
one-fourth of the American female population in the thirty-to-sixty
|
|
age group uses psychoactive prescription drugs on a regular basis.
|
|
Articles in popular magazines such as Cosmopolitan urge sufferers from
|
|
depression to drop in to the local mental hospital for drugs or shock
|
|
treatments, so that they can return to their jobs as quickly as
|
|
possible. "The drug and the mental hospital", writes one political
|
|
scientist, "have become the indispensable lubricating oil and
|
|
reservicing factory needed to prevent the complete breakdown of the
|
|
human engine". (Excerpted from "The Reenchantment of the World" by
|
|
Morris Berman, Cornell University Press, 1981, reprinted in QT)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
When asked by a reporter what he thought of modern civilization,
|
|
Gandhi was said to have replied, "I think it would be a good idea."
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
The Rhythms of Life (Stanley Diamond)
|
|
|
|
In machine-based societies, the machine has incorporated the demands
|
|
of the civil power or of the market, and the whole life of society, of
|
|
all classes and grades, must adjust to its rhythms. Time becomes
|
|
lineal, secularized, "precious"; it is reduced to an extension in
|
|
space that must be filled up, and sacred time disappears. The
|
|
secretary must adjust to the speed of her electric typewriter; the
|
|
stenographer to the stenotype machine; the factory worker to the line
|
|
or lathe; the executive to the schedule of the train or plane and the
|
|
practically instantaneous transmission of the telephone; the chauffeur
|
|
to the superhighways; the reader to the endless stream of printed
|
|
matter from high-speed presses; even the schoolboy to the precise
|
|
periodization of his day and to the watch on his wrist; the person
|
|
"at leisure" to a mechanized domestic environment and the flow of
|
|
efficiently scheduled entertainment. The machines seem to run us,
|
|
crystallizing in their mechanical or electronic pulses the means of
|
|
our desires. The collapse of time to an extension in space, calibrated
|
|
by machines, has bowdlerized our natural and human rhythms and helped
|
|
dissociate us from ourselves. Even now, we hardly love the earth or
|
|
see with eyes or listen any longer with our ears, and we scarcely feel
|
|
our hearts beat before they break in protest. Even now, so faithful
|
|
and exact are the machines as servants that they seem an alien force,
|
|
persuading us at every turn to fulfill our intentions which we have
|
|
built into them and which they represent -- in much the same way that
|
|
the perfect body servant routinizes and, finally, trivializes his
|
|
master. (Excerpted from "In Search of the Primitive," by Stanley
|
|
Diamond [Transaction Books, 1974], reprinted in QT(see B&B Bookshelf))
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Faster Faster -- Make It Perfect (Jerry Mander)
|
|
|
|
In our society, speed is celebrated as if it were a virtue in itself.
|
|
And yet as far as most human beings are concerned, the acceleration of
|
|
the information cycle has only inundated us with an unprecedented
|
|
amount of data, most of which is unusable in any practical sense. The
|
|
true result has been an increase in human anxiety, as we try to keep
|
|
up with the growing stream of information. Our nervous systems
|
|
experience the acceleration more than our intellects do. It's as if we
|
|
were all caught at a socially approved video game, where the
|
|
information on the screen comes faster and faster as we earnestly try
|
|
to keep up. (Excerpted from "In The Absence of the Sacred: The Failure
|
|
of Technology & the Survival of the Indian Nations" by Jerry Mander
|
|
(Sierra Club Books, 1991)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
We All Live in Bhopal (George Bradford)
|
|
|
|
The industrialization of the Third World is a story familiar to anyone
|
|
who takes even a glance at what is occurring. The colonial countries
|
|
are nothing but a dumping ground and pool of cheap labor for
|
|
capitalist corporations. Obsolete technology is shipped there along
|
|
with the production of chemicals, medicines and other products banned
|
|
in the developed world. Labor is cheap, there are few if any safety
|
|
standards, and *costs are cut*. But the formula of cost-benefit still
|
|
stands: the costs are simply borne by others, by the victims of Union
|
|
Carbide, Dow, and Standard Oil.
