1394 lines
69 KiB
Plaintext
1394 lines
69 KiB
Plaintext
The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger
|
||
|
||
September 1994 Vol. XII, No. 9
|
||
|
||
ISSN 1073-6859
|
||
|
||
Published by the Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers in the
|
||
interest of continued, improved, and expanded rail service for the present
|
||
and potential railroad and rail transit passengers of southeastern
|
||
Pennsylvania, southern New Jersey, and nearby areas.
|
||
|
||
|
||
For more information about DVARP and good rail service, please contact us:
|
||
P.O. Box 7505, Philadelphia, PA 19101 215-222-3373
|
||
<mmitchell@asrr.arsusda.gov> or <73243.1224@compuserve.com>
|
||
|
||
The electronic edition is produced as a public service to the network
|
||
community. It is archived on the CUNYVM Listserver in the RAILNEWS
|
||
directory. An index of back issues is available by sending INDEX RAILNEWS
|
||
to LISTSERV@CUNYVM. Thanks to Geert K. Marien (GKMQC@CUNYVM) for
|
||
maintaining this archive! If you have comments or questions, contact us,
|
||
not Geert!
|
||
|
||
The DVRP is also archived on these FTP servers
|
||
ftp://wuarchive.wustl.edu/graphics/trains/text *OR*
|
||
graphics/trains/incoming ftp://hipp.etsu.edu/pub/railroad/dvarp (Thanks to
|
||
Bob Weir) Volumes X (1992) and XI (1993) are on floppy disk for $4.00 each
|
||
from DVARP.
|
||
|
||
Now on World Wide Web! Visit the Cyberspace World Railroad [gGeneral
|
||
Superintendent: Dan Dawdy] http://venus.mcs.com/~dsdawdy/cyberroad.html
|
||
|
||
We hope you consider joining DVARP; your financial support makes possible
|
||
this newsletter and our many other activities on behalf of rail and transit
|
||
passengers. Annual dues are $15.00. see the coupon at ##V.
|
||
|
||
Contents copyright (C) 1994 DVARP, except photos (C) 1994 credited
|
||
photographers
|
||
|
||
Opinions expressed in The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger are not
|
||
necessarily those of DVARP or its members. We welcome your comments: call
|
||
215-222-3373
|
||
|
||
DVARP President: Chuck Bode Newsletter Editor: Matthew Mitchell
|
||
Production Manager: Tom Borawski for other officers and committee chairs,
|
||
search for ##U
|
||
|
||
|
||
Schedule change alert: New SEPTA R8 schedules are in effect SEPTA City
|
||
Transit schedules change Sept. 12.
|
||
|
||
contents:
|
||
use the search function of your word processor to find articles
|
||
|
||
##A Reinventing Amtrak: Downs Shakes Up Management:
|
||
##B From the Editor's Seat:
|
||
##B1 Passengers Can Have an Effect! [President's Note]
|
||
##B2 Changes in Your Newsletter
|
||
##C On the Railroad Lines...
|
||
Center City Work to Begin
|
||
Another Fern Rock Boondoggle
|
||
Teach Your Children... Please!
|
||
Another Seat Test
|
||
##R3 West Trenton Project
|
||
##R5 Crews Cause Chaos
|
||
##R6 Shawmont Saved?
|
||
##R8 AM Reliability Sacrificed
|
||
Schedule Change, Sunday Disruption
|
||
Octoraro Lives!
|
||
##D Transit News Update
|
||
##LRD Eye on the Infrastructure: 15 Surviving
|
||
##100 Cab Signals Working
|
||
##PATCO Deal Struck, Fare Increase Likely
|
||
##E News Notes
|
||
Two Minute Warning
|
||
Syracuse Opening
|
||
Hot Rails?
|
||
##F Gambaccini Pay Dispute Ends
|
||
##G PennDOT Listening
|
||
##H The Value of a One-Seat Ride
|
||
##CREDITS
|
||
##I South Jersey Notes
|
||
NJT Rail Crew Wins "Roadeo" Again
|
||
##J Unions Not Pacific
|
||
##K More Comments on NE Subway
|
||
##L Freight Mergers in the News
|
||
##M Computer Corner:
|
||
Web Access to the DVRP
|
||
German Train Info at ICE Speed
|
||
##N State of the Art: Fare Collection [Part 1-Amtrak]
|
||
##O Fare Wars: Amtrak Strikes Back
|
||
##P Amtrak Notes
|
||
Superliners in the East!
|
||
Derailment Casualty 500 Miles Away
|
||
##Q Congress Acts on Rail Safety
|
||
Quoteable: Ross Capon on Rail Accidents
|
||
##R Eurorail Views: Baptism of the Unborn?
|
||
##S Dates of Interest
|
||
##T Up and Down the Corridor
|
||
Two Levels, One Seat to Port Jeff
|
||
Rare Mileage
|
||
Labor Upset Delays Maine Train
|
||
Air Connections?
|
||
Highway Steamroller Stalled in NJ
|
||
Short-term Pain, Long-term Gain
|
||
##U DVARP Phone & Voice-mail Directory
|
||
##V DVARP Membership Coupon
|
||
##W Upcoming DVARP Meetings:
|
||
|
||
|
||
##A Reinventing Amtrak: Downs Shakes Up Management:
|
||
by Matthew Mitchell
|
||
|
||
The trains and stations are the same; they still go the same places, and
|
||
there isn't a catchy new slogan; but a new Amtrak is under construction in
|
||
1994. The architect of these changes is Tom Downs, Amtrak's new president.
|
||
Downs is implementing a top-down reinvention the nation's passenger
|
||
railroad.
|
||
|
||
The changes start with a reorganization of Amtrak into three business
|
||
units: Northeast Corridor, Intercity, and Western. This kind of
|
||
'sectorization' has been a popular trend in the worldwide railway industry,
|
||
aimed at vesting one person with ultimate responsibility for performance of
|
||
the sector, rather than diffusing responsibility among several
|
||
departments. In turn, the business unit managers are reorganizing the
|
||
departments they control.
|
||
|
||
The change in corporate culture couldn't be more dramatic; and it stems
|
||
from the history of Amtrak's leaders. Downs comes from a career in
|
||
government while Graham Claytor, his predecessor, was a lifetime
|
||
railroader. Claytor epitomized the approach of the old-time railroad, with
|
||
its resistance to all but the most incremental changes. New ways of doing
|
||
things always involve some risk, but old-time railroaders taught that
|
||
"safety is the first duty" avoided taking risks. Staying with the old ways
|
||
is also more comfortable for everyone involved.
|
||
|
||
But Downs make it clear he wouldn't stand for mediocrity, no matter how
|
||
comfortable. Visibly perturbed with what he saw at the time he took
|
||
office, [see April DVRP] Downs prescribed radical change. So far, that
|
||
change has been virtually invisible to the average passenger. And much of
|
||
what that passenger will see is beyond even Downs's ability to change.
|
||
Downs's reorganization can't do more than bandage Amtrak's biggest problem,
|
||
its chronic shortage of capital. And to tinker with Amtrak's route map is
|
||
to invite the wrath of Congress.
|
||
|
||
Downs's ultimate goal is for each and every employee to understand how
|
||
their individual task affects the bottom line. And to Downs, that bottom
|
||
line is the delivery of good, consistent service to Amtrak's customers. An
|
||
internal memo distributed systemwide tells why he feels this restructuring
|
||
is so crucial:
|
||
|
||
>Our railroad is in serious trouble. Our employees are telling us they
|
||
>don't feel empowered to solve customers' problems. Our customers are
|
||
>telling us they have far too many problems when they ride our trains.
|
||
>These feelings have a direct effect on our bottom line. In July, revenues
|
||
>were almost $16 million below budget and we lost $28 million more than we
|
||
>had anticipated. We are projecting losses for the year to be about $82
|
||
>million more than we had planned. That $82 million would buy about 40 new
|
||
>passenger cars. Or it would pay nearly 1,600 employees for a whole year.
|
||
>We cannot afford to let this trend continue.
|
||
>
|
||
>Restructuring our organization to focus on the customer and to give our
|
||
>employees the resources and tools they need to do a better job is critical
|
||
>if we are to turn Amtrak around. And we don't have a lot of time. If we
|
||
>can't stop the hemorrhaging, we'll lost the patient.
|
||
|
||
Claytor's management style did keep Amtrak alive through the eighties,
|
||
slowly but steadily improving short-term financial performance and even
|
||
ordering badly-needed new equipment, but day-to-day effectiveness slipped.
|
||
Maintenance of equipment was deferred, causing breakdowns and delays, and
|
||
more importantly causing dissatisfied customers.
|
||
|
||
Authoritarian top-down management was a legacy of a railroading era based
|
||
on great numbers of unskilled laborers building standard structures and
|
||
equipment. Today it stifles the ingenuity of line employees who are
|
||
better-educated than predecessors of decades ago. Clearly that is one part
|
||
of the old way which has to go.
|
||
|
||
At least a few of the changes have filtered down to the passengers. New
|
||
measures giving employees more power to resolve customer service problems
|
||
have been put in practice with train chiefs empowered to give refund
|
||
vouchers to on the spot to passengers. Meanwhile, at 30th Street, staff
|
||
have instituted a curbside baggage check-in service at the 29th St. (Center
|
||
City-side) entrance to the station.
