894 lines
49 KiB
Plaintext
894 lines
49 KiB
Plaintext
----------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
VOLUME 1, NUMBER 3 --
|
|
PRIVATE LINE: A JOURNAL OF INQUIRY INTO THE
|
|
TELEPHONE SYSTEM
|
|
|
|
INFORMATION ON PRIVATE LINE
|
|
I. EDITORIAL PAGE
|
|
II. UPDATES AND CORRECTIONS
|
|
III AN INTRODUCTION TO LOCAL SCANNING
|
|
IV. DEF CON II REVIEW: FEAR AND HACKING IN LAS VEGAS
|
|
V. ROAD TRIP TO VEGAS
|
|
IV. A FEW THOUGHTS ON EMS AND 911
|
|
|
|
----------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
GENERAL INFORMATION ON PRIVATE LINE
|
|
ISSN No. 1077-3487
|
|
|
|
A. private line is published six times a year by Tom Farley. Copyright
|
|
(c) 1994 It runs 24 to 28 pages. It's done in black and white.
|
|
|
|
B. Subscriptions: $24 a year for subscriber's in the U.S. $31 to Canada
|
|
or Mexico.
|
|
$44 overseas. Mailed first class or equivalent.
|
|
1. Make checks or money orders payable in US funds to private line.
|
|
2. Back issues are five dollars apiece.
|
|
3. A sample is four dollars.
|
|
4. The mailing list is not available to anyone but me.
|
|
|
|
C. Mailing address: 5150 Fair Oaks Blvd. #101-348, Carmichael, CA
|
|
95608
|
|
|
|
D. e-mail address: privateline@delphi.com
|
|
|
|
E. Phone numbers: (916) 488-4231 Voice (916) 978-0810 FAX
|
|
|
|
F. Submissions: Go for it! Anything semi-technical is strongly
|
|
encouraged. I pay with subscriptions.
|
|
|
|
G. Ads: Yes, I'm taking electronic related ads. A full page is $75.00, a
|
|
half page $37.50 and a quarter $18.75. Subscribers get free classified
|
|
ads of 25 words or less.
|
|
|
|
H. Feel free to post this file at any site or on any BBS you wish. I just
|
|
ask that you keep the file together and not sell any hardcopy version of it.
|
|
Fair enough?
|
|
|
|
I. The fourth issue is now on sale. Send me four dollars or ask your
|
|
dealer to get it through Fine Print Distributors.
|
|
|
|
------------------------------------------------------------------
|
|
|
|
I. EDITORIAL PAGE
|
|
|
|
Going National; War Footing
|
|
|
|
Welcome to the third issue of private line. I hope you enjoy it. The look
|
|
and feel of this issue is different from the first two. Why? Well, it's an
|
|
effort to make the magazine more readable. The first two issues had a
|
|
great deal of information. I presented that information, however, in a
|
|
dry, humorless form. Without enough pictures and photographs. I think
|
|
I can do better, in fact, I know that I must. private line is going national.
|
|
|
|
I got a letter from Fine Print Distributors of Austin, Texas when I got
|
|
back from Def Con. Fine Print distributes FactSheet5 as well as several
|
|
hundred other periodicals. They wanted to distribute private line. I was
|
|
happy that I had found a way to put the magazine on newsstands. That's
|
|
where my readers are. But Fine Print wanted 250 copies to start. As in
|
|
starting now. And that's when the problems began.
|
|
|
|
I had been producing private line cheaply by myself. I'd take the
|
|
originals to Kinkos and run off twenty-five or thirty copies at a time. It
|
|
was an affordable, part time hobby. Two hundred and fifty copies,
|
|
however, is quite a different thing. That would cost at least 300 dollars.
|
|
Plus shipping. I would prefer, however, to print 350 copies since I sell
|
|
back issues and because I need samples. That's at least four hundred and
|
|
fifty dollars. For the first issue. With five more needed for 1995. With
|
|
no guarantee that the magazine would sell. I could be down over three
|
|
thousand dollars in less than a year. What to do? I needed financing, a
|
|
small business plan and some advertisers. A scanner to add pictures. And
|
|
time to learn how to produce a more readable
|
|
magazine.
|
|
|
|
So, I punted. I put off the distributor. I explained the problems and they
|
|
were very nice about it. They would be ready when I was. I thought that
|
|
the first of the year would be a good idea. The first national edition,
|
|
therefore, comes out in January of 1995. private line is now on a war
|
|
footing. We're behind schedule but world domination will begin soon.
|
|
We will never put off a major decision again. Instead, every opportunity
|
|
will be exploited immediately. private line's staff has dispersed and gone
|
|
to ground. This assures the public that the national issue will not be
|
|
stopped. We'll come out swinging for the national edition. Speaking of
|
|
which, let me tell you about some new things scheduled for the January
|
|
issue.
|
|
|
|
Chris Hall of Executive Protection Associates has agreed to write a
|
|
column. He's their Chief Operating Officer. This company deals with,
|
|
among other things, industrial espionage and corporate spying. He
|
|
helped give a great talk at Def Con. His first column may be on telephone
|
|
bugs.
|
|
|
|
John Higdon will write a column about telecom from a non-corporate
|
|
point of view. John keeps alt.dcom.telecom.tech together. It is the most
|
|
technically grounded newsgroup. John is a good writer with common
|
|
sense. His posts are always informative and independent.
|
|
|
|
I will add a small column on telephony and the internet. I'll try to list
|
|
which resources feature information on communications. The internet is a
|
|
great help to learning. Books and magazines are wonderful but limited.
|
|
Try to find, for example, a recent American book on pay phones. There
|
|
aren't any. But you may find a coin line expert in a newsgroup who is
|
|
willing to talk. Many people in these groups have worked their entire
|
|
lives in telecom. They have insights and answers that you will not find
|
|
anywhere else.
|
|
|
|
In the meantime, this issue will concentrate less on technical issues and
|
|
more on observation and opinion. There is no other way to comment on
|
|
Def Con. The January issue will have more real information. There may
|
|
be less, however, than in the first two issues because of the space taken
|
|
up by the photographs. Still, the information that is presented will be
|
|
more understandable than in the past. I wish you all well and I hope you
|
|
contribute.
