1306 lines
64 KiB
Plaintext
1306 lines
64 KiB
Plaintext
The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger
|
|
Electronic Edition
|
|
April 1994
|
|
Vol. XII, No. 4
|
|
ISSN 1073-6859
|
|
|
|
Published by the Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers in the
|
|
interest of continued, improved, and expanded rail service for the present and
|
|
potential railroad and rail transit passengers of southeastern Pennsylvania,
|
|
southern New Jersey, and nearby areas.
|
|
|
|
For more information about DVARP and good rail service, please contact us:
|
|
P.O. Box 7505, Philadelphia, PA 19101
|
|
215-222-3373
|
|
<mmitchell@asrr.arsusda.gov> or <73243.1224@compuserve.com>
|
|
|
|
The electronic edition is produced as a public service to the network community.
|
|
It is archived on the CUNYVM Listserver in the RAILNEWS directory. An index of
|
|
back issues is available by sending INDEX RAILNEWS to LISTSERV@CUNYVM. Thanks
|
|
to Geert K. Marien (GKMQC@CUNYVM) for maintaining this archive! If you have
|
|
comments or questions, please contact us, not Geert!
|
|
The DVRP is also archived on these FTP servers
|
|
wuarchive.wustl.edu, directory graphics/trains/text or graphics/trains/incoming
|
|
hipp.etsu.edu, directory pub/railroad/dvarp (Thanks to Bob Weir)
|
|
Volumes X (1992) and XI (1993) are on floppy disk for $4.00 each from DVARP.
|
|
|
|
We hope you consider joining DVARP; your financial support makes possible
|
|
this newsletter and our many other activities on behalf of rail and transit
|
|
passengers. Annual dues are $15.00. see the coupon below.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##Schedule change alert: Amtrak schedule changes have been postponed to May 1.
|
|
New NJ Transit bus and SEPTA Suburban Transit schedules in effect this month.
|
|
|
|
Contents copyright (C) 1994 DVARP, except photos (C) 1994 credited photographers
|
|
|
|
Opinions expressed in The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger are not necessarily
|
|
those of DVARP or its members. We welcome your comments: call 215-222-3373
|
|
|
|
DVARP President: Chuck Bode Newsletter Editor: Matthew Mitchell
|
|
Production Manager: Tom Borawski
|
|
for other officers and committee chairs, see page 15
|
|
|
|
CONTENTS:
|
|
##A SEPTA 'Springs' Budget on Public: No Fare Increase or Service Cuts
|
|
##B Editorial: What We're Up Against
|
|
##C House Restores Transit Operating $$$
|
|
##D SEPTA: Cynwyd Link is Amtrak's Problem
|
|
##E DVARP Continues to Act on Harrisburg Line
|
|
##F "Try Transit Week" Coming
|
|
##G On the Railroad Lines...
|
|
Fare Sale for Passholders
|
|
New Title is Old Title
|
|
R1--One Less Stop?
|
|
R3--SEPTA Buys Elwyn Land
|
|
R8--Uhh...Turn it On, OK?
|
|
Boom, Boom for More Room
|
|
CTD (Subway-Elevated)--SEPTA-PATCO 'One Way Deal?'
|
|
Construction End in Sight!
|
|
Wanamaker's Door to Reopen
|
|
LRD--Paving Over More Tracks
|
|
More PCCs For Sale
|
|
STD--Schedule Change Preview
|
|
CTD (Surface)--Wheelchair Lift Deal
|
|
##H SEPTA Ridership Stats
|
|
##I Flagstops
|
|
SEPTA to Get Schedule-by-Fax?
|
|
Familiar Faces...New Faces
|
|
New Freight Connection
|
|
##J Seattle Metro: The Solution, Not the Problem
|
|
##K LA: More Service, Less Bureaucracy
|
|
##L Let's Go Talgo
|
|
##M Union Rules Hurt Route 57 Passengers
|
|
##N Commuter Rail Resurges-Elsewhere
|
|
##O Vuchic Proposes Radical Change for RRD: Build It and They Will Come!
|
|
##P "Walk Across the Corridor"
|
|
##Q Rail Service for Moorestown and Burlington County: The Simple Truth
|
|
##R South Jersey Notes, NJT Ridership Report
|
|
##S Federal Investigation: Amtrak Underfunded
|
|
##T Amnotes
|
|
Schedule Change Postponed
|
|
Downs Speaks Out on Service
|
|
##U NARP Looks at Commuter Rail
|
|
##V VIA Facing Another Service Slash
|
|
##W Up and Down the Corridor
|
|
VRE Guarantee
|
|
Rudy Lets Straphangers Down
|
|
MARC Looks to Improve Commuter Environment
|
|
T for Free!
|
|
Mass. to T: Build Ridership
|
|
##X DVARP Details
|
|
NARP Region III Meeting: Time Change
|
|
Circle the Date
|
|
Fair Notices, Volunteers Wanted
|
|
##Y Dates of Interest
|
|
##Z DVARP Phone & Voice-mail Directory
|
|
##AA Upcoming DVARP Meetings:
|
|
Agenda for the April meeting:
|
|
Committee Meetings:
|
|
|
|
|
|
DVARP Membership Coupon
|
|
|
|
Yes, I want to support improved passenger train service in our region!
|
|
Here are my DVARP membership dues for 1994! 4/94
|
|
|
|
Name Membership Number
|
|
|
|
Address
|
|
|
|
City, State, Zip
|
|
|
|
Please choose a membership category below, enclose check and mail to:
|
|
DVARP, PO Box 7505, Philadelphia, PA 19101
|
|
|
|
( ) Regular: $15.00 ( ) Family: $20.00 ( ) Supporting: $25.00
|
|
( ) Sustaining: $50.00 ( ) Patron: $75.00 ( ) Benefactor: $100.00
|
|
( ) under 21 or over 65: $7.50
|
|
|
|
|
|
##A SEPTA 'Springs' Budget Proposal on Public:
|
|
No Fare Increase or Service Cuts by Matthew Mitchell
|
|
|
|
By the time you read this article (unless you got it on the internet), SEPTA
|
|
will have already held the legally-mandated public hearing on its proposed
|
|
Fiscal 1995 operating budget. Legal notice of the budget and the hearing was
|
|
given while the March DVRP was in press, just meeting the legal requirement of
|
|
thirty days notice. The budget itself was made available to the public just two
|
|
weeks before the hearing. Despite the short notice, DVARP is preparing as
|
|
complete testimony as possible. The DVARP statement will endorse SEPTA's basic
|
|
strategy, while offering specfic ways to reduce costs and improve passenger
|
|
service.
|
|
|
|
A look at the proposed FY95 budget shows no surprises. Expenses increase by 5.9
|
|
percent, relieving inflationary pressure after two years of limited spending
|
|
increases. Operating revenue (including senior citizen fares paid by the
|
|
lottery fund) increases 3.0 percent, leaving a 14.4% increase in the amount to
|
|
be financed by state and local governments. The SEPTA bet on increased
|
|
subsidies to balance the budget was widely hinted over the past year.
|
|
|
|
Transit service will be slightly increased, continuing a process of rolling back
|
|
the cuts which cost more than they saved. Fine-tuning of the service also
|
|
continues: with minor route revisions for greater efficiency and selective cuts
|
|
where the service has little benefit. This trend has been strongly supported by
|
|
DVARP.
|
|
|
|
The total budget has also increased as the result of a state-mandated accounting
|
|
change incorporating the Shared-Ride Program (which SEPTA took over in 1993) and
|
|
the Act 26 asset maintenance fund into the Operating Budget. This also makes
|
|
the state share of the budget look larger, even though it doesn't actually
|
|
change any spending.
|
|
|
|
The budget document spells out steps SEPTA took to reduce expenses this year.
|
|
Administrative reductions were targetted to departments which do little in terms
|
|
of real passenger service, instead of the harmful across-the-board furloughs of
|
|
FY 93.
|
|
|
|
SEPTA has ended the practice of holding budget hearings in the four suburban
|
|
counties, replacing them with "public meetings" where we assume comments will be
|
|
taken for entry into the hearing record and SEPTA personnel will answer
|
|
citizens' questions, but now only one formal hearing is to take place, April 11
|
|
in Philadelphia. Attendance in some of the counties has been sparse in some
|
|
years, but only time will tell if the new format can maintain meaningful and
|
|
accessible public input into the decision on how to spend almost 700 million
|
|
dollars of fare and tax money.
|
|
|
|
There was no improvement in the service standards portion of the budget, so
|
|
riders still have little way of determining if added state funding turns into
|
|
better-quality service. However, a major revamp of the state-mandated standards
|
|
and assessment program is to be undertaken this year.
