705 lines
30 KiB
INI
705 lines
30 KiB
INI
Date: Tuesday, 19 November 1991 09:51-GMT
|
|
From: starke@rhrk.uni-kl.de (Gerolf Starke [MW])
|
|
Re: Xwindows, all answers !!
|
|
|
|
Dear newsgroup readers!
|
|
|
|
Thanks to all who answered my query about an Xwindows terminal
|
|
emulation for PC/AT clones.
|
|
|
|
First I have to thank David Orman who gave me a lot of information
|
|
he received about the same subject.
|
|
|
|
I also have to thank Colin Frank, Lyle Holman and Bob Hardy for
|
|
the information.
|
|
|
|
In the following there's a summary of all the answers I received. All
|
|
names of persons (authors) are droped.
|
|
|
|
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
The main players seem to be Hummingbird communications HCL-eXceed (DOS
|
|
and MS windows), Unipalm X11/AT (windows), Locus computing (PC-Xsight),
|
|
Spectragraphics/GSS PC-Xview (DOS) and Visionware Xvision (windows).
|
|
|
|
Also "coming real soon" is Quarterdecks Desqview/X. This promises to
|
|
be a really exciting product, particularly as it will provide
|
|
portability of X based applications to the PC. While many developers
|
|
will appreciate the portability and using a non-proprietary system
|
|
rather than MS-Windows, the phenomenal success of MS Windows (at least
|
|
according to the computer press) will have no doubt cut deeply into
|
|
their potential market. No doubt this has a great bearing on the
|
|
extravagent advertising Quarterdeck indulged in late last year (a bid
|
|
for vapourware of the century???). Hopefully the portability to Unix
|
|
will encourage developers to use Desqview/X. Time only will tell.
|
|
|
|
Returning to the products available now, I was specifically asking for
|
|
comparisons of the various products available. The most informative
|
|
reply I got was from Steve Cohen (see below), who has tried many of these
|
|
products. His strong recommendation is for HCL-eXceed, using the FTP
|
|
software PC/TCP transport and VGA graphics. Esmond Pitt recommended
|
|
Xvision in favour of PC-Xview. Stephen Guerke noted that there is a
|
|
review of PC based X servers in the current PC Magazine -
|
|
unfortunately I haven't tracked down a copy of this yet as we seem to
|
|
be a few months behind! Digital Review (July 16, 1990) compared
|
|
HCL-eXceed with PC-Xsight and found the former much preferable. On
|
|
the basis of these comments HCL-eXceed seems to be the unanimous
|
|
choice for a PC based X server, at least as far as performance is
|
|
concerned.
|
|
|
|
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
A) Vendor List
|
|
|
|
AGE (619-565-7373) offers the XoftWare TIGA.
|
|
|
|
Bell Technologies (Fremont, CA: 415-659-9097)
|
|
|
|
PC DECWindows a.k.a. the PC DECWindows Display Facility is an
|
|
MS-DOS application that turns your PC into an X11R3 terminal.
|
|
It supports DECnet. Available from DEC. [Dennis Giokas
|
|
(giokas@mosaic.enet.dec.com), 3/90]
|
|
|
|
HP (800-752-0900) has the "HP Accelerated X Window Display
|
|
Server" (HP AXDS/PC; HP part D2300B) which will run on any
|
|
AT-class DOS machine with 640KB, MSDOS 3.1 or higher, and the
|
|
HP Intelligent Graphics Controller 10 card, to which the
|
|
X11R3-based server is downloaded (avoiding
|
|
performance-limitations from PC RAM-size and processor speed).
|
|
[from John Kempff (kempff@hppad.hp.com), 3/90]
|
|
|
|
Hummingbird Communications (Canada 416-470-1203) produces the
|
|
HCL-eXceed and HCL-eXceed Plus for EGA, VGA, and VGA+ controllers.
|
|
** Also HCL-eXceed/W for windows.
|
|
|
|
Information Network Solutions also offers a product called
|
|
HCL-eXceed for the *86. The fax is 02-4122079 inside
|
|
Australia, 612-4122079 from overseas.