|
|
|
|
73's
|
|
|
|
Tom Farley
|
|
|
|
II. UPDATES AND CORRECTIONS
|
|
|
|
1. I made a big mistake in the second issue. It's in the Coin First
|
|
Coin Line article. In paragraph 3.31 I wrote that ". . . coin first did
|
|
contribute something that it is used to this day by every dial tone first
|
|
telco pay phone. It's called ground start." Wrong, wrong, wrong. Pay
|
|
phones actually use loop start, just like ordinary phones. Pay phones do
|
|
use a ground to produce many signals but they do not depend on it for
|
|
making the original connection. A pay phone may use groundstart for
|
|
origination as an option. Groundstart is the rare exception and not the
|
|
rule. Let's go over my mistake. It says something about making
|
|
assumptions, the lack of good reference material and about how useful
|
|
the internet is.
|
|
|
|
2. Ground start first interested me because it is unusual. A telco coin
|
|
line is different in many ways than a normal subscriber line. That made it
|
|
easy for me to think that a coin phone originated a call in a different way.
|
|
Fike and Friend stated that "Ground start lines are used on loops
|
|
connecting PBXs to the central office, and in other situations where it is
|
|
desireable to detect a line that has been selected for use (seizure of the
|
|
line) instantaneously from either side of the line." (emphasis added) (1)
|
|
|
|
3. What were these other situations? Pay phones. A table in
|
|
Engineering and Operations in The Bell System describes the various
|
|
kinds of loop signaling. It says that coin stations use "loop start or
|
|
ground start origination" and that loop signaling may involve "ground-
|
|
start format similar to coin service for PBX-CO trunks. (2) Freeman
|
|
reprinted this table without comment in his weighty tome. (3) Seemed
|
|
like good enough authority to me. The language in the chart, however,
|
|
was conditional. It said may. I thought these three sources proved that
|
|
pay phones used ground start. All I proved, however, was that pay
|
|
phones might use ground start. I never went back to check my notes once
|
|
I made my conclusion.
|
|
|
|
4. There's more. I didn't know why ground start was used. So I
|
|
speculated. I thought it tied up switching equipment for less time than
|
|
loop start. After all, time was the chief reason why the Bell System chose
|
|
coin first instead of post pay at the turn of the century. I described their
|
|
decision in the Post Pay article in the first issue. In the second issue I
|
|
quoted Bell System literature that detailed how concerned they were with
|
|
this problem when they re-introduced dial tone first in 1968.
|
|
|
|
5. My speculative argument assumed that ground start is quicker
|
|
than loop start. Supporting this assumption was Fike's use of the word
|
|
"instantaneously" in the quotation previously mentioned. Instantaneously
|
|
seizing a line, however, seems to refer to PBX operation; not the "other
|
|
situations" that he also mentioned. Seizing the line instantaneously may
|
|
prevent an incoming call from displacing an outgoing call with a PBX. It
|
|
does not mean necessarily that ground start is faster. I myself alluded
|
|
to this in Telco Payphone Basics, Part II.
|
|
|
|
6. In paragraph 1.71-2(2) I said that DC signals are quick. That's a
|
|
chief reason for their use. Ground start is a DC signal just like loop start.
|
|
I pointed out that a DC signal traveling at even 60% of the speed of light
|
|
would be moving at near a hundred thousand miles a second. What
|
|
difference in time would there be, therefore, between ground start and
|
|
loop start? Most pay phones are within three to eight miles of a central
|
|
office. All DC signals must act as if they are instantaneous. Any
|
|
difference in time between loop start or ground start is probably
|
|
minuscule or irrelevant or both.
|
|
|
|
7. That's not all. I used two other facts to bolster my argument that
|
|
pay phones used ground start. This part of the argument was also wrong.
|
|
The presence of a coin is detected by the presence of a ground. Dial tone
|
|
first, I thought, would then utilize ground start as part of its operating
|
|
system. Not so. One does not depend on the other. Loop start can be
|
|
used even if a ground is used for other things. Reeve clears up all this
|
|
confusion in his excellent chapter on Coin Line Services. He says that
|
|
"(M)ost prepay paystations are loop start, but many can be optioned for
|
|
ground start."(4)
|
|
|
|
8. I found out about my mistake from alt.dcom.telecom.tech. I got
|
|
involved in a discussion about ground start. People commented on why it
|
|
was used in PBX operation. No one, however, mentioned pay phones.
|
|
So I did. I asked why COCOTs used it and not telco pay phones. A coin
|
|
line expert named Jay replied in great detail that both kinds used loop
|
|
start. I was rather defensive at first since it went against what I had
|
|
written. His comments, however, forced me to go back to my notes. He
|
|
was right. He also gave details about coin phones that I have not found
|
|
elsewhere. This is what makes the newsgroups so compelling. A
|
|
question, though, remains: why would a pay phone use ground start?
|
|
Why would a coin line be optioned for this method? I'm still working on
|
|
finding this out.
|
|
|
|
NOTES:
|
|
|
|
(1.) Rey, R.F., ed. Engineering and Operations in the Bell System. 2d
|
|
ed. Murray Hills, N.J. AT&T Bell Laboratories. 1983
|
|
|
|
(2.) Fike, John L. and George Friend. Understanding Telephone
|
|
Electronics. 2d. ed. Carmel, SAMS 1990 191
|
|
|
|
(3.) Freeman, Roger L. Reference Manual for Telecommunications
|
|
Engineering Wiley Interscience. New York 1985 74
|
|
|
|
(4.) Reeve, Whitman D. Subscriber Loop Signaling and Transmission
|
|
Handbook: Analog. New York: Institute of Electrical and Electronics
|
|
Engineers. IEEE Press. 1992 223
|
|
|
|
III AN INTRODUCTION TO LOCAL SCANNING
|
|
|
|
9. Editor's Note: I hoped to make this article a complete guide to
|
|
local scanning but time ran out on me. I had to turn over the entire project
|
|
to a local hacker at the last moment. Biff was incensed that I dumped this
|
|
on him. He did agree, though, to write the following introduction.
|
|
|
|
An Introduction
|
|
|
|
10. Local scanning is a systematic attempt to find interesting phone
|
|
numbers. It is a daunting task in many cases because of the number of
|
|
numbers. A prefix contains 10,000 possible numbers. A large city may
|
|
contain hundreds of prefixes. Even smaller cities have access to a huge
|
|
wealth of possibilities. The village of Fair Oaks, for example, uses only
|
|
11 prefixes. A local call, for them, however, goes out to a total of 149
|
|
prefixes. That's 160,000 possible numbers to investigate with a local
|
|
call. And, of course, that does not include unlisted prefixes, test numbers
|
|
or telco numbers. Let's start at the beginning.
