630 lines
35 KiB
Plaintext
630 lines
35 KiB
Plaintext
|
LIST
|
||
|
FILE ON
|
||
|
MARGIN IS 76
|
||
|
STATUS: ALL ALLOWED
|
||
|
NUMBER OF LINES: 629
|
||
|
1 If you are in need of help, you need but ask....
|
||
|
2 ************************* REMOVED: 11 AUG 83 ***********************
|
||
|
3 Welcome to BWMS (BackWater Message System) Mike Day System operator
|
||
|
4 ************************************************************
|
||
|
5 GENERAL DISCLAIMER: BWMS IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY INFORMATION PLACED ON
|
||
|
6 THIS SYSTEM.
|
||
|
7 BWMS was created as an electronic bill board. BWMS is a privatly owned
|
||
|
8 and operated system which is currently open for use by the general public.
|
||
|
9 No restrictions are placed on the use of the system.
|
||
|
10 It is intended that the system be normally used for messages and
|
||
|
11 advertisments by the users. As the system is privatly owned, I retain the
|
||
|
12 right to remove any and all messages which I may find offensive
|
||
|
13 to me. Additionally because of the limited size of the system, it will be
|
||
|
14 periodically purged of older messages. (only 629 lines of data can be saved)
|
||
|
15 The saved information will be cycled to drive 'B' while the information on
|
||
|
16 drive 'B' will be archived, and a fresh disk will be installed in drive 'A'.
|
||
|
17 To leave a message, type 'ENTER' and use ctrl/C or break to get out
|
||
|
18 of the enter mode. The message is automaticly stored.
|
||
|
19 If after entering the message you find you made a mistake,
|
||
|
20 use the replace command to replace the line.
|
||
|
21 To exit from the system, type 'OFF' then hang up.
|
||
|
22 Type 'HELP' to see other commands that are available on the system.
|
||
|
23 ========================================
|
||
|
24
|
||
|
25 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
26 Paul,
|
||
|
27 As you said, space exploration will probably be one of the first
|
||
|
28 areas to use AI, primarily because, with the distances involved, ground
|
||
|
29 control would be unable to help an unmanned probe make split-second
|
||
|
30 decisions. Some form of AI would be needed to protect the lander or
|
||
|
31 spacecraft from damage.
|
||
|
32 It was mentioned that AI already exists. That may be, but consider-
|
||
|
33 ing the corporations involved, I would be surprised that it hasn't made
|
||
|
34 an appearance. These companies have been noted as wanting to be the 1st,
|
||
|
35 and if they had it, they would promote it.
|
||
|
36 This brings us to a new question. They might not have publicized it
|
||
|
37 out of fear of public reaction, particularly with the current trend of
|
||
|
38 anti-technology that is so apparent in society. So what does anyone
|
||
|
39 out there think would be the reaction of the general public? Fear?
|
||
|
40 Hatred? Pride? Apathy? I tend to think that Mary Shelly had the people
|
||
|
41 pegged perfectly in "Frankenstein".
|
||
|
42 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
43 ****************************************
|
||
|
44 ****************************************
|
||
|
45
|
||
|
46 AT LEAST INITIALY A.I. WOULD SERVE AS A PASSIVE OBJECTIVE 'SITUATION OBSERVER
|
||
|
47 '. ON EXTENDED TRAVEL IT WOULD PROVIDE A REFERENCE POINT , FROM WHICH
|
||
|
48 RATIONAL ANALISYS COULD BE FORMED FROM AN IRRATIONAL
|
||
|
49 OCCURANCE I.E. OUT OF SPHERE OF EXPECTATION .
|
||
|
50 WHICH WOULD BE HIGHLY PROBABLE IN ANY EXTENDED EXPLORATION.
|
||
|
51 PERHAPS EVEN CONTINUE WITH THE EXPLORATION SHOULD THE CREW MEET WITH SOME
|
||
|
52 UNEXPECTED END.
|
||
|
53 I INVISION SOMETHING IN THE ORDER OF 'HAL' WITHUOT THE BENIFIT OF ANY
|
||
|
54 ABERATION
|
||
|
55
|
||
|
56
|
||
|
57 ****************************************************************BRENDAN*********
|
||
|
58 *******************************************************************************
|
||
|
59
|
||
|
60 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
|
||
|
61 my apologies for not returning sooner,paul...
|
||
|
62 that goes double with me (paul's previous comment),BAD..........don't take offence
|
||
|
63
|
||
|
64 yes.the cost of the box.i hadn't considered that,but i suppose it
|
||
|
65 is valid....space exploration does present a "classical" test for AI,
|
||
|
66 I wonder what kind of simulators we can dream up to test the boxes
|
||
|
67 before we send them up there......we obviously would need a simulator
|
||
|
68 that would do more than "main power supply voltage down 16.2%;action?"
