651 lines
34 KiB
Plaintext
651 lines
34 KiB
Plaintext
![]() |
10 page printout.
|
|||
|
Reproducible Electronic Publishing can defeat censorship.
|
|||
|
**** ****
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This file, its printout, or copies of either
|
|||
|
are to be copied and given away, but NOT sold.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom, Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Works of ROBERT G. INGERSOLL
|
|||
|
**** ****
|
|||
|
Part 3 -- FIELD - INGERSOLL debate.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
1887
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
My Dear Colonel Ingersoll:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
I have read your Reply to my Open Letter half a dozen times,
|
|||
|
and each time with new appreciation of your skill as an advocate.
|
|||
|
It is written with great ingenuity, and furnishes probably as
|
|||
|
complete an argument as you are able to give for the faith (or want
|
|||
|
of faith) that is in you. Doubtless you think it unanswerable, and
|
|||
|
so it will seem to those who are predisposed to your way of
|
|||
|
thinking. To quote a homely saying of Mr. Lincoln, in which there
|
|||
|
is as much of wisdom as of wit, "For those who like that sort of
|
|||
|
thing, no doubt that is the sort of thing they do like." You may
|
|||
|
answer that we, who cling to the faith of our fathers, are equally
|
|||
|
prejudiced, and that it is for that reason that we are not more
|
|||
|
impressed by the force of your pleading. I do not deny a strong
|
|||
|
leaning that way, and yet our real interest is the same -- to get
|
|||
|
at the truth; and, therefore, I have tried to give due weight to
|
|||
|
whatever of argument there is in the midst of so much eloquence;
|
|||
|
but must confess that, in spite of all, I remain in the same
|
|||
|
obdurate frame of mind as before. With all the candor that I can
|
|||
|
bring to bear upon the question, I find on reviewing my Open Letter
|
|||
|
scarcely a sentence to change and nothing to withdraw; and am quite
|
|||
|
willing to leave it as my Declaration of Faith -- to stand side by
|
|||
|
side with your Reply, for intelligent and candid men to judge
|
|||
|
between us. I need only to add a few words in taking leave of the
|
|||
|
subject.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
You seem a little disturbed that "some of my brethren should
|
|||
|
look upon you as "a monster" because of your unbelief. I certainly
|
|||
|
do not approve of such language, although they would tell me that
|
|||
|
it is the only word which is a fit response to your ferocious
|
|||
|
attacks upon what they hold most sacred. You are a born gladiator,
|
|||
|
and when you descend into the arena, you strike heavy blows, which
|
|||
|
provoke blows in return. In this very Reply you manifest a
|
|||
|
particular animosity against Presbyterians. Is it because you were
|
|||
|
brought up in that Church, of which your father, whom you regard
|
|||
|
with filial respect and affection, was an honored minister? You
|
|||
|
even speak of "the Presbyterian God! "as if we assumed to
|
|||
|
appropriate the Supreme Being, claiming to be the special objects
|
|||
|
of His favor. Is there any ground for this imputation of
|
|||
|
narrowness? On the contrary, when we bow our knees before our
|
|||
|
Maker, it is as the God and Father of all mankind and the
|
|||
|
expression you permit yourself to use, can only be regarded as
|
|||
|
grossly offensive. Was it necessary to offer this rudeness to the
|
|||
|
religious denomination in which you were born?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
1
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
And this may explain, what you do not seem fully to
|
|||
|
understand, why it is that you are sometimes treated to sharp
|
|||
|
epithets by the religious press and public. You think yourself
|
|||
|
persecuted for your opinions. But others hold the same opinions
|
|||
|
without offence. Nor is it because you express your opinions.
|
|||
|
Nobody would deny you the same freedom which is accorded to Huxley
|
|||
|
or Herbert Spencer. It is not because you exercise your liberty of
|
|||
|
judgment or of speech, but because of the way in which you attack
|
|||
|
others, holding up their faith to all manner of ridicule, and
|
|||
|
speaking of those who profess it as if they must be either knaves
|
|||
|
or fools. It is not in human nature not to resent such imputations
|
|||
|
on that which, however incredible to you, is very precious to them.
