541 lines
33 KiB
Plaintext
541 lines
33 KiB
Plaintext
SPATIAL DECONCENTRATION
|
|
by Yolanda Ward
|
|
|
|
This article was researched and written primarily by Ms. Yolanda Ward,
|
|
sometime in the early Nineteen Eighties. It is based largely on material
|
|
that is publicly available, especially the "Report of the National Advisory
|
|
Commission on Civic Disturbances," otherwise known as the Kerner Commission
|
|
Report.
|
|
|
|
A large portion of this document is, however, based on materials which were
|
|
not publicly available, specifically a number of Housing and Urban
|
|
Development (HUD) department files which Ms. Ward and her collaborators
|
|
apparently stole from the HUD office in Washington, D.C. The material herein
|
|
contained details a policy, known as "Spatial Deconcentration," which rivals
|
|
both Nazi Germany and present day South Africa in its injustice to
|
|
individuals, its utter disregard for human and civil rights, and outstrips
|
|
them both in the remarkable secrecy with which it has been, until now,
|
|
instituted.
|
|
|
|
This document was first published as part of a collection of notes for a
|
|
national housing activists conference held in Washington D.C. some years
|
|
ago. No more than five hundred copies were made at that time, and to the
|
|
best of our knowledge, this was the report's only publication, prior to the
|
|
one you now hold in your hands. Shortly after this first publication, Ms.
|
|
Ward and two associates were accosted on a Washington street one night by
|
|
two well-dressed white men, who singled out Ms. Ward from her two friends,
|
|
ordered her at gunpoint to lie face down in the street, and then shot her in
|
|
the back of the head. The documents she and her friends allegedly stole from
|
|
HUD have never been published, nor are they included here.
|
|
|
|
-- J.F.W., Editor (published in World War Three Illustrated circa1989)
|
|
|
|
This book is the result of painstaking work done during the second half of
|
|
1979, mostly in Philadelphia, but also in St. Louis, Chicago, New York City
|
|
and Washington D.C.
|
|
|
|
It includes a collection of materials from federal agencies such as the
|
|
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), and the General
|
|
Accounting Office (GAO); from community sources, such as Philadelphia and
|
|
St. Louis Legal Aid Societies; and from independent sources, such as
|
|
foundations, private corporations, books, private papers, etc.
|
|
|
|
The search for and collection of this material began in August, 1979, when
|
|
housing activists in Philadelphia first stumbled across the strangely-worded
|
|
theory called "spatial deconcentration." A letter had been forwarded from
|
|
the Philadelphia-area regional planning commission to activist attorneys in
|
|
one of the legal service agencies announcing a new "fair housing" program
|
|
called the "Regional Housing Mobility Program." It might have been all greek
|
|
to housing activists had they not already known that some type of sweeping
|
|
master plan had already swung into effect to depopulate Philadelphia of its
|
|
minority neighborhoods. The massive demolition operations in minority
|
|
neighborhoods; which had been systematic, and the total lack of
|
|
reconstruction funds from public or private sources spoke to that fact.
|
|
|
|
Activists had fought pitched battles with the city administration over
|
|
housing policies for some three years before the word "mobility" was ever
|
|
mentioned among their ranks. In march of 1979, in fact, Philadelphia public
|
|
housing leaders launched an attack on a city organized and HUD sponsored
|
|
plan to empty the city's public housing high-rise projects. The question at
|
|
the time had been: "Where will all the tenants go?" When the mobility
|
|
program was unearthed in August, the answer fell into place like a major
|
|
piece in a jig-saw puzzle. The answer, naturally, was the suburbs. It seemed
|
|
to fit perfectly into the "triage" or "Gentrification" scheme, which froze
|
|
the inner city land stocks for the returning suburbanites who were finding
|
|
city life more economical than the suburbs.
|
|
|
|
Focussing their attention on this phenomenon called "Mobility," the
|
|
activists dug for more materials at the planning commission office. With the
|
|
new materials available they began to slowly understand that the Mobility
|
|
Program was much more than met the eye. By late September they only
|
|
understood that the program seemed to be a keystone among federal housing
|
|
programs and that HUD was making special efforts to avoid a confrontation
|
|
over the matter.
