797 lines
32 KiB
Plaintext
797 lines
32 KiB
Plaintext
|
||
:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:
|
||
-----=====Earth's Dreamlands=====-----
|
||
(313)558-5024 - Supra 14.4 - Sysop: Gug
|
||
A Game Master Support BBS
|
||
RPG, Homebrew Beer, & Fiction Text
|
||
.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.
|
||
|
||
|
||
.oO CAMELOT FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS LIST Oo.
|
||
===============================================
|
||
|
||
Author : Chris Thornborrow
|
||
Last Update : May 13th 1992
|
||
Version: 1.1
|
||
|
||
Changes Since the Last Version
|
||
==============================
|
||
|
||
MAJOR:
|
||
|
||
MINOR:
|
||
*The address to mail for the first set of archives has been changed.
|
||
*This section has been moved to the front of the file
|
||
*Version number added
|
||
*Sundry spelling mistakes etc.
|
||
*More locations to visit
|
||
|
||
Index
|
||
=====
|
||
|
||
INTRODUCTION
|
||
|
||
SECTION 1 Details about The Camelot Mailing List
|
||
subsection About Camelot
|
||
Mailing Addresses
|
||
How do I get ON/OFF the list ?
|
||
How do I contact the administrator ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 2 Other Available Services Linked with Camelot.
|
||
subsection The ftp service
|
||
How do I get the book list ?
|
||
How do I get the film list ?
|
||
How do I get archives of past Messages ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 3 General Information.
|
||
subsection When did the main characters first appear ?
|
||
How many Knights of the Round Table are there ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 4 Books.
|
||
subsection Which Books Should I Read ?
|
||
How Accurate is Geoffrey of Monmouth ?
|
||
How Legitimate is the Work of Norma Lorre Goodrich ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 5 Arthur Himself.
|
||
subsection Who was Arthur ?
|
||
What is the Earliest Reference to Arthur ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 6 Merlin and Related Characters.
|
||
subsection Where Did the Idea of Merlin Living Backwards Come From?
|
||
Who was the Woman that Caused Merlins Downfall ?
|
||
Who Was Taliesin ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 7 The Holy Grail.
|
||
subsection What is the Holy Grail ?
|
||
Has Anyone Read Holy Blood- The Holy Grail ?
|
||
Who was the Fisher King ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 8 Locations Linked with the Legend.
|
||
subsection Where was Camelot ?
|
||
What is Avalon ?
|
||
Is the Grave at Glastonbury Genuine ?
|
||
What Places Should I Visit ?
|
||
|
||
SECTION 9 : Miscellaneous.
|
||
subsection What is/was Arthur's Cross ?
|
||
How Can I get a Copy of Rohmers Perceval Le Gallois?
|
||
What is the Pendragon Society ?
|
||
Where did the Term Matter of Britain Come From ?
|
||
|
||
APPENDIX A Administration of the FAQ.
|
||
subsection Formatted Copies.
|
||
Where to send comments/criticism.
|
||
|
||
===========================================================================
|
||
INTRODUCTION.
|
||
===========================================================================
|
||
|
||
This is the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) list for the mailing list
|
||
Camelot. It contains sections on the running of the mailing list, the
|
||
facilities it provides and on Arthurian Lore. The list is constructed
|
||
from past questions that appeared on the list, together with answers.
|
||
Where answers to questions have conflicted, the most accurate and
|
||
complete answer has been chosen. Questions sometimes appear that nobody
|
||
answers satisfactorily on the list. In these cases, the questions are
|
||
not included in this list. The list is therefore a frequently answered
|
||
question list.
|
||
|
||
A Comment.
|
||
----------
|
||
For the unwary, this FAQ may appear to answer few questions. To
|
||
many questions in the Arthurian Lore, there are no definitve answers,
|
||
only theories and a few, a very few, undisputed facts. History, legend,
|
||
religion and myth all combine to make this subject both fascinating and
|
||
mysterious. Differing authors provide differing answers to the same
|
||
question. It is not possible for this FAQ to tell you who Arthur truly
|
||
was. Any answers chosen for this FAQ will always reflect the authors own
|
||
theories and beliefs.
|
||
|
||
|
||
============================================================================
|
||
SECTION 1: Details About the Camelot Mailing List
|
||
============================================================================
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
About Camelot.
