770 lines
44 KiB
Plaintext
770 lines
44 KiB
Plaintext
![]() |
Uncertainties
|
||
|
|
||
|
by Karen Linzer
|
||
|
|
||
|
Data was in his quarters, watching Spot chase mice. He had
|
||
|
designed a set of artificial mice, each programmed with various
|
||
|
evasive maneuvers, to see whether the cat could adapt his stalking
|
||
|
strategy to changes in the behavior of the prey. After an hour of
|
||
|
observation he had concluded that, insofar as hunting was
|
||
|
concerned, Spot was endowed with great enthusiasm and absolutely
|
||
|
no technique. Now he was watching merely to see whether Spot
|
||
|
understood the concept of futility.
|
||
|
The doorsignal chirped. Jriba MacKenzie, a cyberneticist, had
|
||
|
an appointment with him to discuss a new chip design. She had
|
||
|
been on board the Enterprise for four months as a civilian
|
||
|
consultant, modifying some of the artificial intelligence networks
|
||
|
in the ship's communication systems. She worked on other
|
||
|
cybernetics projects in her free time. As Jriba entered the room,
|
||
|
one of the mice escaped past her into the corridor; Data touched a
|
||
|
remote-control button to turn it off. Jriba glanced back at the now-
|
||
|
motionless mouse but didn't ask. Spot retrieved it, his tail held
|
||
|
high as he carried in his first kill.
|
||
|
Data and Jriba sat down at his desk. He turned on his
|
||
|
computer viewscreen and accessed his notes on Jriba's project. "I
|
||
|
have reviewed your design for an esthetic-response chip," he said.
|
||
|
"It appears promising, but I believe you have overlooked some
|
||
|
complications."
|
||
|
Data had several suggestions for improving the design, which
|
||
|
they discussed at length. He and Jriba had collaborated on a
|
||
|
number of projects since she came on board the Enterprise. At
|
||
|
times they also discussed Data's subjective experience as an
|
||
|
artificially-created consciousness. Although Jriba was curious
|
||
|
about him from a cybernetics perspective, it was clear to Data that
|
||
|
she viewed him as a person, not merely as an object of study. He
|
||
|
considered her a friend.
|
||
|
At last Data turned off his computer screen. He had another
|
||
|
topic to discuss with Jriba. "I would like to talk about my recent
|
||
|
experiences with the dream program, if you would not mind."
|
||
|
"Sure -- you know I'm always curious to hear about that.
|
||
|
What's been happening lately?" Spot had climbed into her lap while
|
||
|
they were reviewing the chip design; she scratched under his chin.
|
||
|
"Something which I did not believe was possible, and which
|
||
|
has preoccupied me for some time. I have been experiencing
|
||
|
sexually explicit dreams."
|
||
|
Jriba was surprised, though not by Data's candidness -- she'd
|
||
|
been exposed to that before. "Why wouldn't you -- I mean, why
|
||
|
would you think that was impossible? You're programmed for sex,
|
||
|
aren't you?" The advantage to Data's straightforwardness was that
|
||
|
he was never offended by blunt questions. She thought sometimes
|
||
|
that spending too much time with him could make a person lose all
|
||
|
sense of tact.
|
||
|
"I am programmed to emulate sexual behavior," he said. "I am
|
||
|
not programmed to experience desire or arousal. My sexual
|
||
|
functions are entirely under voluntary control."
|
||
|
"So why shouldn't you dream about exercising your, uh,
|
||
|
functions? It doesn't sound any stranger than dreaming about
|
||
|
anything else." Jriba was intrigued. She'd been curious about Data's
|
||
|
sexual programming, but they had never spoken about it before.
|
||
|
"The difference is that the dreams involve sensations which
|
||
|
are unfamiliar to me, and which have never occurred during the
|
||
|
waking activation of my sexual programs. I am not certain how to
|
||
|
evaluate these sensations, as I lack appropriate reference points,
|
||
|
but I suspect I am experiencing some form of sexual arousal."
|
||
|
The seriousness of his expression made her laugh. "I'm sorry,
|
||
|
Data -- it's just that you don't look very happy about it. Let me
|
||
|
rephrase that," she added, guessing he might be about to respond
|
||
|
literally. "I know you're never _happy_ about anything. I meant that
|
||
|
you seem concerned, and I don't see why. It could be a major
|
||
|
breakthrough for you."
|
||
|
"It is simply that I do not know where these sensations
|
||
|
are being generated, or what their long-term effects may be. To use
|
||
|
an aphorism, I do not know whether I have opened a can of worms."
|
||
|
Jriba sensed that he was holding something back. Data was
|
||
|
incapable of feeling embarrassment, but he was able to calculate
|
||
|
that certain information might provoke a negative reaction, and
|
||
|
should therefore be kept to himself. She would have to wait until he
|
||
|
was ready to tell her the rest of it. Meanwhile, she could offer a
|
||
|
small suggestion.
|
||
|
"Perhaps you should investigate the physical side-effects of
|
||
|
your dream program," she offered. "Has anyone ever checked to see
|
||
|
whether you experience rapid eye movement, for example?"
|
||
|
"Not as yet. Would that be relevant?"
|
||
|
"Well, humans seem to have an intrinsic connection between
|
||
|
dreaming and sex -- the rapid eye movement or REM sleep period,
|
||
|
when the dreams occur, is often accompanied by symptoms of
|
||
|
arousal. If you're designed the same way, you could simply be
|
||
|
experiencing some kind of spillover activation of your sexual
|
||
|
programs."
|
||
|
Data considered this. "I do not think it is that simple. The
|
||
|
normal activation of my sexual functions does not produce the
|
||
|
sensations I have experienced in my dreams. Nevertheless, you
|
||
|
have a point. I will ask the computer to monitor for physiological
|
||
|
changes when I next activate the dream function."
|
||
|
"Then if any turn up, you could run some tests and try to
|
||
|
identify the circuitry involved."
