1297 lines
59 KiB
Plaintext
1297 lines
59 KiB
Plaintext
![]() |
|
|||
|
=================================================================
|
|||
|
*****************************************************************
|
|||
|
=================================================================
|
|||
|
____
|
|||
|
/ ) ___ ()
|
|||
|
/ __ * / / ^
|
|||
|
/ / / / ) / _/_ ___ /__ / \
|
|||
|
__| / / / / / /___) / ) \/ \
|
|||
|
(_/ \____(__/___(___)___/_____/______(________/________/\___ )
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
_____
|
|||
|
/ ) /
|
|||
|
/ _ / _ _
|
|||
|
>-- / ) /___ / (_)___
|
|||
|
/ / / ) / /
|
|||
|
(_______)___(___)___/ (____(____/
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
===================================================================
|
|||
|
******The*E-Zine*of*Atheistic*Secular*Humanism*and*Freethought*****
|
|||
|
===================================================================
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
###################################################################
|
|||
|
########## Volume I, Number 3 ***A Collector's Item!***##########
|
|||
|
###################### ISSN 1198-4619 ###########################
|
|||
|
########################## JULY 1994 ##############################
|
|||
|
###################################################################
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In the mythology and symbolism of our name, "Lucifer" is not to be
|
|||
|
confused with ha-Satan, the mythological source of evil. Lucifer's
|
|||
|
ancient identity was a bearer of light, the morning star, and it is
|
|||
|
as such that this journal intends to publish.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
As the religion virus depends on obscurity, obfuscation, confusion,
|
|||
|
irrationality and darkness in order to flourish, it is natural that
|
|||
|
it would see light as an enemy. Rational, skeptical inquiry has
|
|||
|
ever been the enemy of all religions and is ultimately fatal to all
|
|||
|
gods.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The purpose of this magazine is to provide a source of articles
|
|||
|
dealing with many aspects of humanism. Humanists have been
|
|||
|
vilified by the religious as immoral. Apparently, the most
|
|||
|
horrible thing they can think of is an atheist.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
As we find their values, such as faith in the non-existent,
|
|||
|
obedience to the imaginary and reverence of the ridiculous,
|
|||
|
repulsive, we adopt the name of their ancient antagonist with
|
|||
|
pride.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
We are atheistic as we do not believe in the actual existence of
|
|||
|
any supernatural beings or any transcendental reality.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
We are secular because the evidence of history and the daily
|
|||
|
horrors in the news show the pernicious and destructive
|
|||
|
consequences of allowing religions to be involved with politics and
|
|||
|
nationalism.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
We are humanists and we focus on what is good for humanity, in the
|
|||
|
real world. We will not be put off with offers of pie in the sky,
|
|||
|
bye and bye.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
==><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><==
|
|||
|
|| Begging portion of the Zine ||
|
|||
|
==><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><==
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This is a "sharezine." There is no charge for receiving this, and
|
|||
|
there is no charge for distributing copies to any electronic
|
|||
|
medium. Nor is there a restriction on printing a copy for use in
|
|||
|
discussion. You may not charge to do so, and you may not do so
|
|||
|
without attributing it to the proper author and source.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
If you would like to support our efforts, and help us acquire
|
|||
|
better equipment to bring you more and better articles, you may
|
|||
|
send money to Greg Erwin at: 29, ch Grimes / Aylmer, Qc / J9J 1H4
|
|||
|
/ CANADA. As of 1994July1, the address will be: 100 Terrasse
|
|||
|
Eardley / Aylmer, Qc J9H nBn
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
==><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><==
|
|||
|
|| End of Begging portion of the Zine ||
|
|||
|
==><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><==
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Articles will be welcomed IF:
|
|||
|
(
|
|||
|
they are emailed to: ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA; or,
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
sent on diskette to me at the above Aylmer address in any format
|
|||
|
that an IBM copy of WordPerfect can read; ) and
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
they don't require huge amounts of editing; and
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
I like them.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
If you wish to receive a subscription, email a simple request to
|
|||
|
ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA, with a clear request for a subscription.
|
|||
|
It will be assumed that the "From:" address is where it is to be
|
|||
|
sent. We will automate this process as soon as we know how.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Yes, please DO make copies! (*)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Please DO send copies of Lucifer's Echo to anyone who might be
|
|||
|
interested.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The only limitations are:
|
|||
|
You must copy the whole document, without making any changes to it.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
You do NOT have permission to copy this document for commercial
|
|||
|
purposes.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The contents of this document are copyright (c) 1994, Greg Erwin
|
|||
|
and are on deposit at the National Library of Canada
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\
|
|||
|
Shameless advertising and crass commercialism:
|
|||
|
\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/
|
|||
|
Atheistic self-stick Avery(tm) address labels. Consisting of
|
|||
|
180 different quotes, 30 per page, each label 2 5/8" x 1".
|
|||
|
This leaves three 49 character lines available for your own
|
|||
|
address, phone number, email, fax or whatever. Each sheet is
|
|||
|
US$2, the entire set of 6 for US$11; 2 sets for US$20.
|
|||
|
Indicate quantity desired. Print address clearly, exactly as
|
|||
|
desired. Order from address in examples below. Laser
|
|||
|
printed, 8 pt Arial, with occasional flourishes.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
_________________________________________________
|
|||
|
|"Reality is that which, when you stop believing |
|
|||
|
|in it, doesn't go away." [Philip K. Dick] |
|
|||
|
|Greg Erwin 100 Terrasse Eardley |
|
|||
|
|Aylmer, Qc J9H 6B5 Canada |
|
|||
|
| email: ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA |
|
|||
|
|________________________________________________|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
_________________________________________________
|
|||
|
|"...and when you tell me that your deity made |
|
|||
|
|you in his own image, I reply that he must be |
|
|||
|
|very ugly." [Victor Hugo, writing to clergy] |
|
|||
|
|Greg Erwin 100 Terrasse Eardley |
|
|||
|
|Aylmer, Qc J9H 6B5 Canada Ph: (613) 954-6128 |
|
|||
|
| email: ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA |
|
|||
|
|________________________________________________|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Other stuff for sale:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Certificate of Baptism Removal and Renunciation of Religion.
|
|||
|
Have your baptism removed, renounce religion, and have a neat
|
|||
|
8" x 11" fancy certificate, on luxury paper, suitable for
|
|||
|
framing, to commemorate the event! Instant eligibility for
|
|||
|
excommunication! For the already baptism-free: Certificate
|
|||
|
of Freedom from Religion. An official atheistic secular
|
|||
|
humanist stamp of approval for only $10!
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Poster 8x11: WARNING! This is a religion free zone!
|
|||
|
All religious vows, codes, and commitments are null & void
|
|||
|
herein. Please refrain from contaminating the ideosphere with
|
|||
|
harmful memes through prayer, reverence, holy books,
|
|||
|
proselytizing, prophesying, faith, speaking in tongues or
|
|||
|
spirituality. Fight the menace of second-hand faith!
|
|||
|
Humanity sincerely thanks you!
|
|||
|
Tastefully arranged in large point Stencil on luxury paper.
|
|||
|
Likewise $10.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
4. Ingersoll poster: "When I became convinced that the
|
|||
|
universe is natural" speech excerpt. 11"x17" See the June
|
|||
|
1994 issue of the _Echo_ for full text. $15
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Order from the same address as above.
|
|||
|
Order now to celebrate the rebirth of the Invincible Sun!
