120 lines
6.9 KiB
Standard ML
120 lines
6.9 KiB
Standard ML
Copyright 1983
|
||
NPG,Ltd.
|
||
FINGERPRINTING KIDS
|
||
|
||
Issue: Should parents voluntarily create detailed identification records
|
||
(including fingerprints) on their children in anticipation of possible runaway
|
||
problems or abductions? (1) Yes. You can never tell when terrible things will
|
||
happen to a child, so its best to be prepared. (2) No. The vast majority of
|
||
missing children are not abducted. Whether abducted or not, fingerprinting will
|
||
do no good. It wastes time and money and pushes us that much closer to the
|
||
creation of the Orwellian National Data Center that Congress rejected fifteen
|
||
years ago.
|
||
|
||
BACKGROUND: As of early 1983, 11 states had launched programs to fingerprint
|
||
children.( These were New York, Virginia, Florida, Georgia, New Jersey,
|
||
California, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Nebraska, Connecticut, Rhode Island,
|
||
Kansas, Illinois, and Indiana.)
|
||
|
||
Most of this activity was stimulated by the passage of the Missing Children
|
||
Act in October 1982. What the new law did was to legitimize the use of the
|
||
FBI's national computer network,the National Crime Information Center (NCIC) for
|
||
non-criminal purposes.
|
||
|
||
All of the programs are voluntary. In some cases the police departments
|
||
retain the records, while in others the fingerprint cards are turned over to the
|
||
parents for safekeeping. The apparent purpose of the program is to help provide
|
||
positive identification to link either children picked up, or bodies recovered,
|
||
with missing person notices.
|
||
|
||
Every year about 1 million children are reported missing. Of these most,
|
||
about 800,000, are away from home for less than two weeks. About 150,000 of the
|
||
total missing are abducted; of these two thirds are abducted by a divorced
|
||
parent.
|
||
|
||
Some of the reasons behind the missing children are not pretty. According to
|
||
an article in Parade, "about 35 percent of runaways leave home because of
|
||
incest, 53 percent because of physical neglect. The rest are "throwaways,"
|
||
children kicked out or simply abandoned by parents who move away. Every state
|
||
has laws against incest, child abuse, abandonment, child pornography and the
|
||
procuring of children, but they are rarely enforced."
|
||
|
||
POINT: Conscientious parents should have their childrens' fingerprints
|
||
recorded to help in the event of an abduction; they shouldn't wait until after
|
||
something terrible happens, but should take reasonable steps now. Thousands of
|
||
children are runaways, and in many cases it is all but impossible to determine
|
||
clearly who they really are. People change, but fingerprints don't.
|
||
Well-intentioned but misguided civil libertarians worry about Big Brother. But
|
||
they tend to overlook the obvious benefits of the program and concentrate on
|
||
wildly imaginative fantasies about Big Brother. If they would come down to
|
||
earth once in a while, and visit with and share the anguish of a family of an
|
||
abducted child, they would quickly change their attitudes. Besides, in most
|
||
cases the police do not keep the records, the parents do.
|
||
|
||
COUNTERPOINT: Absent some showing that the fingerprinting will actually help
|
||
keep children safe and help capture criminals who harm or abduct them, parents
|
||
should refuse to have their children fingerprinted. In promoting the child
|
||
fingerprinting program, police officials tend to be vague about how the program
|
||
will increase the average child's safety. How does it improve children's safety
|
||
to be fingerprinted? Surely, it may help identify a body, but that is not much
|
||
help. Besides, dental records do the same thing and probably do a better job.
|
||
People forget that this program is geared to eventually entering the child's
|
||
identification data into the National Crime Information Center. That is a
|
||
criminal records databank, and it could be very harmful to a child in the future
|
||
to have what many employers will automatically take to be a "criminal record."
|
||
And that is not far fetched. In April 1983 the Congress' General Accounting
|
||
Office released a report saying that in some states children picked up as
|
||
runaways are jailed along with real criminals. GAO found that in five states
|
||
(Virginia, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, North Carolina, and Oregon) 39 percent
|
||
of the juveniles incarcerated had not been charged with a serious offense,
|
||
despite federal standards requiring that. Running away from home, shoplifting
|
||
and other minor thefts made up most of the offenses. Even advocates admit to
|
||
the possibility of a stigma. A PTA Council President in Virginia spoke out in
|
||
favor of the program: "I can't think at this point of a practical reason for
|
||
not having your fingerprints taken. It seems to me the higher the percentage of
|
||
the population that has its fingerprints on file, the less stigma will be
|
||
attached to it." Another mother, as her child was being fingerprinted, told a
|
||
New York Times reporter, "Unless you're planning a life of crime for your child,
|
||
I can't see why any parent would object." If we are really serious about
|
||
reducing the runaway problem, we should demand that our police officials start
|
||
looking closely into the family situations from which the runaway came from. If
|
||
there is evidence of incest or abuse, the offendor should be prosecuted. Maybe
|
||
if more abusive parents got that message, they would be less inclined to do the
|
||
things that cause the vast majority of runaway cases in the first place.
|
||
|
||
QUESTIONS:
|
||
o Do you think that the police will be more effective in locating missing
|
||
children if there are copies of their fingerprints on record?
|
||
|
||
o Do you think that there is any problem with having your own records stored in
|
||
a criminal record computer system? Would anyone assume from such records that
|
||
you have done something wrong?
|
||
|
||
o If a child runs away from home because of incest or physical abuse, should
|
||
the police help put him back in that home?
|
||
|
||
o Do you think that the voluntary fingerprinting program will make the next
|
||
generation of American citizens less reluctant to let government keep more
|
||
records on them? Or will it have the opposite effect and make people used to
|
||
having this kind of record kept?
|
||
|
||
REFERENCES:
|
||
Fingerprinting of Children Spreading, New York Times,
|
||
February 22, 1983
|
||
Fingerprinting the Kids Won't Solve the Problem, The Fairfax
|
||
Journal (editorial), April 15, 1983, p.A6
|
||
Reston Kids Ink Up for Fingerprints, Adrian Higgins, The
|
||
Fairfax Journal, September 19, 1983, p.A1
|
||
Jersey County Fingerprints Pupils, Franklin Whitehouse, The
|
||
New York Times, January 26, 1983, p.B1
|
||
Alexandria Cops To Fingerprint School Kids, Joe O'Neill, The
|
||
Fairfax Journal, February 23, 1983, p.A4
|
||
Child Abductions A Rising Concern, Associated Press, The New
|
||
York Times, December 5, 1983
|
||
Finding Missing Children, The Washington Post (editorial),
|
||
May 28, 1982
|
||
|
||
(Note: Please leave your thoughts -- message or uploaded comments -- on this
|
||
issue on Tom Mack's RBBS, The Second Ring --- (703) 759-5049. Please address
|
||
them to Terry Steichen of New Perspectives Group, Ltd.)
|
||
|