|
||
|
Data nodded but said nothing more. Jriba looked at him,
|
||
|
surprised. She'd never known Data to be reluctant to talk. She was
|
||
|
tempted to ask a few more questions, but decided not to pry.
|
||
|
Gently removing Spot from her lap, Jriba stood up and said
|
||
|
goodnight.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
After Jriba left, Data reflected on the situation. His dreams
|
||
|
were not precisely upsetting -- he was incapable of feeling upset --
|
||
|
but they required careful evaluation. He had not told Jriba
|
||
|
everything about the dreams. The imagery was not merely sexual,
|
||
|
but violent. Many of the things he did in the dreams would, in real
|
||
|
life, conflict with the ethical programming which monitored his
|
||
|
behavior.
|
||
|
Data had not discussed the dreams with Counselor Troi; he
|
||
|
supposed that she would merely tell him not to worry about it. He
|
||
|
had discussed his mental state with her on several other occasions,
|
||
|
and it seemed she gave essentially the same advice every time.
|
||
|
Jriba was usually more helpful. It seemed to him that she too
|
||
|
tended to take his concerns lightly, but when he could persuade her
|
||
|
to bring her analytical skills to bear, she often had useful insights.
|
||
|
Jriba's questions about REM sleep were intriguing, but Data
|
||
|
was unsure whether it was safe to continue exploring the dreams.
|
||
|
In the most recent dreams, he had experienced unfamiliar physical
|
||
|
sensations of surprising intensity. Of greater concern was the
|
||
|
possibility that he was responding emotionally as well -- a factor
|
||
|
with unpleasant implications. All of this was uncertain; as Jriba
|
||
|
had noted, he still had insufficient information about the effects of
|
||
|
the dreams.
|
||
|
Data could rarely resist the temptation of curiosity.
|
||
|
Requesting the computer to monitor his physiological responses, he
|
||
|
lay down on the bed and shut down all conscious functions,
|
||
|
activating the dream program.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
He was standing next to a large worktable of some kind, in
|
||
|
what appeared to be a laboratory. The walls were lined with shelves
|
||
|
on which lay an assortment of body parts -- android body parts, he
|
||
|
realized. Evidently this was a cybernetics laboratory.
|
||
|
A female lieutenant whom he did not recognize approached
|
||
|
him. "What do you want me to do now, sir?"
|
||
|
He could not understand why she thought he was in charge.
|
||
|
He stared at her, puzzled. "What is this place? And what are we
|
||
|
doing here?"
|
||
|
She looked at him strangely. "Don't you know? This _is_ your
|
||
|
project."
|
||
|
He remembered then: they were constructing some kind of
|
||
|
android. He had no idea what needed to be done at that moment,
|
||
|
however. The lieutenant was still waiting for him to give her
|
||
|
instructions. The thought that came to him seemed illogical; he
|
||
|
hesitated, confused. He could find no explanation for his impulse,
|
||
|
yet it seemed necessary to express it.
|
||
|
"Lieutenant, remove your uniform, please." She seemed
|
||
|
unperturbed by his request but did not comply. Taking hold of the
|
||
|
collar of her uniform, he tore the material down the front; it fell
|
||
|
away in shreds. He was momentarily aware of his own strength, and
|
||
|
the awareness provoked an unfamiliar sensation in him.
|
||
|
Taking hold of her hips, he lifted her onto the worktable. He
|
||
|
climbed up and pushed her down on her back. She struggled
|
||
|
slightly, but he easily pinned her hands above her head. His actions
|
||
|
made no sense to him, but he felt compelled to continue. In
|
||
|
addition to confusion, he noticed another sensation -- perhaps
|
||
|
excitement.
|
||
|
It seemed appropriate to restrain her somehow. He found
|
||
|
that there were straps attached to the table, apparently intended for
|
||
|
this purpose. She did not seem frightened, although she tried to
|
||
|
resist; her struggling intensified the sensation he perceived as
|
||
|
excitement. He found that he was now naked as well. He ran his
|
||
|
hands over her body, feeling a surge as he realized she was
|
||
|
extremely aroused. As he entered her his excitement peaked, the
|
||
|
physical sensations reaching an intensity that jolted him back to
|
||
|
consciousness.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
Data awoke with a sense of confusion that was becoming
|
||
|
familiar. This dream had been similar to the others -- different in
|
||
|
several specifics, but clearly involving the same themes. As before,
|
||
|
the symbolism was opaque. The cybernetics laboratory might have
|
||
|
some connection with Jriba's recent visit, but it was certain that
|
||
|
the female Starfleet lieutenant did not represent Jriba; not only
|
||
|
were they very different in appearance, but Jriba was a civilian. The
|
||
|
overall meaning of the dream completely eluded Data. He knew that
|
||
|
his skills in interpreting metaphoric symbolism were minimal, but
|
||
|
he was reluctant to ask anyone for assistance. Setting aside
|
||
|
interpretation for the moment, he mentally replayed the dream
|
||
|
several times, becoming absorbed in the images. He was surprised
|
||
|
when it was time to report to the bridge.
|
||
|
Data's duties on the bridge that day were routine, requiring
|
||
|
little attention. He accessed the ship's computer through his
|
||
|
console and began reading about the physiology of REM sleep. He
|
||
|
had been intrigued by the computer's report that he did in fact
|
||
|
experience rapid eye movement, along with symptoms of sexual
|
||
|
arousal. The shutdown of his conscious mind during the dream
|
||
|
program should have inactivated all sexual functions, as these were
|
||
|
normally under conscious, voluntary control. Now it seemed there
|
||
|
might be an involuntary component to his sexual programming,
|
||
|
perhaps accessible only through the dream function. He wondered
|
||
|
what its purpose might be.
|
||
|
For that matter, he was not certain why he had been
|
||
|
constructed with sexual functions of any kind, as he was incapable
|
||
|
of biological reproduction. The obvious hypothesis was that Dr.