|
||
--------------
|
||
|
||
Camelot is a forum for discussion of all Arthurian fields of
|
||
interest. I won't be moderating the list but I'll give a few ideas
|
||
here about what the field might cover.
|
||
|
||
* Contemporary stories
|
||
* Book/film reviews
|
||
* Poetry
|
||
* Papers of literature study
|
||
* Archaeology
|
||
* History
|
||
* New-age views
|
||
* Comparative mythology
|
||
* Location visits
|
||
* Events/clubs/shows
|
||
* Grail Lore
|
||
* Re-enactment
|
||
* Art
|
||
* Ideas/theories/questions/answers ...
|
||
* ... and almost anything else - you tell me.
|
||
|
||
The list was created on 11/06/91. It is not an automated list and is
|
||
run by one person - Chris Thornborrow. The list was established to
|
||
encourage the exchange of ideas and information pertaining to the
|
||
Arthurian mythos. It was felt that no existing news group would suffice
|
||
and no similar mailing list existed. Many of the members of the list do
|
||
not have access to Usenet and there are no existing plans to make the
|
||
mailing list a News group.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Mailing Addresses :
|
||
-------------------
|
||
There are two mailing addresses you will need to know.:
|
||
|
||
1) camelot@castle.ed.ac.uk
|
||
This is for your articles and chat. It is unmoderated and
|
||
unfiltered, so anything goes. This is the address you will
|
||
post to mainly.
|
||
2) camelot-request@castle.ed.ac.uk
|
||
If you wish to be removed from the mailing list or if you
|
||
want to report a bug or if you want info on the mailing
|
||
list or any other such technical stuff, this is the address
|
||
to use. This would also be used to add you (as you know) or
|
||
anyone else who might be interested (hint - the more the
|
||
merrier).
|
||
|
||
How do I Get on/off the List ?
|
||
-----------------------------
|
||
|
||
To get ON/OFF the list mail camelot-request@castle.ed.ac.uk .
|
||
The system is not automated and is run by one person. So both of these
|
||
may take time. I always notify the list if I am going on holiday so try
|
||
to keep track of this. Usually though, expect a delay of ( a day for
|
||
mail to arrive + a day for me to process it + a day for you to receive a
|
||
reply) three working days. As the system is not automated, you do not
|
||
have to worry about getting wording exactly right for an automaton to
|
||
sign you off or subscribe you. Please try to be nice to me as well. I am
|
||
always interested in why someone leaves the list, especially if they
|
||
include constructive criticism.
|
||
|
||
|
||
How do I contact the Administrator ?
|
||
------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
I don't mind if people mail me personally about the mailing
|
||
list especially if they find mail starts to bounce at either of the
|
||
above addresses.
|
||
|
||
My e-mail address is ct@castle.ed.ac.uk.
|
||
My telephone number at work is (+44) 31 650 5024
|
||
My land mail address is Chris Thornborrow, Rm 2259, J.C.M.B.,
|
||
Kings Buildings, Mayfield Rd, Edinburgh.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
===========================================================================
|
||
SECTION 2 : Other Available Services Linked with Camelot.
|
||
===========================================================================
|
||
|
||
The FTP Service.
|
||
----------------
|
||
|
||
If you do not know what FTP is then don't worry, just skip this
|
||
bit and move on. It is not necessary to use ftp to enjoy this list.
|
||
There is an ftp service available with archives of previous
|
||
postings, photos of locations in gif format etc. If you don't know what
|
||
ftp or gif is, then this probably won't interest you, but you could
|
||
always ask someone at your site about this.
|
||
For those of you who have ftp access, the address is :
|
||
|
||
129.215.56.11
|
||
|
||
It has been tested from America and should work for most of the world.
|
||
|
||
Log on and type:
|
||
cd pub/camelot
|
||
bin
|
||
get README
|
||
|
||
This is a list of all the available files via ftp. This is updated with
|
||
useful articles from the list and then the list is notified of the
|
||
changes. Let the adminstrator know of any problems.
|
||
|
||
|
||
How do I get the Book list ?
