727 lines
39 KiB
Plaintext
727 lines
39 KiB
Plaintext
![]() |
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
(word processor parameters LM=8, RM=75, TM=2, BM=2)
|
||
|
Taken from KeelyNet BBS (214) 324-3501
|
||
|
Sponsored by Vangard Sciences
|
||
|
PO BOX 1031
|
||
|
Mesquite, TX 75150
|
||
|
|
||
|
There are ABSOLUTELY NO RESTRICTIONS
|
||
|
on duplicating, publishing or distributing the
|
||
|
files on KeelyNet except where noted!
|
||
|
|
||
|
October 30, 1993
|
||
|
|
||
|
SHOCKWAV.ASC
|
||
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
By: Roald Z. Sagdeev
|
||
|
Charles F. Kennel
|
||
|
|
||
|
Reprinted without permission from Scientific American, April 1991
|
||
|
|
||
|
Collisionless Shock Waves
|
||
|
|
||
|
Shock waves resonate through the solar system, much like the
|
||
|
reverberating boom from a supersonic jet. In the latter case, the
|
||
|
disturbance is caused by an aerodynamic shock, an abrupt change in
|
||
|
gas properties that propagates faster than the speed of sound. It
|
||
|
had long been recognized that in a neutral gas, such as the earth's
|
||
|
atmosphere, particles must collide if shocks are to form.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Beginning in the 1950s, we and our colleagues theorized that,
|
||
|
contrary to the expectations of many scientists, similar shock waves
|
||
|
could form even in the near vacuum of outer space, where particle
|
||
|
collisions are extremely rare. If so, shocks could play a
|
||
|
significant role in shaping space environments.
|
||
|
|
||
|
"Collisionless" shocks cannot occur naturally on the earth, because
|
||
|
nearly all matter here consists of electrically neutral atoms and
|
||
|
molecules. In space, however, high temperatures and ultra-violet
|
||
|
radiation from hot stars decompose atoms into their constituent
|
||
|
nuclei and electrons, producing a soup of electrically charged
|
||
|
particles known as a plasma. Plasma physicists proposed that the
|
||
|
collective electrical and magnetic properties of plasmas could
|
||
|
produce interactions that take the place of collisions and permit
|
||
|
shocks to form.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In 1964 the theoretical work found its first experimental
|
||
|
confirmation. Norman F. Ness and his colleagues at the Goddard
|
||
|
Space Flight Center, using data collected from the IMP-1 spacecraft,
|
||
|
detected clear signs that a collisionless shock exists where the
|
||
|
solar wind encounters the earth's magnetic field. (Solar wind is
|
||
|
the continuous flow of charged particles outward from the sun.)
|
||
|
|
||
|
More recent research has demonstrated that collisionless shocks
|
||
|
appear in a dazzling array of astronomical settings. For example,
|
||
|
shocks have been found in the solar wind upstream (sunward) of all
|
||
|
the planets and comets that have been visited by spacecraft.
|
||
|
Violent flares on the sun generate shocks that propagate to the far
|
||
|
reaches of the solar system; tremendous galactic outbursts create
|
||
|
disruptions in the intergalactic medium that are trillions of times
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 1
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
larger. In addition, many astrophysicists think that shocks from
|
||
|
supernova explosions in our galaxy accelerate cosmic rays, a class
|
||
|
of extraordinarily energetic elementary particles and atomic nuclei
|
||
|
that rain down on the earth from all directions.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The study of plasmas began in the 19th century, when Michael Faraday
|
||
|
investigated electrical discharges through gases. Modern plasma
|
||
|
research dates from 1957 and 1958. During those years, Soviet
|
||
|
Sputnik and American Explorer spacecrafts discovered that space near
|
||
|
the earth is filled with plasma. At the same time, till then secret
|
||
|
research on controlled thermonuclear fusion conducted by the U.S.,
|
||
|
Soviet Union and Europe was revealed at the Atoms for Peace
|
||
|
Conference in Geneva, greatly increasing the freely available
|
||
|
information on plasmas.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Fusion research focuses on producing extremely hot plasmas and
|
||
|
confining them in magnetic "bottles," to create the conditions
|
||
|
necessary for energy-producing nuclear reactions to occur. In 1957,
|
||
|
while searching for a method to heat fusion plasmas, one of us
|
||
|
(Sagdeev) realized that an instantaneous magnetic compression could
|
||
|
propagate through a collisionless plasma, much as a shock moves
|
||
|
through an ordinary fluid.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Magnetic fields that thread through plasmas make them behave
|
||
|
somewhat like such a fluid. A magnetic field exerts a force (the
|
||
|
Lorentz force) on a moving electrically charged particle. The field
|
||
|
can be thought of as a series of magnetic lines through the plasma,
|
||
|
like the field lines around a bar magnet that can be made visible
|
||
|
with iron filings.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The Lorentz force always acts perpendicular both to the direction of
|
||
|
the magnetic field line and to the direction in which a particle is
|
||
|
moving. If the particle moves perpendicular to the field, the force
|
||
|
acts like a rubber band, pulling the particle back and constraining
|
||
|