|
|
|
|
A powerful image: industrial civilization as one vast, stinking
|
|
extermination camp. We all live in Bhopal, some closer to the gas
|
|
chambers and to the mass graves, but all of us close enough to be
|
|
victims. And Union Carbide is obviously not a fluke -- the poisons are
|
|
vented in the air and water, dumped in rivers, ponds and streams, fed
|
|
to animals going to market, sprayed on lawns and roadways, sprayed on
|
|
food crops, every day, everywhere. The result may not be as dramatic
|
|
as Bhopal (which then almost comes to serve as a diversion, a
|
|
deterrence machine to take our minds off the pervasive reality which
|
|
Bhopal truly represents), but it is as deadly. When ABC News asked
|
|
University of Chicago professor of public Health and author of The
|
|
Politics of Cancer, Jason Epstein, if he thought a Bhopal-style
|
|
disaster could occur in the US, he replied: "I think what we're seeing
|
|
in America is far more slow-not such large accidental occurrences, but
|
|
a slow, gradual leakage with the result that you have excess cancers
|
|
or reproductive abnormalities."
|
|
|
|
In fact, birth defects have doubled in the last 25 years. And cancer
|
|
is on the rise. In an interview with the Guardian, Hunter College
|
|
professor David Kotelchuck described the "Cancer Atlas" maps published
|
|
in 1975 by the Department of Health, Education and Welfare. "Show me a
|
|
red spot on these maps and I'll show you an industrial center of the
|
|
US", he said. "There aren't any place names on the maps but you can
|
|
easily pick out concentrations of industry. See, it's not Pennsylvania
|
|
that's red it's just Philadelphia, Erie and Pittsburgh. Look at West
|
|
Virginia here, there's only two red spots, the Kanawha Valley, where
|
|
there are nine chemical plants including Union Carbide's, and this
|
|
industrialized stretch of the Ohio River. It's the same story wherever
|
|
you look." (SOURCE: George Bradford, "We All Live in Bhopal," Fifth
|
|
Estate, Winter 1985, p. 1, reprinted in QT)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Viruses as Weapons of War (John McAfee and Colin Hayes)
|
|
|
|
Officials tend to be scornful of suggestions that viruses will become
|
|
an important terrorist weapon or threat to national security. A
|
|
Congressional report on the issue acknowledged that the possibility of
|
|
terrorist computer virus activity has disturbing implications, but it
|
|
paid little attention to this topic because there have been few
|
|
recorded instances of viral assaults directed at specific targets --
|
|
so far. In fact, the terrorist threat is being taken far more
|
|
seriously by the authorities than they are
|
|
revealing. Fortunately, there is now an awareness among those
|
|
advising government agencies on their computer security that, contrary
|
|
to some well-publicized expert opinions, terrorists can pick
|
|
vulnerable targets for viruses with comparative ease.
|
|
|
|
It should be a cause for concern that high-level terrorist groups are
|
|
studying the use of viruses, just as governments are worried that
|
|
terrorists may one day use nuclear devices or chemical and biological
|
|
technology to further their political aims. The computer virus is
|
|
especially tempting for them. They could put together a team of people
|
|
with software engineering skills who, with very little risk, could
|
|
launch an electronic offensive with the potential to seriously disrupt
|
|
the affairs of any nation.
|
|
|
|
Indeed, computer viruses could begin to change the political balance
|
|
of power in a remarkable way. They represent the first weapons that
|
|
could be deployed at both low cost and comparatively little risk by
|
|
individuals, groups, or small countries against big business or the
|
|
major powers. A hostile Third World government can readily acquire the
|
|
potential ability to cause serious damage to computer installations in
|
|
Moscow, Washington, or any other seat of political, military, or
|
|
economic power. A country that is not critically dependent on
|
|
computers could unleash viruses with capabilities to paralyze data
|
|
processing in more technically sophisticated nations. Such a
|
|
government would not need to concern itself with targeting those
|
|
viruses accurately to contain their spread and thus protect the
|
|
perpetrators from the risk of being infected themselves. (SOURCE:
|
|
"Computer Viruses, Worms, Data Diddlers, Killer Programs, and Other
|
|
Threats to Your System" by John McAfee and Colin Hayes (St. Martin's
|
|
Press, 1989)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
The Cult of Information (Theodore Roszak)
|
|
|
|
Is it wise to commit the society so massively to a technology that is
|
|
so vulnerable to widespread breakdown, error, sabotage, and criminal
|
|
tampering? The computer makers and computer scientists have no doubt
|
|
that it is. And having won the commanding heights of the economy, they
|
|
are moving rapidly to find other frontiers for investment. The current
|
|
effort is to graft the microcomputer on to as many aspects of daily
|
|
life as possible, so that our homes, workplaces, and schools will soon
|
|
be no less dependent on the flow of electronic information. Without a
|
|
steady supply, the children will not be able to learn, checkbooks will
|
|
go unbalanced, appointments will not be scheduled, taxes will not be
|
|
paid...possibly dinner will not reach the table.