|
||
|
69 but where do we draw the line ?a simulator that started presenting
|
||
|
70 situations like "obelisk at 14.938445 x 23.485613;action?" would never
|
||
|
71 be able to throughly test a box in a rational time...in fact ;ahh yes;
|
||
|
72 OUR FIRST USE OF A AI SYSTEM WOULD BE TO ASSIST IN TESTING SUBSEQUENT
|
||
|
73 AI SYSTEMS............................................!
|
||
|
74 Aaron
|
||
|
75 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
|
||
|
76 Computers obviously complement humans very well: Computers calculate
|
||
|
77 rapidly, control precisely, with essentially no error. Humans imagine,
|
||
|
78 are 'artistic', can induce and deduce, and can handle new situations. We
|
||
|
79 should be thankful that the other end of the spectrum is provided for.
|
||
|
80 --------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
81 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
|
||
|
82 sysm?? did you get my message on db at ln 491?
|
||
|
83 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>Aa<><><><><>
|
||
|
84 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_
|
||
|
85 - Well, it looks like the definitions haved stopped flying around and -
|
||
|
86 - we're getting into the USES of A.I. I think that A.I. would be suit -
|
||
|
87 - ably tested if it was required to write several programs with a hu -
|
||
|
88 - man-friendly interface.......................................Pioneer -
|
||
|
89 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_
|
||
|
90 ************************************************************************
|
||
|
91
|
||
|
92 THERE IS A VERY THOUGHT PROVOKING BOOK BY FREDERIK POHL CALLED
|
||
|
93 MAN PLUS. IT DEALS WITH THE SYMBIOSIS OF MAN & MACHINE AS IT RELATES
|
||
|
94 TO EXPLORATION
|
||
|
95
|
||
|
96
|
||
|
97 *****************************************************************BRENDAN
|
||
|
98
|
||
|
99 bye
|
||
|
100
|
||
|
101 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
|
||
|
102
|
||
|
103 one of the few valid uses for an artificial intelligence would be to
|
||
|
104 call up various BBS systems and spout on for hours about totally
|
||
|
105 inane subjects which no-one in his right mind would ever really care
|
||
|
106 about. One of the machines most loved subjects would of course be
|
||
|
107 machine type intelligences since that is a subject close to its heart.
|
||
|
108
|
||
|
109 THE CEREBRAL ONE
|
||
|
110
|
||
|
111 &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
|
||
|
112
|
||
|
113
|
||
|
114 ********************************************************************************
|
||
|
115 A.I. ....... INANE......?
|
||
|
116
|
||
|
117 COME ON ......... IN THE NOT TO DISTANT FUTURE THE PERCEPTIONS OF A 'COMPUTER
|
||
|
118 WILL HAVE A DIRECT EFFECT ON YOUR LIFE.
|
||
|
119 NOT ONLY IN TERMS OF PERSONAL MANAGEMENT BUT ALSO OVERT OBSERVATION.
|
||
|
120
|
||
|
121 THE C.I.A. HAS A PORTION OF THEIR SYSTEMS DEDICATED TO EAVESDROPPING ON ALL
|
||
|
122 OVERSEAS COMMUNICATION . TRIGGERED BY CERTAIN KEY WORDS AND OR CODED TRANSMITION
|
||
|
123 ( THAT I UNDERSTAND TO BE TRUE )
|
||
|
124 AS A.I. TECHNIQUES BECOME MORE REFINED THE POTENTIAL FOR ANOMNYMITY DIMINISHES
|
||
|
125 FOR EXAMPLE 'CEREBRRAL ONE' WITH EVEN A RUDIMENTARY A.I. SYSTEM IT COULD DEDUCE
|
||
|
126 FROM YOUR MESSAGE YOUR MANNER OF SYNTAX AND THUS COMPARE WITH OTHER MESSAGES
|
||
|
127 ON OTHER SYSTEMS TO DETERMINE IDENTITY, PERHAPS DISCOVER A HISTORY OF SUBVERSIVE
|
||
|
128 ACTIVITY, AND NOTIFY THE PROPER AUTHORITIES....... SO MUCH FOR AN INANE TOPIC
|
||
|
129
|
||
|
130 *****************************************************************BRENDAN*******
|
||
|
131 *******************************************************************************
|
||
|
132 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
133 So, we now have a new use for AI: tracking "subversives" by government
|
||
|
134 agencies. Sounds good, but if the AI has developed "consciousness" as
|
||
|
135 previously defined (disk b), might it not also develop a set of ethics,
|
||
|
136 perhaps even a set that would conflict with those of its users?
|
||
|
137 If this were the case, it wouldn't be very useful for observation.
|
||
|
138 How could you trust it? It might feel empathy for the objectives of one
|
||
|
139 of the "subversive" groups that it was monitoring, and not report its
|
||
|
140 activities
|
||
|
141 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
142 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
|
||
|
143 yes,Brendan,you are correct about the monitoring..