it to move in small circles about the magnetic field line. The
|
||
|
particle can, however, move freely in the direction of the magnetic
|
||
|
field line. The combination of the free motion along and
|
||
|
constrained, circular rotation across the magnetic field shapes the
|
||
|
particle's trajectory into a helix that winds around a magnetic
|
||
|
field line.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The Lorentz force makes it difficult to disperse the plasma in the
|
||
|
direction perpendicular to the magnetic field. The maximum distance
|
||
|
over which particles can move away from the field, called the Larmor
|
||
|
radius, is inversely proportional to the field strength. In the
|
||
|
weak interplanetary magnetic field, the Larmor radius amounts to
|
||
|
several kilometers for electrons and several hundred kilometers for
|
||
|
more massive ions. These distances may seem large, but they are
|
||
|
tiny compared with the size of the region where the solar wind
|
||
|
encounters the earth's magnetic field.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The shock that forms there, called a bow shock, has the same
|
||
|
parabolic shape as the waves that pile up ahead of a speedboat. It
|
||
|
stretches more than 100,000 kilometers across. When the scale is
|
||
|
larger than the Larmor radius for ions, the collective motion of
|
||
|
plasma particles across the magnetic field actually drags the field
|
||
|
lines along with it. The magnetic field thus becomes "frozen" into
|
||
|
the plasma.
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 2
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
In short, a magnetic field endows collisionless plasmas with elastic
|
||
|
properties analogous to those of a dense gas, and so a plasma wave
|
||
|
crossing a magnetic field behaves somewhat like an ordinary sound
|
||
|
wave. The theoretical analysis of collisionless shocks therefore
|
||
|
started by following the ideas developed from earlier research on
|
||
|
aerodynamic shocks.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Suppose, for example, a sudden compression creates a sound wave in
|
||
|
air. As the wave travels, its shape--that is, its profile of
|
||
|
pressure and density--changes. Because the most compressed regions
|
||
|
of the wave move the fastest, the wave grows stronger and its
|
||
|
leading edge becomes sharper. The great German mathematician
|
||
|
Bernhard Riemann showed how this phenomenon, called wave steepening,
|
||
|
creates shock waves.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Ultimately the faster-moving denser air behind catches up with the
|
||
|
slower air ahead. At this point, the sound wave behaves somewhat
|
||
|
like an ocean wave heading toward shore. A water wave steepens,
|
||
|
overturns and then crashes into foam.
|
||
|
|
||
|
A sound wave reaches an analogous but different climax. As the wave
|
||
|
grows so steep that it is about to overturn, individual gas
|
||
|
molecules become important in transporting momentum between
|
||
|
neighboring points in the gas: molecules from the faster, denser
|
||
|
region of the wave rush ahead of the steepening wave front,
|
||
|
colliding with molecules in the slower region ahead of the wave and
|
||
|
exchanging momentum with them. In this way, the slower molecules
|
||
|
are brought up to the speed of the moving wave.
|
||
|
|
||
|
This exchange of momentum is caused by molecular viscosity. In this
|
||
|
process, momentum is passed from the overtaking wave crest and
|
||
|
imparted to the undisturbed region ahead of it, much as in a relay
|
||
|
race a baton is passed from one runner to the next. Molecular
|
||
|
viscosity becomes highly efficient when the thickness of the wave
|
||
|
front shrinks to the average distance that a particle can travel
|
||
|
before it collides with another, a distance known as the collision
|
||
|
mean free path. (The mean free path of a molecule in air is about
|
||
|
one ten-thousandth of a centimeter long.) At this thickness,
|
||
|
steepening and viscosity balance each other, and a steady shock wave
|
||
|
forms. The resulting shock represents an almost steplike change in
|
||
|
gas velocity, density and pressure.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Before physicists knew of a mechanism that could replace molecular
|
||
|
viscosity in plasmas, it made little sense for them to talk of
|
||
|
collisionless shocks. Consequently, the topic lay fairly dormant
|
||
|
for many years. Then, in the late 1950s, one of us (Sagdeev) and,
|
||
|
independently, Arthur R. Kantrowitz and Harry E. Petschek, then at
|
||
|
the Avco-Everett Research Laboratory near Boston, suggested that a
|
||
|
similar sort of momentum relay race could take place in a tenuous
|
||
|
plasma. They theorized that in a plasma, waves rather than
|
||
|
individual particles pass along the baton.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The plasma relay race depends on the fact that the speed of a plasma
|
||
|
wave changes with wavelength, an effect called dispersion. Indeed,
|
||
|
whereas in ordinary gases the speed of a sound wave is practically
|
||
|
independent of wavelength, in collisionless plasma a wave is very
|
||
|
dispersive. That is, its speed may either increase or decrease as
|
||
|
its wavelength shortens, depending on the angle between the
|
||
|
direction of propagation of the wave and orientation of the magnetic
|
||
|
field.