|
|
|
|
It was tactically decided that the program was too massive to be fought on a
|
|
local level. Activists in other cities would have to be sensitized to the
|
|
Program and encouraged to swing into action against it. Between early
|
|
November and late December, such contacts had been developed in St. Louis,
|
|
Chicago and New York City -- all key Mobility cities. All the information
|
|
that had been collected in Philadelphia before November was distributed to
|
|
community activists in these cities. This action helped uncover massive
|
|
amounts of new information about the program, which would have been
|
|
impossible to procure on the east coast for various reasons, and which
|
|
changed the basic nature of the struggle the activists were waging against
|
|
the government.
|
|
|
|
The Philadelphia housing leaders had fought their campaign between 1976 and
|
|
1979 under the assumption that their struggle against the land speculators
|
|
and government bureaucracy had an economic base. They understood
|
|
"gentrification" perfectly, but thought it had developed because the
|
|
speculators were slowly but steadily viewing the land in minority
|
|
neighborhoods as some kind of gold mine to be vigorously exploited at any
|
|
cost. The information uncovered about the mobility program slowly taught
|
|
them that they were entirely wrong, and perhaps this misdirection had
|
|
prevented them from realizing any measurable amount of success in forcing
|
|
the city or government to start-up housing construction projects in the
|
|
city. It is now clear, in 1980, that instead of being economic the manifest
|
|
crises that plague inner-city minorities are founded in a problem of
|
|
control.
|
|
|
|
The so-called "gentrification" of the inner-cities, the lack of
|
|
rehabilitation financing for inner-city families, the massive demolition
|
|
projects which have transformed once-stable neighborhoods into vast
|
|
wastelands, the diminishing inner-city services, such as recreation,
|
|
health-care, education, jobs and job-training, sanitation, etc.; are all
|
|
rooted in an apparent bone-chilling fear that inner-city minorities are
|
|
uncontrollable.
|
|
|
|
Lengthy government-sponsored studies were conducted in the wake of the riots
|
|
of the 1960s, particularly after the 1967 Detroit fiasco which cost 47 lives
|
|
and was quelled only after deployment of 82nd Airborne paratroopers flown in
|
|
from North Carolina which had been commissioned for duty on the emergency
|
|
order of then-President Lyndon Johnson. Among intelligence agencies pressed
|
|
into service to study the problem was the Rand Corporation. In late
|
|
December, 1967 and early January, 1968, Rand was requested by the Ford
|
|
Foundation to conduct a three-week "workshop" concerning the "analysis of
|
|
the urban problem." It was "intended to define and initiate a long-term
|
|
research program on urban policy issues and to interest other organizations
|
|
in undertaking related work. Participants included scientists, scholars,
|
|
federal and New York City officials, and Rand staff members.
|
|
|
|
Johnson also ordered a particularly significant study of the riots to be
|
|
commissioned which has led to the emergence of some of the most dangerous
|
|
theories since the rise of Adolf Hitler. It was the National Advisory
|
|
Commission Report on Civil Disorders, more commonly called the Kerner
|
|
Commission Report. Strategists representing all specialities were contracted
|
|
by the government to participate in the study. Begun in 1967 immediately in
|
|
the wake of the Detroit riot, it was not published until March of 1968. But
|
|
only weeks after its emergence, Dr. Martin Luther King was assassinated and
|
|
the most massive wave of riots that was ever recorded in American history
|
|
almost forced a suspension of the Constitution.
|
|
|
|
Samuel Yette reported in his 1971 book, The Choice, that the House
|
|
Un-American Affairs Committee, headed by right-wing elements, had put heavy
|
|
pressure on Johnson to suspend the Constitution and declare martial law in
|
|
the cities. Johnson resisted and instead ordered government strategists to
|
|
employ the finest minds in the country to analyze the cause of the revolts
|
|
and develop strategies to prevent them in the future.