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-TABLE OF CONTENTS-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
|
|||
|
1. Christianity on Trial, part II, Dr Wendell W. Watters
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
2. Anti-Semitism: Its Prevalence Within the Christian Right, Part
|
|||
|
I, by Skipp Porteous
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
3. How We know What Isn't So; The fallibility of human reason in
|
|||
|
everyday life Reviewed by Greg Erwin
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
4. Visit the Birthplace of Robert G. Ingersoll by Fred Edwords
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
|
|||
|
Part II Christianity on Trial, by Dr Wendell W. Watters
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
[Dr. Watters is Professor Emeritus of psychiatry at McMaster
|
|||
|
University, Hamilton, Ontario. The following is a transcript of his
|
|||
|
talk to the 1991 Hamilton conference of the Humanist Association of
|
|||
|
Canada, which was published in the _Humanist in Canada_ quarterly
|
|||
|
magazine as a series of six articles]
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
|
|||
|
+ For subscriptions to Humanist in Canada send Can$15 for one year,
|
|||
|
+ Can$28 for two years. Outside of Canada, US$16 for one year, (or
|
|||
|
+ Can$19), US$30 for two years (Can$36). Back issues available,
|
|||
|
+ write for free ten year index. Send large SASE. Address all
|
|||
|
+ correspondence to: Humanist in Canada, P.O. Box 3769, Stn C,
|
|||
|
+ Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1Y 4J8
|
|||
|
+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Charge 1. Christianity's teachings about sexuality have contributed
|
|||
|
in a major way to human misery in this area.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Early in the history of the church, when it became evident that
|
|||
|
Jesus would not be coming back, the leaders of the church realized
|
|||
|
that they would have to harness the sexual and reproductive urges
|
|||
|
of the flock in order to build an earthly church. Previously they
|
|||
|
had not been very interested in what people did with their
|
|||
|
genitals. Jesus, for example, is mute on the entire issue.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
To achieve their demographic aims, they declared all forms of
|
|||
|
sexual expression not leading to conception to be against the laws
|
|||
|
of God. This included masturbation, oral sex, homosexual love,
|
|||
|
birth control and abortion. Only unprotected heterosexual inter-
|
|||
|
course between couples whose union was blessed by the clergy was
|
|||
|
licit and lawful.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Many of the teachings on sexuality found their way into the secular
|
|||
|
legislation in states dominated by Christianity, the most notable
|
|||
|
example being to the effect that homosexuality was a crime. Many
|
|||
|
more found their way into the sexual mythology of couples
|
|||
|
throughout the western world and, when combined with attitudes
|
|||
|
about gender roles derived from Christianity, they formed some very
|
|||
|
destructive myths which still foul up sexual relationships between
|
|||
|
men and women the world over. Some of these are the fixation on
|
|||
|
coitus as the only legitimate outcome of all sexual encounters, the
|
|||
|
myth of the vaginal orgasm and even the myth of the simultaneous
|
|||
|
orgasm. This is the belief that, if women were to have a climax at
|
|||
|
all, it should be at the same time as her husband, presumably on
|
|||
|
the assumption that conception would be most likely to take place
|
|||
|
at that time. This statement appeared in a book called _Sex,
|
|||
|
Marriage and Birth Control_ by a Canadian Anglican minister writing
|
|||
|
in the 1930's: Experienced lovers will usually contrive that the
|
|||
|
climax shall occur for both simultaneously. This is the ideal and
|
|||
|
it ought to be striven for. I wish I had a dollar for every sexual
|
|||
|
relationship that has been ruined by that myth.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Let me cite a clinical vignette to illustrate the connection
|
|||
|
between Christian teachings about sex and sexual difficulties. A
|
|||
|
University professor and his wife had been married for 20 or so
|
|||
|
years and sought help for sexual and marital problems. They had
|
|||
|
both grown up in the Bible Belt of the American midwest and when
|
|||
|
they were courting, got into heavy petting or manual stimulation of
|
|||
|
each others genitals, fully clothed mind you, and this they both
|
|||
|
found pleasurable. They did not have intercourse because of their
|
|||
|
Christian upbringing. When they got married and were now able to do
|
|||
|
it, they expected that now she would get the same or more pleasure
|
|||
|
out of intercourse that she had got out of the heavy petting.
|
|||
|
Expecting to experience simultaneous orgasm, they found that she
|
|||
|
was not even having an orgasm at any time during intercourse. It
|
|||
|
never occurred to them to incorporate the fun things they were
|
|||
|
doing before they got married. This was kid stuff and they should
|
|||
|
not need to do this now that their union was blessed by the deity.
|
|||
|
She felt she was a failure as a woman, and he felt he was a failure
|
|||
|
as a lover. Their relationship went down hill to the point where it
|
|||
|
could not be repaired.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Returning to the myth of the vaginal orgasm, this myth is that the
|
|||
|
woman should have her climax, if not simultaneously with her
|
|||
|
partner, then at least sometime during the act of intercourse. In
|
|||
|
spite of the fact that this myth has been exploded in women's
|
|||
|
magazines, it is still very much alive. This places a tremendous
|
|||
|
burden on both participants. The fact is that the majority of women
|
|||
|
do not have orgasms with intercourse, requiring more direct
|
|||
|
stimulus of the clitoris than intercourse provides. Many men whose
|
|||
|
partners do not have orgasms after ten minutes of pelvic thrusting
|
|||
|
think they suffer from so-called, premature ejaculation. In fact
|
|||
|
the average length of time between penetration and ejaculation in
|
|||
|
the male is 2 to 5 minutes. On the other hand, I have seen women
|
|||
|
who felt they were defective because they were unable to have an
|
|||
|
orgasm during intercourse that lasted a mere thirty seconds.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Space does not permit me to explore how Christian teachings about
|
|||
|
sexuality contribute to rape and child sexual molestation. Anyone
|
|||
|
interested in this can refer to an article I wrote on this in
|
|||
|
_Humanist in Canada_, Autumn 1990. I just want to remind you that
|
|||
|
neither rape nor child sexual molestation are specifically
|
|||
|
prohibited in Christian teachings about sex. One was not supposed
|
|||
|
to look at another man's wife or seduce his daughter only because
|
|||
|
these women were his property. The crime of rape was against the
|
|||
|
owner of the victim, whether she was a slave, a servant, or a wife.
|
|||
|
Indeed the concept of rape within marriage was not considered
|
|||
|
seriously by secular legislators until quite recently.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Sexual ignorance is characteristic of all sexual problems. The
|
|||
|
level of sexual ignorance in our society moved Bertrand Russell to
|
|||
|
state: Almost every adult in a Christian community is more or less
|
|||
|
diseased nervously as a result of the taboo on sexual knowledge
|
|||
|
when he or she was young. It follows that knowledge is what people
|
|||
|
need to enable them to free themselves from the sexual prison
|
|||
|
Christianity has created, but the acquisition of that knowledge has
|
|||
|
been steadfastly resisted by Christian god-talkers everywhere
|
|||
|
throughout the English-speaking world.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Charge 2. Policies of coercive pronatalism and demographic
|
|||
|
aggression, implicit in Christianity's opposition to reproductive
|
|||
|
regulation, have been directly responsible for sixteen centuries of
|
|||
|
human suffering, mainly on the part of women.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The suffering of women has taken many forms;
|
|||
|
(a) premature death in countless millions of women over the
|
|||
|
centuries,
|
|||
|
(b) intense suffering by untold millions of families and
|
|||
|
individuals due to excess and unwanted births, and
|
|||
|
(c) ecological disaster through over-population,
|
|||
|
Christianity being numerically the largest religion in
|
|||
|
the world.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
American Demographer Stephen Mumford (5) has demonstrated
|
|||
|
pretty conclusively something we all knew but would rather
|
|||
|
forget, namely, that excessive population growth lies at the
|
|||
|
root of many of the world's social and economic problems. We
|
|||
|
are already the most numerous of all the mammals, whose
|
|||
|
numbers are dropping, and our growth rate is much higher than
|
|||
|
predictions of ten years ago. God must surely be satisfied,
|
|||
|
since the biblical instructions to populate and subdue the
|
|||
|
earth have been obeyed to a "T".