|
|
|
|
Integrated Inference Machines (714-978-6201 or -6776) is
|
|
shipping X11/AT, an X server that runs under MS-windows. The
|
|
server converts an IBM-AT into an X terminal which can
|
|
simultaneously run MS-DOS and Microsoft Windows applications.
|
|
** Now marketed by Unipalm Limited (England 954-211797, Fax
|
|
954-211244).
|
|
|
|
Intelligent Decisions, Inc. (Sunnyvale, CA: 408-734-3730)
|
|
|
|
IBM is rumored to offer a product; part #5709-029.
|
|
|
|
Locus Computing (800-955-6287; CA: 213-670-6500; UK: +44 296
|
|
89911) has a server called PC-Xsight which also appears in
|
|
Acer's X terminal.
|
|
|
|
Metrolink Inc. (+1-305-566-9586, sales@metrolink.com; in
|
|
Europe contact ADNT, (33 1) 3956 5333) ships an implementation
|
|
of X11R4 for several 386 systems.
|
|
|
|
Pericom's TeemTalk-X for IBM clones allows toggling between X
|
|
and DOS. Information: +44 (0908) 560022. [5/90]
|
|
|
|
DESQview/X from Quarterdeck (213-392-9851; 213-399-3802 FAX)
|
|
incorporates X into the DESQview multi-tasking DOS
|
|
environment.
|
|
|
|
SpectraGraphics/GSS (503-641-2200) makes PC-Xview, an
|
|
MSDOS-based X server which interfaces with PC/TCP Plus
|
|
networking software from FTP Software and Excelan's LAN
|
|
WorkPlace for DOS. The server works with (a) 286, 386, 486
|
|
(b) EGA, VGA, DGIS displays. (c) DOS 3.2 and above (d)
|
|
Microsoft, Logitech, Mouse Systems Mice (e) 640k memory up to
|
|
16 MB memory [the PC-Xview/16 is available for PCs with
|
|
extended memory].
|
|
|
|
VisionWare's XVision is a Microsoft Windows-based X server
|
|
which allows an IBM-compatible PC or PS/2 to display X clients
|
|
running on a networked computer at the same time as local DOS
|
|
programs. VisionWare is at 612-377-3627 or vision@vware.mn.org
|
|
(UK: +44 532 788858 and vware@vision.uucp).
|
|
|
|
Xnth is an implementation of X11 R4 which runs on AT-bus PCs
|
|
running DOS 3.3 or higher. It currently supports 1280X1024 or
|
|
1024X768 resolution monitors at 256 colors (out of 16M) with
|
|
hardware accelleration for graphics and text operations. It
|
|
currently utilizes a TCP/IP byte stream over Ethernet.
|
|
Information: Jerry Norman, Nth Graphics, Ltd., 1-800-624-7552.
|
|
|
|
* StarNet Communications Corp 408-739-0881 Fax 408-739-0936
|
|
* makes an X server that runs on MS-DOS. MicroX has TCP/IP built
|
|
* in, and will work with any ethernet card that has a driver
|
|
* that conforms to the PC/TCP Packet Driver Specification --
|
|
* drivers for the most common card and in 256-color on most
|
|
* super VGA cards.
|
|
|
|
B) More detailed info on some vendors:
|
|
|
|
I. Server running under MS (Microsoft) Windows
|
|
|
|
1) Integrated Inference Machines (714-978-6201 or -6776)
|
|
|
|
Contact : John Walsh
|
|
X Server version : X11R3 (with R4 font support)
|
|
-- No plan for R4 yet
|
|
Network SW : supports PC-NFS
|
|
DOS version : 3.0
|
|
Memory Requirement: 2 MB
|
|
Graphic cards : EGA, VGA, 8514
|
|
AT : 286, 386, 486
|
|
PS/2 : Model 80 with 8514
|
|
Simultaneously run X, MS-DOS and Microsoft Windows applications: Yes
|
|
Cut & Paste between windows (includes X emulation window) : Yes
|
|
Price:
|
|
$495 (1-9 units)
|
|
$465 (10-24 units)
|
|
$395 (10-24 units with document sharing -- 1 doc/5 units)
|
|
$395 (25-95 units)
|
|
$325 (25-95 units with document sharing -- 1 doc/5 units)
|
|
Available: Yes
|
|
|
|
* Now marketed by Unipalm.
