205 lines
11 KiB
Plaintext
205 lines
11 KiB
Plaintext
|
||
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|
||
%% %%
|
||
%% ========================== %%
|
||
%% Meet and Beat the Lie Detector %%
|
||
%% ========================== %%
|
||
%% %%
|
||
%% Stolen from the book %%
|
||
%% BIG SECRETS! %%
|
||
%% by: William Poundstone %%
|
||
%% %%
|
||
%% Typed By %%
|
||
%% --==**>>THE RELFEX<<**==-- %%
|
||
%% [Member: Omnipotent, Inc.] %%
|
||
%% %%
|
||
%% 80-col for Countlegger 8 and %%
|
||
%% various typo. corrections by %%
|
||
%% Count Lazlo Hollifeld-Nibble %%
|
||
%% %%
|
||
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|
||
|
||
The polygraph test was invented by William Moulton Marston, who was,
|
||
strangely enough, also the creator of the "Wonder Woman" comic strip (under
|
||
the
|
||
name Charles Moulton). The standard polygraph records only three distinct
|
||
vital signs. A blood-pressure cuff on the upper arm measures changes in blood
|
||
pressure. Wires attached to the fingers measure changes in electrical
|
||
resistance of the skin due to sweating. Rubber straps around the torso
|
||
measure
|
||
the breathing rate. This information is displayed as four squiggles on a
|
||
moving strip of graph paper.
|
||
|
||
Whether or not you believe a polygraph provides useful information (most
|
||
psychologists have their doubts), there is a good chance you'll be asked to
|
||
take a polygraph test. The vast majority of lie-detector tests are
|
||
administered for employee screening--"Have you been using the WATS like for
|
||
personal calls?" and so forth--not <20>'r police work. In 'A Tremor In the
|
||
Blood:
|
||
Uses and Abuses of the Lie Detector' (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1981), polygraph
|
||
critic David Thoreson Lykken estimates that as many as one million polygraph
|
||
examinations are performed on Americans each year. In criminal cases however,
|
||
even the manifestly innocent may be asked to take a polygraph test. All
|
||
Yakima
|
||
County, Washington, rape victims are required to take the test; refusal means
|
||
the case will not be prosecuted.
|
||
|
||
At best, all the polygraph can indicate is a heightened emotional
|
||
reaction
|
||
to a question. It cannot specify what kind of an emotional reaction.
|
||
Polygraphers try to design question formats so guilt-induced nervousness will
|
||
be the only emotional invoked and so the subject's reaction to relevant
|
||
questions can be compared to other, "control" questions.
|
||
|
||
THE LIE CONTROL TEST
|
||
--------------------
|
||
|
||
This is the question format used in most police investigations. It
|
||
usually starts with a card trick devised by two pioneer polygraphers, John E.
|
||
Reid and F. E. Inbau.
|
||
|
||
The polygrapher hooks the subject to the polygraph and takes out a deck
|
||
of
|
||
cards. The polygrapher tells the subject that he must "calibrate" the
|
||
polygraph with a simple test. He fans the deck and asks the subject to select
|
||
a card. The subject is told to look at the card but not to show it or mention
|
||
its name. The polygrapher tells the subject to answer "no" to every question
|
||
asked about the card. "Is it a black card?" the polygrapher asks. "Is it a
|
||
high card?" and so on. After each "no" the polygrapher scrutinizes the
|
||
tracings and fiddles with the dials. If the no answer is incorrect, the
|
||
polygrapher disagrees. The field is soon narrowed to one card--and it is the
|
||
correct card.
|
||
|
||
Needless to say, the polygrapher uses a trick deck. The point is to
|
||
foster confidence in the machine. After identifying the card, the polygrapher
|
||
comments that the subject's reactions are particularly easy to read and segues
|
||
into the interrogation.
|
||
|
||
Three types of questions are used in a lie-control test. The entire list
|
||
is read to the subject well in advance of the test. The start of a typical
|
||
interrogation might run like this:
|
||
|
||
1. Is your name Sarah Elkins?
|
||
2. Is Paris the capital of France?
|
||
3. Have you ever failed to report more than $50 of tip, gambling or gift
|
||
income on a single year's tax return?
|
||
4. Is this apple red?
|
||
5. Do you have any idea why the cash reciepts for the last quarter are about
|
||
$22,000 in error?
|
||
6. Is there something important that you did not mention on your job
|
||
application?
|
||
7. Have you ever been embezzling from the company?
|
||
|
||
The first question is always irrelevant to the matter being investigated.
|
||
It has to be because many subjects get nervous on the first question no matter
|
||
what. Other irrelevant questions are asked throughout the interrogation
|
||
(questions 2 and 4 in the sample list). If the subject gives any thought to
|
||
these questions, he assumes that they are control questions to provide a
|
||
yardstick for evaluating responses to the relevant questions. Actually, the
|
||
irrelevant questions are there to give the subject's vital signs time to
|
||
return
|
||
to normal. They aren't the control questions.