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The current recession, starvation in various parts of the
|
|||
|
world, the plight of the millions of street children
|
|||
|
especially in Catholic South America, the world-wide refugee
|
|||
|
problem, illegal migration across national borders; these
|
|||
|
represent only a few of the problems posed by excess
|
|||
|
population growth, and any discussion that refuses to confront
|
|||
|
connections between these problems and excess population is
|
|||
|
meaningless.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Mumford also points out that, even when excess population
|
|||
|
growth is discussed, it is rare that the coercively
|
|||
|
pronatalist forces operating in society are identified. Even
|
|||
|
more rarely is the finger pointed at the main villains of the
|
|||
|
piece, the Roman Catholic and Fundamentalist Christian
|
|||
|
Churches. It is his view and mine, that, for example if the
|
|||
|
Roman Catholic Church were to drop its vigorous and vicious
|
|||
|
opposition to secular abortion laws, the so-called "pro-life"
|
|||
|
movement would collapse. And this is an important point since
|
|||
|
world population cannot be brought under control without ready
|
|||
|
access to abortion services to deal with failed contraception.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Because many Catholics have ignored Humanae Vitae and use
|
|||
|
contraception freely, and because many of them have abortions
|
|||
|
when they are available, just like non-Catholics do, we have
|
|||
|
been lulled into a sense of false security about the part the
|
|||
|
Roman Catholic Church is playing now in the population crisis.
|
|||
|
We forget that the teachings of Christianity have more impact
|
|||
|
on people in the developing world, those who are less well
|
|||
|
educated and those who are economically disadvantaged: so that
|
|||
|
the church's pronatalist injunctions are still working
|
|||
|
directly in large parts of the Christian world. But more
|
|||
|
important is the control exerted by the Vatican over
|
|||
|
politicians throughout the world,(except perhaps in China), in
|
|||
|
blocking legislation aimed at placing more power to control
|
|||
|
their fertility in the hands of sexually active men and women.
|
|||
|
We have yet to see any world leader speak out against the
|
|||
|
Vatican for its part in hurtling all of us towards an
|
|||
|
ecological holocaust. Can you imagine Brian Mulroney or Joe
|
|||
|
Clark, both Roman Catholics, chastising the Pope for his part
|
|||
|
in setting a match to the population bomb?
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In this country it is a crime to yell "fire" in a crowded
|
|||
|
theatre; meanwhile, metaphorically, the pope and his
|
|||
|
fundamentalist friends set fire to the theatre and everyone
|
|||
|
ignores it. Mumford claimed in 1980, that when it finally gets
|
|||
|
through to people, the extent to which the policies of the
|
|||
|
Roman Catholic and fundamentalist churches are contributing to
|
|||
|
the population problem, people will turn on the churches in a
|
|||
|
rage and destroy them. Meanwhile it may be too late to save
|
|||
|
the world.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
If we want to avoid this Christian Armageddon, national secu-
|
|||
|
lar governments will have to lead the way and protest the
|
|||
|
coercive pronatalist policies of these Christian churches. And
|
|||
|
they must do what they can to mute the impact of those
|
|||
|
policies on the people who are not yet in a position to stand
|
|||
|
up to their god-talking masters. This is unlikely to happen
|
|||
|
unless we Humanists, on both a national and an international
|
|||
|
level give this issue top priority. We must see to it that the
|
|||
|
villains in the Vatican and elsewhere are recognized as the
|
|||
|
inhuman power mongers they really are. Only those of us who
|
|||
|
have managed to get the religious monkey off our backs, more
|
|||
|
or less, are in a psychological position to call a spade a
|
|||
|
spade in this way. Others will follow but we must lead and
|
|||
|
work until we have the support of enough people to convince
|
|||
|
our leaders that they must switch allegiances and confront the
|
|||
|
Christian church rather than remain cowed by that institution.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Charge 3. Christianity's teachings about gender roles (sex
|
|||
|
roles) are a major cause of couple relationship stress.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In the early Christian church, women may have had a totally
|
|||
|
different role than they had after the decision was made to
|
|||
|
build an earthly institution. Christianity may not have
|
|||
|
invented sexism, but it certainly did everything it could to
|
|||
|
place women in the subservient role, a role that was necessary
|
|||
|
for converting the uterus into a Christian baby factory. The
|
|||
|
church became a vehicle for males to assert absolute control
|
|||
|
over females, thereby making egalitarian human relationships
|
|||
|
between the sexes impossible.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The attitude of the church about the role of the sexes was
|
|||
|
codified in a book all Humanists should read "The Malleus
|
|||
|
Maleficarum" or the Witches Hammer by two medieval Dominican
|
|||
|
priests. This was a manual for the Inquisition during the
|
|||
|
witch hunts that ravaged Europe for three centuries. This
|
|||
|
book, which one editor said was "among the most important,
|
|||
|
wisest and weightiest books of the world" first appeared about
|
|||
|
1486 and saw 14 editions between 1487 and 1520 and at least 16
|
|||
|
editions between 1574 and 1669, and was adopted by Roman
|
|||
|
Catholic and Protestant jurisdictions. Given that publication
|
|||
|
track record it must be given the credit or blame for many of
|
|||
|
our modern western attitudes about maleness and femaleness.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Listen to what this book says of women:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
" There is no head above the head of a serpent and there is no
|
|||
|
wrath above the wrath of a woman. I had rather dwell with a
|
|||
|
lion and a dragon than to keep house with a wicked woman."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"All wickedness is but little to the wickedness of a woman."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"What else is woman but a foe to friendship, an unescapable
|
|||
|
punishment, a necessary evil, a natural temptation, a
|
|||
|
desirable calamity, a domestic danger, a delectable detriment,
|
|||
|
an evil of nature painted with fair colours.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
According to the authors, women were "credulous, more nat-
|
|||
|
urally impressionable and more ready to receive the influence
|
|||
|
of a disembodied spirit." They were reputed to have "weak
|
|||
|
memories," a view with which most married men will not agree,
|
|||
|
I'm sure. It was also determined that women "have slippery
|
|||
|
tongues and are unable to conceal from their fellow-women
|
|||
|
those things which by evil arts they know; and since they are
|
|||
|
weak, they find an easy and secret manner of vindicating
|
|||
|
themselves by witchcraft." I like that: the church does
|
|||
|
everything it can to keep women subordinate to men and then
|
|||
|
criticizes them for being weak!
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Women were "feebler in mind and body," and "intellectually
|
|||
|
like children." And "she was formed from a bent rib, that is,
|
|||
|
a rib of the breast, which is bent as it were in a contrary
|
|||
|
direction to man." The authors conclude "Since through this
|
|||
|
defect she is an imperfect animal, she always deceives." She
|
|||
|
is "a liar by nature."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Most telling is this indictment of normal human emotions;
|
|||
|
"Just as through the first defect in their intelligence, they
|
|||
|
are more prone to abjure the faith: so through their second
|
|||
|
defect of inordinate affections and passions they search for
|
|||
|
and brood over, and inflict vengeance, either by witchcraft or
|
|||
|
by some other means."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The good monks sum it up in these words "All witchcraft comes
|
|||
|
from carnal lust, which is in women insatiable." It is not
|
|||
|
much wonder that by the nineteenth century women had been so
|
|||
|
frightened of their normal sexuality that they had repressed
|
|||
|
it almost completely. The so-called Victorian era had nothing
|
|||
|
to do with Victoria but was related to three centuries of this
|
|||
|
kind of indoctrination by the Christian church.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
What about men, you ask. Well Eve was the one whom the devil
|
|||
|
managed to seduce in the Garden of Evil; Adam being too well
|
|||
|
put together apparently to succumb. But although Adam did not
|
|||
|
allow himself to be seduced by Satan, he could not stand up to
|
|||
|
the blandishments of the devil's agent, Eve. The authors of
|
|||
|
The Malleus Maleficarum put it this way: "And blessed be the
|
|||
|
Highest Who has so far preserved the male sex from so great a
|
|||
|
crime (witchcraft); for since He was willing to be born and to
|
|||
|
suffer for us, therefore He has granted to men this privilege.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
It always struck me that these female creatures who were so
|
|||
|
feeble in mind and body, stupid, deceitful, and emotional,
|
|||
|
were at the same time expected to conceive, to bear, to
|
|||
|
nurture and to raise each new generation of Christians. That
|
|||
|
sounds like a lot of responsibility for people who, by
|
|||
|
definition, were so ill-equipped for the task. One wonders why
|
|||
|
the men, who were so perfect according to this teaching, were
|
|||
|
not required to take over the job of raising the children, as
|
|||
|
soon as it was biologically possible, rather than leave them
|
|||
|
to the mercy of such wretched role models.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Larry Feldman, a researcher on family functioning has reviewed
|
|||
|
the literature on the impact of gender role on the
|
|||
|
relationship between the sexes, and he concluded that this was
|
|||
|
and is a major cause of family dysfunctions(6). As he put it
|
|||
|
"Sex role conditioning exerts a variety of dysfunctional
|
|||
|
influences on the marital and family relationships: and these
|
|||
|
sex roles interact in a mutually reinforcing way that inhibits
|
|||
|
the psychological development of each family member.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Feldman found that in our society, women were expected to be
|
|||
|
home and child oriented, warm, affectionate, gentle tender,
|
|||
|
aware of feelings of others, considerate, tactful,
|
|||
|
compassionate, moody, high strung, temperamental, excitable,
|
|||
|
emotional, subjective, illogical, complaining, nagging, weak,
|
|||
|
helpless, fragile, easily hurt emotionally, submissive,
|
|||
|
yielding, dependent.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Men, on the other hand were expected to be calm, stable,
|
|||
|
unemotional, realistic, logical, ambitious, competitive,
|
|||
|
enterprising, worldly, strong, tough, powerful, aggressive,
|
|||
|
forceful, decisive, dominant, independent, self-reliant,
|
|||
|
harsh, severe, stern, cruel, autocratic, rigid, arrogant.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
I'm sure you can see many parallels between the profile of the
|
|||
|
female painted by Feldman and the one described by the Malleus
|
|||
|
Maleficarum. The same thing is true of the male.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
We usually think of the woman as being the chief victim of the
|
|||
|
fall-out of centuries of Christian teaching about gender
|
|||
|
roles. Few people realize that the male, who was encouraged in
|
|||
|
Malleus Maleficarum to suppress his normal natural emotions,
|
|||
|
lest he appear like a woman, was, in doing so, cutting himself
|
|||
|
off from a very important part of his humanness. This is also
|
|||
|
encouraged in the second book I would recommend to all
|
|||
|
humanists: "The Imitation of Christ" by Thomas a Kempis, first
|
|||
|
published about 1427(7). By 1472 the first printed edition
|
|||
|
appeared. By the end of the nineteenth century 600 editions
|
|||
|
had been printed in Latin, 300 in Italian, 350 in German and
|
|||
|
"uncounted hundreds of editions of this choicest devotional
|
|||
|
handbook," to quote one editor, had been printed in English.