|
||
|
Page 3
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
According to Fourier's theorem, a fundamental theorem of
|
||
|
mathematics, any wave profile consists of many superimposed waves,
|
||
|
or harmonics, of different wavelengths. (By analogy, white light is
|
||
|
composed of many distinct colors, each of a different wavelength.)
|
||
|
If the wave profile steepens, it excites harmonics of ever shorter
|
||
|
wavelength.
|
||
|
|
||
|
For wave propagation that is not exactly perpendicular to the
|
||
|
magnetic field, dispersion causes shorter-wavelength harmonics to
|
||
|
travel faster than the longer-wavelength ones (negative disperson).
|
||
|
The effects of dispersion become significant when a steepening shock
|
||
|
front becomes about as thin as the Larmor radius for ions.
|
||
|
|
||
|
At this point, the shorter-wavelength harmonics race ahead of the
|
||
|
front into the undisturbed plasma upstream. These harmonics carry
|
||
|
along the momentum, like the fast molecules in a sound wave.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The competing actions of steepening and dispersion yield a series of
|
||
|
wave pulses that propagate in the direction of the shock. As a
|
||
|
result, the front acquires the shape of a "wave train." The weakest
|
||
|
(smaller-amplitude) waves announce the arrival of the train, and
|
||
|
successively stronger oscillations build up until the full shock
|
||
|
transition arrives. The length of the train (in other words, the
|
||
|
thickness of the shock front) depends on how rapidly the energy of
|
||
|
the waves dissipates.
|
||
|
|
||
|
For waves propagating exactly perpendicular to the magnetic field,
|
||
|
dispersion causes the harmonic wave speed to decrease at shorter
|
||
|
wavelengths. Short-wavelength harmonics now trail behind the shock
|
||
|
front, and so they cannot affect steepening of the overall wave. In
|
||
|
this case, the shock passes the momentum baton to a series of
|
||
|
compressional pulses called solitons.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Solitons in perpendicular shocks are approximately the thickness of
|
||
|
an electron's Larmor radius, and they are created when the wave
|
||
|
profile steepens to that scale. The steepening front radiates an
|
||
|
ordered sequence of solitons, led by the largest (highest-amplitude)
|
||
|
one and trailed by successively smaller ones that ultimately blend
|
||
|
into the smooth state behind the shock. The length of the soliton
|
||
|
train depends on how fast the soliton energy is dissipated into
|
||
|
heat.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Waves on the surface of shallow water behave very much like
|
||
|
dispersive waves in collisionless plasma. The theory of shallow
|
||
|
water waves was developed in the late 19th century, culminating in
|
||
|
the classic work of Diederik J. Korteweg and G. DeVries that first
|
||
|
described the solitons that occasionally propagate down Dutch
|
||
|
canals. The seemingly recondite analogy between shallow water
|
||
|
solitons and plasma solitons expresses a general physical truth:
|
||
|
solitons can form whenever wave steepening and dispersion compete.
|
||
|
|
||
|
One implication of this fact is that solitons form even in shocks
|
||
|
that do not propagate exactly perpendicular to the magnetic field.
|
||
|
The wave pulses mentioned earlier can also be thought of as
|
||
|
solitons, the difference being that these solitons are rarefactive
|
||
|
(low density) rather than compressive. In this case, short-
|
||
|
wavelength harmonics travel relatively slowly (positive dispersion),
|
||
|
and the greater the amplitude of the rarefactive soliton, the more
|
||
|
slowly it propagates.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 4
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
As a result, the wave train terminates with the strongest soliton.
