61 lines
3.4 KiB
Plaintext
61 lines
3.4 KiB
Plaintext
FEBRUARY 1990
|
||
|
||
|
||
ARSON INVESTIGATIONS
|
||
|
||
By
|
||
|
||
William A. Tobin
|
||
Special Agent
|
||
FBI Laboratory
|
||
Washington, DC
|
||
|
||
|
||
Collapsed furniture springs, which have been subjected to
|
||
fire, have been used by arson investigators for many years, both
|
||
as an indicator of arson and/or of a slow, smoldering source,
|
||
such as a cigarette. However, FBI Laboratory research has
|
||
revealed that collapsed springs are not a valid indicator of the
|
||
presence of an accelerant or of a smoldering source.
|
||
|
||
A review of the literature reveals that there are
|
||
contradictory conclusions regarding the condition of springs
|
||
subjected to fire. Some sources maintain that collapsed springs
|
||
are, indeed, an indication of a slow, smoldering origin because
|
||
of the consistent heat required to collapse them. Others argue
|
||
that collapsed springs are positive proof of the presence of an
|
||
accelerant because the temperature required to collapse the
|
||
springs cannot be reached by the burning of normal building
|
||
materials alone. The contradictory nature of these conclusions,
|
||
therefore, suggests that a detailed metallurgical investigation
|
||
was necessary to determine which theory was valid.
|
||
|
||
When metals are subjected to elevated temperatures, many
|
||
metallurgical parameters and considerations can come into play.
|
||
Metallurgists have long known, for example, that in order for a
|
||
metal to be of equal strength, it must be heated to a certain
|
||
temperature in a certain amount of time. This can be
|
||
accomplished by applying twice the heat in half the time, or half
|
||
the heat in twice the time. The FBI Laboratory's investigation
|
||
examined not only the interactions of time and temperature but
|
||
also of chemical composition, fabrication history, and other
|
||
metallurgical conditions.
|
||
|
||
Part of the FBI's investigation involved actual test
|
||
burnings of mattresses of varying inner-spring construction. The
|
||
mattresses were placed in a room full of furniture at the FBI's
|
||
Test Burn Facility in Quantico, VA. To simulate an
|
||
accelerant-based fire, gasoline was poured on the mattresses and
|
||
ignited. To simulate a cigarette or other slow, smoldering type
|
||
of fire, 10 ml of propanol was placed on the mattresses and
|
||
ignited. After the resulting fires were allowed to burn for
|
||
varying amounts of time, they were extinguished and data,
|
||
including photographs, were collected. The most notable
|
||
conclusion was that within the same mattress, there were both
|
||
collapsed and uncollapsed springs. Therefore, consistent with
|
||
metallurgical expectations, controlled testing revealed that the
|
||
collapsed, partially collapsed or uncollapsed condition of
|
||
furniture springs is of no value as an indicator of arson or of a
|
||
slow, smoldering fire.
|
||
|
||
|