|
|
|
|
Some History
|
|
|
|
11. The first three digits in a phone number guide the call to the right
|
|
central office or exchange. The next four digits direct the call to the right
|
|
subscriber in that exchange. Why 10,000 numbers in a prefix? Why not
|
|
a thousand? Or 3,425? It's because early switching equipment was
|
|
designed that way. Tradition continues it. Step by step equipment was
|
|
arranged in banks of one hundred contacts. Each bank or selector had
|
|
ten rows of ten contacts. Three banks produced 10,000 numbers.
|
|
Smaller communities used two banks. Bigger cities used four. It's easier
|
|
to study the old diagram below.
|
|
|
|
The Big Picture
|
|
|
|
12. The prefix map on the next page represents a look at one city's
|
|
prefixes. It is the logical map to develop if you are interested in your city
|
|
as a whole. A better map would be color coded. Cell prefixes would be
|
|
printed in one color, pager prefixes another, governmental agencies
|
|
would occupy still another. Most prefixes are not dedicated to a single
|
|
use but you could note the ones that were.
|
|
|
|
Getting Started: Some Suggestions
|
|
|
|
13. This depends on what you want to do. What you're interested in.
|
|
If you are in a big city you have hundreds of thousands of possible
|
|
numbers to call. Here are some suggestions if you're not sure:
|
|
|
|
14. a.) The ANAC Angle: Absolutely critical to find. Your first
|
|
assignment. ANAC stands for automatic number announcement circuit.
|
|
It's a phone number that you call to get the number you are calling from.
|
|
Linemen use it to verify the line that they are working on. You can use it
|
|
to find the number of a pay phone that no longer has its number
|
|
displayed. Among other things. ANAC's are central office specific.
|
|
They can vary from one city to another, or even from parts of one city to
|
|
another. ANAC lists are scattered about the internet and even on services
|
|
like Compuserve. These are lists built on the definitive anac guide article
|
|
published in the Autumn 1990 issue of 2600. I did not reproduce it
|
|
because it is copyrighted. In any case, these lists do exist and they are
|
|
arranged by area codes. You may not find your number. I have not seen,
|
|
for example, an ANAC ever listed for 916. So you must search. Many
|
|
ANACS revolve around touch tone keys that are close together. There are
|
|
a great deal of "2's" and "1's" in the guides. This probably makes it easy
|
|
for the lineman to punch in a number quickly.
|
|
|
|
15. I found the ANAC for my part of town in six tries. It's (916)
|
|
211-2222. It was a fantastic piece of luck but I did concentrate on "2's"
|
|
and "1's". I had a plan. I may, though, go to Davis and hunt for hours.
|
|
If you are really frustrated then get to a 2600 meeting. Post a message to
|
|
alt.2600. But try first. And then spread the wealth. I had my local ANAC
|
|
up on the net within five minutes of its discovery. There are 800 numbers
|
|
that do the same thing. A local ANAC is preferable since it keeps the 800
|
|
number from being abused.
|
|
|
|
16. b.) The Payphone Angle: Telco payphones rely on specific
|
|
circuitry at specific central offices. Not all CO's have the hardware to
|
|
perform coin line functions. Telco payphones, therefore, have been tied
|
|
to certain CO's. Your mission, should you decide to accept it, is to map
|
|
out the locations and numbers of each payphone in an area near you. You
|
|
can investigate them further once your inventory is completed. Here are
|
|
some tips.
|
|
|
|
17. An old Thomas map book works great for noting the location of
|
|
each phone. The particulars ought to be logged in a notebook, with the
|
|
kind of information I have in my sample sheet on page 55. Do not ignore
|
|
the wiley COCOT. Many started out as telco payphones. Many still have
|
|
the same number they did when the telco owned them. They may not be
|
|
tied to the same circuitry but they do provide clues with their numbers.
|
|
Speaking of numbers, an 800 ANAC is sometimes essential to have if the
|
|
number is missing. Although ANAC calls are free with most telco
|
|
phones, a private phone may charge for the call if it can be completed.
|
|
Their automated coin toll service or ACTS may ask you for a substantial
|
|
sum. And then you might just get a long distance call and not the number
|
|
reading back to you.
|
|
|
|
18. c.) The Telco Angle: Scanning for telephone company numbers.
|
|
Always fascinating. Try the lower end of the biggest, oldest exchanges.
|
|
You'll note in your phone book that certain prefixes are tied together. For
|
|
example, 440-449 or 451-457. Start out at the bottom of 440. Numbers
|
|
like 440-0031, 0041, 0003 and so on. Try the first 100 numbers for that
|
|
exchange. Try the top 100 if nothing is there. You'll find tons of
|
|
interesting numbers if you are persistent. The bottom of 440, for
|
|
example, is like an announcement store. You get recordings like "Due to
|
|
telephone company facility trouble, your call cannot be completed at this
|
|
time." Or, "Due to heavy calling, your call cannot be completed at this
|
|
time." Even the ominous, "There is no charge for this call. This number
|
|
has been disconnected as a result of a recent federal court decision and
|
|
Pacific Bell's business policy."
|
|
|
|
19. You'll also find test tones and telco modem numbers in places
|
|
like these. You might also pick up the telco name for each exchange.
|
|
Someone picks up the line at the bottom of 440 with just the words
|
|
"Main" Calling it that makes sense since it is the largest CO downtown.
|
|
But who would know what "Ivanhoe" means in the 481 exchange? Well,
|
|
I do. The 481 used to be dialed with IV when letters were used. IVanhoe
|
|
8349, for example. To this day, the only human you'll find at the bottom
|
|
of 481 still answers "Ivanhoe" when he answers the phone. It's still their
|
|
name for that exchange. Telco tradition dies slowly if at all. By the way,
|
|
you can find a list of these older names at a well stocked local libary.
|
|
Look in old newspapers or any locally produced magazine from before
|
|
1955 or so. Ads in the back of old high school year books work well,
|
|
too.