|
||
|
Surface tension in water creates small waves that have positive
|
||
|
dispersion and rarefactive solitons. The physics of water waves
|
||
|
therefore provides an analogy to both types of dispersion found in
|
||
|
collisionless plasma.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The elegant theory of solitons is an impressive achievement of
|
||
|
modern mathematical physics. In 1967 Martin Kruskal and his
|
||
|
colleagues at Princeton University proved that any wave profile in a
|
||
|
dispersive medium that can support steepening evolves into a
|
||
|
sequence of solitons. By relating soliton theory to the problem of
|
||
|
elementary particle collisions, which has been studied in depth in
|
||
|
quantum physics since the 1920's, they showed that solitons preserve
|
||
|
their identities when they collide, just as particles do.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The understanding of dispersive shocks remains incomplete without a
|
||
|
knowledge of how to dissipate the energy of waves or solitons into
|
||
|
heat. If not for the effect of dissipation, the train of wave
|
||
|
structures making up the shock front would be infinitely long. In
|
||
|
effect, the fundamental question of how collisionless shock waves
|
||
|
transport energy and momentum has reappeared, but in a new guise.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In 1945 the great Soviet physicist Lev D. Landau discovered a
|
||
|
dissipation mechanism that requires no collisions between particles.
|
||
|
Among the randomly moving particles in a plasma, a few happen to
|
||
|
travel at a velocity that matches the velocity of the plasma wave.
|
||
|
These particles are said to be in resonance with the wave. An
|
||
|
intense exchange of energy can take place between a wave and the
|
||
|
particles resonant with it.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In the early 1970s one of us (Sagdeev) and Vitaly Shapiro, also at
|
||
|
the Institute of Space Research in Moscow, showed that Landau's
|
||
|
mechanism damps solitons by accelerating resonant ions.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Consider, for example, a train of compressive solitons propagating
|
||
|
perpendicular to the magnetic field. Each soliton generates an
|
||
|
electric field parallel to its direction of motion. Ions traveling
|
||
|
close to the resonant velocity move slowly compared with the
|
||
|
solitons, and the soliton electric field is able to stop and reverse
|
||
|
the motion of these ions. The soliton loses part of its energy to
|
||
|
the ions resonant with it during the interaction.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The process does not end here, because the magnetic Lorentz force
|
||
|
curves the path of the reflected ion so that it returns again and
|
||
|
again to the same soliton. Each encounter adds to the energy of the
|
||
|
particle. The Lorentz force, which grows stronger as the particle
|
||
|
velocity increases, eventually throws the ion over the top of the
|
||
|
first soliton. The acceleration continues as the ion encounters the
|
||
|
remaining solitons in the wave train.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The resonant ions gain energy much as surfers gain speed by riding
|
||
|
ocean waves. This analogy inspired John M. Dowson of the University
|
||
|
of California at Los Angeles to design a new kind of charged
|
||
|
particle accelerator, which he dubbed the SURFATRON.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The heating of ions by solitons can form a shock if the number of
|
||
|
ions in resonance is great enough. Such is the case if the ions are
|
||
|
hot. If not, the solitons find another way to dissipate energy:
|
||
|
they themselves generate microscopic plasma waves that heat the
|
||
|
plasma.
|
||
|
Page 5
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
Plasma electrons flow over ions, thereby creating the electric
|
||
|
current responsible for the characteristic soliton magnetic field
|
||
|
profile. If the ions are cold, the electrons can easily move at
|
||
|
supersonic velocities relative to the ions, in which case the
|
||
|
electrons amplify extremely small scale electric field oscillations
|
||
|
called ion acoustic waves. These waves, which do not affect the
|
||
|
magnetic field, grow in an avalanche-like fashion.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The plasma particles collide not with one another but with these ion
|
||
|
acoustic waves. After the waves develop, the plasma enters a
|
||
|
microturbulent state.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In 1968 Robert W. Fredericks and his colleagues at TRW in Los
|
||
|
Angeles were the first to detect ion acoustic waves in shocks. They
|
||
|
made this discovery using instruments on the OGO-5 spacecraft that
|
||
|
were designed specifically to study plasma waves in space. Since
|
||
|
then, plasmawave detectors have been included on most space mission
|
||
|
concerned with solar system plasmas, notably the International Sun-
|
||
|
Earth Explorers (ISEE 1, 2 and 3) in earth orbit and the Voyager 1
|
||
|
and 2 missions to the outer planets. The late Fred Scarf of TRW and
|
||
|
his collaborators often played back the microturbulent-wave electric
|
||
|
fields recorded by the ISEE and Voyager spacecraft through an
|
||
|
ordinary loudspeaker. To most listeners, shocks would sound
|
||
|
cacophonous; to our ears, however, they were a symphony of space.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Although easy to record, microturbulence has proved difficult to
|
||
|
understand completely. Theorists turned to numerical computations
|
||
|
to help elucidate the behavior of a strongly microturbulent plasma.