|
|||
|
Hence it is that they think you a rough antagonist; and when you
|
|||
|
shock them by such expressions as I have quoted, you must expect
|
|||
|
some pretty strong language in return. I do not join them in this,
|
|||
|
because I know you, and appreciate that other side of you which is
|
|||
|
manly and kindly and chivalrous. But while I recognize these better
|
|||
|
qualities, I must add in all frankness that I am compelled to look
|
|||
|
upon you as a man so embittered against religion that you cannot
|
|||
|
think of it except as associated with cant, bigotry, and hypocrisy.
|
|||
|
In such a state of mind it is hardly possible for you to judge
|
|||
|
fairly of the arguments for its truth.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
I believe with you, that reason was given us to be exercised,
|
|||
|
and that when man seeks after truth, his mind should be, as you say
|
|||
|
Darwin's was, "as free from prejudice as the mariner's compass."
|
|||
|
But if he is warped by passion so that he cannot see things truly,
|
|||
|
then is he responsible. It is the moral element which alone makes
|
|||
|
the responsibility. Nor do I believe that any man will be judged in
|
|||
|
this world or the next for what does not involve a moral wrong.
|
|||
|
Hence your appalling statement, "The God you worship will,
|
|||
|
according to your creed, torture (!) through all the endless years
|
|||
|
the man who entertains an honest doubt," does not produce the
|
|||
|
effect intended, simply because I do not affirm nor believe any
|
|||
|
such thing. I believe that, in the future world, every man will be
|
|||
|
judged according to the deeds done in the body, and that the
|
|||
|
judgment, whatever it may be, will be transparently just. God is
|
|||
|
more merciful than man. He desireth not the death of the wicked.
|
|||
|
Christ forgave, where men would condemn, and whatever be the fate
|
|||
|
of any human soul, it can never be said that the Supreme Ruler was
|
|||
|
wanting either in justice or mercy. This I emphasize because you
|
|||
|
dwell so much upon the subject of future retribution, giving it an
|
|||
|
attention so constant as to be almost exclusive. Whatever else you
|
|||
|
touch upon, you soon come back to this as the black thunder-cloud
|
|||
|
that darkens all the horizon, casting its mighty shadows over the
|
|||
|
life that now is and that which is to come. Your denunciations of
|
|||
|
this "inhuman" belief are so reiterated that one would be left to
|
|||
|
infer that there is nothing else in Religion; that it is all wrath
|
|||
|
and terror, But this is putting a part for the whole. Religion is
|
|||
|
a vast system, of which this is but a single feature: it is but one
|
|||
|
doctrine of many; and indeed some whom no one will deny to be
|
|||
|
devout Christians, do not hold it at all, or only in a modified
|
|||
|
form, while with all their hearts they accept and profess the
|
|||
|
Religion that Christ came to bring into the world.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Archdeacon Farrar, of Westminster Abbey, the most eloquent
|
|||
|
preacher in the Church of England, has written a book entitled
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
2
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Eternal Hope," in which he argues from reason and the Bible, that
|
|||
|
this life is not "the be-all and end-all" of human probation; but
|
|||
|
that in the world to come there will be another opportunity, when
|
|||
|
countless millions, made wiser by unhappy experience, will turn
|
|||
|
again to the paths of life; and that so in the end the whole human
|
|||
|
race, with the exception of perhaps a few who remain irreclaimable,
|
|||
|
will be recovered and made happy forever. Others look upon "eternal
|
|||
|
death" as merely the extinction of being, while immortality is the
|
|||
|
reward of pre-eminent virtue, interpreting in that sense the words,
|
|||
|
"The wages of sin is death but the gift of God is eternal life
|
|||
|
through Jesus Christ our Lord." The latter view might recommend
|
|||
|
itself to you as the application of "the survival of the fittest"
|
|||
|
to another world, the worthless, the incurably bad, of the human
|
|||
|
race being allowed to drop out of existence (an end which can have
|
|||
|
no terrors for you, since you look upon it as the common lot of all
|
|||
|
men,) while the good are continued in being forever. The acceptance
|
|||
|
of either of these theories would relieve your mind of that "horror
|
|||
|
of great darkness" which seems to come over it whenever you look
|
|||
|
forward to retribution beyond the grave.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
But while conceding all liberty to others I cannot so easily