|
|
|
|
Graph of SEPTA spending available in printed edition
|
|
|
|
A copy of the DVARP statement is available. Please send $2.00 to cover printing
|
|
and postage costs.
|
|
|
|
##B From the Editor's Seat: What We're Up Against
|
|
|
|
We got a letter at DVARP last month from the Pennsylvania Highway Information
|
|
Association-the road-building lobby. The letter, on stationery with the tag
|
|
line "user fees not taxes build roads," disputes stories in the DVRP which
|
|
describe subsidies from general tax revenues to road construction and operation
|
|
of private cars and trucks. I stand by our reporting.
|
|
|
|
PHIA ignores huge chunks of the cost of our highway system, but perhaps they can
|
|
be forgiven because they're involved mostly in the construction of roads. They
|
|
must not get township contracts for salt and plows, or provide care to people
|
|
with lung disease.
|
|
|
|
One fact is that a lot of the subsidy to drivers is at the local level: does
|
|
your township levy a gas tax to pay for plowing snow, patching potholes, and
|
|
electricity for streetlights? What about the property taxes which could be
|
|
collected if land consumed by roads were available for private use?
|
|
|
|
An even bigger cost is paid by the general public in indirect costs like
|
|
accident and environmental costs. It's that part of the true cost of driving
|
|
(which I'll readily admit is hard to pin a firm number on) on which Professor
|
|
Pucher of Rutgers bases his arguement that highway users are subsidized ten
|
|
times more than transit users.
|
|
|
|
We want the public and its elected and appointed officials to understand that
|
|
all transportation is subsidized, and that anyone who denies such is either
|
|
terribly ignorant or attempting to deceive us. That's why we're starting an
|
|
occasional series of articles in this newsletter called "The Hidden Subsidies."
|
|
Look for it in coming months.-MDM
|
|
|
|
|
|
##C House Restores Transit Operating $$$
|
|
|
|
The Federal FY 1995 budget passed by the House of Representatives last month
|
|
restores $202 million cut from Federal support of public transit operations.
|
|
(cover story-February DVRP) Operating assistance would remain at this year's
|
|
level of $802 million. However, this increase in operating funds would come at
|
|
the expense of an equal cut in capital support. The total transit budget of $4.6
|
|
billion is still half a billion dollars short of the level authorized under the
|
|
ISTEA legislation.-MDM
|
|
|
|
|
|
##D SEPTA: Cynwyd Link is Amtrak's Problem
|
|
|
|
Responding to an urgent DVARP letter about the deteriorating 'flyover'
|
|
connecting the SEPTA R6 Cynwyd line to the Amtrak Harrisburg main line, (cover
|
|
story-March DVRP), SEPTA AGM for Program Analysis Carol Lavoritano has says that
|
|
SEPTA and Amtrak are "reviewing all possible service scenarios along the R-5
|
|
line in the area of the new Overbrook Shop."
|
|
|
|
The undated letter, which arrived while last month's newsletter was at the
|
|
printer, described the present situation, then stated SEPTA's position. It says
|
|
that Amtrak is obliged by law to provide "the type and level of services"
|
|
provided when SEPTA took over the RRD in 1983.
|
|
|
|
A deal selling out the Cynwyd Line for unspecified concessions elsewhere by
|
|
Amtrak is not ruled out. An ominous sentence gives more credence to the
|
|
possibility that SEPTA may let the Cynwyd Line go: "...all decisions must be
|
|
made in the context of available funding and the prioritized needs of all SEPTA
|
|
facilities." [emphasis added]-MDM
|
|
|
|
|
|
##E DVARP Continues to Act on Harrisburg Line
|
|
|
|
With funding and service set to run out in July, DVARP continues to work for a
|
|
permanent solution to the problem of supporting and operating the Philadelphia-
|
|
Harrisburg local train service, now running with temporary PennDOT funding. A
|
|
hearing on the service is to be held by the State Legislature on April 13.
|
|
DVARP has already drafted a statement to be presented at the hearing. It
|
|
reiterates the DVARP recommendation for better coordiation of the service so
|
|
that passengers will have to deal with two different operators with different
|
|
tickets and schedules which do not complement each other.
|
|
|
|
DVARP is also asking for investment in the Harrisburg Line infrastructure, to
|
|
catch up with deferred maintenance and increase train speeds, especially betwene
|
|
Paoli and Lancaster, where the tracks are most worn out. Unlike other states
|
|
which are taking an active part in expanding and improving train service, it
|
|
took the threat of a shutdown to get action from Pennsylvania, which seems to
|
|
have a hard time recognizing the value of cleaner air, less-crowded highways,
|
|
and more mobility for senior citizens and others who can not or do not wish to
|
|
drive.-MDM
|
|
|
|
For a copy of the April 13 statement, send $1.00 for printing and postage to
|
|
DVARP.
|
|
|
|
##F "Try Transit Week" Coming
|
|
|
|
May 16-20 will be the dates of "Try Transit Week," sponsored by the American
|
|
Public Transit Association and local transit operators. Special marketing and
|
|
communication efforts will be made to make Americans more aware of how public
|
|
transit makes their lives and communities better. SEPTA may join in the
|
|
nationwide campaign for the first time this year; it held its first "Try
|
|
Transit" event last November. NJ Transit and PATCO are expected to participate
|
|
as before.
|
|
|
|
You should participate too! This month, find out who is responsible for
|
|
commuter arrangements at your work place or in your city or town. Then ask them
|
|
to get involved in "Try Transit Week" by thinking of transit as the normal way
|
|
to get around the Delaware Valley and by giving people incentives to leave their
|
|
cars at home. One good thing to do is to sign people up for a pledge to ride
|
|
transit and see how convenient it can be.
|
|
|
|
It's also a good time to ask your employer to join the Transitchek program.
|
|
Employers who don't think twice about spending thousands and thousands of
|
|
dollars subsidizing their employees' car habits suddenly get stingy when it
|
|
comes to picking up the tab for bus and rail commuters. You can make the
|
|
'bottom line argument'; when you think about all the costs of having someone
|
|
drive to work, it's cheaper to buy that person a Transitchek!-MDM
|
|
|
|
##G On the Railroad Lines...
|
|
|
|
Fare Sale for Passholders
|
|
|
|
For the month of April, SEPTA is offering free weekend travel on the entire
|
|
SEPTA system to all persons with a TransPass or TrailPass. Not only that, you
|
|
can bring a companion along for free. It's a good way for SEPTA to thank its
|
|
most loyal customers and for you to enjoy the colors of spring.
|
|
|
|
New Title is Old Title
|
|
|
|
The job title of "Passenger Attendant" has been changed by SEPTA RRD back to
|
|
"Assistant Conductor." SEPTA broke with most other railroads in 1983, changing
|
|
the title to reflect the fewer responsibilities and lower pay of those crew
|
|
members.
|
|
|
|
##R1--One Less Stop?
|
|
|
|
SEPTA has stopped issuing written orders to trains at Wayne Tower except under
|
|
special circumstances. As reported here last month, orders are now issued at
|
|
30th Street to trains in both directions. But trains are still stopping,
|
|
sometimes twice, for loading and unloading of deadheading employees who are
|
|
selfish enough to delay a trainload of people so they don't have to walk the few
|
|
steps from Wayne Junction.
|
|
|
|
##R3--SEPTA Buys Elwyn Land
|
|
|
|
SEPTA has purchased a 4.5 acre parcel from the Elwyn Institute to expand parking
|
|
at the Elwyn station.
|
|
|
|
##R8--Uhh...Turn it On, OK?
|
|
|
|
Orders were issued recently to place the cab signal system into service on the
|
|
Chestnut Hill West line. The system was installed a long time ago, but left
|
|
unused until SEPTA Deputy GM Howard Roberts asked Railroad management why the
|
|
expensive system wasn't in use. The cab signals can speed up trips on the
|
|
Chestnut Hill line by informing engineers of clear track ahead sooner than
|
|
lineside signals do.
|
|
|
|
Boom, Boom for More Room
|
|
|
|
Conrail's Flat Rock Tunnel, alongside the Schuylkill Expressway in Lower Merion,
|
|
is being enlarged to allow double-stack container cars and other large freight
|
|
cars to move to the Port of Philadelphia via Conrail's Harrisburg Line. The
|
|
blasting is part of a state-wide project to increase clearances, funded by
|
|
Conrail, CP Rail System, and the Commonwealth.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
##CTD (Subway-Elevated)--SEPTA-PATCO 'One Way Deal?'
|
|
|
|
Philadelphia residents are losing out on the special discounted fare for trips
|
|
combining SEPTA and PATCO services. SEPTA has stopped selling its return-trip
|
|
ticket, for reasons unknown, while PATCO's machines just keep going and going...