|
|
|
|
The workshop participants were asked to prepare and submit papers
|
|
recommending "program initiatives and experiments" in the areas of
|
|
welfare/public assistance, jobs and manpower training, housing and urban
|
|
planning, police services and public order, race relations, and others. The
|
|
papers were grouped into four headings, including two called "urban
|
|
poverty," and "urban violence and public order."
|
|
|
|
The Kerner Commission strategists came to the conclusion that America's
|
|
inner-city poverty was so entrenched that the ghettoes could not be
|
|
transformed into viable neighborhoods to the satisfaction of residents or
|
|
the government. The problem of riots, therefore, could be expected to emerge
|
|
in the future, perhaps with more intensity and as a more serious threat to
|
|
the Constitutional privileges which most Americans enjoy. They finally
|
|
concluded that if the problem could not be eliminated because of the nature
|
|
of the American system of "free enterprise," than American technology could
|
|
contain it. This could only be done through a theory of "spatial
|
|
deconcentration" of racially-impacted neighborhoods. In other words, poverty
|
|
had been allowed to become so concentrated in the inner-cities that
|
|
hopelessness overwhelmed their residents and the government's resolve to
|
|
dilute it.
|
|
|
|
This hopelessness had the social effect of a fire near a powderkeg. But if
|
|
the ghettoes were thinned out, the chances of a cataclysmic explosion that
|
|
could destroy the American way of life could be equally diminished.
|
|
Inner-city residents, then, would have to be dispersed throughout the
|
|
metropolitan regions to guarantee the privileges of the middle-class. Where
|
|
those inner-city minorities should be placed after their dispersal had been
|
|
the subject of intense research by the government and the major financial
|
|
interests of the U.S. since 1968. In the Kerner Commission Report, Chapter
|
|
17 addressed itself to this prospect. Suburbs were its answer: the furthest
|
|
place from the inner-city.
|
|
|
|
A high proportion of the commissioners for the Report and their contracting
|
|
strategists were military or paramilitary men. Otto Kerner, himself,
|
|
chairman of the Commission, was the Governor of Illinois at the time of the
|
|
Report but before that had been a major general in the army. John Lindsey,
|
|
Mayor of New York City, had been chairman of the political committee of the
|
|
NATO Parliamentarian's Conference. Herbert Jenkins, before becoming a
|
|
commissioner, had been chief of the Atlanta Police Department and President
|
|
of the International Association of Chiefs of Police, a reputed
|
|
"anti-terrorist" organization. Charles Thornton, the fourth of the seven
|
|
commissioners, was chairman of the board of Litton Industries at the time he
|
|
accepted his commission, one of the country's chief military suppliers and,
|
|
before that, had been general manager of the Hughes Aircraft Corporation --
|
|
another major military supplier -- and a colonel in the U.S. Air Force, a
|
|
trustee of the National Security Industrial Association, and a member of the
|
|
Advisory Council to the Defense Department.
|
|
|
|
The Commission's list of contractors and witnesses was no less glittering in
|
|
military and paramilitary personnel. No less than thirty police departments
|
|
were represented on or before the Commission by their chiefs or deputy
|
|
chiefs. Twelve generals representing various branches of the armed services
|
|
appeared before the Commission or served as contractors. The Agency for
|
|
International Development, the Rand Corporation, The Brookings Institute,
|
|
the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the International Association of
|
|
Chiefs of Police, the Institute of Defense Analysis, and the Ford Foundation
|
|
all played significant roles in shaping the Commission's findings.
|
|
|
|
A hardly-noticeable name listed among the intelligence and military giants
|
|
was that of one Anthony Downs, a civilian. Unlike most of the other
|
|
contractors, whose names were followed by lines of titles, Downs was simply
|
|
listed as being from Chicago, Illinois. His name was to become very
|
|
prominent among inner-city grassroots leaders around the country by the end
|
|
of 1979. Philadelphia housing leaders had remembered Downs as having been
|
|
the author of the so-called "triage" report of 1975 which led to a storm of
|
|
controversy at the time.