|
|||
|
It has been called "the best-loved, most widely read religious
|
|||
|
book in the world, after the Bible." It was the book Pope John
|
|||
|
Paul I was supposed to have been reading when he met his
|
|||
|
untimely death in 1978.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This book reinforces the notion that the godly man denies his
|
|||
|
emotions; "A passionate man turneth even good into evil and
|
|||
|
easily believeth evil. My son, trust not to thy feeling, for
|
|||
|
it will quickly be changed into something else." This is not
|
|||
|
simply an issue of historical or scientific curiosity. One of
|
|||
|
the main problems we find in working with couples in
|
|||
|
couple/sex therapy is the difficulty the woman has in living
|
|||
|
with a partner so cut off from feelings: the main difficulty
|
|||
|
for the male is recognizing this is no longer an admirable
|
|||
|
characteristic, but a handicap whose removal could make life a
|
|||
|
richer experience for him.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
End of Part II Christianity on trial
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|| END OF ARTICLE ||
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Anti-Semitism: Its Prevalence Within the Christian Right,
|
|||
|
Part I, by Skipp Porteous
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Freedom Writer * May 1994
|
|||
|
Anti-Semitism: Its Prevalance Within the Religious Right
|
|||
|
By Skipp Porteous
|
|||
|
c. 1994 IFAS
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A study by the Institute for First Amendment Studies found a
|
|||
|
prevalence of anti-Semitism within the Christian Right. While
|
|||
|
some of the prejudice and hostility toward Jews is concealed,
|
|||
|
much is blatant. Stereotyping of Jews is widespread; and
|
|||
|
anti-Semitism in the form of aggressive missionary activity
|
|||
|
threatens the very existence of Judaism.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Several disturbing trends indicate that _ unless sweeping
|
|||
|
changes are made _ anti-Semitism within conservative
|
|||
|
Christianity will not only continue as a long-term problem,
|
|||
|
but will escalate sharply. Thousands of private Christian
|
|||
|
schools and Christian home schools utilize anti-Semitic
|
|||
|
textbooks. These textbooks include the "original" McGuffey's
|
|||
|
Readers, which have enjoyed a tremendous resurgence in recent
|
|||
|
years, and books published by Bob Jones University Press for
|
|||
|
use in Christian schools.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Additionally, the Christian Right's anti-abortion movement has
|
|||
|
anti-Semitic overtones. Anti-abortion groups such as Operation
|
|||
|
Rescue and Life Dynamics list "Jewish doctors" as the leading
|
|||
|
performers of abortion.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
So-called "humanism" is under attack by the Religious Right in
|
|||
|
schools and other institutions across the country.
|
|||
|
Condemnation of humanism has anti-Semitic roots. Though seldom
|
|||
|
mentioned, Christian Right leaders link humanism with Judaism,
|
|||
|
saying "Judaism grew out of the rejection of Jesus Christ and
|
|||
|
steadily became humanism."(1)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Other disturbing observations involve a melding of extreme
|
|||
|
right-wing anti-Semites and their mainstream counterparts.
|
|||
|
Pastor Pete Peters, a nationally known anti-Semitic Christian
|
|||
|
Identity preacher, has found a home on the Keystone
|
|||
|
Inspiration Network. This Christian "family" network is
|
|||
|
available on cable TV in approximately 120 cities across the
|
|||
|
country.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Rev. Donald Wildmon, the Methodist minister who heads the
|
|||
|
American Family Association (AFA), is no stranger to
|
|||
|
accusations of anti-Semitism. Though he denies being
|
|||
|
anti-Semitic, he has emerged as the darling of the
|
|||
|
anti-Semitic Liberty Lobby. In fact, his AFA has a special
|
|||
|
spot on Liberty Lobby's LogoPlex, an extreme-rightist computer
|
|||
|
bulletin board service.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Ofttimes, only the most blatant anti-Semitic incidents are
|
|||
|
reported. Much of the anti-Semitism within conservative
|
|||
|
Christianity goes unnoticed and unreported. Some forms are so
|
|||
|
subtle that only those familiar with the code words and
|
|||
|
innuendo can spot it.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Stereotyping
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Stereotyping is among the most common form of anti-Semitism.
|
|||
|
This is evidenced by the words of many well-known Christian
|
|||
|
leaders, among them the Rev. Bailey Smith. "I don't know why
|
|||
|
God chose the Jew," Smith said. "They have such funny noses."(2)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Outward appearance, though, is not the only way some leaders
|
|||
|
characterize Jews. The Rev. Dan C. Fore, former head of the
|
|||
|
Moral Majority in New York, said, "I love the Jewish people
|
|||
|
deeply. God has given them talents He has not given others.
|
|||
|
They are His chosen people. Jews have a God-given ability to
|
|||
|
make money...They control the media, they control this city."(3)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"A few of you don't like the Jews and I know why," said the
|
|||
|
Rev. Jerry Falwell. "He [sic] can make more money accidently
|
|||
|
than you can make on purpose."(4)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Missionary Activity
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A second form of anti-Semitism involves missionary activity
|
|||
|
directed at Jews. Many conservative Christian leaders hold the
|
|||
|
view that Judaism is an invalid religion, that Jews who don't
|
|||
|
believe in Jesus are "unsaved" or "incomplete." The
|
|||
|
offensiveness of this type of anti-Semitism should be obvious,
|
|||
|
but often goes unnoticed.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"It's interesting at great political rallies," preached the
|
|||
|
Rev. Bailey Smith, "how you have a Protestant to pray, a
|
|||
|
Catholic to pray, and then you have a Jew to pray. With all
|
|||
|
due respect to those dear people, my friends, God Almighty
|
|||
|
does not hear the prayer of a Jew. For how in the world can
|
|||
|
God hear the prayer of a man who says that Jesus Christ is not
|
|||
|
the true Messiah? That is blasphemy."(5)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Rev. Jerry Falwell sanctioned this viewpoint in his book,
|
|||
|
Listen, America! "The Jews are returning to their land of
|
|||
|
unbelief. They are spiritually blind and desperately in need
|
|||
|
of their Messiah and Savior. Yet they are God's people, and in
|
|||
|
the world today Bible-believing Christians are the best
|
|||
|
friends the nation Israel has."(6)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Falwell correctly points out that he and other American
|
|||
|
Fundamentalist Christians support the nation of Israel. It
|
|||
|
should be noted, however, that this support is for a piece of
|
|||
|
real estate, the land of Israel, and not necessarily for the
|
|||
|
Jewish people.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Pat Robertson, too, thinks of Jews as "spiritually deaf" and
|
|||
|
"spiritually blind." In the end times, Robertson believes,
|
|||
|
Jews will be brought in as "offerings to the Lord."(7) He
|
|||
|
predicts mass conversions of Jews to Christianity, and toward
|
|||
|
this end, Robertson built a Christian radio station in Lebanon
|
|||
|
to beam the Gospel into the Jewish state, which
|
|||
|
Fundamentalists believe will eventually be inherited by
|
|||
|
Christians. For the present, Jews occupy the land as
|
|||
|
caretakers.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Many Christian organizations presume an obligation to convert
|
|||
|
Jews to Christianity. While Jews for Jesus may be the most
|
|||
|
well-known of these groups, according to Mark Powers, national
|
|||
|
director of Jews for Judaism, more than 450 missionary
|
|||
|
organizations specifically target Jews in the United States,
|
|||
|
Canada, and Israel. More than 350,000 American Christians now
|
|||
|
identify themselves as former Jews; 140,000 of that total call
|
|||
|
themselves "Hebrew Christians."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
One group, The Christian Jew Foundation (CJF), publishes a
|
|||
|
newsletter called The Message of the Christian Jew. An ugly
|
|||
|
article by Charles Halff, the group's executive director,
|
|||
|
titled "The Blindness of the Jew"(8) stated:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Gentile Christians sometimes wonder why Jewish evangelism is
|
|||
|
such difficult and discouraging work. Our missionaries are
|
|||
|
spat on, ridiculed, threatened, maligned, and sometimes
|
|||
|
physically abused.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"David Zauber, our CJF missionary in Georgia, is a Jewish
|
|||
|
Christian_and weighs probably 150 pounds, soaking wet! He was
|
|||
|
passing out Gospel tracts near the subway a few years ago,
|
|||
|
when a Jewish man knocked him down with his fist. By the time
|
|||
|
David caught his breath and got back to his feet, the man had
|
|||
|
disappeared into the crowd. This is just one example of the
|
|||
|
difficulties our missionaries face.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"We wonder, why are the sons of Israel so belligerent and
|
|||
|
hard-hearted?"