|
||
----------------------------
|
||
|
||
Very kindly constructed for us at Camelot by Shannon Appel, the book
|
||
list is a good starting point for those looking for references or just a
|
||
good read. There are atwo ways to get the book list :
|
||
|
||
i) Mail Shannon (appel@soda.berkeley.edu) directly.
|
||
ii) Use the ftp facility described above.
|
||
|
||
|
||
How do I get the Film List ?
|
||
----------------------------
|
||
|
||
The filmlist was originally compiled by Christine Wein who has since
|
||
lost her account. I have taken it over and it is available by either :
|
||
|
||
i) Mailing me directly (ct@castle.ed.ac.uk)
|
||
ii) Using the ftp facility described above.
|
||
|
||
|
||
How do I get Archives of Past Messages ?
|
||
----------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
The most up to date archives are available by using the ftp facility.
|
||
However, Dana Paramskas has put in an awful lot of effort to cut out
|
||
rubbish and mail headers etc. to make the archives more readable. These
|
||
more readable archives are available by mailing Dana direct at
|
||
|
||
lngdanap@vm.uoguelph.ca
|
||
|
||
|
||
The one catch with these archives is that it takes Dana a reasonable
|
||
amount of time to clean up the archives, so they are not as up to date
|
||
as the FTP ones.
|
||
|
||
|
||
===========================================================================
|
||
SECTION 3: General Information.
|
||
===========================================================================
|
||
|
||
|
||
Who are the main Characters and when Did they First Appear ?
|
||
-----------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
> Arthur
|
||
Gododdin epic, Attributed to Anerin (there is evidence of later additions),
|
||
C. AD600 explicitly mentions Arthur. Geoffrey of Monmouth sets his reign
|
||
at AD455 - 470.
|
||
|
||
> Guinevere
|
||
Life of Gildas, Caradoc, AD1130 mentions her simply as "Arthur's Wife...",
|
||
The Mabinogion names her ( and three other queens) as Gwenhwyfar.
|
||
|
||
> Merlin
|
||
History of the Kings of Britain, Geoffrey of Monmouth AD1136. Called "Myrddin"
|
||
Geoffrey introduces Arthur's birth at Merlin's contrivance at Tintagel. He
|
||
also attributes Merlin with the feat of moving Stonehenge.
|
||
|
||
> Mordred
|
||
first called "Medraut" in the Annales Cambriae attributed to Nenius
|
||
(10th C.)
|
||
|
||
> Morgan le Fey
|
||
History of the Kings of Britain, Geoffrey of Monmouth AD1136. She is a
|
||
benign healer who looks after Arthur.
|
||
|
||
> Excalibur
|
||
Mentioned only as "the sword in the stone" by de Boron c1200
|
||
|
||
> Round Table
|
||
Mentioned by Wace in "Romance of Brutis" in 1155 in his Old French
|
||
"translation" of Geoffrey of Monmouth.
|
||
|
||
> Camelot
|
||
Chretien, 1160 - 80 first names Camelot. The site was thought to be Cadbury
|
||
Castle by Leyland 1542, modern thought has it at South Cadbury where
|
||
an archeological dig was held in 1966 - 67.
|
||
See Alcock, L. "Arthur's Britain" or
|
||
"By South Cadbury, is that Camelot?" by the same author.
|
||
|
||
> Avalon
|
||
Celtic myth in the 1st C AD has a banished god asleep in a cave on a western
|
||
isle. The Bretons introduced the concept of Arthur's immortality and may
|
||
be responsible for the name Avalon.
|
||
|
||
> Galahad, Lancelot, etc (who named them all)
|
||
Taliesin names the older companions in the 10th C. He forshadows the
|
||
Grail Quest in "The Spoils of Annwfn". The Company of the Round Table
|
||
in something close to the present form is found in the writings of
|
||
de Longuyon (1310).
|
||
|
||
> (or anything else)
|
||
Read "The Arthurian Handbook" by Norris Lacey and Geoffrey Ashe. Garland
|
||
1988, ISBN 0-8240-7597-8
|
||
|
||
[Wayne Robinson]
|
||
|
||
|
||
How Many Knights of the Round Table Were There ?
|
||
------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
There is no simple answer to this. Malory claims 150. Others claim
|
||
different numbers. Here is a list compiled from different sources by
|
||
Brian C. Hogue to who we should be grateful. It is by no means complete
|
||
but provides the source for some serious work.