|
|
|
|
The office work force is currently one of the major targets of the
|
|
data merchants. . . . The fully computerized office will do for white
|
|
collar work what the automated assembly line has done in the
|
|
factories: it will "save labor by eliminating it, starting with the
|
|
file clerks and secretaries, but soon reaching to the junior
|
|
executives and the sales force. Possibly these casualties of progress
|
|
will find work at Burger King down the street, where the cash
|
|
registers come equipped with pictures, not numbers, or as the janitors
|
|
who clean up whatever there is left to clean up at the end of the day-
|
|
at least until these jobs are turned over to robots. There may soon be
|
|
no one left in the high-rise ziggurats of our cities but a small elite
|
|
of top-level decision makers surrounded by electronic apparatus. They
|
|
will be in touch around the globe with others of their kind, the only
|
|
decently paid work force left in the information economy, manipulating
|
|
spreadsheets, crafting takeover bids, transferring funds from bank to
|
|
bank at the speed of light, arranging "power lunches." As time goes
|
|
by, there will be less and less for them to do, for even decision
|
|
making can be programmed. . . .
|
|
|
|
At that point, even the corporate leadership will not have to report
|
|
to the office. Most of what needs to be done by way of human
|
|
intervention will be done out of the home. One forms an eerie vision
|
|
of the high industrial future: a vista of glass towers standing empty
|
|
in depopulated business districts where only machines are on the job
|
|
networking with other machines. (SOURCE: Theodore Roszak, "The Cult
|
|
of Information" (Pantheon Books, 1986). pp.)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Growing Up With Technology (Jerry Mander)
|
|
|
|
The new value system that was sold in the forties and fifties was
|
|
designed to fuel the most massive expansion of the U.S. industrial and
|
|
marketing sectors in history. The "American way of life" became an
|
|
advertising theme; it drew an explicit equation between how much you
|
|
consumed and how American you were. During the Truman-Eisenhower years,
|
|
the American ideal of consumerism was directly juxtaposed with
|
|
Russia's emphatically nonconsumerist stance. In the I950S, buying a
|
|
washing machine was a blow against communism.
|
|
|
|
This value system incorporated certain key attitudes: Technological
|
|
innovation is good. It is always good. It aids health. It saves labor.
|
|
It is the engine that drives economic growth, which in turn drives the
|
|
American standard of living upward, which benefits all people.
|
|
Technical innovation promotes democracy, freedom, and leisure.
|
|
Technical and scientific progress will spread around the world and
|
|
relieve all people of the awful toil that has oppressed them since the
|
|
dawn of time. Someday, every place will look like the World's Fair. It
|
|
is inevitable. You can't turn back the clock.
|
|
|
|
For me, going through my teenage years in that period; for my family
|
|
and neighbors; and I believe for most Americans, there was the
|
|
disposition to go along with it all. Swept along by the rhetoric and
|
|
hype, it was as though we found ourselves living within a gigantic
|
|
environmental theatre. We sat and watched while they rolled away one
|
|
diorama and replaced it with another and then another. While our world
|
|
was being dramatically transformed, while places we loved were fast
|
|
deteriorating, while lifestyles were
|
|
sharply altered, while the forest receded, while open land was paved
|
|
over and built upon, while pollution and smog became commonplace,
|
|
while small towns began to look like New York City, and New York City
|
|
began to resemble Fritz Lang's Metropolis, we watched as if it were a
|
|
movie.