|
|
|
|
In his HUD-sponsored study, Downs argued that the inner-cities were
|
|
hopelessly beyond repair and would be better off cleared of services and
|
|
residents and landbanked. The middle-class should then be allowed to
|
|
re-populate these areas, giving them a breath of new life. The activists, in
|
|
their rush to uncover information about the Mobility Program, discovered, to
|
|
their surprise, that Downs had written Chapters 16 & 17 of the Kerner
|
|
Commission Report; the chapters devoted to demographic shifts in the
|
|
inner-cities and spatial deconcentration.
|
|
|
|
Housing activists studying theories of "mobility" and "spatial
|
|
deconcentration" stumbled upon yet another "strategist," also, like Downs,
|
|
out of Chicago, named Bernard Weissbourd. Weissbourd wrote two papers in
|
|
Chicago in 1968 concerning the crisis of exploding minority inner-city
|
|
populations. In one paper, entitled An Urban Strategy, he proposed a
|
|
so-called "one-four-three-four" plan. Inner-city minority populations
|
|
represented such a growing political threat by their growing numbers, he
|
|
argued, that a strategy had to be quickly developed to thin out their
|
|
numbers and prevent them from overwhelming the nation's biggest cities. He
|
|
proposed that this be accomplished through a series of federal and private
|
|
programs that would financially-induce minorities to migrate to the suburbs
|
|
until their absolute numbers inside the cities represented no more than
|
|
one-fourth of the total population.
|
|
|
|
It is not clear if An Urban Strategy was written before the Kerner
|
|
Commission Report was released or before the end of the Rand Corporations
|
|
"workshop." Around the same time, however, he wrote another paper entitled,
|
|
Proposal for a New Housing Program: Satellite Communities. Weissbourd argued
|
|
that the bombed-out inner-city neighborhoods should be completely rebuilt as
|
|
"new towns in town" for the middle-class. As in his Urban Strategy paper, he
|
|
discussed the threat of explosive inner-city minority populations and their
|
|
threatening political power. He suggested that this threat could be repulsed
|
|
with the construction of new housing outside the cities for inner-city
|
|
minorities. He also suggested that jobs be found for these people in the
|
|
suburbs and that ". . . some form of subsidy" be developed to induce them to
|
|
leave the inner-cities. It is not clear whether Downs knew Weissbourd or
|
|
borrowed his theories in time for his Kerner Commission Report, or if, in
|
|
fact, the Report was finished after Weissbourd published his works, although
|
|
it is likely, since both worked out of Chicago. It is clear that both
|
|
strategists saw American middle-class life-styles as being challenged by the
|
|
same explosive, racially-impacted inner-city neighborhoods.
|
|
|
|
In the same year that Downs had completed his Kerner Commission Report
|
|
chapters and Weissbourd published his theories, President Johnson requested
|
|
the formation of a research network that could focus on analyses of
|
|
inner-city evolution and area-wide metropolitan strategies. This "thinktank"
|
|
is called the Urban Institute. Since its founding in 1968, the likes of
|
|
Carla Hills, Robert McNamara, Cyrus Vance, William Ruckelshaus, Kingman
|
|
Brewster, Joseph Califano, Edward Levi, John D. Rockerfeller, Charles
|
|
Schultze and William Scranton, have served as members of its board of
|
|
trustees.
|
|
|
|
The five Blacks who have served, or are serving, are Whitney Young, Leon
|
|
Sullivan, William Hastie, Vernon Jordan, and William Coleman; all prominent
|
|
middle-class "yes-men." The board of the Institute has had an interlocking
|
|
relationship with the boards of trustees of the Rand Corporation and the
|
|
Brookings Institute, both close CIA affiliates. Rand's Washington office, in
|
|
fact, is located in the same building where the Institute has its
|
|
headquarters.
|
|
|
|
The Institute, to say the least, is a bizarre agency. It was supposedly
|
|
founded in the spirit of harmony between the races, but has been dominated
|
|
by a substantial number of presidential cabinet members and major U.S.