|
||
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
|
||
Common? Malorey Lawhead Mabinogian T.H. White
|
||
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
Arthur Arthur Arthur Arthur Arthur
|
||
Bors
|
||
Ban
|
||
Balan
|
||
Balin
|
||
Bedevere Bedwyr
|
||
Cador
|
||
Clegis
|
||
Dodinas le Savage
|
||
Donard
|
||
Ector Ector (foster Father)
|
||
Ector de Maris (bro of Lance.)
|
||
Gaheris
|
||
Galahad
|
||
Gareth
|
||
Gwain Gawain Gwalchmai
|
||
Griflet le Fise de Dieu
|
||
Harry le Fise Lake
|
||
Hervis de Revel
|
||
Kay Kay the Seneschal (Art's foster bro) Cai Kai
|
||
La Cote Mal Taile
|
||
Lamorak de Gales
|
||
Lancelot Launcelote
|
||
Lionel
|
||
Loevel (knighthood questionable)
|
||
Lucan the Butler
|
||
Ozanna le Cure Hardy
|
||
Palomides
|
||
Pelleas
|
||
Pelinore Pellinor
|
||
Percival Percival
|
||
Safer
|
||
Urien of Gore
|
||
"Yvain (a.k.a. Owain, Owen)"
|
||
Tristam (assoc.)
|
||
Geraint
|
||
Culwych
|
||
Heylan
|
||
Bellinore
|
||
Valadon
|
||
Marhuas
|
||
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
SECTION 4 Books.
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
|
||
Which Books Should I Read ?
|
||
---------------------------
|
||
|
||
In such a vast field of literature (over a thousand books) this
|
||
is a difficult question. Several books are recommended on the list time
|
||
and time again :
|
||
|
||
Historical :
|
||
_Arthur's Britain_ by Leslie Alcock
|
||
_The Age of Arthur_ by John Morris
|
||
Anything by Geoffrey Ashe (_The Discovery of King Arthur_, _King
|
||
Arthur's Avalon_, and _The Quest for Arthur's Britain_)
|
||
|
||
Modern Fiction :
|
||
T.H. White's _Once and Future King_
|
||
Marion Zimmer Bradley's _Mists of Avalon_
|
||
|
||
Modern Theories (new age ?) :
|
||
Anything by John Matthews (_The Grail Seekers Companion_, _The
|
||
Arthurian Way_)
|
||
_The Grail Legend_ by Marie Louise Von Franz, Emma Jung
|
||
|
||
Reference :
|
||
_The Arthurian Encyclopaedia_
|
||
_The Encyclopaedia of Arthurian Legend_
|
||
|
||
Old Texts :
|
||
_Morte D'Arthur_ by Sir Thomas Malory
|
||
_Perceval_ Chretiens de Troyes
|
||
_Parzival_ Wolfram Von Eschenbach
|
||
_Mabinogion_ (various translations)
|
||
|
||
There are many others and the choice of which to read is largely a
|
||
matter of taste. For fuller references, please refer to the book list.
|
||
|
||
|
||
How Accurate is Geoffrey of Monmouth ?
|
||
--------------------------------------
|
||
[Geoffrey wrote an early text with references to Arthur called
|
||
_Historia regum Britanniae_ : ed]
|
||
|
||
Regarding complaints about Geoffrey of Monmouth's accuracy:
|
||
anyone who criticizes Geoffrey for writing a fabricated work is completely
|
||
missing the point. Although he claimed that he was merely copying an ancieint
|
||
manuscript he had run across, there is no doubt that he invented most of his
|
||
story, although large elements are beleived to have already existed in
|
||
Celtic myth. He was definitely interested in writing a "political work"
|
||
more than an accurate description of past events. His intention was much
|
||
like that of Vergil in The Aeneid or the authors of the Charlemagne/Roland
|
||
legends.
|
||
[NAGORDON@earn.amherst]
|
||
|
||
How Legitimate is the Work of Norma Lorre Goodrich ?