|
|
|
|
To say that we, the public, had no participation in these vast changes
|
|
would be inaccurate. We lived in the world; we interacted with the
|
|
changing environment. By our silence we gave our tacit approval. But
|
|
no one ever inquired into what we thought about it all. No one ever
|
|
indicated that there could be a question about the process. It all
|
|
happened so fast, and with so much power, it was difficult to grasp
|
|
what was changing, as it was changing. The process itself overpowered
|
|
all doubt. We asked no questions. We never had time to think it
|
|
through. Even if we'd had the time, we didn't have the thoughts or the
|
|
words by which to articulate our concerns. There was no language of
|
|
technological evaluation, nor is there one now. The parameters of the
|
|
discussion, even the parameters of thought, were predefined by
|
|
corporate, governmental, and scientific institutions. No formal means
|
|
existed by which ordinary people could engage in discussions or
|
|
debates, or could hear the pros and cons of what was happening. There
|
|
were no national referenda, save for what appeared in the media. And
|
|
the media reports were mainly confined to advertising or government
|
|
predictions. If there existed an alternative view, it remained within
|
|
intellectual and cultural circles not visible to the average American.
|
|
|
|
In the absence of an alternative vision, the paradigm was confirmed
|
|
that technological innovation was good, invariably good, and would be
|
|
the principal means by which our society would solve its problems and
|
|
produce a better world.
|
|
|
|
Fifty years later, however, as the world hurtles toward its greatest
|
|
environmental crisis since the dawn of human life, a crisis driven by
|
|
the insatiable need to feed resources to the technological machine,
|
|
and to consume them as commodities, we are at an appropriate moment to
|
|
question whether this path we have chosen and celebrated has lived up
|
|
to its promise, and if not, if it ever will. (Excerpted from Chapter
|
|
One of "In The Absence of the Sacred: The Failure of Technology & the
|
|
Survival of the Indian Nations" by Jerry Mander (Sierra Club Books,
|
|
1991)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Bits and Bytes Bookshelf:
|
|
|
|
Questioning Technology: Tool, Toy or Tyrant Edited by John Zerzan
|
|
and Alice Carnes (New Society Publishers, 1991. 222 pp. $12.95)
|
|
|
|
- If you enjoyed this issue of B&B, you will enjoy this critical
|
|
anthology of writings on issues related to the downside of
|
|
technology. This book is from a small press, so you may have trouble
|
|
finding it. It can be ordered directly from the publisher at: PO BOX
|
|
582, Santa Cruz, CA 95061. Add $1.75 for shipping and handling.
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Thirteen for Halloween: Some Horror/Scifi/Monster Movies Worth Renting
|
|
|
|
1) Alien (1979, dir: Ridley Scott) A very scary sci-fi horror movie
|
|
that takes place in a claustrophobic, dilapidated spaceship.
|
|
2) The Andromeda Strain (971, dir: Robert Wise) Great techno-thriller
|
|
based on a Michael Critchon novel. A virus from outer space
|
|
threatens to wipe out mankind. Can science save the day?
|
|
3) Blade Runner (1982, dir: Ridley Scott) A cyberpunk sci-fi vision
|
|
set in Los Angeles in the 2st century. Harrison Ford must find and
|
|
kill Rutger Hauer, a superhuman replicant. A visual feast.
|
|
4) A Clockwork Orange (1971, dir: Stanley Kubrick) Government mind
|
|
control experiments, a nihilistic future where young "droogs" roam
|
|
the street committing random acts of violence. Sound familiar?
|
|
5) Dr. Strangelove or How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb
|
|
(1963, dir: Stanley Kubrick) Not a horror film, but the blackest of
|
|
black comedies, with Peter Sellers playing 3 different roles.
|
|
"Hey, you can't fight in here -- this is the war room!"
|
|
6) The Fly (1958, dir: Kurt Neumann/1986, dir: David Cronenberg) Both
|
|
versions have their charm. Mad scientists run amuck! The remake is
|
|
quite gross and disturbing. I liked it.
|
|
7) Forbidden Planet (1956, dir: Fred Wilcox) Great special effects!
|
|
Robby the Robot! Vanished alien civilizations! The monster from the
|
|
Id! Space vixens! Leslie Nielsen! Entertaining fluff!
|
|
8) Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956, Dir: Don Siegal) The pod
|
|
people are coming! This chilling tale is a metaphor for the domes-
|
|
tication of the American Spirit during the Eisenhower years.
|
|
9) Metropolis (1926, Dir: Fritz Lang) A visual and emotional
|
|
masterpiece. And an accurate projection of futuristic society.