|
|
|
|
20. d.) The Answering Service Angle: I've had good results with
|
|
this, although I'm not sure what I have. Older, smaller exchanges often
|
|
had answering services tied to a particular range. You can still find this in
|
|
most cities. Call numbers near existing services. No need to call a listed
|
|
number. You'll get answering machines that are actually voice mail
|
|
locations, weird tie lines and merchant credit numbers. It's all quite
|
|
strange. Perhaps the telcos grouped the answering services together in
|
|
order to deal with heavier loads. Maybe it says something about the
|
|
switch.
|
|
|
|
21. e.) The Governmental Telephone System Angle: Always
|
|
intriguing. I find it fascinating the way that certain counties arrange their
|
|
communications. You get a taste of this on page 63. Each little
|
|
community or district needs to communicate with the county seat. Many
|
|
times it is simply with ordinary dial up lines. Other times it is most
|
|
complex. Best approach is to poach the relevant county phone book in
|
|
order to get started.
|
|
|
|
Logging Your Calls
|
|
|
|
22. The most difficult part of scanning is keeping your records
|
|
organized. It's just about impossible with paper. It could be done with
|
|
the right software, but that is quite a project. Let's look at paper first.
|
|
Check out the experimental worksheet on page 55. It's nothing special,
|
|
just a table done in Word. The spacing, though, is correct. You need that
|
|
much room to make notes. And you need the numbers to be printed out
|
|
before you make a call. Don't write down each number as you go. It
|
|
doesn't work. Notice how one sheet only covers 100 numbers. One
|
|
prefix, however, needs 100 sheets. What's needed is the right equation
|
|
for EXCEL. You could then produce the pages needed for a particular
|
|
range.
|
|
|
|
23. An electronic logging program might be the best thing but I'm not
|
|
sure it's worth it by itself. If you develop such a beast then you might as
|
|
well commit to a war dialer as well. A single program could help place
|
|
calls as well as log them. Quite a project. I am uneasy about any program
|
|
than scans an entire prefix. You might hassle as many people as a
|
|
telemarketer. I think the best scanning happens while disturbing the
|
|
fewest people. (As if you are calling to talk to anyone.) I'd like some
|
|
comments from anyone interested in local scanning. Hams have a great
|
|
deal of logging software that is in the public domain; possibly some of it
|
|
could be converted.
|
|
|
|
Biff
|
|
|
|
IV DEF CON II REVIEW: FEAR AND HACKING IN LOS VEGAS
|
|
|
|
24. We were somewhere around Barstow on the edge of the desert
|
|
when the cell coverage began to come in . . . The second Def Con was
|
|
held at the Sahara Hotel in Las Vegas on the weekend of July 21, 1994.
|
|
Three hundred and seventy people attended. At times it was chaotic,
|
|
disorganized and anarchistic. I can't wait to go again. Where else can you
|
|
hear a discussion of UNIX, cryptography, industrial espionage, and the
|
|
Chaos Computer Club in one weekend? For fifteen dollars? There were
|
|
some problems. None of them, however, seemed serious enough for me
|
|
to be concerned with. Dark Tangent and his people deserve
|
|
congratulations for pulling off a great event for the second year in a row.
|
|
|
|
25. The con got off to a rocky start on Friday night. Mark Ludwig
|
|
was to have spoken on UNIX security. But no Ludwig appeared. He
|
|
was rumored to be either sick, jet lagged or drunk. No one knew. We did
|
|
know, however, that the Def Con people were in trouble. There was no
|
|
alternate speaker. One of Dark Tangent's friends tried to stall for time by
|
|
telling bad jokes on the stand. There was, however, nothing to stall for.
|
|
Audience members themselves arranged a discussion of UNIX after
|
|
about a half hour. The con had been hacked. Peter Shipley bravely
|
|
volunteered to answer general UNIX questions.
|
|
|
|
26. You could tell by the audience questions than many in the crowd
|
|
knew a great deal about UNIX. Few, though, got up to speak. Peter
|
|
did. That deserves credit. Shipley's company is the Little Garden in San
|
|
Francisco. It provides internet connections to the greater San Francisco
|
|
bay area. His remarks reminded me that I need to learn more about
|
|
UNIX. Much of the discussion went right over my head. Still, that is
|
|
my fault. English may be the unofficial language of the internet but
|
|
UNIX seems to be the official one.
|
|
|
|
27. Saturday ran more smoothly. Philip Zimmerman introduced
|
|
himself by saying in a quiet voice that he had authored Pretty Good
|
|
Privacy. The crowd gave him a round of loud applause. Zimmeran talked
|
|
about electronic privacy, new developments with PGP and how he was
|
|
now the subject of a federal grand jury investigation. It was somewhat
|
|
eerie to listen to Zimmerman. An invisible whirlwind of current events
|
|
and history surrounds him as he speaks. Hearing him speak was enough
|
|
to justify the entire trip to Vegas. At least for me. I won't remember
|
|
much of this convention ten years from now. But I will remember that I
|
|
saw Zimmerman at Def Con.
|
|
|
|
28. He talked about designing simpler interfaces to make PGP easier
|
|
to use. True point and click routines with graphical interfaces. He also
|
|
went to great lengths to explain that the current release of PGP is as
|
|
robust as the older version. The new one is slightly different for patent
|
|
and legal reasons. He also talked about how close he was to perfecting a
|
|
secure voice phone based on PGP routines. You wouldn't need a special
|
|
telephone, just your regular computer. Using conventional Sound Blaster
|
|
cards and 19,000 baud modems, one could finally talk on a telephone
|
|
line in complete privacy. Just so long as the party on the other end has
|
|
the same equipment. He also told a story that someone had told him.
|
|
AT&T engineers supposedly became depressed upon hearing of his
|
|
work. They should be. A cheaper, better system now threatens their
|
|
expensive Clipper based phones.
|
|
|
|
29. Gail Thackeray spoke next. She is now a deputy district attorney
|
|
for Maripoca County, Arizona. Her points were poorly delivered and not
|
|
well received. Her first stumble came when she seized upon an innocent
|
|
example provided by Zimmerman. He said that privacy was simple in the
|
|
old days. You just went behind the barn to talk with someone in private.
|
|
PGP restored what people had before the days of electricity and
|
|
electronics. Thackeray attacked this. She maintained that privacy was
|
|
never assured because your comments could always be misinterpreted
|
|
and distorted later. What? Zimmerman's point was that privacy used to
|
|
be secure during transmission. Thackeray's point dealt with the
|
|
conversation after transmission. The two points are not related. Yet she
|
|
tried to say that they were.