|
|
corporations and Universities, such as Yale and Chicago. Worse, the
|
|
Institute has conducted a substantial portion of the research that has led
|
|
to the development of Mobility Program techniques. Its president, William
|
|
Gorham, recently described the agency as a HUD "testing laboratory." It is
|
|
theoretically dominated by the likes of the quasi-military strategists that
|
|
dominated the Kerner Commission, especially one John Goodman, the
|
|
Institute's major "mobility" specialist.
|
|
|
|
In terms of the types of experiments the Institute has conducted over its
|
|
short history and the highly-sensitive nature of its research work, it ranks
|
|
on a par with the CIA itself. Goodman, for instance, heading a team of
|
|
strategists, developed, between 1975 and 1979, a series of experiments to
|
|
determine the best way to induce inner-city Blacks and other minorities to
|
|
leave the cities. A favorite ploy they developed was housing allowances and
|
|
the so-called housing "subsidy" progress, whereby low-income families are
|
|
supported in their rent payments, or paid cash grants, if they first agree
|
|
to move out. Heavy experimentation was also conducted by the Institute on
|
|
tactics that could be used to shape the Section 8 Program into a
|
|
counterinsurgency tool against minorities.
|
|
|
|
In 1970, Downs wrote a little known book called Urban Problems & Prospects,
|
|
in which he more graphically detailed the theory of spatial deconcentration.
|
|
He developed a bizarre concept in the book entitled "the theory of
|
|
middle-class dominance." According to him, the dispersal of the inner-city
|
|
populations to the suburbs could not be successfully completed unless and
|
|
until a model of dispersal was developed whereby the artificially-induced
|
|
outflow of minorities from the inner-cities would be controlled and directed
|
|
to the point that they would not be permitted to naturally reconcentrate
|
|
themselves in the suburbs.
|
|
|
|
This was the heart of the government theory which was later to become the
|
|
theory of "integration maintenance." This type of control had to be
|
|
exercised, according to Downs, because white suburbanites would not remain
|
|
stable in their bungalows if they were led to suspect that the incoming
|
|
Blacks and other minorities were gaining power through their sheer numbers
|
|
in the suburbs. The consistent theme of Down's Problems, Chapters 16 & 17 of
|
|
the Kerner Commission Report, and Goodman's works at the Institute, was that
|
|
of control.
|
|
|
|
The line of thinking about control found reinforcement in another book Downs
|
|
wrote in 1973, entitled Opening Up the Suburbs: An Urban Strategy for
|
|
America. Down's theories from the Kerner Commission Report crystalized,
|
|
taking as their cue his arguments laid down in Urban Problems. The theory of
|
|
white "dominance" was carefully discussed in Suburbs. Included here were
|
|
ideas for ". . . a broader strategy," where ". . .a workable mechanism
|
|
ensuring that whites will remain in the majority . . ." were produced. But
|
|
Chapter 12 of Suburbs carefully laid down a mechanism which could transform
|
|
the theories of his former works into practical application.
|
|
|
|
The chapter was called "Principles of a Strategy of Dispersing Economic
|
|
Integration," and laid down five basic concepts: 1 -- establishing a
|
|
"favorable" political climate for the strategy; 2 -- creating "economic
|
|
incentives" for the strategy; 3 -- "preserving suburban middle-class
|
|
dominance; 4 -- rebuilding inner-cities; 5 -- developing a further
|
|
"comprehensive strategy." In outline format, he analyzed each one. He noted
|
|
that experiments should be conducted before the strategy was effectuated and
|
|
that ". . . more effective means of withdrawing economic support . . . "
|
|
should be developed for the inner-cities to clear the way for landbanking
|
|
inner-city neighborhoods.
|
|
|
|
To the amazement of the inner-city housing leaders across the country,
|
|
Down's theory of "dispersed economic integration" was exactly reproduced in
|
|
HUD's Regional Housing Mobility Program Guidebook, issued six years after
|
|
Suburbs, in 1979.
|
|
|
|
Also by 1977, a mysterious "fair housing" group in Chicago, the Leadership
|
|
Council for Open Metropolitan Communities, was contracted by HUD to begin
|
|
mobility programming experiments on Black high-rise public housing tenants
|
|
in the Southside and Westside. It was called "The Gautreaux Demonstration
|
|
Program" and achieved in two years the removal to the far suburbs of 400
|
|
families. Materials from HUD's 1979 review of the Gatreaux experiment are
|
|
included in this anthology.