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Halff answered his rhetorical question. "As we look at Jews
|
|||
|
today, we see that they are blinded by tradition; they are
|
|||
|
blinded by prejudice; and they are blinded by
|
|||
|
self-righteousness." He adds, "The majority of them live by
|
|||
|
the Talmud, rather than by the Old Testament. Judaism is a
|
|||
|
religion of works and tradition. One such tradition is the
|
|||
|
practice of waving a chicken overhead and chanting, `This is
|
|||
|
my sacrifice!' We know this is absolutely contrary to the
|
|||
|
teaching of the New Testament, since the blood of Messiah
|
|||
|
(Jesus) had been shed for the sins of many, and `there is no
|
|||
|
more offering for sin' (Hebrews 10:18.)"
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
One entire issue of The Message of the Christian Jew(9) dealt
|
|||
|
with anti-Semitism. While acknowledging the most overt types
|
|||
|
of anti-Semitism, the writers failed to see how Christian
|
|||
|
missionary activity is a threat to the very existence of
|
|||
|
Judaism. In fact, an article by Gary Hedrick, the group's
|
|||
|
president, utilized a strange approach.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Let us not forget, however," Hedrick wrote, "that a more
|
|||
|
subtle form of anti-Semitism is now sweeping our land. It's
|
|||
|
known by a variety of names, but most notably as the
|
|||
|
'Two-Covenant,' or `Dual-Covenant' movement. Its proponents
|
|||
|
claim that the Jewish people have their own Sinai Covenant and
|
|||
|
therefore have no need of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Can you think of a more diabolical form of anti-Semitism than
|
|||
|
the view that the Gospel of Jesus Christ is for Gentiles, but
|
|||
|
not for Jews?"
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Anti-Semitism and Christian Schools
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
With an estimated 500,000 children being taught at home, the
|
|||
|
home school movement is a rapidly growing phenomena.
|
|||
|
Newsweek's Sam Allis called Christian Fundamentalism "the
|
|||
|
backbone of the home-school movement." One series of books,
|
|||
|
McGuffey's Eclectic Readers, popular with both Christian
|
|||
|
schools and home schools, influence the minds of
|
|||
|
tens-of-thousands of impressionable youngsters.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
These are the same books originally published in 1836 by the
|
|||
|
Rev. William H. McGuffey. With 19th century sales of 125
|
|||
|
million copies, McGuffey is considered "the author of the most
|
|||
|
popular schoolbook ever written." McGuffey's original Readers
|
|||
|
were, according to the current publishers, "Christ-centered."
|
|||
|
In time, though, most of the religious references were
|
|||
|
removed.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
McGuffey's original Readers, now reborn for use in Christian
|
|||
|
homes and schools, are sexist, racist, and anti-Semitic. While
|
|||
|
the Readers reflect the time in which they were written, their
|
|||
|
use today indicates a giant step backward in human relations.
|
|||
|
The sexist aspects of the Readers promote "proper" roles for
|
|||
|
men and women. Among the racism portrayed is the constant
|
|||
|
referral to Native Americans as "savages." The anti-Semitism
|
|||
|
found in the McGuffey's Readers takes several forms.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A line from the Eclectic Third Reader warns students about the
|
|||
|
perils of rejecting Christianity. "It will cost something to
|
|||
|
be a Christian: it will cost more not to be so."(10)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In the same Reader, Christianity is championed as the only
|
|||
|
dependable religion. "There are no principles but those of
|
|||
|
CHRISTIANITY, to be depended upon in cases of REAL DISTRESS."
|
|||
|
(Emphasis in original)(11)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Jewish veneration of the Scriptures is denigrated. "The Old
|
|||
|
Testament has been preserved by the Jews in every age, with a
|
|||
|
scrupulous jealousy, and with a veneration for its words and
|
|||
|
letters, bordering on superstition..."(12)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
McGuffey suggests that the rise of Christianity was not only
|
|||
|
predicted in the Old Testament, but was a result of Jewish
|
|||
|
infidelity toward God _ a common anti-Semitic theme. The
|
|||
|
Reader mentions "...the Jews as the keepers of the Old
|
|||
|
Testament." Then, "It was their own sacred volume, which
|
|||
|
contained the most extraordinary predictions concerning the
|
|||
|
infidelity of their nation, and the rise, progress, and
|
|||
|
extensive prevalence of Christianity."(13)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In one fell swoop, McGuffey obliterates Jewish moral law, and
|
|||
|
all other moral teachings before Jesus. "The morality taught
|
|||
|
by Jesus Christ was purer, sounder, sublimer, and more perfect
|
|||
|
than had ever before entered into the imagination, or
|
|||
|
proceeded from the lips of man."(14)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In Lesson XVIII, dealing with Divine inspiration of the
|
|||
|
Gospel, the Eclectic Fourth Reader asks, "Why is it
|
|||
|
inconceivable that the book is fiction?" The answer, "The
|
|||
|
Jewish authors were incapable of the diction, and strangers to
|
|||
|
the morality, contained in the gospel..."(15)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A short story called "The Blind Preacher," recounts a blind
|
|||
|
minister's sermon about the trial and crucifixion of Jesus.