|
|
|
|
30. She then trotted out the same tired arguments she related to Bruce
|
|
Sterling in The Hacker Crackdown. One is that law enforcement needs
|
|
better tracing abilities. A telco once told her that a kidnapper's call
|
|
couldn't be traced. This still upsets her. She provided no details about the
|
|
incident. I have no idea, therefore, why the company couldn't. I suspect
|
|
it may be a problem beyond legislation. Tracing calls from certain
|
|
remote places may be difficult or impossible. Arizona and the West in
|
|
general have dozens of small phone companies that use simple central
|
|
office equipment. These may not pass ANI or automatic number
|
|
identification to the toll office. What then? Many CO's support party line
|
|
service. How do you know, therefore, if the call is coming from Ranch
|
|
A or Ranch B? There are also thousands of miles of open carrier wire and
|
|
aerial cable that can be clipped into without detection. Just you, your
|
|
lineman's handset and your jeep between, say, Jarbridge, Nevada and
|
|
Elko. How does better call tracing help any of this? And why is she
|
|
talking about this to us? Talk to a telco, that's what I say. Or give us
|
|
some specific information.
|
|
|
|
31. Thackeray also talked about how encryption works against
|
|
discovering the dreaded, mythical nuclear bomber, Her worst fear. The
|
|
scenario that she holds us hostage to. The reason that we have to accept
|
|
Clipper or some other government imposed encryption standard. Get
|
|
real. For better or worse, someone who has a nuclear bomb is already
|
|
using encryption, passing notes by hand or delivering plans in a
|
|
diplomatic pouch. The issue is moot unless the government makes their
|
|
form of encryption the only one that people can use. And only then if
|
|
they are prepared to jail people for not going along. Listening to
|
|
Thackeray, I am convinced that law enforcement is ready to do that.
|
|
|
|
32. Her talk really broke down after the first audience question. One
|
|
audience member said that he didn't worry about the police reading his e-
|
|
mail; the reason that he encrypted was to keep snoopy system
|
|
administrators from reading it. A reasonable solution to a common
|
|
problem. Thackeray's demeanor changed when she heard this question.
|
|
Her voice became strident. She said that she didn't have a problem with
|
|
him doing so, for now, but her tone was very condescending. "What"
|
|
she seemed to say, "e-mail? I have bigger problems to deal with."
|
|
|
|
33. Yeah. Sure you do. Until my e-mail interests you and you can't
|
|
read it. The audience kept up their questioning. She kept delivering fuzzy
|
|
answers. This is the woman who has talked to hackers for years? About
|
|
what? What useful information has she given us? Tell me what happens
|
|
when I'm arrested. What the process is. The difference between federal
|
|
law and state law. What the fines are. The code sections we might be
|
|
arrested under. I heard nothing specific. We got philosophy instead.
|
|
Great.
|
|
|
|
34. A central theme to her talk was that we may all have to abide by a
|
|
breakable encryption scheme. Why? In order to fulfill a social contract
|
|
that she maintains exists between all members of society. The greater
|
|
good, that sort of thing. Defined, of course, by her and law enforcement.
|
|
|
|
35. Well, that's a big subject. One best discussed over many drinks.
|
|
In the end, however, I'm not sure that anything useful will be
|
|
accomplished, no matter how much philosophizing and talking that you
|
|
do. Law enforcement types favor control. Hackers push control away.
|
|
No two groups could be farther apart before they start talking. No
|
|
amount of talking will bring them together. Communication does not
|
|
necessarily lead to acceptance or understanding. Both sides of the
|
|
abortion debate, for example, understand each other's position very well.
|
|
Neither side, however, will change. Endless arguing may appeal to the
|
|
contentiously inclined but I would rather participate in a debate with a fair
|
|
chance of winning. Thackeray gamely answered people's questions after
|
|
her talk. I got two back issues out of my back pack. "What the hell", I
|
|
thought. I'll give her two copies of private line. She did make the effort
|
|
to get here. Maybe she'll read my comments on California toll fraud in
|
|
those issues. Maybe she'll see that some people are interested in
|
|
specifics. As I waited to hand her the issues, though, I heard her say
|
|
something to an acquaintance. She said that many in the audience were
|
|
very naive and that many had never thought about some of the
|
|
issues that she raised. I stepped up and told her that my magazine
|
|
contained some naive ramblings about California Penal Code section
|
|
502.7 and 502.8. She looked a little lost at hearing Penal Code cites in
|
|
this strange setting but she did thank me. The Con raced on after this.
|
|
There were some canceled talks but other people stepped in. The
|
|
following is a loose collection of notes on some of the more interesting
|
|
speakers. In no particular order.
|
|
|
|
36. Stephen Dunnifer of Free Berkeley Radio gave an interesting,
|
|
politically charged talk on micro-broadcasting. He's trying to bring radio
|
|
to the community and neighborhood level with low power transmitters.
|
|
His radios seem well built and designed. Most current circuits don't drift
|
|
enough, anyway, to cause interference. His people are currently fighting
|
|
the FCC to loosen restrictions on licensing. Starting a radio station today
|
|
means tens of thousands of dollars. And then what do you get? A
|
|
monolithic station that doesn't serve an area very well. KFBK in
|
|
Sacramento, "the flame-thrower of the Central Valley" seems to cover
|
|
Carmichael only when there is a murder. No local news. Dunnifer's
|
|
people will go to court to change things. As a ham I feel that the FCC
|
|
will never move away from the present system without that court order.
|
|
Dunnifer thinks that changing the system through legislation is
|
|
impossible. He's probably right.
|
|
|
|
37. Padgett Peterson talked about viruses and computer security. He
|
|
has been involved with computers since the 1950's. He's done quite a bit
|
|
of work for the military including all sorts cryptography projects.
|
|
Peterson spoke with a quiet authority. He seems to see the Big Picture.
|
|
He knows how things work. Most of us are trying to figure out bits and
|
|
pieces of the puzzle a little at a time. He has worked full time in computer
|
|
related fields for over 30 years. He says, for example, that a DOS
|
|
computer gives him everything he needs. Doesn't need UNIX to do
|
|
anything. But that's because he knows UNIX already. He can make that
|
|
kind of decision because he knows both systems. As a beginner I don't
|
|
think that I can put off learning UNIX even though he says it isn't
|
|
necessary. I'll probably stick to basic commands, though, and let it go at
|
|
that. Peterson also talked about how viruses were changing. He said that
|
|
many people say they are developing viruses to learn more. If so, he
|
|
said, then viruses should become harder to find yet easy to remove once
|
|
discovered. The reverse is true. Today, he said, viruses are just as easy
|
|
to discover but they are much more difficult to get rid of.