|
||
|
Soong, the cyberneticist who created him, had wanted him to
|
||
|
participate fully in human experience -- except that his sexual
|
||
|
programs were clearly inadequate for complete participation. He
|
||
|
could perform sexually, but 'perform' was an apt description; he felt
|
||
|
no desire, no emotional response, and no physical pleasure. His only
|
||
|
reason to engage in sex was curiosity. Perhaps Dr. Soong had thought
|
||
|
of that, and had given him functional genitals only so that he could
|
||
|
closely observe this facet of human behavior.
|
||
|
Which left unexplained his experience of the most recent
|
||
|
dream. He was certain that he had felt both pleasure and
|
||
|
excitement, though he had thought this to be impossible. Emotions
|
||
|
were not part of his normal programming. Dr. Soong had designed
|
||
|
a chip to give him basic emotions, but Lore, the android created
|
||
|
before him, had stolen it. Lore later used the chip to induce violent
|
||
|
emotions in Data, causing him to behave sadistically. That incident
|
||
|
had convinced Data to abandon his lifelong wish of attaining
|
||
|
emotions; he believed their effects on him were too dangerous.
|
||
|
His relationship to Lore was the most disturbing aspect of the
|
||
|
situation. Data and Lore were virtually identical in construction --
|
||
|
"except for a bit of programming," Dr. Soong once said. Data would
|
||
|
have preferred to think that Dr. Soong had exaggerated the
|
||
|
similarity. Lore had the emotional capacity which Data lacked, a
|
||
|
fact which had once led Data to hope that their circuitry was
|
||
|
fundamentally different. The incident with the emotion chip had
|
||
|
removed that hope. He now knew that mere programming
|
||
|
modifications could give him the capacity for emotions -- and make
|
||
|
him as violent as Lore.
|
||
|
By activating the dream function, he had risked bringing an
|
||
|
unknown factor into his programming. He realized now that he had
|
||
|
not considered how unpredictable the consequences could be. It
|
||
|
occurred to him that he did not know whether Lore had ever
|
||
|
activated his dream function; perhaps a malfunction there had
|
||
|
contributed to his aberrations. Accessing subspace communications,
|
||
|
Data sent an inquiry to the Daystrom Institute, which had taken
|
||
|
Lore's components for study. He could think of no other avenue of
|
||
|
investigation at the moment. Perhaps he would discuss it with Jriba
|
||
|
later.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
Jriba came to his quarters again that evening. Data was
|
||
|
observing Spot's acrobatic abilities. He dangled a cord for Spot to
|
||
|
chase, pulling it up into the air and reversing direction suddenly to
|
||
|
see whether the cat could twist around in mid-leap. It seemed that
|
||
|
Spot could perform quite complex maneuvers, though at certain
|
||
|
angles and velocities they resulted in what could only be described
|
||
|
as a crash landing. By the time Jriba showed up, Spot had knocked
|
||
|
over an impressive number of objects. Data set the cord aside and
|
||
|
sat down at his desk.
|
||
|
Jriba took the chair next to his. "So, how have your dreams
|
||
|
been?"
|
||
|
"Intriguing." He did not wish to discuss the dream as yet. "I
|
||
|
have been thinking about Lore again. I believe we should investigate
|
||
|
his circuitry further."
|
||
|
"Again? I thought we gave up on that project a couple of
|
||
|
months ago." They had discussed Lore extensively when Jriba first
|
||
|
came on board the Enterprise, though it seemed she had lost
|
||
|
interest in the subject.
|
||
|
"We might have overlooked something. I realized today that
|
||
|
we do not know whether Lore ever activated his dream function. I
|
||
|
have sent an inquiry to the Daystrom Institute."
|
||
|
Jriba picked up the cord Data had used to play with Spot; she
|
||
|
began absently running it through her fingers. "Why do you want to
|
||
|
know about Lore's dream function?"
|
||
|
"It might be a clue to his malfunction." He hesitated. "I have
|
||
|
become concerned that my exploration of the dreams may lead to a
|
||
|
similar malfunction."
|
||
|
"Why would you think that?"
|
||
|
Data was unsure which factor to mention first. "I am now
|
||
|
convinced that the dreams are evoking emotional responses, though
|
||
|
only within a certain range -- primarily excitement. As you know, I
|
||
|
believe emotions were a central factor in Lore's instability." He
|
||
|
paused as a memory came to him. "Lore once told me that if I began
|
||
|
experiencing emotions, we would become more alike. The thought
|
||
|
does not appeal to me."
|
||
|
She shrugged. "I'm sure Lore said a lot of things."
|
||
|
"Indeed, he talked a great deal, though his range of topics was
|
||
|
rather limited --"
|
||
|
"That was an expression. I meant you shouldn't believe
|
||
|
whatever he said to win your sympathy." Jriba wound the cord
|
||
|
around one wrist. He found the gesture oddly distracting. "Look,
|
||
|
Dr. Soong once disassembled Lore because of his malfunctions. He
|
||
|
obviously didn't think there was anything wrong with _you_. For all
|
||
|
you know, he may have intended for your dream function to trigger
|
||
|
some kind of -- sexual awakening. It may just be another way the
|
||
|
dream function contributes to your creative and cognitive
|
||
|
development."
|
||
|
"Dr. Soong made a number of mistakes. Most significantly, he
|
||
|
underestimated Lore's capacity for violence, after he had been
|
||
|
reassembled."
|
||
|
"Nevertheless, Data, you can't go through life constantly
|
||
|
comparing yourself to Lore. It would be nice to be certain that you
|
||
|
could never malfunction the way Lore did, but I don't think we're
|
||
|
going to find any proof of that -- and meanwhile, obsessing on it is
|
||
|
going to cripple your own development."
|
||
|
"My similarity to Lore is not the only concern," he reminded
|
||
|
her. "Past events have demonstrated that emotions have dangerous
|
||
|
effects on me."
