textfiles/magazines/STB/stb-1933-08.txt

SHORT TALK BULLETIN - Vol.XI   August, 1933   No.8

ROUGH AND PERFECT

by: Unknown

The rough Ashlar and the Trestleboard seem to have been symbols in 
Ancient Craft Masonry at least from the beginning of the Grand Lodge 
period (1717).  They are illustrated on the earliest of the old 
tracing-boards which have come down to us.
Just when or how the Perfect Ashlar came into our symbolism is 
another matter, and not as simple as it appears.
In 1731 one Samuel Prichard, who denominated himself as a <20>Life 
Member of a Constituted Lodge<67> wrote and published <20>Masonry 
Dissected,<2C> the first of a long series of exposes of Freemasonry.
In it is this curious dialogue, purporting to be held between the 
Entered Apprentice during his initiation, and some initiating 
officer:
Q.	<09>Have you any Jewels in your Lodge?<3F>
A.	<09>Yes.<2E>

Q.	<09>How Many?<3F>
A.	<09>Six, three movable and three immovable.<2E>

Q.	<09>What are the movable Jewels?<3F>
A.	<09>Square, Level and Plumb Rule.<2E>

Q.	<09>What are their uses?<3F>
A.	<09>Square, to down true and right lines; Level, to try all 
Horizontals; and Plumb Rule, to try all Uprights.<2E>
Q.	<09>What are the immovable Jewels?<3F>
A.	<09>Tarsel Board, Rough Ashlar and Broached Thurnel.<2E>