|
|
|
|
By 1974, the Congress had enacted the Community Development Act. The
|
|
legislation fused together the Urban Renewal programs of the Johnson era and
|
|
the Revenue Sharing programs of the Nixon Administration. The title to the
|
|
Act laid-out its theory: 1 -- reduce the geographic isolation of various
|
|
economic groups; 2 -- promote spatial deconcentration; 3 -- revitalize
|
|
inner-city neighborhoods for middle and upper-income groups.
|
|
|
|
It wasn't until 1975 that point four of Down's theory in Suburbs, rebuilding
|
|
the inner-cities, was fully analyzed. It was done in the form of the
|
|
"triage" report, completed under HUD contract while he was still president
|
|
of the Real Estate Research Corporation in Chicago; a firm founded by his
|
|
father, James, some twenty years before. In this report, Downs made it clear
|
|
that he wasn't projecting the inner-cities being rebuilt for its present
|
|
residents -- the minorities -- but for the white middle-class; the so-called
|
|
urban gentry; a theory completely compatible with the Community Development
|
|
Act of the previous year, Weissbourd's 1968 writings, and the Kerner
|
|
Commission findings. Under point four in Suburbs, Downs wrote that ". . .
|
|
new means of comprehensively 'managing' entire inner-city neighborhoods
|
|
should be developed to provide more effective means of withdrawing economic
|
|
support from housing units that ought to be demolished."
|
|
|
|
In his "triage" report, he wrote that Community Development funds should be
|
|
withheld from inner-city neighborhoods so as to allow ". . . a long-run
|
|
strategy of emptying out the most deteriorated areas. . ." A city's basic
|
|
strategy, he wrote, " . . . would be to accelerate their abandonment . .. ."
|
|
The land having been "banked," it could be redeveloped for the gentry. He
|
|
argued that instead of being given increased services, minority
|
|
neighborhoods should be infused with major demolition projects.
|
|
|
|
When Patricia Harris became Secretary of HUD two years after the enactment
|
|
of the Community Development Act and one year after the Section 8 Program
|
|
replaced the Section 235 and 236 housing subsidy programs, the General
|
|
Accounting Office, under the direction of Henry Eschwege, issued a stinging
|
|
review of the Department's policies. Noting that the Section 8 Program was
|
|
the ". . . principal federal program for housing lower-income persons . . ."
|
|
the 1978 report suggested, in threatening language, that "HUD needs to
|
|
develop an implementation plan for deconcentration . . ." The report argued
|
|
that ". . . freedom of choice . . ." was supposed to be the Department's
|
|
"primary intent," but that top HUD officials were confused about the policy.
|
|
HUD, the GAO insisted, was continuing to offer "revitalization" projects in
|
|
the inner-cities, which was concentrating poverty in the cities. This
|
|
policy, it stressed, was "incompatible" with spatial deconcentration.
|
|
|
|
In 1979, on the heels of the GAO report came HUD's Regional Housing Mobility
|
|
Program. The introduction of the program was itself bizarre, let alone the
|
|
program. The emergence of the program was kept so quiet that virtually no
|
|
grassroots community organizations in the country knew of its existence. The
|
|
activists in Philadelphia had not even been aware of its existence until
|
|
August of that year. It still wasn't until November that grassroots leaders
|
|
encountered an advisory council member to one of the planning agencies --
|
|
and that was in St. Louis -- who openly admitted that the program's success
|
|
depended on its "invisibility."
|
|
|
|
On August 3, 1979, the planning commission directors of 22 pre-selected
|
|
regions in the country were asked by HUD to gather in Washington to be
|
|
schooled on the mechanics of the program. They were given Guidebooks and
|
|
asked to return to their respective jurisdictions and prepare $75,000 to
|
|
$150,000 applications for the program. The Guidebook made it clear that
|
|
these regions had been specially selected because of their heavy
|
|
concentration of inner-city minorities. They were instructed to contact
|
|
major civil rights organizations and gain their "input" into the program. It
|
|
was not coincidental that the National Urban League was one of the very few
|
|
Black organizations that knew of the program's existence. After all, Vernon
|
|
Jordan, its president, sits on the board of trustees of the Urban Institute.