|
|
DVARP's Transit Committee is investigating.
|
|
|
|
Construction End in Sight!
|
|
|
|
SEPTA's latest "Makin' Tracks" newsletter reports that the final stages of
|
|
redecking the Frankford El will get underway by a year from no, and that all
|
|
work in the Priority Element Program will be completed by 1997, in time for the
|
|
arrival of new trains. Rebuilding of stations will also be finished by then,
|
|
except for Frankford Terminal, which is still at the design stage (see March
|
|
DVRP)
|
|
|
|
DIAGRAM: schematic map of Frankford El, showing completed sections of redecking,
|
|
sections under construction now, & sections where construction starts later.
|
|
courtesy Frankford El Reconstruction Project
|
|
|
|
Wanamaker's Door to Reopen
|
|
|
|
Brickstone Realty, manager of the Wanamaker Building, and SEPTA are working to
|
|
reopen the subway concourse entrance to the building. When ready this fall, the
|
|
passage will lead into a basement parking level, where escalators to the store
|
|
and elevators to the offices in the building will be available. The stairs from
|
|
Market St. to the 13th St./Juniper subway station are also expected to reopen at
|
|
that time.
|
|
|
|
##LRD--Paving Over More Tracks
|
|
|
|
In last month's Board meeting, SEPTA approved spending half a million dollars
|
|
for paving and pothole repairs to streets with SEPTA tracks which are also
|
|
designated as state highways (e.g. Broad St./PA 611) Included in this contract
|
|
is "overlay of inactive tracked state highways." As specified in the three-way
|
|
deal struck several years ago, SEPTA, the City of Philadelphia, and the state
|
|
will split the cost of the contract evenly.
|
|
|
|
More PCCs For Sale
|
|
|
|
SEPTA continues to get rid of its PCC streetcars. A sealed-bid auction will be
|
|
held for another batch; and sources say that Cleveland is the latest city to
|
|
look at the SEPTA PCCs as an inexpensive, attractive, and ready-to-run transit
|
|
solution. The expected price of the SEPTA cars is one-one-hundredth (yes,
|
|
1/100) of the price of a new high-tech LRV. Even with a full overhaul, the PCCs
|
|
are less expensive.
|
|
|
|
We said it when San Francisco bought SEPTA PCCs and we'll say it again: what do
|
|
they know that SEPTA doesn't?
|
|
|
|
##STD--Schedule Change Preview
|
|
|
|
Red Arrow schedules will be revised April 10. Details of the changes have been
|
|
included in SEPTA's internet file. The biggest changes are a new Route 117
|
|
schedule, serving the West Goshen Shopping Center and the addition of Sunday
|
|
service on Route 110. Route 119 Saturday service from Elwyn to Painter's
|
|
Crossing is to be eliminated. Route 113 will be extended to 2nd and Green Sts.
|
|
in Marcus Hook. Also in southern DelCo, Route 109 will add more Saturday
|
|
service from Springfield Mall to Chester; minor schedule changes take place on
|
|
the 114 and 115. Additional weekday trips were added to Routes 104, 108, 112,
|
|
and 120. With new cars continuing to arrive, SEPTA has restored Sunday Route
|
|
100 service to three trips an hour,
|
|
|
|
On the Frontier Division, schedules will change May 1, bringing good news and
|
|
bad news. Most of the bad news comes in the form of slower schedules:
|
|
specifically on Routes 92 and 99. The good news is major increases in 96 and 98
|
|
service; the 96 will see half-hourly base headways between Norristown and
|
|
Lansdale, plus longer Saturday hours, while the 98 will run on a half-hour
|
|
frequency from Norristown to Plymouth Meeting Mall. Special 95 service to the
|
|
Inquirer building in Gulph Mills has been dropped. Minor changes will be seen
|
|
on the 94 and 97.
|
|
|
|
##CTD (Surface)--Wheelchair Lift Deal
|
|
|
|
SEPTA settled a Federal lawsuit brought by advocates for the disabled who
|
|
alleged that SEPTA failed to maintain the wheelchair lifts on its buses, and in
|
|
some cases refused to use the lifts when they were working. The agreement calls
|
|
for SEPTA to take further steps to ensure compliance with Federal mandates on
|
|
wheelchair-access. The plaintiffs say that SEPTA drivers made up excuses to
|
|
avoid picking up passengers in wheelchairs. (In practice, a pickup or drop-off
|
|
takes about three minutes start to finish)
|
|
|
|
##H SEPTA Ridership Stats
|
|
|
|
Six-month data shows continued declines in SEPTA City Transit bus ridership,
|
|
which couldn't be offset by improved showings on the Subway or Regional Rail
|
|
Divisions. Senior citizen ridership fell systemwide.
|
|
|
|
ridership (000s) change
|
|
Surface (bus) 52,834 -5.3%
|
|
Subway-Elevated 26,618 +2.7%
|
|
Light Rail 4,806 -1.5%
|
|
City Trans. total 84,258 -2.4%
|
|
Red Arrow 6,213 -3.0%
|
|
Frontier 1,041 -4.3%
|
|
Suburban Total 7,254 -3.2%
|
|
RRD Total 9,536 +3.0%
|
|
SEPTA Total 101,048 -2.2%
|
|
|
|
RRD Weekday Ridership by Line: December 93 vs. December 92
|
|
R1 Airport 1,964 +11.1%
|
|
R2 Wilmington 5,791 -8.1%
|
|
R3 Elwyn 8,143 +3.0%
|
|
R5 Paoli 19,869 +4.1%
|
|
R6 Cynwyd 207 -31.7%
|
|
R7 Trenton 8,000 -5.4%
|
|
R8 C.H. West 5,192 +17.5%
|
|
PRR total 49,166
|
|
R2 Warminster 5,150 +17.7%
|
|
R3 West Trenton 6,332 +9.8%
|
|
R5 Doylestown 9,327 -1.4%
|
|
R6 Norristown 3,345 +25.6%
|
|
R7 C.H. East 3,833 +3.5%
|
|
R8 Fox Chase 3,416 +14.4%
|
|
RDG total 31,403
|
|
RRD total 80,569 +4.4%
|
|
|
|
|
|
##I Flagstops
|
|
|
|
SEPTA to Get Schedule-by-Fax?
|
|
|
|
Bids have been sought by SEPTA for a "Multichannel, multihost fax server" which
|
|
to this cyberspace surfer sounds like a 'schedule-by-fax' machine. Once SEPTA
|
|
obtains and installs this device, you will be able to phone SEPTA, enter your
|
|
fax number and the schedule you want, and have a SEPTA schedule in a matter of
|
|
minutes.
|
|
|
|
As the cost of this kind of technology continues to decline and power increases,
|
|
more and more transit operators are finding new ways to communicate with their
|
|
customers. SEPTA was first to put schedules on the internet, while NJ Transit
|
|
has had schedule-by-fax for a year now, and MARC offers a complete voice-mail
|
|
system with schedules and other information for all stations.
|
|
|
|
Familiar Faces...
|
|
|
|
Former SEPTA Board and Federal Transit Administrator Brian Clymer has been named
|
|
as NJ Governor Christine Todd Whitman's State Treasurer, while Frank Wilson
|
|
(former SEPTA AGM) will be Whitman's Transportation Commissioner. Former City
|
|
of Philadelphia Finance Director Betsy Reveal has taken the job of VP for
|
|
Finance and Administration at Amtrak.
|
|
|
|
...New Faces
|
|
|
|
Maurice Cannon is the new head of the Delaware Railroad Administration.
|
|
|
|
New Freight Connection
|
|
|
|
Conrail's new Engleside Connection means less interference between freight and
|
|
passenger trains in the congested Zoo area. The track, visible on the south
|
|
side of the Northeast Corridor between the Schuylkill and North Philadelphia,
|
|
makes a direct link between Conrail's Trenton Line on the east shore of the
|
|
Schuylkill and the '0 track' which is Conrail's dedicated piece of the Corridor
|
|
from the river to the Delair Bridge.
|
|
|
|
With the new connection, trains from Harrisburg and beyond cross the Columbia
|
|
Bridge and pull up the hill to North Philadelphia instead of going onto the West
|
|
Philadelphia 'High Line' for a time-consuming runaround move across Zoo
|
|
interlocking.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##J Seattle Metro: The Solution, Not the Problem
|
|
|
|
Gary Locke, County Executive of King County, Washington, struck a blow against
|
|
misguided regulators by unveiling a plan to scrap King County Metro's plan to
|
|
spend 96 million dollars converting its bus fleet to natural gas power. Big
|
|
vehicle fleets like those of public transit operators have long been targetted
|
|
for special antipollution mandates instead of the millions of individually-owned
|
|
cars that cause most of the problem. Locke recognized that the best thing he
|
|
can do for environmental quality in the Puget Sound area is to get more people
|
|
to ride public transit: "Natural gas will not get people out of their cars...