|
||
|
|
||
|
By solving millions of equations of motion for the particles,
|
||
|
computer simulation shows how ion acoustic waves grow and heat the
|
||
|
plasma. Today's supercomputers are just beginning to give
|
||
|
scientists comprehensive understanding of many different kinds of
|
||
|
microturbulence.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Even without knowing the detailed nature of microturbulent plasma,
|
||
|
physicists can deduce its general behavior. Electrons in the plasma
|
||
|
transfer their momentum to ion acoustic waves, which in turn
|
||
|
transfer it to ions. This process retards the motion of the
|
||
|
electrons in the plasma and so creates resistance to the electric
|
||
|
current. In some shocks, ion acoustic-wave resistance grows
|
||
|
sufficiently intense to suppress the generation of solitons. When
|
||
|
this happens, no wave train forms, and the shock is called
|
||
|
resistive.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Although both simple dispersive and resistive shocks have been found
|
||
|
in space, most shocks observed there have entirely different
|
||
|
characteristics from those discussed so far. Most shocks are
|
||
|
sufficiently powerful that neither dispersion nor resistance can
|
||
|
prevent steepening from causing the waves to overturn. Overturning
|
||
|
then leads to a host of new shock phenomena.
|
||
|
|
||
|
A consideration of shallow water waves, once more, helps to
|
||
|
illustrate the process of overturning. When a shallow ocean wave
|
||
|
grows sufficiently high, the tip of its wave crest swings forward
|
||
|
through an arc and ultimately collapses under gravity. The water
|
||
|
stream from behind the crest collides with that ahead, giving rise
|
||
|
to the foam on whitecaps. Thus, a large wave crashing toward shore
|
||
|
repeatedly overturns, or "breaks."
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 6
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
A plasma wave also develops overlapping velocity streams as it
|
||
|
overturns. The fastest stream, which comes from the wave crest,
|
||
|
invades the plasma ahead of the shock front. The Lorentz force
|
||
|
turns the ions in this stream back into the shock. These reflected
|
||
|
ions ultimately mix with those behind the front. If the shock is
|
||
|
weak, its structure will remain steady. If the shock is strong, ion
|
||
|
reflection will temporarily overwhelm steepening; however, the shock
|
||
|
soon steepens again, and the cycle repeats.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Recent numerical simulations by Kevin B. Quest and his colleagues at
|
||
|
Los Alamos National Laboratory confirm the idea that very strong
|
||
|
shock waves consist of a repeated cycle of steepening, overturning
|
||
|
and ion reflection.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The interactions between reflected and flowing ions can also lead to
|
||
|
microturbulence. The Voyager spacecraft detected ion acoustic
|
||
|
waves, this time generated by ions reflected by Jupiter's bow shock
|
||
|
[see top illustration on page 110]. Near the earth, reflected ions
|
||
|
generate waves in the solar wind at the geometric mean of the
|
||
|
frequencies of rotation of the ions and electrons about the earth's
|
||
|
magnetic field; this mean is called the lower hybrid-resonance
|
||
|
frequency.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In 1985 the Soviet-Czech Intershock spacecraft made the first
|
||
|
definitive measurements of lower hybrid turbulence in the earth's
|
||
|
bow shock. Around both planets, the ion acoustic waves take energy
|
||
|
from ions and give it to electrons. Some heated electrons escape
|
||
|
forward into the solar-wind flow, others back into the shock zone.