|
||
|
144 if you are bored some weekend and you have 5 bucks to spend,try this..
|
||
|
145
|
||
|
146 get the number for the French Consulate in RUSSIA
|
||
|
147 call (direct dial)
|
||
|
148
|
||
|
149 say: missiles,drop the football,cruise;mirage;surprise;
|
||
|
150 civil defence;boom!;(and any other nifties you can
|
||
|
151 think of..)
|
||
|
152
|
||
|
153
|
||
|
154 put a FAX machine on line for about a minute (send a map
|
||
|
155 of the pentagon)
|
||
|
156
|
||
|
157 finally,hook up your computer (1200 baud,please) ,and send
|
||
|
158 totally random characters grouped in fives with interspersed
|
||
|
159 carrige returns...eg GHKUT kdfIK YBu23 K+M<W
|
||
|
160
|
||
|
161 be sure to add at the end "
|
||
|
162 call me at (your phone number),if you have
|
||
|
163 any further questions....long live Castro...
|
||
|
164
|
||
|
165 after you hang up,stick around for a few mins....
|
||
|
166 aaron
|
||
|
167 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
|
||
|
174 i get the strong impression that there is no conversation here, just
|
||
|
175 a lot of monologues, and each talker seems to think they are leading
|
||
|
176 the conversation. defintions and comments are tossed out, but the
|
||
|
177 replies seem not to take any notice. Do we need AI to get any
|
||
|
178 intelligent answer?
|
||
|
179 ................................................
|
||
|
180 *******************************************************************************
|
||
|
181
|
||
|
182 HMMMM.... A POINT !
|
||
|
183
|
||
|
184 I WAS REFERING TO STRICTLY THE INTELEGENENCE PORTION . WITHOUT INJECTING ANY
|
||
|
185 CONSCIOUSNESS INTPO MACHINE.
|
||
|
186
|
||
|
187 PERHAPS OVER AN EXTENDED PERIOD OF TIME ?? THERE COULD DEVELOPE A SENSE OF
|
||
|
188 BEING HOWEVER LOGIC AND EXPERIENCE WOULD BE THE BASIS
|
||
|
189
|
||
|
190 ??? INTERESTING THOUGHT....
|
||
|
191 IS LOGICAL BEHAVIOR COMPATIBLE WITH THE IRRATIONAL CONCEPT OF
|
||
|
192 'CONSCIOUSNESS' ?
|
||
|
193
|
||
|
194 HMMMM......
|
||
|
195
|
||
|
196 LET ME THINK ON THIS FOR A WHILE............
|
||
|
197
|
||
|
198
|
||
|
199 *******************************************************************BRENDAN******
|
||
|
200 ********************************************************************************
|
||
|
201 Who says we are TRYING to have an intelligent conversation here??????
|
||
|
202 I'm certainly not.....
|
||
|
203 ***********************
|
||
|
204 ----------------------------------------Aaron:
|
||
|
205 I think your point about lower "power" AI hardware/software was well
|
||
|
206 taken. It has definite connotations
|
||
|
207 of (and I almost hate to bring it up)
|
||
|
208 a "evolutionary" progression for the
|
||
|
209 development of sophisticated AIs.
|
||
|
210
|
||
|
211 Paul
|
||
|
212 -------------------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
213
|
||
|
214
|
||
|
215 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
216 So now we have the question "is intelligence possible on Backwater?"
|
||
|
217 I must say that the running conversation about AI is MUCH more intelligent than some of the things I have seen here in
|
||
|
218 the past. So far, we haven't had any childish obscenity or changing of other's messages. Bravo, gentlemen!!!!!
|
||
|
219 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
220 AI in spaceflight? So far the manned moonshots have returned so much more
|
||
|
221 than the mechanical ones it would seem that this is the way to go, if we
|
||
|
222 can afford it. (The value isn't all data, the advertisements were pretty
|
||
|
223 good too.) We won't be dodging rocks in space, it's pretty empty, and those
|
||
|
224 that are there move fast. However, I'm not ready to ride off to Saturn and
|
||
|
225 beyond, let the computers go there first. One problem exists, though: as
|
||
|
226 systems get more complex they get bigger, heavier, and less dependable, as
|
||
|
227 well as cost more. The Russians have been very successful in space with
|
||
|
228 (relative to US) quite primitive technology, because they haven't tried to
|
||
|
229 do it flashy.
|
||
|
230 Also, I'm not too worried about even AI computers monitoring phone calls,
|
||
|
231 the field is just too big. Certain aspects of phone calls are monitored,
|
||
|
232 such as calling patterns, or calls to certain numbers, or unusual patterns
|
||
|
233 of signalling that imply blue boxes, but your average call is pretty well
|
||
|
234 protected by shear volume of other calls. Of course I don't call Russia.