|
|||
|
relieve myself of this stern and rugged truth. To me moral evil in
|
|||
|
the universe is a tremendous reality, and I do not see how to limit
|
|||
|
it within the bounds of time. Retribution is to me a necessary part
|
|||
|
of the Divine law. A law without a penalty for its violations is no
|
|||
|
law. But I rest the argument for it, not on the Bible, but on
|
|||
|
principles which you yourself acknowledge. You say, "There are no
|
|||
|
punishments, no rewards: there are consequences." Very well, take
|
|||
|
the "consequences," and see where they lead you. When a man by his
|
|||
|
vices has reduced his body to a wreck and his mind to idiocy, you
|
|||
|
say this is the "consequence" of his vicious life. Is it a great
|
|||
|
stretch of language to say that it is his "punishment," and none
|
|||
|
the less punishment because self-inflicted?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
To the poor sufferer raving in a madhouse, it matters little
|
|||
|
what it is called, so long as he is experiencing the agonies of
|
|||
|
hell. And here your theory of "consequences." if followed up, will
|
|||
|
lead you very far. For if man lives after death, and keeps his
|
|||
|
personal identity, do not the "consequences" of his past life
|
|||
|
follow him into the future? And if his existence is immortal, are
|
|||
|
not the consequences immortal also? And what is this but endless
|
|||
|
retribution?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
But you tell me that the moral effect of retribution is
|
|||
|
destroyed by the easy way in which a man escapes the penalty. He
|
|||
|
has but to repent, and he is restored to the same condition before
|
|||
|
the law as if he had not sinned. Not so do I understand it. "I
|
|||
|
believe in the forgiveness of sins," but forgiveness does not
|
|||
|
reverse the course of nature; it does not prevent the operation of
|
|||
|
natural law. A drunkard may repent as he is nearing his end, but
|
|||
|
that does not undo the wrong that he has done, nor avert the
|
|||
|
consequences. In spite of his tears, he dies in an agony of shame
|
|||
|
and remorse. The inexorable law must be fulfilled.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
And so in the future world. Even though a man be forgiven, he
|
|||
|
does not wholly escape the evil of his past life. A retribution
|
|||
|
follows him even within the heavenly gates; for if he does not
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
3
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
suffer, still that bad life has so shriveled up his moral nature as
|
|||
|
to diminish his power of enjoyment. There are degrees of happiness,
|
|||
|
as one star differeth from another star in glory; and he who begins
|
|||
|
wrong, will find that it is not as well to sin and repent of it as
|
|||
|
not to sin at all. He enters the other world in a state of
|
|||
|
spiritual infancy, and will have to begin at the bottom and climb
|
|||
|
slowly upward.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
We might go a step farther, and say that perhaps heaven itself
|
|||
|
has not only its lights but its shadows, in the reflections that
|
|||
|
must come even there. We read of "the book of God's remembrance,"
|
|||
|
but is there not another book of remembrance in the mind itself --
|
|||
|
a book which any man may well fear to open and to look thereon?
|
|||
|
When that book is opened, and we read its awful pages, shall we not
|
|||
|
all think "what might have been?" And will those thoughts be wholly
|
|||
|
free from sadness? The drunken brute who breaks the heart that
|
|||
|
loved him may weep bitterly, and his poor wife may forgive him with
|
|||
|
her dying lips; but he cannot forgive himself, and never can he
|
|||
|
recall without grief that bowed head and that broken heart. This
|
|||
|
preserves the element of retribution, while it does not shut the
|
|||
|
door to forgiveness and mercy.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
But we need not travel over again the round of Christian
|
|||
|
doctrines. My faith is very simple; it revolves around two words;
|
|||
|
GOD and CHRIST. These are the two centers, or, as an astronomer
|
|||
|
might say, the double-star, or double-sun, of the great orbit of
|
|||
|
religious truth.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
As to the first of these, you say "There can be no evidence to
|
|||
|
my mind of the existence of such a being, and my mind is so that it
|
|||
|
is incapable of even thinking of an infinite personality;" and you
|
|||
|
gravely put to me this question: "Do you really believe that this
|
|||
|
world is governed by an infinitely wise and good God? Have you
|
|||
|