|
|
Single unit price 450 pounds.
|
|
Requires a TCP/IP carrier. PC/TCP kernel (serves X windows only)
|
|
available for 160 pounds.
|
|
|
|
|
|
2) SpectraGraphics/GSS (503-641-2200)
|
|
|
|
Contact : Mike Cox
|
|
Product Name : PC-Xvision
|
|
X Server version : X11R3
|
|
-- R4 is available in the summer
|
|
Network SW : supports PC-NFS
|
|
DOS version : 3.2
|
|
Memory Requirement: 3 MB (2MB for M/S Windows)
|
|
Graphic card : EGA, VGA, DGIS
|
|
AT (PS/2) : 286, 386, 486
|
|
Simultaneously run X, MS-DOS and Microsoft Windows applications: Yes
|
|
Cut & Paste between windows (includes X emulation window) : Yes
|
|
Price:
|
|
$449 (1 unit)
|
|
$359.2 (20-49 units -- 20% discount)
|
|
$336.75 (50+ units -- 25% discount)
|
|
|
|
(NOTE: The cost for the upgrade to X11R4 server is $150.
|
|
It is available in the summer.)
|
|
Available: Yes
|
|
|
|
|
|
****
|
|
3) Hummingbird Communications Ltd (416) 470-1203 Fax (416) 470-1207
|
|
|
|
Contact : Jan Adamek
|
|
Product Name : HCL-eXceed/W
|
|
X Server version : X11R4
|
|
Network SW : requires TCP/IP carrier
|
|
DOS version : > 3.0, MS Windows 3.0
|
|
Memory Requirement: 2MB
|
|
Graphic card : Supported by MS windows
|
|
AT (PS/2) : 286, 386, 486
|
|
Simultaneously run X, MS-DOS and Microsoft Windows applications: Yes
|
|
Cut & Paste between windows (includes X emulation window) : Yes
|
|
Price:
|
|
US $595 (1 unit)
|
|
US $536 (2-4 units)
|
|
US $476 (5-9 units)
|
|
US $417 (10+ units)
|
|
Available: Yes
|
|
****
|
|
|
|
|
|
II. Native Server (Not running under Microsoft Windows)
|
|
|
|
1) Locus Computing (800-955-6287; CA: 213-670-6500)
|
|
|
|
Contact : Dada Halili (213-337-5251)
|
|
Product Name : PC-Xsight
|
|
X Server version : X11R3 & X11R4
|
|
Network SW : supports PC-NFS 3.1+
|
|
DOS version : 3.1+
|
|
Memory Requirement: 2 MB upto 16MB extended memory
|
|
Graphic card : EGA, VGA, 8514A
|
|
AT : 286, 386, 486
|
|
PS/2 : Model 70, 80
|
|
Swicthing between DOS and X Server: Yes
|
|
Price:
|
|
$495 (with Locus TCP/IP)
|
|
$425 (without Locus TCP/IP)
|
|
~$382.5 (12-19 unit, 10% discount)
|
|
~$361.25 (20+ unit, 15% discount)
|
|
Available: Yes
|
|
|
|
(NOTE: Microsoft Windows support in 5-6 months.)
|
|
|
|
2) SpectraGraphics/GSS (503-641-2200)
|
|
|
|
Contact : Mike Cox
|
|
Product Name : PC-Xview
|
|
X Server version : X11R3
|
|
-- R4 is available in the summer
|
|
Network SW : supports PC-NFS
|
|
DOS version : 2.1.2
|
|
Memory Requirement: 640KB upto 16MB extended memory
|
|
Graphic card : EGA, VGA, DGIS
|
|
AT (PS/2) : 286, 386, 486
|
|
Swicthing between DOS and X Server: Yes
|
|
Price:
|
|
$445 (1 unit)
|
|
~$356 (20-49 units -- 20% discount)
|
|
~$333.75 (50+ units -- 25% discount)
|
|
|
|
(NOTE: The cost for the upgrade to X11R4 server is $150.
|
|
It is available in the summer.)