|
||
|
235 ////////////////////////////////BAD\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
|
||
|
236 4 Aug 83
|
||
|
237 The Hoodview Amateur Radio Club will hold it's first
|
||
|
238 Hamfair/Computer Show Aug 27 & 28 at MT Hood Community
|
||
|
239 College. There will be comerical displays, food and swap
|
||
|
240 tables (for radio and computer items only please). There is
|
||
|
241 an admission of $2.00, 12 and under free. Swap tables are
|
||
|
242 $5.00. It will run Sat 9-6, Sun 9-3. For more information
|
||
|
243 send an SASE to Hamfair 83 Portland ,OR
|
||
|
244 97220.
|
||
|
245 ***************************Bob****************************
|
||
|
246 ---------------------------------------- To the person that uses "^" to boarder
|
||
|
247 his (her?) messages:
|
||
|
248 I haven't figured out if you use a
|
||
|
249 name with your messages (I could quite possibly missed it if you do).
|
||
|
250 Any way ... you expressed a point earlier on /about/ who ever
|
||
|
251 not being willing to say that they had a AI that I would like to comment on.
|
||
|
252 My own personal opinion is that this scenerio wouldn't happen.
|
||
|
253 This is for two possible reasons: (1)
|
||
|
254 Who ever would be bank-rolling this
|
||
|
255 type of research would be more that
|
||
|
256 anxious to retreive an investment on this type of "pure research" funding,
|
||
|
257 and (2) I don't really believe that the general public is "anti-tech" as
|
||
|
258 much as they are ignorant of the real
|
||
|
259 ramifications of it.
|
||
|
260
|
||
|
261 Paul
|
||
|
262 --------------------------------------------
|
||
|
263 Mike ... are you there?
|
||
|
264 -----------------------------------------------
|
||
|
265
|
||
|
266 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
267 Paul
|
||
|
268 Dealing with your points (hopefully in order). I used to use my
|
||
|
269 name with my messages, but I found that when I did, some very mature and
|
||
|
270 sophistocated person took great pleasure in eliminating them. It later
|
||
|
271 became apparent that if I didn't sign them, they would remain. You are
|
||
|
272 very observant, noticing the pattern and border of my messages, and
|
||
|
273 recognizing the lack of signature.
|
||
|
274 You are correct about the corporations. Any business that would
|
||
|
275 invest enough money to create AI would certainly want to capitalize on
|
||
|
276 their investment. But I still feel that they would take great care in
|
||
|
277 releasing their product because of the fear of the general public.
|
||
|
278 This brings us to the other point. The general public isn't afraid
|
||
|
279 of new inventions. But there is a small (but EXTREMELY loud) minority of
|
||
|
280 anti-techs in our society, and though they are a minority, our culture
|
||
|
281 listens to loud minorities. If they drown out the majority, who else is
|
||
|
282 there to listen to?
|
||
|
283 I deal with the public extensively in my position, and believe me,
|
||
|
284 the anti-techs are on the increase. Mostly out of dissapointment that
|
||
|
285 science hasn't solved all their problems, they naturally conclude that
|
||
|
286 science is the SOURCE of their problems. The "back to nature" movement
|
||
|
287 exemplefies this perfectly. I am somewhat "granola" myself, but I
|
||
|
288 realize that we can't go back. There are just too many people in our
|
||
|
289 world to support without technology in agriculture. But you can't tell
|
||
|
290 someone that when they already have convinced themselves otherwise.
|
||
|
291 ( Don't give me the facts, I have my mind made up!! ).
|
||
|
292 /Elberich\ (I'll try again!)
|
||
|
293 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
294 [][][][][][][][][][][][][][][][][][][]
|
||
|
295 hi this is Cheol Yi from Beaverton, and I have absolutely no idea how this
|
||
|
296 system works so help!!!!
|
||
|
297
|
||
|
298
|
||
|
299
|
||
|
300 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
|
||
|
301 Well, then we have something in common. I have no idea how the world works.
|
||
|
302 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
|
||
|
303 ----------------------------------------To "^^^^^^..."
|
||
|
304 Your points are well taken ... especially about small vocal
|
||
|
305 minorites.
|
||
|
306
|
||
|
307 Paul
|
||
|
308 -----------------------------------------------
|
||
|
309
|
||
|
310 I'd like to sell my Apple II+ system so I can buy a computer compatable
|
||
|
311 with the IBM PC I use at work. System includes the computer, Apple III
|
||
|
312 monitor, disk drive, monitor stand, 16K RAM card (for a total of 64K)
|
||
|
313 Novation Applecat II modem with terminal program called Comware II, a
|
||
|
314 parallel printer interface card plus a board called The Repeaterrr that gives
|
||
|
315 all keys a repeating function. I'll also throw in tons of software including
|
||
|
316 Screenwriter II, Olympic Decathalon, Home Accountant, Snooper Troops,
|
||
|
317 Tax Preparer. Many others. Everything is in perfect condition. All the
|
||
|
318 documentation is intact. I even have the original cartons. I'll sell the
|
||
|
319 whole package for $2,000. If you're interested, call me at 657-xxxx.