|
|
|
|
38. Winn Schwartu gave a fascinating talk on electronic security,
|
|
state sponsored corporate theft, HERF guns and EMP/T bombs.
|
|
Among other things. I might have thought he was a charlatan but I think
|
|
he is the real thing. I overheard him talking about electromagnetic pulse
|
|
weapons at lunch to his friends. He was trying to explain the technology
|
|
to his friends with the enthusiasm of a little kid. In other words, he really
|
|
enjoys his work. He's written a few books but he didn't push them on
|
|
anybody. He hardly mentioned them at all. I respect the discipline that
|
|
that takes. He also hung around the con for the entire weekend, unlike
|
|
some speakers who came in and left quickly. His just wrote Information
|
|
Warfare: Chaos on the Electronic Superhighway.
|
|
|
|
39. Dead Addict offered some home spun philosophy about the
|
|
electronic future. I think DA's real contribution to Def Con were his
|
|
frequent questions about better interfaces. He seemed to ask every
|
|
programmer about how they would develop a program that was easier to
|
|
use. I think we all assume that programmers are working on better
|
|
GUI's. It's not a bad idea to have someone make sure.
|
|
|
|
40. Dr. Mark Ludwig talked about viruses, file security and on being
|
|
a citizen of the world. He writes a quarterly on viruses. He sponsored a
|
|
virus contest just for the convention. Before he gave out the best virus
|
|
award he noted a contest rule. He said it prohibited a destructive virus.
|
|
"But" he added, "I don't consider the destruction of an anti-virus
|
|
program to be a destructive act." I thought that rather clever.
|
|
|
|
41. He talked about how important it was to encrypt files and to
|
|
encrypt them often. He also talked about how we ought to become more
|
|
comfortable with travel and distant places. Take cheap flights when you
|
|
can to visit different countries. Get used to the idea that you can move
|
|
yourself and your work to another place if you need to. I thought this
|
|
was a liberating kind of talk. Most of us get used to our surroundings.
|
|
He seems comfortable traveling to, say, Nigeria at a moment's notice.
|
|
He also mentioned a few books that give information on setting up
|
|
overseas bank accounts.
|
|
|
|
42. Chris Hall of Executive Protection Associates, Inc. helped give
|
|
an interesting talk on industrial espionage and corporate security. He's
|
|
their Chief Operating Officer. There were a lot of security types at the
|
|
con. They talked about bugging and wiretaps and showed some
|
|
photographs. They made the important point that you really can't do
|
|
much about law enforcement monitoring. If they are using a form of
|
|
REMOBS or remote observation, then they listen through the central
|
|
office and not in a location that you can access or control. Chris will soon
|
|
be writing a column for private line.
|
|
|
|
43. These were just some of the speakers. It seemed that on Saturday
|
|
and Sunday someone was always talking. Some people bailed out and
|
|
others filled in. I never did catch any talk on cell phones, despite a few
|
|
being listed in the program. Still, White Lightning brought along a
|
|
custom test set that he uses with his cell work. He patiently answered
|
|
questions and demonstrated how the equipment worked. This demo was
|
|
out in the lobby but improntu demonstrations happened here and there by
|
|
different people. Most were the result of pure curiosity and enthusiasm
|
|
for different kinds of technology.
|
|
|
|
44. I was surprised how socially connected people were. It dispels
|
|
the lone hacker myth. Only 30 to 40 people sat by themselves before each
|
|
talk. The conferees were young. Most seemed in their 20's with some
|
|
generation Y and a few thirty somethings thrown in. Everyone over
|
|
thirty, by the way, was deemed to be a Fed.
|
|
|
|
45. I was also taken by the enormous creativity of the event.
|
|
Americans are a creative, driven lot. We are a nation of tinkers,
|
|
inventors, gadgeteers and fix it men. It has always been this way.
|
|
Thomas Edison, Samuel Morse, Eli Whitney and Elias Howe were all
|
|
represented in some small way by all of the people at the con. We push
|
|
toward a common goal: understanding. Figuring out how things work.
|
|
Motivated for different reasons, perhaps, but motivated none-the-less.
|
|
Infuriated when we don't have the information we want. Delighted when
|
|
we get that last piece of the puzzle. Only to find, of course, that there is
|
|
another puzzle to figure out. I can't think of a better life.
|
|
|
|
Def Con Info:
|
|
|
|
e-mail list: majordomo@fc.net with "subscribe dc-announce" in the
|
|
body of the
|
|
message to join the announcement list. "subscribe dc-stuff" for the
|
|
chat list.
|
|
|
|
FTP : fc.net in /pub/defcon from cyberspace.com.
|
|
|
|
DT's e-mail: dtangent@defcon.org
|
|
|
|
Snail mail: DEF CON
|
|
2709 E. Madison #102
|
|
Seattle, WA, 98112
|
|
|
|
(DT says that he has tapes of the whole convention for sale. They
|
|
consist of (10) 90 minute tapes, $32.90 for a set. He also has some
|
|
shirts left: 20 long sleeve white shirts, about 1/2 old style 1/2 new style.
|
|
They are three color front, two color back and $22.90 (that extra 2.90 is
|
|
for postage))
|
|
|
|
V. ROAD TRIP TO VEGAS
|
|
|
|
46. We took the road less traveled. Most people from Sacramento go
|
|
down the Central Valley to Bakersfield and then head east to Vegas. That
|
|
route looked fast and boring. We wanted slow and interesting. I just put
|
|
out the second issue and I was tired. In no mood to rush. So, we took a
|
|
criss crossing, zig-zagging route instead. We went over the Sierra
|
|
Nevada, down to Bishop and then over the White mountains to Nevada.
|
|
A two day trip. We started out by pointing the Jeep east along Highway
|
|
16, the old Jackson Highway. It runs into Highway 49, the only true
|
|
north south route of the Sierra Nevada foothills. We headed south until
|
|
we caught Highway 88, which then strikes north-east over the Sierra.