|
|
more convenient bus service will." Locke added that switching to gas requires
|
|
expensive new facilities, and adds to operating costs.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##K LA: More Service, Less Bureaucracy
|
|
|
|
Ridership on Metrolink commuter rail in the Los Angeles area is down some from
|
|
the post-earthquake high, but still far greater than anyone had anticipated just
|
|
four months ago. Another new station opened up just two months after the quake.
|
|
(The first stations took only a week to open!) Another line was extended last
|
|
month; while the track is not in optimum shape, service came first-repair crews
|
|
are working to boost train speeds. Railcars are being leased from GO Transit in
|
|
Ontario, they were delivered in just a few weeks: not years.
|
|
|
|
That ability to start service quickly, without hundreds of millions of dollars
|
|
of make-work projects, it the great advantage of commuter rail. That is, if
|
|
transit agencies can think more about providing service to the public than about
|
|
providing contracts to construction companies and engineers. Almost makes one
|
|
wish an earthquake would strike the Delaware Valley...
|
|
|
|
|
|
##CREDITS
|
|
News compiled by Matthew Mitchell and correspondents: Chuck Bode, Howard Bender,
|
|
Tom Borawski, John Hay, James Morgan, Bill Mulloy, Don Nigro, John Pawson.
|
|
|
|
Additional news from BITNET, Conrail Newswire, Delmarva RPA, mass. transit, NARP
|
|
News, Passenger Transport, Pro-Rail Nebraska, USENET, Washington Post.
|
|
|
|
Special thanks to John McGee, Thomas Nuxoll and Alan Wickersham of SEPTA, and
|
|
Alan Tillotson of NJT.
|
|
|
|
The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger is a charter member of the Rail Online
|
|
Newswire.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##L Let's Go Talgo by Chuck Bode and Matthew Mitchell
|
|
|
|
The State of Washington is not waiting for a special Federal appropriation,
|
|
Amtrak investment, or outside mandates to improve its corridor train service: it
|
|
has arranged and funded a demonstration service of the Spanish Talgo train
|
|
between Seattle and Portland, Oregon, to supplement the existing Amtrak service
|
|
in this corridor. (Wow, a progressive state promoting an alternative to
|
|
highways and two states cooperating on cross border trains-must not be the same
|
|
country the Delaware Valley is in.)
|
|
|
|
On its way to the Pacific Northwest, the Talgo visited 30th Street March 12 and
|
|
14. Unlike the X2000 and ICE trains, the locomotive remained in Spain. Amtrak
|
|
engines are hauling the train.
|
|
|
|
PHOTO: Talgo approaching Walnut St. March 12. Notice the difference in height
|
|
between the Amtrak engine and Talgo cars. photos: Chuck Bode
|
|
|
|
Talgo was invented in Spain during the 1940s: the Spanish acronym means "light
|
|
articulated train." The basic idea is a low, light-weight train of short cars
|
|
with only one axle each. The front of each car is supported by the car ahead;
|
|
the single axle is at the rear of each car. Talgo was one of the first 'tilt
|
|
trains.' Unlike the X2000, the Talgo tilt system is passive, like a pendulum,
|
|
rather than active, with hydraulic systems tilting the train.
|
|
|
|
Several attempts to build a successful Talgo for service in the United States
|
|
were made during the 1950s. General Motors built three trains, using components
|
|
from their buses. The Pennsylvania RR briefly operated some of the GM trains on
|
|
Pittsburgh-Philadelphia service. None were successful, though several remained
|
|
in use as commuter trains on the Rock Island and Boston & Maine railroads until
|
|
the mid 60s. Complaints centered around the rough ride of the light-weight cars
|
|
on American track. The railroads were also unable to adjust the fixed formation
|
|
Talgo to accomodate changes in passenger demand.
|
|
|
|
photo: The single axle, low-level design.
|
|
|
|
In Spain, however, more effort was put into making Talgo successful. Several
|
|
generations have been produced, including trains with sleeping cars. Some have
|
|
adjustable wheel and axle sets that change gauge as the train croses from
|
|
Spain's broad gauge track to France's standard track-enabling thru service from
|
|
Spain to France and Germany.
|
|
|
|
We look forward to reports of the train's operation. Hopefully, the newest
|
|
Talgo has overcome previous problems. A lightweight, low cost train could
|
|
improve the economics of passenger train operation.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##M Union Rules Hurt Route 57 Passengers
|
|
|
|
About a year ago, SEPTA reorganized and consolidated several bus routes. The 50
|
|
was abandoned, with a vastly changed Route 57 expected to carry the load in
|
|
South Philadelphia. But the length of 57 made it hard to tailor service levels
|
|
to passenger demand. Since the reorganization, DVARP has heard from several
|
|
would-be passengers who could not even get on the overcrowded buses.
|
|
|
|
Upon investigation, we discovered deadheading buses nearby that could easily end
|
|
the overcrowding. However, the deadheading buses were from Southern Depot,
|
|
while Route 57 was from Luzerne. The TWU insists that drivers from one depot
|
|
not run routes of another depot. So empty buses roll by while passengers can't
|
|
get home.
|
|
|
|
The February schedule change finally has two trippers from Market St. to Oregon
|
|
Ave.-but not with the Southern Depot buses. We urge the TWU to be more
|
|
flexible. Increased SEPTA costs followed by increased fares followed by
|
|
decreased ridership is not the route to job security.-CB
|
|
|
|
|
|
##N Commuter Rail Resurges-Elsewhere by John Pawson
|
|
|
|
Commuter trains are moving ahead all over the United States. Decades ago, there
|
|
were only six major central business districts to which large numbers of trains
|
|
carried many thousands of seated commuters-Boston, New York City, Newark,
|
|
Philadelphia, Chicago, and San Francisco. A handful of minor commuter
|
|
operations existed in other Northeast and Midwest centers. By 1955, it appeared
|
|
that the commuter train, by then a somewhat specialized and upscale mass
|
|
transportation activity, would roll on to oblivion.
|
|
|
|
Transportaton writer and Indiana University professor George Smerk cited three
|
|
causes for the near-demise of commuter service, as stated in the landmark "Doyle
|
|
Report" of 1961:
|
|
|
|
1. Fundamental changes in habits and tastes. The automobile, the television,
|
|
and the growing self-sufficiency of the suburban area all had effects on travel
|
|
demand, tending most notable to reduce off-peak travel by train.
|
|
|
|
2. Keener competition for the railroads' freight traffic. They responded by
|
|
trimming or eliminating (where regulators allowed) money-losing services such as
|
|
commuter trains.
|
|
|
|
3. Long-term worsening of the price-cost relationship of the trains. Work rules
|
|
were fixed; and post-World War II prosperity led to a rapid rise in railroad
|
|
wages, faster than the regulators-or even the marketplace-would allow fare
|
|
levels to follow. Whenever the companies were able to win concessions from the
|
|
unions, they were in freight operations, not passenger.
|
|
|
|
The railroads induced Congress to write clauses facilitating abandonment of
|
|
passenger trains into the Transportation Act of 1958. As a result, several
|
|
important lines collapsed, most notably the [New York Central] West Shore
|
|
service in New Jersey. To this there were two distinct reactions:
|
|
|
|
1) A Chicago railroad (eventually followed by other Chicago roads and San
|
|
Francisco) sought to make commuter trains profitable by large-scale investment
|
|
in new technologies and methods. Its operation became profitable for a decade
|
|
until the price/cost trend caught up once again.
|
|
|
|
2) By contrast the East Coast political establishments chose to subsidize the
|
|
commuter train operations. The initial effort failed in six months, terminating
|
|
Boston's Old Colony [south shore, ex-New Haven] services.
|
|
|
|
The second subsidy effort, in Philadelphia, succeeded; and by the mid-1960's,
|
|
all of the area's inner commuter services were supported by public money. The
|
|
region's bus and subway operators, however, viewed the campaign as "unfair
|
|
subsidized competition." A strong slant against commuter rail infected their
|
|
senior officials. When SEPTA acquired these companies and their employees, the
|
|
antipathy for commuters and commuter rail service took hold among some employees
|
|
in the new agency.
|
|
|
|
By the 1980s, the declining fortunes of the railroads had forced a drastic
|
|
reduction in the numbers of their employees, and thus in their political clout.
|
|
Also by this time, the long post-World War II wage spiral had moderated.
|
|
Observers were shocked when the fireman on diesel commuter trains, long mandated
|
|
for 'safety,' was legislated out of existence by Congress.