|
|
|
|
The Guidebook smacks of computer technology and is prepared with
|
|
mind-control phrases, such as establishing "beachheads" in "alien"
|
|
communities; initiating ". . . a long-term promotion of deconcentration;"
|
|
identifying ". . . homeseeker traits which operate . . . on a process of
|
|
suppression not selection;" and banking on the ". . . promotion of target
|
|
areas" that ". . . will require that natural inclinations be altered." True
|
|
to the Down's model established in Suburbs and Urban Problems, the Guidebook
|
|
carefully analyzes the financial inducements to be used by the government to
|
|
force minorities out of the cities and to force uncooperative suburban
|
|
landlords to accept the program.
|
|
|
|
The Guidebook makes it clear that the program is intended for major
|
|
expansion by 1982, when its funding base will be switched from
|
|
HUD-Washington to an assortment of agencies, interestingly including the
|
|
Community Development Block Grant funds, CETA, an the Ford, Rockerfeller and
|
|
Alcoa Foundations. The CETA job component clearly traced its theoretical
|
|
roots not only to Downs, but also to Weissbourd. The Guidebook also
|
|
carefully lays out the use of the Section 8 Program as a primary base for
|
|
mobility operations.
|
|
|
|
Once it became clear to inner-city housing leaders that the Mobility Program
|
|
was nothing more than the first in a set of mechanisms the government
|
|
intended to use to effectuate the ideas discussed in the Kerner Commission
|
|
Report, it was easy to organize concerned people around the issue. It was
|
|
actually a relief to some activists that proof had finally emerged of a real
|
|
master plan, and not merely another fictionalized account of some remote
|
|
possibility.
|
|
|
|
Less than one month after the Philadelphia leaders had made their final
|
|
contacts in Chicago and New York City, a five-city conference was organized
|
|
in Washington. Called the Grassroots Unity Conference, and held in January,
|
|
1980, it focussed on driving the message home to the government, through
|
|
HUD, that the masterplan had been exposed and efforts were being organized
|
|
in key regions of the country to stop it.
|
|
|
|
An almost violent meeting was held between top HUD officials and activists
|
|
from Washington, Chicago, St. Louis, New York and Philadelphia during the
|
|
two-day conference. A busload of inner-city residents literally invaded the
|
|
Urban Institute offices and persuaded its staff to hand over dozens of
|
|
documents that further reinforced community leader's arguments that a
|
|
masterplan existed, and that the Mobility Program was merely the first step
|
|
in a new series of programs designed to systematically empty the
|
|
inner-cities of their minority residents.
|
|
|
|
The friction slowly being generated between the government and the
|
|
inner-city communities over this programming and its exposure has the
|
|
potential of producing a major domestic crisis in the U.S. Housing and
|
|
community activists have for years been confused about the nature of the
|
|
deterioration of the inner-cities. The confusion often led to
|
|
disillusionment and bitter dissension that sometimes created malevolent
|
|
situations within the inner circles of community leaders and groups. Many
|
|
community leaders knew that the government was not an innocent party to the
|
|
problems of the cities, but few imagined the close association between it
|
|
and private market forces in systematically driving the poor and the Black
|
|
out of the cities.
|
|
|
|
Fewer still realized that the government had helped organize the "control"
|
|
strategy from its inception. Now that the masterplan is being slowly
|
|
uncovered by the persistent efforts of grassroots leaders and the confusion
|
|
within community groups is evaporating, it may not be possible to vent their
|
|
anger in non-destructive ways when the tale is finally told.
|
|
|
|
Some elements of the Black community, for instance, have argued for years
|
|
that the government had declared a "secret war" on Blacks in America. Now
|
|
evidence exists which makes the point difficult, if not impossible, to
|
|
defeat. At least, an innocent observer must ask the question: "What kind of
|
|
a government would allow these types of strategies to develop and thrive?"