|
||
|
|
||
|
So far we have concentrated on those shocks propagating more or less
|
||
|
at right angles to the magnetic field, those physicists call
|
||
|
quasiperpendicular. Plasma turbulence is even more important when
|
||
|
the shock propagates almost parallel to the magnetic field. The
|
||
|
field no longer holds back the fast particles that rush ahead of a
|
||
|
quasiparallel shock. These particles are a major source of
|
||
|
turbulent instability.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The ability of the magnetic field to channel particle motion along
|
||
|
field lines creates a situation analogous to a fire hose left
|
||
|
spraying water on the ground. Bends in the hose become increasingly
|
||
|
curved by the centrifugal force of the flowing water; eventually the
|
||
|
hose wriggles uncontrollably on the ground.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The magnetic field channeling the overlapping plasma streams ahead
|
||
|
of a quasiparallel shock experiences a similar instability, often
|
||
|
called the fire-hose instability. The centrifugal force that bends
|
||
|
the magnetic field lines is proportional to the density of energy in
|
||
|
plasma motion along the magnetic field. Instability occurs when
|
||
|
this energy density exceeds that of the magnetic field. Many
|
||
|
physicists conceived of the fire-hose instability independently, but
|
||
|
the version invented in 1961 by Eugene N. Parker of the University
|
||
|
of Chicago was tailored specifically to quasiparallel shocks.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The plasma fire-hose instability leads to a random flexing of the
|
||
|
magnetic field lines. This kind of magnetic turbulence can be
|
||
|
regarded as a chaotic ensemble of "torsional" waves, that is, ones
|
||
|
that twist the magnetic field lines. They are known as Alfven
|
||
|
waves, after Hannes Alfven of the Royal Institute of Technology in
|
||
|
Stockholm, who first described them.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 7
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
Alfven waves, like ion acoustic waves, can exchange energy and
|
||
|
momentum with ions in resonance with them. As far as the ions are
|
||
|
concerned, the interaction with Alfven waves mimics the effect of
|
||
|
collisions. Thus, Alfven waves limit how far ions escaping the
|
||
|
shock can penetrate upstream and determine the thickness of the
|
||
|
quasiparallel shock.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Theory predicts that collisions between ions and Alfven waves should
|
||
|
be nearly elastic, that is, they should involve only slight changes
|
||
|
in energy despite a large change in momentum (for example, when a
|
||
|
rubber ball bounces off a hard wall, its momentum reverses, but its
|
||
|
energy remains essentially the same). As a result, the Alfven
|
||
|
turbulence inside the shock front should disintegrate relatively
|
||
|
slowly. This notion led us to conclude in 1967 that quasiparallel
|
||
|
shocks could be much thicker than quasiperpendicular ones.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The very first measurements of the earth's bow shock by the IMP-1
|
||
|
spacecraft in 1964 hinted at the substantial differences between
|
||
|
parallel and perpendicular shocks. The data returned by IMP-1 were
|
||
|
somewhat puzzling at first because sometimes the shock appeared thin
|
||
|
and other times it appeared thick. Three years later we suggested
|
||
|
that shock structure could depend on the orientation of the
|
||
|
interplanetary magnetic field.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In 1971 Eugene W. Greenstadt of TRW and his colleagues assembled the
|
||
|
first evidence that the thickness of the earth's bow shock does
|
||
|
indeed vary with the direction of the solar-wind magnetic field.
|
||
|
Since this field constantly changes direction, the regions where the
|
||
|
bow shock is locally quasiperpendicular and where it is
|
||
|
quasiparallel are always moving, even if the shock itself remains
|
||
|
fairly stationary. Wherever the shock is quasiperpendicular, it is
|
||
|
thin; where it is quasiparallel, it is thick [see illustration on
|
||
|
page 107].
|
||
|
|
||
|
In the early 1970s spacecraft began to detect small fluxes of
|
||
|
energetic particles, ion acoustic waves and Alfven waves far
|
||
|
upstream of where the earth's bow shock was understood to be. The
|
||
|
ISEE program, which started in 1977, established that all the
|
||
|
upstream activity is actually part of the extended quasiparallel
|
||
|
shock. The shock is so thick that it dwarfs the earth, and
|
||
|
therefore earth-orbiting satellites cannot really measure its size.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Another, larger class of shocks does lend itself to investigation by
|
||
|
spacecraft, however. Flares in the solar corona occasionally launch
|
||
|
gigantic shock waves that propagate through the interplanetary
|
||
|
medium to the far reaches of the solar system. These can be
|
||
|
observed as they sweep by instrumented spacecraft.
|
||
|
|
||
|
One of us (Kennel), along with colleagues in the ISEE project, found
|
||
|
that the region of Alfven and ion acoustic turbulence upstream of
|
||
|
quasi-parallel interplanetary shocks can be more than a million
|
||
|
kilometers thick.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Alfven waves play a particularly prominent role in the shocks that
|
||
|
form ahead of comets as they pass through the solar wind in the
|
||
|
inner solar system. Cometary nuclei are far too small to cause any
|
||
|
detectable physical disturbance in the flow of the solar wind (the
|
||
|
nucleus of Halley's comet, for instance, measures only about 15
|
||
|
kilometers across), and the nuclei possess a negligible magnetic
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 8
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
field. Because of these properties, comets cannot generate shocks
|
||
|
in the way that planets do. Nevertheless, scientists have found
|
||
|
that when comets approach the sun, they create large collisionless
|
||
|
shocks.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Sunlight evaporates atoms and molecules from the surface of a
|
||
|
comet's nucleus. Most of the liberated gas is ionized by solar
|
||
|
ultraviolet light and forms a plasma cloud similar to the earth's
|
||
|
ionosphere. The solar wind never penetrates the cometary
|
||
|
ionosphere, and it is not the ionosphere that forms the shock wave.