|
|
Available: Yes
|
|
|
|
|
|
****
|
|
3) Hummingbird Communications Ltd (416) 470-1203 Fax (416) 470-1207
|
|
|
|
Contact : Jan Adamek
|
|
Product Name : HCL-eXceed/Plus
|
|
X Server version : X11R4
|
|
Network SW : requires TCP/IP carrier
|
|
DOS version : > 3.0
|
|
Memory Requirement: 1.64MB
|
|
Graphic card : EGA, VGA, many Super VGA
|
|
AT (PS/2) : 286, 386, 486
|
|
Simultaneously run X, MS-DOS and Microsoft Windows applications: Yes
|
|
Cut & Paste between windows (includes X emulation window) : Yes
|
|
Price:
|
|
US $595 (1 unit)
|
|
US $536 (2-4 units)
|
|
US $476 (5-9 units)
|
|
US $417 (10+ units)
|
|
Available: Yes
|
|
****
|
|
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
I don't know if you get PC MAGAZINE, but the current issue has a
|
|
rather lengthy discussion of just this issue. It mentions and reviews
|
|
several of the products that you mentioned in your list. Unfortunatly
|
|
I don't have the magazine here with me or I would try to summarize it
|
|
for you. On product (not yet available....but "real soon now") that
|
|
looks like a winner is DESQviewX by Quaterdeck. Apparantly this
|
|
product (when available) will solve (I'll belive it when I see it)a
|
|
lot of the complaints about the other products...the major one being
|
|
that they tend to run slowly on a PC..
|
|
------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
I have been doing studies and benchmarks on the various X-SERVER
|
|
products that are available for PC's.
|
|
|
|
After much research the three products from Hummingbird, are by far the
|
|
fastest, easiest to use, and real implementations of X11 R4.
|
|
|
|
Hummingbirds EXCEED/W for WINDOWs 3.0 is almost twice as fast as
|
|
X-VISION and almost an order of magnitude faster than X11-AT.
|
|
|
|
X-VISION is very difficult to install and if your computer cannot
|
|
do an rsh, is a pain to start up.
|
|
|
|
EXCEED/w gives good performance on a 386sx based system.
|
|
|
|
It is much better to use PC/TCP from FTP software than the other transports.
|
|
|
|
For non Windows 3.0 systems use EXCEED/P from Hummingbird. It is an R4
|
|
server and takes advantage of extended memory. It is much faster than
|
|
any of the other X-SERVERS, and will run with PC-NFS, ftp's software
|
|
or EXCELLAN.
|
|
|
|
the Locus PC-XSIGHT product is not particularly easy to install,
|
|
has a lot of bugs, and is slow.
|
|
|
|
I have used the Hummingbird products on 286s, 386sx, 386s and a 486. It is
|
|
almost twice as fast with a VGA card instead of an EGA card.
|
|
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
>
|
|
> PC-Xview Graphic Software Systems
|
|
>
|
|
> * Xvision Visionware
|
|
|
|
I have used both of these and would recommend the latter over the
|
|
former, if you can live with the different environment, i.e. windows,
|
|
no xdm/mwm on the host (good!). Xview seemed slow and clunky to me.
|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Received you letter via NASA/Ames. I would like to introduce
|
|
you to MicroX. StarNet Communications Corp 408-739-0881 Fax
|
|
408-739-0936 makes an X server that runs on MS-DOS. MicroX
|
|
has TCP/IP built in, and will work with any ethernet card
|
|
that has a driver that conforms to the PC/TCP Packet Driver
|
|
Specification -- drivers for the most common card and in
|
|
256-color on most super VGA cards.
|
|
Other information follows to the address that is at the
|
|
bottom of your letter. [Contact Larry Wible <larry@starnet.com>]
|
|
|
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
I recently ran into a new one which runs under MS Windows (286/386
|
|
only). Implied is that the X Windows will run under any display
|
|
configuration which has an MS Windows device driver.
|
|
|
|
Product: X11/AT
|
|
Company: Integrated Inference Machines
|
|
1468 E. Katella Ave.
|
|
Anaheim, CA 92805
|
|
(714) 978-6776
|
|
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Transparent Technology has a product called PC-Xsight which is apparently
|
|
a full implementation of X 11.3 under MS-DOS, using TCP/IP over an Ethernet
|
|
connection to talk to the server. They advertise in Unix Review, among
|
|
other places. Total cost of their software is around $500, with another
|
|
$700 buying you a Western Digital Ethernet card, a Paradise VGA card, and a
|
|
Logitech mouse, which they selected and vend because of proven value &
|
|
compatibility with PC-Xsight. I don't have their address handy.