|
|
|
|
For the first time, labor costs on diesel powered commuter trains could equal
|
|
those of the fireman-less multiple-unit electric commuter trains. Electrified
|
|
lines were expensive to build and maintain, and could be justified only by heavy
|
|
traffic. Outside the conservative East, the understanding came that where a
|
|
good rail freight system through the suburbs existed, starting a low-density
|
|
commuter rail system at relatively low per-mile cost was now feasible.
|
|
|
|
Previously, several metropolitan areas had built very expensive heavy rapid
|
|
transit lines into the suburbs, followed by nearly-as expensive light rail
|
|
transit lines. However, they had encountered their natural economic,
|
|
demographic, and political confines before reaching all the suburbs. Every
|
|
metro area which has opened a rapid transit or light rail system, now enjoys, or
|
|
plans to open a commuter rail line or system. In one case (BART), it's the
|
|
rapid transit operator itself making such studies, as a way of reducing the cost
|
|
of expanding rail service.
|
|
|
|
So today commuter rail is more vibrant and widespread than in 1955. Few know
|
|
this fact because the commuter rail community doesn't toot its horn as well as
|
|
the rail transit community does. There are now 13 commuter rail operations in
|
|
this country which run 83 lines leading to over a dozen central business
|
|
districts, with about 1020 stations in 14 states. A fourteenth operation is
|
|
expected to begin late this year, between Oceanside, California and San Diego.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##O Vuchic Proposes Radical Change for RRD:
|
|
Build It and They Will Come! by Matthew Mitchell
|
|
|
|
In a consultant study done for SEPTA, transit experts Vukan Vuchic and Shinya
|
|
Kikuchi suggest that the way to rebuild the ridership of the Regional Rail
|
|
system is to convert it from a commuter rail operation to "regional metrorail"
|
|
not unlike PATCO or the Washington Metro.
|
|
|
|
The two scholars (Vuchic from the University of Pennsylvania, Kikuchi from
|
|
Delaware) have been influential on the operation in the past: their "General
|
|
Operations Plan for the SEPTA Regional Rail System" was the model followed when
|
|
SEPTA united the ex-Pennsylvania and Reading systems with the Center City
|
|
tunnel. Some planners within SEPTA and in City government find the metrorail
|
|
model attractive; the plan has sparked much discussion there and within DVARP
|
|
too.
|
|
|
|
But in the zeal to promote what might be a better idea, does the report
|
|
sacrifice objectivity? There are oversights in the report, and questions which
|
|
must be answered before hundreds of millions of dollars are invested in the
|
|
"metrorail" concept.
|
|
|
|
The logic of the study goes as follows: improvements in the frequency of train
|
|
service will make the railroad more convenient for potential users, leading to a
|
|
major increase in off-peak ridership. In order to pay for the increased
|
|
service, SEPTA has to reduce the cost of running each train by reducing crews to
|
|
two or even one person.
|
|
|
|
One-man operation will not be safe or feasible without installation of high
|
|
platforms at RRD stations and purchase of cars similar to PATCO's or those on
|
|
the New York MTA lines, says the report. If the cost of these improvements can
|
|
be kept reasonable, the return on capital investment is reasonable; they might
|
|
even pay for themselves in increased ridership and revenue.
|
|
|
|
The report starts with an evaluation of the state of the railroad today:
|
|
"The RGR [Regional Rail System] is presently an underfinanced, underperforming
|
|
and therefore, greatly underutilized Philadelphia Region's [sic] resource.
|
|
This condition has created an urgent need for a careful evaluation and
|
|
planning of actions that would stop and reverse the downward train.
|
|
|
|
The basic facts are identified: a dense network with closely-spaced stations,
|
|
dominance of peak-hour riders, and a history of service abandonments and
|
|
ridership losses. Reading between the lines, one finds criticism of RRD
|
|
management:
|
|
"...maintenance and reconstruction projects were carried out without adequate
|
|
protection for service reliability.
|
|
...While each of these [improvement] measures has been useful, their
|
|
introduction has often been done without coordination with other elements
|
|
which has prevented achievement of the maximum effectiveness of each
|
|
investment.
|
|
|
|
Take for example ticket vending machines; they should have reduced the expense
|
|
of collecting fares on board the trains, but SEPTA did not reduce the number of
|
|
crew members on its trains. When maintenance is figured in, the machines likely
|
|
cost SEPTA more than they save.
|
|
|
|
Land use and transportation policy decisions at all levels of government also
|
|
are criticized. And Vuchic and Kikuchi bring up a heretofore underrecognized
|
|
culprit: Federal regulations which combine steam railroad operating rules with
|
|
mandates for foolproof high-tech safety devices, forcing high spending to
|
|
comply, but little real safety benefit.
|
|
|
|
The bulk of the report discusses the technical aspects of high-platform
|
|
operation with reduced crews, including a lengthy treatise on platform height
|
|
alternatives. A good case is made for high platforms, and suggestions for
|
|
minimizing their cost are given, but Vuchic and Kicuchi forsee an idealized
|
|
world where real-world constraints like limited right-of-way don't interfere.
|
|
They do make a good argument for building the platforms, though: SEPTA will have
|
|
to do it sooner or later to comply with Federal wheelchair-access rules.
|
|
|
|
The biggest problem with the 'metrorail' study is that it pays far too little
|
|
attention to the peak-hour riders who make up the bulk of commuter rail users.
|
|
The thoroughness of the platform-height analysis doesn't carry over to ridership
|
|
studies.
|
|
|
|
The second real problem is that Vuchic and Kikuchi assume on-board crew wages
|
|
make up the bulk of RRD costs. That just isn't the case; a lot of RRD people
|
|
work behind the scenes. So this report will spur talk about 'transitization,'
|
|
but it also gives ammunition to its opponents.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##P "I Walked Across the Corridor" by James S. Morgan
|
|
|
|
Ten o'clock Sunday morning, January 16, found me waiting at Market East Station
|
|
for the R5 Paoli local to join a friend for a day of railfanning. A train
|
|
pulled up on Track 4, but it bore no markings as to train number or final
|
|
destination. The loudspeaker announced that the R5 Paoli local was boarding on
|
|
Track 4 and I hopped on. The stops at Suburban Station and 30th Street were
|
|
announced, but nothing was said by any of the crew about the final destination.
|
|
|
|
I noticed that the train was passing the Philadelphia Zoo, and this struck me as
|
|
odd, but when the train crossed a frozen Schuylkill, I went up to the cab and
|
|
asked where the train was going. I had boarded the R7 to Trenton! Apparently
|
|
the R7 departs two minutes earlier on the same track. Then, and only then, the
|
|
crew began announcing that the train was the R7 bound for Trenton.
|
|
|
|
I was put off at North Philadelphia. The conductor simply pointed to the
|
|
stairwell and told me to use the stairs and not cross the tracks. I was told
|
|
that an R7 back to 30th Street would be along in ten minutes. Both stairwells
|
|
appeared boarded up. I could not open anything at the southern stairwell, so I
|
|
went to the northern stairwell. It likewise was boarded up, but the boards were
|
|
knocked out of two of the windows, permitting access to the stairs. The passage
|
|
at the bottom of the stairs was boarded up.
|
|
|
|
I was desperate. The station platform was an island in a sea of tracks on the
|
|
high-speed Northeast Corridor. An Amtrak train passed through, and I tried to
|
|
signal my plight to the engineer. Finally, I saw a figure in Amtrak's North
|
|
Philadelphia Tower. I succeeded in gaining his attention. He said that if I
|
|
could not use the stairs, I would have to cross the tracks to get to the
|
|
southbound platform. I protested that such a crossing would be illegal and
|
|
dangerous. He checked his schedule and told me that I had two minutes before
|
|
the next train. He told me to walk out to the end of the platform, descend the
|
|
wooden stairs and cross fast.
|
|
|
|
The area around the stairwells was clear of ice, but to reach the end of the
|
|
platform, I had to step over an orange barricade fence, then walk across a long
|
|
stretch of glare ice. I reached the other side just as the southbound R7
|
|
arrived. I had to walk up against another barricade fence to board the train.
|
|
|
|
The conductor on the southbound R7 was very helpful and pointed out the correct
|
|
track for the R5 when the train stopped at 30th Street. He remarked that he had
|
|
only to look at my face to tell what happened. By his own admission, passengers
|
|
are regularly put off at North Philadelphia because of confusion between the R7
|
|
and the R5.
|
|
|
|
I detailed these events on a Service Guarantee claim form while I was waiting
|
|
for the R5, and made two suggestions to avoid a repetition of this type of
|
|
incident-that the end destinations as well as individual stops of SEPTA trains
|
|
should be announced on board by train crews, and that North Philadelphia Station
|
|
should be fixed up.