|
||
----------------------------------------------------
|
||
I used the _King Arthur_ and _Merlin_ books as sources for a thesis
|
||
paper. The general consensus I've run into is that her geography is
|
||
plausible and well-supported. I have a problem with the way she presents
|
||
some of her arguments, though. In a number of cases, she starts with an
|
||
assumption that is unsupported but presented as a common truth, then
|
||
procedes to base a whole chapter of well-reasoned argument on this
|
||
assumption. The one case of this I remember clearly was her defense of
|
||
Lancelot as a historical figure (a fairly likely possibility) and as a
|
||
contemporary of the historical Arthur (a fairly unlikely possibility).
|
||
Still, the books are good source material. They do represent some of the
|
||
contemporary work now being done in the analysis of the Arthurian mythos.
|
||
[Ken Kubo <CENYDD@com.mti>]
|
||
|
||
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
SECTION 5 Arthur Himself.
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
|
||
Who was Arthur ?
|
||
----------------
|
||
This is a very complicated question. There is no known answer.
|
||
The histroical Arthur is shrouded in the mists of the Dark Ages. The
|
||
best description of what we know and do not know about Arthur is to be
|
||
found in the introduction to :
|
||
_The Encyclopaedia of Arthurian Legend_, Ronan Coghlan (91)
|
||
|
||
What is certain is that Arthur was NOT a medieval King. The modern
|
||
images of knights in plate armour and a grand castle called Camelot are
|
||
not historical at all. We know very little historically speaking but
|
||
Arthur was probably a 5th century warrior cheiftain who protected his
|
||
peoples from invaders for a time. The battle of Camlan is probably
|
||
connected to Arthur. More than this is pure conjecture, though there is
|
||
an awful lot of conjecture.
|
||
|
||
A more modern approach to the question "Who was Arthur ?" might
|
||
say that history is irrelevant and that the mythology surrounding the
|
||
legend is more important. Even mythology is complex though and Arthur
|
||
changes in stories from a God-like Celtic King, through to a deflated
|
||
early medieval monarch and finally in modern times, to an ordinary man
|
||
with an extra-ordinarily difficult job !
|
||
|
||
[Chris Thornborrow]
|
||
|
||
What is the Earliest Reference to Arthur ?
|
||
------------------------------------------
|
||
There may be one near contemporary Reference to Arthur in the
|
||
poem _Gododdin_ (A.D. 600) which tells of a hero who although valiant
|
||
was not as valiant as Arthur. This may be a case of interpolation. The
|
||
earliest undisputed reference to Arthur occurs in the _Historia
|
||
Brittonum_ by Nennius (A.D. 800) which left enough time for fact to mix
|
||
with fancy.
|
||
|
||
[Chris Thornborrow]
|
||
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
SECTION 6 Merlin and Related Characters.
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
|
||
Where Did the Idea of Merlin Living Backwards Come From ?
|
||
---------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
Merlin "remembering the future" was used by T.H.White in "The Once and Future
|
||
King", and this work has been the starting point for a lot of 20th century
|
||
treatments of Arthur.
|
||
[peter card <pjc@uk.jet>]
|
||
|
||
Who was the Woman that Caused Merlins Downfall ?
|
||
------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
From "The Arthurian Encyclopedia" (Norris J. Lacy, Editor, published 1986
|
||
by Peter Bedrick Books, New York, don't leave Camelot without it...)
|
||
|
||
LADY OF THE LAKE, a name designating several different women, although
|
||
the distinction among them is frequently blurred. In additional to
|
||
being known as the Lady of the Lake, or the Dame du Lac, she most often
|
||
bears such names as Viviane, Eviene, or Niviene; elsewhere, she is Nimue or
|
||
(in Wordsworth) Nina. Readers of Malory will recognize her as the being who
|
||
gives Excalibur to Arthur and later receives it back from him, and some
|
||
works also identify her as the lady responsible for Lancelot's
|
||
upbringing. In Malory, the Vulgate Cycle, and various other settings of the
|
||
legend (e.g., Apollinaire), she enchants Merlin with spells he had taught her.
|
||
Some texts in fact tell us that she not only enchants him but kills him.
|
||
|
||
In the "Vita di Merlino", for example, the Lady of the Lake serves as a
|
||
scribe for Merlin, recording his prophecies, after which she tricks him
|
||
into lying in a tomb; then, by a charm she had learned from him, she
|
||
closes the lid and seals the wizard's doom (although the author assures
|
||
us that Merlin's spirit will not die). [NJL]
|
||
|
||
|
||
The [NJL] refers to the contributor of this particular entry, who was
|
||
Norris J. Lacy himself (the editor, from the University of Kansas).
