209 lines
10 KiB
Plaintext
209 lines
10 KiB
Plaintext
ÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÜ ÜÜÜ ÜÜÜÜ
|
||
ÜÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛßÛßßßßßÛÛÜ ÜÜßßßßÜÜÜÜ ÜÛÜ ÜÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÜÜÜÜÜÛßß ßÛÛ
|
||
ßÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÜ ßÛÛ ÜÛÛÛÜÛÛÜÜÜ ßÛÛÛÛÜ ßÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÜÛÛÜÜÜÛÛÝ Ûß
|
||
ßßßÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÜ ÞÝ ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛßßÛÜÞÛÛÛ ÛÛÛÛÛÜ ßßÛÛÛÞß
|
||
Mo.iMP ÜÛÛÜ ßÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÝÛ ÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛ ÞÛÛÛÛ ÞÛÛÛÛÛÝ ßÛß
|
||
ÜÛÛÛÛÛÛÛ ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÝ ÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÝ ÛÛÛ ÛÛÛÛÛÛ
|
||
ÜÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÝ ÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛ ÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛ ß ÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÜ ÜÛ
|
||
ÜÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÝ ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛ ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÝ ÞÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛß
|
||
ÜÛßÛÛÛÛÛÛ ÜÜ ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÝ ÛÛÞÛÛÛÛÛÝ ÞÛÛÛÛÛÛßß
|
||
ÜÛßÛÛÛÛÛÛÜÛÛÛÛÜÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛ ÞÛ ßÛÛÛÛÛ Ü ÛÝÛÛÛÛÛ Ü
|
||
ÜÛ ÞÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛß ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛ ßÛÜ ßÛÛÛÜÜ ÜÜÛÛÛß ÞÛ ÞÛÛÛÝ ÜÜÛÛ
|
||
ÛÛ ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛß ÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÜ ßÛÜ ßßÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛß ÜÜÜß ÛÛÛÛÜÜÜÜÜÜÜÛÛÛÛÛß
|
||
ßÛÜ ÜÛÛÛß ßÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÛÜ ßßÜÜ ßßÜÛÛßß ßÛÛÜ ßßßÛßÛÛÛÛÛÛÛßß
|
||
ßßßßß ßßÛÛß ßßßßß ßßßßßßßßßßßßß
|
||
ARRoGANT CoURiERS WiTH ESSaYS
|
||
|
||
Grade Level: Type of Work Subject/Topic is on:
|
||
[ ]6-8 [ ]Class Notes [The Criminalization of ]
|
||
[ ]9-10 [ ]Cliff Notes [knowingly Transmitting ]
|
||
[x]11-12 [ ]Essay/Report [Aids. ]
|
||
[ ]College [x]Misc [ ]
|
||
|
||
Date: 06/94 # of Words:1320 School:? State:?
|
||
ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ>ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ>ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ>Chop Here>ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ>ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ>ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ>ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ
|
||
|
||
Table of Contents
|
||
|
||
Brief history of AIDS and the criminalization of knowingly
|
||
transmitting it.......................................3
|
||
Interviews concerning the issue............................4
|
||
Reasons for the criminalization of knowingly transmitting
|
||
AIDS..................................................5
|
||
Reasons against the criminalization of knowingly
|
||
transmitting AIDS.....................................7
|
||
My position and conclusion.................................8
|
||
|
||
Brief History of AIDS and the Criminalization
|
||
of Knowingly Transmitting It
|
||
|
||
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) is caused by the Human
|
||
Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV). The virus was discoverd independently in
|
||
France in 1983 and in the United States in 1984. In the United States, it
|
||
was initially identified in 1981. In 1986, a second virus, now called
|
||
HIV-2, was also discovered in Africa. HIV-2 also causes AIDS.
|
||
|
||
AIDS is transmitted in three ways: From sexual contact without
|
||
protection, from the mixing of ones blood with infected blood, and from an
|
||
infected pregnant woman to her fetus. Infection can occur from blood
|
||
transfusions of infected blood, or sharing 'dirty' needles. (Needles
|
||
already used, in this case, by a HIV positive person.)
|
||
|
||
The criminalization of intentionally spreading AIDS has been a big
|
||
issue recently, and still remains so. As of September, 1991, legislation
|
||
criminalizing AIDS transmission has been passed in 24 states. Among these
|
||
states are California, Idaho, Ohio, Missouri, Michigan, and South Carolina.
|
||
Under these current laws, it is a crime to knowingly transmit the virus
|
||
through sex, sharing needles, donating infected blood, organs, or skin
|
||
tissue.
|
||
|
||
The first person to go to court under these laws in Michigan was
|
||
Jeffrey Hanlon. Hanlon was a gay man who infected another man from
|
||
Michigan while he was in New York. The American Civil Liberties Union, who
|
||
agreed to take the case, agrued that the AIDS disclosure law is
|
||
unconstitutional. Privacy of those with AIDS is what they were worried
|
||
about. Opponents argued that "they're [those with AIDS] killing people.
|
||
It's like rape." The maximum sentence Hanlon could have recieved was four
|
||
years in prison and a $2000 fine.
|
||
|
||
In addition, under the current New York State law, which dates back
|
||
well before June, 1987, the knowing transmission of a venerial disease is a
|
||
felony. However, at that time, and currently, AIDS was not classified as a
|
||
venerial disease.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Interviews Concerning the Issue
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Most people believe that the willful transmission of AIDS to others it
|
||
virtually murder. I have interviewed **name** and **name**. Both of them
|
||
feel that intentionally passing AIDS on to another person is murder. The
|
||
recipient of the virus will, in almost every case, die rather quickly of an
|
||
AIDS related disease.
