86 lines
4.5 KiB
Plaintext
86 lines
4.5 KiB
Plaintext
June 1990
|
||
|
||
POLICE PRACTICES:
|
||
THE NELSON-DENNY EXPERIMENT
|
||
|
||
|
||
The Arizona Law Enforcement Training Academy (ALETA)
|
||
provides statewide law enforcement basic training to officers who
|
||
have no other basic training available to them. Over 100
|
||
agencies train their cadets at ALETA.
|
||
|
||
THE PROBLEM
|
||
|
||
A major problem encountered at the academy was the large
|
||
number of academic failures among minority police recruits,
|
||
especially Native Americans. One of the critical areas in which
|
||
the trainees were deficient was reading comprehension, which
|
||
impacted on their ability to read and understand material from
|
||
the required reading list.
|
||
|
||
THE SOLUTION
|
||
|
||
To address the problem, at the outset of basic training, the
|
||
Nelson-Denny Reading Test was administered to the recruits in
|
||
order to determine their individual reading comprehension level.
|
||
The test has been standardized and validated with a primary
|
||
purpose of providing a trustworthy ranking of a student's ability
|
||
in reading comprehension, vocabulary development, and reading
|
||
rate--the three most important skills in the reading process.
|
||
|
||
In addition to being standardized and valid, the
|
||
Nelson-Denny Reading Test has a simple format, is administered
|
||
easily, can be graded quickly by converting answer sheets to a
|
||
computer Scantron grading process, and is equated to a public
|
||
school grade level range of 3.6 to 16.9. Total administration
|
||
time is less than 45 minutes. Forms of the test can be used
|
||
interchangeably as a pretest and post-test to measure the
|
||
recruits' growth in vocabulary and comprehension.
|
||
|
||
Pretest scores showed that Native Americans, Hispanics, and
|
||
blacks usually scored in the low grade levels (5 to 11), while
|
||
the majority of the nonminorities scored in the higher levels (12
|
||
to 16.9). In an effort to improve minority reading levels, it
|
||
was decided to have recruits with high comprehension levels tutor
|
||
those with lower comprehension levels. After the pretest was
|
||
administered during orientation, the cadet classes, which ranged
|
||
in size from 40 to 50 recruits, were divided into four squads of
|
||
10 or more recruits. The high Nelson-Denny scorers were assigned
|
||
to tutor (or be a mentor to) the low scorers throughout the 12
|
||
weeks of training. This concept was facilitated by assigning a
|
||
pair as roommates in the dormitories, whenever possible.
|
||
|
||
THE RESULTS
|
||
|
||
The results of the Nelson-Denny experiment were immediate
|
||
and dramatic. The academic failure rate among minorities fell
|
||
from around 80 to 85% to below 15%. Overall academic failures of
|
||
all ethnic classes fell from 20% to 10%, excluding terminations
|
||
due to physical training deficiencies or resignations.
|
||
|
||
After a minimum of 300 recruits had been tested for a
|
||
statistical base, a grade level of 10.9 was determined to be
|
||
critical for success in the basic training. Thus, a police
|
||
recruit with a Nelson-Denny grade level below 10.9 would
|
||
experience academic difficulties at ALETA. The critical grade
|
||
level proved to be extremely accurate with each new recruit
|
||
class.
|
||
|
||
The Nelson-Denny Reading Test has gained statewide
|
||
acceptance as a pre-employment screening instrument once the 10.9
|
||
grade level was identified as critical for success. On September
|
||
1, 1989, the Arizona Law Enforcement Officers Advisory Council
|
||
made it a requirement that all certified basic training academies
|
||
in Arizona administer a reading test, with the recommendation
|
||
that the Nelson-Denny Reading Test be used. And while the test
|
||
should never be the sole determinant of success in police basic
|
||
training, it can be a screening device, in conjunction with other
|
||
test results, for pre-employment screening of a police applicant,
|
||
if properly used.
|
||
|
||
____________
|
||
|
||
Information for this column was submitted by Lt. Samuel T.
|
||
Ragland of the Arizona Law Enforcement Training Academy, Tucson,
|
||
Arizona.
|
||
|