|
|||
|
The story reinforces the notion that Jews are responsible for
|
|||
|
the death of Jesus. "We saw the very faces of the Jews, the
|
|||
|
staring, frightful distortions of malice and rage."(16)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In fact, every single reference to Jews in McGuffey's Readers
|
|||
|
is negative. No effort is made to explain Judaism, or to teach
|
|||
|
what Jews believe.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The McGuffey Readers series is frequently advertised by the
|
|||
|
Conservative Book Club on the back of the Rev. Donald
|
|||
|
Wildmon's magazine, the AFA Journal, and in Pat Robertson's
|
|||
|
Christian American. The ads proclaim: "The ORIGINAL McGuffey's
|
|||
|
Readers were different. They were Christian." Copy in the ad
|
|||
|
says, "...give them some of the memorable poetry and prose of
|
|||
|
our Anglo-American inheritance..."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Two companies, Mott Media, of Milford, Michigan, and Thoburn
|
|||
|
Press, of Tyler, Texas, publish the "original" McGuffey's
|
|||
|
Eclectic Readers. The seven-volume set has been reprinted from
|
|||
|
the originals.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Several organizations that provide textbooks to Christian home
|
|||
|
schoolers promote the use of McGuffey's Readers. One,
|
|||
|
Christian Liberty Academy Satellite Schools (CLASS), now
|
|||
|
publishes its own Eclectic Reader. Michael McHugh, curriculum
|
|||
|
administrator for CLASS, reported that his organization sold
|
|||
|
between 5,000 and 6,000 of the Thoburn McGuffey's Readers to
|
|||
|
home schools.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Since 1982, Mott Media has sold a whopping 100,000 sets of the
|
|||
|
Readers. "Last year [1993] we started our Home School Book
|
|||
|
Club," Joyce Bowen, Mott Media's general manager, said. "In
|
|||
|
less than a year we sold between 4,000 and 5,000 sets to home
|
|||
|
schools."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The widespread use of McGuffey's Readers is a good indication
|
|||
|
of what children are being taught about Jews in many Christian
|
|||
|
schools and home schools. With the rapid growth of these
|
|||
|
schools, this should be of concern to caring Christian parents
|
|||
|
and responsible Christian leaders.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In other Christian textbooks, anti-Semitism exists by
|
|||
|
omission. The curriculum used by many Christian schools
|
|||
|
neglects Jewish accomplishments and positive contributions to
|
|||
|
history. This is documented by Albert J. Menendez in Visions
|
|||
|
of Reality _ What Fundamentalist Schools Teach, a report on
|
|||
|
the textbooks used in Christian Fundamentalist schools:
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Surprisingly, Jews and Judaism are almost invisible in these
|
|||
|
volumes. No mention is made of any Jewish contribution to U.S.
|
|||
|
history nor are any Jewish personalities in literature, sports
|
|||
|
or the arts mentioned. There is no reference to justices
|
|||
|
Frankfurter, Brandeis or Cardozo. The only Jews mentioned are
|
|||
|
Karl Marx, who is called `an atheistic German Jew,'(17) and
|
|||
|
Sigmund Freud. It is noted that Jews were persecuted in
|
|||
|
Catholic countries but nothing is said about anti-Jewish
|
|||
|
discrimination in Protestant countries. Jewish supporters of
|
|||
|
Columbus are mentioned, as is the suggestion that Columbus may
|
|||
|
have been seeking a refuge for Jews.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"One passage in a world history text, however, blames Jews for
|
|||
|
the crucifixion of Jesus. `The Jewish religious leaders, whose
|
|||
|
blindness and hypocrisy Jesus had denounced, sought to put Him
|
|||
|
to death. They brought Christ before the Roman governor
|
|||
|
Pontius Pilate, charging that Christ had disrupted the
|
|||
|
state...Although Pilate found no fault in Jesus, he desired to
|
|||
|
maintain the peace. Giving in to the Jewish demands, he
|
|||
|
sentenced Jesus to death by crucifixion.'(18) In addition, we
|
|||
|
are informed, `God used the destruction of Jerusalem to
|
|||
|
separate the early church from its Jewish environment and to
|
|||
|
scatter Christians throughout the Roman Empire.'(19)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"And one strange passage in a biology text says, `The Jews
|
|||
|
were pruned for the Gentiles' sake, but they were also pruned
|
|||
|
for their disbelief.'"(20)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Anti-Semitism and Anti-Abortion
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
There are indications that the Christian Right's anti-abortion
|
|||
|
crusade has anti-Semitic components. In 1989, Newsweek
|
|||
|
magazine reported that Randall Terry, founder of the
|
|||
|
anti-abortion group Operation Rescue, said, "We have tried to
|
|||
|
do some outreach to the black and Jewish communities," but
|
|||
|
admitted that those efforts have failed, "...and that he is
|
|||
|
critical of the Jewish doctors, who he believes perform a
|
|||
|
large number of abortions."(21)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In doing research for this report, Operation Rescue National
|
|||
|
referred us to Life Dynamics Incorporated, a Christian
|
|||
|
anti-abortion organization based in Dallas, for specific
|
|||
|
information on abortion. Life Dynamics is an important
|
|||
|
research arm of the Christian Right's anti-abortion crusade.
|
|||
|
According to Life Dynamics, 26% of all doctors who perform
|
|||
|
abortions are Jewish (A spokesperson for Planned Parenthood
|
|||
|
called this figure "ludicrous.") Considering that Jews
|
|||
|
comprise only 2% of the population, this figure is
|
|||
|
disproportionately high.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The thought is not lost in Life Dynamics' popular Bottom
|
|||
|
Feeder "joke book." Bottom Feeder is an assortment of
|
|||
|
hackneyed jokes aimed at doctors who perform abortions. The
|
|||
|
jokes and cartoons are crude, scatological, and suggest that
|
|||
|
abortionists have sex with animals. Significantly, Bottom
|
|||
|
Feeder contains a number of references to Jews, and
|
|||
|
consistently portrays in cartoon form doctors who perform
|
|||
|
abortions as having exceptionally large noses, an age-old
|
|||
|
anti-Semitic allusion to Jews.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Examples of Bottom Feeder's references to Jews include a list
|
|||
|
of the "four shortest books in the world." One is entitled
|
|||
|
"Famous Jewish Astronauts." One joke favors Adolf Hitler over
|
|||
|
an abortionist. It goes, "Q. What would you do if you found
|
|||
|
yourself in a room with Hitler, Mussolini and an abortionist,
|
|||
|
and you had a gun with only two bullets? A. Shoot the
|
|||
|
abortionist twice."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Aware that a high percentage of Jews are liberal and
|
|||
|
pro-choice, the anti-abortion movement targets Jews as "baby
|
|||
|
killers."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Additionally, a considerable number of the people involved in
|
|||
|
groups such as Operation Rescue, Lambs of Christ, and
|
|||
|
Missionaries to the Preborn, teach their children at home,
|
|||
|
using McGuffey's Readers and other materials mentioned in the
|
|||
|
section on Christian schools and home schools.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The Christian Right anti-abortion movement often refers to
|
|||
|
abortion as "the Holocaust in America." [Newsweek, May 1,
|
|||
|
1989] This phrase is notable only for its shock value. To even
|
|||
|
remotely equate the two, especially in such a cavalier manner,
|
|||
|
offends not only Jews, but everyone who is aware of the
|
|||
|
horrors of the Nazis. Rabbi Balfour Brickner, Rabbi Emeritus
|
|||
|
of the Stephen Wise Free Synagogue in New York, said, "The
|
|||
|
Holocaust stands alone...There are no legitimate or acceptable
|
|||
|
analogies."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Bait and Switch
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
For years, anti-Semitic innuendo has cleverly passed as simply
|
|||
|
an attack on humanism. By employing a sort of "bait and
|
|||
|
switch" tactic, the conservative Christian right has shifted
|
|||
|
all the blame for the world's ills from the Jews to
|
|||
|
"humanists" _ whom conservatives suspect are mostly Jews
|
|||
|
anyway. The theory here is that humanism is a "secular
|
|||
|
religion" that evolved out of modern Judaism. Instead of
|
|||
|
saying that Jews control the financial institutions, the
|
|||
|
media, the entertainment industry, and education, it is now
|
|||
|
the humanists who are in control.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
This is borne out in the teachings of Rousas John (R.J.)
|
|||
|
Rushdoony, a former Presbyterian minister who is known as the
|
|||
|
"father of Christian Reconstruction." While Rushdoony is not
|
|||
|
well-known outside the circle of conservative Christian
|
|||
|
leadership, his influence within the movement is substantial.