|
|
Even more to the point, one must ask: "How stable can a government be with
|
|
such information emerging?" It now seems evident that the Constitution,
|
|
which the Kerner Commissioners and the Johnson Administration feared was in
|
|
need of special protections, does not apply to all people in America, but
|
|
only the white middle class. The only way the government can now disprove
|
|
this argument is to abolish all types of mobility programming and the
|
|
"thinktanks" that shaped it.
|
|
|
|
Researchers in all parts of the country who believe the government is
|
|
traveling a lethal path are now uncovering major pieces of evidence to show
|
|
the elaborate workings of the masterplan. Some of their arguments are
|
|
enclosed in Part III of this book, under the title, "The Minority Response."
|
|
Other technical data are enclosed in Part IV and V. Of particular interest
|
|
in Part V are the listings offered by the Urban Institute under housing
|
|
allowance programs. Section 8 experimentation takes up a good portion of the
|
|
available listings. A cursory examination of some of these papers -- and in
|
|
some instances a mere reading of the project titles -- plainly shows the
|
|
determination of the government to manipulate the Section 8 Program as a key
|
|
instrument to force inner-city residents to move into the suburbs through
|
|
the Mobility Program.
|
|
|
|
It aptly explains why these same researchers created the Section 8 Programs
|
|
in the first place. Included in Part IV are lists of Boards of Trustees of
|
|
the Brookings and Urban Institutes in Washington D.C. Attempts were made, in
|
|
preparation for this edition to include a listing of the Rockerfeller and
|
|
Ford Foundation's Boards of Trustees. These corporations, however, refused
|
|
to release their Annual Reports.
|
|
|
|
The exposure of the Mobility Program's real intentions will hopefully change
|
|
the direction of the government. If not, then the worse can be assumed for
|
|
the future of the U.S. because no righteous people on the face of the earth
|
|
would or should permit the existence of such policy, even if its
|
|
dismemberment means inevitable confrontation or conflagration.
|
|
|
|
Several aspects of this mobility programming have deliberately been avoided
|
|
at this time. Cyrus Vance, for instance, was Deputy Secretary of Defense at
|
|
the time of the Detroit riot of 1967 and the initiation of the Kerner
|
|
Commission Report. By 1980, Vance was Secretary of State, directly
|
|
responsible for at least one organization named in the Report, the Agency
|
|
for International Development (AID), widely reputed for its CIA ties. He was
|
|
also a trustee of the Urban Institute along with Robert NcNamara, chairman
|
|
of the World Bank and former Secretary of Defense under Johnson.
|
|
|
|
A reasonable question emerges at this point: Why is the military so closely
|
|
attached to this mobility programming? Or, worse: What does the military
|
|
intend to do in the event that this mobility-type programming fails, and the
|
|
Blacks and other minorities remain in large part in the cities into the turn
|
|
of the century, and riots create greater so-called threats to Constitutional
|
|
safeguards? After all, Downs, himself, stated in Suburbs that he believed
|
|
the mobility programming would fail. Is a repeat of the recent history of
|
|
Greece or Chile the logical answer to these questions? Did the military, in
|
|
1967, issue an ultimatum to the government to remove the Blacks and other
|
|
inner-city minorities to Black suburban "townships" in kid-glove fashion,
|
|
with the option, in case of failure, being the iron fist? Furthermore, how
|
|
could it have been possible for the surgical demolition operations in the
|
|
minority neighborhoods of the cities to be so identical in all major
|
|
American cities? Could any organization other than the Pentagon have done
|
|
this?
|
|
|
|
These questions have been left unexplored because the weight of available
|
|
documentation and the speed with which it is being collected and digested
|
|
has been burdensome on anti-mobility forces. Further, this discussion about
|
|
the military must be carefully explored by itself because of its obvious
|
|
sensitivity. Also left for "Book II" is the discussion concerning the
|
|
companion programs of the Mobility Program. Their successful exploration and
|
|
revelation may make Watergate look pale by comparison.
|
|
|