|
||
|
||
Under Downs, buzzwords of nineties-style management flood internal memos
|
||
and meetings: 'team-building,' 'outreach,' 'empowerment,' and
|
||
'stakeholders.' In the chaos of staff transfers, surveys, people in the
|
||
ranks feel great unease. Will this reorganization mean layoffs? Will
|
||
people be asked to do jobs they aren't suited to do? Will the rules change
|
||
in the middle of the game? The employees are the most important group
|
||
Downs must sell his plan to, so communication and openness to the
|
||
employees has been stressed almost to the point of information overkill.
|
||
Says another explanatory memo:
|
||
|
||
>In today's economy, everyone feels pressured to get the maximum value for
|
||
>the lowest cost. For the transportation service industry and especially
|
||
>for Amtrak the competition is fierce. People have lots of choices, and
|
||
>many of those choices are lower cost, faster time, better quality or more
|
||
>convenient than the train. If we're going to compete successfully in this
|
||
>rapidly changing world we have to figure out how to work smarter and how to
|
||
>do it with a single-minded focus on our customers and their needs.
|
||
>
|
||
>Having a plan to work smarter and more competitively is what strategic
|
||
>planning is all about. A strategic plan isn't a one-time event. It is a
|
||
>dynamic process that requires the attention of each and every employee.
|
||
>It isn't about budget numbers and glossy reports it's about how we deliver
|
||
>our services and sell our products day in and day out.
|
||
>
|
||
>Over the past several months, the management committee has commissioned a
|
||
>number of efforts to define the basic building blocks of an Amtrak
|
||
>strategy.
|
||
>
|
||
>The fact-finding stage of the strategic planning as included getting facts
|
||
>about who our customers are and what they think of our service, how our
|
||
>employees feel, what the real costs are of doing business the way we do it
|
||
>today, and what employees in the field believe can make things better.
|
||
>
|
||
>Since May, about 100 analysts from every Amtrak department have been
|
||
>working on a series of cost and performance studies. These studies have
|
||
>looked at five critical issues: equipment reliability and utilization,
|
||
>on-time performance, the physical condition of stations, the right-of-way
|
||
>and other facilities, the costs of customer and employee complaints, and
|
||
>the cost impact of special legal and regulatory requirements.
|
||
>
|
||
>In addition, nearly 200 focus groups with more than 1,000 participants were
|
||
>held throughout the system to discuss what quick hits could be done in 1995
|
||
>to improve the customer experience, employee morale and equipment
|
||
>reliability. The TARP customer survey and Gallup employee survey are two
|
||
>other important building blocks for the planning effort. Finally,
|
||
>throughout the summer, work has continued on the design of Amtrak's new
|
||
>strategic business units--the organizations that will be primarily
|
||
>responsible for refining and carrying out Amtrak's strategic plan.
|
||
>
|
||
>From this point forward the real work begins--deciding what the facts mean
|
||
>and what we have to do, in what order, to turn the customer experience
|
||
>around while also improving the bottom line. The company's senior
|
||
>management and board of directors will be discussing the implications of
|
||
>the data collected this summer at a leadership meeting in Crotonville,
|
||
>N.Y., and at special board meetings Sept. 13 and Sept. 27-28.
|
||
>
|
||
>So what does a strategic business plan mean for Amtrak employees? When it
|
||
>is done right, it means we have a framework that lets each and every
|
||
>employee understand how his or her job affects the bottom line and what
|
||
>their daily priorities should be.
|
||
> It means constantly reexamining how and why we do the tings we do. And it
|
||
>means constantly adjusting our behavior to changing markets and customer
|
||
>needs. In the next several months, all employees will have the opportunity
|
||
>to see and react to the management committee and board's conclusions about
|
||
>where we are today and what those facts mean for our future. The
|
||
>fact-finding process is just the tip of the planning iceberg. Changing our
|
||
>business priorities, focusing on the customer, and making sure we sell a
|
||
>high-quality product that people want to buy will remain a never-ending
|
||
>challenge. Strategic planning is just a process to make meeting that
|
||
>challenge a little easier.
|
||
|
||
|
||
##B From the Edit^H^H^H^H President's Seat:
|
||
##B1 Passengers Can Have an Effect!
|
||
|
||
[editor's note: Chuck wrote such a good commentary on our recent victories,
|
||
I'm turning this space over to him this month]
|
||
|
||
At times DVARP's cause can seem hopeless-volunteer passengers taking on the
|
||
"system." Much effort is put forth, but often results are hard to find.
|
||
SEPTA service standards show that change does come, even if slowly.
|
||
|
||
From our May 15, 1989 Operating Budget Testimony:
|
||
|
||
> We also recommend that SEPTA make an effort to involve the public much
|
||
> earlier in the process.... A system of announcing projects when they
|
||
> are in concept form and soliciting public input (through meetings and
|
||
> telephone and mail submissions to SEPTA) when they are at that stage
|
||
> could resolve many of the issues that are currently disputed at
|
||
> hearings and carried over into Board meetings. A community meeting
|
||
> with riders, and potential riders, to obtain their input before
|
||
> beginning route changes could assist in making the riders feel that
|
||
> SEPTA is their system....
|
||
|
||
By our May 21, 1993 statement, we had refined it to:
|
||
|
||
> The budget process should begin with an annual assessment and a
|
||
> proposed operating plan. The operating plan would outline the
|
||
> proposed service levels and routes, the resources required, and the
|
||
> anticipated ridership, revenue, and subsidy. This plan-less detailed
|
||
> in the more distant years-would be distributed to the interested
|
||
> parties for review and recommendations early in the process. Following
|
||
> agreement-such as it is in a public process-the capital and operating
|
||
> budgets would be developed in coordinated fashion to support the
|
||
> planned services.
|
||
|
||
Notice how closely SEPTA's process matches DVARP's proposals. As a member
|
||
of DVARP, you helped change SEPTA. Congratulations!-CB
|
||
|
||
##B2 Changes in Your Newsletter
|
||
|
||
The decision we made to mail the DVRP first-class again has a few other
|
||
consequences besides the fact that you won't wait so long for the Postal
|
||
Service to deliver it. The third-class rate we had used had a much greater
|
||
weight limit; now we must pay 23 cents more if we exceed one ounce (16
|
||
pages).
|
||
|
||
That means I have to work harder to fit all the news and analysis you want
|
||
into the trimmer package. Because some articles have to be cut to fit
|
||
into the space we have available, we will expand our on-line edition of the
|
||
DVRP to include the full text of those pieces, and will direct you to the
|
||
on-line edition when there is more to be found there. More and more people
|
||
have access to computers at home, work, school, or library; so we'll take
|
||
advantage of the internet to connect with you more effectively.
|
||
|
||
I also plan to conduct a reader survey this fall, to make sure we know
|
||
clearly what it is you expect from this newsletter. When it is printed,
|
||
please take a few min-utes to write down your candid comments about this
|
||
publication (and about our organization too, if you like); they will be of
|
||
great value.
|
||
|
||
This newsletter is a labor of love for the many volunteers who make it each
|
||
month. Satisfied, involved readers are our best reward.-MDM
|
||
|
||
|
||
##C On the Railroad Lines...
|
||
|
||
Center City Work to Begin
|
||
|
||
Renewal of overhead wires on the segment of RRD trackage between Suburban
|
||
Station and 30th St. will commence this month. Be ready for minor delays
|
||
at off-peak and especially weekend hours.
|
||
|
||
Another Fern Rock Boondoggle
|
||
|
||
An unconfirmed report from a SEPTA source indicates that the Stations
|
||
Department of RRD is planning to install a platform washing system at Fern
|
||
Rock which is alleged to cost $2 million. The source expressed concern
|
||
that the washer might cause the rails below to be slippery.
|
||
|
||
Teach Your Children... Please!
|
||
|
||
A half-dozen trains were delayed the afternoon of August 21 when a
|
||
nine-year-old Philadelphia boy accidentally contacted the catenary wires
|
||
while throwing debris on the tracks near Zoo Tower. The young vandal
|
||
suffered electrical burns over 50 percent of his body.
|
||
|
||
Another Seat Test
|
||
|
||
Have you spotted the new seats in a few of SEPTA's Silverliners? A v
|
||
ariety of models are being tested as the Silverliner IV fleet approaches
|
||
its twentieth birthday. We passengers have an twice-a-day intimate
|
||
relationship with SEPTA's seats, so we ought to have some say in their
|
||
selection. Though other railroads have held public open-houses for
|
||
soliciting feedback on plans for new or refurbished trains, SEPTA riders
|
||
are going to stand up for themselves. Got comments? Forward them to
|
||
DVARP's Commuter Rail Committee and we'll 'butt' in on SEPTA and make sure
|
||
they're heard.
|
||
|
||
##R3 West Trenton Project
|
||
|
||
Reconstruction crews have gone to work on the overhead catenary of the West
|
||
Trenton line, and on signal equipment too. The line has been
|
||
problem-plagued during the rush hours these past few months. Fortunately
|
||
for the passengers, full R3 service will be maintained during this
|
||
project.