|
|
This is a movie that will stay with you long after you see it.
|
|
10)Road Warrior (1981, Dir: George Miller) In a post nuclear future,
|
|
Mel Gibson drives around a desolate landscape battling a tribe of
|
|
punked out killers on wheels. Great chase sequences, good fun.
|
|
11)Robocop (1987, Dir: Paul Verhoeven) Extremely violent, nihilistic
|
|
view of the future. Sharp digs at corporate greed abound in this
|
|
black comedy. Make sure you get the first one.
|
|
12)Them! (1954, Dir: Gordon Douglas) Needed at least one giant
|
|
mutated monster movie, and this is one of the best. The atomic
|
|
critters in this case are ants. Great cheesy fun.
|
|
13)THX 1138 (1971, dir: George Lucas) George "Star Wars" Lucas'
|
|
directorial debut is an atmospheric sci-fi movie set in a
|
|
chilling, dystopian future.
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Gifts to Posterity (Bruce Sterling)
|
|
|
|
We're already leaving some impressive gifts for the remote future
|
|
of this planet. Nuclear wastes, for instance. We're going to be
|
|
neatly archiving this repulsive trash in concrete and salt mines
|
|
and fused glass canisters, for tens of thousands of years. Imagine
|
|
the pleasure of discovering one of these nice radioactive time-bombs
|
|
six thousand years from now. Imagine the joy of selfless, dedicated
|
|
archaeologists burrowing into one of these twentieth- century
|
|
pharaoh's tombs and dropping dead, slowly and painfully. Gosh,
|
|
thanks, ancestors. Thanks, twentieth century! Thanks for thinking
|
|
of us! (Bruce Sterling, from "Free as Air, Free As Water, Free As
|
|
Knowledge," a speech given to the Library Information Technology
|
|
Association in June of 1992)
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
### ADMINISTRIVIA ###
|
|
|
|
NEW INSTRUCTIONS FOR SUBSCRIBING AND UNSUBSCRIBING: I am pleased to
|
|
announce that B&B is now available via listserver. Subscribe to it
|
|
by mailing listserv@acad1.dana.edu, no subject, text:
|
|
SUBSCRIBE bits-n-bytes. A confirmation will be mailed to you. To
|
|
unsubscribe send a message to listserv@acad1.dana.edu, no subject,
|
|
text: UNSUBSCRIBE bits-n-bytes . Notice that your email address is no
|
|
longer necessary in the message body. If you're already subscribed,
|
|
there's no need to do anything.
|
|
|
|
THANKS to everyone who wrote with thoughts and suggestions, thanks to
|
|
the folks at alt.quotations, and MAJOR THANKS to Paul Snow for setting
|
|
me up with the listserver mechanism, thereby freeing up a major chunk
|
|
of time for me to devote to B&B's editorial content. Greetings and
|
|
whuzzup to the Extropian community, an enclave of hopeless optimists
|
|
if ever there was one, and who *might* have a bone or two to pick
|
|
with me regarding this issue's contents. See you in a week or so,
|
|
where we'll catch up with all the high tech news.
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
BITS AND BYTES ONLINE, an electronic newsletter for text-based life-
|
|
forms, is now published irregularly, 2 or 3 times a month. As one
|
|
reader pointed out, it was quantity or quality. I chose the latter.
|
|
*This newsletter is printed on 100% recycled electrons*
|
|
======================================================================
|
|
Jay Machado = (Copyright 1993 Jay Machado) *unaltered* =
|
|
1529 Dogwood Drive = ELECTRONIC distribution of this file for =
|
|
Cherry Hill, NJ 08003 = non-profit purposes is encouraged. =
|
|
ph (eve) 609/795-0998 = The editor is solely responsible for the =
|
|
======================== editorial content. Opinions expressed are =
|
|
not necesarily shared by the editor, and are subject to change w/o =
|
|
prior notice. The copyright for individual pieces is held by by the =
|
|
original author or publisher. The editor is not responsible for =
|
|
massive depressions or attempted suicides caused by contemplation of =
|
|
all the bad news presented in this special issue of B&B. "That which =
|
|
does not kill us makes us stronger." (Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche) =
|
|
We'd better hope so. =
|
|
=============== End of Bits and Bytes Online V1, #13 =================
|