|
|
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Graphic Software Systems (GSS) offers PC-Xview, an X Window server on a PC.
|
|
PC-Xview interfaces with PC/TCP Plus networking software from FTP Software
|
|
and Excelan's LAN WorkPlace for DOS. GSS is a distributor for the PC/TCP
|
|
product and can offer you one stop shopping for all of your PC X Server needs.
|
|
|
|
PC-Xview works with:
|
|
|
|
a) 286, 386, 486
|
|
b) EGA, VGA, DGIS displays. DGIS displays are available from Compaq,
|
|
Dell, HP, NEC, Imagraph, Control Systems, and others
|
|
c) DOS 3.2 and above
|
|
d) Microsoft, Logitech, Mouse Systems Mice
|
|
e) 640k memory up to 16 MB memory
|
|
f) Network cards from 3Com, WD, Interlan, Intel, Proteon, UB,
|
|
Nat'l Semi, Tiara, and Excelan. Also SLIP.
|
|
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
VisionWare XVISION - The X Connection for Microsoft Windows
|
|
|
|
XVision is a Microsoft Windows based X server which allows an IBM-compatible PC
|
|
or PS/2 to display X clients running on a networked computer, at the same time
|
|
as local DOS programs. The main features are:
|
|
|
|
o A PC becomes an X Window System graphics terminal.
|
|
|
|
o Microsoft Windows based X server.
|
|
|
|
o X clients and DOS applications appear on the same screen.
|
|
|
|
o Cut and paste between X clients and DOS applications using the Windows
|
|
Clipboard.
|
|
|
|
o Full support for X11 protocols.
|
|
|
|
o Use a standard X Window manager, or let Microsoft Windows manage X
|
|
clients.
|
|
|
|
o Independent of specific PC graphics display system.
|
|
|
|
X FOR WINDOWS
|
|
|
|
XVision is a Microsoft Windows application, which means that you
|
|
can run X Window System clients alongside DOS programs on a PC
|
|
workstation. This provides a common user interface for DOS and X
|
|
applications, and allows cut and paste operations to transfer
|
|
information between them.
|
|
|
|
Because the server runs under Microsoft Windows it can use any
|
|
graphics display screen for which a Windows driver is available. This
|
|
includes EGA and VGA, as well as large high resolution monitors.
|
|
|
|
XVISION SERVER
|
|
|
|
The XVision server is based on the sample server distributed by the X
|
|
Consortium. It runs on a PC under Microsoft Windows and supports the
|
|
standard X protocol between clients and the server over TCP/IP network
|
|
links. This is the most efficient method of implementation since the X
|
|
protocol is optimised to reduce the overheads involved in passing
|
|
graphics requests to and receiving events from a workstation.
|
|
|
|
XVision does not require any special software to be installed on a
|
|
host system and it can accept requests from X clients running anywhere
|
|
on the network. The interface between XVision and the PC network
|
|
software is implemented as a DOS TSR program, which provides a
|
|
flexible method of supporting different networks.
|
|
|
|
XVision allows cut and paste operations between X clients to be
|
|
carried out in the normal way using the X selection mechanism. It also
|
|
enables the data associated with a text selection to be mirrored on
|
|
the Windows Clipboard. This enables data to be copied between X
|
|
clients and DOS applications.
|
|
|
|
The server is capable of running a few simple clients on a PC with 640
|
|
kbytes of memory. It implements virtual memory to allow a greater
|
|
number of clients and more complex clients to be run. The virtual
|
|
memory mechanism will make use of expanded memory if it is available,
|
|
and if there is insufficient expanded memory it will use the hard
|
|
disk.
|
|
|
|
Clients can be initiated from the PC, or may be started anywhere on
|
|
the network. For a UNIX host, the X Display Manager can be set up to
|
|
allow a user to log in and execute the first X client. Otherwise,
|
|
TELNET or another terminal emulator facility can be used to initiate
|
|
the X session.