|
||
|
||
##R5 Crews Cause Chaos
|
||
|
||
A late summer disruption in morning-commute service on the Paoli line was
|
||
handled poorly by at least one R5 crew. A line blockage resulted in trains
|
||
being halted way back up the line. Rather than wait at Rosemont until the
|
||
line was cleared, the crew moved the train up to the signals west of Bryn
|
||
Mawr, where trains were holding. A crew member made an announcement of the
|
||
delay in the first car, then hid from the passengers the rest of the time.
|
||
|
||
Meanwhile, another crew member had also gone away, leaving the door and
|
||
trap of his car open. Passengers were jumping off the steps to the
|
||
roadbed below, at danger not only of a sprained ankle, but also of being
|
||
struck by an Amtrak train on the next track as they walked to a station to
|
||
call for a ride. A DVARP member took it upon himself to close the door and
|
||
warn his fellow passengers to stay on the train for safety.
|
||
|
||
Were any SEPTA managers riding this train? Did anyone hear about these
|
||
incidents before now? Has the crew been instructed on the proper
|
||
procedures to follow when a serious disruption comes up and is someone
|
||
making sure they follow those procedures? It's a matter of attitude.
|
||
First the details that improve customer satisfaction slip, then the
|
||
details that maintain safety follow. That slippage has to stop, now.
|
||
|
||
##R6 Shawmont Saved?
|
||
|
||
Outcry from area residents who showed up at a station abandonment hearing
|
||
may have prevented closure of the Norristown Line's Shawmont station.
|
||
Residents of a nearby apartment complex petitioned to keep their train
|
||
service, citing their needs and that of a new complex under construction
|
||
next door. Shawmont is also a handy stop for people who want to ride SEPTA
|
||
to the Valley Forge bike/recreation trail.
|
||
|
||
##R8 AM Reliability Sacrificed
|
||
|
||
Reliable service on the Chestnut Hill West line has suffered because of the
|
||
whims of some Chestnut Hill residents. In the "good old days," trains that
|
||
were due to go out on the early morning runs stayed in Chestnut Hill the
|
||
night before so as to get an on-time start the next day. This writer [BC]
|
||
recently learned that neighbors were complaining about the noise made by
|
||
blowers and compressors of the idling Silverliners as they sat in the
|
||
station. As a result, SEPTA was forced to store the trains downtown and
|
||
run a number of deadhead trips up to Chestnut Hill. If the deadhead gets
|
||
delayed, the rush-hour train it turns into will also be delayed
|
||
|
||
Is it fair to Chestnut Hill residents who ride the R8 to put up with
|
||
delayed service because some other residents complained about some noise?
|
||
Why all the fuss now about noise? Go figure.
|
||
|
||
Schedule Change, Sunday Disruption
|
||
|
||
New R8 schedules are in effect, reflecting a project which will sever the
|
||
two halves of the line on Sundays for Center City electrification repairs.
|
||
|
||
Octoraro Lives!
|
||
|
||
PennDOT has contracted with the newly-created Delaware Valley Railroad for
|
||
operation of the former Octoraro Railroad lines in Chester County and
|
||
Delaware. DVRR is a subsidiary of Rail America Corp., which operates a
|
||
number of other shortlines in the Midwest.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
##D Transit News Update
|
||
##LRD Eye on the Infrastructure:
|
||
|
||
15 Hanging in There
|
||
|
||
A recent inspection of the eastern portion of the Girard Avenue light rail
|
||
infrastructure yielded reassuring results. Overhead wire remains intact
|
||
from Broad St. to the Richmond and Westmoreland loop, except for one block
|
||
at Front St. removed for work on the El station. The safety islands at
|
||
trolley stops between Broad and Front have been removed, as has one of the
|
||
three loop tracks. The west end of the line remains serviceable; this
|
||
summer it hosted an excursion for trolley fans, as well as detoured Route
|
||
10 cars.
|
||
|
||
|
||
##100 Cab Signals Working
|
||
|
||
SEPTA has now cut in the new NHSL signal system from Norristown all the way
|
||
in to West Overbrook. The remainder, protecting the complex of trackage
|
||
around 69th St., is expected to go into service soon. The system
|
||
automatically brakes trains which exceed the speed limit, and can speed
|
||
service by communicating clear conditions to the operator sooner than
|
||
wayside signals can. Once the inevitable (though the system is fail-safe)
|
||
bugs are worked out, the cab-only signal system is supposed to save signal
|
||
maintenance costs.
|
||
|
||
*SEPTA bought 60 third-rail heaters, to improve reliability of P&W service
|
||
in winter storms.
|
||
|
||
|
||
##PATCO Deal Struck, Fare Increase Likely
|
||
|
||
The long-boiling feud over payments to the City of Philadelphia for PATCO's
|
||
use of the City-owned Locust St. Subway has been resolved. The Delaware
|
||
River Port Authority will pay $2 million per year, plus a steep penalty in
|
||
the event that PATCO's deficit (covered by bridge toll surpluses) exceeds
|
||
$6 million.
|
||
|
||
At the heart of the question is a debate over who benefits from PATCO's
|
||
trains: New Jersey, whose residents make up the bulk of Speedline
|
||
ridership; or Philadelphia, which collects the hefty wage tax from those
|
||
commuters.
|
||
|
||
In statements to an Inquirer reporter, State Sen. Walter Rand (D-Camden)
|
||
commented: "But what I do object to is [the city] trying to make a profit
|
||
out of PATCO." while David Cohen, chief of staff to Mayor Rendell, called
|
||
the $2 million "fair rent."
|
||
|
||
PATCO GM Robert Schwab said a fare and parking fee increase would be
|
||
inevitable, to make the payment to the city and balance the budget. The
|
||
Inquirer mentions the possibility of three increases of 9% each in the next
|
||
three years, bringing the cost of a ride to Camden to about $1.00, and a
|
||
Lindenwold trip to about $2.10. A hearing on the fares has not yet been
|
||
scheduled, but may occur as soon as October.
|
||
|
||
##E News Notes
|
||
|
||
Two Minute Warning
|
||
|
||
Commuter rail's ability to quickly solve transportation keeps getting
|
||
demonstrated all across the country. Football fans in Seattle may end up
|
||
travelling by train to Tacoma, which is where Seahawks games will be played
|
||
while the falling tile problem of Seattle's Kingdome is being fixed. You
|
||
can't build access roads and parking lots that quick!
|
||
|
||
Syracuse Opening
|
||
|
||
The commuter train service in Syracuse, NY (run by the New York,
|
||
Susquehanna, and Western) is expected to start September 17. Local
|
||
officials are planning to move the Salt City's Amtrak station to a new
|
||
location closer to downtown than the present East Syracuse station. The
|
||
new station is to be an intermodal transportation hub.
|
||
|
||
Hot Rails?
|
||
|
||
A man was arrested for removing a quarter-mile of track from a dormant
|
||
branch of the Scranton-area Pocono Northeast Railroad and selling it to a
|
||
scrapyard. Though the scrap value of the steel rail is $15,000, it will
|
||
cost about $100,000 for labor and materials to relay the tracks.
|
||
|
||
##F Gambaccini Pay Dispute Ends by Betsy Clarke
|
||
|
||
The ongoing saga of the Lou Gambaccini pay dispute finally came to an end
|
||
with he SEPTA Board giving him a three-year contract at his current salary
|
||
of approximately $191,700 with no raises. He will, however, receive an
|
||
additional lump sum to close out his old contract which provided for raises
|
||
and benefits he has not used from the time he came to SEPTA in August of
|
||
1988. Reliable sources also indicated that he really is entitled to an
|
||
amount of $450,000 to $500,000 if he chose to resign now.
|
||
|
||
The new contract also provides for an incentive provision which awards him
|
||
$10,000 if SEPTA's ridership increases by 1% over the span of one year;
|
||
$20,000 if it rises by 3%.
|
||
|
||
Missing from this current pact are a series of perks which had caused
|
||
concern among some suburban members of the Board as well as Mayor Rendell
|
||
and City Council President John Street. The mayor, however, indicated his
|
||
satisfaction with the provisions of the new agreement.
|
||
|
||
According to Patrick McCarthy, Governor Casey's appointee to the SEPTA
|
||
Board, Gambaccini's health and life insurance and pension benefits would
|
||
be identical to those of other SEPTA managers. At one point during the
|
||
negotiations, it had been proposed that he receive higher benefits.
|
||
McCarthy told the Board "this is a very hard-edged, give-back,
|
||
concession-oriented contract."
|
||
|
||
Most Board members wanted to see Gambaccini remain with SEPTA. The
|
||
General Manager for his part clearly stated that he would like to remain
|
||
for three more years.
|
||
|
||
The contract negotiations had become a public issue when a tentative
|
||
version was leaked to state legislators. [see July, August DVRP]
|
||
Senators William J. Stewart and Vincent Fumo, in particular, expressed
|
||
strong opposition to this pact. This outcry by members of the state
|
||
legislature was interpreted by some as a political ploy to increase
|
||
Harrisburg's control over the SEPTA board.
|
||
|
||
This contract dispute was settled the same day that SEPTA learned that it
|
||
would be receiving $400 million in new funds for capital projects. [cover
|
||
story, August] Rendell said that the city and surrounding counties had
|
||
agreed to delay upwards of $400 million in highway projects so that SEPTA
|
||
would receive this money. The first $100 million of this money will be
|
||
used next January to help pay for 220 new cars for the Market-Frankford El.