|
||
|
||
**name** feels that "if someone knowingly transmits AIDS to another
|
||
person, it's like committing murder. He or she should be punished to the
|
||
full extent of the law."
|
||
|
||
In addition to personal interviews, I have found the opinions of
|
||
Governor Cuomo and former President Ronald Reagan.
|
||
|
||
On June 1, 1987, Cuomo revealed that state lawmakers would consider
|
||
making the transmission of AIDS a crime. He was quoted at the time as
|
||
saying:
|
||
|
||
"If you know you have AIDS and you pass it on to someone who is not
|
||
aware, that should be regarded as a very serious offense. I'm not talking
|
||
about sins and morality; I'm talking about a sin against the community, a
|
||
crime. We should look into that." However, nothing was proposed at the
|
||
time.
|
||
|
||
Former President Ronald Reagan called for "routine" AIDS testing of
|
||
prisoners, marriage license applicants, immigrants, and possibly some
|
||
hospital patients. His purpose was only to identify carriers of the
|
||
disease; no comment concerning the criminalization of the transmission of
|
||
AIDS was made.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Reasons for the Criminalization of
|
||
Knowingly Transmitting AIDS
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
There are not many reasons for the criminalization of knowingly
|
||
transmitting AIDS. However, they are very convincing arguments.
|
||
|
||
The first and one of the most convincing arguments is because it will
|
||
help stop the propogation of the virus. Ideally, if people know that it is
|
||
a crime to transmit the virus, then they will not. The only way that AIDS
|
||
will remain an epidemic is if it is continually spread. This is because
|
||
those with AIDS will in most cases die rather quickly of an AIDS related
|
||
disease. If they do not spread it, then the number of people with the
|
||
virus will decline steadily without fail.
|
||
|
||
Another reason is that someone who is intentionally transmitting the
|
||
disease is doing it for their own satisfaction and/or to hurt others. Such
|
||
is the case with a drug pusher. Many magazine articles have made reference
|
||
to the analogy "a drug pusher is the same as an AIDS pusher." Their
|
||
argument is that if drug pushers are treated as if they commit criminal
|
||
acts, then so should the supposed 'AIDS' pushers.
|
||
|
||
The Constitutional argument involoved is also a moral one. By
|
||
transmitting the virus willingly one is usurping on others' rights to life
|
||
and happiness. It is also seen as wrong by the public. In effect, it is
|
||
murder in the second or third degree. If it is done intentionally, it is
|
||
murder in the first degree. Obviously this should be illegal and those who
|
||
break the proposed laws should be prosecuted as if they committed a crime.
|
||
|
||
Another reason to criminalize the transmission of AIDS is because the
|
||
money from fines incurred may be put towards research and development of
|
||
cures, as well as education and prevention programs. This will help stop
|
||
the problem and also speed up the process of finding a cure or immunization
|
||
for AIDS.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
Reasons Against the Criminalization of
|
||
Knowingly Transmitting AIDS
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
There are many more reasons against the criminalization of willingly
|
||
transmitting AIDS to others. However, these are based not on morals but on
|
||
facts and practicality.
|
||
|
||
Criminalizing AIDS would divert millions of dollars to legal fees that
|
||
could be better spent on AIDS programs such as prevention, education, and
|
||
research and development in terms of finding a cure. "Criminalization is a
|
||
short cut taken when not enough energy is given to prevention." Instead of
|
||
helping erradicate the epidemic, criminalization would instill more fear
|
||
among the people living with HIV. "It would create a witch hunt
|
||
atmosphere," stated William Ramir‚z, an attorney for a HIV positive client.
|
||
Criminalizing AIDS transmission would open doors for people to knowingly
|
||
accuse others they know that have it just to get rid of them.
|
||
|
||
The law would also be practically impossible to enforce. In some
|
||
cases, intent would have to be proven. However, it is usually impossible
|
||
to prove intent since it is not possible to go "inside" the minds of others
|
||
to know what they were thinking in their moment of passion, whether it be
|
||
intercourse or drug use.
|
||
|
||
Even the United States Health Department opposes criminalization. They
|
||
fear that it would scare people from reporting that they have AIDS. This
|
||
is because those that do report it may be accused of committing a crime
|
||
sometime in the future.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
My Position and Conclusion
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
I have mixed feelings on whether or not the transmission of AIDS should
|
||
be a criminal act. I feel that it is morally wrong, and in effect, those
|
||
who do it are committing murder. There is definitely a valid argument
|
||
there. However, due to the validity of the arguments against the
|
||
criminalization of passing AIDS on to others, I am partial to both sides.
|
||
I agree that it would divert millions of dollars that could be put to
|
||
better use in research and other programs. I also agree that it would be
|
||
legally and scientifically impossible to prove intent.
|
||
|
||
I feel that because of these conflicting ideas that I believe, the best
|
||
way to resolve the issue would be to make transmitting the virus a criminal
|
||
act, but not subject to jail time. Instead of wasting the taxpayers money
|
||
on giving free medical care and room and board to inmates, it should be put
|
||
towards finding a cure for AIDS. Instead of a jail term, those who
|
||
transmit the disease should be fined very heavily so as to discourage them
|
||
from repeating the offense. The money accrued from the fine should then be
|
||
used for research and other related programs, including helping those that
|
||
are infected.
|
||
|
||
All in all, AIDS is an epidemic that is a part of the nineties. It is
|
||
scary, but it must be dealt with. If the proper precautions are taken,
|
||
then eventually it will be taken care of in the right way. However, there
|
||
will unfortunately always be those that have malice towards society and
|
||
insist upon spreading their pain and suffering.
|