|
||
|
"Only under some circumstances," she insisted. "Maybe you
|
||
|
do have a latent capacity for emotion -- but it probably wouldn't
|
||
|
have manifested in such a nasty way if Lore hadn't been manipulating
|
||
|
things. Mere excitement doesn't sound that bad."
|
||
|
Data hesitated, unsure how to convince her to take the
|
||
|
problem seriously. "There is another factor which I have not
|
||
|
mentioned. I find myself committing violent acts in these dreams,
|
||
|
suggesting that this aspect of my sexual functioning may involve
|
||
|
hostility."
|
||
|
Jriba stopped fidgeting with the cord. "'Violent acts'? That's
|
||
|
very interesting." She looked at him curiously. "You shouldn't jump
|
||
|
to conclusions, though. Before you decide it's hostility, I think you
|
||
|
need to sort out whether you're actually feeling hostile emotions in
|
||
|
these dreams. For example, how do your feelings compare with
|
||
|
what you felt when Lore was controlling you?"
|
||
|
It had not occurred to him to compare the feelings in detail.
|
||
|
He hesitated, reluctant to re-experience those particular memories.
|
||
|
He knew from experience, however, that Jriba's suggestions were
|
||
|
usually worth pursuing. Asking her to excuse him for a few
|
||
|
moments, Data closed his eyes and began accessing memories.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
Waiting for Data to come back to the conversation, Jriba asked
|
||
|
herself whether she had the stamina to see him through another
|
||
|
round of obsession with Lore. She knew that the incident with the
|
||
|
emotion chip had left Data with an urgent need to determine the
|
||
|
cause of Lore's instability, even after Lore had been deactivated and
|
||
|
disassembled for the last time. The fact that they were almost
|
||
|
identical had taken on a new significance, one which apparently did
|
||
|
not sit well with Data's ethical programming. When Jriba came on
|
||
|
board the Enterprise, Data immediately asked for her assistance.
|
||
|
They spent weeks reviewing the analyses of Lore's badly-damaged
|
||
|
circuitry and the incomplete notes recovered from Dr. Soong's
|
||
|
laboratory. Their friendship developed as Data confided his
|
||
|
concerns to her; she gathered it was hard for him to discuss the
|
||
|
matter with his other friends, particularly Geordi.
|
||
|
After several weeks, Jriba had concluded that they weren't
|
||
|
going to figure out what had gone wrong with Lore. By then Data's
|
||
|
fixation was starting to seem excessive. She tried once to nudge
|
||
|
him out of it, telling him he was in danger of developing an
|
||
|
obsessive neurosis known as Evil Twin Syndrome; this backfired
|
||
|
when he became intrigued and she was forced to admit she'd made
|
||
|
it up. At last Data had seemed to accept that he wasn't going to find
|
||
|
any guarantees for himself other than the fact that, without the
|
||
|
emotion chip, he had no emotions. Now that this had become
|
||
|
uncertain, it looked as if he was going to get hung up on the same
|
||
|
problem again.
|
||
|
Data opened his eyes at last. "I believe the emotions are
|
||
|
largely different," he said, "though it is difficult to be certain. It
|
||
|
appears however that I am not as yet experiencing violent emotions,
|
||
|
such as rage. I have ascertained also that there is no impairment of
|
||
|
my ethical programs, as there was when Lore was controlling me."
|
||
|
"I didn't think there would be."
|
||
|
"Nevertheless," he continued, "further exploration of the
|
||
|
dream function would involve an unacceptable risk. If I have a latent
|
||
|
potential for violent emotion, I may be on the verge of accessing it
|
||
|
unintentionally. I should not take that chance."
|
||
|
Jriba had had all she could take of his self-flagellation. "Data,
|
||
|
if you're not willing to take chances, you're not willing to live," she
|
||
|
snapped. "For gods' sake, all we know for certain is that you have a
|
||
|
lot of unexplored potential. If you're going to stop exploring
|
||
|
because you _might_ find something inside yourself that you don't
|
||
|
like -- then you might as well deactivate yourself right now,
|
||
|
permanently."
|
||
|
She stopped herself; she hadn't meant to yell at him. Gods
|
||
|
forbid, if he thought he was turning into another Lore, he might
|
||
|
decide deactivating himself was the best response. After a moment
|
||
|
she smiled ruefully and added, "And then the rest of us should all
|
||
|
kill ourselves too, because we don't come with any guarantees
|
||
|
either."
|
||
|
He cocked his head, eyebrows raised thoughtfully. "If I
|
||
|
understand your meaning, you are saying that being uncertain of
|
||
|
one's capacity for evil is part of being human. That is something for
|
||
|
me to consider."
|
||
|
There was a silence. Jriba dangled the cord in front of Spot,
|
||
|
once again in her lap; he did not appear interested. Data seemed to
|
||
|
have brightened slightly, but the atmosphere in the room remained
|
||
|
heavy. Jriba wanted to change the subject.
|
||
|
"Data, there's something I've been curious about -- but please
|
||
|
let me know if you don't want to discuss it."
|
||
|
"What do you wish to know?"
|
||
|
"To put it very straightforwardly -- why would you ever have
|
||
|
sex? Not in your dreams, in real life. I know you don't feel
|
||
|
emotions, and you've told me you don't experience physical
|
||
|
pleasure. Do you get anything out of it?"
|
||
|
"Yes, of course." He seemed surprised by the question. "I am
|
||
|
fascinated by all aspects of human life, and sexuality plays a central
|
||
|
role in human experience. I am sure I have a great deal to learn
|
||
|
about it. Unfortunately, I am seldom given opportunities to exercise
|
||
|
my curiosity in that area."
|
||
|
It was her turn to be surprised. "Why not?"