|
|
|
|
WINDOW MANAGEMENT
|
|
|
|
There are two different ways of using XVision. The first way is for
|
|
the whole X world to occupy one Microsoft Window, and all X clients
|
|
appear within this window. The Microsoft Window may be positioned on
|
|
the screen in relation to other DOS windows or iconised in the normal
|
|
Windows manner. To manage individual X client windows within the
|
|
single Microsoft Window, a standard X window manager such as UWM must
|
|
be used.
|
|
|
|
When used in this single window display mode you can specify that the
|
|
"virtual display" should be larger than the size of the PC screen, and
|
|
Microsoft Windows scroll bars can then be used to alter the visible
|
|
area.
|
|
|
|
The second way to use XVision is for each X client to run within its
|
|
own Microsoft Window, and here individual X client window management
|
|
may be achieved by using the standard Microsoft Windows management
|
|
facilities. This method provides X applications with a Presentation
|
|
Manager look and feel to their user interface. When a client opens a
|
|
window it supplies "hints" such as size, title and icon which are
|
|
mapped to equivalent features of a Microsoft Window.
|
|
|
|
X FONTS SUPPLIED
|
|
|
|
Compiled versions of the standard X fonts are distributed with
|
|
XVision, and you have the option to install all of them or just a
|
|
minimum set. A Microsoft Windows font file is associated with each
|
|
X font file, and contains the character bitmaps. All the other
|
|
properties of the X font remain in the X font file and many are used
|
|
by the server when drawing text.
|
|
|
|
XVISION AND VISIONWARE
|
|
|
|
XVision is one of a range of VisionWare workstation integration
|
|
products and services. Also available is PC-Connect, which allows
|
|
IBM-compatible PC or PS/2 computers to act as multi-windowed
|
|
workstations connected to one or more UNIX host systems without the
|
|
need for the X Windows system. SQL-Connect enables workstation users
|
|
to access information held in remote SQL databases. The VisionWare
|
|
strategy is to combine PCs and multi-user systems into a unified
|
|
operating environment, so that maximum benefits can be obtained from
|
|
information processing technology.
|
|
|
|
SYSTEM REQUIREMENTS
|
|
|
|
An IBM-compatible PC/AT or PS/2 computer with at least an 80286 processor.
|
|
|
|
At least 640kbytes of memory. XVision will also use LIM/EMS 3.2 or 4.0
|
|
expanded memory if available.
|
|
|
|
A hard disk.
|
|
|
|
Either a 1.2Mbyte 5 1/4" disk drive, or a 1.44Mbyte 3 1/2" drive.
|
|
|
|
Windows compatible graphics adapter and display.
|
|
|
|
A mouse is strongly recommended. A three-button mouse is ideal, but a
|
|
two-button mouse can be used together with the emulation facilities
|
|
built into XVision.
|
|
|
|
A local area network card and networking software.
|
|
|
|
MS-DOS or PC-DOS version 3.0 or later.
|
|
|
|
A run-time version of Microsoft Windows may be included with XVision
|
|
(ask your supplier or call VisionWare). If you want to use full
|
|
Windows then you need Windows/286 or Windows/386 version 2.0 or later.
|
|
|
|
XVISION PACKAGES
|
|
|
|
There are two XVision packages, one containing 5 1/4" disks (1.2 Mbyte)
|
|
and the other containing 3 1/2" disks (1.44Mbyte). Choose the
|
|
appropriate package for your disk drive.
|
|
|
|
AVAILABILITY
|
|
|
|
XVision is supplied with network communications interface programs for
|
|
various TCP/IP networking software. These include Locus TCP/IP for
|
|
DOS, FTP PC/TCP and Excelan LAN WorkPlace. More networks are being
|
|
added continually, and you contact your supplier or VisionWare for
|
|
exact details of availability.
|
|
|
|
|
|
(C) VisionWare Limited, 1989. All Rights Reserved.
|
|
|
|
The names of companies referred to herein, their corporate logos, the
|
|
names of their hardware and software may be tradenames, trademarks or
|
|
registered trademarks of their respective owners.