|
||
|
||
##G PennDOT Listening
|
||
|
||
As it continues with development of a master Transportation Policy Plan,
|
||
the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation is holding three meetings
|
||
for the purpose of reporting and discussing proposed goals. Your
|
||
attendance has been invited, though none of the meetings are in our
|
||
immediate area, let alone accessible by SEPTA. The Eastern PA meeting is
|
||
in Whitehall, near Allentown, on Oct. 6.
|
||
|
||
If you are unable to attend in person, you can still participate; phone the
|
||
plan staff at 1-800-838-PLAN to have a set of workshop materials mailed to
|
||
you.
|
||
|
||
*The PennDOT Air Quality Task Force will hold a public meeting in
|
||
Harrisburg Sept. 27, to hear comments on the state's implementation plan.
|
||
This document sets out how local and state agencies are supposed to assess
|
||
transportation projects. It's an important document, because it defines
|
||
what level of public participation is enough and because goals and
|
||
assessment criteria can be molded to favor one transportation mode over
|
||
another. Rail advocates need to make sure the process won't overlook
|
||
rail's advantages.
|
||
|
||
You may also submit a written statement for this meeting; and getting the
|
||
materials is as easy as a phone call to Becki Mescher-Vuxta, at
|
||
717-787-9626.
|
||
|
||
##CREDITS News compiled by Matthew Mitchell and correspondents: Chuck
|
||
Bode, Howard Bender, Tom Borawski, Betsey Clarke, Russ Gould, John Hay,
|
||
Mike Mandy, Don Nigro, Mike Rubin, Sharon Shneyer.
|
||
|
||
Additional news from BITNET, Passenger Transport, Philadelphia Inquirer,
|
||
Pro-Rail Nebraska, USENET
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
##H The Value of a One-Seat Ride by Donald Nigro
|
||
|
||
The following is an op-ed piece from the Courier-Post, July 30. In the
|
||
weeks prior to its publication, DVARP and NJ-ARP repeatedly expressed
|
||
written concern to NJ Transit about a lack of balance in their presentation
|
||
of the alternatives for the Burlington/Gloucester Initiative. DVARP and
|
||
NJ-ARP were not alone in perceiving this leaning. When the press wrote of
|
||
NJ Transit's "three hour briefing [which] revolved around" one alternative,
|
||
a public response was in order.
|
||
|
||
It was with great dismay that I read of New Jersey Transit's reckless push
|
||
to expand rail transit service into Burlington and Gloucester Counties
|
||
through the cheapest means rather than considering the most cost-effective
|
||
end. Through this, they have disregarded the data in their own most
|
||
recently published study on the matter. NJ Transit's is hastily pushing
|
||
for a trolley-style vehicle, which would require a transfer in Camden for
|
||
the bulk of the passengers destined for Center City, Philadelphia. This
|
||
is at the expense of the public's consideration of other rail options
|
||
which, in addition to providing effective intra-state connections, could
|
||
offer a one-seat (no transfer) ride to Center City, Philadelphia.
|
||
|
||
These are the figures from NJ Transit's most recent study. I will focus on
|
||
Gloucester County, but the numbers are similar for Burlington County.
|
||
The capital costs for a modified-PATCO line to Glassboro would be $552
|
||
million; the trolley-style, light rail cost would be $495 million. The
|
||
difference is 11%. Yet, the projected average weekday ridership for
|
||
modified-PATCO is 75% higher, than that of light rail; 23,100 for
|
||
modified-PATCO, 13,200 for light rail. Furthermore, the travel time from
|
||
Glassboro to Philadelphia is significantly shorter with modified-PATCO
|
||
than light rail. With light rail in Gloucester County, a trip to
|
||
Philadelphia would take 6 to 18 minutes longer depending on the additional
|
||
time spent waiting for the arrival of the next train at the transfer point
|
||
within Camden.
|
||
|
||
Yes, we want effective intra-state connections; at the same time, the
|
||
value of a one-seat ride to Philadelphia should not be underestimated.
|
||
87% of the Lindenwold Line passengers travel between Southern New Jersey
|
||
and Philadelphia. In the words of NJ Transit's study, the "Center City
|
||
bound commuters are a key ingredient," and this market is the only one
|
||
"with enough potential passenger volume to justify" rail expansion within
|
||
Southern New Jersey. Good business transportation decisions are needed to
|
||
avoid a boondoggle project.
|
||
|
||
All of the surrounding counties of Philadelphia with the exception of
|
||
Burlington and Gloucester Counties currently offer one-seat rail rides to
|
||
Center City, Philadelphia. Rail service failed in Burlington and
|
||
Gloucester Counties in the late sixties primarily because it did not offer
|
||
a one-seat ride. Passengers got off at Broadway Station and transferred to
|
||
the Bridge Line (the predecessor to the PATCO Speed Line).
|
||
|
||
NJ Transit values a one-seat ride for Northern New Jersey. In that part
|
||
of the state, NJ Transit is constructing the Kearny Connection, a link to
|
||
allow the Morris & Essex commuter rail lines direct access into New York
|
||
City rather than forcing a transfer at Hoboken Terminal. If such an idea
|
||
is desirable for passengers in Northern New Jersey, a region with
|
||
horrendous traffic problems such that significant numbers of commuters
|
||
accept a multiple-seat ride, then certainly it is strategic in Southern New
|
||
Jersey, where commuters view their car as the primary choice for travel;
|
||
after all, commuters will always take the path of least resistance. With
|
||
the investment in the Kearny Connection, the state, through NJ Transit, is
|
||
spending over $131 million for direct and indirect costs to increase
|
||
ridership by 38%. All of this because of the desirability of a one-seat
|
||
ride.
|
||
|
||
On April 18, 1994, the Washington Post revealed a common text book case of
|
||
what we fear for Southern New Jersey. The new [Washington Metro] Greenbelt
|
||
[Green] Line within the Washington, D.C. area requires its passengers to
|
||
transfer to the Wheaton [Red] Line at a modern, pleasant facility to
|
||
complete their trip to and from Washington D.C. 13,000 riders were
|
||
expected for this line, the actual figure has been 8,600. The Post refers
|
||
to this serious shortfall as a "disappointment" and further states that
|
||
these figures suggest "that many concerns expressed by riders in December
|
||
have turned out to be true". "The vast 1,068-space lot at Prince George's
|
||
Plaza usually has about 175 spaces filled." The article goes on to state
|
||
that "transit studies show transfers can discourage ridership." Asked
|
||
whether the transfer was a prime reason for the low numbers, Metrorail
|
||
manager Fady P. Bassily was quick to respond: "Absolutely".
|
||
|
||
For the South Jersey initiative, NJ Transit has pledged itself to an open
|
||
process, but these words ring with hollowness. Although they technically
|
||
have refused to make an outright endorsement of a particular transit
|
||
system, by their tactics, epitomized by the three-hour press briefing on
|
||
July 20 revolving around one possible outcome, NJ Transit has tainted the
|
||
process with its manipulation. In addition, they have demonstrated a clear
|
||
and gross disregard for the available and upcoming research data. This is
|
||
not conducive for effective expansion of rail transit service into
|
||
Burlington and Gloucester Counties.
|
||
|
||
We do not want the cheapest system; we want the most cost-effective one,
|
||
the one that will attract the most motorists out of their cars for the
|
||
best price.
|
||
|
||
##I South Jersey Notes
|
||
|
||
Congratulations to NJ Transit's rail operator team, which successfully
|
||
defended its APTA Rail 'Roadeo' championship this summer.
|
||
|
||
|
||
##J Unions Not Pacific by Matthew Mitchell
|
||
|
||
An unwanted merger offer escalated into an inter-union battle last month
|
||
during the strike of United Transportation Union members against CP
|
||
Rail/Soo Line in the midwest. Earlier in the year, UTU sought to
|
||
incorporate the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers into its
|
||
organization, but BLE leadership rebuffed the plan. UTU pressed ahead
|
||
though, and sought provisions in the Soo contract that BLE officers called
|
||
a "raid" on their union.
|
||
|
||
The war of words escalated to the point where BLE told its members to cross
|
||
the UTU picket lines and return to work, a rare breach of labor solidarity.
|
||
Faced with a weakening position vis-a-vis management, the UTU strikers
|
||
announced an impending secondary boycott against all the other railroads
|
||
which connect to the Soo. Though the widened strike was not to be directed
|
||
at Chicago-area commuter railroads, the action set off the predictable
|
||
chain reaction. President Clinton declared the impending secondary action
|
||
to be a threat to interstate commerce and intervened under the Railway
|
||
Labor Act. A mandatory 'cooling-off' period has been instated while
|
||
Federal mediators examine the case. After 30 days, UTU is free to resume
|
||
its strike, though it would be likely that Congress would impose the
|
||
mediators' settlement on the parties.
|
||
|
||
Besides the representational issues which upset BLE, train staffing levels
|
||
are at issue in the walkout. Soo is one of the few American railroads
|
||
where contracts still require three-person crews on all trains. UTU
|
||
accuses management of failing to bargain in good faith. Amtrak service
|
||
between Chicago and Milwaukee has been disrupted by the strike. Several
|
||
trains have been canceled for the duration, while others have been delayed
|
||
due to detours over other railroads.