|
||
|
He considered. "I do not know. Given the information I have
|
||
|
on human sexual taboos, I would speculate that most humans find
|
||
|
the prospect of sex with an android -- distasteful." Data looked as
|
||
|
close to pained as she had ever seen him. "I only know that I am
|
||
|
very rarely requested to access those programs."
|
||
|
Suddenly she figured it out. It struck her as both hilarious and
|
||
|
heartbreaking. "Oh my gods.... Data, I think you've been
|
||
|
misunderstanding something. You never initiate sex, right? You
|
||
|
only, umm, access your programs when someone asks you to?"
|
||
|
"That is correct. I cannot judge when it would be appropriate
|
||
|
to initiate sexual contact, and so I do not attempt to do so; I merely
|
||
|
respond when given an explicit invitation."
|
||
|
"An explicit invitation," she repeated, still amazed. "You mean
|
||
|
the woman has to come right out and ask you to go to bed with
|
||
|
her?"
|
||
|
He looked puzzled. "I believe that is what I just said. Do you
|
||
|
find this remarkable?"
|
||
|
She struggled not to laugh. "Data, I can't imagine very many
|
||
|
women would have the nerve to ask. If a woman is interested, she'll
|
||
|
try to make sure the interest is mutual before saying anything
|
||
|
direct. But you don't take hints. A woman could try every flirtation
|
||
|
technique in the book, and finally she'd give up and leave. Nobody is
|
||
|
going to give you an 'explicit invitation' out of the blue -- not unless
|
||
|
she's incredibly brazen, or drunk out of her mind."
|
||
|
Data's face went blank; she knew that meant he was thinking
|
||
|
intently, perhaps accessing memory files. "What you suggest would
|
||
|
account for certain things," he said at last. "It is a more appealing
|
||
|
theory than my previous explanation."
|
||
|
She smiled. "I am sure that plenty of women would love to ask
|
||
|
you, if they thought you would say yes." Feeling suddenly
|
||
|
emboldened, she leaned forward and took his hand. "Data, would
|
||
|
you like to exercise your curiosity with me?"
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
Data took Jriba into his bedroom, after pausing to evaluate the
|
||
|
situation. He knew from one previous experience that a sexual
|
||
|
liaison with a friend could lead to awkwardness later, but this did
|
||
|
not seem to be a danger with Jriba. Unlike Tasha Yar, Jriba seemed
|
||
|
unlikely to suffer embarrassment over the incident, or to deny
|
||
|
afterwards that it had occurred. On reflection, he realized he had
|
||
|
never known Jriba to suffer embarrassment over anything.
|
||
|
He accessed his basic sexuality programs, which informed him
|
||
|
that it would be appropriate for them to sit down on the bed at this
|
||
|
point, while still clothed. He told the computer to partially dim the
|
||
|
lights.
|
||
|
Jriba put her hand on his shoulder and leaned over to kiss
|
||
|
him. Data checked his systems once again. He felt intense
|
||
|
curiosity, but other than that, he felt nothing. All functions
|
||
|
appeared to be normal.
|
||
|
"Maybe we should get undressed now," she suggested.
|
||
|
He was aware of Jriba watching him as he undressed. "White
|
||
|
all over," she murmured as they lay down on the bed, facing each
|
||
|
other. "But you're as warm as a human, and nicer to touch -- your
|
||
|
skin is silky, not like most men's."
|
||
|
Jriba guided his hand to her breast, and he felt her nipple
|
||
|
harden beneath his fingers. Her hands roamed over his body,
|
||
|
caressing his hips and thighs before moving to his genitals. His
|
||
|
programs told him she would expect a physiological response to her
|
||
|
touch; he activated that mechanism.
|
||
|
Jriba stroked his penis, looking at his face as if searching for
|
||
|
a reaction. "I suppose you don't feel much of anything when I do
|
||
|
this?"
|
||
|
"I am incapable of feeling pleasure," he replied. "Though I
|
||
|
observe that the sensation in that part of my body differs subtly
|
||
|
from other tactile inputs. I was not previously aware of this, and I
|
||
|
cannot specify the nature of the additional sensory information."
|
||
|
"That's okay." She moved her hand away from his penis,
|
||
|
resting her fingers lightly on his hip. "It's just that, since you don't
|
||
|
get turned on -- I just hope you're not bored."
|
||
|
"I assure you, I am not bored."
|
||
|
She smiled. "You're curious, right?"
|
||
|
She did not appear to be displeased; nevertheless he wanted
|
||
|
to make sure. "Does that disturb you? I am aware that my sexual
|
||
|
functioning may seem cold and, perhaps, artificial."
|
||
|
She pressed his hand in what he understood to be a gesture of
|
||
|
reassurance. "Data, I think that if curiosity is how you approach sex,
|
||
|
then it's authentic for you. Besides, I'm fairly curious myself."
|
||
|
Jriba kissed him again, gently parting his lips with her tongue.
|
||
|
With her arm around his waist, she pulled herself closer to him, one
|
||
|
leg intertwined with his. The increase in her body temperature
|
||
|
told him that she was becoming aroused.
|
||
|
Data was uncertain how to proceed. His programs suggested a
|
||
|
range of options, but he did not know which might meet with her
|
||
|
approval. He thought it best to inquire. "Would you like me to
|
||
|
stimulate you manually or orally?"
|
||
|
Her eyes flew open. "Uh, either would be nice. Manually, I
|
||
|
guess."
|
||
|
Assured that this was acceptable to her, he proceeded. He ran
|
||
|
his finger gently between her labia, almost but not quite touching
|
||
|
her clitoris. She sighed and let herself fall back slightly, opening
|
||
|
her legs wider as he continued to stroke her.
|
||
|
His programs told him that women often enjoyed stimulation
|
||
|
of their nipples as well. "Would you like me to touch your breasts?
|
||
|
I could also -- "
|
||
|
"No -- I guess -- just do what you were doing, that felt nice."
|
||
|
He continued to stroke her genitals, but he had detected a
|
||
|
change; her breathing indicated she was no longer aroused. He
|
||
|
stopped touching her. "What would you like me to do next?"