convinced even yourself of this?" Here are two questions -- one as
|
|||
|
to the existence of God, and the other as to His benevolence. I
|
|||
|
will answer both in language as plain as it is possible for me to
|
|||
|
use.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
First, Do I believe in the existence of God? I answer that it
|
|||
|
is impossible for me not to believe it. I could not disbelieve it
|
|||
|
if I would. You insist that belief or unbelief is not a matter of
|
|||
|
choice or of the will, but of evidence. You say "the brain thinks
|
|||
|
as the heart beats, as the eyes see." Then let us stand aside with
|
|||
|
all our prepossessions, and open our eyes to what we can see.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
When Robinson Crusoe in his desert island came down one day to
|
|||
|
the seashore, and saw in the sand the print of a human foot, could
|
|||
|
he help the instantaneous conviction that a man had been there? You
|
|||
|
might have tried to persuade him that it was all chance, -- that
|
|||
|
the sand had been washed up by the waves or blown by the winds, and
|
|||
|
taken this form, or that some marine insect had traced a figure
|
|||
|
like a human foot, -- you would not have moved him a particle. The
|
|||
|
imprint was there, and the conclusion was irresistible: he did not
|
|||
|
believe -- he knew that some human being, whether friend or foe,
|
|||
|
civilized or savage, had set his foot upon that desolate shore. So
|
|||
|
when I discover in the world (as I think I do) mysterious
|
|||
|
footprints that are certainly not human, it is not a question
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
4
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
whether I shall believe or not: I cannot help believing that some
|
|||
|
Power greater than man has set foot upon the earth.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It is a fashion among atheistic philosophers to make light of
|
|||
|
the argument from design; but "my mind is so that it is incapable"
|
|||
|
of resisting the conclusion to which it leads me. And (since
|
|||
|
personal questions are in order) I beg to ask if it is possible for
|
|||
|
you to take in your hands a watch, and believe that there was no
|
|||
|
"design" in its construction; that it was not made to keep time,
|
|||
|
but only "happened" so; that it is the product of some freak of
|
|||
|
nature, which brought together its parts and set it going. Do you
|
|||
|
not know with as much positiveness as can belong to any conviction
|
|||
|
of your mind, that it was not the work of accident, but of design;
|
|||
|
and that if there was a design, there was a designer? And if the
|
|||
|
watch was made to keep time, was not the eye made to see and the
|
|||
|
ear to hear? Skeptics may fight against this argument as much as
|
|||
|
they please, and try to evade the inevitable conclusion, and yet it
|
|||
|
remains forever entwined in the living frame of man as well as
|
|||
|
imbedded in the solid foundations of the globe. Wherefore I repeat,
|
|||
|
it is not a question with me whether I will believe or not -- I
|
|||
|
cannot help believing; and I am not only surprised, but amazed,
|
|||
|
that you or any thoughtful man can come to any other conclusion. In
|
|||
|
wonder and astonishment I ask, "Do you really believe" that in all
|
|||
|
the wide universe there is no Higher Intelligence than that of the
|
|||
|
poor human creatures that creep on this earthly ball? For myself,
|
|||
|
it is with the profoundest conviction as well as the deepest
|
|||
|
reverence that I repeat the first sentence of my faith: "I believe
|
|||
|
in God the Father Almighty."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
And not the Almighty only, but the Wise and the Good. Again I
|
|||
|
ask, How can I help believing what I see every day of my life?
|
|||
|
Every morning, as the sun rises in the East, sending light and life
|
|||
|
over the world, I behold a glorious image of the beneficent
|
|||
|
Creator. The exquisite beauty of the dawn, the dewy freshness of
|
|||
|
the air, the fleecy clouds floating in the sky -- all speak of Him.
|
|||
|
And when the sun goes down, sending shafts of light through the
|
|||
|
dense masses that would hide his setting, and casting a glory over
|
|||
|
the earth and sky, this wondrous illumination is to me but the
|
|||
|
reflection of Him who "spreadeth out the heavens like a curtain;
|
|||
|
who maketh the clouds His chariot; who walketh upon the wings of
|
|||
|
the wind."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
How much more do we find the evidences of goodness in man
|
|||
|
himself: in the power of thought; of acquiring knowledge; of
|
|||
|
penetrating the mysteries of nature and climbing among the stars.