|
||
[Christopher Russell, CRUSSELL@FASDER.ENET.DEC.COM]
|
||
|
||
|
||
Who Was Taliesin ?
|
||
------------------
|
||
|
||
Taliesin was a historical 6th (?) century poet who became quite well
|
||
known and famous. He wrote a large body of poems and a number of older
|
||
works came to be associated with him, turning him into an almost mythic
|
||
figure. I am reading a book called "Taliesin: Shamanism and the Bardic
|
||
Mysteries in Britain and Ireland" by John Matthews which postulates that
|
||
Taliesin and the material that became associated with him, give evidence
|
||
for shamanic practices in Britain and Ireland. It is a quite long book
|
||
and very detailed and very good.
|
||
|
||
[raven@pagan.halcyon.wa.com]
|
||
|
||
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
SECTION 7 The Holy Grail.
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
|
||
What is the Holy Grail ?
|
||
------------------------
|
||
|
||
There is an introduction to current theories about the Holy Grail
|
||
written by Chris Thornborrow . Mail direct to ct@castle.ed.ac.uk for a
|
||
copy of this. Here is the abstract :
|
||
|
||
Abstract:
|
||
|
||
|
||
This article is a collection of theories concerning the Holy Grail and
|
||
what it could be. The confusion arises because the word Grail is derived
|
||
from the word graal which first appeared in turn of the first millenium
|
||
(A.D.) prose and poetry. There is no confusion over the meaning of the
|
||
word Graal, which was a dish or platter brought to the table at various
|
||
stages during a meal. However, the things that the graal or grail has
|
||
come to represent has changed from story to story throughout the words
|
||
history. The first story in which the word appears was written by
|
||
Chretien de Troyes - ``Le Conte del Graal''. Chretiens story was almost
|
||
certainly based on an earlier one, but it is unknown what his actual
|
||
source was or his meaning of the word Graal. Chretien did not finish his
|
||
story and continuations and rewrites of the story are then free to
|
||
embellish and invent as much as the authors saw fit. Now the Grail
|
||
represents many different things to many different people. No one meaning
|
||
seems to explain all the strange events in the Grail stories.
|
||
The reader will not find a definitive answer. Nor will he read all
|
||
theories as some are obscure and not yet encountered in detail by the author.
|
||
|
||
|
||
Has Anyone Read The Holy Blood and The Holy Grail ?
|
||
---------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
The book in question is "The Holy Blood & The Holy Grail" by Michael Baigent,
|
||
Richard Leigh and Henry Lincoln. In this they hypothesise that Jesus may not
|
||
have died on the cross but fled (or if he did die, that his descendants fled)
|
||
to Europe for safety. Here they established a royal line that gave rise to
|
||
the Merovingian Kings. The French for royal blood = "Sang Re`al", which is
|
||
could easily be changed to give "San Gre`al", the holy grail. Also, the Mary
|
||
that Jesus was married to was either the Magdalene or Martha's sister
|
||
(or they could be one and the same).
|
||
[James Nolan]
|
||
|
||
A word of warning for those of you dashing out to buy it. The book is on
|
||
the surface a well researched, honest historical account. It is not. The
|
||
work done is claimed to have been discovered while researching an
|
||
altogether different subject. Their work is actually very very *very*
|
||
similar to work done by Walter Stein. Steins work was discredited and
|
||
largely ignored because of his one time connection with the Nazis (can
|
||
you say Indiana Jones ?). Mssrs Baigent and Co. conveniently discover
|
||
pieces of paper in French libraries that afterwards disappear that fill
|
||
in the gaps that Stein was never able to. Consequently their work in the
|
||
field of Grail Lore is not taken seriously at all. It is considered to
|
||
be exploitative fabrication.
|
||
[Chris Thornborrow]
|
||
|
||
|
||
Who was the Fisher King ?