|
|
|
|
I called Amtrak and DVARP. On DVARP's advice, I wrote a letter to all the
|
|
parties involved, explaining that day's events.
|
|
|
|
Kevin Dant of Amtrak called me twice on January 24, 1994. In the first call, he
|
|
noted that he had called SEPTA, which said that it would rectify the
|
|
announcement problems. In the second call, he said he had called the station
|
|
operator at North Philadelphia. The operator had walked out and tested the door
|
|
on the southernmost stairwell, and the door was working. It was not clear why I
|
|
failed to open it. He noted, of course, that the door is not labelled, and
|
|
without knob or handle, it looks as though the entrance is boarded over. Dant
|
|
said that he would recommend that signs be posted to direct passengers to the
|
|
door. How long they will last with all the vandalism I do not know.
|
|
|
|
Amtrak confirmed in a written response February 24 that Federal budgetary
|
|
constraints do not permit repair of the North Philadelphia Station. Both Amtrak
|
|
in this letter and the Federal Transit Authority in its letter of February 15
|
|
stated that SEPTA should respond to me on the problem of train announcements.
|
|
|
|
SEPTA also sent me a response to my Service Guarantee claim dated February 16,
|
|
1994. The Service Guarantee Monitor stated that I was not eligible for a refund
|
|
(which I didn't ask for) because the incidents of which I complained occurred on
|
|
a weekend.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##Q Rail Service for Moorestown and Burlington County: The Simple Truth
|
|
|
|
A letter published in the NEWSWeekly of Burlington County in response to letters
|
|
opposing passenger trains though Moorestown:
|
|
|
|
To The Editor:
|
|
|
|
I am writing in response to the concerns that have been put forward by some
|
|
individuals in the past two weeks regarding passenger rail service for
|
|
Moorestown and greater Burlington County, in particular Jane Wiltshire's
|
|
February 10 letter to the editor and some remarks made at the February 17
|
|
meeting held in Moorestown.
|
|
|
|
At the meeting, local rail opponents expressed to government officials their
|
|
opposition to the use of the existing rail right-of-way needed by residents of
|
|
Moorestown and other Burlington County communities east and north of Moorestown.
|
|
Two alternatives to the use of existing rail right-of-way were discussed. The
|
|
first uses the Interstate 295 corridor connecting with the Lindenwold Line at
|
|
Woodcrest. The second uses the existing rail right-of-way but avoids downtown
|
|
Moorestown and instead cuts over to the Moorestown Mall via the North Branch
|
|
Pennsauken Creek. The line would be built on concrete pilings and would cross
|
|
above Main St. Both of these rail alternatives to avoid downtown Moorestown are
|
|
circuitous and clearly infeasible.
|
|
|
|
The April 1993 study shows that constructing a rail line in the medial strip of
|
|
Interstate-295 would cost 6% more and draw 42% fewer riders. This alternative
|
|
does not adequately serve anyone. Communities such as Maple Shade, Pennsauken
|
|
and Delran are abandoned, those who live in other parts of Burlington County are
|
|
offered only a grossly circuitous routing to Philadelphia. Their travel path is
|
|
an 'L' shape. It is the aviational equivalent of flying to Washington D.C. with
|
|
a stop-over in Pittsburgh. Moreover, high speed travel is already available on
|
|
I-295 with the use of the automobile. Many people will just continue to drive
|
|
down I-295 to catch a train at the Woodcrest Station. All of these factors
|
|
indirectly result in the dismally low computer model ridership projection of 42%
|
|
fewer riders for the I-295 alternative, thereby confirming what had been
|
|
intuitively obvious to transportation professionals.
|
|
|
|
The second alternative which uses the North Branch Pennsauken Creek would draw
|
|
slightly fewer passengers and cost 57% more, an additional $333 million. Both
|
|
of these alternatives with their ridership projections are not cost-effective.
|
|
We cannot (and the state will not) foolishly squander an additional one-third of
|
|
a billion dollars of taxpayer money for a lesser solution. It will not happen.
|
|
|
|
Therefore, if the local rail opponents are successful in denying the use of the
|
|
existing rail right-of-way, passenger rail service will go no further than Maple
|
|
Shade requiring many Burlington County residents to drive through Moorestown.
|
|
|
|
Senator Haines said that the only reason to bring the train through Moorestown
|
|
is that it would be less expensive than other routes because the rail is already
|
|
there. The Senator cautions, however, that it would not be efficient.
|
|
|
|
Contrary to the Senator's belief, New Jersey Transit has indicated in all
|
|
likelihood that the rail would be relaid to a higher standard; this expense also
|
|
is reflected in the cost estimates. The only thing that would be reused is the
|
|
right-of-way and many of the bridges. The cost estimates for construction on
|
|
the existing right-of-way have nothing to do with the rail already being there.
|
|
|
|
"We are under the gun to get more people riding public transportation," Senator
|
|
Haines said, but "I will not support a cheap system. Cheap will not solve the
|
|
problem."
|
|
|
|
Contrary to the Senator's understanding, the existing right-of-way is more than
|
|
just the most frugal option. The right-of-way in its entirety from Mt. Holly to
|
|
the heart of the Delaware Valley is the most direct, quickest and only feasible
|
|
alternative for Burlington County.
|
|
|
|
However, the line is not perfect. For three blocks in Moorestown, between
|
|
Washington Ave. and Chester Ave. along Third St., the right of way narrows and
|
|
homes are located on both sides of the street. Three diesel freight trains per
|
|
week currently travel this line. The right-of-way amongst the same homes once
|
|
had many passenger and freight trains on it at all hours of the day and night.
|
|
The last passenger train operated April 25, 1969.
|
|
|
|
Jane Wiltshire, in her February 10 letter to the editor, expressed concern about
|
|
passenger rail service returning to the existing right-of-way. Ms. Wiltshire
|
|
said that they will have a "dangerous, disruptive and noisy high speed train
|
|
running directly in our front or back yards."
|
|
|
|
First of all, although the electric train will not go unheard, it can often go
|
|
unnoticed. It also will be much quieter than the diesel freight trains that are
|
|
seen on the line. Regarding safety and intrusion issues, there are a number of
|
|
possible prescriptions that could be implemented, several in combination with
|
|
each other:
|
|
|
|
1. Install a fence;
|
|
|
|
2. Submerge the line;
|
|
|
|
3. Many of those properties on that three block strip are 200 feet deep. Pour
|
|
new foundations and move the structures back. This could work especially well
|
|
with option two;
|
|
|
|
4. Restrict train speeds to 15 or 25 mph for the three blocks; and
|
|
|
|
5. Offer home owners a more-than-fair buyout, possibly including such items as
|
|
low interest mortgages on their next home and moving expenses. Some residents
|
|
will not want to live near the line, but others will be glad to take their
|
|
place. Being close to effective rail service can conveniently allow a family to
|
|
have just one car.
|
|
|
|
Ms. Wiltshire, for the benefit of the tens of thousands of potential riders from
|
|
Burlington County, in the spirit of the public good, we ask that you and your
|
|
neighbors on the three block stretch to please contemplate all of to the above
|
|
options. As you yourself said, we ask you to "please consider the enormous
|
|
human impact."
|
|
|
|
Unlike, some other state related agencies, New Jersey Transit has demonstrated
|
|
that it is exceptionally fair to those who are most greatly impacted by
|
|
community investments. We would like to work with the home owners on the three
|
|
block stretch to see that New Jersey Transit continues this practice in
|
|
Moorestown.
|
|
|
|
Finally, I would like to address a few other concerns that have been expressed
|
|
in the past two weeks. At the February 17 meeting held in Moorestown, there
|
|
were some worries expressed about the crime rate and passenger rail service.
|
|
The crime rate in Haddonfield should give residents peace of mind. Haddonfield
|
|
is one of the safest towns in the state.
|
|
|
|
Regarding congestion, Ms. Wiltshire in her letter to the editor stated, "I also
|
|
have to laugh at the idea that building a station in Moorestown will relieve
|
|
traffic congestion. Riders from towns west of here will surely increase
|
|
downtown traffic, as happened in Haddonfield..." From my letter to the editor
|
|
of January 27, Ms. Wiltshire should know better.
|
|
|
|
As the study indicates, Moorestown would have a community walk-on station. Such
|
|
a station would be quite small and fit well into the community; less than 50
|
|
parking spaces would be provided. The large park & ride stations would be east
|
|
and west of the town, at the Route 537 interchange with Route 73 in Maple Shade,
|
|
and near Route 295 & 38 in Mount Laurel. This would draw motorists who wish to
|
|
access the train away from Moorestown.