Q.	<09>What are their uses?<3F>
A.	<09>A Tarsel Board for the Master to draw his designs upon, Rough 
Ashlar for the Fellow-Craft to try their Jewels upon, and the 
Broached Thurnel for the entered Apprentice to learn to 	work 
upon.<2E>
The learned Dr. Oliver, most prolific of the early writers on 
Freemasonry, to whose industry if not to whose accuracy Freemasonry 
owes a great debt, unwittingly muddied the waters of antiquity in 
which this Broached Thurnel was apparently immersed!  He confused it 
with the Rough Ashlar, stating that the two were the same.	
Old tracing-Boards of the entered Apprentice Degree disclose what we 
readily recognize as the Trestle-Board, although in those days it was 
known as <20>Tarsel!<21>  Adjacent to it is what is plainly a Rough Ashlar.  
Immediately next is a drawing of a cube, surmounted by a pyramid - a 
cubical stone with a pyramidal apex.
Early French tracing-boards display the <20>pierre-cubique,<2C> of cubical 
stone.
Modern tracing-boards show the Perfect Ashlar (not the rough Ashlar, 
as Oliver had it) in place of the Broached Thurnel, or cubical stone 
with pyramid atop.
Mackey quotes Parker<65>s <20>Glossary of Terms in Architecture<72> as 
follows:
<EFBFBD>Broach or broche is an old English term for spire, still in use in 
Leicestershire, where it is said to denote a spire springing from the 
tower without any intervening parapet.  Thurnel is from the old 
French, <20>tournelle,<2C> a turret or little tower.  The Broached Thurnel, 
then, was the Spired Turret.  It was a model on which Apprentices 
might learn the principles of their art because it presented to them, 
in its various outlines, the forms of the square and the triangle, 
the cube and the pyramid.<2E>
Modern authorities dispute this.  G.W. Speth finds that Broach, in 
Scotland means to rough-hew.  Thurnel, he states, is a chisel with 
which to rough-hew, rather than a model of a spired turret on which 
an Apprentice might learn to work.  But, he inquires, what then 
becomes of the pyramid on the cube, displayed on the old tracing-
boards?  Moreover, the Scotch use <20>boast<73> as an alternate word for 
<EFBFBD>broach,<2C> and <20>boasted ashlar<61> can be found in modern dictionaries, 
meaning chiseled with an irregular surface.
As a matter of fact, no one really <20>knows<77> just what our ancient 
brethren meant by Broached Thurnel; what we do know is that somewhere 
in the early formative period of the modern ritual, Broached Thurnel 
gave way to Perfect Ashlar.
But it did not necessarily do so because of the presence on the 
tracing-board of a Rough Ashlar.  No less an authority than R.W. 
Charles C. Hunt, Librarian and Grand Secretary of the Grand Lodge of 
Iowa, presents the <20>Perpend Ashlar<61> as its probable progenitor.  A 
Perpend Ashlar - the word has many variations, such as parpen, 
parpend, parpent, parpine, parpin, parping - is a dressed stone which 
passes completely through a wall from one side to the other, having 
two smooth, vertical faces.  This perpenstone. or bonder, or 
bondstone, is the same as the Parping Ashlar of Glocestershire - a 
stone which passes through a wall and shows a fair face on either 
side.
In the <20>True Masonic Chart<72> published by R.W. Jeremy L. Cross in 
1820, appear pictures of the Rough and Perfect Ashlars, showing them 
substantially as we know them today.  It is noteworthy that the 
stones illustrated are more than twice as long as wide and high, 
which seems to bear out the idea that the Perfect Ashlar, at least, 
was once the Perpend Ashlar.
Before examining the symbolism of the Ashlars it is illuminating to 
read at least one passage from the Great Light:
<EFBFBD>And the king commanded, and they brought great stones, and costly 
stones, and hewed stones, to lay the foundation of the house.
<EFBFBD>And Solomon<6F>s builders and Hiram<61>s builders did hew them, and the 
stonesquarers; so they prepared timber and stones to build the 
house.<2E> (I Kings, V 16-17)
There is a distinction between builders and stone squarers - while 
those who cut and squared the stone and those who built, both hewed, 
yet they were distinct in functions.  It is also interesting to 
observe the classification <20>great<61>, <20>costly<6C> and <20>hewed.<2E>
<EFBFBD>Great<EFBFBD> of course refers to size.  The larger the stone, the harder 
it was to cut from the quarry, the more difficult to transport, and 
therefore, the more expensive.  But <20>costly<6C> may also refer to the 
expense of hewing.  Then, as now, the more truly and carefully a 
stone was hewed and smoothed, squared and polished, the more time was 
required and therefore, the more <20>costly<6C> the stone became.
Few symbols seem more obvious, at least in their simpler aspects.  
Rough Ashlar, man in his untutored state; 
Perfect Ashler, man educated, refined, with mind filled light.  It is 
this symbolism which Brother J.W. Lawrence evidently had in mind when 
he wrote:
<EFBFBD>The Perfect Ashlar, as a symbol, is the summum bonum of Freemasonry.  
That is to say, everything else in Masonry leads up to it.  The V. of 
S.L. describes it, the checkered pavement illustrates it, the Great 
Architect no less than the Grand Geometrian desire it, and are 
satisfied with nothing less.  When the craft has fashioned the 
Perfect Ashlar, it has nothing else to do.<2E>
With part of which all can agree; if some think that there yet 
remains building to be done, after the Ashlars are hewn to 
perfection, we may still make our own the thought that the Grand 
Master of the Grand Lodge Above wants only perfection in the 
spiritual stones for the <20>House Not Made With Hands.<2E>
But the symbolism can be carried further.  In this subject 