|
||
|
||
##K More Comments on NE Subway
|
||
|
||
Replying to a DVRP cover story on proposals for rapid transit service,
|
||
Chris Zearfoss, of the Mayor's Office for Transportation, and Ed Tennyson,
|
||
P.E., told us some of long the history of this project. Here are some
|
||
excerpts from Tennyson's letter:
|
||
|
||
[quote] Less than thirty years ago, we put it to a vote, and the Pennway
|
||
alignment was approved by over 60 percent of the entire city, including
|
||
every ward in the service area. Only the small ward on the Schuylkill
|
||
River at South Street opposed it....Final construction plans were drawn and
|
||
work began. A station shell was built under the Sears parking structure
|
||
just north of Roosevelt Boulevard....GM [General Motors] made it clear to
|
||
him, with PTC [Philadelphia Transportation Company, predecessor to SEPTA]
|
||
help, that Philadelphia was no place for new rail transit. (He later went
|
||
to jail for other problems). The politicians went right ahead with the
|
||
Pattison Avenue extension.... Primary candidate Frank Rizzo ran a full
|
||
page ad in the papers promising to finish the Northeast subway if elected.
|
||
He was, but in the general election he ran another full page ad promising
|
||
NOT to build it, substituting the Center City Commuter Connection which
|
||
businessmen downtown saw as serving higher income clients, with different
|
||
funds.
|
||
|
||
Zearfoss adds:
|
||
|
||
[quote] Now that significant, but not complete, progress has been made in
|
||
repairing old infrastructure, and with some measure of financial confidence
|
||
in light of ISTEA and Act 26, the City wishes to explore the Northeast rail
|
||
issue-much as New Jersey is advancing the Burlington and Gloucester Rail
|
||
Corridors Study, and SEPTA is advancing the Cross County Metro concept.
|
||
|
||
[quote] On the questions of subway vs. commuter rail, both writers defended
|
||
the subway plan. DVARP hasn't endorsed one mode over the other for
|
||
Northeast service, but is concerned that the planning process won't give
|
||
thorough consideration to alternatives other than the subway. Said
|
||
Tennyson:
|
||
|
||
[quote] [The] Broad Street subway has plenty of capacity, far more than
|
||
enough, with a Northeast express every five minutes and an Olney local
|
||
every five. That is 24 trains per hour, 144 cars, 20,000 peak hour
|
||
passengers, although for longer rides it might be held down to 18,000.
|
||
That is 180,000 per day.
|
||
|
||
And Zearfoss:
|
||
|
||
[quote] The City is not "locked into heavy rapid transit as the only
|
||
option." The current Needs and Preferences Study will also evaluate the
|
||
SEPTA proposal for a Northeast Metro Light Rail Line....
|
||
|
||
[quote] In 1984, Booz, Allen, and Hamilton, consultants to the City
|
||
Planning Commission, conducted a federally-funded feasibility study of
|
||
instituting commuter rail service on the New York Short Line, which
|
||
concluded that ridership and revenue generated would be insufficient to
|
||
justify the capital investment and operating costs.
|
||
|
||
[quote] While in concept commuter rail could be implemented on the New York
|
||
Short Line more easily than a rapid transit subway along Roosevelt
|
||
Boulevard, what is actually a "sensible price" is predicated upon detailed
|
||
studies of operating and service constraints &and parameters, land-use
|
||
issues, alternative alignments and modes, capital investment required,
|
||
ridership, fares, revenues, operating costs, plus externalities.
|
||
|
||
[quote] ...The flat fare from the Far Northeast has many roots, including
|
||
ease of fare collection, and the fact that the trip time to Center City is
|
||
nearly an hour-twice that for commuter rail....
|
||
|
||
[quote] ...Any correlation that may exist between the flat fare to the
|
||
Northeast and taxes paid by residents is no different in principle from the
|
||
City's paying a disproportional share of the commuter rail local subsidy,
|
||
which as I recall DVARP has supported on the basis of wage tax
|
||
considerations....
|
||
|
||
[quote] A major factor constraining Northeast Philadelphia commuter rail
|
||
patronage is poor access. Bus routes linking rapid transit lines are
|
||
within walking distance of almost every neighborhood. With few exceptions,
|
||
commuter rail stations must be accesses by car; even if park-and-ride were
|
||
expanded, many Northeast residents do not have the luxury of a second or
|
||
third car to leave at the station all day.
|
||
|
||
[quote] The Northeast Metro LRT is not a "mostly in-street (trolley route)
|
||
through Olney and North Philadelphia". Between roughly Tabor Road and
|
||
Huntingdon Street, the line would be on abandoned railroad ROW, and between
|
||
Huntingdon and Master Streets, in a reservation along the extra-wide
|
||
segment of American Street. Dedicated lanes and transitways would carry
|
||
the line most of the rest of the way into Center City. This proposal is
|
||
not as some have misconstrued, just a replication of the Route 50
|
||
streetcar."
|
||
|
||
[quote] The chart allegedly portraying more favorable travel time for the
|
||
Reading commuter rail route versus the Broad Street and Market-Frankford
|
||
Lines extensions is misleading, since it does not pinpoint the comparable
|
||
station locations, let alone allow for the advantages of much better
|
||
transit headways. Current R-8 timetables show a 25 minute travel time
|
||
between Fox Chase (at Rhawn Street) and Market East Stations-not 20
|
||
minutes. By contrast, prior studies have shown that Broad Street Subway
|
||
Extensions can provide City Hall-Rhawn Street service in 20 minutes or
|
||
less.
|
||
|
||
[quote] City Hall Station, Northeast Extension or not, is slated for a
|
||
major modernization to improve amenities and capacity....
|
||
|
||
[quote] ...Whatever the preferred route or mode, ultimately it will be
|
||
selected through community and political consensus-building. The real
|
||
point, however, is that a rail transit line, wit h frequent headways,
|
||
convenient transfer points, and a fare structure fully coordinated with
|
||
that of the surface feeder lines, is required. Commuter rail service
|
||
levels, typical station spacing and amenities, and fares, are inadequate to
|
||
meet fully the public transport needs of Northeast Philadelphia.
|
||
|
||
Author Matthew Mitchell replies:
|
||
|
||
The problems with commuter rait to the Northeast like today's too-slow
|
||
travel times and a capacity problem also mentioned by Tennyson, are
|
||
matters of implementation rather than capability. When trains are only
|
||
going 40 mph on brand new track cleared for 60, that's the fault of
|
||
management, not the mode itself.
|
||
|
||
But whatever the outcome this kind of discussion is what will make
|
||
passengers and taxpayers feel confident their money is being spent wisely,
|
||
whichever way the decision goes. If the City officials have as good an
|
||
understanding of the commuter rail option as they say they do, then it
|
||
shouldn't be either difficult or threatening to include it wth the
|
||
official choices.
|
||
|
||
Zearfoss's objections to the commuter rail routing and mode stem from an
|
||
assumption that a Northeast commuter rail line would be operated in the
|
||
same manner as the present RRD lines in Philadelphia, with hourly base
|
||
headways, and poor integration of fares and service with local transit
|
||
routes. Instead of abandoning commuter rail as a viable choice for city
|
||
residents, why not change the commuter rail service so that it meets their
|
||
needs? Increase service levels, coordinate and guarantee connections and
|
||
establish an intermodal single fare, so people can use commuter rail for
|
||
their trunk haul instead of an inefficient bus or a crowded Frankford El.
|
||
The result will be faster travel times, increased transit market share,
|
||
and more room for the closer-in people who watch buses pass them by.
|
||
|
||
And if flat fares are justified on city transit routes, why not on city
|
||
railroad routes? The difference in fare structures (and the mediocre train
|
||
service) keeps rail ridership within the city artificially depressed,
|
||
despite good city/SEPTA initiatives like acceptance of TransPasses on
|
||
off-peak trains.
|
||
|
||
##L Freight Mergers in the News
|
||
|
||
Rail industry sources claim the Philadelphia-based Consolidated Rail Corp.
|
||
is in merger talks with Norfolk Southern Corp., which previously sought to
|
||
acquire Conrail at the time the Federal government privatized Conrail.
|
||
Coming on the heels of the announced merger of western giants Burlington
|
||
Northern and Union Pacific and a track-sharing agreement between Canadian
|
||
National and CP Rail, the eastern deal foreshadows a new round of mergers
|
||
which would leave only three or four coast-to-coast megacarriers in place
|
||
of the present nine big railroads.
|
||
|
||
The pundits feel a CR/NS merger would make sense, but the deal is far from
|
||
complete, though. It would be a virtual certainty that strings would be
|
||
attached to the deal, to ensure that some competition in rail freight
|
||
service would remain in the areas served by the two railroads.--MDM
|
||
|
||
|
||
##M Computer Corner: Web Access to the DVRP
|
||
|
||
A new and easy way to retrieve current and back issues of the Delaware
|
||
Valley Rail Passenger is with the all-point-and-click hypertext interface
|
||
of the World Wide Web. Aim your WWW client at:
|
||
|
||
http://venus.mcs.com/~dsdawdy/cyberroad.html
|
||
|
||
German Train Info at ICE Speed
|
||
|
||
If you can access the World Wide Web, you can now visit RailServer for
|
||
information on the German Railways. By filling out a form on your
|
||
screen, you can get schedule information, including connections. Fare,
|
||
fly-ride, and other travel information is also on the server, in English.