|
|
|
|
47. We struck gold quickly on Highway 88 near the Bear River Lake
|
|
Resort. Right off the highway was a Northern Telecom pay phone that
|
|
ran on solar power. Cool. It even had a locking cabinet around it. The
|
|
number is (209 295-9801. A telco with perhaps the most distinctive name
|
|
in America operates this pay phone: The Volcano Telephone Company.
|
|
They serve a fairly large area in the central Sierra . Three exchanges. Six
|
|
thousand lines or so. Their trucks are white with bold blue lettering if
|
|
you are keeping a watch. I resisted the temptation to call Belize and took
|
|
photos instead. We kept on 88 until it ran into 395. We then headed
|
|
south.
|
|
|
|
48. The next stop was the slightly funky town of Markleeville. Tye
|
|
dye clothing. VW buses. CONTEL country. Continental Telephone
|
|
Company of California, that is. Pay phone placards suggested that repair
|
|
and admin were out of Stateline at Lake Tahoe. CONTEL operated
|
|
dozens of step by step offices as late as 1987. One post to a newsgroup
|
|
stated that CONTEL installed 5ESS's in many Southern California cities
|
|
instead of the less expensive GTD-5's. Enlightened thinking, indeed. I
|
|
don't know, though, what kind of switch now serves Markleevile. It
|
|
may be a remote instead of a stand alone switch.
|
|
|
|
49. I do know, however, that 99XX numbers tie most pay phones
|
|
together from here to Bishop. Numbers like 694-9994, 9991, 9995 and
|
|
so on. Some run in consecutive order. For example, at the top of
|
|
Conway Summit on Highway 395 is a pay phone. Right at the 8,138
|
|
foot mark. It's number is (619) 647-9964. The next stop is the Mono
|
|
Basin National Scenic Area about a dozen miles away The two pay
|
|
phones there are 9962 and 9961. What happened to 9963? Probably back
|
|
at the one phone I didn't stop at on the way. Might be pretty easy to find
|
|
test numbers in this country Stop at the Visitor Center if you drive by
|
|
Mono Lake. It's well done. You can learn about tufa. Rain and lightning
|
|
over the Sierra Nevada provided a dramatic background as we visited. A
|
|
tropical storm had pushed inland from the Gulf Of Mexico. 100 percent
|
|
humidity and 85 degrees. Humidity in Las Vegas the next day would be
|
|
less than 10%. Next stop was Bishop. The overnight destination.
|
|
|
|
50. We stayed at the Frau Haus or the Krautz Haus motel I don't
|
|
remember. At four p.m. it was hot and humid. Overweight people filled
|
|
the pool. The only way to cheer me up was to find a used bookstore.
|
|
Which we did. I found a three year old book on telecom for about seven
|
|
dollars. This brings up an important point. Many used bookstores in
|
|
bigger cities are picked clean when it comes to telephony. Try book
|
|
stores in smaller towns as well as antique stores. You may be surprised
|
|
|
|
51. I passed out after dinner and then woke up around 10:30 p.m.
|
|
Time for a night op. I strolled over to CONTEL's corporation yard
|
|
downtown. They maintain a big presence in Bishop. You can't miss their
|
|
microwave tower as you drive through the city. My intel says that Bishop
|
|
is a toll center. This makes sense because Bishop is the largest city in the
|
|
southern Sierra Nevada. CONTEL's building may also house the central
|
|
office switch for the city. Their corporation yard was spotless and well
|
|
lit. Several company trucks were parked at weird angles near the back
|
|
door. The building looked occupied. I understand that most toll centers
|
|
are manned around the clock. In any case, the highlight of their yard was
|
|
a brand new, bright red Snow Cat on a trailer with the CONTEL logo
|
|
emblazoned across the side. Great stuff. Made me wish I had some
|
|
private line bumper stickers to paste on it. I bet the linemen fight
|
|
over who gets to make service calls with this machine during the winter.
|
|
|
|
52. We took off the next morning to cross the southern end of the
|
|
White Mountains into Nevada. You cross these mountains by using
|
|
Highway 168. We gassed up in Big Pine first before heading toward the
|
|
summit. Count on all gas being 15 to 20 cents a gallon higher than in the
|
|
city. We didn't buy any food or drinks in Big Pine. That was a mistake.
|
|
The next supplies turned out to be 97 miles away in Scotty's Junction,
|
|
Nevada. I'm taking extra water for the jeep as well. Next time. One
|
|
problem with these isolated roads is that having a AAA card doesn't help
|
|
much. They pay for the first five miles of towing only. Getting stuck
|
|
fifty miles up the road might bankrupt your vacation.
|
|
|
|
53. The road to the Westgard Pass was long and turning. This is the
|
|
way to the Bristlecone Pine grove. Some of these trees are over 4000
|
|
years old. We didn't look at them because they are twelve miles off the
|
|
road near the top of the grade. But we will see them next year when we
|
|
return to Def Con. Just takes more planning. This 80 miles of road had
|
|
few houses along it. No services. Some ranch houses had electric power
|
|
but I did not see telephone cable running out to them. It's odd to think
|
|
of people in 1994 who don't have telephone service available. Still, that
|
|
is also the situation in some northern California counties as well.
|
|
|
|
54. The scenery was beautiful, though, and we enjoyed the drive.
|
|
Wide vistas of bare mountains and the occasional soda lake. Five or six
|
|
falling down houses marked the town of Lida Junction. No stores. I was
|
|
confident, however, that there would be something at the junction of
|
|
Nevada Highway 95. There was. A cathouse. I told my friend that I
|
|
would check things out in the interest of finding her something to drink.
|
|
She told me to keep driving. The drive south to Las Vegas was boring
|
|
and uneventful. A fiber optic cable runs alongside it. At 7,000 feet the
|
|
temperature in the mountains was pleasant. It was now climbing past 100
|
|
degrees as we drove down Highway 95. We stopped in Beatty for lunch.
|
|
Beatty heralds itself as "The Gateway to Death Valley." Great. This little
|
|
town has a strange affinity for mules. Mule Days. Twenty Mule Team.
|
|
Borax mining and all that. Expensive mule related t-shirts, sweaters and
|
|
key chains. A casino named for a mule. We had a pleasant lunch and then
|
|
got back on the road. It was your basic Death Drive until Las Vegas.