|
||
--------------------------
|
||
|
||
The Fisher King is generally seen as the keeper of the Grail. He is sometimes
|
||
called the Rich Fisher/Angler. He might be an avatar of the Welsh hero/god
|
||
Bran the Blessed. The Fisher king is the wounded occupant of the Grail
|
||
Castle in Chretien de Troyes's Perceval as well as in other works. The
|
||
nature of the Fisher King's wound varies, but is generally seen as some form
|
||
of castration or other loss of fertility. In the various versions of the
|
||
Perceval Saga, Perceval sees a procession while at the Grail Castle, but
|
||
fails to ask questions despite his curiosity. P. later discovers that
|
||
if he
|
||
had asked his questions, he would have discovered that the Fisher King was
|
||
his cousin and P. would not have been forced to go on the Grail Quest. In
|
||
Wolfram von Eschenbach's Perceval, The Fisher King is given the name Anfortas.
|
||
|
||
Robert de Boron, in his Arthurian cycle, identifies the Fisher King with either
|
||
Bron or Hebron and makes him Joseph of Arimathea's brother-in-law.
|
||
(Note the similarity to Bran). In The Didot-Perceval, Perceval finishes
|
||
his quest and returns to the Grail castle where he asks the proper
|
||
question and in so doing Perceval restores the health (read "fertility")
|
||
of the Fisher King (read "country").
|
||
[Steven H Silver, SHSILVER@ucs.indiana.edu]
|
||
|
||
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
SECTION 8 Locations Linked with the Legend.
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
|
||
|
||
Where was Camelot ?
|
||
-------------------
|
||
|
||
Camelot itself is, by some, believed to be at the site of Cadbury
|
||
castle. This is a small village in Somerset some 15 or so miles
|
||
south of Glastonbury.
|
||
All that remains today is a ringed hillfort with evidence of a large
|
||
castle inside the outer walls. There have been some extensive excavations
|
||
of the site, and there are detailed reports of the archaeological dig
|
||
available. This dig was undertaken by the Pendragon Society.
|
||
From Cadbury you can see, on a clear day, the Glastonbury Tor.
|
||
Once again though, there is no definitive answer to this.
|
||
|
||
[Peter L. Rosencrantz, ed: Chris Thornborrow]
|
||
|
||
What is Avalon ?
|
||
----------------
|
||
|
||
Avalon is the place Arthur is said to have been taken to when he was
|
||
dieing, to be healed. There are lots of theories as to where Avalon
|
||
might actually have been. Some say it was not a geographical place, but
|
||
a euphemism for the otherworld. Of those that claim Avalon to have a
|
||
modern geographical equivalent, the most usual claim is Glastonbury.
|
||
|
||
[Chris Thornborrow]
|
||
|
||
|
||
Is the Grave at Glastonbury Genuine ?
|
||
-------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
There is a good article available in the archives or by FTP that
|
||
discusses this issue well. The introduction is included here.
|
||
_Lost_Island_of_Glastonbury_
|
||
|
||
In recent years the Arthurian legends have become very
|
||
popular. One of the more intriguing aspects of the Arthurian
|
||
legends deals with the disappearance or death of King Arthur.
|
||
In many accounts of the Arthurian legends, King Arthur was
|
||
taken to the Isle of Avalon to be healed, but what happened to
|
||
him after reaching the island remains a mystery. Some people
|
||
say he lies in a cave awaiting the day he is once again needed.
|
||
Others say King Arthur was taken to Avalon and he died there.
|
||
If this is true, surely his remains were buried in or around
|
||
the island of Avalon. Some scholars believe that Arthur was
|
||
indeed buried at Avalon, which, according to these scholars,
|
||
is now known as Glastonbury. In 1190 monks at the Glastonbury
|
||
abbey produced a tomb and a cross that they claimed belong to
|
||
the late King Arthur. Since that time some doubt has arisen
|
||
about the validity of this claim.
|
||
|
||
[aoj@edu.purdue.cc.mentor]
|
||
|
||
What Places Should I Visit ?
|
||
----------------------------
|
||
Many people asking this question have no idea that within an
|
||
hours drive of any city in Britain there is an Arthur's Hill or a
|
||
Merlin's Grave. There are so many places trying to claim Arthur and his
|
||
knights as one time residents that an entire book could be written on
|
||
the subject. Having said that, the major sites are always popular.