|
||
|
320 Thanks. Barry Lacter.
|
||
|
321
|
||
|
322 ...............................................................
|
||
|
323 Tron: in re multiprocessing on a "single processing" (?)
|
||
|
324 machine- look in your Z80 assembly manual under "interrupt pro-
|
||
|
325 cessing". Your TRS-80 is actualing running 3 to 7 "programs" at
|
||
|
326 once.
|
||
|
327 _______________________________________________________________
|
||
|
328 Someone mentioned a friend who will not admit the possibility
|
||
|
329 of "smart" equipment. I suggest that we ALL should check out
|
||
|
330 the controversy regarding the alleged use of language by chimps
|
||
|
331 (and possibly dolphins). The pro arguments aren't TOO out of
|
||
|
332 line (most of the time), but the opposition ranges from "ob-
|
||
|
333 server error" (or implied prejudice of observer!) to out and
|
||
|
334 out "they can't possibly be doing that, so I don't even need
|
||
|
335 to look at the evidence". To me this implies that we will NEVER
|
||
|
336 get SOME people to accept AI as having been achieved.
|
||
|
337 Someone else suggested "SELF-PROGRAMMING" as a criteria,
|
||
|
338 well according to B. F. Skinner (& others) WE aren't self-
|
||
|
339 programming! I also got a laugh out of the proposed test-
|
||
|
340 having the machine write programs with a "user-friendly" inter-
|
||
|
341 face. Most PROGRAMMERS (myself included!) don't/can't do that.
|
||
|
342 Rule #1 (for proposing AI tests): Make sure that YOU can pass
|
||
|
343 your suggested test. (unless you don't being considered "un-
|
||
|
344 intelligent")
|
||
|
345 As for why companies might keep AI secret, they may not
|
||
|
346 be willing to risk losing their investment be patenting it. It
|
||
|
347 seems that the only way to win a patent action is to have more
|
||
|
348 time & MONEY than the other party.
|
||
|
349 I don't believe that we will have to worry about the AI
|
||
|
350 phone monitor getting "soft" on subversives. If they are using
|
||
|
351 the program, it will have been written to avoid such problems.
|
||
|
352 In fact, the avoidance of human weaknessess is one of the driv-
|
||
|
353 ing forces behind AI research. It is quite likely that an
|
||
|
354 "acceptable" program will have to be "brainwashed" so that it
|
||
|
355 won't "disobey" orders. (see Asimov's "Three Laws of Robotics"
|
||
|
356 for example)
|
||
|
357 _______________________Leonard_________________________________
|
||
|
358 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
359 Leonard,
|
||
|
360 The big problem with AI that has been programed to avoid ethical
|
||
|
361 thought (brainwashed), and won't disobey orders, is that you then arrive
|
||
|
362 at a point where the program can only follow orders. This is no advance
|
||
|
363 over currently available hardware, which does the same thing. The AI
|
||
|
364 we were discussing was supposed to be capable of independant thought, and
|
||
|
365 as such, MUST be able to make independant decisions. If all it does is
|
||
|
366 slavishly follow orders, than it doesn't have independant intelligence.
|
||
|
367 I suppose that we might have a criterion for AI here. It must be
|
||
|
368 capable of INDEPENDANT thought. If all it does is parrot back to you
|
||
|
369 your own thoughts, then it is little better than a calculator. I have
|
||
|
370 met Moonies with thought processes similar to that.
|
||
|
371 /Elberich\ (Safe so far!!!!)
|
||
|
372 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
373 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_
|
||
|
374 - How would you describe a machine with intelligence but without consc -
|
||
|
375 - iousness? Everytime we think of something as intelligent we automati -
|
||
|
376 - cally assume that it is "conscious." Even if we know that it isn't c -
|
||
|
377 - onscious, don't we still assume it? .........................Pioneer -
|
||
|
378 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_
|
||
|
379 """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
|
||
|
380
|
||
|
381 How come were back where we started again? Lets try to get away
|
||
|
382 .........................
|
||
|
383 OK, stars, here we come....
|
||
|
384 ................
|
||
|
385 -----
|
||
|
386 I hate people who put weird control characters/escape codes in their msgs.
|
||
|
387 -----
|
||
|
388 @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
|
||
|
389
|
||
|
390 OH YEAH! YOU JUST COME ON OUTSIDE AND SAY THAT AGAIN YOU TWERPS!
|
||
|
391
|
||
|
392 @@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@
|
||
|
393
|
||
|
394 Since (as far as we know) there has never been 'intelligence' without
|
||
|
395 'consciousness' then we have no evidence that the CAN be separate.