|
|||
|
Can a being endowed with such transcendent gifts doubt the goodness
|
|||
|
of his Creator?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Yes, I believe with all my heart and soul in One who is not
|
|||
|
only Infinitely Great, but Infinitely Good; who loves all the
|
|||
|
creatures He has made; bending over them as the bow in the cloud
|
|||
|
spans the arch of heaven, stretching from horizon to horizon;
|
|||
|
looking down upon them with a tenderness compared to which all
|
|||
|
human love is faint and cold. "Like as a father pitieth his
|
|||
|
children, so the Lord pitieth them that fear Him; for He knoweth
|
|||
|
our frame, He remembereth that we are dust."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
5
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
On the question of immortality you are equally "at sea." You
|
|||
|
know nothing and believe nothing; or, rather, you know only that
|
|||
|
you do not know, and believe that you do not believe. You confess
|
|||
|
indeed to a faint hope, and admit a bare possibility, that there
|
|||
|
may be another life, though you are in an uncertainty about it that
|
|||
|
is altogether bewildering and desperate. But your mind is so
|
|||
|
poetical that you give a certain attractiveness even to the
|
|||
|
prospect of annihilation. You strew the sepulchre with such flowers
|
|||
|
as these:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"I have said a thousand times, and I say again, that the idea
|
|||
|
of immortality, that like a sea has ebbed and flowed in the human
|
|||
|
heart, with its countless waves of hope and fear beating against
|
|||
|
the shores and rocks of time and fate, was not born of any book,
|
|||
|
nor of any creed, nor of any religion. It was born of human
|
|||
|
affection. and it will continue to ebb and flow beneath the mists
|
|||
|
and clouds of doubt and darkness as long as love kisses the lips of
|
|||
|
death.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"I have said a thousand times, and I say again, that we do not
|
|||
|
know, we cannot say, whether death is a wall or a door; the
|
|||
|
beginning or end of a day; the spreading or pinions to soar, or the
|
|||
|
folding forever of wings; the rise or the set of a sun, or an
|
|||
|
endless life that brings rapture and love to every one."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Beautiful words! but inexpressibly sad! It is a silver lining
|
|||
|
to the cloud, and yet the cloud is there, dark and impenetrable.
|
|||
|
But perhaps we ought not to expect anything clearer and brighter
|
|||
|
from one who recognizes no light but that of Nature. That light is
|
|||
|
very dim. If it were all we had, we should be just where Cicero
|
|||
|
was, and say with him, and with you, that a future life was "to be
|
|||
|
hoped for rather than believed." But does not that very uncertainty
|
|||
|
show the need of a something above Nature, which is furnished in
|
|||
|
Him who "was crucified, dead and buried, and the third day rose
|
|||
|
again from the dead?" It is the Conqueror of Death who calls to the
|
|||
|
fainthearted: "I am the Resurrection and the Life." Since He has
|
|||
|
gone before us, lighting up the dark passage of the grave, we need
|
|||
|
not fear to follow, resting on the word of our Leader: "Because I
|
|||
|
live, ye shall live also."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This faith in another life is a precious inheritance, which
|
|||
|
cannot be torn from the agonized bosom without a wrench that tears
|
|||
|
every heartstring; and it was to this I referred as the last refuge
|
|||
|
of a poor, suffering, despairing soul, when I asked: "Does it never
|
|||
|
occur to you that there is something very cruel in this treatment
|
|||
|
of the belief of your fellow-creatures, on whose hope of another
|
|||
|
life hangs all that relieves the darkness of their present
|
|||
|
existence?" The imputation of cruelty you repel with some warmth,
|
|||
|
saying (with a slight variation of my language): "When I deny the
|
|||
|
existence of perdition, you reply that there is something very
|
|||
|
cruel in this treatment of the belief of my fellow-creatures." Of
|
|||
|
course, this change of words, putting perdition in the place of
|
|||
|
immortal life and hope, was a mere inadvertence. But it was enough
|
|||
|
to change the whole character of what I wrote. As I described "the
|
|||
|
treatment of the belief of my fellow-creatures," I did think it
|
|||
|
"very cruel," and I think so still.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
6
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
While correcting this slight misquotation, I must remove from
|
|||
|
your mind a misapprehension, which is so very absurd as to be
|
|||
|
absolutely comical. In my Letter referring to your disbelief of
|
|||
|
immortality, I had said: "With an air of modesty and diffidence
|
|||
|
that would carry an audience by storm, you confess your ignorance
|
|||
|
of what perhaps others are better acquainted with, when you say,
|
|||
|
'This world is all that I know anything about, so far as I
|
|||
|
recollect'" Of course "what perhaps others are better acquainted
|
|||
|
with "was a part of what you said, or at least implied by your
|
|||
|
manner (for you do not convey your meaning merely by words, but by
|
|||
|
a tone of voice, by arched eyebrows, or a curled lip') and yet,
|
|||
|
instead of taking the sentence in its plain and obvious sense, you
|
|||
|
affect to understand it as an assumption on my part to have some
|
|||
|
private and mysterious knowledge of another world (!), and gravely
|
|||
|
ask me, "Did you by this intend to say that you know anything of
|
|||
|
any other state of existence; that you have inhabited some other
|
|||
|
planet; that you lived before you were born; and that you recollect
|
|||
|
something of that other world or of that other state? "No, my dear
|
|||
|
Colonel! I have been a good deal of a traveler, and have seen all
|
|||
|
parts of this world, but I have never visited any other. In reading
|
|||
|
your sober question, if I did not know you to he one of the
|
|||
|
brightest wits of the day, I should be tempted to quote what Sidney
|
|||
|
Smith says of a Scotchman, that "you cannot get a joke into his
|
|||
|
head except by a surgical operation!"
