61 lines
3.4 KiB
Plaintext
61 lines
3.4 KiB
Plaintext
s 1
|
||
Executive News Svc.
|
||
|
||
APn 03/06 1955 Circumcision
|
||
|
||
Copyright, 1989. The Associated Press. All rights reserved.
|
||
|
||
By PAULINE JELINEK Associated Press Writer
|
||
CHICAGO (AP) -- Newborn boys may benefit from circumcision, the American
|
||
Academy of Pediatrics said Monday in a modification of its previous stand, but
|
||
the organization stopped short of endorsing the procedure.
|
||
The academy, which has a membership of 37,000 pediatricians, said it was
|
||
changing the position it adopted in 1971, when it found "no absolute medical
|
||
necessity" to circumcise newborns.
|
||
The group now believes circumcision, the removal of a band of skin encircling
|
||
the tip of the penis, may help prevent some urinary tract infections, said Dr.
|
||
Donald Schiff, the academy's president.
|
||
"The previous statement was pretty dogmatic and no longer holds," he said.
|
||
Circumcision is the nation's most commonly performed surgical procedure, but
|
||
appears to be on the decline.
|
||
About 75 percent of infant boys in the United States are circumcised now,
|
||
compared with 85 to 90 percent 10 or 15 years ago, Schiff said.
|
||
The academy, which is based in suburban Elk Grove Village, said the decision
|
||
on whether a child should be circumcised is best made by parents in consultation
|
||
with their doctors.
|
||
"Before, we told parents there may be social and religious reasons to do it
|
||
but that there were no specific medical benefits," Schiff said. "Now we can tell
|
||
them there may be some potential value."
|
||
The group was influenced partly by 1985 studies at Army hospitals that found
|
||
an elevenfold increase in urinary tract infections in uncircumcised boys
|
||
compared with circumcised infants, Schiff said. The study involved 200,000
|
||
infants.
|
||
"When physicians talk to parents, they should say we still don't know for
|
||
sure, but there is data that suggests not having a circumcision is linked with a
|
||
greater liklihood of urinary tract infection," Schiff said.
|
||
However, the Army research is not convincing enough to merit an all-out
|
||
endorsement of circumcision, Schiff said. He said the studies may have been
|
||
flawed.
|
||
"If those studies are corrorborated ... we could take an even stronger
|
||
position," Schiff said, adding that further research is under way.
|
||
In its statement on circumcision, the academy said infants undergoing
|
||
circumcision without anesthesia appear to experience pain.
|
||
But, it said, "reported experience with local anesthesia in newborn
|
||
circumcision is limited, and the procedure (anesthesia) is not without risk."
|
||
More studies are needed before routine local anesthesia can be endorsed, the
|
||
group said.
|
||
Circumcision is a controversial issue worldwide. The first International
|
||
Symposium on Circumcision was held last week in Anaheim, Calif., sponsored by
|
||
the National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers and the
|
||
Institute for the Advancement of Human Behavior.
|
||
The symposium concluded that the medical need for circumcision is very rare
|
||
and that ordinarily it should not be done, said Billy Boyd, a participant and
|
||
co-founder of The Victims Speak, a group working against circumcision.
|
||
"Parents do not have the right to consent to unnecessary medical procedures
|
||
on their children," and physicians have an obligation to refuse to remove normal
|
||
body parts, the symposium said in a policy statement presented to the California
|
||
Medical Association.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
! |