|
||
Link to: http://rzstud1.rz.uni-karlsruhe.de/~ule3/info-Trn.html
|
||
|
||
Much of the information is also available, though not as conveniently, by
|
||
electronic mail. Send a message saying #HELP to
|
||
<rail@rx.uni-karlsruhe.de>.
|
||
--MDM
|
||
|
||
##N State of the Art: Fare Collection by Matthew Mitchell
|
||
|
||
(first of a three-part series)
|
||
|
||
After decades of little change, the collection of fares on rail and transit
|
||
systems has been revolutionized in the 80s and 90s. New ideas and new
|
||
technology are being used in efforts to boost system revenue while reducing
|
||
the cost of collecting that revenue. This article will describe some of
|
||
those developments and try to see how they might work in our area.
|
||
|
||
Amtrak: Taking technology for granted
|
||
|
||
It is difficult to envision how Amtrak could get along without its Arrow
|
||
computerized reservations and ticketing system. Though the railroad runs
|
||
from coast to coast, and dedicated buses extend its network to hundreds of
|
||
additional cities, itineraries and tickets for any trip can be generated at
|
||
the touch of a few keys. Before Amtrak, passengers (or their travel
|
||
agents) often had to deal with two or more different ticket agents.
|
||
Uniting America's intercity passenger trains also brought consistency in
|
||
policies like childrens' fares, and made nationwide offers like the All
|
||
Aboard America fare possible.
|
||
|
||
In recent years, Amtrak has taken more and more cues from the airlines. A
|
||
'yield-management' system was implemented to allow Amtrak to tailor its
|
||
fares to passenger demand. With yield management, a certain number of
|
||
seats on each lng-distance train are allocated to each discount level.
|
||
When Amtrak needs to fill more seats, they are shifted to lower-fare
|
||
categories. When demand is high, Amtrak can charge full fares. The system
|
||
is also given part of the credit for increasing the average trip length and
|
||
keeping train seats filled longer. In another move patterned after the
|
||
airlines, Amtrak has just made its discount tickets non-refundable.
|
||
|
||
One place where Amtrak hasn't emulated the airlines is with a
|
||
frequent-traveler program. Riders accustomed to piling up air miles for a
|
||
trip to Hawaii often ask why they can't do the same with the train. The
|
||
airlines instituted their mileage programs to build repeat business in an
|
||
industry where nearly all carriers offer the same prices. Since it has no
|
||
rail competitor, Amtrak doesn't need such a program, and is grateful it
|
||
hasn't had to. The airlines lose buckets of money on them, but because
|
||
business travellers now have a sense of entitlement to the perk, the
|
||
airlines can't eliminate them.
|
||
|
||
Amtrak pioneered self-service ticketing, with credit card-operated
|
||
machines seen throughout the Northeast Corridor and at other stations.
|
||
Savvy riders know to bypass ticket lines by stepping over to the
|
||
easy-to-use machines. But once the tickets are sold, their collection on
|
||
board the train is much like it was thirty years ago. Conductors must
|
||
still handle cash fares from unattended stations, punching the traditional
|
||
two-part receipt. They inspect and punch tickets and mark seat checks
|
||
identifying the passenger's destination. Only minor changes are
|
||
anticipated here; Amtrak has tested a new ticket with pre-printed seat
|
||
check.
|
||
|
||
Finally, Arrow plays an important behind-the-scenes role. Data from the
|
||
computer can be used to forecast travel demand and adjust train consists to
|
||
meet it where possible. This helps keep costs down, and pays off on the
|
||
bottom line. Though Northeast Corridor passengers may complain about
|
||
having to stand when trains are full, Arrow makes that problem less
|
||
frequent.
|
||
|
||
With Amtrak starved for capital, few improvements are anticipated.
|
||
Computer terminals and other hardware have been upgraded, but other goals,
|
||
like one-stop ticketing and information for passengers connecting to or
|
||
from local commuter trains remain illusory. Until that improvement is
|
||
made, the millions of potential rail passengers living in suburbia will
|
||
continue to find that catching a train is no more convenient than catching
|
||
a plane.
|
||
|
||
##O Fare Wars: Amtrak Strikes Back
|
||
|
||
An Amtrak fare sale offers a 50 percent discount off lowest available fares
|
||
for a friend or family member you bring along on your next train trip.
|
||
The offer ends October 31, and travel must be completed by December 11.
|
||
Restrictions and limitations apply (including: not valid Nov. 23 or 27, for
|
||
weekday Metroliners, or with certain fare plans like 'All Aboard America'),
|
||
but Amtrak's fine print isn't quite as onerous as the airlines. Call your
|
||
travel agent or 1-800-USA-RAIL for reservations.
|
||
|
||
##P Amtrak Notes
|
||
|
||
Superliners in the East!
|
||
|
||
Amtrak has announced that the Capitol Limited
|
||
(Washington-Pittsburgh-Chicago) will be the first eastern train to employ
|
||
the double-deck Superliner equipment, beginning October 30.
|
||
|
||
As of July 1, Amtrak had taken delivery of a quarter of its 195 new
|
||
double-deck cars. 25 sleepers are on the property, along with 15 new
|
||
diners and 11 high-low transition cars. The new cars will let Amtrak move
|
||
its tri-weekly trains to daily service, and equip the Auto Train with
|
||
Superliners. The added capacity is sorely needed if Amtrak is to come
|
||
closer to its goal of breaking even financially.
|
||
|
||
*Amtrak sources say the fall schedule change may see an extension of the
|
||
Palmetto to Tampa, Florida, in place of the Tampa section of the Silver
|
||
Meteor.
|
||
|
||
*Trying to get a reservation on Amtrak but the train is booked up the day
|
||
you want to travel? Try calling shortly after 3:00 am. Amtrak's Arrow
|
||
computer system closes out its day and releases unticketed reservations at
|
||
midnight Pacific time, which is 3:00 in Philadelphia.
|
||
|
||
*Bad weather caused a signal failure and a number of train delays on the
|
||
A.C. line August 14. Another storm August 13 knocked out signals at New
|
||
Brunswick, hampering Amtrak and NJT service.
|
||
|
||
*Preliminary investigations of the Lake Shore Limited derailment in
|
||
Batavia, NY last month have placed blame on the underframe of one of the
|
||
train's Heritage Fleet cars.
|
||
|
||
*Kosher meals served to Amtrak passengers who specially reqest them have
|
||
been upgraded with new menus and improved presentaton.
|
||
|
||
Derailment Casualty 500 Miles Away
|
||
|
||
Amtrak's Executive Sleeper (the car dropped off/picked up in New York by
|
||
the Night Owl for travelers who want to wake up in downtown Washington or
|
||
New York) has been discontinued due to a shortage of sleeping cars
|
||
resulting from the Batavia derailment.
|
||
|
||
##Q Congress Acts on Rail Safety
|
||
|
||
In response to the well-publicized Amtrak accidents of the past year, the
|
||
House has passed a bill ordering the Department of Transportation to
|
||
consider new rules for detection of hidden track defects, evaluate
|
||
technological gizmos for saving railroad bridges from lost barges, and test
|
||
possible changes in regulations governing rail workers' hours of service.
|
||
|
||
Another bill was passed authorizing $182 million for planning of high-speed
|
||
rail service in a number of corridors, including New York-Buffalo and
|
||
Washington-Carolinas. The authorization was scaled way back from the
|
||
original committee proposal of $1.2 billion to start actually upgrading
|
||
these lines for high-speed passenger trains.--MDM
|
||
|
||
Quoteable
|
||
|
||
I guess God decided it was time to send a message about the safety of the
|
||
towboat industry....We have accepted the fact that highways are unsafe.
|
||
Somewhere along the way, someone made the decision that one passenger
|
||
[rail] fatality is one to many -Ross Capon, NARP Executive Director,
|
||
commenting on recent Amtrak accidents and the proposal to impose
|
||
expensive safety mandates on the railroad.
|
||
|
||
|
||
##R Eurorail Views: Baptism of the Unborn? by James Morgan
|
||
|
||
[Full text here in the online editon of the DVRP; the hard copy edition has
|
||
been edited for length-Ed.]
|
||
|
||
On June 28, 1994, the latter half of the first program in New Jersey
|
||
Network's new series Makin' Tracks (available on Channel 23 Tuesday
|
||
evenings from 8:30-9:00 in the Camden-Philadelphia area) focused upon the
|
||
feat of digging the channel tunnel. The trip by Queen Elizabeth II of
|
||
England and French President Mitterand under the Channel on May 6, 1994
|
||
seems to represent a milestone in railroading. In fact, the May 13 issue
|
||
of Die Zeit [Time] devoted three full feature articles plus a short article
|
||
to this very event. But the consensus of the articles seems to be that the
|
||
celebration resembles a festooned christening of an unborn child, as Reiner
|
||
Luykens puts it. After all, when will ordinary mortals be able to ride Le
|
||
Shuttle?