|
||
|
Jriba pulled back slightly and propped herself up on one
|
||
|
elbow, facing him. She hesitated a long moment before answering.
|
||
|
"Data, I was just wondering -- could you possibly be a bit more, uh...
|
||
|
assertive?"
|
||
|
"Certainly. Being unfamiliar with your preferences, I thought
|
||
|
it best to proceed cautiously. Do you prefer an aggressive partner?"
|
||
|
Jriba looked surprised. "Can you do that? Completely
|
||
|
different styles, I mean?" She sat up, frowning slightly.
|
||
|
"Of course." He sat up as well. "I am programmed in multiple
|
||
|
techniques. I have also read extensively on human sexual practices,
|
||
|
and have incorporated the information into my programs."
|
||
|
"I see. And when you say 'aggressive', you mean...?"
|
||
|
"I can assume complete control of the encounter, if you wish."
|
||
|
Her eyes widened; he took that to mean she was interested. He
|
||
|
elaborated, "I have various programs for what is commonly called
|
||
|
'domination', ranging from the use of different forms of restraint, to
|
||
|
the infliction of pain without permanent physical damage."
|
||
|
"Oh." She was obviously intrigued, though perhaps uncertain
|
||
|
how to respond. "Well... to be perfectly honest, I often have
|
||
|
fantasies about being, mm, dominated. In fact, I had one lover who
|
||
|
used to do that, and I definitely enjoyed it. I'd be interested in doing
|
||
|
that with you -- but without any pain," she added quickly.
|
||
|
Data nodded and began accessing the necessary programs. He
|
||
|
stopped as certain implications occurred to him. "I believe it would
|
||
|
be inadvisable to proceed at this time. There may be danger of a
|
||
|
malfunction."
|
||
|
"What kind of malfunction?"
|
||
|
"I... cannot specify. I am not entirely certain that there is a
|
||
|
danger; it is only speculation. Nevertheless I think we should
|
||
|
discontinue."
|
||
|
Jriba looked at him strangely. "You're thinking about your
|
||
|
dreams, right? I had a feeling, when you said 'violent acts', that I
|
||
|
knew what you meant. You're afraid this is getting too close to
|
||
|
whatever part of you is coming out in your dreams." Oddly, this did
|
||
|
not appear to make her nervous; in fact he was fairly certain that
|
||
|
she was displaying signs of increased interest.
|
||
|
"You are essentially correct, although the word 'afraid' does
|
||
|
not strictly apply. Until I understand the full effects of the dreams,
|
||
|
I hesitate to access programs which closely approximate my dream
|
||
|
behavior. I might be risking interference from the dream function
|
||
|
on my conscious mind." He had experienced such interference
|
||
|
once before, in very different circumstances; that incident
|
||
|
culminated in his stabbing Counselor Troi.
|
||
|
"Look, Data, I think I've got a pretty good guess what these
|
||
|
dreams are like, and I'm willing to bet that they aren't dangerous or
|
||
|
- or evil, or whatever it is you're worried about. You said they don't
|
||
|
involve rage or other hostile emotions, isn't that right?"
|
||
|
"Insofar as I am aware, that is correct."
|
||
|
"And does anyone in these dreams get hurt?"
|
||
|
He accessed his memories. "I do not believe so."
|
||
|
"Then what are you worried about?" Jriba took both his hands
|
||
|
in hers. "Look, I don't know exactly what being, uh, 'dominant' is
|
||
|
about, in psychological terms, but my ex-lover used to try to explain
|
||
|
it. He said it had something to do with 'claiming your power to
|
||
|
create an experience' -- realizing your ability to evoke an intense
|
||
|
response in someone." She looked at him intently. "In other words,
|
||
|
maybe these dreams mean that you're developing a sense of potency
|
||
|
- wanting to have a strong effect on another person, especially
|
||
|
sexually."
|
||
|
He had not even remotely imagined such an interpretation,
|
||
|
and had no ready reply. Her suggestion might make a certain
|
||
|
amount of sense, but he would need to consider it at length. At the
|
||
|
least, the observation that he did not inflict physical injuries in the
|
||
|
dreams suggested that the danger might be less than he had
|
||
|
supposed. He noted also that he had not as yet experienced any
|
||
|
symptoms of malfunction.
|
||
|
After a moment Jriba asked, "In any case, have you ever had a
|
||
|
chance to use these particular programs?"
|
||
|
He shook his head.
|
||
|
"I didn't think so. And so you may never know how they would
|
||
|
work in real life." She sat back then and waited.
|
||
|
Data found once again that he had little defense against a
|
||
|
direct appeal to his curiosity. "Very well. But you must inform me
|
||
|
immediately if you wish me to stop."
|
||
|
"Of course. We can set up a safeword -- if I want you to stop,
|
||
|
I'll say 'Exit', like on the holodeck."
|
||
|
Consulting his programs, he realized that he would need one
|
||
|
piece of equipment. "I will be back momentarily." He stood up and
|
||
|
went into the next room to use the replicator.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
Spot had jumped up on the bed while they were talking. Jriba
|
||
|
carried him over to a chair, admonishing him to stay put. It was all
|
||
|
she could do not to burst out laughing at the irony of dragging Data
|
||
|
into taking a dominant role, practically against his will. She
|
||
|
wondered if he could possibly be any good at it; the whole thing
|
||
|
might easily turn out to be ridiculous. He might tie her up and ask,
|
||
|
"What would you like me to do next?"
|
||
|
She heard Data coming back into the room; before she could
|
||
|
turn around, he suddenly picked her up and dropped her onto the
|
||
|
bed. She landed on her back, gasping in surprise. "My gods -- you
|
||
|
startled me," she said quickly. He did not reply, but moved to pin
|
||
|
her arms above her head, holding both her wrists in one hand.