|
|||
|
Rushdoony is a prolific author and his books approach
|
|||
|
best-seller status, shaping contemporary Christian thought
|
|||
|
since the 1960s. Rushdoony, a profound Christian thinker, is
|
|||
|
never afraid to say what some other Christian leaders are
|
|||
|
merely thinking.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
According to Gary North, Rushdoony's son-in-law, "Rushdoony
|
|||
|
identified the underlying problem a generation ago: `JUDAISM
|
|||
|
grew out of the rejection of Jesus Christ and STEADILY BECAME
|
|||
|
HUMANISM [emphasis added], and the Talmud is essentially the
|
|||
|
exposition of humanism under the facade of Scripture.'"(22)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Judaism became humanism! To grasp this concept is to
|
|||
|
understand why some notable Christian leaders exhibit
|
|||
|
hostility toward humanists. Leaders of the radical Christian
|
|||
|
Right know that many influential Jewish leaders are wholly
|
|||
|
secular. That is, they embrace Jewish culture, without
|
|||
|
observing the rituals of Judaism.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Another Christian writer is the Rev. Tim LaHaye, former leader
|
|||
|
of the Moral Majority. LaHaye is married to Beverly LaHaye,
|
|||
|
head of the 600,000-member Concerned Women for America
|
|||
|
organization.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In his 1980 book, The Battle for the Mind, LaHaye unleashed a
|
|||
|
vicious attack against humanism. Jews have traditionally been
|
|||
|
accused of everything for which LaHaye blames humanists.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Our country is "...controlled by a small but very influential
|
|||
|
cadre of committed humanists..."(23)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Pornography is the fault of "the humanist controllers of the
|
|||
|
American Civil Liberties Union and their humanist partners in
|
|||
|
moral crime_the judges who were appointed by the humanist
|
|||
|
politicians."(24)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"When the humanists came to America, their obstacles seemed
|
|||
|
overwhelming. But rather than waste their resources, they
|
|||
|
concentrated on using four vehicles to penetrate the minds and
|
|||
|
lives of our people: education, the media, organizations, and
|
|||
|
government."(25)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"We have already seen how John Dewey and his fellow humanists
|
|||
|
took over education..."(26) While Dewey wasn't Jewish, many of
|
|||
|
his colleagues were.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Space does not permit a detailed account of how newspapers
|
|||
|
from coast to coast were gradually purchased by powerful,
|
|||
|
monied interests. As radio came into view, it was bought up by
|
|||
|
some of these same interests. Later, when TV licenses became
|
|||
|
available, the humanists flooded the field. Today, it is all
|
|||
|
humanistically controlled."(27)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"This news is carefully edited before being sent out to the
|
|||
|
daily papers. Who does the editing? Who hired the editors, and
|
|||
|
what are their beliefs? Anyone really familiar with humanism
|
|||
|
can recognize its influence in the way the news is managed."
|
|||
|
(28)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"It is obvious, by the degenerate programming that has
|
|||
|
appeared in recent years, that the three major networks (ABC,
|
|||
|
NBC, and CBS) are predominantly controlled by amoral
|
|||
|
humanists."(29)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Not all the fifty or so people who control network news are
|
|||
|
committed humanists, but most of them are."(30)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"The humanists see TV as a vehicle, first, to indoctrinate and
|
|||
|
second, to make money. Shortly after learning that Norman Lear
|
|||
|
was the producer of the most amoral `comedy' series on TV
|
|||
|
(such as the infamous Mary Hartman, Mary Hartman), I had lunch
|
|||
|
with a Christian businessman who told me how relieved he was
|
|||
|
to have sold his cable TV stations. Guess who bought them?
|
|||
|
Norman Lear."(31)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"There is one easy way to illustrate whose team Hollywood has
|
|||
|
really been on during the last fifty years. They rarely make a
|
|||
|
film that shows Communism as a world aggressor or murderer of
|
|||
|
the people _ particularly of their own. Anti-German and
|
|||
|
anti-Japanese films abound..."(32)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
"Sixty years of Communist crime against humanity provide ample
|
|||
|
material to draw on, but not if you're afraid to show
|
|||
|
humanistic socialism in a bad light."(33)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Why, in LaHaye's opinion, are humanists "soft" on Communism?
|
|||
|
It is entirely possible, if not probable, that the Rev. LaHaye
|
|||
|
equates Socialist/Communist Jews with Humanists. In many
|
|||
|
instances, the words are interchangeable.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In "A Special Jewish History Issue" of The Truth At Last(34),
|
|||
|
a tabloid published by Dr. E.R. Fields in Marietta, Georgia,
|
|||
|
the assertion is made that "the original founders of Communism
|
|||
|
were all Jews." The author names Lenin as "a secret Jew."
|
|||
|
Furthermore, the article states that these Communist Jews came
|
|||
|
to America and established "the U.S. Communist Party and other
|
|||
|
socialist groups." This echoes LaHaye's theories on
|
|||
|
"humanists" coming to America to establish socialist groups,
|
|||
|
armed with a plan to penetrate and control the minds of the
|
|||
|
American people.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Oftentimes, conservative's use of "humanism," "socialism,"
|
|||
|
"communism," and "Jews" are interchangeable. Of course,
|
|||
|
"humanism" is a more palatable word when speaking to the
|
|||
|
general public.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Published monthly by
|
|||
|
Institute for First Amendment Studies
|
|||
|
PO Box 589
|
|||
|
Great Barrington MA 01230
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
ifas@mcimail.com
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Annual subscriptions are $25.00
|
|||
|
The magazine is ***The Freedom Writer*** and the organization
|
|||
|
is the Institute for First Amendment Studies. Contributions
|
|||
|
are tax deductible (in the US).
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|| END OF PART I ||
|
|||
|
|| ANTISEMITISM AND THE CHRISTIAN RIGHT ||
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
References (both parts)