|
||
|
||
While I had hoped to deal with articles from other sources, this special
|
||
issue of Die Zeit provides enough material for one installment. One of the
|
||
articles is a translation from the English of a paper by Roy Jenkins,
|
||
"Sehnsucht nach dem alten Glanz" [Yearning for the Old Splendor]. Roy
|
||
Jenkins has occupied various English ministerial posts, and has served as
|
||
President of the European Commission. The other articles include Reiner
|
||
Luykens' "Tunnel? Wer braucht einen Tunnel?" [Tunnel? Who Needs a
|
||
Tunnel?], and Ludwig Siegele's article, "R<>hre zwischen zwei Welten" [Tubes
|
||
between two Worlds] and his note, "Modell f<>r Europa?" [Model for Europe?].
|
||
|
||
Luykens' article affords a sketch of the problem. Freight transportation
|
||
was supposed to being on March 7, 1994, but this was postponed. Of course,
|
||
at the time of this writing in July, four freights a day pass through the
|
||
tunnel. An advertising campaign for tourists which took shape in the fall
|
||
of 1993 quickly ran out of steam. Those who call receive the answer that
|
||
passenger service may begin in October 1994-but callers are best advised to
|
||
watch for announcements in the newspapers. Dividends were to be paid to
|
||
stockholders beginning in 1995. Probably now no dividends will be declared
|
||
before 2000. There has been a third issue of shares. Debts mount. Each
|
||
day initiation of full service is delayed results in the loss of <20>2 million
|
||
in expected earnings.
|
||
|
||
The results of tests of the system have been very dubious. True, Waterloo
|
||
Station in London has been ready for some time. Now speeds of the
|
||
Trans-Manche [English Channel]-Super-Train in Oile, Somme and Pas-de-Calais
|
||
in France are 300 kilometers per hour. Speeds through Kent County in
|
||
England are a leisurely 140 kilometers per hour. Luykens argues that
|
||
trains will have to travel at high speeds to be competitive with air
|
||
travel. In France, the trains draw power from the overhead, in England
|
||
from a third rail. Test trips through England experienced difficulties
|
||
because of frequency flutter in the current. At the time Luykens wrote,
|
||
the ninth proposed route was under discussion, but now a route to London
|
||
has been selected. Luykens focuses on the case of the town of Ashford,
|
||
which has railroaded [durchgedr<64>ckt] itself into the European railway
|
||
network. There are only two ways out of Ashford. The one would entail
|
||
extra costs of <20>65 million. The other runs through a stretch of
|
||
countryside immortalized in the filmed novel The Darling Buds of May.
|
||
Luykens criticizes the proposed use of Diesel locomotives in England.
|
||
These are currently being coupled on to freight trains upon their arrival
|
||
in England, but electric locomotives will be used for passenger service..
|
||
|
||
Is any aspect of the project working? The museum at Folkstone is proving
|
||
to be a success with its life-sized mockups and its model railroad, despite
|
||
an entry fee of <20>3.70 per person. The French intend to duplicate the feat
|
||
in their own way, with audiovisual aids using 8 headed laser cannons and
|
||
sublime music.
|
||
|
||
Luykens does not, however, go into the roots of the problem. He does note
|
||
the joy of many British at the hardships of tunnel project. He draws
|
||
attention to the shadow market in French alcoholic beverages, especially
|
||
canned beer, on the ferries, which relaxed customs regulations have
|
||
created. He notes that many participants in this trade view the train with
|
||
dismay. It is Siegele who goes into the various conflicts which have
|
||
dogged the project.
|
||
|
||
An underlying issue is the fact that the project is basically French. The
|
||
French have done much of the planning and two thirds of the stock holders
|
||
are French. The three French companies in the Trans-Manche Consortium
|
||
operate worldwide, while the five British companies restrict their business
|
||
to the United Kingdom. The British have reacted to the venture as a new
|
||
Hastings.
|
||
|
||
The clash of cultures manifested itself even in the haggling over the name
|
||
of the train. The French rejected the proposed designation of the Loop
|
||
because of its similarity to their word for wolf, loup. Dart was rejected
|
||
because it had no particular connotations for the French, except for a skin
|
||
eruption. The name finally adopted, Le Shuttle, is objectionable because
|
||
it is franglais.
|
||
|
||
The clash over terminology is just
|
||
one manifestation of a general lack of communications. In contracts, for
|
||
example, French credit agreements are basically short. Many contingencies
|
||
are addressed by the operation of law in the French system. If the French
|
||
planned the operation, it was left to the English to implement it. British
|
||
lawyers found the simple credit agreements to constitute a fertile ground
|
||
for objections. The French find the British tendency to draw up contracts
|
||
which can fill a wardrobe in an attempt to address every imaginable
|
||
contingency to be a waste of time-and money, too, perhaps, given the legal
|
||
fees.
|
||
|
||
The difference between the two approaches is made visually concrete in the
|
||
contrast between the superhuman station facilities at Pas-de-Calais and the
|
||
simple facilities at Folkstone. The French find that the British love for
|
||
smallness can lead to confusion. In the French system, a single person is
|
||
responsible for police, fire and accidents, the prefect. The British would
|
||
have separate authorities responsible for each.
|
||
|
||
The conflicts between the two cultures have lead to complicated equipment
|
||
design in the cars being produced by Bombardier ANF Industrie in
|
||
Valenciennes, France. Each car contains 76 kilometers of cables, ten times
|
||
more than a TGV car. There is even a control chip for the restrooms. The
|
||
production line resembles an airplane factory, and great cost overruns have
|
||
resulted from the attempt to convert what was conceived as a Renault 4 into
|
||
a Rolls-Royce. The cars contain elaborate smoke detectors, and in case of
|
||
fire, a fire-extinguishing gas called halon would be sprayed from above,
|
||
while foam would be introduced from below. These specifications were
|
||
requested by the British, who fear a tunnel fire, remembering the
|
||
devastating conflagration which occurred at the King's Cross subway station
|
||
in London in 1984. While Siegele mentions that enlarging the width of the
|
||
car door entailed considerable additional expenditures, he fails to mention
|
||
the cause for the 10 centimeters which raised the price for the 252 cars to
|
||
nearly one and one half times the projected DM 1.1 billion: Initial
|
||
failure to design the doors to accommodate wheelchairs, which is an
|
||
international requirement.
|
||
|
||
Of course, the British find the tunnel to be an ideal target for the IRA.
|
||
An automatic life sentence is imposed upon anyone attacking the Chunnel.
|
||
Despite the priority which the English assign to combatting terrorists,
|
||
French gendarmes will have to leave part of their uniforms on the train
|
||
should they wish to enter Waterloo station: Their sidearms. Debating this
|
||
thorny problem consumed a month.
|
||
|
||
Has there been significant cooperation in any area? Siegele's short note,
|
||
"Model for Europe?" suggests that such has occurred between British and
|
||
French labor organizations working on the project, which has employed 1300
|
||
persons. The communistically inspired Conf<6E>deration g<>n<EFBFBD>rale du travail
|
||
(CGT) [General Confederation of Labor] and the less ideological Transport &
|
||
General Worker's Union (TGWU) found that about 80% of their rules were
|
||
really similar, despite differences in their union traditions. The French
|
||
felt that labor law was nonexistent in England, where everyone has to
|
||
negotiate his or her own labor contract. The British were astonished the
|
||
French Labor Code regulates in great detail what British unions have to
|
||
fight for. Siegele notes that recently a British court found that all
|
||
participants must be announced by name in advance in case of a strike. CGT
|
||
officials were irritated that Eurotunnel did not ask them to put up
|
||
candidates in the most recent personnel representative elections, despite
|
||
the fact that they had a right to do so. TGWU spokespersons have stressed
|
||
the importance of soliciting union members. CGT functionaries are
|
||
participating in TGWU practical courses in London.
|
||
|
||
What is there to fear in a tunnel connecting the United Kingdom with the
|
||
European Continent? The cartoon illustrating Roy Jenkins' article surely
|
||
says more than a thousand words. The nineteenth century cartoon depicts
|
||
the British lion fleeing from a French rooster emerging from a projected
|
||
tunnel under the English Channel. Jenkins points out that a land
|
||
connection between the British Isles and the Continent has a diminished
|
||
strategic significance in the age of supersonic military aircraft. In the
|
||
Victorian era, Britain was very much involved in European affairs. Britain
|
||
was a significant force in European affairs from Waterloo in 1815 to
|
||
Locarno in 1925. Prime Minister Gladstone undertook more than nine trips
|
||
to Europe and corresponded with several major European statesmen in their
|
||
own languages (Theodor Ignaz von D<>llinger in German, Franaois Guizot in
|
||
French, and Cavour and Mazzini in Italian). Benjamin Disraeli dominated
|
||
the Berlin Congress. The events of 1940 changed much of this. Although
|
||
Britain did not lose World War II, it was the United States and the Soviet
|
||
Union which provided the troops necessary to win it. They were now the
|
||
superpowers. After World War II, Britain did not pursue a policy of
|
||
splendid isolation. England was active in three intersecting circles, the
|
||
Commonwealth, its relationship with the United States, and Europe. England
|
||
sought to play in the same league as the new superpowers, and missed the
|
||
Messina conference in 1955. Germany and France overtook the United Kingdom
|
||
in per capita income and in influence in Europe.