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
But to return to what is serious: you make light of our faith
|
|||
|
and our hopes, because you know not the infinite solace they bring
|
|||
|
to the troubled human heart. You sneer at the idea that religion
|
|||
|
can be a "consolation." Indeed! Is it not a consolation to have an
|
|||
|
Almighty Friend? Was it a light matter for the poor slave mother,
|
|||
|
who sat alone in her cabin, having been robbed of her children, to
|
|||
|
sing in her wild, wailing accents:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Nobody knows the sorrows I've seen:
|
|||
|
Nobody knows but Jesus?"
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Would you rob her of that Unseen Friend -- the only Friend she
|
|||
|
had on earth or in heaven?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bat I will do you the justice to say that your want of
|
|||
|
religious faith comes in part from your very sensibility and
|
|||
|
tenderness of heart. You cannot recognize an overruling Providence,
|
|||
|
because your mind is so harassed by scenes that you witness. Why,
|
|||
|
you ask, do men suffer so? You draw frightful pictures of the
|
|||
|
misery which exists in the world, as a proof of the incapacity of
|
|||
|
its Ruler and Governor, and do not hesitate to say that "any honest
|
|||
|
man of average intelligence could do vastly better." If you could
|
|||
|
have your way, you would make everybody happy; there should be no
|
|||
|
more poverty, and no more sickness or pain.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This is a pleasant picture to look at, and yet you must excuse
|
|||
|
me for saying that it is rather a child's picture than that of a
|
|||
|
stalwart man. The world is not a playground in which men are to be
|
|||
|
petted and indulged like children: spoiled children they would soon
|
|||
|
become. It is an arena of conflict, in which we are to develop the
|
|||
|
manhood that is in us. We all have to take the "rough-and-tumble"
|
|||
|
of life, and are the better for it -- physically, intellectually,
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
7
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
and morally. If there be any true manliness within us, we come out
|
|||
|
of the struggle stronger and better; with larger minds and kinder
|
|||
|
hearts; a broader wisdom and a gentler charity.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Perhaps we should not differ on this point if we could agree
|
|||
|
as to the true end of life. But here I fear the difference is
|
|||
|
irreconcilable. You think that end is happiness: I think it is
|
|||
|
CHARACTER. I do not believe that the highest end of life upon earth
|
|||
|
is to "have a good time;" to get from it the utmost amount of
|
|||
|
enjoyment; but to be truly and greatly good; and that to that end
|
|||
|
no discipline can he too severe which leads us "to suffer and be
|
|||
|
strong." That discipline answers its end when it raises the spirit
|
|||
|
to the highest pitch of courage and endurance. The splendor of
|
|||
|
virtue never appears so bright as when set against a dark
|
|||
|
background. It was in prisons and dungeons that the martyrs showed
|
|||
|
the greatest degree of moral heroism, the power of "Man's
|
|||
|
unconquerable mind."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
But I know well that these illustrations do not cover the
|
|||
|
whole case. There is another picture to be added to those of heroic
|
|||
|
struggle and martyrdom -- that of silent suffering, which makes of
|
|||
|
life one long agony, and which often comes upon the good, so that
|
|||
|
it seems as if the best suffered the most. And yet when you sit by
|
|||
|
a sick bed, and look into a face whiter than the pillow on which it
|
|||
|
rests, do you not sometimes mark how that very suffering refines
|
|||
|
the nature that bears it so meekly? This is the Christian theory:
|
|||
|
that suffering, patiently borne, is a means of the greatest
|
|||
|
elevation of character, and, in the end, of the highest enjoyment.