|
||
|
||
Questions 5 and 7 in the list above are relevant questions--the only
|
||
questions the examiner is really interested in. The relevant questions are
|
||
asked in several different wordings during the test.
|
||
|
||
Questions 3 and 6 are control questions. In the pretest discussion of
|
||
the
|
||
questions, the polygrapher explains that it is helpful to throw in a few
|
||
"general honesty" questions. Whoever committed the serious crime, the spiel
|
||
goes, probably comitted less serious crimes in the past. Hence the inclusion
|
||
of questions about tax cheating, lying on the job applications, stealing as a
|
||
child, etc.
|
||
|
||
The polygrapher affects the attitude that it would be damaging indeed to
|
||
admit any such indiscretions. Frequently this scares the subject into
|
||
admitting minor crimes. In that case, the plygrapher frowns and agrees to
|
||
rewrite the question. Should the subject concede failing to report eighty
|
||
dollars in gambling winnings, question 3 might be changes to "Have you ever
|
||
failed to report more than a hundred dollars of tip, gambling, or gift income
|
||
on a single years's tax return?" If necessary, several of the control
|
||
questions may be reworded before the test--always so that the subject will be
|
||
able to give the "honest" response.
|
||
|
||
In reality, the whole point of each working question is to manufacture a
|
||
lie. It is the secret working premise of polygraphers that everyone commits
|
||
the minor transgressions that are the subject of the usual control questions.
|
||
All the subject's denials on the control questions are assumed to be lies.
|
||
The
|
||
polygraph tracings during these "lies" establish a base line for interpreting
|
||
the reaction to the relevant questions.
|
||
|
||
The reason for rewriting some control questions is so a candid subject
|
||
will no admit to minor crimes on the test. That would be telling the truth,
|
||
and the polygrapher wants the subject to lie. The control questions are
|
||
intentionally broad. Even if a question is reworded to exclude the confessed
|
||
instance, it is assumed that any denial must be a lie.
|
||
|
||
The rationale for the lie-control test goes like this: The honest
|
||
subject
|
||
will be worried about the control questions. He'll know that he has
|
||
committted
|
||
small transgressions or suspect that he must have, even if he can't remember
|
||
them. So he'll be afraid that the machine will detect his deception on the
|
||
"general honesty" questions (especially in view of its success with the card
|
||
trick). That would be embarrassing at least, and it might throw suspicion on
|
||
him for the larger crime. In contrast, the relevant questions should be less
|
||
threating to the honest subject. He knows he didn't commit the crimes they
|
||
refer to.
|
||
|
||
The guilty person, on the other hand, should have far more to fear from
|
||
the relevant questions. If the machine can detect lying on the relevant
|
||
issue,
|
||
it matters little that it might also implicate him in petty matters.
|
||
|
||
By this hypothesis, an innocent person should have greater polygraphic
|
||
response to the control questions than to the relevant questions. The guilty
|
||
pattern is just the reverse: greater response to the relevant qustions.
|
||
This,
|
||
at any rate, is what polygraphers look for when the machine is switched on.
|
||
|
||
THE RELEVANT-CONTROL TEST
|
||
-------------------------
|
||
|
||
The relevant-control test is the type used for mos<6F>olygraph test. You
|
||
won't be wowed by the card demonstration. You realize
|
||
that the polygraph's powers are limited. There are two additional techniques
|
||
for beating the polygraph. The more obvious is to learn how to repress
|
||
physiologic responses to stressful questions. Some people are good at this
|
||
one; others are not. Most people can get better by practicing with a
|
||
polygraph. Of course, this training requires a polygraph, and polygraphs are
|
||
expensive.
|
||
|
||
The opposite approach is to pick out the control questions in the pretest
|
||
discussion and exaggerate reactions to these questions during the test. When
|
||
the control-question responses are greater than the relevant-question
|
||
responses, the polygrapher must acquit the subject.
|
||
|
||
Because breathing is one of the parameters measured, taking a deep breath
|
||
and holding it will record as an abnormal response. Flexing the arm muscles
|
||
under the cuff distorts the blood-pressure reading. But a suspicious
|
||
polygrapher may spot either ruse.
|
||
|
||
A more subtle method is to hide a tack in one shoe. Stepping on the tack
|
||
during the control questions produces stress reactions with no outward signs
|
||
of
|
||
fidgeting. Biting the tounge forcefully also works.
|
||
--William Poundstone
|
||
|
||
|
||
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////
|
||
// The PIRATES' HOLLOW //
|
||
// 415-236-2371 //
|
||
// over 12 Megs of Elite Text Files //
|
||
// ROR-ALUCARD //
|
||
// Sysop: Doctor Murdock //
|
||
// C0-Sysops: That One, Sir Death, Sid Gnarly & Finn //
|
||
// //
|
||
// "The Gates of Hell are open night and day; //
|
||
// Smooth is the Descent, and Easy is the way.." //
|
||
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
|