|
||
|
||
Both major parties, Labor and Conservative, have fallen victim to the
|
||
arrogance of isolationism. For a while, the left wing of the Labor party
|
||
believed it could establish an independent, insular socialism. After the
|
||
threat of socialism on Great Britain subsided, the earlier enthusiasm of
|
||
the Tories for Europe cooled and they began to see Jacques Delors as the
|
||
embodiment of the ugly alien. Recent election victories by pro-European
|
||
forces in the Labor and Liberal parties manifest popular support for a
|
||
policy of cooperation with Europe. But, cautions Jenkins, Channel Tunnel
|
||
or no Channel Tunnel, if Britain is poorly represented in European official
|
||
bodies, this is due to a weakness in British politics, of attempting to
|
||
play in another league.
|
||
|
||
At the present time (July), the main obstacle to passenger service, a plan
|
||
of evacuation in case of fire, has been overcome. Perhaps the initiation of
|
||
regular passenger service, and other events, will generate occasions for
|
||
assessing additional literature I have accumulated.
|
||
|
||
|
||
##S Dates of Interest
|
||
|
||
NJ DOT public input meeting for state budget planning: Mon., Sept. 12, 7
|
||
p.m., at Henry Beck Middle School, Cropwell Rd., Cherry Hill. Additional
|
||
meetings Thurs., Sept. 22, 7 p.m. at Freehold Borough High School, Rt. 79
|
||
and Robertsville Rd., Freehold Borough and Wed, Sept. 28, 7 p.m., at Thomas
|
||
Jefferson School, James and Ogden Sts., Morristown.
|
||
|
||
DVARP General Meeting: Sat., Sept 17, 1:00 to 4:00 at Temple University
|
||
Center City, 1616 Walnut St., Philadelphia.
|
||
|
||
SEPTA Citizen Advisory Committee: Tues., Sept. 20, 5:45 pm at SEPTA Board
|
||
Room, 714 Market St.
|
||
|
||
SEPTA on Site (Suburban Transit): Wed., Sept. 21, 7:30 to 9:30 am and 3:30
|
||
to 5:30 pm at 69th St. Terminal, 7:30 to 9:30 am at Norristown
|
||
Transportation Center.
|
||
|
||
SEPTA Board Meeting: Thu., Sept. 22, 3:00 pm at SEPTA Board Room, 714
|
||
Market St.
|
||
|
||
NJ Transit Hoboken Festival: Sat., Sept. 24, all day, at Hoboken Terminial.
|
||
|
||
Deadline for October newsletter material: Tues., Sept. 27, to Matthew
|
||
Mitchell or in DVARP mailbox.
|
||
|
||
Delmarva Rail Passenger Association: Thu., Oct 6, 6:30 pm, at
|
||
Stationmaster's Office, Amtrak Wilmington Staton. Call Ken Berg,
|
||
410-648-5961, for more information.
|
||
|
||
DVARP General Meeting: Sat., Oct. 15, 12:00 to 5:00 at Lansdowne Library,
|
||
Lansdowne Ave. just south of R3 tracks, Lansdowne, PA. Note change of
|
||
place and time!!
|
||
|
||
DVARP General Meeting: Sat., Nov. 19, 1:00 to 4:00 at Collingswood Public
|
||
Library.
|
||
|
||
Listings based on information provided to DVARP. Contact sponsor to
|
||
confirm time & place.
|
||
|
||
Call 215-222-3373, message box 3, to add your event to this calendar.
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
##T Up and Down the Corridor
|
||
News of other Northeastern commuter rail and
|
||
rail transit services
|
||
|
||
Two Levels, One Seat to Port Jeff
|
||
|
||
A pair of milestones were marked on Long Island last month.
|
||
New York became the second Northeastern city to
|
||
begin using double-deck commuter rail coaches as a dozen new cars entered
|
||
service. The new train is pulled by a freshly-rebuilt FL9AC locomotive
|
||
which puts high-tech guts into a classic body. The dual mode
|
||
electric/diesel engine allows this train to operate LIRR's first direct run
|
||
from Port Jefferson all the way to Penn Station.
|
||
|
||
One rider called the new cars "light and airy-looking"-high praise for a
|
||
double-deck car which must fit under the electric wires at Penn Station.
|
||
But unlike gallery cars, a crowded 3+2 seating plan is used, since the goal
|
||
is to get more commuters into Manhattan but not strain the capacity of the
|
||
East River Tunnels. A European feature makes its local debut in those
|
||
cars: jump seats. The ride of the cars is reported to be less than
|
||
satisfactory, though. An unpleasant pitching motion was felt, especially
|
||
on the upper level.
|
||
|
||
Rare Mileage
|
||
|
||
Conversion of a couple of deadhead runs to revenue service now makes it
|
||
possible to ride the LIRR from Hunterspoint Ave., Queens to Long Island
|
||
City, over a little-used branch.
|
||
|
||
Labor Upset Delays Maine Train
|
||
|
||
The start-up of Amtrak service from Boston North Station to Portland, ME
|
||
has been postponed until at least Thanksgiving, and likely longer. Work to
|
||
improve the tracks has been stalled by labor union opposition under a
|
||
provision of Federal law which requires labor union consent before a
|
||
Federally-funded project which would result in a loss of jobs can go ahead.
|
||
Bus workers have claimed they will be hurt by the train service [though at
|
||
least one local experience showed that bus patronage can increase where
|
||
passengers can travel at least one way on a train].
|
||
|
||
Air Connections?
|
||
|
||
New York area air travelers may soon not have to use a car or bus to get to
|
||
the airport. Port Authority officials are eyeing a dedicated ticket tax as
|
||
the means to build a rail line connecting Kennedy and LaGuardia airports
|
||
with midtown Manhattan.
|
||
A grand opening would be many years away though; the mode and route of the
|
||
line has not even been decided. Meanwhile, plans exist to extend Newark
|
||
Airport's monorail (now under construction) to a new station on the
|
||
Northeast Corridor. Neither project will be able to match the convenience
|
||
of SEPTA's R1 Airport Line.
|
||
|
||
Highway Steamroller Stalled in NJ
|
||
|
||
Following intense criticism from community and environmental groups
|
||
(including NJ-ARP), the North Jersey Transportation Advisory Committee
|
||
voted to turn down an I-287 highway widening previously approved by the
|
||
committee. A bus/carpool lane project was substituted. Committee chairman
|
||
Richard DuHaimie, a freeholder of Passaic County, called project opponents
|
||
"obstructionists" for blocking his plans to pave over more and more of
|
||
Somerset County. However, the opponents had both Federal law and NJTPA's
|
||
own technical advisors on their side. Both said that adding more lanes for
|
||
single-occupant cars would worsen, not solve the area's transportation
|
||
problems.
|
||
|
||
Short-term Pain, Long-term Gain
|
||
|
||
Commuter and Amtrak riders will have a harder time finding parking when
|
||
garage construction projects begin this fall both at Metropark and at BWI
|
||
Airport Rail Station.
|
||
|
||
##U DVARP Phone & Voice-mail Directory
|
||
DVARP main number (voice mail line) 215-222-3373
|
||
9 Chuck Bode, President 215-222-3373
|
||
1 Tom Borawski, VP-Transportation 215-552-4198
|
||
<73243.1224@compuserve.com>
|
||
6 Robert H. Machler, VP-Administration 215-222-3373
|
||
5 Sharon Shneyer, VP-Public Relations 215-386-2644
|
||
3 Matthew Mitchell, Newsletter Editor 215-885-7448
|
||
<mmitchell@asrr.arsusda.gov>
|
||
4 Betsey Clark, Volunteer Coordinator 215-222-3373
|
||
8 Mark Sanders, Treasurer 215-222-3373
|
||
2 John Pawson, Commuter RR Comm. 215-659-7736
|
||
(6 to 9 pm please)
|
||
3 Transit Committee 215-222-3373
|
||
7 Don Nigro, South Jersey Committee 609-869-0020
|
||
Dan Radack, Bicycle Coordinator 215-232-6303
|
||
|
||
Media Hotline (digital beeper) 215-552-4198
|
||
Computer e-mail (internet) 73243.1224@compuserve.com
|
||
|
||
|
||
|
||
##V DVARP Membership Coupon
|
||
|
||
Yes, I want to support improved passenger train service in our region!
|
||
|
||
Here are my DVARP membership dues for 1994! 9/94
|
||
|
||
Name
|
||
|
||
Address
|
||
|
||
City, State, Zip
|
||
|
||
Please choose a membership category below, enclose check and mail to:
|
||
|
||
DVARP, PO Box 7505, Philadelphia, PA 19101
|
||
|
||
( ) Regular: $15.00 ( ) Family: $20.00 ( ) Supporting: $25.00 ( )
|
||
Sustaining: $50.00 ( ) Patron: $75.00 ( ) Benefactor: $100.00 ( )
|
||
Introductory-new members only: $10.00 ( ) under 21 or over 65: $7.50
|
||
|
||
##W Upcoming DVARP Meetings:
|
||
|
||
Saturday, September 17, 1:00 to 4:00 Temple University Center City
|
||
1616 Walnut St., Philadelphia. Please see bulletin board in lobby
|
||
for meeting room. Food and drinks prohibited in meeting room.
|
||
|
||
Saturday, October 15, 12:00 to 3:00 Lansdowne Public Library
|
||
**Note change of place and time** Accessible by SEPTA R3 train.
|
||
|
||
Saturday, November 19, 1:00 to 4:00 Collingswood Public Library
|
||
Accessible by PATCO train
|
||
|