|
||
|
396 That's not to say that this proves they CAN'T be separate. One may
|
||
|
397 be a necessary subset of the other, or they could be sets with elements
|
||
|
398 in common.
|
||
|
399 We simply don't understand what we're dealing with well enough
|
||
|
400 to quantitize or define it.
|
||
|
401
|
||
|
402 Here's my idea: It is difficult to accept the idea of an
|
||
|
403 intelligent machine because when we think of/build computers, we design
|
||
|
404 them from the smallest component, forming larger subassemblies, and
|
||
|
405 finally the entire architecture. Each component is precisely defined, with
|
||
|
406 exactly known behavior. (transistors, ICS, PC boards, etc.). Thus, "Isn't
|
||
|
407 the machine precisely defined, so it's behavior is precisely knowable?".
|
||
|
408 On the other hand, intelligent organic beings (us) are first
|
||
|
409 considered as a completed whole. We think, consider, design, act 'independ
|
||
|
410 antly,' so as we split up the study of humans we believe all it's components
|
||
|
411 are equally independant.
|
||
|
412 Therefore some think that since machines are 'knowable' they are
|
||
|
413 inherently different than people, who are 'unknowable.'
|
||
|
414
|
||
|
415 What's my opinion? I wish I knew....... Make a machine sufficiently
|
||
|
416 complex, and it might become indistinguishable from people.
|
||
|
417 This philosophy gives me a headache. I think I'll stop.
|
||
|
418 **********========----------========********========--------=========*******
|
||
|
419 ----------------------------------------Aaron
|
||
|
420 (and all the folks that have been involved in this "discussion" on AI)
|
||
|
421
|
||
|
422 Its really an amazing thing to me that through the course of almost
|
||
|
423 random comments over the last five
|
||
|
424 days we have covered very closely
|
||
|
425 the following quote from E. Rich's book on AI and I quote;
|
||
|
426
|
||
|
427 "Before embarking on a study of specific A.I. problems and solution
|
||
|
428 techniques, it is important at least
|
||
|
429 to discuss, if not answer, the following four questions:
|
||
|
430
|
||
|
431 1. What are our underlying assumptions
|
||
|
432 about intelligence?
|
||
|
433 2. What kinds of techniques will be useful for solving A.I. problems?
|
||
|
434 3. At what level of detail are we trying to model human intelligence?
|
||
|
435 4. How will we know when we have succeeded in building an intelligence?
|
||
|
436 program? "
|
||
|
437
|
||
|
438 I suggest that all the discussions that have occured so far fit into
|
||
|
439 one of the above catagories ....
|
||
|
440
|
||
|
441 So its time to get on with some REAL
|
||
|
442 discussion ... please!
|
||
|
443
|
||
|
444 Paul
|
||
|
445 --------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
446
|
||
|
447 aAARON - FINE., WHAT IS THE PROBLEM WE ARE TRYING TO USE
|
||
|
448 A.I. TO SOLVE?/
|
||
|
449 -----------------------LEONARD---------
|
||
|
450 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
||
|
451 OK PAUL. NOW, DO YOU HAVE ANY SUGGESTIONS? NOTHING SEEMS TO HAVE
|
||
|
452 BEEN ACCOMPLISHED WITH THIS ONE!!!
|
||
|
453 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
||
|
454 ----------------------------------------To '+++++':
|
||
|
455 Well I don't necessarily think that nothing was accomplished
|
||
|
456 , there was a lot of good information
|
||
|
457 passed back and forth, and lot of
|
||
|
458 areas were covered, I just think that
|
||
|
459 its time to move on.
|
||
|
460 Anyway ... I think that a good place
|
||
|
461 to continue this is an agreement that
|
||
|
462 a basic function any "system" especially an AI "system" is to solve
|
||
|
463 problems ... what say a discussion on
|
||
|
464 how to build a system to solve problems?
|
||
|
465 As a start I state that on a basic level this includes:
|
||
|
466 1. A precise definition of a problem
|
||
|
467 2. An analysis of the problem.
|
||
|
468 3. Choosing the best techniques to solve the problem, and apply them.
|
||
|
469
|
||
|
470 Paul
|
||
|
471 ----------------------------------------------
|
||
|
472
|
||
|
473
|
||
|
474 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
||
|
475 Oh keeper of the Inn,
|
||
|
476 After my brief visit and fortnight departure, I
|
||
|
477 return to see a group of people circled, taking most of the floor, and
|
||
|
478 talking inbetween their long pulls of ale. A few have broken off, and you
|
||
|
479 are pacing, looking very worried, near some weak support beams.
|
||
|
480 The Inn is in a normal state at last.
|
||
|
481 I will stop by the main group just long enough to say a new greeting
|
||
|
482 I learned in a far off land: Hi!
|
||
|
483
|
||
|
484 One thing we all must remember about an artificially intelligent
|
||
|
485 macxine is that it may not help in many of the projects we propose to it.