|
|
|
|
Haddonfield Station has over 1000 parking spaces, yet Ms. Wiltshire and others
|
|
compare it to the potential Moorestown Station which would have under 50 spaces.
|
|
Unfortunately, this is another example of what is a lack of understanding for
|
|
the passenger rail initiative by the vocal opposition. If the rail opponents
|
|
continue to make such a comparison, their intent will be seen as fearmongering
|
|
for their own personal benefit.
|
|
|
|
However, if Moorestown and Burlington County someday have cost effective
|
|
passenger rail service, it will reap many benefits for the beautiful town.
|
|
Historically, such passenger rail service has significantly increased the value
|
|
of the homes in the vicinity of the line. The rail service will help reduce
|
|
pollution, combat traffic congestion, and protect the environment. And, in
|
|
downtown Moorestown, the young, the elderly, the disabled and the daily commuter
|
|
will be able to walk to the railroad station on a spring day and catch a train
|
|
to their destination.
|
|
|
|
[signed]
|
|
|
|
Donald Nigro
|
|
South Jersey Coordinator
|
|
New Jersey Association of Railroad Passengers
|
|
Delaware Valley Association of Railroad Passengers
|
|
|
|
|
|
##R South Jersey Notes
|
|
|
|
NJ Transit is changing some bus schedules April 2. Pick up a new timetable at
|
|
Camden Transportation Center or the Philadelphia bus terminal, or call NJ
|
|
Transit.
|
|
|
|
NJT Ridership Report
|
|
|
|
All of NJ Transit's operating divisions reported strong gains in ridership for
|
|
the second quarter of the fiscal year. This appears to be a true gain in market
|
|
share, as employment in the NJT service area is still declining slightly. Part
|
|
of the gain was attributed to the bad winter weather, as people left their cars
|
|
behind and took transit instead. According to NJT's report, the agency is first
|
|
in ridership growth among the ten biggest U.S. transit agencies.
|
|
|
|
line ridership(1000s) change
|
|
Atlantic City 156.7 +17.7%
|
|
NE Corridor 4798.9 +2.6%
|
|
North Jer. Coast 1568.9 +9.0%
|
|
Raritan Valley 966.3 +7.9%
|
|
Morris & Essex 1788.2 +6.0%
|
|
Main/Bergen 1011.9 +4.5%
|
|
Boonton 383.2 +8.4%
|
|
Pascack 319.5 +6.5%
|
|
Rail Total 10993.6 +5.2%
|
|
South Jersey Bus 5014.0 +7.8%
|
|
North Jersey Bus 26758.9 +5.4%
|
|
PATCO 2783.0 -1.4%
|
|
|
|
|
|
##S Federal Investigation: Amtrak Underfunded
|
|
by Dan Lutz (Pro-Rail Nebraska) and Matthew Mitchell
|
|
|
|
The U.S. General Accounting Office reported that Amtrak "has deteriorated so
|
|
badly that it cannot continue to operate a viable national passenger train
|
|
network without substantial increases in federal and state funding," according
|
|
to newspaper accounts. Amtrak's new president, Thomas Downs, told the House
|
|
Appropriations Subcommittee on Transportation he agreed with the GAO findings:
|
|
"We are now, as America's railroad, promising a service we can't deliver."
|
|
|
|
Kenneth Mead, director of transportation issues for GAO (Congress' investigative
|
|
arm), added: "Congress cannot have both quality train service and low Amtrak
|
|
budgets."
|
|
|
|
Federal Railroad Administrator Jolene Molitoris told the House subcommittee
|
|
President Clinton proposed a 15 percent increase in Amtrak's capital and
|
|
operating budget-to $788 million in fiscal 1995-which she called "a good start."
|
|
However, Mead and Downs said the Clinton budget is inadequate, given the state
|
|
of Amtrak. The Clinton budget, if adopted, they said, "will help, but it will
|
|
not resolve the short- and long-term challenges facing Amtrak."
|
|
|
|
During the administration of Graham Claytor, Amtrak's objective was to become
|
|
self-sufficient-free of Federal operating subsidy by the year 2001. But
|
|
progress to that goal came at the cost of reduced maintenance of aged equipment
|
|
and more and more breakdowns. As long as Amtrak depends on annual Congressional
|
|
appropriations (highways aren't forced to compete with Coast Guard drug
|
|
patrols), it has to run trains through as many Congressional districts as
|
|
possible. The result is like forcing twenty pounds of service into a ten-pound
|
|
sack.
|
|
|
|
It looks as though Downs will relax the drive for financial independence and
|
|
demand instead that the government level a playing field which has been tilted
|
|
towards roads and airports and away from rail-a welcome change.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##T Amnotes
|
|
Schedule Change Postponed
|
|
|
|
Amtrak pushed its spring schedule change back from the traditional April date to
|
|
Sunday, May 1. According to NARP, the new schedule will have some interesting
|
|
features: lots of added service in New York State, including an extra summer
|
|
weekend service to Saratoga Springs (summer home of the Philadelphia Orchestra)
|
|
and a new late-night weekend train (with sleeper!) across the Empire State to
|
|
Niagara Falls. This summer's 'Cape Codder' service will be extended to the
|
|
weekend after Labor Day.
|
|
|
|
Downs Speaks Out on Service
|
|
|
|
In a "Leadership Conference" for top staff in February, new Amtrak President
|
|
Thomas Downs bluntly assessed Amtrak's declining service:
|
|
"I've also found a number of [employees] who love railroading but think
|
|
passengers get in the way.... I have a feeling the part of [this] is relate
|
|
to the fact that we have systems that don't work, we have management
|
|
structures that don't work, and we sure as hell have equipment that doesn't
|
|
work....
|
|
|
|
|
|
##U NARP Looks at Commuter Rail
|
|
|
|
Invited to present the passengers' point of view at an APTA commuter rail
|
|
meeting, NARP Executive Director Ross Capon recently sought out opinions from
|
|
local organizations like DVARP. DVARP President Chuck Bode, in consultation
|
|
with the Commuter Rail Committee and other members, replied with a letter
|
|
reminding all that "the focus has to be on the passenger, not on the
|
|
consultants, construction companies, politicians, and agency administrative
|
|
staff."
|
|
|
|
|
|
##V VIA Facing Another Service Slash
|
|
|
|
Despite vague statements supporting passenger train service in last year's
|
|
election campaign, the ruling Liberal Party in Canada is poised to reduce its
|
|
suport of the VIA national passenger train system by 30 percent. Said Transport
|
|
Minister Doug Young: "There's no more money from the Government of Canada for
|
|
VIA. And there's no point in asking for any....Undoubtedly there will be major
|
|
problems for employees and users. We're just trying to do the best we can."
|
|
|
|
Transport 2000 sources are speculating that service will be cut across the
|
|
country. The 'Atlantic': from Montreal to the Maritimes via northern Maine is
|
|
likely to go, along with VIA local service from Toronto to Niagara Falls and
|
|
Sarnia. The 'Canadian,' the train which made the nation, will be cut again.
|
|
But joint Amtrak/VIA services to Toronto and Montreal should be spared.
|
|
|
|
##W Up and Down the Corridor
|
|
News of other Northeastern commuter rail and rail transit services
|
|
|
|
#VRE Guarantee
|
|
|
|
Frustrated by its freight railroad hosts' reluctance to have additional
|
|
passenger trains on its lines, Virginia Railway Express has still found a way to
|
|
meet its customers' needs. If passengers have an emergency and need to get back
|
|
home in the middle of the day when VRE doen't run any service, it will pay 90
|
|
percent of the cost of a taxi or other alternate transportation, up to $100.
|
|
|
|
Most people won't need to use this "Special Delivery" guarantee, but the peace
|
|
of mind it brings them may be what it takes to get them to take the train
|
|
instead of driving.
|
|
|
|
#Rudy Lets Straphangers Down
|
|
|
|
In a proposed Capital Plan for the City of New York, new Mayor Rudolph Guliani
|
|
has not only tipped the transit/highway balance, he's upset it completely.
|
|
Instead of the longstnading 50/50 ratio between road and transit projects in the
|
|
budget, he shifts the balance heavily to dirty, dangerous cars.
|
|
|
|
#MARC Looks to Improve Commuter Environment
|
|
|
|
As the Maryland Rail Commuter operation purchases new cars to accomodate its
|
|
growing ridership, the newly-formed Commuter Advisory Committee will give its
|
|
opinion on the vehicles in which its members spend up to four hours a day in.
|
|
The CAC voted last month to recommend 2+2 instead of 2+3 seating in the new
|
|
cars. MARC is looking at western-style bi-level gallery cars, which are 2+2.