|
||
|
The key players in producing cometary shocks are the few neutral
|
||
|
atoms and molecules that manage to escape the comet's ionosphere.
|
||
|
These, too, are ultimately ionized, but farther out, where they have
|
||
|
entered the solar wind.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The newly ionized particles respond to the electric and magnetic
|
||
|
fields of the solar wind by joining the flow. They increase the
|
||
|
mass density of the solar wind, which, according to the law of
|
||
|
conservation of momentum, decreases the wind speed. Because
|
||
|
cometary ions are much heavier than the protons of the solar wind, a
|
||
|
number of cometary ions can slow the wind appreciably.
|
||
|
|
||
|
More than 20 years ago Ludwig Biermann of the Max Planck Institute
|
||
|
for Astophysics in Munich suggested that such a decelerating solar-
|
||
|
wind flow should produce a shock similar to a planetary bow shock.
|
||
|
During its 1986 encounter with Comet Halley, the Soviet spacecraft
|
||
|
Vega-1 heard the plasma wave cacophony that signaled the existence
|
||
|
of a shock wave about one million kilometers from the nucleus, the
|
||
|
distance predicted by Biermann's theory.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The Soviety Vega, Japanese Suisei and the European Giotto spacecraft
|
||
|
encountered both quasiperpendicular and quasiparallel shocks at
|
||
|
Comet Halley. The quasiparallel shocks were similar to those at the
|
||
|
planets. Heavy ions upstream of the quasiperpendicular cometary
|
||
|
shocks generated intense Alfven-wave turbulence, however, something
|
||
|
that does not happen around the planets.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Shocks that generate Alfven waves can also accelerate a small group
|
||
|
of particles to high energies. The "collisions" of particles with
|
||
|
Alfven waves return escaping particles back to the shock front.
|
||
|
Each time they recross the shock, the particles increase their
|
||
|
energy. This acceleration mechanism is based on one proposed by
|
||
|
Enrico Fermi in 1954.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In 1986 one of us (Kennel) and his ISEE collaborators found that a
|
||
|
theory of Fermi acceleration developed for interplanetary shocks by
|
||
|
Martin A. Lee of the University of New Hampshire successfully passed
|
||
|
the test of observations. Yet the Fermi process develops so slowly
|
||
|
that the protons accelerated by quasiparallel interplanetary shocks
|
||
|
only reach energies of a few hundred thousand electron volts in the
|
||
|
one day it takes the shock to travel from the sun to the earth. In
|
||
|
comparison, cosmic rays--energetic subatomic particles and atomic
|
||
|
nuclei from deep space--have energies up to 100 trillion electron
|
||
|
volts.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Exploding stars--supernovas--create very strong shocks that speed
|
||
|
into the interstellar plasma at tens of thousands of kilometers per
|
||
|
second. We cannot put a space probe ahead of a supernova shock, so
|
||
|
we cannot say for sure whether the shock generates Alfven waves and
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 9
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
accelerates interstellar ions. We can, however, apply to supernova
|
||
|
shocks the theory of particle acceleration that is being tested
|
||
|
today using solar system shocks.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Since supernova shocks last about a million years before dying out,
|
||
|
particles have time to reach extremely high energies via the Fermi
|
||
|
process. Working independently, Germogen F. Krymskii of the
|
||
|
Institute of Space Physics Research and Aeronomy in Yakutsk,
|
||
|
U.S.S.R., Roger D. Blandford of the California Institute of
|
||
|
Technology and Ian W. Axford of the Max Planck Institute for
|
||
|
Aeronomy in Katlenburg-Lindau, together with their colleagues,
|
||
|
showed in 1977 that the distribution in energy of the particles
|
||
|
accelerated by collision-less shocks is virtually identical to that
|
||
|
of cosmic rays.
|
||
|
|
||
|
The origin of cosmic rays has long been a puzzle. Many
|
||
|
astophysicists now believe that they are created when supernova
|
||
|
shocks accelerate particles, although it is still not understood how
|
||
|
the particles reach the highest energies observed.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Collisionless shocks probably exist even around remote galaxies.