|
||
|
||
Glastonbury Abbey (see Arthurs Cross)
|
||
Glastonbury Tor
|
||
Cadbury Castle (18 miles south of Glastonbury)
|
||
Stone Henge
|
||
Winchester Cathedral (Round Table)
|
||
Edinburgh (especially Chris Thornborrows Chapel :-)
|
||
Tintagel in Cornwall - site of Uthers Castle
|
||
Orkney, supposed home of King Lot.
|
||
|
||
And many more.
|
||
[Chris Thornborrow]
|
||
|
||
============================================================================
|
||
SECTION 9 : MISCELLANEOUS
|
||
============================================================================
|
||
|
||
What is/was Arthur's Cross ?
|
||
----------------------------
|
||
|
||
HIC IACET SEPULTUS INCLITUS REX ARTURUS IN INSULA AVALONIA
|
||
|
||
"HERE LIES BURIED THE RENOWNED KING ARTHUR IN THE ISLE OF AVALON"
|
||
|
||
Those were the words which were inscribed on the cross found at Arthur's
|
||
tomb in Glastonbury. The cross apparently existed and was around during
|
||
the 18th century. Then it was lost.
|
||
|
||
[tashauk@athena.mit.edu]
|
||
|
||
|
||
How Can I get a Copy of Rohmers Perceval Le Gallois ?
|
||
-----------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
||
For 14:99 (pounds sterling) you can get a copy on video (VHS) from :
|
||
Castle Communications PLC
|
||
A29 Barwell Business Park,
|
||
Leatherhead Road,
|
||
Chessington,
|
||
Surrey,
|
||
KT9 2NY
|
||
|
||
|
||
What is the Pendragon Society ?
|
||
-------------------------------
|
||
|
||
I have been asked about the Pendragon society. Well as far as I
|
||
know, it is one of only two Arthurian Societies in Britain. The first is
|
||
The Arthurian Society (natch) which is for scholars and academics in the
|
||
field and which you need two references to get into ! The other is for
|
||
amateur enthusiasts like myself - this is Pendragon.
|
||
|
||
Its not my intent to advertise for Pendragon here but as people have
|
||
asked I will give you details. They charge 6 pound (sterling) for
|
||
membership for which you get a quarterly newsletter and an AGM in
|
||
September. The society includes people like Geoffrey Ashe (famous author
|
||
on the subject). The magazine is unprofessionally produced (to be honest
|
||
it is a bit tatty) but has some great articles. In other words, don't
|
||
judge the book by its cover.
|
||
|
||
Address :
|
||
The Chairman: Smithy House (Fred Stedman-Jones)
|
||
Newton by Frodsham
|
||
Cheshire
|
||
England
|
||
WA6 6JX
|
||
|
||
They also supply information on celtic art, weapons and armour and all
|
||
sorts of Arthurian connected stuff. Recommended.
|
||
|
||
p.s. if you do want to join, please mention my name - thanks.
|
||
[Chris Thornborrow]
|
||
|
||
|
||
Where did the Term Matter of Britain Come From ?
|
||
------------------------------------------------
|
||
The term "Matter of Britain" is a play on the term "Matter of France," which
|
||
was the story of Charlemagne, mainly the _Song of Roland_. This term was in
|
||
widespread use at the time when the French romances about Arthur were being
|
||
written. Since the Charlemagne stories were about the beginnings of France,
|
||
and the Arthurian stories were about the beginnings of England, the analogy
|
||
was an obvious one at the time. Eleanor of Aquitaine made both terms popular
|
||
because she used the stories to strengthen the positions of each of her husbands
|
||
by stressing their respective illustrious "ancestors."
|
||
|
||
[Susan Snyder <SUTAYLOR@earn.ukanvm>]
|
||
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
Appendix A : Administration of this List.
|
||
=============================================================================
|
||
|
||
Formatted Copies
|
||
----------------
|
||
This FAQ will be available in Latex format in the near future.
|
||
There is no other format version yet.
|
||
|
||
Where to send comments/criticism
|
||
--------------------------------
|
||
If you believe that an item on the FAQ ought to be discussed by
|
||
everyone on the list then post to the list as described in section 2. If
|
||
you think it is just for the administrator only, then the current
|
||
administrator is Chris Thornborrow (ct@castle.ed.ac.uk).
|
||
|
||
|
||
|