|
||
|
Feeling suddenly exposed, she turned to one side, pulling her knees
|
||
|
up to cover herself. With his other hand he took hold of her hip
|
||
|
and pulled her flat onto her back. He looked down at her as if
|
||
|
searching for clues to her reaction.
|
||
|
She squirmed slightly, wondering what would happen next.
|
||
|
Her wrists were going numb in his grip, and she could not move her
|
||
|
hips more than one or two centimeters. She'd known he was
|
||
|
strong, but she hadn't imagined it would feel like being caught in a
|
||
|
vise. She could also feel herself becoming aroused as she struggled
|
||
|
against him. "What are you going to do with me?" she asked. A
|
||
|
cliche, but she couldn't think of anything more clever to say.
|
||
|
"I have not decided yet." Apparently he was programmed for
|
||
|
this kind of dialogue; she giggled nervously. He suddenly turned
|
||
|
her onto her stomach and pulled her arms behind her back. He
|
||
|
wrapped some kind of strap several times around her wrists, pulling
|
||
|
it tight and fastening it. She tried to pull her wrists apart, half
|
||
|
expecting to find that he had tied them only loosely, symbolically; a
|
||
|
shockwave of arousal went through her as she found that she was
|
||
|
securely bound. She was beginning to think that Data had not been
|
||
|
exaggerating when he said he could take complete control.
|
||
|
He turned her onto her back again; she was startled by the
|
||
|
ease with which he manipulated her body. Lifting her hips, he
|
||
|
pulled her to the edge of the bed, leaving only her upper body on
|
||
|
the bed. He pushed her legs apart and knelt between her legs to
|
||
|
look at her closely. She felt his hands between her thighs and then
|
||
|
his fingers spreading her open. She was intensely aware of his
|
||
|
curiosity; she found it suddenly disconcerting.
|
||
|
Jriba gasped as Data's tongue stroked between her labia; her
|
||
|
body jerked slightly and she felt the pressure of his hands on her
|
||
|
pelvis, holding her in place. His tongue probed her cleft again, and
|
||
|
then he pulled back momentarily; she guessed he was analyzing the
|
||
|
taste and smell of her wetness. She shivered slightly as his fingers
|
||
|
spread her more fully open, exposing her clitoris. Again he paused,
|
||
|
looking at her, before continuing to explore her with his tongue.
|
||
|
She moaned softly, feeling herself opening to him.
|
||
|
After a short time Data pulled away from her and stood up.
|
||
|
Jriba looked up at him, slightly apprehensive. She was suddenly
|
||
|
aware of feeling very vulnerable and exposed, her hands still behind
|
||
|
her back. Data knelt on the bed beside her. His face was
|
||
|
expressionless as he pulled her knees up and apart. His fingers
|
||
|
brushed lightly between her legs and she squirmed, wanting to be
|
||
|
touched more firmly. Then she gasped as he pushed two fingers
|
||
|
into her. She knew she was dripping wet; his fingers slipped easily
|
||
|
between her labia. She groaned as his fingers slid in and out of her,
|
||
|
bringing her closer to orgasm. Despite her intense excitement, she
|
||
|
felt a twinge of nervousness. Data had changed somehow; the
|
||
|
thought of being under his control no longer seemed entirely safe.
|
||
|
Data seemed to move in an uneven, mechanical way, as he
|
||
|
always did when he was fascinated by something. She could see that
|
||
|
he was observing her reactions as he touched her; his head jerked
|
||
|
slightly as he scanned her body. Data suddenly seemed very much
|
||
|
an android, his demeanour entirely unlike his usual childlike
|
||
|
curiosity. He was obviously enthralled by the effect he was having
|
||
|
on her. He flexed his hand, pressing the heel of his palm against her
|
||
|
clitoris as his fingers moved inside her. She gasped, reflexively
|
||
|
pulling away slightly and raising her upper body; immediately he
|
||
|
moved his other hand to her shoulder, pinning her against the bed.
|
||
|
The awareness of being totally helpless pushed her over the edge to
|
||
|
orgasm; she spread her legs wider as she climaxed, opening herself
|
||
|
to him more fully. As her orgasm faded, she was aware that Data
|
||
|
had stopped stroking her and was now sitting motionless, simply
|
||
|
watching.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
Data hesitated, struggling to understand what was happening
|
||
|
to him. At first he had been merely curious, dispassionately
|
||
|
following his programs -- but as Jriba began to respond to him, he
|
||
|
felt a change. Something similar to the experience in his dreams
|
||
|
was happening, as curiosity had given way to a sensation that could
|
||
|
only be excitement. And yet his ethical programming was not
|
||
|
objecting, and he found that he did not wish to stop. His earlier
|
||
|
concerns seemed trivial compared to the fascination of observing
|
||
|
Jriba's responses. He had never imagined he could affect another
|
||
|
being so intensely. Every detail -- her wetness, her movements, the
|
||
|
sounds she made -- brought a surge of excitement. He wanted to
|
||
|
continue, to see what the limits were to her responsiveness.
|
||
|
Data turned Jriba onto her stomach. Her hands were still tied
|
||
|
behind her back. He knelt between her legs, spreading her thighs
|
||
|
to look at her more closely. She was extremely wet, and her
|
||
|
swollen clitoris and labia indicated that she was still aroused, even
|
||
|
after her orgasm. He stroked her gently and she moaned,
|
||
|
squirming slightly; her reaction sent another jolt through him. He
|
||
|
decided to initiate intercourse, and was surprised to find that he
|
||
|
already had an erection; he did not remember accessing that
|
||
|
subroutine.
|
||
|
He mounted her, resting his weight on one arm as his other
|
||
|
hand guided his penis into her. She groaned softly as it slid fully
|
||
|
into her. He reached around to find her clitoris as he began to
|
||
|
thrust, short sharp movements that made her gasp repeatedly as
|
||
|
her body was driven down against the bed. He found that he was
|
||
|
experiencing intense sensations in his penis, similar to those in his
|
||
|
dreams. He was no longer concerned about interference effects;
|
||
|
whatever part of him had been concerned was quiet now, drowned
|
||
|
out in the rush of excitement.