|
|
Commuters everywhere dislike the crowded feel of the three-abreast seats; SEPTA
|
|
riders often stand for twenty minutes or more rather than take that middle seat.
|
|
|
|
But just as it did in adding cafe and parlor car service, MARC is going a step
|
|
further. It is looking into specifying airline-style individual ventilation
|
|
controls for its railcars!
|
|
|
|
#T for Free!
|
|
|
|
MBTA (Boston) General Manager John Haley said he wasn't satisfied with speed
|
|
with which his company recovered from a big January snowstorm, and punctuated
|
|
his comment by making the entire system free the morning of Jan. 11th. Not only
|
|
was this a touching apology to customers who were inconvenienced by the
|
|
unreliable service, it was a message to T employees that Haley doesn't consider
|
|
bad weather an excuse.
|
|
|
|
#Mass. to T: Build Ridership
|
|
|
|
When the MBTA failed to provide a legally-mandated environmental impact report
|
|
for its 1993 fare increase, the Massachusetts Secretary of Environmental Affairs
|
|
had a novel idea. Rather than roll back the fares raised in contravention of
|
|
regulations, he placed the money raised ($5.9 million) in escrow-to be used only
|
|
for projects designed to increase T ridership, such as information and
|
|
advertising campaigns, parking fee reductions, new ticket machines, and bike-
|
|
and-ride projects.
|
|
|
|
##X DVARP Details
|
|
|
|
NARP Region III Meeting: Time Change
|
|
|
|
Philadelphia-area residents who plan to ride SEPTA to Wilmington for the Region
|
|
III Annual Meeting of the National Association of Railroad Passengers will be
|
|
glad to hear that the meeting start time has been changed to 11:00 am. The
|
|
location remains the same: The City/County Building in Wilmington, Delaware.
|
|
Delmarva RPA members will meet passengers arriving at the train station and
|
|
direct them onto DART buses for the short trip to the meeting.
|
|
|
|
While not confirmed yet, DRPA is working to arrange a tour of the Wilmington Car
|
|
Company's shops to follow the meeting. Guest speakers will address the meeting,
|
|
too. The fee for this day's activities is a very reasonable $10.00. For
|
|
information and reservations, please call Steve von Bonin at 302-492-3676.
|
|
|
|
Circle the Date
|
|
|
|
Delmarva RPA has announced that it is planning its third annual "Rail to the
|
|
Fair" excursion to the Delaware State Fair for July 23. This special Amtrak
|
|
train is expected to run from 30th Street to the Fairgrounds and back: a new and
|
|
interesting routing has been promised for 1994!
|
|
|
|
Fair Notices, Volunteers Wanted
|
|
|
|
Got a community fair or other special event coming up in your neighborhood?
|
|
Please let DVARP know about it. Every year DVARP volunteers staff tables at
|
|
these kind of events, handing out literature, showing pictures and sometimes
|
|
videotapes of modern trains and trolleys, and telling residents how good train
|
|
and transit service makes their community a better place to live and work.
|
|
These kind of events are also fertile ground for finding new DVARP members, so
|
|
if you'd like to spend part of a day at one of these fairs, we'd love to have
|
|
you. It's easy and fun; call DVARP volunteer coordinator Betsey Clark: 215-222-
|
|
3373, message box 4.
|
|
|
|
|
|
##Y Dates of Interest
|
|
|
|
IEEE Vehicular Technology Society: Wed., Apr. 13, 7:00 pm at Lebow Engineering
|
|
Center, Drexel Univ., 31st and Market Sts. Topic: AC Traction Electromagentic
|
|
Interference...
|
|
|
|
DVARP General Meeting: Thurs., Apr. 14, 6:00 to 9:00 at Temple University Center
|
|
City, 1616 Walnut St.
|
|
|
|
NARP Region III Meeting: Sat., Apr. 16, 11:00 to 2:00 in Council Chambers,
|
|
Wilmington City-County Building. Registration fee $10.00 includes lunch. Call
|
|
Steve von Bonin, 302-492-3676, for details.
|
|
|
|
SEPTA Citizen Advisory Committee: Tues., Apr. 19, 5:45 pm at SEPTA Board Room,
|
|
714 Market St.
|
|
|
|
SEPTA on Site (Suburban Transit): Wed., Apr. 20, 7:30 to 9:30 am and 3:30 to
|
|
5:30 pm at 69th St. Terminal, 7:30 to 9:30 am at Norristown Transportation
|
|
Center.
|
|
|
|
Deadline for May newsletter material: Tue., Apr. 26, to Matthew Mitchell or in
|
|
DVARP mailbox.
|
|
|
|
SEPTA Board Meeting: Thu., Apr. 28, 3:00 pm at SEPTA Board Room, 714 Market St.
|
|
|
|
Delmarva Rail Passenger Association: Mon., May 2, 7:00 pm, (note change of date)
|
|
in State Senate Chamber, Legislative Hall, Dover. Call Ken Berg, 410-648-4405,
|
|
for more information.
|
|
|
|
Jenkintown Kiwanis Travelrama Lecture Series: "The Great Canadian Train Ride."
|
|
Mon., May 9, 8:00 pm at the Keswick Theater, Easton Rd. and Keswick Ave.,
|
|
Glenside. Tickets $10.00 at the door.
|
|
|
|
IEEE Vehicular Technology Society: Thurs., May 11. Time and place not
|
|
available at this time. Topic: Grand Central Terminal.
|
|
|
|
DVARP Commuter Rail Committee: Sat., May 14, 12:00 at Chestnut Gourmet, 1121
|
|
Chestnut St., Phila.
|
|
|
|
DVARP South Jersey Committee: Sat., May 21, 10:30 at 104 Edison Ave.,
|
|
Collingswood, NJ.
|
|
|
|
DVARP General Meeting: Sat., May 21, 1:00 to 4:00 at Ludington Library,
|
|
Lancaster Ave., Bryn Mawr.
|
|
|
|
Listings based on information provided to DVARP.
|
|
Contact sponsor to confirm time & place.
|
|
|
|
Call 215-222-3373, message box 3, to add your event to this calendar.
|
|
|
|
##Z DVARP Phone & Voice-mail Directory
|
|
- DVARP main number (voice mail line) 215-222-3373
|
|
1 Chuck Bode, President 215-222-3373
|
|
5 Tom Borawski, VP-Transportation 215-552-4198
|
|
6 Robert H. Machler, VP-Administration 215-222-3373
|
|
5 Sharon Shneyer, VP-Public Relations 215-386-2644
|
|
3 Matthew Mitchell, Newsletter Editor 215-885-7448
|
|
4 Betsey Clark, Volunteer Coordinator 215-222-3373
|
|
8 Treasurer 215-222-3373
|
|
2 John Pawson, Commuter RR Comm. 215-659-7736
|
|
(6 to 9 pm please)
|
|
3 Transit Committee 215-222-3373
|
|
7 Don Nigro, South Jersey Committee 609-869-0020
|
|
- Dan Radack, Bicycle Coordinator 215-232-6303
|
|
Media Hotline (digital beeper) 215-552-4198
|
|
Computer e-mail (internet) 73243.1224@compuserve.com
|
|
|
|
|
|
##AA Upcoming DVARP Meetings:
|
|
|
|
Thursday, April 14, 6:00 to 9:00 Temple University Center City
|
|
1616 Walnut St., Philadelphia. please note special date!
|
|
see message board in lobby for room number
|
|
food, drinks, smoking prohibited in meeting room.
|
|
|
|
NARP Region III Meeting:
|
|
Saturday, April 16, 11:00 to 2:00 Wilmington City-County Building
|
|
|
|
Saturday, May 21, 1:00 to 4:00 Ludington Library, Bryn Mawr
|
|
|
|
Saturday June 18, 1:00 to 4:00 Bucks County Library, Doylestown
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
##BB Agenda for the April meeting:
|
|
6:00 Introductions, agenda, minutes
|
|
6:10 Issues requiring immediate action
|
|
SEPTA Budget
|
|
NARP Region III meeting
|
|
7:15 Other issues
|
|
Commuter Rail Committee:
|
|
NJ-PA through-service
|
|
South Jersey Committee:
|
|
Gloucester County organizing
|
|
Administration:
|
|
Incorporation
|
|
Guest speakers for meetings
|
|
Membership brochure
|
|
|
|
Committee Meetings:
|
|
|
|
South Jersey Comm.: Sat., May 21, 10:30 at 104 Edison Ave., Collingswood, NJ
|
|
Commuter Rail Comm.: Sat., May 14, 12:00, Chestnut Gourmet, 1121 Chestnut St.
|
|
Transit Committee: no meeting this month.
|
|
|
|
-30-
|