|
|||
|
Looking at it in this light, we can understand how it should be
|
|||
|
that "the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be
|
|||
|
compared [or even to be named] with the glory which shall be
|
|||
|
revealed." When the heavenly morning breaks, brighter than any dawn
|
|||
|
that blushes "o'er the world," there will be "a restitution of all
|
|||
|
things:" the poor will be made rich, and the most suffering the
|
|||
|
most serenely happy; as in the vision of the Apocalypse, when it is
|
|||
|
asked "What are these which are arrayed in white robes, and whence
|
|||
|
came they?" the answer is, "These are they which came our of great
|
|||
|
tribulation."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In this conclusion, which is not adopted lightly, but after
|
|||
|
innumerable struggles with doubt, after the experience and the
|
|||
|
reflection of years, I feel "a great peace." It is the glow of
|
|||
|
sunset that gilds the approach of evening. For (we must confess it)
|
|||
|
it is towards that you and I are advancing. The sun has passed the
|
|||
|
meridian, and hastens to his going down. Whatever of good this life
|
|||
|
has for us (and I am far from being one of those who look upon it
|
|||
|
as a vale of tears) will soon be behind us. I see the shadows
|
|||
|
creeping on; yet I welcome the twilight that will soon darken into
|
|||
|
night, for I know that it will be a night all glorious with stars.
|
|||
|
As I look upward, the feeling of awe is blended with a strange,
|
|||
|
overpowering sense of the Infinite Goodness, which surrounds me
|
|||
|
like an atmosphere:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"And so beside the Silent Sea,
|
|||
|
I wait the muffled oar;
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
No harm from Him can come to me
|
|||
|
On ocean or on shore.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
8
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
I know not where His Islands lift:
|
|||
|
Their fronded palms in air;
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
I only know I cannot drift
|
|||
|
Beyond His love and care."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Would that you could share with me this confidence and this
|
|||
|
hope! But you seem to be receding farther from any kind of faith.
|
|||
|
In one of your closing paragraphs, you give what is to you "the
|
|||
|
conclusion of the whole matter." After repudiating religion with
|
|||
|
scorn, you ask, "Is there not room for a better, for a higher
|
|||
|
philosophy?" and thus indicate the true answer to be given, to
|
|||
|
which no words can do justice but your own:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"After all, is it not possible that we may find that
|
|||
|
everything has been necessarily produced; that all religions and
|
|||
|
superstitions, all mistakes and all crimes, were simply
|
|||
|
necessities? Is it not possible that out of this perception may
|
|||
|
come not only love and pity for others, but absolute justification
|
|||
|
for the individual? May we not find that every soul has, like
|
|||
|
Mazeppa, been lashed to the wild horse of passion, or like
|
|||
|
Prometheus to the rocks of fate?"
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
If this be the end of all philosophy, it is equally the end of
|
|||
|
"all things." Not only does it make an end of us and of our hopes
|
|||
|
of futurity, but of all that makes the present life worth living --
|
|||
|
of all freedom, and hence of all virtue. There are no more any
|
|||
|
moral distinctions in the world -- no good and no evil, no right
|
|||
|
and no wrong; nothing but grim necessity. With such a creed, I
|
|||
|
wonder how you can ever stand at the bar, and argue for the
|
|||
|
conviction of a criminal. Why should he be convicted and punished
|
|||
|
for what he could not help? Indeed he is not a criminal, since
|
|||
|
there is no such thing as crime. He is not to blame. Was he not
|
|||
|
"lashed to the wild horse of passion," carried away by a power
|
|||
|
beyond his control? What cruelty to thrust him behind iron bars!
|
|||
|
Poor fellow! he deserves our pity. Let us hasten to relieve him
|
|||
|
from a position which must be so painful, and make our humble
|
|||
|
apology for having presumed to punish him for an act in which he
|
|||
|
only obeyed an impulse which he could not resist. This will be
|
|||
|
"absolute justification for the individual." But what will become
|
|||
|
of society, you do not tell us.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Are you aware that in this last attainment of "a better, a
|
|||
|
higher philosophy" (which is simply absolute fatalism), you have
|
|||
|
swung round to the side of John Calvin, and gone far beyond him?