|
||
|
He needed to see Jriba's face, to see the effect he was having
|
||
|
on her. Reaching down to release her hands from the strap, he
|
||
|
turned her onto her back. He rubbed his penis between her legs,
|
||
|
feeling another upwelling of excitement when she moaned and
|
||
|
pressed herself harder against him. Her desire made him aware of
|
||
|
his body, his being, in a new way; the change in perspective was
|
||
|
exhilarating. He pinned her hands beside her head, resting his
|
||
|
weight on his knees and elbows. With a quick movement of his hips
|
||
|
he pushed himself into her again. The sensations in his penis were
|
||
|
stronger now; with a shock he realized that he was enjoying these
|
||
|
sensations, enjoying the entire experience.
|
||
|
Data stopped moving then, pausing to focus on this novel
|
||
|
awareness. Still holding Jriba's wrists, he raised himself up to look
|
||
|
at her. He held himself motionless, feeling her pushing ineffectually
|
||
|
against his hands; the sudden awareness of his own strength excited
|
||
|
him. He moved his pelvis slightly, just enough to see her react. He
|
||
|
realized he liked being inside her, liked pinning her down, feeling
|
||
|
her tightness and her small movements as she squirmed as if trying
|
||
|
to stimulate herself against him. He wanted to be inside her even
|
||
|
further, to be inside her mind.
|
||
|
"Does it excite you to feel my penis inside you?" he asked.
|
||
|
"Of course," she said, almost whispering.
|
||
|
An unexpected thought occurred, one he could not have
|
||
|
imagined before. "And does it excite you, knowing that you are
|
||
|
being penetrated by an android?"
|
||
|
Jriba blushed, embarrassed at last; she did not answer. He
|
||
|
tightened his grip on her wrists, not enough to cause real pain.
|
||
|
"Tell me," he ordered.
|
||
|
"Yes, it turns me on -- I can't stop thinking about it," she
|
||
|
confessed in a rush.
|
||
|
Her response evoked a deep need in him. He began to thrust,
|
||
|
closing his eyes to focus on the sensations in his penis. He felt her
|
||
|
climax, her contractions intensifying his own pleasure. He groaned
|
||
|
and felt his body jerk hard several times as his circuits were
|
||
|
flooded with sensation.
|
||
|
|
||
|
***
|
||
|
|
||
|
Data opened his eyes and looked at Jriba. He was momentarily
|
||
|
concerned that he might have injured her, but she did not appear to
|
||
|
be in pain. He rolled over and lay on his side next to her.
|
||
|
Jriba turned to face him, smiling. "Data, that was wonderful,"
|
||
|
she said softly. Taking his hand, she added, "And slightly
|
||
|
surprising -- I have to admit, I didn't know you had that in you."
|
||
|
"It was a revelation to me as well." He did not know what else
|
||
|
to say as yet; he would need time to evaluate the experience.
|
||
|
"I thought it might be." She looked at him curiously. "You
|
||
|
actually -- felt something, didn't you."
|
||
|
"Yes," he replied. "The experience was much like my recent
|
||
|
dreams -- though the sensations were more intense."
|
||
|
"How exciting for you. I'm glad I got to share the experience
|
||
|
with you." Jriba kissed him lightly. "How do you feel now?"
|
||
|
He considered. "I am not experiencing any emotions at the
|
||
|
moment. I believe all systems are functioning normally, though I
|
||
|
will need to run some diagnostics."
|
||
|
She nodded. "Data, would you mind if I slept here? I'd like
|
||
|
to be close to you for a while -- but I know you don't need to sleep,
|
||
|
and I don't want to keep you from whatever you want to do."
|
||
|
He realized that he did not wish for her to leave just yet. "You
|
||
|
are most welcome to stay," he said. "The experience has given me a
|
||
|
great deal to consider; I intend to spend the next several hours in
|
||
|
contemplation."
|
||
|
Certain questions demanded to be addressed immediately.
|
||
|
His ethical programs had not objected to anything he had done or
|
||
|
felt during the encounter with Jriba. This might mean that he had
|
||
|
done nothing unethical, or it could be an indication that his ethical
|
||
|
programs were not functioning properly. He closed his eyes and ran
|
||
|
several self-diagnostics.
|
||
|
"My ethical programming is unimpaired," he announced
|
||
|
several moments later, opening his eyes. "Yet I am intrigued to find
|
||
|
that it did not interfere with my responses during our encounter."
|
||
|
Jriba had gotten under the covers. She raised her eyebrows at
|
||
|
his remark. "Data, if your ethical programming said you couldn't
|
||
|
give someone an experience like that, I'd say it needed adjusting."
|
||
|
"My actions would not, in themselves, be unethical -- provided
|
||
|
that you granted consent. But my emotional reaction requires
|
||
|
additional evaluation. To enjoy controlling another being --"
|
||
|
"One who enjoyed being controlled," she reminded him. She
|
||
|
yawned. "I'm sorry, but I think you're going to have to sort out your
|
||
|
ethical programs by yourself; I don't think I can keep my eyes open
|
||
|
another minute." She smiled and added, "But I want to thank you
|
||
|
for a wonderful evening -- and for making yourself vulnerable like
|
||
|
that."
|
||
|
He frowned, perplexed. "I would thank you for the experience
|
||
|
as well. But perhaps you are mistaken in your choice of the word
|
||
|
'vulnerable'. The term does not properly apply, as I was the one in
|
||
|
control."
|
||
|
"If you say so." Jriba lay back and closed her eyes.
|
||
|
Data added her comment to his list of things to ponder. He
|
||
|
was suddenly certain that several hours would not be nearly enough
|
||
|
time to sort it all out.
|
||
|
|