|
|
|
|
55. We got into Vegas after a total of 563 miles. We traveled through
|
|
North Vegas first. Many North Las Vegas residents think their town has
|
|
an image problem. I understand. Much of this area looks like Telegraph
|
|
Avenue South. Litter and street people and 1050 heat. Lovely. I read
|
|
now, though, that they are trying to clean things up. The town got
|
|
cleaner but busier as we drove. Traffic is very heavy around all the
|
|
hotels. We didn't have a detailed map of Las Vegas so we just motored
|
|
toward the hotel signs. I'll have a map next year.
|
|
|
|
56. Next year we'll set aside an even longer block of time for the road
|
|
trip. I think that many people could only set aside a weekend for the Con.
|
|
That's unfortunate. It makes everything feel rushed. My suggestion is to
|
|
think about taking an entire week off next year. That's what I am doing
|
|
since I have so much time to plan ahead. I hope to see you there.
|
|
|
|
The Sahara Hotel ---
|
|
|
|
57. Dark Tangent would like the Con to return to the Sahara next
|
|
year. They are, however, raising the costs dramatically. Dark Tangent
|
|
says that they now want $3,000 for the space he needs next year. Here's
|
|
a few random notes on the hotel in case we all wind up back there in
|
|
1995.
|
|
|
|
58. The parking lot is a mess. Ignore all signs, parking attendants
|
|
and wrong way arrows and drive into the parking garage first. Not the
|
|
temporary lot. Park the car but leave your luggage inside. Scope out
|
|
things first. The check in line can vary from a few people to an hour long
|
|
wait. Get a beer and relax. Jump into line if the wait is short. The
|
|
baggage handlers are union, by the way, so you may want to carry your
|
|
own luggage.
|
|
|
|
59. The Sahara is an old casino. It's kept up well but it's been used
|
|
hard. The rooms though, are much cleaner and brighter than the rest of
|
|
the motel. We registered early and got a room on a top floor. I didn't
|
|
hear anything from adjacent rooms. They do check for hotel cards before
|
|
you get on the elevators. I think that's a nice touch. I understand,
|
|
though, that they won't issue room cards to people under 18 without an
|
|
"adult" present. So don't lose your card if you are under age. I thought
|
|
there would be more friction between the casino and those under 21. I
|
|
really didn't see any incidents. Maybe security was low key but I did not
|
|
see anything overt.
|
|
|
|
60. Driving and parking are such a hassle that you may find yourself
|
|
staying at the hotel the whole weekend. If so, food is going to get
|
|
expensive. Still, there is a nice cafe near the pool where you can buy
|
|
fruit, pastries, milk and sandwiches. It's actually more pleasant than the
|
|
restaurants, especially in the morning when you can take your food
|
|
outside. Speaking of the pool, the hotel does not keep it open after
|
|
dark. That's a shame since the area is so well lit and because the weather
|
|
is so hot.
|
|
|
|
61. Pay per view movies in the hotel room are an overpriced joke.
|
|
Seven to eight dollars. The drink specials, though, are a godsend. The
|
|
Sahara had Heinekens for a dollar all weekend. They were the savoir of
|
|
many, including me. just got an exciting document with a dull name.
|
|
|
|
VI. A FEW THOUGHTS ON EMS AND 911
|
|
|
|
62. I just got an exciting document with a dull name. It's called The
|
|
Sacramento Regional Fire/EMS Communications Center: Computer
|
|
Aided Dispatch and Records Management System. Request for
|
|
Proposals. What is it? It's an invitation to bid. The City and County of
|
|
Sacramento want to upgrade the communication system that
|
|
handles their fire and emergency medical response. The Warner Group
|
|
put together for the County a complete description of the existing system
|
|
as well as the requirements for a new one. This booklet gives all bidders
|
|
the same information. They use this Request for Proposal to develop
|
|
their bid. It gives a lot of fascinating, telecom related details.
|
|
|
|
63. The smaller cities of Sacramento county use Macintoshes and PC
|
|
clones to deal with the regional communication center. The larger districts
|
|
use mini-computers. The larger districts have dedicated tie lines to the
|
|
EMS center. The smaller ones, though, still use normal dial up phone
|
|
lines. Galt has a dedicated line but it is over microwave. Galt, in fact,
|
|
wins the hacker seal of approval for having their headquarters and their
|
|
three fire stations running Amigas! Where do you go, anyway, for fire
|
|
dispatch and EMS software for the Amiga? It poorly details callboxes.
|
|
Many still exist in downtown Sacramento. Some still use open wire
|
|
strung on poles.
|
|
|
|
64. Alas, these different setups will probably be made uniform with
|
|
the new system. Motorola will probably come stomping in with A
|
|
Solution. The public will benefit, of course, but I'll miss the thought of
|
|
a life saving message racing through the CPU of an Amiga.
|
|
|
|
65. Speaking of different setups, the Sacramento area has one of the
|
|
most patched together 911 systems you can imagine. Cell calls are the big
|
|
problem. The 911 center for the county was at capacity when cell phones
|
|
came in around 1986. Most phones were then, of course, in cars. It was
|
|
decided, therefore, to route 911 cell calls to the CHP headquarters in
|
|
Sacramento. The calls from five counties tumble into their dispatch center
|
|
with, at times, perhaps three people to answer them.
|
|
|
|
66. A dispatcher then has to figure out where the person is, often
|
|
with a poor description and a panicked caller. There's no address on a
|
|
screen like a land line call. Indeed, the dispatchers don't have screens.
|
|
Just a phone with keys. The Sacramento Bee had a long article on all of
|
|
this on July 10, 1994. In that piece they described a call that actually
|
|
happened: 1) A kid got knocked out at a ball game in Placer County,
|
|
2) A spectator called 911, 3) The dispatcher determined after three
|
|
minutes that the ballpark was in Placer County, 4) The dispatcher notified
|
|
the Department of Forestry since they were the agency to pass an
|
|
emergency call to, 5) CDF then called the Newcastle Fire Department, 6)
|
|
Newcastle Fire then dispatched their medical emergency response team.
|
|
|
|
67. Normal land line 911 calls, by comparison, go directly to a main
|
|
dispatch center. They verify your address with ANI or automatic number
|
|
identification They can also send out the appropriate agency without
|
|
having to pass off the call. The coming years will streamline the process.
|
|
I will not be nostalgic for the days of CDF handling traffic. Write me if
|
|
you have some information about the system in your area.
|
|
|
|
privateline@delphi.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
|