|
||
|
Dynamic processes in the centers of some active galaxies (possibly
|
||
|
involving a massive black hole) create supersonic jets hundreds of
|
||
|
thousands of light-years long. Shocks are likely to occur when the
|
||
|
jets interact with the plasma surrounding the galaxy. Radio
|
||
|
emissions from the jets indicate that electrons are accelerated to
|
||
|
extremely high energies. Albert A. Galeev, director of the Soviet
|
||
|
Institute of Space Research, suggests that a theory he and his
|
||
|
colleagues developed to explain how lower hybrid waves accelerate
|
||
|
electrons in the earth's bow shock may also clarify how electrons
|
||
|
are accelerated in galactic jets.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Contemporary collisionless shock research encompasses phenomena that
|
||
|
vary tremendously in scale and origin. The concepts that we and
|
||
|
others developed 20 years ago have turned out to be a reasonable
|
||
|
basis for understanding collisionless shocks. Spacecraft have found
|
||
|
individual examples of most of the shock types predicted by theory.
|
||
|
Still to come are refined measurements and numerical calculations
|
||
|
that simulate in detail the impressive variety of shocks found in
|
||
|
nature.
|
||
|
|
||
|
In most cases, the fairly simple mechanisms we have described here
|
||
|
are intertwined in fascinating ways. Yet even now collisionless
|
||
|
shock theory has enabled physicists to speculate with some
|
||
|
confidence on the physical processes underlying some of the grandest
|
||
|
and most violent phenomena in the universe.
|
||
|
|
||
|
ROALD Z. SAGDEEV and CHARLES F. KENNEL have been friends and
|
||
|
colleagues since they met at the International Centre for
|
||
|
Theoretical Physics in Trieste in 1965. Sagdeev heads the theory
|
||
|
division of the Soviet Institute of Space Research and is professor
|
||
|
of physics at Moscow Physico-TEchnical Institute. Last year he
|
||
|
joined the physics department of the University of Maryland at
|
||
|
College Park. In addition to his astronomical and physical
|
||
|
research, Sagdeev has been active in the areas of arms control,
|
||
|
science policy and global environment protection. Kennel is
|
||
|
professor of physics at the University of California, Los Angeles,
|
||
|
as well as consultant to TRW Systems Group, where he participates in
|
||
|
space plasma experiments. He is also a distinguished visiting
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 10
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
scientist at the Geophysical Institute of the University of Alaska,
|
||
|
Fairbanks, and a collector of native Alaskan art.
|
||
|
|
||
|
FURTHER READING
|
||
|
|
||
|
SHOCK WAVES IN COLLISIONLESS PLASMAS. D. A. Tidman and N. A. Krall.
|
||
|
Wiley-Interscience, 1971.
|
||
|
|
||
|
UPSTREAM WAVES AND PARTICLES. Journal of Geophysical Research, Vol.
|
||
|
86, No. A6, pages 4319-4529; June 1, 1981.
|
||
|
|
||
|
HANDBOOK OF PLASMA PHYSICS. Edited by M. N. Rosenbluth and R. Z.
|
||
|
Sagdeev. North-Holland Publishing Company, 1983.
|
||
|
|
||
|
COLLISIONLESS SHOCKS IN THE HELIOSPHERE: REVIEW OF CURRENT RESEARCH.
|
||
|
Edited by Bruce T. Tsurutani and Robert G. Stone. American
|
||
|
Geo-physical Union, 1985.
|
||
|
|
||
|
NONLINEAR PHYSICS: FROM THE PENDULUM TO TURBULENCE AND CHAOS. R. Z.
|
||
|
Sagdeev, D. A. Usikov and G. M. Zaslavsky. Translated from
|
||
|
the Russian by Igor R. Sagdeev. Harwood Academic Publishers,
|
||
|
1988.
|
||
|
|
||
|
(Refer to 4THSTATE and POWERING on KeelyNet)
|
||
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
|
||
|
If you have comments or other information relating to such topics
|
||
|
as this paper covers, please upload to KeelyNet or send to the
|
||
|
Vangard Sciences address as listed on the first page.
|
||
|
Thank you for your consideration, interest and support.
|
||
|
|
||
|
Jerry W. Decker.........Ron Barker...........Chuck Henderson
|
||
|
Vangard Sciences/KeelyNet
|
||
|
|
||
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
If we can be of service, you may contact
|
||
|
Jerry at (214) 324-8741 or Ron at (214) 242-9346
|
||
|
--------------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
Page 11
|
||
|
|
||
|
|