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
1 Gary North, The Judeo-Christian Tradition, 1989 p. 152
|
|||
|
2 The Sunday (Hackensack, NJ) Record, June 21, 1981
|
|||
|
3 The New York Times, February 5, 1981
|
|||
|
4 The Washington Star, July 3, 1980
|
|||
|
5 The New York Times, April 22, 1981
|
|||
|
6 Jerry Falwell, Listen America!, Sword of the Lord
|
|||
|
Publishing, c. 1980, p. 113
|
|||
|
7 Christian Broadcasting Network staff prayer meeting, January
|
|||
|
1, 1980
|
|||
|
8 Message of the Christian Jew, March/April 1994
|
|||
|
9 Message of the Christian Jew, January/February 1994
|
|||
|
10 Eclectic Third Reader (McGuffey), reprinted by Mott Media,
|
|||
|
1982, p. 64
|
|||
|
11 Ibid., p. 66
|
|||
|
12 Ibid., p. 69
|
|||
|
13 Ibid., p. 75
|
|||
|
14 Ibid., p. 82
|
|||
|
15 Eclectic Fourth Reader (McGuffey), reprinted by Mott Media,
|
|||
|
1982, p. 67
|
|||
|
16 Ibid., p. 205 Ibid.
|
|||
|
17 Glen Chambers and Gene Fisher, United States History for
|
|||
|
Christian Schools, Greenville, SC: Bob Jones University
|
|||
|
Press,1982, p. 38
|
|||
|
18 Fisher, pp. 109-110
|
|||
|
19 Ibid., p. 112
|
|||
|
20 William S. Pinkston, Jr., Biology for Christian Schools,
|
|||
|
Book 1, Teacher's Edition, Greenville, SC: Bob Jones
|
|||
|
University Press, 1991, page 333
|
|||
|
21 Newsweek, May 1, 1989, p. 32
|
|||
|
22 Gary North, The Judeo-Christian Tradition, 1989, p. 152
|
|||
|
23 Tim LaHaye, The Battle for the Mind, Fleming H. Revell,
|
|||
|
1980, p.142
|
|||
|
24 Ibid., p. 143
|
|||
|
25 Ibid., p. 147
|
|||
|
26 Ibid., p. 147
|
|||
|
27 Ibid., p. 148
|
|||
|
28 Ibid., p. 148
|
|||
|
29 Ibid., p. 152
|
|||
|
30 Ibid., p. 152
|
|||
|
31 Ibid., p. 158
|
|||
|
32 Ibid., p. 159
|
|||
|
33 Ibid., p. 159
|
|||
|
34 The Truth at Last, issue number 368
|
|||
|
35 Tim LaHaye, The Battle for the Mind, Revell, 1980, p. 163
|
|||
|
36 Ibid., p. 166
|
|||
|
37 People magazine, July 6, 1981
|
|||
|
38 Donald Wildmon, The Home Invaders, Victor Books, 1986, p.
|
|||
|
49
|
|||
|
39 Ibid., p. 68
|
|||
|
40 NFD Journal, September 1986
|
|||
|
41 Ibid., p.22
|
|||
|
42 November 5, 1987
|
|||
|
43 January 26, 1988
|
|||
|
44 February 22, 1988
|
|||
|
45 May 11, 1988
|
|||
|
46 AFA Journal, November/December 1988
|
|||
|
47 Ibid., pp. 28, 29
|
|||
|
48 Ibid., p. 95
|
|||
|
49 Ibid., p. 8
|
|||
|
50 AFA Journal, January 1989, p. 11
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|| END OF ARTICLE (Part I) ||
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
How We know What Isn't So; The fallibility of human reason in
|
|||
|
everyday life by Thomas Gilovich
|
|||
|
Macmillan Inc., New York, 1992, hardcover, $27.95
|
|||
|
216 pp. Index and Notes
|
|||
|
ISBN:
|
|||
|
Reviewed by Greg Erwin
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Despite such section titles as "Cognitive Determinants of
|
|||
|
Questionable Beliefs," this is a clearly written and easily
|
|||
|
understood book; only the titles are intimidating. Thomas
|
|||
|
Gilovich explains the many mistakes we all make in everyday
|
|||
|
reasoning. All readers will find that some belief that they
|
|||
|
lent credence to is overturned in this book. Gilovich also
|
|||
|
explains why we formed the belief in the first place, why it
|
|||
|
is wrong, and how to avoid similar errors in the future.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
These errors in "practical" reasoning (rather than formal
|
|||
|
logic or scientific method) have obvious implications for
|
|||
|
religion. The first few chapters point out errors such as:
|
|||
|
finding patterns in random data; drawing conclusions from
|
|||
|
incomplete or unrepresentative information; interpreting
|
|||
|
events with bias; accepting authority; avoiding
|
|||
|
contradiction to be "polite."
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
These are things we all do. For instance, how often do you
|
|||
|
tell someone that their pet theories are moronic? (Off the
|
|||
|
Net, anyway?) In polite society, they conclude that
|
|||
|
everyone agrees with them, as no one ever contradicts them.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Lastly, he gives examples of persistent questionable beliefs
|
|||
|
from "alternative" health, (e.g., faith healing);
|
|||
|
interpersonal strategies, (why do some guys continue to
|
|||
|
believe in the effectiveness of their incredibly corny come-
|
|||
|
on lines?); ESP, (astrology columns). He shows the errors
|
|||
|
that allow people to hold these beliefs and how we can
|
|||
|
correct these mistakes if we want to.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
In the last chapter he points out the salutary role of the
|
|||
|
social sciences in protecting against irrational beliefs.
|
|||
|
People who have studied psychology or sociology are less
|
|||
|
susceptible. The social sciences must deal with "messy,"
|
|||
|
complex, human data, rather than the neat, mathematical,
|
|||
|
precise information that forms the object of the physical
|
|||
|
sciences, thus social scientists are more familiar with the
|
|||
|
'tricks' data can play. I believe he has hit on the reason
|
|||
|
that simply informing people about the scientific method
|
|||
|
does not protect them against irrationality.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
A book to help understand practical everyday reasoning with
|
|||
|
clues as to why irrational beliefs persist.
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|| END OF REVIEW ||
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
VISIT THE BIRTHPLACE OF ROBERT G. INGERSOLL
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
by Fred Edwords
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
After years of planning and restoration, the Robert G.
|
|||
|
Ingersoll Birthplace Museum opened its doors to the public on
|
|||
|
June 2, 1993. It is now regularly open to receive visitors
|
|||
|
June through October. The hours of operation are Wednesday
|
|||
|
through Sunday, Noon to 5:00 PM.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Located in the Village of Dresden, on the shore of Lake
|
|||
|
Seneca, it becomes one of the many attractions of the
|
|||
|
picturesque Finger Lakes Region of upstate New York. Of
|
|||
|
especial interest to Humanists and Freethinkers is its
|
|||
|
convenient proximity to the Women's Rights Hall of Fame and
|
|||
|
restored home of Elizabeth Cady Stanton located in Seneca
|
|||
|
Falls, the homes of Susan B. Anthony and Frederick Douglass in
|
|||
|
Rochester, the Roycroft campus of Elbert Hubbard in East
|
|||
|
Aurora, the Elmira home and burial place of Mark Twain, and
|
|||
|
the natural monument to the last ice age in Watkins Glen (with
|
|||
|
its nightly laser show on evolution). Furthermore, all of
|
|||
|
this is in easy driving distance from the national
|
|||
|
headquarters of both the American Humanist Association (AHA)
|
|||
|
and the Council on Democratic and Secular Humanism (CODESH)!
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
During the weekend immediately following Ingersoll's birthday
|
|||
|
on August 11, 1993, the Robert G. Ingersoll Memorial
|
|||
|
Committee, sponsors of the birthplace museum, conducted a
|
|||
|
special conference in nearby Geneva. The featured event was
|
|||
|
Roger Greeley giving his best performance yet of his "An
|
|||
|
Evening with Colonel Ingersoll." Attendees were also given the
|
|||
|
grand tour of the Ingersoll home.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
As one of the tourists myself, I was extremely pleased with
|
|||
|
what I saw. The 1833 birthplace of America's "Great Agnostic"
|
|||
|
has become everything I hoped it would be. The main rooms of
|
|||
|
the house are a museum of artifacts and information
|
|||
|
memorializing the life of Ingersoll. A short but informative
|
|||
|
video introduces the self-guided tour, and a gift shop
|
|||
|
offering Ingersoll tee-shirts, books, and other mementos
|
|||
|
greets you at the end. (Proceeds support continued
|
|||
|
restoration.) One of the rooms features objects and
|
|||
|
information relevant to the Village of Dresden. But, the best
|
|||
|
part of all is upstairs where, in the words of Ingersoll
|
|||
|
himself, "my infant cry first broke the stillness of the birth
|
|||
|
room and my wakening eyes first looked upon the wondrous
|
|||
|
mysteries of the little world around me." It is the museum's
|
|||
|
period bedroom, restored with furnishings appropriate to the
|
|||
|
time.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
The AHA newsletter Free Mind first reported on the Ingersoll
|
|||
|
home back in the summer of 1987, when the building was in
|
|||
|
danger of being torn down. In order to save it, the AHA
|
|||
|
expressed an interest in picking up from the work of Ingersoll
|
|||
|
enthusiast Ruth Jokenin and converting the home into a museum.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
That effort staved off disaster long enough for AHA member
|
|||
|
Phil Mass to inspire a number of Humanists and Freethinkers to
|
|||
|
join together, under the auspices of CODESH, to establish the
|
|||
|
Robert G. Ingersoll Memorial Committee. That committee then
|
|||
|
raised the money and restored the building. Appropriately,
|
|||
|
the museum video on Ingersoll is dedicated to Phil Mass, who
|
|||
|
unfortunately did not live to see the completion of his dream.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
As a lover of historic preservation, myself, I encourage
|
|||
|
Humanists and Freethinkers everywhere to plan a trip soon
|
|||
|
around the monuments to our philosophy that are so
|
|||
|
conveniently clustered in upstate New York. The Ingersoll
|
|||
|
museum can be the centerpiece of what could make for a great
|
|||
|
vacation!
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
If you need more information for planning your itinerary, feel
|
|||
|
free to write or phone the Robert G. Ingersoll Memorial
|
|||
|
Committee, P.O. Box 664, Amherst, NY 14226-0664 -- (716)
|
|||
|
636-7571.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
--------------------------------------------------------------
|
|||
|
--
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Originally published in the Sept./Oct. 1993 issue of Free
|
|||
|
Mind, the newsletter of the American Humanist Association.
|
|||
|
Permission is hereby granted to republish this article in any
|
|||
|
medium, in whole or in part. Please credit Free Mind as the
|
|||
|
original source.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
--------------------------------------------------------------
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Phone the above number, or write P.O. Box 1188 Amherst, NY
|
|||
|
14226-7188 for membership information about the American
|
|||
|
Humanist Association.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Write CODESH at P.O. Box 664, Buffalo, NY 14226-0664 or call
|
|||
|
(716) 636-7571 for information re: CODESH. Or write Tim
|
|||
|
Madigan at aa506@FreeNet.Buffalo.edu.
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|| END OF ARTICLE ||
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|| END OF ISSUE ||
|
|||
|
==============================================================
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
Volume I, Number 3: JULY 1994.
|
|||
|
Once again: ISSN: 1198-4619 Lucifer's Echo.
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
--
|
|||
|
nullifidian, n. & a. (Person) having no religious faith or belief. [f.
|
|||
|
med. L nullifidius f. L nullus "none" + fides "faith";] / If this is a
|
|||
|
humanist topic then I am President of the Humanist Association of Ottawa.
|
|||
|
Greg Erwin. ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA
|