|
|
|
|
The policy of VisionWare Limited is to develop and enhance its
|
|
products and services and it therefore reserves the right to alter
|
|
without notice the specification and/or design thereof.
|
|
|
|
VisionWare Limited, The Leeds Business Park, Morley, Leeds LS27 0JG, UK
|
|
Tel +44-532-522020. Fax +44-532-526614. Telex 556283. Email: vware@vison.uucp
|
|
|
|
VisionWare, PO Box 3991, Minneapolis, MN 55405, USA
|
|
Tel +1-612-377-3627
|
|
|
|
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
For those interested in using X Windows Version 11 Release 3 on an
|
|
IBM-AT (80286 or 80386) or compatible, Integrated Inference Machines
|
|
is shipping a high performance X11 server called X11/AT which runs
|
|
under MS-DOS using Microsoft Windows for $395. The server converts an
|
|
IBM-AT into an X Windows terminal which can simultaneosuly run MS-DOS
|
|
and Microsoft Windows applications. FTP and TELNET are also supplied.
|
|
X11/AT requires a system with 2Meg of extended memory. Because X11/AT
|
|
runs under Microsoft Windows, a large variety of monochrome and color
|
|
displays are supported including EGA, VGA, and special high resolution
|
|
displays.
|
|
|
|
For more information, contact:
|
|
|
|
Charles Baecker
|
|
Integrated Inference Machines
|
|
1468 E. Katella Avenue
|
|
Anahiem, California 92805
|
|
Phone (714)978-6201
|
|
FAX (714)939-0746
|
|
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
You can run X on PC's without X cards. There is X/Sight from Locus
|
|
Computing, XVision from VisionWare Ltd., and XView from GSS, Inc. Of
|
|
these products, so far I have found that XView is actually the fastest
|
|
in terms of performance, and was one of the easiest to install.
|
|
|
|
They all have dependencies upon some third party vendor's TCP/IP
|
|
software to handle the X protocol; the best of which is from FTP
|
|
Software. None of these packages were easy to install on the PC; in
|
|
fact Locus' product was by far the most difficult. It took quite a
|
|
bit of hacking to brute force X/Sight into working because the
|
|
documentation was poorly organized and lacked adequate "real"
|
|
examples.
|
|
|
|
XVision had its problems too, but they were not related to XVision,
|
|
rather they were MS Windows problems because of Windows 3.0 was still
|
|
a beta release. The XVision installation process was the easiest
|
|
because it has to conform to the standard MS Windows installation
|
|
guidelines which makes it easy for novices. It also needed some
|
|
"persuasion" before being able to work correctly, but once it did it
|
|
worked as advertised, although somewhat slow.
|
|
|
|
XView was easy to install, their documentation is adequate but could
|
|
use some minor improvement. It is the fastest of the three packages
|
|
even though I am told that I am using the slowest of the Ethernet
|
|
boards. I personally like XView the best, although novice PC users
|
|
will probably like XVision better because of the familiar MS Windows
|
|
interface. XView, like X/Sight allows you to hot key between your X
|
|
session and local DOS.
|
|
|
|
I can't tell you much more than this, because I have written
|
|
evauations for articles to be published in an upcoming issue of
|
|
UnixWorld, about these three fine products. Take your pick, any of
|
|
them are OK, but I feel that speed, reliability, and ease of
|
|
installation are very important so I personally would recommend XView
|
|
(if you are not a PC novice) or XVision if you are a MS Windows junkie
|
|
like myself.
|
|
|
|
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
I have been using XVision from VisionWare, Ltd., on a 286, using FTP's
|
|
PC/TCP communications software via a 3COM 3C503 Ethernet board. For one
|
|
that does not need to work "heavily" within the X environment, I find it
|
|
an excellent solution.
|
|
|
|
It requires Microsoft Windows (I am using 3.0). That means that I
|
|
have my normal PC windows and I have "X" windows. Actually, XVision
|
|
works in either "multi-window" or "single-window" mode. The "multi"
|
|
means that each X client has its own Microsoft window and that
|
|
Microsoft Windows handles much of the windowing -- more efficient that
|
|
way. The "single" approach means there is one X window, inside of
|
|
which you have as many X clients as you wish (see caveat later). I
|
|
actually prefer working this way, as it is closer to the real X feel.