<EFBFBD>Introduction to Freemasonry<72> reads:
<EFBFBD>The common Gavel, which breaks off the corners of rough stones, the 
better to fit them for the builders use, joins the Rough and Perfect 
Ashlars in a hidden symbol of the Order at once beautiful and tender.  
The famous sculptor and ardent Freemason, Gutzon Borglum, when asked 
how he carved stone into beautiful statues, once said: <20>it is very 
simple.  I merely knock away with a hammer and chisel the stone I do 
not need, and the statue is there - It Was There All of the Time.<2E><>
<EFBFBD>In the Great Light We read: <20>The Kingdom of Heaven is Within You.<2E>  
We are also there taught that man is made in the image of God.  As 
Brother Borglum has so beautifully said, images are made by a process 
of taking away.  The perfection is already within.  All that is 
required is to remove the roughness and excrescences, <20>Divesting our 
Hearts and Consciences of the Vices and Superfluities of life<66> to 
show forth the perfect man and Mason within.<2E> 
Albert Pike, always original, thought the interpretation of the Rough 
and Perfect Ashlars, as given in our Ancient craft monitors and 
ritualistic instruction, to be superficial.  He found another 
meaning:
<EFBFBD>The Rough Ashlar is the people, as a mass, rude and unorganized.  
The Perfect Ashlar, cubical stone, symbol of perfection, is the 
State, the rulers deriving their powers from the consent of the 
governed; the constitution and laws speaking the will of the people; 
the government, harmonious, symmetrical, efficient - its powers 
properly distributed and duly adjusted in equilibrium.<2E>
Any brother is privileged to extend symbolism in new directions as 
far as he wishes; if his reading of a symbol is to him satisfactory 
teaching of a truth, it is a good reading.  But the rough and Perfect 
Ashlars are sufficiently inclusive of the many truths-within the 
grasp of the average individual, without extending the interpretation 
to such vast conceptions as the people and the state.  Even Pike, 
great interpreter of symbols though he was, never contended that the 
original symbolism of the Ashlars, as developed from operative 
practice by the early Speculatives, was of a political nature.
Hunt<EFBFBD>s reading of the Perfect Ashlar, as the successor to the Perpend 
Ashlar, is most beautiful. In <20>Some Thoughts on Masonic Symbolism<73> he 
suggests:
<EFBFBD>We call it the Perfect Ashlar, but we must remember that it is 
perfected only because it is completely adapted to the purpose for 
which it was made, namely; to exactly fit into its place in the 
building, and act as a binder for other stones..
<EFBFBD>In order that it may do this, it must possess certain attributes and 
through these attributes we are reminded <20>of that state of perfection 
at which we hope to arrive by a virtuous education, our own endeavors 
and the blessing of god.<2E>  It has two faces to be exposed, and both 
must be absolutely upright.  It does not have one standard for the 
world and another for the home; the same face, square and true, is 
presented both to the world and the Lodge, and it teaches that we 
should not have one code of morals for one place and another for 
another, but that right is the same wherever we are and under 
whatever circumstance we may be placed.<2E>
The making of a Perfect Ashlar from a Rough Ashlar requires skill, 
tools and a plan.  Without any of the three the Ashlar cannot be made 
perfect.
Skills to use the tools means education to wield Chisel and Mallet - 
education to use the talents God gave us in whatever walk of life we 
may be called.
Tools must the workman have, for empty hands cannot chip away hard 
stone; tools must the Speculative Craftsman have. for an empty mind 
cannot wear away the resistance of our complicated life. Speculative 
tools are honor and probity, energy and resource, courage and common 
sense and the like virtues, the generation of which forms character.
Most especially must the operative workman have a plan to which to 
hew.  His mind must see both dimension and form, otherwise his tools 
will cut aimlessly, and his Ashlar will be askew, not square, fit 
only for the waste pile or the curiosity shop.  So must the 
Speculative workman have a plan to which to fit his Perfect Ashlar of 
character . . . an ambition, a goal for which to strive, some hope in 
the future towards which he can stretch eager hands, bending every 
energy to accomplish.
Considered thus, the Rough and Perfect Ashlars become symbols of 
greater interest than appear on only a casual inspection.  One 
interpretation is, perhaps, as satisfactory as another - it is one of 
the great beauties of symbolism that interpretations can differ 
widely and yet all be true, and all fit with each other.  As one 
writer puts it:
<EFBFBD>Most symbols have many interpretations.  These do not contradict but 
amplify each other.  Thus, the square is a symbol of perfection, of 
honor, and honestly, of good work.  These are all different, and yet 
allied.  The square is not a symbol of wrong, or evil, or meanness, 
or disease.  Ten different men may read ten different meanings into a 
square and yet each meaning fits with, and belongs to, the other 
meanings .  . . all these meanings are right. When all men know all 
the meanings, the need for Freemasonry will have passed away.<2E>  
(<28>Foreign Countries<65>)
Read the symbolism of the Ashlars as we choose, from the simplest 
conception to the most profound, the though remains; even as the 
cornerstone of a temple must be a perfect ashlar, so are these 
symbols cornerstones of our Speculative Science, the more beautiful 
and important that learned men have found in them so many and such 
beautiful lessons.