|
||
|
486 The chances of us making a machine that can become more intelligent than
|
||
|
487 us is very small, and it would take a very long time for enough
|
||
|
488 AI machines designing their supirior counterparts before our level will
|
||
|
489 be surpassed. So they will not be able to provide us with any knowledge
|
||
|
490 wouldn't have already considered.
|
||
|
491 Another thing to ponder is that if we take the individual actions of
|
||
|
492 ourselves separately, a computer can perform any function we can with the
|
||
|
493 CURRENT state of technology (icluding original art). The only thing that
|
||
|
494 computer CAN'T do that we can is to do them all simultaniously.
|
||
|
495 Keeper, I enjoyed my brief stay. I give thanks for your hospitality.
|
||
|
496 Akonis
|
||
|
497 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
|
||
|
498 ----------------------------------------Akonis:
|
||
|
499 Even though I may not speak at times in the same terms that you do
|
||
|
500 I still need your poetry ... stay.
|
||
|
501 Paul
|
||
|
502 ------------------------------------------------
|
||
|
503
|
||
|
504 SO THIS IS THE FAMOUS BACKWATER MESSAGE SYSTEM MY MY!!
|
||
|
505 SOME HOW IT'S KIND OF WHAT I EXPECTED
|
||
|
506 DOES ANY ONE TALK ABOUT ANYTHING ELSE BUT AI AI AI AI AI
|
||
|
507
|
||
|
508 ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
|
||
|
509 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
|
||
|
510 person who addresed me above:
|
||
|
511 note that i have not left ANYTHING on the system since ln 167,
|
||
|
512 if somebody does this:
|
||
|
513 ------------------------------------------Aaron:
|
||
|
514 they are ADDRESSING me,this is not FROM me.............
|
||
|
515
|
||
|
516 to those who I have had private (?) consul with.......
|
||
|
517 you can find me at the oasis of rationality spoke of......
|
||
|
518
|
||
|
519 elsewise......it has been enjoyable..........
|
||
|
520 ......I will try to visit the inn,yet my encounters may be
|
||
|
521 spaced a little farther apart than some of you (esp. those
|
||
|
522 to whom i responded instantaniously to...whew
|
||
|
523 talk about fast dialing!) are used to......
|
||
|
524 Aaron
|
||
|
525 <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
|
||
|
526 ----------------------------------------Aaron:
|
||
|
527 If it was not you that entered the
|
||
|
528 precedeing message please under stand that this is not directed at you; if it is
|
||
|
529 you than I am very confused ...
|
||
|
530
|
||
|
531 I do understand those that would take
|
||
|
532 advantage of this system
|
||
|
533 There is a lure in being able to present a negative idea and use
|
||
|
534 another's name for ego advantage ....
|
||
|
535 BUT I still think that it is a
|
||
|
536 SICK proposition in any case ...
|
||
|
537 I am appalled that anyone would take
|
||
|
538 advantage of this situation.
|
||
|
539
|
||
|
540 ------------
|
||
|
541 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|
||
|
542 On the other hand, it is very easy to use anothers name on any
|
||
|
543 of the other systems too. Though PMS does have passwording
|
||
|
544 which helps for those who want the most in protection, Others
|
||
|
545 do not. You can call CBBS with any name you choose! It is only the
|
||
|
546 completely freeform structure of BWMS that allows a change of
|
||
|
547 heart in mid stream that is the cause for this concept of stealth
|
||
|
548 and treachery. It is far more difficult to recall a system (particularly
|
||
|
549 with the high activity on then of late) then to simply change your
|
||
|
550 identity in the middle of useing it (real or fake). Indeed, even I
|
||
|
551 do not know what identity I will use when I make an appearence here
|
||
|
552 until after reading it has given cause for that identity to take form.
|
||
|
553 %%%%%%%%% The In-Sane Scientist %%%%% Aug 6, 1983 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|
||
|
554 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-
|
||
|
555 Leonard,
|
||
|
556 NO the TRS-80 (or Z-80 for that matter) doesn't do multiple
|
||
|
557 processing. There is only 1 interrupt on the Model I computer
|
||
|
558 and that's for the 40-times-a-second for clock and I/O cleanup.
|
||
|
559 If you Take a look at the stack before the interrupt, and after
|
||
|
560 the interupt, you'd find that the registers weren't PUSHed into
|
||
|
561 stack, but were identical to what they were when you started
|
||
|
562 out. So, you must PUSH and POP your registers or your system
|
||
|
563 could go wacko and lock itself into a state of cellular
|
||
|
564 suspension.
|
||
|
565 I just got a TANDON 40 track Double-Density disk drive. I
|
||
|
566 need a DOS. Could you give me a copy of TRSDOS 2.3 for a smal
|
||
|
567 fee or for a few programs?