|
|||
|
That you, who have exhausted all the resources of the English
|
|||
|
language in denouncing his creed as the most horrible of human
|
|||
|
beliefs -- brainless, soulless, heartless; who have held it up to
|
|||
|
scorn and derision; now hold to the blackest Calvinism that was
|
|||
|
ever taught by man? You cannot find words sufficient to express
|
|||
|
your horror of the doctrine of Divine decrees; and yet here you
|
|||
|
have decrees with a vengeance -- predestination and damnation, both
|
|||
|
in one. Under such a creed, man is a thousand times worse off than
|
|||
|
under ours: for he has absolutely no hope. You may say that at any
|
|||
|
rate he cannot suffer forever. You do not know even that; but at
|
|||
|
any rate he suffers as long as he exists. There is no God above to
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
9
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A LAST WORD TO ROBERT G. INGERSOLL.
|
|||
|
by Dr. Henry M. Field
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
show him pity, and grant him release; but as long as the ages roll,
|
|||
|
he is "lashed to the rocks of fate," with the insatiate vulture
|
|||
|
tearing at his heart!
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In reading your glittering phrases, I seem to be losing hold
|
|||
|
of everything, and to be sinking, sinking, till I touch the lowest
|
|||
|
depths of an abyss; while from the blackness above me a sound like
|
|||
|
a death-knoll tolls the midnight of the soul. If I believed this I
|
|||
|
should cry, God help us all! Oh no -- for there would be no God,
|
|||
|
and even this last consolation would be denied us: for why should
|
|||
|
we offer a prayer which can neither be heard nor answered? As well
|
|||
|
might we ask mercy from "the rocks of fate" to which we are chained
|
|||
|
forever!
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Recoiling from this Gospel of Despair, I turn to One in whose
|
|||
|
face there is something at once human and divine -- an
|
|||
|
indescribable majesty, united with more than human tenderness and
|
|||
|
pity; One who was born among the poor, and had not where to lay His
|
|||
|
head, and yet went about doing good; poor, yet making many rich;
|
|||
|
who trod the world in deepest loneliness, and yet whose presence
|
|||
|
lighted up every dwelling into which He came; who took up little
|
|||
|
children in His arms, and blessed them; a giver of joy to others,
|
|||
|
and yet a sufferer himself; who tasted every human sorrow, and yet
|
|||
|
was always ready to minister to others' grief; weeping with them
|
|||
|
that wept; coming to Bethany to comfort Mary and Martha concerning
|
|||
|
their brother; rebuking the proud, but gentle and pitiful to the
|
|||
|
most abject of human creatures; stopping amid the throng at the cry
|
|||
|
of a blind beggar by the wayside; willing to be known as "the
|
|||
|
friend of sinners," if He might recall them into the way of peace;
|
|||
|
who did not scorn even the fallen woman who sank at His feet, but
|
|||
|
by His gentle word, "Neither do I condemn thee; go and sin no
|
|||
|
more," lifted her up, and set her in the path of a virtuous
|
|||
|
womanhood; and who, when dying on the cross, prayed: "Father,
|
|||
|
forgive them, for they know not what they do," In this Friend of
|
|||
|
the friendless, Comforter of the comfortless, Forgiver of the
|
|||
|
penitent, and Guide of the erring, I find a greatness that I had
|
|||
|
not found in any of the philosophers or teachers of the world. No
|
|||
|
voice in all the ages thrills me like that which whispers close to
|
|||
|
my heart, "Come unto me and I will give you rest," to which I
|
|||
|
answer:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
THIS IS MY MASTER, AND I WILL FOLLOW HIM.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Henry M. Field.
|
|||
|
**** ****
|
|||
|
Reproducible Electronic Publishing can defeat censorship.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Bank of Wisdom is a collection of the most thoughtful,
|
|||
|
scholarly and factual books. These computer books are reprints of
|
|||
|
suppressed books and will cover American and world history; the
|
|||
|
Biographies and writings of famous persons, and especially of our
|
|||
|
nations Founding Fathers. They will include philosophy and
|
|||
|
religion. all these subjects, and more, will be made available to
|
|||
|
the public in electronic form, easily copied and distributed, so
|
|||
|
that America can again become what its Founders intended --
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Free Market-Place of Ideas.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bank of Wisdom
|
|||
|
Box 926, Louisville, KY 40201
|
|||
|
10
|
|||
|
|