|
|
Nonetheless, you should realize that the more efficient way is "multi"
|
|
windowing.
|
|
|
|
Since the PC is color, the X, naturally, provides color. With one
|
|
exception, I have not had any problem with the color. It has only
|
|
been an asset. The one exception is FrameMaker -- just yesterday I
|
|
tried for the first time to use it and it complained that the colors
|
|
weren't setup correctly. I haven't tried to resolve this yet, but I
|
|
assume it will be no problem.
|
|
|
|
So far as running on a 286, it is slow in setting up the environment.
|
|
It takes about 60 sections before I see my first X window. On a 386,
|
|
I assume it would be much faster. Until I get all my windows set up
|
|
just the way I like takes about 1 1/2 minutes more. Once set up, I
|
|
have two mailbox windows, one to a Sun workstation and one to a
|
|
mainframe, I have a "manual browser" from another mainframe, I have a
|
|
"workload" figure from a Sun, and I have four working windows, two on
|
|
Suns and two on mainframes, these last two using "tn3270" to give me
|
|
true 3270 compatibility. And that works nicely, too.
|
|
|
|
Again, but for setup, I think the response is fine. I have good
|
|
control of moving windows around, resizing them, iconizing them,
|
|
opening them up, etc.
|
|
|
|
By the way, my screen is a MultiSync 3D, with a video adapter from
|
|
Video Seven, 512K video RAM. This provides 1024x768 resolution. It
|
|
means I can devote one half of my screen to PC and one half to X, and
|
|
the X side is wide enough to give me a full 80x24 character screen.
|
|
The size of the lettering is small, but I can live with it. I think a
|
|
better solution, however, would be to have a 16" or even 19" monitor.
|
|
I'm looking into that now.
|
|
|
|
The only big problem that I have is that XVision has a limit,
|
|
unfortunately, of only ten X clients. For a serious user, that is a
|
|
very bad limitation. Additionally, a bug in the system causes it to
|
|
die a most unglorious death when you try to create the eleventh
|
|
client. As my mother would say, "You shouldn't know from such
|
|
things." PC/TCP from FTP, however, allows you to set a limit on the
|
|
number of TCP/IP connections, and this precludes my ever asking for
|
|
the eleventh client. Visionware is aware of the bug and is coming out
|
|
with a correction. They also recognize that ten clients is a very low
|
|
number. They aren't saying when they'll have a version allowing more
|
|
than ten.
|
|
|
|
That's about it. In summary, it's a very good solution for one who has
|
|
strong ties to the PC world, but needs a "window" (no pun intended) to the
|
|
X world.
|
|
|
|
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
I got the following info from David Solan, sales rep of the Wollongong Group
|
|
(415) 962-7172. They produce a TCP/IP package for windows plus a lot more
|
|
He sent me some info about their product that included vendors that
|
|
sell X servers for Windows3.0. These include:
|
|
|
|
Product: Windows 3.0 based X11R4 server
|
|
-------------------------------------------------------
|
|
Company: Hummingbird Communications
|
|
Phone: (416) 470-1203
|
|
|
|
Company: Integrated Inference Machines
|
|
Phone: (714) 939-0746
|
|
|
|
Company: VisionWare
|
|
Phone: (201) 985-8000
|
|
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
I have seen three programs that allow your PC to act as an X
|
|
terminal over the ethernet.
|
|
|
|
Xvision
|
|
Spectragraphics
|
|
1-800-800-9599
|
|
|
|
HCL-eXceed/W
|
|
Hummingbird Communications Inc.
|
|
416-470-1203
|
|
|
|
Xsight
|
|
AGE Logic Inc.
|
|
619-455-8600
|
|
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
|
|
DESQview-X should be released soon. It claims to do (X) windows.
|
|
|
|
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
|
|
Thanks to all again,
|
|
|
|
Gerolf Starke
|
|
--
|
|
Gerolf Starke Tel: +49/631/205-2419
|
|
Institute of Applied and Technical Mechanics e-mail: starke@rhrk.uni-kl.de
|
|
University of Kaiserslautern, 6750 compuserve: 100010,3451
|