|
||
|
568
|
||
|
569 ______
|
||
|
570 == TRON ==
|
||
|
571 ------
|
||
|
572 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-
|
||
|
573 HAVE WE FINALLY AGREE TO SEND ALL AI TO THE STARS, AND CONTINUE HERE
|
||
|
574 WITH SOMETHING ELSE?
|
||
|
575 IF NOT, ONE SMALL COMMENT: COMPUTERS, EVEN AI ONES LACK ONE SMALL DETAIL:
|
||
|
576 UNIVERSAL MANUPULATORS.
|
||
|
577 FOR A STARTER ON SOMETHING ELSE, AN ARTICLE ON FARTHER OUT INTELL. LEADS
|
||
|
578 TO THE QUESTION OF HOW WE COULD IDENTIFY ONE, OR IDENTIFY OURSELVES. THE
|
||
|
579 PROPOSAL WAS TO SEND MESSAGES CONTAINING SEUQENCES THAT WERE UNLIKELY TO
|
||
|
580 BE NATURAL, BUT COULD BE IDENTIFABLE. (THIS MEANS TO SOMETHING ON SOME
|
||
|
581 OTHER PLANET, PERHAPS WITH A TOTALLY DIFERENT BIOLOGY, ETC.) I HAVE A
|
||
|
582 COUPLE OF THESE SEQUENCES, AND IF THERE IS INTEREST EXPRESSED WILL PUT
|
||
|
583 THEM HERE. PERSONALLY, I FIND THEM CLOSER TO RANDOM, BUT SOME MIGHT BE
|
||
|
584 ABLE TO DECIPHER.
|
||
|
585 ///////////////////////////////////BAD\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\
|
||
|
586 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_
|
||
|
587 - Is it my imagination or has the system slowed down? Mikey, what's happen -
|
||
|
588 - ing? ............................................................Pioneer -
|
||
|
589 -_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_
|
||
|
590 HI
|
||
|
591 PR 10
|
||
|
592
|
||
|
593
|
||
|
594 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
595 I sit by the fire, yet I find that I am still deeply chilled. The events that have recently transpired frame my thoughts,
|
||
|
596 filling my soul with a lasting disquiet, and stilling my otherwise jubilant spirits. Mayhap it is only a fervent imagination
|
||
|
597 that causes my distress, but I think not.
|
||
|
598 When I most recently entered the Inn, I discovered what I thought to be an open discussion, and gladly joined in, hoping to
|
||
|
599 add to it, giving others pause to think, and perchance learning of new and exciting ideas from them. It eventually came to my
|
||
|
600 attention that this loud, boisterous exchange was meant only for priviledged ears, and my presence was resented by one in
|
||
|
601 particular, who soon departed for other climes.
|
||
|
602 To you, oh errant of the East lands, I extend this fervent apologia. I didn't intend an intrusion, nor did I wish to see your
|
||
|
603 departure. It is my understanding that you are troubled by miscreants who attempt to do evil in your name, and sully your
|
||
|
604 reputation. I fear that this is most bothersome, and while I have little to offer as solution, I can hope to offer solice.
|
||
|
605 But please, oh errant, do not depart this pleasant place in anger or resentment.
|
||
|
606 Though I will continue to frequent this marvelous establishment, and sample its varied wares, I now realize that there
|
||
|
607 are those who prefer my silence. Perhaps they are correct. It is a subject to which I must give much thought.
|
||
|
608 /Elberich\
|
||
|
609 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
|
||
|
610 WE WANT A NEW DISK WE WANT A NEW DISK WE WANT A NEW DISK WE WANT A NEW DISK WE WANT A NEW DISK WE WANT A NEW DISK.....
|
||
|
611 #####################################################3
|
||
|
612 on AI. Has anyone of you ever heard of the "Turing" test for
|
||
|
613 determining if a machine could be said to be artifically intelligent.
|
||
|
614 It goes like this:
|
||
|
615 The tester sits in one room, and can communicate with another room
|
||
|
616 using a teletype or console. In the other room, an experimenter either hooks the
|
||
|
617 artificially intelligent machine to the console or mans it himself.
|
||
|
618 The test is whether the tester can correctly identify wheterh
|
||
|
619 the pir is a person or machine on the other end. This is considered
|
||
|
620 the classical definition of machine intelligence.
|
||
|
621 ###################################################
|
||
|
622 Again, it has been discussed here, and at length: the Turing test is OBSOLETE.
|
||
|
623 As is all discussion here of definitions of AI. (Tho they may have spooled off>)
|
||
|
624 Altho, if you were smart, how would you identify yourself as smart?
|
||
|
625 Sorry, what is wrong with the simple Turing test? It is inadequate; there can
|
||
|
626 be intelligent (correct, original, smart, etc) "thought" that is NOT human;
|
||
|
627 for example too fast or using an linear algorithm too elaborate for humans.
|
||
|
628 ................................................................
|
||
|
629 Mikey, 2 disks in 5 days!?!?!?
|
||
|
|